Blog

New Gold Reports Third Quarter Operational Results – StreetInsider.com

FREE Breaking News Alerts from StreetInsider.com!
StreetInsider.com Top Tickers, 10/14/2022
New Gold Inc. logo (CNW Group/New Gold Inc.)
Provides Notice of Release of Third Quarter Financial Results
(All amounts are in U.S. dollars unless otherwise indicated)
TORONTO, Oct. 12, 2022 /PRNewswire/ – New Gold Inc. (“New Gold” or the “Company”) (TSX: NGD) (NYSE American: NGD) reports third quarter operational results for the Company as of September 30, 2022. The Company is also providing notice that it will release its third quarter 2022 financial results before markets open on Thursday, November 3, 2022.
“We continued the positive momentum experienced in the summer months and finished the third quarter on a strong note,” stated Renaud Adams, President & CEO. “At Rainy River, underground mining commenced during the quarter, and we continue to anticipate underground material to start feeding the mill beginning in the fourth quarter. With mining of the open pit main ODM zone continuing its ramp-up, I look forward to Rainy River finishing the year strong. New Afton had solid production improvement over the second quarter with the continual ramp-up of B3. Last week we received the C-Zone permit, a significant milestone for the mine, and our priority at New Afton continues to be ramping up B3 production and advancing C-Zone development. We remain on track to deliver on our updated guidance.”
Consolidated Operational Highlights
Q3 2022
Q3 2021
9M 2022
9M 2021
Gold eq. production (ounces)1,2
91,021
105,628
249,230
307,359
Gold production (ounces)2
70,147
72,210
190,679
205,849
Copper production (Mlbs)
8.5
15.6
24.1
47.5
 
Rainy River Mine 
Rainy River Mine (Open Pit Mine only)
Q3 2022
Q3 2021
9M 2022
9M 2021
Tonnes mined per day (ore and waste)
112,055
149,630
113,597
152,980
Ore tonnes mined per day
24,701
52,917
19,022
41,681
Operating waste tonnes per day
44,469
88,216
33,110
75,077
Capitalized waste tonnes per day
42,885
8,497
61,465
36,222
Total waste tonnes per day
87,354
96,713
94,575
111,299
Strip ratio (waste:ore)
3.54
1.83
4.97
2.67
Tonnes milled per calendar day
24,439
25,245
24,020
25,628
Gold grade milled (g/t)
0.89
0.89
0.83
0.83
Gold recovery (%)
91
89
91
89
Gold eq. production (ounces)1
60,319
60,785
163,973
172,462
Gold production (ounces)
58,719
58,557
160,069
166,113
 
New Afton Mine
New Afton Mine
Q3 2022
Q3 2021
9M 2022
9M 2021
Tonnes mined per day (ore and waste)
6,523
12,861
6,674
13,125
Tonnes milled per calendar day
7,764
13,068
9,836
13,474
Gold grade milled (g/t)
0.59
0.43
0.43
0.42
Gold recovery (%)
85
83
83
81
Copper grade milled (%)
0.64
0.72
0.50
0.72
Copper recovery (%)
85
82
81
82
Gold eq. production (ounces)1
30,701
44,843
85,257
134,898
Gold production (ounces)
11,427
13,653
30,610
39,735
Copper production (Mlbs)
8.5
15.6
24.1
47.5
 
Third Quarter 2022 Conference Call and Webcast
The Company will release its third quarter 2022 financial results before markets open on Thursday, November 3, 2022. A conference call and webcast will follow at 8:30 am Eastern Time. 
About New GoldNew Gold is a Canadian-focused intermediate mining Company with a portfolio of two core producing assets in Canada, the Rainy River gold mine and the New Afton copper-gold mine. The Company also holds an approximately 5% equity stake in Artemis Gold Inc. and other Canadian-focused investments. New Gold’s vision is to build a leading diversified intermediate gold company based in Canada that is committed to the environment and social responsibility. For further information on the Company, visit www.newgold.com. 
Endnotes
1.
Total gold eq. ounces include silver and copper produced/sold converted to a gold equivalent. All copper is produced/sold by the New Afton Mine. Gold eq. ounces for Rainy River in Q3 2022 includes production of 120,000 ounces of silver converted to a gold eq. based on a ratio of $1,800 per gold ounce and $24.00 per silver ounce used for 2022 guidance estimates. Gold eq. ounces for New Afton in Q3 2022 includes 8.5 million pounds of copper produced and 22,672 ounces of silver produced converted to a gold eq. based on a ratio of $1,800 per gold ounce, $4.00 per copper pound and $24.00 per silver ounce used for 2022 guidance estimates.
2.
Numbers may not add up due to rounding.
 
Cautionary Note Regarding Forward-Looking StatementsCertain information contained in this news release, including any information relating to New Gold’s future financial or operating performance are “forward-looking”. All statements in this news release, other than statements of historical fact, which address events, results, outcomes or developments that New Gold expects to occur are “forward-looking statements”. Forward-looking statements are statements that are not historical facts and are generally, but not always, identified by the use of forward-looking terminology such as “plans”, “expects”, “is expected”, “budget”, “scheduled”, “targeted”, “estimates”, “forecasts”, “intends”, “anticipates”, “projects”, “potential”, “believes” or variations of such words and phrases or statements that certain actions, events or results “may”, “could”, “would”, “should”, “might” or “will be taken”, “occur” or “be achieved” or the negative connotation of such terms. Forward-looking statements in this news release include, among others, statements with respect to: anticipated timing with respect to the release of its third quarter 2022 financial results and the associated conference call and webcast; underground material starting to feed the mill and the anticipated timing thereof; the continued ramp-up of mining of the open pit main ODM Zone; intended priorities at New Afton, including ramping up B3 production and advancing C-Zone development; and the Company’s ability to deliver on updated guidance.
All forward-looking statements in this news release are based on the opinions and estimates of management that, while considered reasonable as at the date of this news release in light of management’s experience and perception of current conditions and expected developments, are inherently subject to important risk factors and uncertainties, many of which are beyond New Gold’s ability to control or predict. Certain material assumptions regarding such forward-looking statements are discussed in this news release, New Gold’s latest annual management’s discussion and analysis (“MD&A”), its most recent annual information form and technical reports on the Rainy River Mine and New Afton Mine filed on SEDAR at www.sedar.com and on EDGAR at www.sec.gov. In addition to, and subject to, such assumptions discussed in more detail elsewhere, the forward-looking statements in this news release are also subject to the following assumptions: (1) there being no significant disruptions affecting New Gold’s operations other than as set out herein; (2) political and legal developments in jurisdictions where New Gold operates, or may in the future operate, being consistent with New Gold’s current expectations; (3) the accuracy of New Gold’s current mineral reserve and mineral resource estimates and the grade of gold, silver and copper expected to be mined and the grade of gold, copper and silver expected to be mined; (4) the exchange rate between the Canadian dollar and U.S. dollar, and to a lesser extent, the Mexican Peso, and commodity prices being approximately consistent with current levels and expectations for the purposes of 2022 guidance and otherwise; (5) prices for diesel, natural gas, fuel oil, electricity and other key supplies being approximately consistent with current levels; (6) equipment, labour and materials costs increasing on a basis consistent with New Gold’s current expectations; (7) arrangements with First Nations and other Aboriginal groups in respect of the New Afton Mine and Rainy River Mine being consistent with New Gold’s current expectations; (8) all required permits, licenses and authorizations being obtained from the relevant governments and other relevant stakeholders within the expected timelines and the absence of material negative comments or obstacles during any applicable regulatory processes; (9) there being no significant disruptions to the Company’s workforce at either the Rainy River Mine or New Afton Mine due to cases of COVID-19 (including any required self-isolation requirements due to cross-border travel to the United States or any other country or any other reason) or otherwise; (10) the responses of the relevant governments to the COVID-19 outbreak being sufficient to contain the impact of the COVID-19 outbreak; (11) there being no material disruption to the Company’s supply chains and workforce that would interfere with the Company’s anticipated course of action at the Rainy River Mine and the New Afton Mine; and (12) the long-term economic effects of the COVID-19 outbreak not having a material adverse impact on the Company’s operations or liquidity position.
Forward-looking statements are necessarily based on estimates and assumptions that are inherently subject to known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause actual results, level of activity, performance or achievements to be materially different from those expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. Such factors include, without limitation: price volatility in the spot and forward markets for metals and other commodities; discrepancies between actual and estimated production, between actual and estimated costs, between actual and estimated Mineral Reserves and Mineral Resources and between actual and estimated metallurgical recoveries; equipment malfunction, failure or unavailability; accidents; risks related to early production at the Rainy River Mine, including failure of equipment, machinery, the process circuit or other processes to perform as designed or intended; the speculative nature of mineral exploration and development, including the risks of obtaining and maintaining the validity and enforceability of the necessary licenses and permits and complying with the permitting requirements of each jurisdiction in which New Gold operates, including, but not limited to: obtaining the necessary permits for the New Afton C-Zone; uncertainties and unanticipated delays associated with obtaining and maintaining necessary licenses, permits and authorizations and complying with permitting requirements, including those associated with the C-Zone permitting process; changes in project parameters as plans continue to be refined; changing costs, timelines and development schedules as it relates to construction; the Company not being able to complete its construction projects at the Rainy River Mine or the New Afton Mine on the anticipated timeline or at all; volatility in the market price of the Company’s securities; changes in national and local government legislation in the countries in which New Gold does or may in the future carry on business; controls, regulations and political or economic developments in the countries in which New Gold does or may in the future carry on business; the Company’s dependence on the Rainy River Mine and New Afton Mine; the Company not being able to complete its exploration drilling programs on the anticipated timeline or at all; disruptions to the Company’s workforce at either the Rainy River Mine or the New Afton Mine, or both, due to cases of COVID-19 or any required self-isolation (due to cross-border travel, exposure to a case of COVID-19 or otherwise); the responses of the relevant governments to the COVID-19 outbreak not being sufficient to contain the impact of the COVID-19 outbreak; disruptions to the Company’s supply chain and workforce due to the COVID-19 outbreak; an economic recession or downturn as a result of the COVID-19 outbreak that materially adversely affects the Company’s operations or liquidity position; there being further shutdowns at the Rainy River Mine or New Afton Mine; significant capital requirements and the availability and management of capital resources; additional funding requirements; diminishing quantities or grades of Mineral Reserves and Mineral Resources; actual results of current exploration or reclamation activities; uncertainties inherent to mining economic studies including the Technical Reports for the Rainy River Mine and New Afton Mine; impairment; unexpected delays and costs inherent to consulting and accommodating rights of First Nations and other indigenous groups; climate change, environmental risks and hazards and the Company’s response thereto; tailings dam and structure failures; actual results of current exploration or reclamation activities; fluctuations in the international currency markets and in the rates of exchange of the currencies of Canada, the United States and, to a lesser extent, Mexico; global economic and financial conditions and any global or local natural events that may impede the economy or New Gold’s ability to carry on business in the normal course; compliance with debt obligations and maintaining sufficient liquidity; taxation; fluctuation in treatment and refining charges; transportation and processing of unrefined products; rising costs or availability of labour, supplies, fuel and equipment; adequate infrastructure; relationships with communities, governments and other stakeholders; geotechnical instability and conditions; labour disputes; the uncertainties inherent in current and future legal challenges to which New Gold is or may become a party; defective title to mineral claims or property or contests over claims to mineral properties; competition; loss of, or inability to attract, key employees; use of derivative products and hedging transactions; counterparty risk and the performance of third party service providers; investment risks and uncertainty relating to the value of equity investments in public companies held by the Company from time to time; the adequacy of internal and disclosure controls; conflicts of interest; the lack of certainty with respect to foreign operations and legal systems, which may not be immune from the influence of political pressure, corruption or other factors that are inconsistent with the rule of law; the successful acquisitions and integration of business arrangements and realizing the intended benefits therefrom; and information systems security threats. In addition, there are risks and hazards associated with the business of mineral exploration, development, construction, operation and mining, including environmental events and hazards, industrial accidents, unusual or unexpected formations, pressures, cave-ins, flooding and gold bullion losses (and the risk of inadequate insurance or inability to obtain insurance to cover these risks) as well as “Risk Factors” included in New Gold’s most recent annual information form, MD&A and other disclosure documents filed on and available on SEDAR at www.sedar.com and on EDGAR at www.sec.gov. Forward looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, and actual results and future events could materially differ from those anticipated in such statements. All forward-looking statements contained in this news release are qualified by these cautionary statements. New Gold expressly disclaims any intention or obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements whether as a result of new information, events or otherwise, except in accordance with applicable securities laws.
Technical InformationThe scientific and technical information contained in this news release has been reviewed and approved by Patrick Godin, Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of New Gold.  Mr. Godin is a Professional Engineer and member of the Ordre des ingénieurs du Québec. He is a “Qualified Person” for the purposes of National Instrument 43-101 – Standards of Disclosure for Mineral Projects.
Cision View original content to download multimedia:https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/new-gold-reports-third-quarter-operational-results-301647847.html
SOURCE New Gold Inc.
Receive full access to all new and archived articles, unlimited portfolio tracking, e-mail alerts, custom newswires and RSS feeds – and more!

