Meta was this intern's 'dream.' Until the recruiter rescinded his job offer. – Protocol

Oct 14, 2022 by The Beat Maker - 0 Comments

Hopeful Meta interns are some of the casualties of the company’s cutbacks.
Coinbase, Twitter, Redfin, and other companies have all rescinded employment offers this year.
Growing up in a small town in Bahia, Brazil, Yure Pablo “never imagined” working abroad for a big tech company. That changed after winning a local hackathon at Facebook (before it was renamed Meta) as a first-year University of Sao Paulo student in 2019.
“Meta was actually a dream because of this kind of relationship that we created since this first year, in Sao Paulo,” Pablo told me.
Six months ago, Pablo was “very, very excited” to receive a 2023 internship offer at Meta’s London offices. But last week, Meta rescinded his offer, along with offers extended to other 2023 London interns, as the company scales back on hiring in response to the economic downturn.
“The recruiter called me. She was, I think, really frustrated as well,” Pablo said. “I think it was unexpected for everyone.”
The decision to rescind London interns’ offers was “not made lightly,” Meta spokesperson Andrea Beasley said in a statement emailed to Protocol. “This company-wide hiring shift is to ensure that our hiring targets are aligned with our highest-priority efforts and business needs.”

The company said it would strongly consider those whose offers had been rescinded for future internships.
For Pablo, whose current internship at Amazon’s London offices has now been extended by a couple of months, a direct offer from Meta may be the only way he would pursue a future internship, even though he’s “still aligned with the culture,” he said.
“If I would need to do the whole process again, I don’t think I would do all of it,” Pablo said. “You don’t trust anymore. You receive the offer and I think you wouldn’t [have] the whole excitement that I had before.” (Pablo has also gotten some offers as a result of posting about the Meta ordeal on LinkedIn, he said.)
The move followed Meta’s postponement in making job offers to this year’s summer interns. In early July, the company told interns in an email that it would push back offers as leaders evaluated hiring plans, which have since all but halted company-wide for the rest of the year.
Meta has been recruiting junior employees faster than senior ones, the company said. Whenever hiring ramps up again, Meta previously said that leadership and senior hires would take priority, especially in machine learning, AI, graphics, gameplay, audio, and embedded software.
Coinbase, Twitter, Redfin, and other companies have all rescinded employment offers this year.
The trend is a painful reminder of other economic shocks in 2020, 2008, and 2009, according to David Hanrahan, a startup adviser who stepped down as Eventbrite’s CHRO earlier this year.
As the economic downturn continues, many companies have tough choices to make as they head into Q4 and plan for the upcoming year.
That said, rescinding an internship offer six months after making it is “kind of abnormal, to have that big of a delay,” Hanrahan said. “It would be pretty jarring.”
Rescinding job offers rather than laying off existing employees is “probably a worthwhile tradeoff,” according to Sandra Sucher, a professor of management practice at Harvard Business School and the co-author of “The Power of Trust: How Companies Build It, Lose It, Regain It.”

In these economic conditions, companies are deciding how much pain to endure up front, Sucher told me. “Usually, that kind of forethought is good when you’re looking at a downturn, because you should start thinking about the things that you can control now.”
Executive teams should go through all other operating expenses that they can cut — marketing, servers, facilities, travel — before rescinding offers, Hanrahan said. Rescinding offers can do significant damage to an employer’s brand, particularly when they’re large or noteworthy enough to make the headlines.
“What has to happen is a really careful analysis of all the financials and all the different considerations that we could pull on spend that would have less of an impact on our employment brand,” Hanrahan said. “Cutting jobs and livelihood has got to be one of the very last things that you do.”
Companies considering making these types of cuts should be able to justify them — because they’ll need to, internally and externally.
The company needs a “good story analysis as to why it is that it’s doing what it’s doing,” Sucher said. Some companies have done this well, while others’ plans have come across less persuasively as “I’m feeling nervous, and so I’m going to pull back,” she said.
Rescinding offers has a “psychological effect that’s probably on par with losing a job” and can mar a company’s employment brand, especially if done in a “robotic and inhuman” way, Hanrahan said.
Rescinding an offer is a “trust betrayal,” Sucher said, and calls for the company to acknowledge the harm it’s created, explain why it did it, and make an “offer of repair.”
Apologies should acknowledge the rigor of the interview process — did the candidate have to go through 20 interviews to get the job? — as well as the fact that the candidate may have already given notice at their current job, leaving them in a potentially precarious employment situation. Taking these personal factors into account when apologizing “at least will give the person the sense that they’re being treated like an actual human being, and not just like a number,” Sucher said.

Secondly, an explanation for why the company rescinded the offer should be “pretty persuasive” and may address what outcomes the decision makers are trying to avoid by rescinding, Sucher said.
“I think we need to imagine a world where job offers don’t mean anything,’ Sucher said. “There’s no universe that most people would want to live in where a commitment to have a job can be so easily walked away from on the part of the company that made the offer.”
Finally, an offer of repair should be an attempt to make the candidate whole, by offering a severance package, a spot on a “callback list” for future opportunities, a formal acknowledgement of the candidate’s job offer for any future engagement with the company, or referrals to other companies that are still hiring.
“It might build some kind of an on-ramp for a would-be employee to say, ‘These are okay people. They understood that they did this to me,’” Sucher said. “‘Here’s how they’re trying to help me — at least with respect to them — know what my next step is.’”
The Small Business Administration will consider lifting a decades-old moratorium on who can lend its government-backed loans.
The change could open the door for fintechs to write loans backed by the SBA 7(a) program.
The Biden administration’s efforts to help small-business owners get better access to capital could open up a big opportunity for fintech lenders.
The Small Business Administration will soon propose a rule change that could lift a 40-year moratorium on new licenses for nonbanks — including fintechs — to lend through its largest loan program. The plan was revealed last week in a list of policy initiatives from Vice President Kamala Harris aimed at advancing racial equity in small-business ownership.
The change could open the door for fintechs to write loans backed by the SBA 7(a) program, a roughly $35 billion annual program that offers loans up to $5 million to small businesses, backed up to 85% by the federal government.
The program is mostly limited to depository institutions or banks. Some non-depository lenders can write the loans through a special license overseen by the SBA. But the number of “small business lending company” licenses has been capped at 14 since 1982, meaning lenders that wish to participate must either bid for one of those licenses or partner with a bank on the loans.

