The Indicator NPR hide caption
SYLVIE DOUGLIS, BYLINE: NPR.
(SOUNDBITE OF DROP ELECTRIC’S “WAKING UP TO THE FIRE”)
DARIAN WOODS, HOST:
When a company gets to a certain stage of life – when it’s grown to a certain size – it comes time to leave the warmth and safety of private investors to flee the coop and go public. That means raising money by listing its stock on the stock market – an initial public offering – an IPO. But here’s a secret – the initial public offering isn’t public at all.
DAKIN CAMPBELL: The investors are decided the night before the shares start trading, and technically that is the IPO.
WOODS: Dakin Campbell is the chief financial correspondent for Business Insider, and he’s the author of the new book “Going Public.” And Dakin explains that what happens is, the night before the shares go on the stock market, the investment banks in charge of the IPO will gather together big investors – so the people who run mutual funds or wealthy private investors. Those people are the ones who will buy all the new shares, often with the intention of selling them again the next morning to the public at large at an almost guaranteed profit.
This is THE INDICATOR FROM PLANET MONEY. I’m Darian Woods. Today on the show – the murky truth about how IPOs really work and how Spotify tried to change it.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
WOODS: Before Spotify upended the IPO process, Steve Jobs at Apple was pushing back, too. In late 1980, Steve Jobs was meeting with some big-shot investment bankers in San Francisco. He wanted to raise some money by taking Apple Computer public. And these finance types say to Steve, we think we could start selling Apple’s shares at $18 each. Steve thinks this is way too cheap. Dakin Campbell tells the story in his book, “Going Public.”
CAMPBELL: He said, now, I hear that I can – might be able to sell shares for 25, 26, 28.
WOODS: Steve Jobs doesn’t like the idea of underpricing the shares. And he says…
CAMPBELL: You know, won’t the investors who get the shares for $18 – won’t they be mighty happy that they got these for 18 and can immediately sell them for 26? And the investment bankers acknowledge that, yes, they will probably be very happy to get the shares so cheaply.
WOODS: And then Steve says, and won’t they give you a lot more brokerage business, and then you’re going to charge me an 8% fee to do it? And the bankers concede, OK, yeah, the starting price could be $22.
CAMPBELL: And I really like that anecdote just because it so clearly lays out the conflict that lays at the heart of the IPO process. Steve Jobs was just so incisive in that meeting.
WOODS: And on the first day of listing, Apple’s shares rise to $29. Apple missed out on $7 a share, which would have been even more if the bankers hadn’t listened to Steve. And over the next few decades, that’s just how IPOs were – investment companies selling cheap shares to preferred clients. Companies have been losing tens of millions of dollars when they’ve done their IPOs because investment banks would underprice them.
Now, a little bit of a pop – like, a slight rise in the share price on the day of the launch – is widely seen as a good thing. A modest share price bump keeps everybody’s spirits high. But the amount that share prices sometimes rise on the first day of an IPO goes way beyond that. Take LinkedIn. Its share price more than doubled on the first day – hundreds of millions of dollars the company missed out on. One person closely watching LinkedIn’s IPO was Barry McCarthy. He’s a gruff finance guy.
CAMPBELL: Barry, being sort of, you know, the no-nonsense financial markets expert, just saw that as so inefficient that it almost offended his sensibilities.
WOODS: Here Barry is in an interview with Goldman Sachs.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
BARRY MCCARTHY: I have watched the public market and thought that it was chronically broken, and I thought surely there must be a better way. So there…
WOODS: A few years later, Barry McCarthy gets his chance with Spotify. Barry joined Spotify as its chief financial officer. And at first, Barry went out and did what pretty much all non-public tech companies do. He went out and raised funds privately from venture capital firms and private investors.
CAMPBELL: And he had actually gone out to raise 500 million, and he raises a billion dollars.
WOODS: OK.
CAMPBELL: Yeah. Yeah.
WOODS: That’s not nothing. I mean, why even have the stock market if you can raise a billion dollars behind the scenes?
CAMPBELL: Yes, exactly.