source

Jake Tapper: My Father's Quest to Free C. J. Rice – The Atlantic

A Philadelphia teenager and the empty promise of the Sixth Amendment

This article was featured in One Story to Read Today, a newsletter in which our editors recommend a single must-read from The Atlantic, Monday through Friday. Sign up for it here.      
On Tuesday, September 20, 2011, a young patient walked haltingly into a medical office in South Philadelphia to have his bullet wounds examined.
The patient was a 17-year-old named C. J. Rice, who lived in the neighborhood. The doctor was a pediatrician named Theodore Tapper.
Check out more from this issue and find your next story to read.
My father had been working as a physician in South Philadelphia for more than four decades and had known Rice since he was a child. Rice had been brought in for a checkup soon after he was born, and as a doctor my father had seen Rice several times a year, along with other members of the family. Two weeks and three days before his September appointment, Rice had been shot while riding his bike, in what he believed was a case of mistaken identity. To remove one of the bullets, a surgeon had made a long incision down the middle of Rice’s torso. The wound was then closed with a ridge of staples—more than two dozen. After his discharge, Rice was in severe pain and could barely walk. He needed help to get dressed in the morning and help to go up and down stairs.
When Rice arrived at my father’s office, the wound was still stapled together. Rice slowly lifted himself onto the examination table and winced as he laid himself down. When the exam was over, he slowly pushed himself back up. My father recalls Rice walking out of the office bent over and with short, choppy steps, like an old man.
The timing of that visit is significant because, six days later, the Philadelphia police announced that they were seeking Rice and a friend of his, Tyler Linder, in connection with a shooting that had occurred in South Philadelphia on the evening of September 25 and left four people wounded, including a 6-year-old girl. No guns were recovered and no physical evidence linked anyone to the crime. On the night of the shooting, the victims told the police they had no idea who was responsible. Then, the next day, one of the victims said she had seen Rice sprinting away.
Rice was still recuperating. Thinking the matter would be cleared up quickly, he turned himself in.
I first met C. J. Rice, by Zoom, in February 2022. But I felt I had gotten to know him over the preceding few years through his letters from prison to my father.
Whatever Rice’s expectations, the matter had not been cleared up quickly. To represent him, the court had appointed a lawyer whose attention was elsewhere and whose performance would prove dangerously incompetent. Despite the weakness of the case, Rice was convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to 30 to 60 years in prison. Eventually, seeking evidence for an appeal, Rice wrote to my father and asked for help obtaining his hospital records—documents that Rice’s original lawyer appears never to have sought, but which could have underscored his physical condition at the time. My father obtained the records, and the two men kept writing to each other. The correspondence has become important to both of them.
Read: An interview with Fulton Leroy Washington about the November issue cover art
Writing helps Rice pass the time at the State Correctional Institution–Coal Township, the Pennsylvania prison where he is incarcerated. In an angular hand on notebook paper, he reflects on the gravitational pull of what he calls “19148”: the zip code of his old neighborhood in South Philadelphia.
In one letter, he described his childhood:
In another letter, he imagined a playground scene in which he and his contemporaries were all 7 years old, then went on to describe what happened to that cohort year by year. Violence and crime were rife in 19148, and few were untouched by it. Rice concluded with a summary:
Rice’s father was addicted to heroin and was in and out of prison. By the time Rice was a teenager, he himself was selling heroin and smoking marijuana. Rice was arrested for marijuana possession in 2009, at age 15, and then again in 2010. After one of these encounters with the law, his mother sent Rice to live with his aunt in North Philadelphia for a period of time to get him out of the neighborhood. Despite the chaos around him, Rice did well in school. He had always been bright—in kindergarten, he was reading well above grade level—and by September 2011, at the start of his senior year, he needed only a handful of credits to graduate from high school. He had visited Howard University and sat in on classes at Temple. He thought he might want to become an accountant.
My father, who is now 82, came of age during the 1960s and has always been something of an activist. A graduate of Harvard Medical School, he chose to do his pediatric residency at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, and returned there after a period with the public-health service in New York City. He became involved with the Medical Committee for Human Rights—a group founded to provide medical care for people injured in civil-rights protests—and served as the head of its Philadelphia chapter. On the side, he treated sick children at a clinic sponsored by the Black Panthers. In time, he set up his own practice in South Philadelphia. This area is also where he and my mother bought a house, in 1969, when I was three months old. My brother and I grew up there through the 1970s, housing projects half a block away.
My father is an idealist. He is generous with his time. When he makes donations, he usually does so anonymously, on principle. But he is not naive. Having worked in South Philly for more than 40 years, until his retirement, he knows all too well that teenagers, even polite and intelligent ones, are capable of horrific acts. And he knows that Rice’s record is far from spotless. But as a doctor, he believes that Rice’s involvement in the crime for which he was convicted was physically impossible. Over the years, he has supported efforts through a variety of channels—state courts, the district attorney’s office, the governor’s office, federal court—to get Rice’s case reconsidered. Some of these efforts have been exhausted. Some continue. In 2020, as I learned more about the case, I related several of the facts as I knew them in a Twitter thread. Then I began to look deeply into the case myself.
In my first conversation with Rice, he appeared on the Zoom screen wearing a dark-red jumpsuit. He smiled often, and even with a beard his face looked young, though from the neck down, his body was a fortress of prison muscle. He was seated in a visitation booth. In his right hand, he held a phone on a cord, which in normal times connects to a phone for a visitor on the opposite side of a plexiglass window. Now, with an open laptop sitting in place of a visitor, the phone served as the audio conduit for the call.
Our conversation was easy, congenial. But when I began to ask Rice about his case, his speech became staccato and impassioned. He recited police-badge numbers from memory. He provided page numbers for specific passages of testimony in trial transcripts. He recalled each of the very few moments spent with his lawyer. Rice has had more than a decade to think about the steps that led to his imprisonment. He had a lot to say.
Read: The Supreme Court doesn’t necessarily care if your lawyer is unethical
The story told here centers on Commonwealth v. Charles J. Rice and the events around that case. Readers will draw their own conclusions about what happened on the night of September 25, 2011. My father and I have drawn ours. There is certainly reasonable doubt—an excess of reasonable doubt—that Rice committed the crimes of which he was accused. But what happened after that night is not open to argument: Rice lacked legal representation worthy of the name. And as he has discovered, the law provides little recourse for those undermined by a lawyer. The constitutional “right to counsel” has become an empty guarantee.
The night of September 25 was unseasonably warm. When Latrice Johnson saw two figures walking up Fernon Street toward South 18th wearing hoodies and long pants, she should have known something was wrong—that’s what she told herself later. The time was about 9:30 p.m. The two figures had their hoods up, the strings drawn tight. On the front stoop of her parents’ house, Johnson was waiting for a food delivery. Her son Kalief Ladson, age 17, sat next to her, cradling her niece, 6-year-old Denean Thomas. Three of her other seven children were perched around them. Latoya Lane, her 23-year-old stepdaughter, was across the street with two more of Johnson’s children and two of their cousins. Some of them were playing basketball. Down the street, on the opposite side, the two figures in hoodies drew handguns and opened fire.
From the January/February 2018 issue: Can you prove your innocence without DNA?
Johnson dove on top of the children and shielded them with her body. Bullets ricocheted off the brick facade of the house. At least 12 shots were fired. Then, according to both Johnson and Lane, the shooters ran off. Looking down at Denean, Johnson saw that her niece was bleeding from one of her legs. Some of the children shouted, “Denean is gonna die!”
In a 911 call, placed at 9:36 p.m., Johnson’s desperation is evident from the audio recording. “My niece just got shot!” Johnson yells. Screams are audible in the background. A dispatcher requests an address and then asks, “Ma’am, the person that shot her—what did he look like? Black male? White male?” Johnson replies, “They got on hoodies! They’re Black!”
Police officers arrived within minutes. By then, Johnson knew that not only Denean but also Ladson and Lane had been shot. With no time to wait for an ambulance, Officer Charles Forrest loaded Denean and Johnson into his squad car and sped to Children’s Hospital. As Forrest later testified, he asked Johnson if she knew who had shot Denean and the others. Johnson said only what she had told the dispatcher. She did not identify the shooters.
Arriving at the hospital, Johnson realized that she, too, had been injured; shrapnel had caused lacerations on the lower part of her body. Forrest took her to the adjacent Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, where he again asked if she knew who the shooters were. Johnson’s answers suggested, once more, that she had no idea who either shooter was: “One Black male wearing a gray hoodie and the other with a black hoodie, and they both had black sweatpants.”
Kalief Ladson and Latoya Lane, meanwhile, had also been brought to a hospital. They were visited later that evening by a police officer, Lynne Zirilli. As Zirilli later testified, she asked them if they could describe the shooters. Ladson said only that he had seen “two to three Black males in dark hoodies.” Lane said she had seen “two to three Black males.” They made no identification.
Overnight, however, everything changed. According to the police, a confidential informant relayed a tip: A teenager named C. J. Rice may have been involved. By evening, Johnson and Lane would change their stories. One of them would say she had seen Rice at the scene, and the other would say she had seen his friend Tyler Linder.
For different reasons, both the prosecution and C. J. Rice would contend that the September 25 shooting had to be seen in the context of the shooting three weeks earlier, on September 3, that had sent Rice to the operating room. That afternoon, Rice and Linder had been gambling with friends at an apartment in South Philly. Around 7 p.m., the two boys mounted their bikes and began pedaling toward Rice’s home. Soon, a black Oldsmobile with tinted windows pulled up behind them. By their own accounts, neither Rice nor Linder recognized the car. From a window, shots were fired. Rice was hit three times, in his abdomen and in his left flank and buttock. He recalls feeling as if the left side of his body had been pinched, then bludgeoned by a crowbar. An ambulance rushed him to Thomas Jefferson University Hospital, where a surgeon named Murray Cohen cut into Rice’s abdomen, from the sternum down to a few inches below the navel. Cohen eventually found and extracted a bullet. Fragments of the others remained inside. One bullet had struck Rice’s pelvis, causing fractures. While still in the hospital, Rice contracted pneumonia. Because of other complications, his wound had to be reopened, drained, and closed again. When he was finally discharged, after eight days, he went to stay with his godmother, Deania Duncan, and her family in West Philadelphia, away from the scene of the shooting.
Who had been in the Oldsmobile? Rice’s mother, Crystal Cooper, told police about a rumor that the perpetrator was someone named “Noodle.” Investigators noted in a report that “the reliability of this information is questionable.” On September 16, Duncan drove Rice—mainly housebound, barely able to walk—from her home to a police station in South Philadelphia. Cooper, who worked in the district attorney’s office and knew many officers on the force, hoped that her son would give a statement. But the relationship between youths in the neighborhood and the Philadelphia police force has long been one of deep hostility. The kids Rice grew up with had an unwritten rule: When you saw the police, you ran. Rice declined to say anything, explaining that he didn’t know who had shot him and wouldn’t tell the police anyway; if he’d done so, he told me later, he “might as well just pack up and move to Texas.” The police report notes that Rice had come downtown only “because his mother dragged him there.” Rice remembers a detective named Robert Spadaccini—who had worked with his mother for years—telling him that the “word on the street” was that Kalief Ladson had been the shooter, and cautioning Rice, with a wave at the squad room, that “if anything happens to him or to his family or anyone close to him, they’re going to come for you first.” Rice recalls pulling up his shirt, showing Spadaccini his stapled wound, and saying, “I won’t be doing anything.” (Detective Spadaccini could not be reached for comment.)
Rice told me that, other than the trip to the police station, he rarely left Duncan’s home. He remembers once visiting his girlfriend, whose mother had just died. And he made the trip to my father’s office, to have his wound looked at.
Rice was in constant pain, but as my father recalls, he was adamant about not taking painkillers—he had an aversion to them. Both men recount their conversation in his office the same way:
“You’re due for a refill,” my father said, referring to the prescription for Percocet the hospital had provided.
“I’m not taking the pills,” Rice replied. He hadn’t taken any since the second day of the prescription; he didn’t need a refill.
“Why not?” my father asked.
“I don’t like the way they make me feel,” Rice said—lazy and spaced-out.
“If you’re feeling enough pain, I think you should take them,” my father urged. But Rice said he was going to tough it out.
It wasn’t just the evident pain that made my father believe that Rice couldn’t have sprinted from the scene of the shooting. My father wasn’t yet aware of the fractures in Rice’s pelvis—that information was in hospital records, which he hadn’t seen—but in his view as a doctor, the totality of Rice’s condition argued against the capacity for strenuous exertion. Rice had just recovered from pneumonia. He had lost muscle strength because of prolonged immobility. And he still had staples in place on the long abdominal incision—they weren’t due to be removed for another week. “I don’t think it would have been physically possible,” my father told me. “He could not have run away.” In the hands of competent counsel, the issue of Rice’s physical capability by itself would have raised serious questions about his involvement.
But the September 3 ambush would also become central to the police narrative, though no evidence to support that narrative was ever presented in court: In the eyes of the police, if the “word on the street” was credible—if Kalief Ladson had staged the ambush—then Rice and Linder had a possible motive to strike back.
The September 25 shooting received significant media attention, and not only because one of the wounded was young. Philadelphia was on track to finish 2011 with the highest per capita murder rate among large American cities. Although no one was killed in this shooting, people were concerned about guns, gangs, and drugs. The Philadelphia police were under intense pressure to clear cases and take shooters and their weapons off the streets.
Nothing is known about the confidential informant who conveyed the tip pointing to C. J. Rice, or about exactly when the tip was received or what the informant alleged. On September 26, after receiving the tip, the police ran Rice’s name and the names of the victims through their “shooting database.” The database noted that Rice, while on his bike with Tyler Linder, had been shot a few weeks earlier. According to the database, Rice was a purported member of the so-called 7th Street gang. Ladson was a purported associate of the rival 5th Street gang. He also was mentioned as a suspect in the earlier shooting. Had they all been involved in a gang feud? If so, maybe Ladson had been the target of a retaliatory hit; Johnson, Lane, and Denean just happened to get in the way. This idea is floated in the police investigation of the September 25 shooting. But the investigation documents contain no supporting evidence for any of this, and none would be presented at trial. Whatever the police may have said to Rice regarding the attack on him—and whatever the police may have thought—no speculation appears in the official investigation of the events of September 3.
Nonetheless, they had a theory. Detectives John Craig and Neal Aitken printed photo arrays that included pictures of Rice and Linder. At the time, the Philadelphia Police Department was still three years from adopting what has become a widely accepted best practice for reducing bias in witness identifications—the “double blind” method. Made official policy under Police Commissioner Charles Ramsey in 2014, the double-blind method ensures that the officers showing witnesses possible perpetrators, either in photographs or in a traditional lineup, are unaware of which individual is the suspect. In this instance, Craig and Aitken knew exactly whom they were looking for—they were the officers on the case.
The day after the shooting, the detectives visited Latoya Lane and then Latrice Johnson. The interviews, conducted at the Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, were crucial to the investigation. Because the guns used in the shooting were never found and no physical evidence tied the crime to any individual, an eyewitness identification of a potential suspect would carry immense weight in court. Indeed, it would be the only evidence. Although Lane and Johnson had said to police on multiple occasions that they did not recognize either shooter, they responded differently during the hospital interviews. Eyewitness accounts do change; fear or trauma may color initial statements. Judging from the interview record, explanations for the new accounts by Lane and Johnson went unexplored. The document invites questions.
Barbara Bradley Hagerty: The other police violence
There are no verbatim transcripts of the interviews because there were never any audio recordings. The conversations were only partially preserved, in handwritten notes. From passing references—an allusion to something that occurred in the interview but that is not actually recounted in the notes—it is clear that things were said that were never written down. Detective Craig, who took the notes, later acknowledged that they are imperfect and incomplete.
Craig and Aitken started with Latoya Lane, who was still receiving inpatient hospital care. Craig’s notes contain no information about a preliminary exchange, though there must have been at least an introduction. The notes officially begin with a question from the detectives about what had happened the night before. Lane said that when she’d heard the shots, she’d turned to run toward the stoop. “That’s when I saw Tyler,” she said. “I seen the spark coming from his hand.” Neither Lane nor the detectives ever use Tyler Linder’s last name, and the detectives never ask for it—it’s as if Linder had already been discussed in a missing earlier part of the interview. It is not known how his name was first brought up. As it happens, Lane knew Linder; he was a friend of a cousin. She said she had seen another person running across the street, also wearing a dark hoodie, but hadn’t glimpsed his face. Later in the interview, the detectives handed Lane a photo array and asked, “Do you see Tyler here?” She replied, “Right here”—not surprising, because she knew him. With a pen, she circled a headshot of Linder in the top row of the grid, second from the left, and signed her name.
Next, about three hours later, the detectives interviewed Johnson. She had been released from the hospital but had returned to visit Lane, and the detectives met with her there. Before the detectives arrived, Lane and Johnson had talked about the case, and Johnson knew that her stepdaughter had given the detectives Linder’s name.
In the interview with the detectives, Johnson, like Lane, changed her story. The police notes indicate that Johnson was shown a photo array before the interview began, but they contain no account of that process. She circled and signed the bottom-right headshot, a picture of C. J. Rice. As had been the case with Lane, Johnson knew the person whose picture she circled. Rice had gone to school with her son Kalief; she and Rice were friends on Facebook. It is not recorded what question from the detectives prompted her to circle his photo. The written account is at times both precise and slightly mysterious. It begins with “My name is Det. Craig & this [is] Det. Aitken,” as if the detectives had not introduced themselves during the earlier, missing part of the interview, when they showed Johnson the photo array. In any case, Johnson thought back to the night before, placing herself on the stoop and describing how she’d watched two hooded figures approach. “Then I saw C.J. shooting in our direction,” she said, according to the notes. “It was loud as shit.”
Johnson insisted to Craig and Aitken no fewer than six times that Rice was the person who had shot her. She did not explain why, when asked on three previous occasions, she’d failed to identify someone she had known for years. Aitken, since retired and recalling the two interviews a decade later, had only a hazy memory of them. According to the notes, Aitken and Craig did not press Johnson or Lane about how their inability to identify the perpetrators had become a solid identification overnight. (A spokesperson for the Philadelphia Police Department suggested that it was not uncommon for eyewitnesses to hesitate before cooperating with police but declined to comment on other aspects of the interviews.) Aitken told me that Johnson’s identification of Rice fit the narrative the detectives were already working with—that the more recent shooting was related to the earlier one and had been spurred by revenge.
The police had the eyewitnesses they needed and secured arrest warrants for Rice and Linder. The pair had acted together, as a team—that was the official theory.
Crystal Cooper learned that her son was wanted for attempted murder on the following day, September 27. Cooper called Deania Duncan, who drove Rice back to the police station in South Philadelphia; Cooper met them there. Rice walked into the building with what Cooper told me were “baby steps.” Outside the station, she called a former colleague, Sandjai Weaver, then working as a defense attorney. As Cooper listened on speakerphone, Weaver cautioned that Rice should say nothing to the police without her present. She promised to hurry over.
As he was booked, Rice made a point of showing his wound to a detective, the staples still sealing the incision. He handed over his cellphone, believing its location data would prove that he hadn’t left West Philadelphia on the day of the shooting. Duncan explained to the police that she had information about Rice’s whereabouts at the time of the shooting and hoped to make a statement.
The intended statement was straightforward, and her family could vouch for it: Rice had spent all of September 25 with Duncan’s son Quadifi, then 14, watching the Jamaican gangster film Shottas over and over again; at the actual moment of the shooting, Rice had been at home with Quadifi, Duncan’s father, and her 7-year-old son, Rickey. The arrest, she said, had been a mistake. “He had to keep a pillow on his abdomen,” Duncan told me later. “His wounds had to be cleaned and changed daily. The way my house is, it was too many steps for him to be able to walk. It made his wound bleed out more, and he could barely stand up or even walk.”
But no one took a statement from Duncan. She says an officer at the station told her she wasn’t needed and sent her on her way. Waiting for Weaver, and following her instructions, Rice said nothing, not even explaining his alibi. And he never got the chance, because for whatever reason, Weaver failed to show up. In the middle of the night, Rice was transferred to the Philadelphia Industrial Correctional Center.
Like Rice, Tyler Linder had an alibi; unlike Rice, he had video to support it and people in his corner, including a lawyer, who made sure the alibi was formally recorded. On the night of the shooting, Linder and his brother had been helping their mother clean a facility in Northeast Philadelphia. He had swept and mopped until at least 10 o’clock, he said, and security video could probably prove it. Linder’s mother had enough money to enlist the services of Raymond Driscoll, a defense attorney at Levant, Martin & Tauber, a small practice in the city. Eventually, Linder made bail. He and his mother and brother had sat for alibi interviews with the police soon after the arrest. A month later, Linder’s mother and Driscoll pressed to arrange a second round of interviews with the D.A.’s office.
Cooper lacked the money to make bail for Rice, so he would remain confined while awaiting trial like any other criminal defendant without resources—one of hundreds of thousands in this situation at any moment. Rice would not go on trial for more than a year. For legal counsel, Cooper looked to Weaver. “Sandjai worked in the office next to my mom’s since I was 5 or 6,” Rice told me. “I knew Sandjai almost my whole life.” In 2005, Weaver had mounted an unsuccessful bid for election as a Court of Common Pleas judge. A 12-year-old Rice had handed out campaign flyers. Cooper doubted she could afford Weaver’s services for very long, but in December, Weaver was granted a formal court appointment to represent Rice, allowing her to be compensated with public funds.
From the June 2022 issue: Can forensic science be trusted?
She met with him for the first time that same month, in advance of his preliminary hearing. Determined to participate in his own defense, Rice asked Weaver to send him copies of the pretrial discovery documents—all of the evidence that the prosecution intended to present. Rice wasn’t sure what to look for, but an older man detained with him had advised that the discovery was everything: If there was something that could clear his name, it was bound to be in those documents. Later, Rice also asked Weaver to subpoena his Cricket Wireless phone records. The location data, he said, would back up his alibi. Weaver promised that she would do both.
The formal appointment of Weaver as counsel may have seemed like a blessing. Rice and his mother did not know that Weaver was in deep financial distress and seemed to be taking all the freelance work from the courts that she could get.
Court-appointed private lawyers and public defenders are not the same thing. Public defenders are salaried professionals who make a career representing the indigent. In Philadelphia, public defenders handle one out of every five murder trials. Courts must appoint private attorneys to take on the remaining 80 percent. Philadelphia is by no means an outlier: The great majority of people in the U.S. live in jurisdictions that rely on both the public-defense bar and appointed private attorneys. In Philadelphia in 2011, court-appointed lawyers received flat fees: $2,000 for preparation if a case went to trial, and $1,333 if it didn’t. For each day after the first day of trial, court-appointed lawyers received $400 a day if they spent more than three hours in the courtroom and $200 if they spent fewer.
These rates were extremely low, especially for cases involving murder or attempted murder, which are among the most challenging a lawyer can take on. Such meager compensation shrinks the pool of available attorneys and reduces its quality. Research suggests that, on everything from conviction rates to severity of sentences, appointed lawyers are far less successful than public defenders. The flat fees also create a perverse incentive. Whether attorneys spend 10 hours preparing for trial or 10,000 hours, they’ll be paid the same small amount. It’s in their interest to maximize their caseload and minimize their prep time.
Weaver was profoundly subject to these pressures. Nine months before her appointment as Rice’s lawyer, she had filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy. On March 16, 2011, Weaver declared that she had only $400 in her two bank accounts. She owed creditors nearly $130,000, not including her mortgage, which she was behind on. As a condition for debt relief, Weaver was required to submit a rigorous accounting of her anticipated income and expenses—her “Chapter 13 Plan”—which would determine how much she paid back to a bankruptcy trustee each month. In her first proposed plan, Weaver declared $4,000 in monthly income and $3,245 in expenses, and she proposed paying creditors $750 a month for 60 months. That wasn’t good enough, so Weaver submitted a second plan, agreeing to pay $1,261 every month. To make these payments, she would have to earn more money than she had initially thought possible.
A judge approved Weaver’s Chapter 13 Plan on September 20—the same day Rice came into my father’s office, and just a week before his arrest.
Between the preliminary hearing and the opening day of the trial—a period of 14 months—Weaver met with Rice only twice. Both meetings took place at the Philadelphia Industrial Correctional Center. Neither lasted longer than 15 minutes. Rice tried frequently to reach Weaver by phone, initiating all the calls himself; she had no answering service, and he succeeded in reaching her only three times, again speaking to her for no more than 15 minutes on each occasion.