The 7(a) loans are designed to serve business owners that struggle to get other types of financing, but data shows long-standing disparities in the loans based on race and income. Harris’ announcement on Oct. 4 said the administration hopes that having more lenders will make the loans more accessible, “particularly in smaller-dollar and underserved markets, where borrowers are most acutely shut out of” lending.
“For too long, the small business ecosystem in underserved communities has struggled to keep up with better funded businesses and entrepreneurs in more prosperous communities,” Harris said.
Fintechs believe they can help. A study of lending data from Funding Circle and LendingClub published last month by the Bank for International Settlements found fintech lenders had the potential to allow “small businesses that were less likely to receive credit through traditional lenders to access credit and to do so at lower cost.”
“The fintech industry is often serving minority-owned, low- to moderate-income, and the smallest of small businesses,” said Ryan Metcalf, head of public policy and social impact at Funding Circle. “That’s the population the SBA is struggling to reach through banks.”
When the Paycheck Protection Program was created in response to the economic hardship brought on by the pandemic, the SBA cleared fintech lenders to originate loans for the program. An analysis by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York found that fintech lenders “likely served borrowers who would not have received loans otherwise,” often because they lacked existing banking relationships. About 1 in 4 Black-owned firms applied to fintech lenders, more than twice the rate of white-, Asian-, and Hispanic-owned firms, according to the New York Fed.
“If we’re serious about expanding access to capital for those business owners and entrepreneurs who have historically lacked such access — and that is part of the original purpose for SBA funding support programs — then we should widen the scope of who’s able to participate,” said Dane Stangler, director of strategic initiatives at the think tank Bipartisan Policy Center.

The Bipartisan Policy Center has convened a panel of bankers, fintech leaders, and small-business owners to study how the SBA can best serve small-business owners. While that panel has not yet put out any formal recommendations, the BPC supported a bill last year from Sens. Tim Scott and John Hickenlooper to lift the moratorium on new SBA lending licenses.
But while fintech companies were credited with helping more businesses access PPP loans, researchers found that some of those fintechs were responsible for a significant share of fraudulent loans — which could weigh on the decision to allow further expansion of SBA-backed loans to nonbank lenders.
“There are good actors and bad actors in the fintech ecosystem,” Stangler said. “But we definitely think that this particular step is something that should be considered. Very carefully crafted, because it has some significant regulatory implications, but genuinely considered if our goal is to expand access to capital.”
One major question will be how the SBA structures the change. No rule has been proposed yet and an SBA spokesperson declined further comment on when to expect one. Bill Briggs, a former SBA official, told Inc. that the process could take up to a year from when the rule is first proposed.
If the rule change is approved, fintech companies will still need to weigh the compliance costs and resources needed to pursue a lending license. Metcalf said there is strong demand both from small businesses and investors to fund the loans, particularly for fintechs that can help reach more business owners and offer easier ways to run through the application process.
“There are additional levers to be pulled to reach more populations,” Metcalf said. “Increasing the distribution channels is a step in that direction.”
Experts say robust intellectual property protection is essential to ensure the long-term R&D required to innovate and maintain America’s technology leadership.
Every great tech product that you rely on each day, from the smartphone in your pocket to your music streaming service and navigational system in the car, shares one important thing: part of its innovative design is protected by intellectual property (IP) laws.
From 5G to artificial intelligence, IP protection offers a powerful incentive for researchers to create ground-breaking products, and governmental leaders say its protection is an essential part of maintaining US technology leadership. To quote Secretary of Commerce Gina Raimondo: “intellectual property protection is vital for American innovation and entrepreneurship.”
Patents are the primary means of protecting IP — trademarks, copyrights, and trade secrets offer additional IP protection — and represent a rule-of-law guarantee akin to a deed’s role in protecting land ownership. The founders of the United States wrote patent protection into the Constitution to “promote the progress of science and the useful arts.” Abraham Lincoln revered patents for adding “the fuel of interest to the fire of genius.”

A fireside chat with Qualcomm youtu.be
In today’s knowledge-based economy, IP rights play a foundational role. “Core R&D is the first step in getting good products into people’s hands,” said John Smee, senior VP of engineering and global head of wireless research at Qualcomm. “Everything from smartphones to the Internet of Things, automotive and industrial innovation begins as a breakthrough within our research labs.” At Qualcomm, Smee said, strong IP laws help the company confidently conduct cutting-edge 5G and 6G wireless research that will make its way into products ranging from everyday consumer goods to the factory floor.
Semiconductor companies, in particular, are fiercely protective of their IP because it’s their primary competitive advantage. Chip companies go to extraordinary lengths to protect their IP by maintaining black boxes only accessible to one person per fab, choosing highly secure operating locations, and keeping R&D teams separate from fab operations teams.
On the legal side, America’s Semiconductor Chip Protection Act of 1984 bestows legal protection of chip topography and design layout IP while the EU’s Legal Protection of Topographies of Semiconductor Products of 1986 protects IC design. These regulations “have encouraged firms to continue to innovate,” according to the findings of Qualcomm’s and Accenture’s report, Harnessing the power of the semiconductor value chain.Having a high-quality patent portfolio also helps companies build out their ecosystem, should they choose to license, through advising, training, support for launches, assistance in expanding to new markets, and much more.
Licensing democratizes innovation and invention— it makes the cutting-edge IP developed by one firm accessible to a broad range of others. As such, it allows other companies to skip the R&D step and jump right into building on the innovator’s foundation. This lowers the barrier to entry for upstart companies while providing a steady return on investments for the companies who have the resources to dedicate to heavy R&D.

An outsize economic impact
IP protection also has an outsized impact on the US economy and helps create good higher-paying jobs. A report from The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) found that in 2019 industries that intensively use IP protection account for over 41% of U.S. gross domestic product (or about $7.8 trillion) and employ one-third of the total workforce — that’s 47.2 million jobs. In 2019, the average weekly earnings of $1,517 for workers across all IP-intensive industries was 60% higher than weekly earnings for workers in other industries.

