Rushdie Case Brings International Spotlight | News, Sports, Jobs – Jamestown Post Journal

Aug 23, 2022 by The Beat Maker - 0 Comments

Aug 20, 2022
Public Defender Ned Barone talks to the media following Hadi Matar’s court appearance.
After Chautauqua County District Attorney Jason Schmidt stepped out of court Thursday following charges placed against Hadi Matar for the alleged stabbing of noted author Salman Rushdie, he walked up to probably more than 25 TV cameras and reporters.
While prosecuting a stabbing is nothing new, having a prominent citizen assaulted is a different experience. “We’re a relatively small prosecutorial office here in Chautauqua County. We’re very familiar with these types of cases. We’re used to prosecuting them, but we’re small. We don’t have a public information officer. We not equipped for this kind of media coverage,” he said.
Schmidt is in his first term as county DA. He had worked for several years both as an assistant district attorney and in the private sector. Even though the attention of this case is unique, he told members of the media he would answer what he could. “I want you to know we’re going to try our best to be as transparent as possible throughout the process. We’re working closely with New York State Police. They are professionals with this. This is an ongoing matter and we’re going to follow every opportunity that’s available,” he said.
Indeed, it’s been a while since a case of this magnitude has hit Chautauqua County.
A decade ago, Anthony “Rob” Taglianetti II shot and killed Clymer School Superintendent Keith Reed Jr. That 2012 murder made national headlines, likely because Taglianetti went after the school chief after discovering an online affair between his wife, Mary, and Reed. The case went to trial and Taglianetti was found guilty.
District Attorney Jason Schmidt talks to the media following Hadi Matar’s court appearance.
In 2006, Ralph “Bucky” Phillips was captured following a massive manhunt. Phillips had escaped the Erie County Correctional Facility on April 2 of that year. On June 10, he shot and injured a state trooper near Elmira. On Aug. 31, he shot two troopers in Pomfret. Following that second shooting, Phillips landed on the FBI’s Top 10 Most Wanted Fugitives and was captured Sept. 8 in Warren County.
Another high profile case that made national headlines was in 1997 when it was learned that Nushawn Williams had unprotected sex with more than 40 females in Chautauqua County after being told he was HIV positive.
Foley served as district attorney for both the Taglianetti and Phillips cases. Taglianetti went to trial, while Phillips took a quick plea deal and there was little activity locally after he was captured. Foley may have been involved with the Williams trial too, since he had hired in 1995 as an assistant district attorney, working with former DA James Subjack.
Foley became the county court judge in 2016. On Thursday, he spoke to the reporters about 30 minutes before the trial. He said he was permitting cell phones and cameras in the court, but insisted they not be a distraction. He also said while images were permitted, there was to be no audio recording. Any violation of that would not be tolerated.
Along with Schmidt and Foley, Public Defender Nathaniel Barone also spoke to the media Thursday.
Barone has served as the county public defender since 2012. Among the cases he’s work on was the Taglianetti trial, where he lost to Foley.
While speaking to the media Thursday, Barone noted the court has issued a temporary gag order, preventing him and Schmidt from speaking to the media. Neither his nor Schmidt’s words were likely a violation, since they mainly repeated facts stated during the trial.
Barone actually requested the gag order during the court appearance. He said that has a lot to do with protecting potential jurors. “We’ve got a ton of pretrial publicity. We don’t want to taint any prospective juror, more than what’s already been done in this county. The more things that are leaked or are spread out there is going to influence the jury in this county and the opinions that are formed,” he said.
Barone said he sees his role to ensure Matar’s constitutional rights are upheld and he is fairly represented in a court of law. “Everyone accused of a crime is entitled to certain presumptions — presumption of innocence, a fair trial, due process. You can’t get that if the case is being tried in the public,” he said.
Barone was asked if he will asked for a change of venue. While not directly answering the question, it did appear that was a possibility. “Those are strategic questions. You don’t know. I’ve got my own theories on that and in this particular case, I wish I could talk about that. I would love to talk about that but I can’t. But there’s a lot of strategic reasons why you do things or don’t do things,” he said.
Today’s breaking news and more in your inbox
ALBANY — What was once the site of the Arthur Kill Correctional Facility is now home to a film studio on 49 acres …
Two more schools are looking to bring back a school resource officer this fall. The Chautauqua County …
Some of my closest relationships are with appliances. I mingle more with mixers, dishwashers and dryers than I …
Today’s breaking news and more in your inbox

Copyright © Post Journal | https://www.post-journal.com | PO Box 3386, Jamestown, NY 14702 | 716-487-1111

source

Leave a Comment