Weaver did not bring Rice a copy of his discovery, but she did come to the meetings carrying what looked to be a large stack of other people’s case files—Rice suspects she had arranged for a marathon series of client meetings at the prison. Rice’s two meetings with Weaver were too brief for any meaningful discussion of trial strategy. Rice reminded her to send over his discovery and get his phone records, which she had not yet done. They were essential. She promised that she would.
Not until April 26, 2012—seven months after her client’s arrest—did Weaver submit a notice of alibi for Rice to the district attorney’s office. In it, she listed all the members of Deania Duncan’s family who lived at her home in West Philadelphia. She stated that Rice had always been at home, with at least one of them, on the day of the shooting. She provided their phone numbers. But unlike Tyler Linder’s attorney, Weaver didn’t make arrangements for alibi witnesses to be interviewed. The burden thus fell on the D.A.’s office to find the alibi witnesses.
When I obtained a copy of Weaver’s notice of alibi, it had been heavily annotated by someone at the D.A.’s office. In the margins, notes in looping cursive recorded a call to the Duncans’ home phone on May 15; there was no answer and no answering machine. The office tried the next day and reached a man—in all likelihood, Duncan’s father—who said he was going to a doctor’s appointment and would call back. The office tried three more times, then seems to have given up. Duncan told me that Weaver made no effort of her own to contact her or other family members in order to take their testimony. As a result, the first time an alibi witness provided an official statement of any kind in support of Rice was in the courtroom, 16 months after the shooting. This negligence would be used by the prosecution to cast doubt on the alibi itself.
In the meantime, the official theory of the case hardened. The September 3 shooting that had sent Rice to the hospital remained unsolved, but the police embraced the assumption that Latrice Johnson’s son Kalief Ladson was the shooter in the Oldsmobile. A further assumption was that Ladson had been retaliating for some previous event. As prosecutors saw it, the tit-for-tat scenario gave Rice and Linder a motive to come after Ladson. Both men dispute the idea that Ladson was the shooter. They were all friends from school, Rice told me. He thinks the shooting was a mistake—that he and Linder had ridden their bikes into the center of some unrelated beef. Medical notes from his hospitalization immediately after the September 3 shooting record that Rice told a nurse that he “does not think he was the intended target.” Rice and Linder also deny that they were members of a gang. “The way they classified it,” Rice told me, referring to the police, “a gang was everybody you went to school with or everybody that you might have played basketball with.” But there were indeed gangs, and for youths in some neighborhoods they could be hard to avoid. What is certain is that official police files and backup documents furnished in discovery contain no supporting evidence for the gang-feud theory that drove the investigation, or for Ladson’s involvement in the September 3 shooting. No evidence for any of this was ever presented in court.
As the trial date approached, Eric Stryd, the assistant district attorney assigned to the case, privately expressed doubts about the police theory that Rice and Linder had acted as a team. As explained in an internal memo I obtained, the case against Linder could prove hard to make.
Video footage largely backed up Linder’s story. It had shown him cleaning a facility in Northeast Philly until at least 8:45 on the night of the shooting. He and his mother said they had then gone on to clean another building; it had no security camera. Additional video evidence showed an SUV matching the description of his mother’s leaving the area at 9:53, though the video was inconclusive because a license plate was not visible. Linder might have skipped out at 8:45 and gotten a ride to the crime scene in South Philly, and his mother and brother could have been covering for him. But accepting the whole scenario could be a lot to ask of a jury. Rice’s alibi, however, was still unverified, and likely to be less sturdy.
Read: How two newspaper reporters helped free an innocent man
In a summary of the overall case, under the rubric “Additional Facts,” the internal memo states, “Victims could not tell the police at the scene who did the shooting.” Under the rubric “Problems,” the memo states, “Victims both can ID only one of the two defendants and they do not tell police/nurses immediately who shot them.”
Coming back, in a different document, to the potential difficulty of proving Linder’s involvement, Stryd asked, “Is there strategic value to getting rid of the weaker case and just go forward on the stronger one?” Stryd said he was “torn about what the best way is to proceed.”
In the D.A.’s office around that time, there was a phrase prosecutors sometimes used: “Just put it up.” In other words, just prosecute and let the jury decide. Whatever the thinking, in the end, the D.A.’s office elected to put both Linder and Rice on trial.
Eric Stryd today works in the office of the state attorney general. In an emailed response to questions, he said he was unfamiliar with the phrase “Just put it up.” He confirmed his uncertainty about the case against Linder.
Of course, giving credence to Linder’s alibi would have called into question the police theory that Rice and Linder had been partners, acting out of revenge. If Rice was one of the shooters, then his partner must have been someone else.
In his emailed response, Stryd wrote, “I was instructed to proceed to trial.” His supervisors, he noted, were “more senior and more experienced than I was.”
C. J. Rice and Tyler Linder were tried together, but they were represented by different lawyers. The case against both was thin. As much as anything else, Rice was up against the performance of Sandjai Weaver.
Right off the bat, Weaver had failed to move to decertify the case to juvenile court, even though Rice was a minor who had no prior violent offenses. (Linder was 19, and did not have this option.) On the trial’s first day, Weaver was admonished by Judge Denis Cohen for arriving in court with unlabeled exhibits and no copies for the bench.
Because there was no physical evidence, the prosecution’s case against Rice rested entirely on the testimony of Latrice Johnson, the sole eyewitness to place him at the scene. That she had not identified him when initially asked, on three separate occasions, opened an array of avenues that Weaver could have exploited, but did not.
To begin with, Weaver could have challenged the way the photo arrays were presented during the hospital interview. More crucially, she could have raised significant doubts about Johnson’s ability to see Rice from the stoop where she was sitting—if she’d been familiar with the crime scene. Johnson affirmed on the stand that the sidewalk where the shooters had stood was approximately 20 feet from the stoop, and that her view of the perpetrators in the darkness was aided by a streetlight. In fact, the distance was more than 60 feet. And there was no streetlight at the spot where the shooters were said by the witnesses to be standing; the closest one was across the street. There would have been ambient light from other sources, but the physical distance was a real problem: From the stoop, it’s difficult to make out someone on the corner—a person looks very small—and it would have been harder at night with a hood drawn tight around the person’s face. There were also two cars obstructing the view of the corner from the stoop. The crime-scene diagram created by the police, which was included in the first few pages of the discovery documents, made most of this clear. A few measurements would have filled in the gaps. But Weaver said nothing, so jurors never knew. Left uncorrected, Johnson’s erroneous description of the crime scene was the crime scene.
By contrast, when Raymond Driscoll, Linder’s attorney, cross-examined Latoya Lane—the only eyewitness placing Linder at the scene—he so vigorously challenged the inconsistencies in her testimony that she broke down, collapsing in tears after saying, “When I was in the hospital, when they came, I was on medication, so, like …” The judge had to call a recess, and ultimately stopped the trial for the day.
Although jurors give significant weight to eyewitness identification, experts agree that eyewitness testimony is highly unreliable. More than two-thirds of the Innocence Project’s 375 DNA exonerations involve eyewitness testimony now proved to have been wrong.
At the time of Rice’s trial, defense attorneys in Pennsylvania were legally prohibited from calling experts to testify about the unreliability of eyewitness testimony—a prohibition lifted by the state supreme court only in 2014. Still, a 1954 case in Pennsylvania, Commonwealth v. Kloiber, allowed attorneys to ask a judge to explain the limits of an eyewitness’s identification in situations where a witness did not have an opportunity to clearly view a perpetrator, had struggled to identify him or her, or had a problem making an identification in the past. Given the circumstances—the hood, the darkness, the distance—and the fact that Johnson had failed to identify Rice the first three times she was asked, her testimony could have merited a “Kloiber instruction.” Weaver never requested one.
Instead, she got into a long and meaningless exchange with Johnson, consuming pages of transcript, about where to locate a basketball hoop on a whiteboard diagram. At one point, confused and frustrated, Weaver seemed ready to throw in the towel: “Sorry, Ms. Johnson, I’m not familiar with your area,” she said.
At the defense table, Rice remembers covering his face with one of his hands. Weaver, he now understood, had never visited the street where the shooting took place. And he himself lacked the knowledge to correct her—despite her promise on two occasions, Weaver still hadn’t provided him with the discovery documents. He says he got them only after the trial, and only after Weaver had sent him another client’s discovery by mistake.
My father testified on Rice’s behalf on the penultimate day of the trial. He had testified in other cases, and those experiences had almost always entailed long preparatory conversations with an attorney. This time was different. He’d had a single, brief conversation with Weaver by phone—a call in which she did nothing more than ask him to testify and give him a date. My father met Weaver in person for the first time in the hallway outside the courtroom. He says she gave him no instructions.
On the stand, my father articulated what he would repeat to me a decade later. From the transcript: “The amount of pain that I saw him with and the inability to stand and get onto and off the table in my office on the 20th of September makes me very dubious as to whether he could walk standing up straight, let alone run with any degree of speed, five days after I saw him.” But Weaver did not present Rice’s condition in all its dimensions—his hospital illness, his weakened muscular state. She did not explore what the stress of exertion might have done to a stapled wound if Rice had in fact started running.
And she missed something else. My father was there to testify specifically about the doctor’s-office encounter. But Weaver seems never to have obtained or reviewed Rice’s full hospital records. She certainly never introduced any such records in court. And she never called any other medical expert to testify. Had an expert witness been able to review the relevant records from the hospital—all 300 pages—he or she would have learned that Rice was dealing not only with the incision in his abdomen but also with that fractured pelvis. My father discovered references to the fractures only later, when he obtained the records on Rice’s behalf and read them for himself. The information was never introduced at the original trial, though it was certainly germane. It is impossible to say, at a remove of more than a decade, what effect these unhealed fractures would have had on the mobility of a specific individual, or how painful running might have been. Rice did tell me that, although he has learned to compensate, one of his legs is today shorter than the other.
Because Weaver had not made time to talk with my father before the trial, she was also unaware of information that might have been used to blunt a line of questioning by the prosecution. Weaver had no knowledge of my father’s conversation with Rice about painkillers, and Rice’s unwillingness to take them or to refill his prescription. So she was helpless when Eric Stryd began his cross-examination. “You find it extremely unlikely that he could actually run down the street?” the prosecutor asked. My father answered affirmatively. “Your conclusion is because of the amount of pain he would have been in?” the prosecutor went on. My father again answered affirmatively. “But you don’t know how many Percocets he may have taken on the 24th, 25th, or 26th?” Stryd asked. My father could only state the truth: “I have no way of knowing.” My father was certain that Rice had not been taking painkillers—hence the distress he saw in the examination room. But he could not say that something was completely impossible if it were not truly so. Reading the trial transcript, I realized that Weaver’s lack of knowledge and preparation had made my father’s testimony essentially a wash.
Weaver’s next witness was Deania Duncan, whose testimony was intended to support Rice’s alibi. Duncan’s son Quadifi had testified earlier in the trial that he had been at home with Rice and his grandfather all day, but his testimony had been turned against Rice. Stryd asked Quadifi why he hadn’t recorded a witness statement or said anything at all about an alibi until this very moment in court; he was able to present what should have been evidence of Weaver’s negligence—she hadn’t collected any alibi statements, despite having had almost a year and a half to do so—as evidence of Quadifi’s deceit. “Today is the first day that you’re telling anybody other than the lawyer about this?” the prosecutor asked. Quadifi assented. “He’s like your brother; you don’t want to see him get in trouble, do you?” the prosecutor continued. Quadifi assented again. “Judge, I have nothing further,” the prosecutor said.
Calling Duncan to the stand undermined Rice’s case further. In one of their two 15-minute meetings during the 14 months before his trial, Rice says he told Weaver that Duncan herself wasn’t in the house at 9:30 p.m.—the time of the shooting. He gave Weaver her name because Duncan would know everyone who had been in the house throughout the day. Although not an alibi witness herself, she’d be able to connect Weaver with everyone who could be. This distinction seems to have been lost on Weaver. As a result, when Duncan admitted under cross-examination that she hadn’t been in the house at the time of the shooting, she inadvertently left the strong impression that Rice had no alibi at all.
One piece of independently verifiable alibi evidence that could have made a difference was the location data from Rice’s cellphone. Rice had asked Weaver to retrieve the phone data, and she had promised that she would. But Weaver never did seek the data. There is nothing to be done now: After Cricket Wireless was purchased by AT&T in March 2014, records containing Rice’s data were deleted.
Speaking with me recently, Raymond Driscoll, Tyler Linder’s lawyer, recalled watching Weaver make decisions with which he disagreed—not just in terms of how those decisions might affect his own client, but how they hurt hers. Rice, Driscoll said, had what should have been strong arguments in his defense—medical incapacity, a dubious identification, no physical evidence linking him to the crime.
The strong arguments proved unavailing. On February 8, 2013, after two days of deliberation, the jury returned a verdict. Tyler Linder, represented by Driscoll, was acquitted on all counts. C. J. Rice, represented by Weaver, was found guilty on four counts of attempted murder and other associated charges. The judge ultimately banged down the gavel on a sentence of 30 to 60 years and said, “Good luck, Mr. Rice.”
In October 2016, as Rice pursued an appeal, a judge brought Weaver’s bankruptcy case to a conclusion, relieving her of her remaining debts. By then, Rice had found a new lawyer, a Philadelphia attorney named Jason Kadish, who hoped to call Weaver as a witness. After Weaver did not respond to a subpoena to appear at the evidentiary hearing, Kadish sought more information and made contact with Weaver’s daughter. He later explained to the court that Weaver was suffering a medical crisis that left her “both physically and cognitively unavailable for the purposes of today’s hearing” as well as “unavailable to provide competent testimony.” Kadish went on to note that “the prognosis is not good” and that “it does not look as if it will improve.” Weaver died in 2019.
I can remember my father saying from the time I was young, “We have a legal system, Jacob. We don’t have a justice system.” In 1971, when I was 2 years old, Philadelphia magazine ran a story that profiled my father and a number of other physicians working in poor communities in the city. It described a house call my father made, the conditions in which he worked, and the feats of organization required to bring medical care to neighborhoods that otherwise would have had none. “I wanted to work with the people,” the article quoted him as saying. “That’s why I got involved in this whole thing.”
To his patients, my father is a caring and respected physician. He is also complicated, and sometimes angry. His furrowed-brow fury has mostly been aimed from a distance—at politicians, and those who foment violence and racism, and those who display hypocrisy. My brother and I still talk about the way he yelled at the TV when a patronizing George H. W. Bush debated Geraldine Ferraro during the 1984 campaign. Under his tutelage, and at crayon-wielding age, I once drew a political cartoon of the racist Democratic mayor of Philadelphia, Frank Rizzo, consisting of his face and the words bad Rizzo bad Rizzo bad Rizzo.
For my father, C. J. Rice is not a distant cause—it is close to home. My father consults frequently with Jason Kadish, the lawyer who now represents Rice in most matters, and whom Rice’s family has found money to pay. He has marshaled medical evidence to bolster an ongoing commutation petition. He was instrumental in finding a specialist lawyer, Karl Schwartz, to handle Rice’s habeas appeal in federal court and, I suspect, has paid Schwartz himself, though he won’t say. Through my CNN colleague Van Jones, with whom I connected him, he has also helped to interest Erin Haney of the Reform Alliance in Rice’s case. Reform is a group dedicated to changing probation and parole systems around the country.
And, of course, my father and Rice write to each other. My father’s letters to Rice cover many topics. He recounts conversations he has had with Kadish. He discusses the appeals process and the efforts of Philadelphia’s district attorney, Larry Krasner, elected in 2017, to seek relief for people in circumstances similar to Rice’s. He recommends books, such as the lawyer and activist Bryan Stevenson’s memoir, Just Mercy. He brings up the Philadelphia 76ers, a subject that arouses passionate hometown feelings.
Rice told me in a recent call that as a 17-year-old, he had long hair and couldn’t grow a beard. “Now I’m going bald in the middle, and I’ve got all this facial hair.” In 2011, he was not yet 6 feet tall and weighed 160 pounds. In prison, he says he has grown a few inches and gained 70 pounds of muscle from lifting weights. Deania Duncan’s daughter Promise was a month old when Rice was arrested; he could hold her in the cup of his hands. These days, she merges phone lines for him when he calls on the weekend.
Rice earned his high-school degree while he was detained and awaiting trial; once he was sentenced, he was able to get a tutoring job, helping other inmates earn their GED. At Coal Township, he has become the experienced inmate, the jailhouse mentor who advises new detainees to get a copy of their discovery as soon as possible. He likes to read, usually nonfiction, often books about business or self-improvement. Sometimes he’ll wash his clothes by hand in the sink, just to occupy himself for 45 minutes—anything to pass the time.
Rice says that he has written Latrice Johnson at least 70 letters. In them, he has explained that he doesn’t hold her testimony against her, that he isn’t bitter. He has urged her to contact his lawyer, in the hope that something might be done on his behalf. He has never received a reply, but the letters haven’t been sent back with a return to sender label, so he believes she has been receiving them. My own luck with Johnson was no better than Rice’s. “I don’t want to relive it,” she said when I called her. “I don’t want to discuss it.” She ended the conversation. One morning in August, I stopped by her parents’ house on South 18th, looking for Johnson or anyone else who might remember the night of the shooting. The door was eventually opened by a woman who knew Johnson and may have been her mother, but who would not identify herself and whose response to every question was simply “Goodbye, sir.” A message left at another house eventually produced a return call from Johnson. “I’m the person you’re going to all of these houses looking for,” she said. “I don’t have any information for you.” She asked not to be contacted again.
Fighting to have your case overturned from a prison cell is nearly impossible. The arguments in Rice’s favor remain as strong as ever, but the nature of the case against him is an obstacle: It’s hard to call evidence into question when there was virtually no evidence to begin with. DNA wasn’t a factor. Impropriety by the police didn’t play a role.
The passage of time can have a flattening effect—perspective can get lost and key facts forgotten. Murray Cohen, the surgeon who operated on Rice, never testified at the original trial. During Rice’s appeal, in 2019, he was called to testify for the commonwealth, and against Rice. Cohen had not evaluated Rice’s condition, weeks after the operation, as my father had; after the hospital stay, Cohen and Rice came face-to-face again only in court during that appeal, seven years later. Cohen did not believe that running would have made staples or sutures come loose—“not my staples and not my suture.” He described the surgery and what he thought would be Rice’s condition on the day of the shooting: “It was a laparotomy with no internal injury,” Cohen stated, meaning that the bullet had not damaged the intestines. “He was 21, 22 days post-op. I didn’t observe the patient that day, but a typical 17-year-old would be able to run.” But Rice was not a typical 17-year-old; among other things, a bullet had fractured his pelvis. According to the Hospital for Special Surgery, patients with a fractured pelvis may require six to 12 weeks for full restoration of function. (Cohen could not be reached for comment.)
What of the argument that Rice was represented by ineffective counsel? It’s a powerful one, at least in the eyes of an ordinary person looking at the facts. That doesn’t mean it carries any weight in a legal system set up in so many ways to protect itself.
The Sixth Amendment guarantees defendants the right to counsel. In a 1984 case, Strickland v. Washington, the U.S. Supreme Court took up the question of just how bad lawyers need to be before their performance proves constitutionally defective. Writing for the majority, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor established a two-part test: A lawyer’s performance falls short of the Sixth Amendment’s right to counsel if (a) it is deficient and (b) that deficiency prejudices the defense, depriving the defendant of a fair trial. The opinion went on to define a deficient counsel as one who “made errors so serious that counsel was not functioning as the ‘counsel’ guaranteed the defendant by the Sixth Amendment”—a definition that is not only vague but circular. The inadequacy of the standard has allowed a patchwork of different rules to proliferate across the country. A lawyer can sleep during part of a client’s cross-examination, or be arrested for drunk driving on the way to court, or be mentally unstable, or have been disbarred midway through a trial without sinking to the level of constitutionally defective performance—all of these instances have been adjudicated in various jurisdictions. This spring, the Supreme Court further restricted the right to claim ineffective counsel as the basis for an appeal. Justice Sonia Sotomayor, writing in dissent, declared that the decision “reduces to rubble” a defendant’s Sixth Amendment guarantee. Most of the largest counties across the country have a system like Philadelphia’s, where court-appointed attorneys such as Sandjai Weaver are among the only options for defendants like C. J. Rice.
Justice Thurgood Marshall, the sole dissenter in the Strickland case, faulted the ruling for a “debilitating ambiguity” that compelled judges to rely on “intuitions” about what constitutes ineffective counsel. Under Pennsylvania’s Post Conviction Relief Act, the person whose intuition matters is the original trial judge—this is the person who first considers an appeal. When the matter came before him, Denis Cohen, the judge who had wished Rice good luck, found that Weaver was not deficient counsel. (Through a spokesperson for the Philadelphia courts, Cohen declined to comment, referring to his opinions in Rice’s case.) Rice appealed Cohen’s judgment to the Pennsylvania Superior Court. He was again disappointed: The Superior Court affirmed Cohen’s ruling. Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court would not take up the case.
For a while, Rice and his allies had looked hopefully to the creation of a much-publicized Conviction Integrity Unit—one of Larry Krasner’s first acts as D.A. The job of the CIU is to review past cases, looking for those in which convictions were unwarranted or sentences were too harsh. In 2021, the CIU issued a report that made reference to “a vicious system that lacked transparency and accountability” and highlighted the unit’s successes. But success in this context has meant the exoneration of only 25 individuals out of more than 800 reviewed cases as of August 2022. As fears about crime heighten in cities across the country, efforts such as the CIU face ferocious opposition from police associations, and from some courts and politicians. D.A.s find themselves treading carefully, mindful of cautionary examples like that of Chesa Boudin, the San Francisco prosecutor who was turned out of office in June. Virtually all of the CIU’s exonerations have involved open-and-shut cases of police or prosecutorial misconduct—that’s the threshold that needs to be met. The greater damage done by the “vicious system” functioning as usual will apparently not get a second look.
When I began reporting this story, in 2020, the Conviction Integrity Unit had some 1,400 cases pending review. In April, the D.A.’s office told me that Rice’s case was no longer being considered. In an emailed statement, a spokesperson said that the CIU had decided that there was an “insufficient legal and factual basis to warrant the Commonwealth intervening to vacate his conviction.” The spokesperson emphasized that the decision was “not confirmation that his conviction was sound.”
Rice’s remaining options are few. Barring some new development, he will have to serve at least 20 and as many as 50 more years in prison. A federal habeas petition will soon be filed, but the record in cases like this one is not grounds for optimism. A petition to the state Board of Pardons is being prepared on Rice’s behalf. A commutation or pardon is in the hands of the board’s five members. They include the lieutenant governor, John Fetterman, a candidate for the Senate this year, and the attorney general, Josh Shapiro, a candidate for governor.
In September 2011, the month C. J. Rice was arrested, the state legislature of Pennsylvania released its “Report of the Advisory Committee on Wrongful Convictions.” The 316-page document ticked off many failures, including lack of state funding for the defense of people without means—Pennsylvania provides none to public defenders at all—as well as the unreliability of eyewitness testimony and suspect lineups. It offered a long list of recommendations, almost none of which have been adopted.
The reality is that Commonwealth v. Charles J. Rice represents nothing out of the ordinary. The Conviction Integrity Unit’s caseload captures the situation in a single city, but the same reality exists everywhere. Reforms, even if enacted, would scarcely touch the deeper dysfunction—not just of the criminal-justice system but of neighborhoods and schools. In too many cases, “reform” simply allows dysfunction to remain functional. Rice’s story has produced no bumper stickers or T-shirts or movies. There is no corrupt cop or evil prosecutor. There is only doubtful evidence, deficient counsel, and the relentless grind of the criminal-justice system itself. Rice’s story is meaningful precisely because it is not unusual. Change the details, and it is the story of tens of thousands of poor defendants and the accumulation of large and small injustices that define their lives.
The only unusual thing about Rice’s story is the quirk of fate—his doctor is the father of a journalist—that has gained it any attention at all. To examine his case is to watch a conveyor belt leading in a single direction, with escape routes slamming shut the moment each is glimpsed: a public defender rather than a court-appointed attorney; a routine check of cellphone data; a timely notice of alibi; the right questions put to a dubious eyewitness; a Kloiber instruction by the judge; a request for hospital records; the testimony of an independent medical expert; a defense counsel familiar with the crime scene; a Sixth Amendment that is taken seriously.
Let me state the obvious, in personal terms: With evidence as meager as that against Rice, no prosecutor in the country would even have charged me, a white man with resources. If it had—and if I’d had legal representation worthy of the name—no jury would have brought a conviction.
Andrew Aoyama contributed reporting. This article appears in the November 2022 print edition with the headline “‘Good Luck, Mr. Rice.’”