Workers in IP-intensive industries were more likely to earn higher wages as well as participate in employer-sponsored health insurance and retirement plans, the USPTO report found.
But patent laws are often subject to much debate — one person’s idea of protection is another’s view of monopoly. That’s where organizations like LeadershIP come into play. The group brings together experts on IP and innovation to debate issues at the intersection of research, policy, and industry.
In addition, several efforts are underway to help inventors get their ideas into the marketplace. The Inventors Patent Academy (TIPA), for instance, is an online learning platform aimed at guiding inventors through the benefits of patenting and the process of obtaining a patent. TIPA has designed its program to make patenting more accessible and understandable for groups historically underrepresented in the patent-heavy science and engineering fields, including women, people of color, people who identify as LGBTQIA, lower-income communities, and people with disabilities.
Closing these gaps would promote U.S. job creation, entrepreneurial activity, economic growth, and global leadership in innovation. Estimates suggest that increasing participation by underrepresented groups in invention and patenting would quadruple the number of American inventors and increase the annual U.S. gross domestic product by nearly $1 trillion.
If we want our nation’s rich history of innovation to continue, experts say, we must create an IP protection ecosystem that helps ensure that tech innovation will thrive.
“With the protection of patents,” Smee said, “there is no limit to where our creativity can take us.”

MIT Energy Initiative’s Howard Herzog explains why the number is unrealistic.
Lowering the cost per ton for carbon dioxide removal is critical to ensuring the industry is economically viable.
Michelle Ma (@himichellema) is a reporter at Protocol covering climate. Previously, she was a news editor of live journalism and special coverage for The Wall Street Journal. Prior to that, she worked as a staff writer at Wirecutter. She can be reached at [email protected].
$100 per ton is the carbon dioxide removal industry’s standard-bearing metric. It’s the target identified by both Frontier’s well-respected advance purchase commitment and the Department of Energy’s Carbon Negative Shot for ensuring CDR is scalable.
Experts agree that we need to remove billions — possibly many billions — of tons of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere to have a decent shot at achieving net zero by midcentury. CDR at that scale would be enormously costly, so lowering the cost per ton is critical to ensuring the industry is economically viable.
The $100-per-ton target is what economists, policymakers, investors, and the industry itself generally agree makes CDR feasible at scale. According to a survey of CDR stakeholders from CarbonPlan, there isn’t consensus on what that number means. Some view it as a break-even point for sellers, and others refer to it as a post-incentive price for buyers. But for the industry at large, it’s an accepted — and achievable — target.

Most techniques that reliably pull carbon from thin air currently cost much more than that. “$100 per ton is an extremely ambitious 10-year target, likely probably more of a 15- to 20-year target,” Carbon180 senior visiting scholar Shuchi Talati told Protocol, adding that it’s “important to be ambitious” and “there’s a lot of momentum around CDR and getting these technologies to scale.”
Yet ambition and momentum may not be enough to reach that milestone, according to Howard Herzog, a senior research engineer with MIT’s Energy Initiative. He’s been studying carbon capture for over 30 years (even writing a book about it in 2018) and is more skeptical given the capital costs to build CDR plants and the enormous amount of energy they need to run. He sat down with Protocol to talk about why he thinks $100 per ton is “pure fantasy.”
This conversation has been edited for brevity and clarity.
Why do you think $100 per ton is an unrealistic target?
Carbon dioxide is so diluted in the air that in order to capture it, almost irrespective of what process you use, you’re going to have to push a lot of air through these machines, and that means a lot of capital costs and a lot of energy spent.
Estimates put the energy requirement at $1,200 a kilowatt-hour per ton of carbon dioxide. The cost of electricity here where I live in Massachusetts is 20 cents a kilowatt-hour. Europe is pushing up prices to 40 cents. And this energy has to be carbon-free. Very few places have carbon-free electricity, but let’s say you can do it for 10 cents a kilowatt-hour, which I think is really stretching it — that’s $120 per ton of carbon dioxide.
That’s before you even start including the capital cost, which is significant. You need larger machines to process all that air. You want to put the air through these machines at a certain rate. And because of that, it’s going to be a large capital cost. Just looking at that, $100 or even $200 per ton just doesn’t pass the smell test.

So what do you think is a more realistic minimum cost for carbon dioxide removal?
Basic physics and engineering say there are some minimum requirements, and when you look at the most optimistic situation, my estimate for where we might be at is $600 to $1,000 for 2030.
Isn’t it possible to get capital costs down with scale?
There’s some truth to that, but it’s one thing to get it down by 40% or even cut it in half, but getting it down by an order of magnitude is a whole other dimension.
If you have a technology that can give you unlimited carbon removal at $100 a ton, that’s nirvana. We’re done, we’ve solved that problem.
There are also capital costs that go up as they scale. There was trouble with the Climeworks installation in Iceland last winter because of the temperature. [Editor’s note: Herzog is referring to the company’s plant, which dealt with frozen machinery last winter. Climeworks head of climate policy Christoph Beuttler said it was a “very good example of how important it is to deploy now and to get the experience.”] We saw this in Texas when everything broke down in cold temperatures; they didn’t spend money to weatherize it, so that adds cost. You’re putting things out, you want them to run at least 20 years. To do that, you have to harden them to stand up to the elements. It’s one thing to make a small demonstration, but when these things mature, some things will raise costs, other things will lower costs.
On the energy front, isn’t it possible to get costs down with the expansion of renewables?
Even if it’s several cents per kilowatt-hour, [renewables are] still intermittent, and you need this to run 24/7, which has a whole bunch of other costs. Say I just buy a lot of batteries so I can have this running all the time: That’s going to cost more than the original wind farm in the first place. On the grid, there’s still the backup problem and the peak problems. When you start putting more and more renewables on the grid, these system costs become more important. So if renewables are only 5% of my energy, there’s not a lot of integration costs; they’ve been absorbed pretty well. When you start getting up to 30[%] to 50% renewables, these costs start becoming much more significant.