WOODS: Still, Barry thought it was worthwhile to do an IPO. So like most private companies, lots of people – like early employers and private investors – have shares in Spotify, but these weren’t easily able to be traded. So being a public company would mean that people were able to buy and sell your shares every single day, and that meant that private shareholders would be able to cash out more easily. Plus, going public means that Spotify can more easily, in the future, raise money from the stock market.
CAMPBELL: So with that billion dollars in the bank, Spotify can and does start thinking about, like, how it can do a potential IPO on its own terms.
WOODS: Now, Barry doing this IPO in a new way wasn’t purely motivated by altruistically wanting to reform the system.
CAMPBELL: None of them want Spotify to issue new shares if it doesn’t need to because that’s just going to dilute their stake in Spotify and make them less wealthy.
WOODS: So Barry tries to figure out a way to retain as much value as possible to Spotify.
CAMPBELL: He starts talking to his lawyers and starts sounding people out about whether he could list Spotify right on the exchange without having to issue new shares. And, you know, his explorations of that discover that, actually, that’s been done before, but in sort of somewhat less savory conditions – you know, companies that go into bankruptcy and delist from the exchange. When they come out of bankruptcy, they directly list.
WOODS: Direct listing – that means just allowing your existing private shares to be traded on the stock market, but you skip over that step of issuing all those new shares to insiders the night before. This doesn’t raise new money, but it does get you that SPOT ticker on the New York Stock Exchange. But people in the finance industry are really skeptical of Barry’s proposal. Like, this is not how it’s done.
CAMPBELL: He is the kind of person who hears that and thinks to himself – sort of like, oh, yeah – like, might take it as a challenge.
WOODS: Barry plows ahead, and he gets a direct listing ready. He works with companies like Morgan Stanley and Citadel. Spotify, of course, has a slick video ready for investors.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: …Float, no IPO allocations and no preferential treatment for any investor. Unlike the traditional IPO, it’s…
WOODS: Then it’s the morning of the IPO, April 2018. Spotify has guesstimated what it’s called a reference price – something to let investors and shareholders know what Spotify might be worth. In this case, it’s based on what private investors have been roughly selling shares at – at $132. Now, this is a huge day for companies. The tradition is for executives to ring the New York Stock Exchange opening or closing bell. Maybe they’ll even hire a choir. But Spotify’s CEO Daniel Ek did things differently. Here he is on CBS.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
DANIEL EK: While this is obviously a big day and I’m very proud of my employees, I really just feel like we’re in the early days – not celebrating the end days.
WOODS: The scene is actually really low-key – but not without stakes.
CAMPBELL: Barry and his lieutenant – they were both nervous. They chose to spend the morning on the trading floor at Morgan Stanley and above Times Square.
WOODS: The first share is traded for $165.90. This is way above expectations. People on the trading floor applaud. They shake hands. And by the end of the day, 30 million shares are exchanged, and it closes at $149 – pretty good.
CAMPBELL: And so Barry and his lieutenant take the subway back to Spotify’s headquarters. And, you know, they’re sitting around. And sometime around, like, 2:30 in a somewhat empty office with no party going on and no pomp and circumstance or balloons or anything, you know, they sort of look at each other and they’re like, OK, well, what do we do now? And one of them says, like, I have no idea. And they just laugh.
WOODS: I mean, you could have a couple of drinks. I don’t know. In any case, the direct listing was a success. Several other companies have followed Spotify’s model – companies like Slack and Palantir. But as for that pop – those huge gains on the first day of trading from share prices that are sold too low – well, that remains the case for a lot of companies. But at least companies going public now have a choice.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
WOODS: By the way, Apple and Spotify both advertise on NPR’s website and distribute some NPR content.
This episode was produced by Jamila Huxtable, with engineering from Josh Newell. Kathryn Yang checked the facts. Viet Le is our senior producer, and Kate Concannon edits the show. THE INDICATOR is a production of NPR.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.
Sponsor Message
Become an NPR sponsor
Aug 24, 2022 by The Beat Maker - 0 Comments