source

The Supreme Court meets Andy Warhol, Prince and a case that could threaten creativity – Iowa Public Radio

You know all those famous Andy Warhol silk screen prints of Marilyn Monroe and Liz Taylor and lots of other glitterati? Now one of the most famous of these, the Prince series, is at the heart of a case the Supreme Court will examine on Wednesday. And it is a case of enormous importance to all manner of artists.
On one side of the dispute is Lynn Goldsmith, famous for photographing rock stars and whose work is on more than 100 album covers. In 1981 Goldsmith was commissioned to shoot a series of photos of Prince for Newsweek. At the time the Purple Rain rock star was just starting to take off. Goldsmith photographed him in concert and invited him to her studio where she gave him purple eyeshadow and lip gloss to accentuate his sensuality and his androgyny. She even set her photography umbrellas to create pinpricks of light in his eyes. The result was an image that she would later say was a portrait of vulnerability. Newsweek didn’t use the studio photo, opting instead to use the concert photo, and Goldsmith kept the other photos in her files for future publication or licensing.
Three years later Prince was a superstar, and Vanity Fair magazine commissioned Andy Warhol to make an illustration of Prince for an article it was running. In commissioning the work, the magazine asked Warhol to use as a reference point one of Goldsmith’s black-and-white photos. The magazine paid Goldsmith $400 in licensing fees and promised in writing to use the image only in this one Vanity Fair issue.
There is no evidence in the record that Warhol knew about the licensing agreement. But in any event, he went beyond it and created a set of 16 Prince silkscreens, which he copyrighted, and one of which Vanity Fair used for the article. The silkscreen images have since been sold and reproduced to the tune of hundreds of millions of dollars in profits for the Andy Warhol Foundation, a nonprofit that was set up after Warhol’s death to promote his work and the visual arts.
After Prince died in 2016, Vanity Fair‘s parent company, Conde Nast, expedited a tribute, “The Genius of Prince,” featuring many Prince photographs, and it paid the Warhol foundation $10,250 to run “Orange Prince” on its cover. Goldsmith received no payment or credit this time, and she eventually sued the foundation, claiming that Warhol had infringed her copyright, and that the foundation owes her potentially millions of dollars in unpaid licensing fees and royalties.
The foundation countered that Warhol not only copyrighted his iconic Prince series, but that his treatment was, in legal terms, “transformative” because his artistic rendering is very different from Goldsmith’s original photo. The foundation asserted that in Warhol’s version, not only did Warhol crop the image to remove Prince’s torso, but he resized the image, altered the angle of Prince’s face, and changed the tones, lighting and detail, in addition to adding layers of bright and unnatural colors, conspicuous, hand-drawn outlines and line screens and stark back shading that exaggerated Prince’s features.
The result, according to the foundation, is “a flat, impersonal, disembodied, masklike appearance” that is no longer vulnerable but iconic. Essentially, the foundation is arguing that Warhol used a black-and-white photograph as a building block, in much the way that a collage artist might use slices of different photos in a larger work.
As you might imagine, each side has its experts, and indeed two lower courts disagreed on the matter. A federal district court judge found that the Warhol series is “transformative” because it conveys a different message from the original, and thus is “fair use” under the Copyright Act. But a three-judge panel of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed, declaring that judges “should not assume the role of art critic and seek to ascertain … the meaning of the works at issue.” If the Supreme Court agrees, the Warhol Foundation will have to pay royalties or licensing fees, and potentially other damages to the original creator, Goldsmith.
However the Supreme Court rules, its decision will have rippling practical consequences. So it is no surprise that some three dozen friend of the court briefs have been filed arguing on one side or the other, and representing everyone from the American Association of publishers and the Motion Picture Association of America to the Library Futures Institute, the Digital Media Licensing Association, Dr. Seuss Enterprises, the Recording Industry Association of America and even the union that represents NPR’s reporters, editors and producers, the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists.
The outcome could shift the law to favor more control by the original artist, but doing that could also inhibit artists and other content creators who build on existing work in everything from music and posters to AI creations and documentaries.
Copyright 2022 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

source

Death on the Border: Were Twin Brothers Hunting Migrants or Wildlife? – The New York Times