Why do these machines have to operate 24/7?
Running these machines costs a lot of money. If I’m running 24/7 and capturing 1,000 tons of carbon a year, OK. If I’m only running half the time, capturing 500 tons a year, the dollar per ton just doubled. The capital cost is still the same. That’s the problem with all of these capital-intensive processes: You need them to operate a significant amount of the time. Usually you shoot for 85[%] to 90% of the time.
$100 per ton is just a target to aspire to. What’s wrong with that?
I just like to deal with facts. I think it’s disingenuous. If you’re really interested in solving climate change, you’ve got to level with people.
Estimates from the U.N. and other sources say that if we want to get to where we need to be, we may need to remove 10 billion tons of carbon dioxide a year by midcentury. Do you agree with that?
It’s at minimum a few billion tons a year, because there are certain sectors that are really hard to decarbonize. A part of that depends on how expensive you think these different sectors are to do, and then how expensive you think the offsets are going to be.
It’s very frustrating. When people think things are too easy, they won’t address the hard decisions, even though those hard decisions may end up with a better solution.
Say I want to decarbonize airplane biofuels and that costs me $700 per ton. If I can capture carbon from the air for $500 per ton, why not just keep emitting the carbon dioxide out of the airplane and capture the air to offset it? And it’s cheaper by $200 per ton. So that’s the driving force. And so I would say that even direct air capture at $500 a ton will have a benefit. For offsets like DAC, they’re going to be more effective for anything that costs more than their price. And so you have to look at the whole system.

It gets more complicated, because there are quite a few negative emissions technologies. DAC isn’t the only one. And none of them are unlimited in their application. If you have a technology that can give you unlimited carbon removal at $100 a ton, that’s nirvana. We’re done, we’ve solved that problem.
If $600 to $1,000 per ton is the likely cost of CDR, what role do you think it will play to get to net zero?
The question is, will there be other, cheaper offsets than that? Every offset has problems. Offsets from bioenergy with carbon capture and storage are cheaper and much more doable. The big issue is the biomass feedstock: how much there is and what the cost will be. Another option, one that I really like, is called liming the ocean. But politically, it’s a nightmare. Think about throwing a chemical in the middle of the ocean. Just think of the protest. But even today, by putting carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, most of that ends up in the ocean.
It’s very frustrating. When people think things are too easy, they won’t address the hard decisions, even though those hard decisions may end up with a better solution. At this point, I don’t know if liming the ocean is a great idea or not, but it has a lot of potential, and we have to look at things like that if we want to get to net zero. And people say capturing carbon dioxide from the air for $100 per ton will get us to net zero. But if it’s a fantasy, it’s not going to get us there.
Michelle Ma (@himichellema) is a reporter at Protocol covering climate. Previously, she was a news editor of live journalism and special coverage for The Wall Street Journal. Prior to that, she worked as a staff writer at Wirecutter. She can be reached at [email protected].
Microsoft’s app store provides opportunities for thousands of independent software vendors, but it also solidifies the cloud giant’s prominence as more and more enterprise software is purchased through the cloud.
The tradeoffs that ISVs face when trying to tap into the vast customer bases of the industry’s biggest names are becoming trickier to navigate.
Aisha Counts (@aishacounts) is a reporter at Protocol covering enterprise software. Formerly, she was a management consultant for EY. She’s based in Los Angeles and can be reached at [email protected].
Joe Williams is a writer-at-large at Protocol. He previously covered enterprise software for Protocol, Bloomberg and Business Insider. Joe can be reached at [email protected]. To share information confidentially, he can also be contacted on a non-work device via Signal (+1-309-265-6120) or [email protected].
Click for more coverage
Over its 47-year history, Microsoft has long been known for employing subtle business practices to ice out competitors by preferencing its own products and services. The software giant is a master of bundling, using discounts on its vast array of products and services to keep consumers inside its ecosystem.
Over the years some of those practices have come under fire for being anticompetitive, and antitrust concerns have been a constant throughout its history. But an area that hasn’t received as much attention is Microsoft’s commercial marketplace strategy, exemplified by AppSource and Azure Marketplace, where third-party developers can build and sell applications across Dynamics 365, Microsoft 365, Power Platform, and Azure.
For Microsoft, the marketplace is a “necessary mechanism” to get the applications of independent software vendors in front of customers, said Anthony Joseph, vice president of Microsoft Cloud Marketplace & ISV Journey. Those applications are critical because they extend Microsoft’s capabilities where its current “products are insufficient to actually meet [the customer’s] business needs,” he added.

Partners also open the door to entirely new revenue streams as well. Microsoft’s enterprise software operation has historically focused on selling primarily to IT departments. But by building partnerships with independent software vendors, or ISVs, that sell primarily to security, supply chain, or sales departments, for example, Microsoft can expand its reach, said Casey McGee, Microsoft’s vice president of global ISV sales.
“What these ISVs get us is, frankly, much better depth by industry,” said McGee. “We will never rival the millions of man-years of work that has been done to build solutions by industry — we will never catch up to what these ISVs have built.”
To date, Microsoft’s commercial marketplaces have 15,000 sellers and 90,000 solution-partner sellers across 141 geographies. Last year, the cloud giant saw a massive 288% year-over-year increase in SaaS billed sales, according to the company.
But although Microsoft’s app store provides opportunities for thousands of ISVs, it also solidifies its market dominance. As more and more companies move their operations to infrastructure cloud services like Azure and SaaS products like Dynamics, Microsoft and other cloud platforms become the primary distribution channel for third-party companies that build products around those services.
In some instances Microsoft has used its marketplace to exert its power, by pushing ISVs to highlight Microsoft’s own software to receive better visibility among end-user customers, while making sure their apps don’t compete too directly with Microsoft’s own wares.
Microsoft continues to draw huge interest among app developers, in part because of the efforts it makes at growing its ecosystem and rewarding those who participate.
But in an era where upstart software vendors have a plethora of platforms to try to align with — as we noted in part one of the Inside the Enterprise App Store series — the tradeoffs that ISVs face when trying to tap into the vast customer bases of the industry’s biggest names are becoming trickier to navigate and raising questions about the real rewards for those efforts.
For ISVs that build add-ons to Microsoft’s products, the benefits of listing on Microsoft’s commercial marketplaces are complicated. While enterprise app stores enable third-party developers to monetize their products and reach new customers, rigorous listing requirements and mismatched incentives can make the experience tricky.