When two migrants were shot on a roadside in West Texas, the police arrested two suspects: The warden of a troubled private prison, and his brother, a local jail employee.
Credit…Ivan Pierre Aguirre for The New York Times
Supported by
Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.
James Dobbins, J. David Goodman and
SIERRA BLANCA, Texas — Jesús Iván Sepúlveda Martínez started his fateful journey to find work in the United States in his father’s car before catching a bus from Ceballos, Mexico, to the border. The 22-year-old soon slipped into Texas and, with a group of about a dozen migrants, began traversing the parched landscape east of El Paso on foot.
Three days after Mr. Sepúlveda texted his father that he had made it across the border, the group stopped for water at a small pond along a rural road. Around sunset, two men in a pickup truck drove by, and the migrants took cover in the brush. Suddenly the truck stopped, backed up and stopped again.
One of the men emerged with a gun and opened fire, fatally striking Mr. Sepúlveda, wounding a young Mexican woman and making the southern border region around Sierra Blanca a new focal point in the nation’s increasingly contentious immigration debate.
What inflamed the already combustible situation was that the men charged with the shooting were familiar local fixtures: Michael Sheppard, the warden of a deeply troubled private prison in town who works closely with the sheriff, and his twin brother Mark Sheppard, an employee at the county jail that the sheriff runs.
The Sept. 27 killing drew broad condemnation, raising questions about the rule of law in the cactus-studded high plains of West Texas and the real-world impacts of a bitter political divide over how to handle a record number of unauthorized crossings at the southern border.
During the recent debate in the race for governor, the Democratic candidate, Beto O’Rourke, said the killing could be traced to Gov. Greg Abbott’s “hateful rhetoric” on immigration. In a news conference last week, Mr. Abbott called the shooting “horrific” and “completely wrong” but blamed President Biden for the spike in arrivals and the need for Texas to deploy National Guard troops to the border and bus thousands of migrants to northern cities.
Days after the killing, yellow plastic evidence numbers still marked the dust near the man-made pond where Mark Sheppard told investigators that he and his brother mistook the men and women hiding in the brush for animals before opening fire.
“At this point, I don’t know what to think. They are good guys. They spend a lot of time outdoors. Mike loves to hunt,” the Hudspeth County sheriff, Arvin West, said in an interview at his office, where he displayed an autographed portrait of former president Donald J. Trump.
“I’ve never gone hunting with them. I don’t hunt animals. I hunt man,” he added in a grinning reference to the nature of his job in law enforcement.
The Sheppard brothers, both 60, were taken into custody late last month, and charged with manslaughter. The killing is being investigated by the Texas Rangers along with agents from the F.B.I.
In his interviews with investigators, Mark Sheppard said he and his brother had been out looking to shoot animals and thought they had spotted some javelinas, similar to wild hogs. Michael Sheppard fired two shots with a shotgun, according to the affidavits.
“Did you get him?” Mark Sheppard recalled asking his brother, in his statements to investigators, before changing the word “him” to “it,” according to the affidavit. They said they did not go to see if they had in fact hit a target.
But the migrants told investigators that the two men had taunted them in Spanish as they were hiding. They said the men used profanity as they shouted at them to come out and opened fire when they emerged.
Mr. Sepúlveda suffered a fatal gunshot to the head. Ms. Casias, 31, was shot in the stomach and, though seriously wounded, was expected to survive.
For days, relatives of the two migrants have been holding a vigil across the Mexican border in Ciudad Juárez, pleading for a full account of what transpired.
Napoleón Sepúlveda Moreno, 56, mourned the death of his son, who he said had hoped to meet up with his brother in Austin, stay a couple of years to make money to support his two young children and then return to Mexico.
“He always talked about going to work in Texas. And so I gave him my blessings,” Mr. Sepúlveda said in a telephone interview. Before leaving for the United States, his son received a small salary caring for farm animals and growing melons in their home of San Martín, several hours south of the border. “My son did not deserve to die this way,” he said.
Ms. Casias is from San José de Bellavista, a small town an hour and a half from San Martín. She met Mr. Sepúlveda on her journey.
Her aunt, Silvia Carrillo, shared an audio recording of a conversation she said she had with Ms. Casias shortly after she was shot. “I’m dying, really. They shot me,” Ms. Casias can be heard saying, then adding, “They are OK. It’s just me and another guy. They shot us. The guy died. And I think I’m next.”
Her aunt replied: “Where are you? Call 911 and the border agents will find you.”
“Please don’t tell Mom. I’ll see how I get out of this one,” Ms. Casias said.
The shooting stunned residents of Sierra Blanca and focused renewed attention on the West Texas Detention Center, a county-owned facility run by a private company, LaSalle Corrections, where Michael Sheppard worked as the warden. A spokesman for the company, which operates more than a dozen detention facilities across Texas, Louisiana and Georgia, said Mr. Sheppard had been fired after his arrest.
The West Texas facility has had a reputation among some within the company as a difficult assignment in part because of its struggles to provide sufficient water supplies for its hundreds of inmates. “That is a hellhole place,” said Gregory Johnson, a former assistant warden at a different LaSalle prison in Texas, describing the West Texas Detention Center. “They always have problems with the water at the facility.”
During Mr. Sheppard’s time as warden there, the facility had a contract with the federal government to house hundreds of detainees for the federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency.
In 2018, some of those detainees complained of abusive treatment including assaults and racial insults, according to a report by researchers from Texas A&M University School of Law, the University of Texas School of Law and Raices, a nonprofit focused on immigrant legal services. The detainees, mostly men from Somalia who were in the process of being deported, told the researchers that they had been mistreated by staff members, including the warden. One detainee accused the warden, who was Mr. Sheppard at the time, of hitting and kicking him; another said he had used racial insults.
A subsequent investigation by the Office of the Inspector General for the federal Department of Homeland Security could not substantiate the detainees’ claims.
“I think there’s often a credibility bias toward law enforcement,” said Fatma E. Marouf, one of the report’s authors and a law professor at Texas A&M University. “One of the reasons we filed the report is that it wasn’t just one person complaining. It was dozens of people complaining.”
By 2021, the detention center no longer housed any migrants for federal authorities, according to inspection records. The company spokesman, Scott Sutterfield, said the detention center currently did not have I.C.E. detainees. He did not respond to the allegations in 2018 about mistreatment at the jail, nor did he say whether any action had been taken against Mr. Sheppard as a result of the complaints.
County officials said the I.C.E. contract had been ended because of the water issues, which stemmed from a problem obtaining adequate supply from a nearby town. A spokesman for I.C.E. did not respond to a request for comment. The facility still holds inmates for the U.S. Marshals, county records showed.
Around Sierra Blanca, the detention center was known as a good job, paying more than double what was offered at the local jail. On at least one occasion, Sheriff West filled in as warden at the facility when Mr. Sheppard was out of town, according to the inspector general’s report, and some of those who worked with them described the two men as friends.
“That warden always had a good relationship with that sheriff down there,” said Mr. Johnson, the former LaSalle employee.
Hudspeth County, which sprawls over an area nearly the size of Connecticut, has faced a larger number of migrants trying to cross through the dangerous desert terrain, as the number of people seeking refuge in the United States has climbed sharply over the past few years. “We’ve had a lot of serious problems with the illegals coming across getting lost and dying in the desert,” said Thomas Neely, 95, the Hudspeth County judge.
Joanna Mackenzie, the county administrator and also its emergency manager, said officials found more than 15 bodies of migrants in the desert last year, an increase from two or three a year in previous years. “We’ve gone from you see a few a week to hundreds crossing property — it is like nothing anyone has ever seen,” she said.
On the evening of the killing, both Michael and Mark Sheppard attended a meeting of the local water board. They arrived around 7:30 p.m., roughly 30 minutes after the shooting. Sheriff West was there, too.
“I saw them that same night at the water board, nothing out of the ordinary,” the sheriff said. “We were finishing the meeting when the call came in,” he added, speaking of the 911 call about the killing. “And I didn’t see their demeanor change.”
Word of the shooting spread rapidly through Sierra Blanca, a pit stop for truck traffic along Interstate 10. The sprawling surrounding county, home to some 3,200 people, is more than three-quarters Hispanic. Some people in town have expressed shock, saying the brothers had never displayed any sort of racial animus.
“I have a Mexican-Native American background, but Mike was never ugly to me,” said Paula Barrios, 39, who lived near the two brothers. “Once you get to know them, they are nice people.”
Others recalled interactions that seemed to take on new meaning in the wake of the arrests.
“We were speaking Spanish, and Mark said, ‘Don’t speak Spanish around me,’” said Bill Addington, 65, a longtime resident who volunteered at a local food bank where Mr. Sheppard would supervise county inmates on work detail in striped uniforms. Waitresses in town also remembered Mr. Sheppard objecting to hearing Spanish spoken in his presence while eating.
Michael and Mark Sheppard were transferred from the El Paso County jail, where they had been taken last month, to a jail in Hudspeth County, and then released last week after each posted bond of $250,000, according to the chief deputy sheriff in Hudspeth County, Lasaro Salgado. Neither responded to requests for comment.
They were then rearrested the following day, Deputy Salgado said, after the Texas Rangers issued a warrant on new charges related to the shooting: aggravated assault with a deadly weapon. As of Tuesday, both men were again in custody, this time closer to home at the Hudspeth County jail. The deputy said Mark Sheppard no longer had a job there.
Advertisement

source

You can earn your master's in public health from these 5 Ivy League schools – Fortune

The pandemic arguably accelerated a lot of trends—from a wider prevalence and acceptance of remote work to a greater focus on digital transformation. What the pandemic also did, however, was show a lot of weak spots in our workforce, namely in health care. 
During the past decade, the public health workforce has shrunk by more than 15% to just around 200,000 jobs. That’s led to a massive staffing shortage for public health positions—and meanwhile, these professionals have more work to do than ever.
“It is difficult in the throes of a COVID-19 surge to think about anything other than the acute pandemic response, but rebuilding the public health workforce in parallel is critical to ensuring that health outcomes are on the path to improvement over the longer term,” reads a report by McKinsey & Co.
This rebuilding of the public health workforce will take time and effort, but is worthwhile—both for the greater good and for individuals pursuing this career path. Many public health positions come with lucrative salaries, some of which are well above the six-figure mark. Among the highest-paying public health positions are an environmental health officer ($100,518 per year), biostatistician ($122,602 per year), and medical director ($193,401 per year).
Many of these positions, however, require or highly encourage a master’s degree in the field. Fortune ranks 15 of the best online MPH programs in the U.S., but there are a plethora of other options, including in-person and other types of online programs. We’ve compiled a list of the Ivy League schools where you can earn a master’s degree in public health to jumpstart your career.
Brown University announced the launch of its online master’s degree program in public health in February 2022, and the first cohort started this fall. “To create the public health workforce of the future, we need to create new modes of public health education,” Dr. Megan Ranney, academic dean at the School of Public Health and director of the Brown-Lifespan Center for Digital Health, said in a statement announcing the program.
Length of program: 12 courses to be completed over two-to-three years
Program format: Online, both synchronous (live) and asynchronous
Admission requirements: Transcripts, three recommendation letters, personal statement, resume, TOEFL score (international applicants)
Tuition: $5,000 per course ($60,000 total for 12 courses)
Harvard University offers three different MPH programs: a traditional on-campus MPH program, a hybrid MPH in epidemiology, and an online MPH generalist degree. These three programs have different curricula aligned with public health careers. 
The MPH in epidemiology is one-third in-person and two-thirds online, and is completed on a part-time basis. The MPH generalist track is completely online and is also part-time, and takes two years to complete. The traditional MPH program is also highly specialized and students select a field of study—like epidemiology or health management—that they’d like to pursue.
Length of program: Depending on the progarm you pursue, it will take one-to-two years to complete
Application requirements: For all three programs, you must submit a statement of purpose, three recommendation letters, a resume, and transcripts. Test scores aren’t required.
Tuition: Part-time tuition per year is $33,480
Yale University offers a hybrid executive master’s of public health program, which is taught by faculty from the Yale School of Public Health and the Yale School of Medicine. The program is suited for professionals who want leadership training in public health. There are four tracks for students to pursue: Health Informatics, Environmental Health Sciences, Applied Analytic Methods and Epidemiology, and Critical Topics in Public Health. It’s a part-time program that’s suitable for full-time working professionals.
Yale also offers a traditional two-year, in-person MPH program, and students choose one of six departments in which to study: biostatistics, chronic disease epidemiology, environmental health sciences, epidemiology of microbial diseases, healthcare management, health policy, and social and behavioral sciences.
Length of program: Two years
Program format: Mostly online courses with “on-site intensives” at Yale
Application requirements: Transcripts, three letters of recommendation, a statement of purpose, and a resume. The GRE requirement is waived this year.
Tuition: $37,695 per year (online executive), $50,261 per year (in-person)
Columbia University offers its master’s in public health degree program both online and in-person, and the curriculums closely resemble each other. Students who pursue the in-person option choose a department in which to study, including: biostatistics, environmental health sciences, epidemiology, health policy and management, population and family health, and sociomedical sciences. The program also includes a “practicum” or an internship in the field.
Columbia also offers an accelerated MPH program, which can be completed in one year, and an executive master’s degree of public health, which is focused on organizational leadership and management, health policy and public health, and health systems.
Length of program: One-to-two years depending on the program
Program format: Online is broken down into modules and is completed fully online
Tuition: $1,882 per credit across programs
The Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice at Dartmouth College offers a hybrid MPH degree program, which is hosted both online and on-campus. The program is focused on public health content including epidemiology, biostatistics, and health care ethics. Students take one course at a time, so the program can be completed on a part-time basis. Students also complete a practicum, which is a combination of a thesis and an internship.
Length of program: 22 months
Program format: Students take one course at a time, which is about 15-20 hours of time commitment per week. Then they spend three weeks at Dartmouth each year to work with other students and faculty on public health curriculum.
Application requirements: Personal statement, two letters of recommendation, resume, transcripts, and GRE score (optional)
Tuition: $38,181 per year
See how the schools you’re considering fared in Fortune’s rankings of the best master’s degree programs in data science (in-person and online), nursing, computer science, cybersecurity, psychology, public health, and business analytics, as well as the doctorate in education programs and MBA programs (part-time, executive, full-time, and online).

source

Migguel Anggelo's newest production, 'English with an Accent,' comes to Lincoln Center – NYSMusic


In “English with an Accent,” Migguel Anggelo looks critically at the concept of The American Dream from a perspective shaped by his intersecting queer, Latino and immigrant identities. The performance, co-commissioned by the Lincoln Center uses original music, dance and theater to tell the story of an immigrant’s arrival in New York City. Migguel Anggelo will lead, joined by a cast of 10 dancers, for a performance coming to the Lincoln Center’s Clark Studio Theater, December 1 through 3. 

English with an Accent


Anggelo is a Venezuelan-American multidisciplinary performing artist. He has been awarded residencies at Mass MoCA, the Kimmel Center, the Miami Light Project and more to develop his works in song, dance, text and costume. 
Music in the show is composed by both Migguel Anggelo and his longtime collaborator and music director Jaime Lozano. Lozano collaborated with Anggelo on other songs on “English with an Accent,” Anggelo’s album of the same name, which will be released December 2, during the production period. “So Ironic” from the upcoming album uses animation and dance paired with spoken word to tackle stereotypes about immigrants in American culture. 
Anggelo said “English with an Accent” is especially meaningful to him now that he has become a naturalized U.S. citizen after 16 years. His naturalization reframes the piece’s themes of safety and home in a country.
Watch a trailer for the performance below; tickets are available at the Lincoln Center’s site.

Syracuse Newhouse journalism major (2023) from Washington, DC. Lover of Upstate NY, Lou Reed, print journalism, nouvelle vague films and long walks on the beach. In addition to interning on the NYS Music news and features desk, I am resident art critic at the Daily Orange. I’m obsessed with music across all genres, from John Coltrane to Fugazi to Yung Lean. Thanks for reading.
Prev Post

Next Post

The Coronas Return to Live Music With New Album and US Tour
Common to Make Broadway Debut in Stephen Adly Guirgis’ “Between Riverside…
Ha*Ash will return to NYC from Mexico City in 2023 Tour
Amina Figarova Sextet brings Elite Jazz Artists to Kleinhans Music Hall on November…
Comments are closed.

The Coronas Return to Live Music With New Album and US Tour

Dante Mazzetti’s Music, an Inferno from a Balcony

In Focus:  Jocelyn and Chris Rock SGNL Launch Party At King…

source

Sussex music charity partners with Crawley film project to provide a 'studio space' to create music – SussexWorld

Subscribe
Fly-tippers dump tonne of rubbish near major Horsham road junction
'Huge sadness' as Bognor Regis pub closes
Non-profit music organisation AudioActive has a new studio space in Crawley thanks to an exciting partnership with Crawley Film Initiative (CFI). The new music production Mac suite is welcoming young people from Crawley and the surrounding areas, located at CFI’s hub in Crawley Museum.
Not only is the suite equipped with the latest music technology, but those “who attend free workshops will also be able to use film editing software”, a spokesman from AudioActive said.
The space will provisionally host music sessions led by AudioActive’s professional artists for six months, following on from their previous pop-up space in Crawley.
Advertisement
The music charity launched an innovative hub for their work in the ex-Dorothy Perkins store on Worthing’s high street, AudioActive plans to establish a similar facility in Crawley town centre and is on the lookout for suitable premises.
In keeping with the charity’s Worthing hub, the space would include a music venue, community studio, project spaces and affordable studio space for professional artists.
AudioActive projects running in Crawley from September 12 include; SESSIONS (Lyrics, Rapping, Singing and Production), Equaliser (Music Production workshop exclusively for young women), Room to Rant (lyric-writing and wellbeing workshop for young men) and vocalise (lyric-writing and wellbeing workshop for young women).
These projects follow on from a summer of delivery in the town that led to young artists performing at HMV Crawley, and on an AudioActive stage at Tilgate Park in collaboration with Creative Crawley.
Advertisement
Did you know with a Digital Subscription to SussexWorld, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more.
Subscribe
Did you know with a Digital Subscription to SussexWorld, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more.

source

Rolex sets sail (literally) with its new gold Yacht-Master 42 watch – New York Post

Thanks for contacting us. We've received your submission.
While Rolex has been synonymous with the world of sailing for 60 years, the brand’s ever-popular Oyster Perpetual Yacht-Master was introduced just 30 years ago, designed especially for navigators, skippers and others who might revel in regattas.
But the classic waterproof design clearly appealed to a wider audience, most notably on shore. Accordingly, it’s evolved and innovated over the years to accommodate the needs of its growing fan base.
The latest iteration makes the Yacht-Master 42 mm available for the first time in 18-karat yellow gold. It retains many features of the original, including a bidirectional rotatable bezel and Chromalight display.
It’s also equipped with Calibre 3235, a movement the company introduced seven years ago in Rolex’s then-new Datejust Pearlmaster 39, protected with 14 patents.
It’s been fitted on the Yacht-Master 42 since 2019, and watch aficionados nerd out on many technical aspects of this movement, but for mere mortals the headline is: Power reserve of about 70 hours.
No doubt this new design will be spotted on many wrists on and offshore during several Rolex-sponsored yachting events this year, which draw sporty jet-setters who like to personally witness the action on the high seas.
The Rolex Middle Sea Race takes place Oct. 22 to 29 in Valletta, organized by the Royal Malta Yacht Club. It’s considered one of the most scenic and tactically challenging courses in the world: a 606-nautical-mile route that takes racers past the confined Strait of Messina, Stromboli’s active volcano and the buzzy island of Pantelleria (where Giorgio Armani has a home).
Those eyeing a holiday getaway might consider Australia, where the Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race, organized by the Cruising Yacht Club of Australia in collaboration with the Royal Yacht Club of Tasmania, takes place from Dec. 26 to 31.
The 628-nautical-mile race was first held in 1945; it starts in Sydney Harbor and finishes in Hobart, the capital of the island state of Tasmania.
What better way to celebrate the first seemingly “normal” holiday season after several stressful years — and perhaps indulge in a sporty new Yacht-Master 42 as a memento?

source

Liberia: Concession Company CEO Heard of Audio Recording Instructing Employee to Organize Protest against Aggrieved Residents in Bomi – Front Page Africa

Welcome, Login to your account.
Recover your password.
A password will be e-mailed to you.