In order to list their application, ISVs need to pass a stringent set of security and compliance reviews. At first glance this makes sense, given that the third-party apps listed are often tightly integrated into the host company’s own suite of products. However, that data can also be used to weed out potentially competing tools, an example of how big vendors use their growing power to limit competition from smaller players.
“You have to ensure that your app is not in conflict with what Microsoft Teams does,” said Matthieu Giorgini, CEO of Waldo, a desk reservation app. “For example, if your app had a chat system within to talk with your support team, you have to remove this because it’s in conflict with the chat feature of Microsoft Teams.”
AvePoint, a Microsoft partner that builds data management apps for Microsoft Teams, confirmed this review process, but didn’t say whether the company asked it to remove features.
“Certainly when you submit something they review whether this feature already exists in Teams or in SharePoint or Word, then that’s part of the review process and consideration,” said Dux Raymond Sy, chief brand officer at AvePoint. But “it’s no different than any other marketplaces for other ecosystems,” he said.
You have to ensure that your app is not in conflict with what Microsoft Teams does.
When asked directly, a Microsoft spokesperson denied the company asks partners to remove competing features. “This is not accurate. Microsoft has several partner solutions that compete in some way with the company’s first-party solutions,” the spokesperson told Protocol in an email.
But Microsoft still acknowledges that competition between first- and third-party apps is a concern.
“That’s the balance that we strike on this all the time, right?” said Jake Swenson, Microsoft’s vice president and general manager of commercial marketplace. To Swenson, the best product should win, but that’s not necessarily a view shared broadly across the company.

“I guarantee you’d encounter plenty of people within Microsoft who might disagree with that, who might own the [profit and loss statement] for a certain one of our products that doesn’t like the competitive dynamic that’s there,” he said. “But the fact of the matter is, whether we facilitate it or not, competition is happening in the ecosystem. So we might as well be a part of making the experience better for customers and the economics better for partners to drive preference for our cloud.”
Although Microsoft may not explicitly force the hands of its partners to do its bidding, at times the company uses a variety of soft power methods to tip the scales in favor of its own products and services. For example, while Microsoft doesn’t require ISVs to pick a particular cloud, it provides discounts on products and services that could make it far easier to use Azure.
“We help them migrate from other clouds,” noted Microsoft’s Joseph, a benefit that could potentially make it cheaper for partners to use Microsoft Azure than competitors AWS or Google Cloud. Still, Microsoft claims to be playing nice. “If they’re considering a multicloud approach, again, in this context of openness, we’re excited by that and support them,” he said.
The statement is backed by some ISVs Protocol spoke with, several of whom have adopted a multicloud approach. “Whether we, in parallel with Azure, use some other clouds, we are not restricted in any way,” said Emil Sildos, chief revenue officer at FlashGrid, which facilitates the migration of Oracle databases to Azure.
Still, while apps listed in its marketplace could be developed on top of AWS or GCP, Microsoft wants partners to stay within the Microsoft ecosystem. “It could be AWS,” said AvePoint’s Raymond Sy. But “we’re a Microsoft partner, sitting in Google may not be as kosher.”
And Microsoft has other ways of pushing partners to use its cloud products.
Microsoft gives benefits to partners who help drive more usage of its products. For example, through its FastTrack program, the company provides customer referrals and leads to partners that help evangelize SharePoint, Teams, and Viva.

“FastTrack is more of an advisory services education program that’s out there … where we provide advisory services, consulting, and workshops around things like adoption of SharePoint and Teams and the Viva modules,” said Christian Buckley, AvePoint’s brand alliance director.
Waldo’s Giorgini also claimed that lead generation and customer referrals primarily go to partners that are only using Microsoft services top to bottom. A Microsoft spokesperson told Protocol in an email that wasn’t true, and that the company also provides marketing and sales engagement to applications platformed on competitive clouds.
What’s clear is that Microsoft does provide substantially more go-to-market support to those partners who align themselves closely with the SaaS giant, which is not unusual in enterprise software.
For some of those partners, like Canonical, Microsoft account executives operate almost as an extension of the go-to-market team, helping large accounts with ISVs that could service their needs. But the ability to co-sell alongside Microsoft is limited to prominent ISVs such as Canonical, whose Ubuntu software makes up about two-thirds of all Linux virtual machines on cloud, according to Canonical.
Although these types of incentives aren’t necessarily uncommon and aren’t illegal, they highlight the contrast between Microsoft’s external messaging of openness and free market competition — especially as it tries to catch up to AWS’ sweeping lead in cloud infrastructure services — and the levers the company is pulling to tip the scales in favor of itself and the apps that are loyal to it.
Most Microsoft partners ultimately see the marketplaces as both necessary and beneficial. Several ISVs Protocol spoke with could cite no major challenges with Microsoft’s commercial marketplaces, and the vast majority were pleased with the partnership overall.
The partner benefits touted by Microsoft are also notable, as many of the partners Protocol spoke with have received measurable sales leads, marketing support, and increased revenue, along with training from one of the largest enterprise software companies in the world.
For many ISVs, the ability to transact via the marketplace, with access to existing cloud budgets, standard contract terms, and billing infrastructure, is also a key benefit.

“We utilize the marketplace first because that’s actually easier,” said Alexander Gallagher, vice president of cloud for Canonical. “So think about it: If Azure is already set up as the chosen supplier, so you’re already buying stuff from Microsoft, isn’t it far easier just to add our software onto that bill, rather than to go off and set up separate contracting?”
That sentiment was echoed by several other ISVs, who also noted the convenience of having Microsoft handle billing and payments across different currencies and geographies. “We really prefer to do our transactions with the customers who use Azure Marketplace instead of establishing the direct billing relationship,” said FlashGrid’s Sildos.
But as more companies utilize cloud services, and more software spend gets consolidated through enterprise cloud app stores, the imbalance of power between the cloud giants and ISVs will grow. At any time Microsoft or others could shift the sands underneath partners: hiking up prices, removing their apps from the store, developing a competing product, or making it harder to receive benefits.
If Azure is already set up as the chosen supplier, so you’re already buying stuff from Microsoft, isn’t it far easier just to add our software onto that bill, rather than to go off and set up separate contracting?
For some ISVs, the potential of Microsoft developing competing products and services is a persistent threat. The fact that Microsoft could develop the very capabilities that Waldo offers is why Giorgini is happy flying under the radar.
“And now the idea is to grow fast so Microsoft doesn’t do the same as us,” he said. The nature of his company’s dependence on the cloud giant may be precarious, but “this is the game of any ISV anyway,” Giorgini added.
Microsoft leaders of course downplay this threat, acknowledging that while there are “scenarios where we do bump into one another,” giving customers more choices is better for everyone in the end, said Microsoft’s McGee.
But once again, the challenge is, at any time Microsoft can shift the playing field.

For example, the company is making a series of changes to its partner program that, while providing additional benefits, will simultaneously make it harder for smaller ISVs. These changes may not impact large established partners with existing customer relationships, such as AvePoint or Canonical, but the same can’t be said for newer app partners, said AvePoint’s Buckley.
“I’ve been doing [partnerships] for a number of years and each year the rules change or the way they compensate or recognize a deal changes,” said Canonical’s Gallagher. “We haven’t really experienced any friction or problem with that.”
But that ability to adapt isn’t as simple for ISVs with smaller footprints.
“Microsoft can sometimes be very picky with their requirements, and they keep changing every single year,” said Carina Faria, an employee at Connecting Software, which builds integration applications for Azure and AppSource. “Sometimes it’s for the better, but then it becomes harder on partners to act upon the changes and adapt to what they now consider to be the requirement.”
As Microsoft significantly raises the bar for hitting its different partner level designations, the company is also making it more difficult for ISVs to get access to the lead generation and marketing support that come along with those designations.
As marketplaces become more crowded, this could deal a critical blow for smaller ISVs.
“Discoverability is a key challenge,” said Jakob Nettelbladt, chief product officer at Mentimeter, which is listed on AppSource. App stores have “so many familiar and not-so-familiar tools, services, and brands to try out,” it’s easy to get lost in the noise, he said.
“I think if your strategy is to think about marketplace discovery, you’re on a losing streak,” Canonical’s Gallagher reiterated. “Marketplaces aren’t really there for discovery, although I can see how there could be a halo effect of being up top.”
Microsoft can sometimes be very picky with their requirements, and they keep changing every single year.
Since Microsoft controls its app stores, it can also exert control over which apps get more visibility. For several partners Protocol spoke with, the reason some apps get featured over others in Microsoft’s stores remains a mystery.
“I’ve asked that question many times and can never get an answer,” said Alon Ekelund, CEO at iGlobe, a CRM application listed on AppSource. Ekelund asked because he noticed that some apps with very low ratings or even no ratings were featured prominently on the home page.

Microsoft was unwilling to reveal much about its strategy when Protocol asked about app discovery. “I mean, the featured apps, it’s one of these things where we’re a little guarded as to what exactly goes kind of in that algorithm, as you might expect,” said Microsoft’s Swenson.
The secrecy makes it easy to imagine Microsoft shifting its algorithms to give preference to its own products and services over others. But Microsoft claims it’s not thinking about the power dynamics of its marketplace in that way.
“I am not interested in gaming or steering the growth of the ecosystem so much as I am reducing the friction to [business-to-business] commerce happening,” said Swenson.
Regardless of how Microsoft thinks about its marketplace, or how explicitly or not it tries to control it, the reach and scope of the cloud giant means every action the company takes will have an impact on the enterprise software industry. And as cloud spending increasingly consolidates through Microsoft’s marketplace, it could shift the power dynamics of the entire industry.
The process of creative destruction has propelled the tech industry forward for decades, as the old guard makes way for new companies and ideas that shake up the existing power dynamics. The enterprise software platforms that dominate today’s world are working very hard to make sure those new companies and ideas spring forward on their terms.

Thursday, Oct. 6
The enterprise app store wars are here. That’s bad timing for Salesforce.
Thursday, Oct. 13
How Microsoft uses its enterprise software app store to center its power

Aisha Counts (@aishacounts) is a reporter at Protocol covering enterprise software. Formerly, she was a management consultant for EY. She’s based in Los Angeles and can be reached at [email protected].
Hermine Wong, director of the Coinbase Institute, says she’s trying to create a source of rigorous research about cryptocurrencies.
“Our advocacy is almost a fundamentally different kind of engagement than we’ve seen historically.”
Benjamin Pimentel ( @benpimentel) covers crypto and fintech from San Francisco. He has reported on many of the biggest tech stories over the past 20 years for the San Francisco Chronicle, Dow Jones MarketWatch and Business Insider, from the dot-com crash, the rise of cloud computing, social networking and AI to the impact of the Great Recession and the COVID crisis on Silicon Valley and beyond. He can be reached at [email protected] or via Google Voice at (925) 307-9342.
It was a quirky dig at the SEC.
“I’ve decided not to set any curfew for my teenager. I’ll just ground her if she comes home later than I’d like. Regulation by enforcement,” Coinbase chief legal officer Paul Grewal wrote on LinkedIn last week, referencing what his company feels is the SEC’s heavy-handed approach to crypto.
Hermine Wong, director of the newly launched Coinbase Institute, acknowledged the off-the-wall post was “cheeky.” But she also said it was indicative of Coinbase’s growing annoyance with the regulator.
“You’re going to see frustration sometimes when there aren’t public and transparent and open engagements,” Wong told Protocol. “Everyone’s trying to be like, ‘Where can we have a really public transparent engagement on these issues?’ That’s not happening.”
That quest for stronger public engagement on crypto was largely why the company launched the Coinbase Institute in May. The idea actually came from Wong, who spent about a decade as a federal government lawyer, including six years at the SEC.