TUBMANBURG, Bomi County – The CEO of the Mano Palm Oil Plantation, Mr. Assad Fadel has been caught on tape instructing the head of his company’s private security, to mobilize residents of Bomi and Cape Mount to stage a protest against residents in his favor against the residents of the communities where his company operates.
By Francis G. Boayue
The residents of the Project Affected Communities (PAC) have been agitating over the company’s failure to live up to its concession agreement.
In the leaked audio, Mr. Fadel is heard calling for a protest action against the Deputy Coordinator on National Concessions Conflict Resolution at the Ministry of Internal Affairs, Adama Seh, who once served as corporate communication manager for his company to be dismissed for not supporting the company against the citizens.
Mr. Assad Fadel asked Abdulia Navo, head of his company’s security company to rally the people of Madina to go against the project-affected communities (PAC) and Mr. Seh.
Liberia: Govt to Sign 27MW Power Agreement with Ivory Coast…
Liberia: 2023 Elections Delay Likely As Controversial…
Liberia: Liberia Revenue Authority Clears TRH Trading Corp;…
The Mano Oil Plantation CEO said: You need to have an emergency meeting and have a strong demonstration against the project-affected communities and come out on the streets with your people and hold placards calling for the dismissal of Adama Seh and this must go political and be very tough with all your people behind you, and with that, you’ll put everybody now on the alert to go against the project affected communities.”
He further said: “You have to fight back because you just joining the people and you suppose to have your men on the street fighting with placard PAC Must Go”. ‘PAC is Wrong’, and with that, you’ll push the people on the ground and counteract them with the people of Madina who really want the investment because this whole thing is political.”
Meanwhile, the Ministry of Internal Affairs in a dialogue on Tuesday, has called for calm in providing remedies and ensuring peace and stability is restored at the Mano Palm Oil Plantation amongst workers, residents of the Project Affected Community and the Mano Management.
Senjeh District Representative Hon. Finda Alice Gborie Lansanah took the lead and stressed the plight of the project Affected Community, and the workers both in Bomi and Grand Cape Mount Counties respectively.
According to Rep. Lansanah, “The Mano Company must live up to its promises as within the Restated and Amended Concession Agreement in providing improvements and social services to the workers and the affected communities in and around the concessionaries areas in line with its responsibilities”.
Highlighting issues, among others, the Senjeh District Astute Representative outlined the need for the worker’s children attending the Mano Central High School to receive both national and international scholarships at any university level and that workers working with the company must be accorded all benefits and opportunities that will improve their conditionalities.
Since taking over from Sime Darby, Mano Palm Oil Plantation has often been accused of bad labor practices and its failure to live up to the terms of its concession agreement. The company has, however, contended that it has a very good relationship with its employees and the communities where it operates.
Prev Post

Next Post

Liberia: Govt to Sign 27MW Power Agreement with Ivory Coast in TRANSCO CLSG Deal
Liberia: 2023 Elections Delay Likely As Controversial Chinese Company, Ekemp Int’l…
Liberia: Liberia Revenue Authority Clears TRH Trading Corp; Says It’s Not Under…
Liberia: Kamara Defense Challenges Prosecution Of 30-Year-old Crimes; French Reveal a…
Liberia: Govt to Sign 27MW Power Agreement with Ivory Coast…
Liberia: 2023 Elections Delay Likely As Controversial…
Liberia: Liberia Revenue Authority Clears TRH Trading Corp;…
Welcome, Login to your account.
Recover your password.
A password will be e-mailed to you.

source

City hosts Lake Springfield master plan meeting October 12 – KY3

SPRINGFIELD, Mo. (KY3) -Just a few months ago thousands of people came to watch the iconic smokestacks come down. Now city leaders are wanting to meet with residents to discuss what comes next.
Crawford, Murphy and Tilly was selected to assist the city with this master planning process. This is the first of many opportunities for various segments of the community to learn more and provide input.
“Increasing economic opportunity in this area is going to be a key focus,” said City Planner Olivia Hough. “So we will be looking at market study retail potential recreation based activities.”
An $800,000 grant from the U.S. Department of Commerce’s Economic Development Administration and $200,000 from the Hatch Foundation will fund the development of a master plan for the Lake Springfield area including the former coal-powered plant (James River Power Station).
“From the $1 million project budget, the vast majority will go towards consultant fees,” said Hough “We’ve assembled a diverse team of consultants who are experts in the various elements of the master plan and transportation and hydrology and waterways studies, the dam study itself the economic study, and so we’ve brought together that team and it will really be collecting the data, their expertise, and then coming up with designing and developing the plan.”
The Plan will include economic and recreational opportunities, new infrastructure, sustainable water quality, and green infrastructure, creating jobs, and improving the quality of life of the workforce and their families.
“It’s exciting that the forward SGF plan identified Lake Springfield as a real opportunity, transformational opportunity for our community and this has this has potential to be a community-changing project for the next hundreds of years,” said Hough
Residents and those owning property near Lake Springfield are invited to an informational meeting from 4:30 – 6:30 p.m. on Oct. 12 at the Springfield Lake Boathouse. Children are welcome.
To report a correction or typo, please email [email protected]
Copyright 2022 KY3. All rights reserved.

source

Five material tissue decomposition by dual energy computed tomography | Scientific Reports – Nature.com