“In my old job as an administrative lawyer, if I think about all the work that we did — writing regulations, interacting with the public — we would frequently cite academic-style journals or create that academic research,” she said. “That was very much just missing here. It was filling a need that we needed to do in order to be more effective in our own advocacy.”
In an interview with Protocol, Wong, who joined Coinbase in February 2020, explained what the crypto company hopes to accomplish by launching its own think tank and how her many years as an SEC regulator shaped her view of crypto and technology.
This interview has been edited for clarity and brevity.
How did the idea of setting up an institute come up?
There was a real need in all our policy advocacy that we were doing to have research and evidence. The challenge again and again that we were hitting was that there isn’t a lot of research in this space because the space is moving so quickly itself. Research tends to take a long time.
The best research out there was responsive to some subset of questions that people would pay for, but not necessarily always the research that you need when you’re doing public policy advocacy.
How was it discussed with [Coinbase CEO] Brian Armstrong or chief legal officer Paul Grewal?
If I’m being perfectly honest, I articulated that we’ve got to stand up this function. I drafted up a proposal and it got sent up.
So it was your idea.
It was my idea. [Laughs.]
Were there any models that you used?
Microsoft has a research space. [JPMorgan Chase] has the Chase Institute. There’s the McKinsey Institute that is also out there.
Those companies set up think tanks many years after they were founded. We’re talking about a 10-year-old company in an industry that’s only about 13 years old.
Crypto is innovating faster than any of those other industries already. On top of that, there were laws on the books already for a lot of those industries. There aren’t any here.

So our advocacy is almost a fundamentally different kind of engagement than we’ve seen historically.
What we’re trying to do is not reinvent the wheel. Let’s take what are good lessons learned from other industries and find a way to apply it here. This is one of those instances where we’ve got this huge information deficit, a huge research deficit. What have other people done in the past? Yeah, it might have taken 40 years for them to figure it out. It doesn’t make it a bad idea if you do it, you know, earlier.
Crypto is often compared to the rise of the web during the dot-com era. There were similar concerns. Government stepped in, like when the Clinton administration put out an executive order essentially saying, “Let the internet evolve and just be mindful of potential pitfalls.” Given your decades of experience in government, are there any lessons from that period that are top of mind for you?
I tell this story all the time. I love the internet analogy for this. Right now, different surveys would have the crypto adoption rate at somewhere between 16% and 20% in the United States.
You may recall the famous interview that David Letterman had with Bill Gates in 1995. It’s a great interview. But the interesting thing is that at that same time in 1995, these Pew surveys that we rely on for crypto adoption surveys said that 14% of Americans had the internet at that time.
So the parallels between 1995 and now are very striking. Imagine how difficult it was for Bill Gates to explain to David Letterman and the general audience what the internet was and what it could do. He couldn’t quite do it right.
So it’s always top of mind for me that we are at that phase of trying to get people to understand not just what crypto is in terms of the plumbing, but we really want to try to get people to understand what the Web3 future is going to look like.

That is hard work to do. It takes time to do that. The Coinbase Institute’s mission is to accelerate getting that on paper, putting very thoughtful people, academics, and industry players together to try to give all of that a more concrete way of being talked about.
Given your government experience, what are you most concerned about? What are the things that you think Brian and other Coinbase execs probably don’t think about much, and you tell them, “We need to do it this way because this is the way government and the system work”?
If you’re a regulator, if you’re like a classic regulator, and you have your 9-to-5 regulatory job and you’re drafting rules, you think first, “I’m drafting my rule. What is my authority to draft this rule? What did Congress say that I can do in this space?”
Then I say, “Well, what’s the problem that I’m trying to solve?” Then I identify, who are the entities involved in this problem? And then I say, here are a few different ways I could solve this problem. Let me do a cost-benefit analysis. That’s how the regulator 9-to-5 guy or girl does this job.
Now the challenge is, the first step doesn’t really exist [in crypto]. You don’t have that congressional authority. That also means you don’t have the congressional appropriations for it. You don’t have the expertise of people. You don’t have the earmarked money to hire crypto experts to do this crypto work necessarily because the legislative authority doesn’t exist. You’re trying to figure out how to do it from your existing work.
That’s the problem that we have. They don’t have the time to organically develop this kind of research and expertise.
What we’re trying to do with the Coinbase Institute is let us try to help jump-start that for you because I know the kinds of questions they need to have answered. Those are not the same kinds of questions that institutional investors might have or that a reporter might have about crypto or the average person who’s trying to figure out what to do with Web3 might have about crypto. They have certain kinds of questions that they need to have answered at a macro scale. Let us try to unpack that for them without you having to do all that work yourself.

But the SEC, the CFPB, Gary Gensler, and Rohit Chopra would argue that there are laws, there are rules that are in place they are using to enforce certain actions, and there are laws that cover companies that deal with people’s money.
Black and white, that’s true. There are absolutely laws on the books that deal with how people look at money. What there isn’t yet, though, are laws on the books for crypto. How we know that this is challenging is to ask any member of Congress how you look at a particular cryptocurrency, which one of those is a security?
I don’t think that you’re gonna get a consistent response. People should know. Everyone should know. How much lawyers’ time do we spend on trying to figure this out and still get a legal opinion that has to be by necessity hedged because we don’t know? These are people in good faith trying to struggle with these questions.
So I agree that when it comes to classical money, yes. But crypto is not and Web3 won’t be money. So how should we be thinking about those use cases and how people will actually be interacting with it if their fundamental way of doing it will not be as, you know, some sort of hedge fund?
But crypto currently is about money. People see it as an investment although Web3 is promising other use cases.
I don’t want to disagree with you, Ben. But again, if we think back about that 1995 analogy, sure we could try to get everyone to understand TCP/IP protocols, but that’s actually not what’s going to get anyone to understand what is going to be the function of the internet and how people actually interact with it.
You will obviously play a key role in Coinbase’s efforts to explore policy issues. I assume you will also play a role in the company’s lobbying efforts.

Our goal is to arm our own lobbyists so that they can get this in front of the right members [of Congress] and in front of anyone. We’re producing this collateral for the good of the community. But our lobbyists I hope will also be using it to put it in front of people who are hungry for research.
What do you say to those who will be naturally skeptical about a Coinbase think tank, which they are likely to think was set up to defend Coinbase’s business and position in this market?
It’s certainly a consideration. This is why we chose the kinds of advisers that we chose. Our advisory board [includes] academics. We have a chief economist who also comes from academia. So the research that we’re putting out is research that they would put their name to. It may very well be research that is also helpful [to Coinbase] but it’s not that this is research that shouldn’t be out there and it is not peer-reviewed-caliber research. Otherwise, what’s the point, right? We didn’t have to go about getting an advisory board like that. I could have probably just hired a bunch of interns.
Let’s talk about a former academic who’s playing an important role in this debate, Gary Gensler. I listened to his 2018 lectures and he comes across as open to the technology, and even acknowledged that there are aspects of blockchain that could be beneficial to a financial system. But he’s viewed as someone who’s critical of the way the industry is evolving. What are your thoughts about the SEC chair?
The SEC chair is a political position at the end of the day. It is different from what I was doing at the SEC, what the 3,200 staff are doing at the SEC. How this chair is going to prioritize his time and his resources, what his ultimate goals are — I don’t know what those are. But you can say that Gensler has not been — his only job has not been the SEC chair. He’s also been at the CFTC. And who knows where he might want to go next.

So it’s the political aspect that’s a focus for you.
I think that he is, by definition, a political person. He’s a political appointee. He goes through Senate confirmation. So how he plays that is just going to be different. They put out speeches. Every time they put out a speech it’s very different from what a staffer would do. They have to say every time these reviews reflect my own views, not the views of the commission, because again, they are political.
How he might interact as a 2018 professor over at MIT trying to educate on the technology is going to be very different from the way he prioritizes what he says as SEC chair.
What were the things from your long experience in government that have been helpful because that was not the way the private sector, or tech, or the startup world operated?
I think it’s knowing actually how the sausage is made when it comes to rulemaking. What is it that the regulators are most concerned about when they are drafting a rule?
I say this because it always struck me as odd when I was in the regulator world how often people thought that regulators are targeting individual companies, that [a regulator] would even remember like, “Oh, that person was really ornery in a meeting with me. I’m going to now burn the entire industry” … there were those kinds of discussions where people thought that certain characters were larger than life and then they would just steamroll the industry through rulemaking because they didn’t like a person in a meeting or something.
That’s just not the way it is. This idea that people would have long-term memory at the staff level for these kinds of private interactions is not only untrue, they could not come up with the evidence to support any rulemaking if that’s how they did things. They would just get vacated on the spot. The biggest black mark on a regulator you could get is when your rulemaking gets overturned by a court.
You just don’t want that to happen. You’ll guard against it. That’s why you want deep cross-functional buy-in. You want to have a ton of research on your side. You want to present both sides of any issues.

Circling back to Gensler, do you have an understanding then that he’s not targeting Coinbase or specific actors, but he is trying to do a very complex job as you describe?
Again, I would say that as a staff versus a political appointee, you have different priorities. So I’m telling you how the staff does its job. Staff do not get the benefit of actually doing that kind of cherry-picking of issues, whereas the chair can or any commissioner could certainly do that. And any political appointee could do that.
Let’s go to the way Coinbase has handled many of these public disputes. There’s been a lot of criticism about how it’s playing out on Twitter and social media. Just this week, Paul Grewal wrote on LinkedIn, “I’ve decided not to set any curfew for my teenager. I’ll just ground her if she comes home later than I’d like. Regulation by enforcement.”
It’s cheeky.
Sometimes a lot of the attacks and exchanges have been personal and even mean-spirited.
I’ll say this: I think that the reason why it’s really important for us to all be able to have an open and transparent debate is that it’s not actually really happening right now.
I think that everyone’s trying to be like, “Where can we have a really public transparent engagement on these issues?” We sent over a rulemaking petition to try to get the SEC to do rulemaking, [to] open that up to a public forum. That’s not happening.
I don’t know why it’s not happening. I wish I knew why it wasn’t happening. But I think that over time, if people keep saying, “Please engage. Please engage,” you’re going to see frustration sometimes when there aren’t public and transparent and open engagements. There should be sunlight brought onto this area. Instead, we’re only getting little slivers through enforcement actions that come from time to time.
If we take Paul’s analogy a little further, his daughter could have said, “Dad, please just tell me what the curfew is. Please just tell me what it is. I will do whatever. If you say it’s 8:30, I will do it. If you say 7, I will do it. Just tell me.” That is like the petition for rulemaking.
Tell me about the very first time you heard about bitcoin.
Ah, it was when I was at the SEC.

What was your reaction? What were the conversations like?
There was a lot of confusion between bitcoin and blockchain at that time. There still is a little bit of confusion on that front and it was seen as a novelty. This was very much part of the ICO phase of things. The overriding narrative of anything bitcoin-related at that time — it had not become an asset class, what it is now. The use cases had not yet been developed to the way that they are now. We didn’t see adoption. It was very much still seen as a fringe thing among a fringe set of the population.
And we were still trying at the SEC to just modernize our disclosures so that they’re machine readable. Let’s not even talk about distributed ledger technology. We were just trying to get out of the fax phase and courier-in-triplicate to the regional office and to the main office and to the overseeing office. We were so backward at that time. Bitcoin seemed just totally fringe.
What were the early concerns that you eventually were able to overcome or go past in terms of your perceptions of bitcoin and crypto in general?
I came to Coinbase in 2020. By 2019 — probably late 2018 — I was already starting to become incredibly interested in crypto, generally. I read the [bitcoin] white paper and I started to understand a lot more about what the thesis was.
Without reading the white paper, all you’re hearing about in the SEC domain is the ICO problem. And that was very much a problem. We can all acknowledge that that was a serious problem.
But by reading the white paper and understanding intellectually, it’s so interesting to try to struggle with how do we come up with the right rules of the road for this really important industry that will have a ton of different use cases. Put differently, it can solve a lot of problems that we’ve accepted as trade-offs as a society, like this idea that we have to have a bunch of middlemen to stamp every single item, whereas, in fact, instant settlement, instant execution alleviates all of that. It also alleviates the fat thumb problem or of people knowing all of my business who have no reason to know my business and someone potentially stealing my funds or my digital identity.
I was like, “Oh my gosh, this is life changing for a lot of people.”

Benjamin Pimentel ( @benpimentel) covers crypto and fintech from San Francisco. He has reported on many of the biggest tech stories over the past 20 years for the San Francisco Chronicle, Dow Jones MarketWatch and Business Insider, from the dot-com crash, the rise of cloud computing, social networking and AI to the impact of the Great Recession and the COVID crisis on Silicon Valley and beyond. He can be reached at [email protected] or via Google Voice at (925) 307-9342.
To give you the best possible experience, this site uses cookies. If you continue browsing. you accept our use of cookies. You can review our privacy policy to find out more about the cookies we use.

source

Leave a Comment