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 17117 (2022)
Metrics details
The separation of mixtures of substances into their individual components plays an important role in many areas of science. In medical imaging, one method is the established analysis using dual-energy computed tomography. However, when analyzing mixtures consisting of more than three individual basis materials, a physical limit is reached that no longer allows this standard analysis. In addition, the X-ray attenuation coefficients of chemically complicated basis materials may not be known and also cannot be determined by other or previous analyses. To address these issues, we developed a novel theoretical approach and algorithm and tested it on samples prepared in the laboratory as well as on ex-vivo medical samples. This method allowed both five-material decomposition and determination or optimization of the X-ray attenuation coefficients of the sample base materials via optimizations of objective functions. After implementation, this new multimodal method was successfully tested on self-mixed samples consisting of the aqueous base solutions iomeprol, eosin Y disodiumsalt, sodium chloride, and pure water. As a first proof of concept of this technique for detailed material decomposition in medicine we analyzed exact percentage composition of ex vivo clots from patients with acute ischemic stroke, using histological analysis as a reference standard.
A clinically well-established method that enables material decomposition in general is dual-energy CT (DE-CT)1. There are several options for DE-CT, such as dual-source CT (DS-CT), rapid kVp-switching, and dual-layer CT (DL-CT), all of which are well-known options in the clinical setting2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9. For this study, a DL-CT scanner system was used, which differs from the other DE-CT options mainly in the type of detector arrangement. Here, the detector consists of two superimposed detector layers, resulting in a better detector response function for low-energy photons in the first layer and for high-energy photons in the second layer10. Thus, DL-CT provides detector-based energy separation with only one primary X-ray spectrum.
(a) Illustration of the basic measurement setup, showing clots stored in tubes filled with formalin after they were extracted from the patient by mechanical thrombectomy and immediately fixated with formalin. (b) For the measurement, two of these tubes can be inserted and measured by the dual-layer CT using a specimen holder. The specimen holder itself was placed on a cardboard tray to prevent the holder from moving during the measurement and to create a slightly inclined plane so that the clots remain at the bottom of the tubes.
In addition, due to the superimposed detector layers, both images are perfectly registered, so no post-processing registration is required. Using the measurement information gathered from the energy responsive detector, the detector response function and the X-ray source spectrum, virtual monoenergetic (monoE) images can then be calculated. Due to the fact that the total attenuation at one specific energy can be expressed as a sum of all individual mass attenuation coefficients multiplied with their densities, solving a linear equation system leads to material decomposition which has already been discussed in the scientific community regarding quantification, accuracy and methodology11,12,13,14. However, a mathematical limit is reached at a decomposition of two different materials by using two virtual monoE images and solving a simple linear equation system of two equations. A third equation at a further different energy would mean linear dependency and thus an infinite number of solutions of the system15,16.
Nevertheless, the determination of more than three materials is possible. For this, in addition to the virtual monoE information, volume conservation must be introduced as an additional condition and at the same time a more complex method is required. To this end, one concept has already been developed separating more than three materials. This method is using a triplet library. To create this library, several material triplets from a unlimited number of basis materials are created and used, with the help of which each voxel with the information of two virtual monoE attenuation coefficients is tried to be split into the respective three materials. Once this is done for each material triplet and voxel, only the correct physical results are then counted for the final solution17. However, this methodology is not suitable for specimens with high intermixing of all basis materials and at the same time contains low concentrations of basis materials. If two measured specimens are investigated, one of which consists only of basis materials A, B and C, and the other of which also contains a low concentration of basis material C on top, the attenuation values of both may still be in the same material triplet for which the material C is not taken into account. Thus, the amount of basis material C cannot be determined. Another generally occurring problem is that the X-ray attenuation coefficients of chemically complicated basis materials may not be known and,furthermore, cannot be determined by other or previous analyses. To solve these problems, we developed an algorithm that uses the information from two virtual monoE images at different energies as well as the data of a further modality, which can determine the percentage distribution of at least three basis materials. This new method then allows both five-material decomposition and can determine or optimize X-ray attenuation coefficients of the specimens’ basis materials via optimizations of objective functions. In addition, the algorithm is able to determine small concentrations of basis materials.
In particular, the newly developed algorithm was first verified with the aid of several test samples mixed in the laboratory and measured on the DE-CT, which consisted of four base materials of different but known concentrations. For this purpose, in addition to the knowledge of the exact composition of the samples, initial situations could be simulated in which components of the solution are not known. The algorithm managed to reliably determine the actual composition based on the simulated samples with incorrect knowledge about the composition and using virtual MonoE images. Based on this successful test of the method, it could now be applied to human ex-vivo clots consisting of red blood cells (RBC), white blood cells (WBC), the conglomerate of fibrin and platelets (fibrin/platelets)18,19, enriched iodine containing contrast agent20 and formalin which cannot be neglected in terms of X-ray attenuation here21. In this particular case, the histological findings provided the baseline information on RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets. Whereas the information about enriched iomeprol and formalin is unknown. After the absorption properties of RBC, WBC, fibrin/platelets, iomeprol and formalin could be investigated and optimized by minimizing a cost function, the algorithm was able to determine the composition of all five basic materials for human clots. This application area is particularly interesting for medical diagnostics since knowledge of the exact composition of the clots originating from patients with acute ischemic stroke (AIS) can have a positive effect on the treatment and extraction of these22. It should be noted that this multimodal method can generally be used for soft tissue samples, biopsies and plaque as well.
(a) Virtual monoE images at 50 keV and (b) 200 keV of the three basis compositions sodium chloride (Na(_0)), iomeprol (I(_0)) and eosin Y disodiumsalt (E(_0)). (c) The linear relationship of each basis material is shown for different concentrations mixed together in aqueous solution. Linear regressions were then created for the linear dependencies, allowing the endpoints of each basis material to be better determined computationally and with greater statistical accuracy. (d) The way of iodine optimization along a characteristic optimization path (red vector) is shown for specimen 2, 4 and 5. The exact results found by the algorithm are shown in Table 1.
With the help of the DE-CT results of the concentration series of eosin Y disodiumsalt, sodium chloride and iomeprol, the ground truth attenuation coefficients could be determined from linear regressions. These resulted in (mu _{Iomeprol}^{50} = 0.433, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{Iomeprol}^{200} = 0.152, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{Eosin}^{50} = 0.290, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{Eosin}^{200} = 0.141, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{NaCl}^{50} = 0.306, 1/{rm cm}) and (mu _{NaCl}^{200} = 0.151, 1/{rm cm}) with higher statistical certainty compared to a single measurement of the basis maximum concentrations, which then would result in (mu _{Iomeprol}^{50} = 0.434, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{Iomeprol}^{200} = 0.152, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{Eosin}^{50} = 0.290, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{Eosin}^{200} = 0.141, 1/{rm cm}), (mu _{NaCl}^{50} = 0.305, 1/{rm cm}) and (mu _{NaCl}^{200} = 0.151, 1/{rm cm}). The virtual monoE images at 50keV and 200keV of all three basis compositions are shown in Fig. 2a,b. The relative deviation from the mean value of the fit parameters were between 0.29% and 1.26% for 50 keV and except for the eosin y disodiumsalt which had a relative error of 8.14%, between 0.46% and 1.65% for 200 keV. The relative errors of the intercept of the linear regression was for all basis materials and energies between 0.10% and 0.18%. To visualize the property of linear dependency, the regressions and the considered single values of the attenuation at 200keV are plotted above the attenuation at 50keV for each measured concentration mixture and basis material Fig.2c. The results of the iomeprol fraction optimization for the testing specimens of aqueous mixtures with all basis materials are shown in Table 1. In addition, it is shown how the algorithm, based on the histological results, is shifted by an individual vector for each specimen towards the base material value of iomeprol until the difference between the shifted value and the CT value is minimal. This is shown for specimen 2, 4 and 5 (Fig.2d). It should be noted that the model was successfully tested on 19 samples for this research project, in addition to the 15 samples used to create the linear regression. Table 1 lists the most important results. The results of all measured samples can be found as Supplementary Table S6 and within the Supplementary Information as Figs. S2 and S3 online.
As an representation of all 73 measured clots, ones DE-CT result is shown for both virtual monoE images in Fig.3a,b. Before optimizing the attenuation coefficients of the basis materials, it has been important to determine a good starting value for each to make the optimization faster. This was successfully achieved with the help of the NIST database and PubChem23,24. The molecular formula and the densities of fibrin, iomeprol and formalin were looked up and by using the NIST database the attenuation coefficients at 50keV and 200keV were calculated. For RBC, the molecular formula could also be determined. But in this case by analyzing the exact composition of its protein structure. Again, the mass attenuation coefficients were determined using the NIST database using the atomic composition and the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) as density. For WBC, soft tissue was assumed and was taken directly from the NIST database. The exact results of these initial values can be found online in the Supplementary Information as Fig. S4, Tables S3, S4 and S5. Based on these initial values, the algorithm found the optima of the correction factors at cost function values of 0.9‰ for sample group one, 1.4‰ for sample group two, and 0.8‰ for sample group three. The correction factors and final weighted attenuation coefficients are listed in Table2.
Using the attenuation properties of RBC, WBC, and fibrin/platelets, the algorithm for the decomposition of five materials was applied to additional clots, resulting in the iomeprol concentration and the error between the optimized point and the measured point. These results are listed in Tables 3 and 4. Furthermore, the optimization and the matching between optimized and measured point is visualized in Fig. 3. To highlight the correction caused by the iomeprol content a section of the particularly interesting area is shown (Fig. 4). Results of all individual 61 clots can be found as Supplementary Table S7 online.
(a) Virtual monoE images of one measured clot at 50keV and (b) 200keV. (c) Illustration of the iomeprol as well as formalin correction using scatter plots and (d) magnification to the area visually representing the error between the optimized point and the value measured on the DE-CT. Using the basis material attenuation of fibrin/platelets, RBC, and WBC as well as the results of the histological analysis, a histological result is plotted in the scatter plot for each specimen. Starting from this point, the algorithm corrects the histological result point by the iomeprol and formalin concentrations along the vectors characteristic for each specimen (optimization paths). The algorithm then reaches its optimum as soon as the distance between the optimized point and the measured specimen point is minimal. The triangle boarder line indicates the enclosed area within which a specimen consisting exclusively of the three base materials can lie.
Illustration of the section from Fig.3c showing the iompeprol correction calculated by the algorithm. The length of the optimization paths directly correlate to the iompeprol concentration.
Five different materials have been separated and quantified from each individual clot in this study, based on the information of DE-CT combined with histological analysis. It should be mentioned that other imaging devices, such as a micro-CT, have much better resolution than a DE-CT used in the clinic. However, such devices are mainly used only on ex vivo specimens and have a much smaller field of view (FOV), which makes it impossible to scan patients as well. Although the samples on which the theory and applicability were tested are suitable in size for micro-CT, the aim of this research project is to demonstrate the in vivo applicability of this new method on the clinically established DE-CT. The in-house developed optimization algorithm showed a high accuracy for the iomeprol correction of the self-mixed specimens consisting of the water based basis materials namely iomeprol, eosin Y disodiumsalt, sodium chloride and pure water. The fact that the linear regression (Fig.2c) finds its optimum at low error of all fit parameters shows that the linearity of the systems of equations can be assumed. In addition, the fact that all linear regressions intersect well in one point and that this intersection point simultaneously corresponds with high accuracy to the theoretical comparison value of water shows that a systematic error can be excluded. This accuracy is very dependent of the iomeprol concentration. The specimen containing a iomeprol concentration of (1.66 , {rm mg/ml}) was optimized to a concentration of (1.72 , {rm mg/ml}) which means a relative error of (3.61%). By contrast, for a concentration of (0.660 , {rm mg/ml}) the algorithm terminates at a value of (0.160 , {rm mg/ml}) that means a relative error of (75.8%). These results substantiate the developed and implemented theory and show that the algorithm can result in high accuracy. In contrast, it shows that not every concentration is optimized with the same accuracy. In general this concentration dependency of the accuracy of the algorithm makes it difficult to decide which results are trustful and which are not. But now after testing the model with known concentrations and volume fractions of each specimen, it turned out that every concentration below (0.660 , {rm mg/ml}) cannot be measured precisly. It is worth noting that this concentration boarder coincide with results of other previous studies that showed a boarder between 1.0 and 0.8 (, {rm mg/ml})25. What has also been confirmed is the initial assumption that the triplet library method does not seem suitable for use on well-mixed samples with low iomeprol concentrations. It can be seen, especially for Specimen 5 in Fig.2d, that although there is iomeprol in the sample, the point is only shifted within the base-material triangle, which does not include iomeprol. The triplet library method would therefore not detect iomeprol even though it is present in the sample. The triplet-library method works well for mixtures of materials that have a cluster and are not strongly mixed. Now we know that clots in high resolution histological images show a cluster of the three main basic materials RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets. Therefore, it can be assumed that the triplet library method should theoretically work. Due to the voxel size (0.41 mm × 0.41 mm × 0.8 mm) of this DE-CT measurement and the small size of the clots, the segmented clots appear intermixed. In addition, the typical iomeprol concentrations are very small. Thus, it is still reasonable that this method cannot work for clots. All this shows that the newly developed method of this study is of great importance for the field of material decomposition on clots.
The error of the specimens containing an iomeprol concentration of above (0.660, {rm mg/ml}) can have a few origins. The sum of all typical errors occurring by mixing different concentrations can be seen in Fig.2. Since all concentrations of iomeprol, eosin Y disodiumsalt and sodium chloride are water based, the linear regressions should in theory cross the basis point of pure water exactly. What can be seen here is that the regressions crosses pure water slightly behind. Reasons can be the neglected volume excess that always occurs at mixing different media volumes26, error of the balance and volume change due to temperature27 change between the lab (293.15K) the specimens where mixed and the room temperature at the DE-CT setup. Since both the specimens used as basis material mixtures and the specimens with different basis substances and concentrations were prepared in the laboratory at the same time and were not separated from then on, the error should be small. It should be mentioned that due to the absorption of photons, characteristic radiation is also emitted by the samples themselves. However, this phenomenon is negligible here, since this form of secondary radiation occurs over the entire solid angle and most of the radiation that would hit the detector is absorbed by the anti-scatter grid in front of the detector. Moreover, considering the transition energies of all base materials of the measured clots and test mixtures, the energetic bandwidth reaches from below 1 keV to a maximum of 28 keV, which was calculated using the NIST database of transitions28. The highest transition energy is due to the iodine-containing contrast medium. Measurements showed that even the fluorescence of iodine samples in aqueous solution contributes only a small peak with a maximum of 20 counts on an energy bandwidth of about 27keV – 32keV and is very low compared to the Compton scattering of water29. Considering these points, it can therefore be assumed that the characteristic radiation of the samples does not significantly distort the measurement results. In summary, despite small and almost unavoidable sources of error, the accuracy of the theory and the implemented algorithm are of high quality and thus an application to human clots is justified and promising. Concerning the previously presented testing of the method, it is important to note that for the basis materials chosen for this purpose, whose K-edges are partly within the measured X-ray spectrum, theoretically further equations with spectral information at further monoenergetic energies would allow a material decomposition beyond the three materials by simply solving the linear system of equations. However, the outlook of this work is on the applicability to human blood clots, whose element with the highest nuclear charge number in vivo is iron with a nuclear charge number of 26. For the measured ex-vivo clots, the enriched iodine-containing contrast agent may then be added, but at the same time formalin is added as a fifth material due to the fixation process. Thus, these samples consist of four materials whose K-edges are not in the measured X-ray spectrum and one material for which this is true. However, this fact makes it impossible to obtain the material composition on the basis of further spectral information by simply solving a linear system of equations. Since the model is intended to test the applicability to human blood clots, the test mixtures were treated in the same way as biological samples whose K-edges do not lie in the relevant X-ray range.
Correction for iomeprol and formalin also worked well for the human clots with high accuracy. Also in this case, it is important to discuss the degree of linearity of the equation system based on the results. Although the individual base materials for human clots are difficult or even impossible to measure due to the difficulty of extracting the individual materials, the high degree of linearity can be indirectly observed from the optimization of the base material attenuation coefficients of fibrin/platelets, RBC and WBC. The small value of the cost function (Eq. 5) between 0.8 and 1.4% at the global optimum of several test samples shows that the approach of the cost function, in which the equation system was assumed to be linear, is justified. Thus, the model with the linearity approach could be applied to more samples regarding the iomeprol and formalin corrections. The mean relative matching error between the optimized point and the measured point is (0.075%) (50 keV) and (0.127%) (200 keV). For specimens that could be corrected by characteristic formalin as well as iomeprol vectors, it is not surprising that the error is exactly zero. This is due to the fact that in a 2D plane, each point or vector can be represented by two different vectors. Therefore, these two mean relative errors were calculated using specimens that could only be optimized by the characteristic vector of formalin and therefore did not necessarily result in an error of zero. The fact that the error is nevertheless small shows emphatically the high accuracy of the algorithm. The results also showed a mean iomeprol concentration of (0.320, {rm mg/ml}), which is well below the limit of (0.660 , {rm mg/ml}) set by the previously performed model test. Thus, for the vast majority of clots, an iomeprol concentration was determined that should be considered equal to zero, or at least lower than the detection limit. However, four clots were optimized to iomeprol concentrations between 0.899 ({rm mg/ml}) and 1.23 ({rm mg/ml}). These are above the limit of (0.660, {rm mg/ml}) and thus are trustworthy results. From a clinical point of view, it is particularly interesting here that three of the four iodine-positive samples also had a comparatively high fibrin/platelets content. This correlation confirms previous studies that were also able to demonstrate this fact qualitatively30,31,32,33,34. Moreover, it can be seen that iomeprol does not accumulate to high levels in fibrin/platelets-containing clots randomly. Rather, a proportionality is discernible. For specimen A, which has a fibrin/platelets content of 99.2(%) as determined by histology, an iomeprol concentration of 1.23 ({rm mg/ml}) was determined. Up to specimen D, for which an iomeprol concentration of 0.899 ({rm mg/ml}) with a fibrin/platelets content of 34.4(%) was determined, the iomeprol concentration decreases directly proportional to the fibrin/platelets content (Table 4). It can be concluded that determination of the fibrin/platelets content in the clot may be possible by determination of the iomeprol concentration. It should be noted, that the clots were stored in formalin for different lengths of time from extraction to measurement. The storage times for specimens A, B, C and D, rounded up to the full hour, was 77 h, 56 h, 33 h and 31 h, respectively. Thus, it is possible that the iomeprol washed out of the clots differently. In this case, an exact protocol would have to be carried out with exactly the same and shortest possible storage times. When analyzing the results of all 61 clots, it is noticeable that there were significantly more clots that had similar or much higher fibrin/platelets content. Therefore, it is initially surprising that the results are not similar to those of samples A, B, C and D. One explanation for this could be that the components RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets appear very regionally as clusters in the range of histological resolution. Therefore, the position of the clot in the artery may be decisive. If mainly a fibrin/platelets containing area of the clot is in contact with the artery wall, the iomeprol may diffuse in more difficulty or less. Since it is known from fluid dynamics that vortices can form behind an obstacle if this obstacle is held in a flow35, it may also play a role whether a fibrin/platelets-containing area is facing the blood stream or away from it. For the side of the clot facing the blood stream, a constant iomeprol concentration can be expected, since the blood is constantly circulating here. On the side facing away from the blood flow, flow-dynamic vortices can form, where a lower iomeprol concentration can be expected. Based on all the results of this ex vivo study, it can be concluded that an in vivo method might be possible if further studies will be done with in vivo clots. Such a methodology might be based on using two virtual monoE images for which no contrast agent has yet been administered to the patient. Thus, neither contrast medium nor formalin is present in the clot. This could then allow the separation into the respective volume fractions of RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets with the aid of the three-material decomposition, for which volume conservation is considered.
Possible sources of error cannot be ruled out, which are mainly found in histological analysis, in the model simplification for the algorithm and in the segmentation of specimens. The histological analysis, which optically calculates the percentage of RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets, has an accuracy of 89–(99%) output by the instrument. This internal error refers to how well the device was able to segment with the help of the training and not whether correct areas were necessarily segmented. Since such sections were excluded manually, the error is considered to be small. As the dimensioning of the cost function had to be reduced for the optimization of the basis materials, WBC was assumed to have a similar composition to soft tissue and was excluded from the optimization. Since the fraction of WBC in the clots is significantly lower compared to fibrin/platelets and RBC, the error is not weighted as heavily in comparison. However, it must be noted that for some clots a WBC fraction of 15(%) is quite possible. It can therefore not be excluded that the simplification of the model can play a role with regard to the total error of the analysis. Another source of error can be the segmentation process. Great care was taken to segment only the clot. But it cannot be completely ruled out that a few background voxels were also segmented. Nevertheless, the results show a very high accuracy. Thus, these errors are also small as claimed for the model testing. Another interesting way to verify the decomposition is to make a measurement on monoenergetic lines, whose energy would then have to correspond to the effective energy of the X-ray spectrum of the DE-CT. Since the X-ray tube of the DE-CT can only emit polychromatic spectra, external and non-clinical facilities such as a synchrotron would have to be used. In theory, this is a feasible method for further verification. However, this method is extremely difficult to perform, especially for clinical DE-CTs, since neither the input spectrum nor the detector response, nor the raw data of the detector layers are freely available.
In general, if mixtures consisting of three basic materials have to be decomposed, this can be achieved with knowledge of the attenuation properties of the individual materials by means of two virtual monoE images calculated on the basis of a DE-CT measurement and by considering volume conservation as well as the linearity of the mass attenuation coefficient with respect to the volume fraction (Eq. 1). The resulting system of equations consisting of a 3 × 3 system matrix (Eq. 2) represents a linear as well as convex problem and can thus be solved quickly and easily for the volume fractions (f_i). Here (mu _{i, 50/200}) refer to the attenuation coefficient of the basis material i at an energy of 50keV and 200keV, respectively. And (mu _{CT, 50/200}) to the virtual monoE attenuation coefficients of the measurement. The condition of volume conservation is achieved here by the condition (f_1+f_2+f_3 = 1)17.
If there are more than three basic materials, this comparatively simple way can be modified by using the decomposition of human clots with histological analysis.
Basically, this method achieves that two different imaging modalities can be correlated with each other mathematically. One modality is the DE-CT, which provides the virtual monoE images. The other modality is the histological analysis, which outputs the volume fraction of RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets. Since the histological analysis overlooks materials such as iomeprol and formalin, the two results are usually different but still mathematically related. The simplest way to establish the relationship between these two modalities is to use a volume fraction representation. If the results of the DE-CT are interpreted as the sum of all actually occurring materials volume fractions (f_i^{CT}), it must now apply that these can also be represented by the sum of all histological results (f_j^{Histo}) normalized with (c_a) and the basis materials (tilde{f_k}) not occurring in the histological analysis (Eq. 3). Here i represents all materials measured by the CT, j the materials that can only be measured visually by the histological analysis and k the missing materials that were not measurable by the histological analysis. Furthermore, due to volume conservation, for (nin [0,1]) it holds that (sum _{i=1}^{4+n}f_i^{CT} = 1) and (sum _{j=1}^3 f_j^{Histo} = 1). Thus, the correction factor (c_a) can also be represented by Eq. (4). Substituting Eq. (2) into Eq. (4) and then changing from a volume fraction representation to an attenuation coefficient representation by multiplying each volume fraction value (f_i) by the associated basis material attenuation coefficient (vec {mu }_i) yields the transitions (sum _{i=1}^{4+n}f_i^{CT} longrightarrow sum _{i=1}^{4+n}f_i^{CT}cdot vec {mu }_i = vec {mu }^{CT}) and (sum _{j=1}^3 f_j^{Histo} longrightarrow sum _{j=1}^3 f_j^{Histo}cdot vec {mu }_j = vec {mu }^{Histo}) and (sum _{k=4}^{4+n} tilde{f_k}longrightarrow sum _{k=4}^{4+n} tilde{f}_kcdot vec {mu }_k). Here (vec {mu }^{CT}) denotes the attenuation vector at 50keV and 200keV determined using DE-CT. Whereas (vec {mu }^{Histo}) denotes the attenuation vector that considers only the initial materials present in the histological findings. After presenting the equation in a more intuitive form and subsequent formation of the (l_2) norm, a cost function (Eq. 5) is obtained, which is used to optimize to the volume fractions (tilde{f}_k).
If only assumptions about the attenuation properties and the volume fractions of three of the basis materials are known, the attenuation coefficients of the three materials can be optimized. In addition, the method allows to consider at the same time another material like formalin with exactly known attenuation properties.
Thus, this method is divided into two sub steps. First, the value measured at the DE-CT must be adjusted for the fourth material. For this, similar to the method presented before, one can now subtract the volume fraction of the additional material (tilde{f}_4) from the CT value presented as the sum of all volume fractions and normalize this with (c_s) (Eq. 6). This results in the volume fraction sum of the specimen composition without the fourth material. Since (sum _{i=1}^4 f_{i}^{CT} = 1) and (sum _{j=1}^3 f_{j}^{‘} = 1) must hold here as well, one can express the normalization factor (c_s) as Eq. (7). Moreover, an inverse relation holds between (c_s) and (c_a). Substituting Eq. (4) into Eq. (6) and moving from the volume fraction representation to the attenuation coefficient representation by (sum _{i=1}^4 f_{i}^{CT} longrightarrow sum _{i=1}^4 f_{i}^{CT}cdot vec {mu }_i = vec {mu }^{CT}) and (sum _{j=1}^3 f_{j}^{‘} longrightarrow sum _{j=1}^3 f_{j}^{‘}cdot vec {mu }_j = vec {mu }^{‘}) are performed, then after a short transformation, an expression is obtained that relates measured DE-CT value to the attenuation coefficients adjusted for the fourth material (Eq. 8). The second part of the method refers to the correction of the basis materials. For this, the attenuation entries of the system matrix already listed in Eq. (2) are multiplied by individual correction factors (c_i). This allows a correction for both density and mass attenuation. For each specimen j the difference between the corrected DE-CT value (vec {mu }_j^{‘}) and the calculated value from the system matrix and the histological result (vec {f}_{j}^{Histo}) can be calculated. (vec {mu }_j^{‘}) must be extended by one dimension with entry 1 to account for volume conservation. Summing now the (l_2) normalized differentials of all specimens j, we obtain a cost function (Eq. 9) with which an optimization for the volume fraction (tilde{f}_{4,j}) and the correction factors (c_m) with (min [1;6]) can be obtained. Here it is important to emphasize again that the correction factors (c_m) refer to the factors in Eq. (9). These allow an optimization of the ground truth absorption values of the base materials. Whereas (c_a) as well as (c_s) represent single factors, which allow the connection between DE-CT measurement and histological analysis.
The cost function (Eq. 9) poses a problem that is neither linear nor convex. Because of this, there can be multiple local minima, so a global optimizer must be used. For this study a simplicial homology global optimization (shgo)36 was used.
First, the model was verified on specimens of which the basis materials and the exact percentage composition are known. The first step is to find suitable basis materials.
The basic requirements for the selection of substances to be used as basis materials are that no precipitation reactions occur if all were mixed together and that they are readily soluble in water. At the same time, all substances should have the greatest possible difference in their attenuation properties and be easy to handle, since the specimens have to be transported.
Iomeprol, eosin Y disodiumsalt and sodium chloride in aqueous solution each fulfill these conditions very well. The iodine-containing iomeprol is not only the contrast agent used for contrast-enhanced CT in this study, but it is also a substance that is non-ionic. Therefore it cannot precipitate with other substances. The bromine-containing eosin Y disodiumsalt, on the other hand, is ionically bonded. However, since eosin Y disodiumsalt only precipitates with heavy anions such as phosphate or sulphate it fulfills the required conditions as well. Sodium chloride with chloride as the anion, is very suitable as a further substance since it fulfills all conditions and does not react or precipitates with the other substances. The main absorbing atoms iodine, bromine, chloride and the solvent water also ensures a different attenuation properties.
To prepare the basis solutions, 10.0 g of sodium chloride, 2.5 ml of an (400, {rm mg/ml}) iomeprol solution and 2.0 g of eosin Y disodium salt were dissolved to the volume of 50 ml in distilled water in an 50 ml Erlenmeyer flask. Starting from the resulting basis solutions of (200 , {rm mg/ml}) sodium chloride, (20 , {rm mg/ml}) iomeprol and (40, {rm mg/ml}) eosin Y disodiumsalt, five different concentrations were pipetted in each case (Table 5) into 1.5 ml sealable tubes. Using the measurement results from the DE-CT of these, linear regressions can be formed to show the accuracy of mixing but also to determine the values of the basis solutions more accurately.
Furthermore, several mixtures of a maximum of all three basis solutions as well as distilled water (Table 6) where pipetted into 1.5 ml closable tubes. Since the exact percent compositions are known, it can be pretended here that a modality corresponding to histological analysis in this case misses the iomeprol. The results of the DE-CT are then used to verify the iomeprol correction by using the model to try to optimize from the measured values and the volume composition (without iomeprol) to the true volume fractions of the solutions.
All tubes are then placed in two identical specimen holders that allow a measurement with the DE-CT of all specimen simultaneously. The composition of further measured samples and a representation of the sample holder can be found within the Supplementary Information as Tables S1, S2 and Fig. S1 online.
72 patients with acute ischemic stroke, and one patient with a sinus vein thrombosis were treated by mechanical thrombectomy. Clot material could then be extracted and immediately placed in tubes containing neutral buffered 3.5–3.7(%) formalin solution for fixation and storage. Except for one patients, which had two acute strokes independently of each other and thus two clots were extracted, all 73 acute stroke clots (12 for optimization and validation and 61 for testing of the material decomposition approach) were from different patients each (median of age: 79, interquartile range (IQR) (Q1 and Q2): 68–85, female fraction: 58.9(%)). Afterwords CT scans of the clots were performed. Therefore a special specimen holder, in which two tubes or two specimens can be placed simultaneously, is then put on the patient desk with the aid of a cardboard tray so that the specimen holder does not move and at the same time an inclined plane is formed. Thus, the specimens remain constantly at the bottom of the tubes and do not move during the measurement (Fig.1). Further images of the sample holder can be found within the Supplementary Information as Figs. S5 and S6.
For the application of the method on human clots, it is obvious to perform the established histological analysis to obtain the composition of RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets, which was performed for each of the 73 specimens (12 for optimization and validation and 61 for testing of the material decomposition approach). This involves cutting the clots into many approximately (1) to (2 ,upmu m) thick sections, which are then routinely stained with hematoxylin–eosin (HE) and Elastica van Gieson. Afterwards the slides were scanned at high resolution by a light microscope and digitally stored37. Due to the cutting of the samples, it is important that the histological analysis was performed after the DE-CT measurement. Since afterwards, the samples can no longer be measured by CT, as they are then destroyed. For the evaluation of the percentage distribution the software Orbit Image Analysis (Version 3.64, Idorsia Pharmaceuticals Ltd., Allschwil, Schwitzerland) was used. This free open source software achieves the segmentation by a machine learning algorithm. Sometimes cracks or overlaps occur in the analyzed histosections, which would affect the result. These were manually left out for the analysis to prevent high errors. Since fibrin and platelets cannot be visually distinguished in HE staining, both are considered as one conglomerate for this study18 A graphical representation of the analysis based on one sample section can be found within the Supplementary Information as Fig. S7 online.
This optimization refers to the formulas (6)–(9). Here j represents the sample number and i represents the abbreviations RBC, WBC, fibrin/platelets, and formalin. In order to significantly limit the optimization environment and thus also reduce the duration of the optimization of the correction factors (c_m) and the volume fraction of formalin corresponding to (tilde{f}_{4,j}) in Eq. (9), it is important to predetermine the attenuation properties as precisely as possible.
For the hemoglobin that is within the RBC, the sum of all elements occurring in the two (alpha)-globine, two (beta)-globine (see Supplementary Information Fig. S4, Tables S3 and S4 online) and four hem-groups which are all part of the quarterly structure is summed up to a total chemical sum formula38,39. The density of the hemoglobin is extracted from the mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration (MCHC) of each patient individually. This value is routinely determined in patients when blood count is performed. For fibrin the chemical sum formula and the density can be looked up at PubChem24. It should be noted here that only the properties of fibrin were looked up or determined. As known from histological analysis, fibrin and platelets are seen as one material due to HE staining. Thus, the platelets are not considered for chemical sum formula assumption. However, the algorithm allows to optimize from fibrin to fibrin/platelets later on. The WBC are substituted by soft tissue assuming that the difference in X-ray attenuation between the is negligible. The chemical sum-formula such as the density of formalin the specimen are fixated can also be looked up. With the knowledge of the chemical sum formula and the density of the RBC, WBC, fibrin and formalin the attenuation coefficients at 50keV and 200keV are calculated or directly looked up by using the United States National Institute of Technology and Standards (NIST) X-ray Mass Attenuation Coefficients Database23.
For the basis material optimization of RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets 12 of all 73 specimen where used which do not have iomeprol diffused to reduce the dimensioning of the model. To reduce this further and make the algorithm faster, the 12 specimen are grouped in three groups containing four specimen each. The correction factors for WBC were set equal to 1, since WBC do not contribute much to the attenuation and also the dimensioning of the problem had to be further reduced. Each group is then optimized separately with the in-house developed algorithm resulting in three different results for (c_m) and the volume fraction of formalin. The end result is then the weighted mean of these. Whereas, the weighting coefficients are the inverse of the value of the cost-function at the minimum.
By using the final results of the (c_m) these can now be multiplied with the assumptions of the attenuation resulting in the final optimized attenuation coefficient of RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets that are used for the following iodine correction of the other specimen not used for this basis material optimization.
This optimization refers to the Eqs. (3), (4) and (5). Here i corresponds to the abbreviations of RBC, WBC, fibrin/platelets, formalin and iomeprol. j corresponds to RBC, WBC and fibrin/platelets only and k corresponds to formalin and iomeprol. The final goal is now to use the knowledge of the basis material attenuation properties to do an iodine as well as an formalin correction for the 61 remaining specimens.
The iomeprol attenuation can be calculated by using the NIST database and looking up the chemical sum formula and density23. Then, the attenuation properties of all basis materials are known and the correction for the iomeprol can be applied using the cost-function (Eq. 5) in consideration of formalin as fifth material.
73 human clots and six test mixtures consisting of water-based solutions of eosin Y disodium salt, sodium chloride, iomeprol and pure water were measured with the DL-CT (IQon Spectral CT, Philips Healthcare, Best, The Netherlands). The test mixtures were fixated and positioned using a suitable holder. This allows all test specimens to be measured simultaneously. The clots were measured using a holder suitable for these specimens (Fig.1b). This holder allows two clots specimens to be measured simultaneously. All specimens were placed as centrally as possible with respect to the gantry for measurement. Each scan was performed with a tube voltage of 120 kVp and an exposure of 500 mAs. The results of the front and rear detector layer were then used by the manufacturer’s internal software (IQon—Spectral CT powered by iPatient v4.7.5.43531) to calculate spectral information, which is stored as a spectral base images (SBI). The CT dose index (CTDI(_{vol})) per scan calculated by the scanner was 85.9mGy for every specimen and resulted in a mean dose length product (DLP) of 215 mGy cm for the clots and 4766.5mGy cm for the test specimens. The Image matrix of 512 × 512 pixel, pitch of 0.328 s, rotation time of 0.75 s and a detector configuration of 64 × 0.625 mm was used for all specimens.
Reconstruction of SBI using projection data from the front and rear detector slices, a Brain Sharp (UC) filter, spectral plane 2, and an axial slice thickness of 0.8 mm was performed using Philips internal software (IQon—Spectral CT powered by iPatient v4.7.5.43531). The MonoE images at 50 keV and 200 keV, important for this study, were mathematically calculated using the SBI and the manufacturer-specific software (Intelli Space Portal v.9.0.1, Philips Healthcare, The Netherlands). Due to the mathematical determination of these images, they are so called virtual monoE images created in Hounsfield Units (HU).
After the CT image acquisition, the data was loaded into a desktop software (3D slicer image computing platform)40. The region of interest (ROI) was then segmented using the available tools and the mean attenuation for the virtual monoE images was generated for the voxels considered. In addition, the clinically relevant HU value was normalized to the physical relevant value with Eq. (10).
The algorithm was implemented on python and executed with Ipython (version 3.7)41. For the visual representation the package matplotlib.pyplot was used and for general mathematical implementation the package NumPy42,43.
This retrospective study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Technical University of Munich. Due to the retrospective nature of the study, the Ethics Committee assumes that all data and thrombi of the patients to be included are already available. Therefore written informed consent was waived by the Ethics Committee of the Technical University of Munich for this retrospective analysis. All experiments were performed in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations.
The datasets generated and/or analysed during the current study are not publicly available according to the regulations on data protection and in accordance with the ethical standards but are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
Toepker, M. et al. Virtual non-contrast in second-generation, dual-energy computed tomography: Reliability of attenuation values. Eur. J. Radiol. 81, E398–E405. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejrad.2011.12.011 (2012).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Pache, G. et al. Dual-energy CT virtual noncalcium technique: Detecting posttraumatic bone marrow lesions—Feasibility study. Radiology 256, 617–624. https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol.10091230 (2010).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Chae, E. J. et al. Dual-energy CT for assessment of the severity of acute pulmonary embolism: Pulmonary perfusion defect score compared with CT angiographic obstruction score and right ventricular/left ventricular diameter ratio. Am. J. Roentgenol. 194, 604–610. https://doi.org/10.2214/AJR.09.2681 (2010).
Article  Google Scholar 
Uotani, K. et al. Dual-energy CT head bone and hard plaque removal for quantification of calcified carotid stenosis: Utility and comparison with digital subtraction angiography. Eur. Radiol. 19, 2060–2065. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-009-1358-x (2009).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Watanabe, Y. et al. Dual-energy direct bone removal CT angiography for evaluation of intracranial aneurysm or stenosis: Comparison with conventional digital subtraction angiography. Eur. Radiol. 19, 1019–1024. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-008-1213-5 (2009).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Yu, L., Leng, S. & McCollough, C. H. Dual-energy CT-based monochromatic imaging. Am. J. Roentgenol.https://doi.org/10.2214/ajr.12.9121 (2012).
Article  Google Scholar 
Bamberg, F. et al. Metal artifact reduction by dual energy computed tomography using monoenergetic extrapolation. Eur. Radiol. 21, 1424–1429. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-011-2062-1 (2011).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Graser, A. et al. Dual energy CT characterization of urinary calculi: Initial in vitro and clinical experience. Invest. Radiol. 43, 112–119. https://doi.org/10.1097/RLI.0b013e318157a144 (2008).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Desai, M. A., Peterson, J. J., Garner, H. W. & Kransdorf, M. J. Clinical utility of dual-energy CT for evaluation of tophaceous gout. Radiographics 31, 1365–1375. https://doi.org/10.1148/rg.315115510 (2011).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Goo, H. W. & Goo, J. M. Dual-energy CT: New horizon in medical imaging. Korean J. Radiol. 18, 555–569. https://doi.org/10.3348/kjr.2017.18.4.555 (2017).
Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 
Sauter, A. P. et al. Perfusion-ventilation CT via three-material differentiation in dual-layer CT: A feasibility study. Sci. Rep. 9, 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-42330-7 (2019).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Nazarov, V. Method of hyperplanes in the problem of identification of an unknown substance. J. Appl. Ind. Math. 15, 451–465. https://doi.org/10.1134/S199047892103008X (2021).
MathSciNet  Article  Google Scholar 
Nazarov, V. Estimation of the calculation accuracy in the problem of partial identification of a substance. J. Appl. Ind. Math. 14, 555–565. https://doi.org/10.1134/S199047892003014X (2020).
MathSciNet  Article  Google Scholar 
Curtis, T. E. & Roeder, R. K. Quantification of multiple mixed contrast and tissue compositions using photon-counting spectral computed tomography. J. Med. Imaging 6, 1–7. https://doi.org/10.1117/1.JMI.6.1.013501 (2019).
Article  Google Scholar 
Sellerer, T. et al. Dual-energy CT: A phantom comparison of different platforms for abdominal imaging. Eur. Radiol. 28, 2745–2755. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00330-017-5238-5 (2018).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Hsieh, J. Computed Tomography: Principles, Design, Artifacts, and Recent Advances. (SPIE-The International Society for Optical Engineering, 2015).
Mendonca, P. R., Lamb, P. & Sahani, D. V. A flexible method for multi-material decomposition of dual-energy CT images. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 33, 99–116. https://doi.org/10.1109/TMI.2013.2281719 (2014).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Boeckh-Behrens, T. et al. The impact of histological clot composition in embolic stroke. Clin. Neuroradiol. 26, 189–197. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00062-014-0347-x (2016).
CAS  Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Niesten, J. M. et al. Histopathologic composition of cerebral thrombi of acute stroke patients is correlated with stroke subtype and thrombus attenuation. PLoS ONE 9, 12–14. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0088882 (2014).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Allmendinger, A. M., Tang, E. R., Lui, Y. W. & Spektor, V. Imaging of stroke: Part 1, perfusion ct—Overview of imaging technique, interpretation pearls, and common pitfalls. Am. J. Roentgenol. 198, 52–62. https://doi.org/10.2214/AJR.10.7255 (2012).
Article  Google Scholar 
Willner, M. et al. Quantitative X-ray phase-contrast computed tomography at 82 keV. Opt. Exp. 21, 4155. https://doi.org/10.1364/oe.21.004155 (2013).
Article  Google Scholar 
Borggrefe, J. et al. Differentiation of clot composition using conventional and dual-energy computed tomography. Clin. Neuroradiol. 28, 515–522. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00062-017-0599-3 (2018).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Hubbell, J. H. & Seltzer, S. M. Tables of X-Ray Mass Attenuation Coefficients and Mass Energy-Absorption Coefficients (Version 1.4). https://doi.org/10.18434/T4D01F (2004).
Kim, S. et al. PubChem in 2021: New data content and improved web interfaces. Nucleic Acids Res. 49, D1388–D1395. https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkaa971. https://academic.oup.com/nar/article-pdf/49/D1/D1388/35363961/gkaa971.pdf (2020).
Ehn, S. et al. Assessment of quantification accuracy and image quality of a full-body dual-layer spectral CT system. J. Appl. Clin. Med. Phys. 19, 204–217. https://doi.org/10.1002/acm2.12243 (2018).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Foroutan, M. Density dependence of the viscosity and excess volume of aqueous solutions of polyvinylpyrrolidone. Acta Chim. Slov. 53, 219–222 (2006).
CAS  Google Scholar 
Fließbach, T. Statistische Physik. (Spektrum Akad., 2010).
Deslattes, R. et al. X-ray Transition Energies (Version 1.2). http://physics.nist.gov/XrayTrans (2005). Accessed 16 June 2022. (National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2022).
Müller, B.H., Hoeschen, C., Florian Grüner, V.A.A. & Johnson, T.R.C. Molecular imaging based on X-ray fluorescent high-Z tracers. J. Med. Imaging 8063–8076. https://doi.org/10.1088/0031-9155/58/22/8063 (2013).
Santos, E. M. et al. Thrombus permeability is associated with improved functional outcome and recanalization in patients with ischemic stroke. Stroke 47, 732–741. https://doi.org/10.1161/STROKEAHA.115.011187 (2016).
CAS  Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Berndt, M. et al. Thrombus permeability in admission computed tomographic imaging indicates stroke pathogenesis based on thrombus histology. Stroke 49, 2674–2682. https://doi.org/10.1161/STROKEAHA.118.021873 (2018).
Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Jones, C. I. & Goodall, A. H. Differential effects of the iodinated contrast agents Ioxaglate, Iohexol and Iodixanol on thrombus formation and fibrinolysis. Thrombosis Res. 112, 65–71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.thromres.2003.09.031 (2003).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
McDonald, M. M. et al. Iodinated contrast does not alter clotting dynamics in acute ischemic stroke as measured by thromboelastography. Stroke 45, 462–466. https://doi.org/10.1161/STROKEAHA.113.003268 (2014).
MathSciNet  CAS  Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Gabriel, D. A., Jones, M. R., Reece, N. S., Boothroyd, E. & Bashore, T. Platelet and fibrin modification by radiographic contrast media. Circ. Res. 68, 881–887. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.RES.68.3.881 (1991).
CAS  Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Visconti, G. & Paolo, R. Fluid Dynamics. (Springer, 2020).
Endres, S. C., Sandrock, C. & Focke, W. W. A simplicial homology algorithm for Lipschitz optimisation. J. Glob. Optim. 72, 181–217. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10898-018-0645-y (2018).
MathSciNet  Article  MATH  Google Scholar 
Boeckh-Behrens, T. et al. Thrombus histology suggests cardioembolic cause in cryptogenic stroke. Stroke 47, 1864–1871. https://doi.org/10.1161/STROKEAHA.116.013105 (2016).
CAS  Article  PubMed  Google Scholar 
Berman, H. M. et al. The protein data bank. Nucleic Acid Res.https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/28.1.235 (2000).
ADS  Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 
Dixon, H. B. F. Nomenclature and symbolism for amino acids and peptides: Recommendations 1983. Eur. J. Biochem. 138, 9–37. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1432-1033.1984.tb07877.x (1984).
Article  Google Scholar 
Fedorov, A. et al. 3d slicer as an image computing platform for the quantitative imaging network. Magnet. Resonan. Imaging 30, 1323–1341. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mri.2012.05.001 (2012).
Article  Google Scholar 
Pérez, F. & Granger, B. E. Ipython: A system for interactive scientific computing. Comput. Sci. Eng. 9, 21—29. https://doi.org/10.1109/MCSE.2007.53(2007).
Harris, C. R. et al. Array programming with numpy. Nature 585, 357–362. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2649-2 (2020).
ADS  CAS  Article  PubMed  PubMed Central  Google Scholar 
Hunter, J. D. Matplotlib: A 2D graphics environment. Comput. Sci. Eng. 9, 90–95. https://doi.org/10.1109/MCSE.2007.55 (2007).
Article  Google Scholar 
Download references
Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. This study were funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) and the Free State of Bavaria under the Excellence Strategy of the Federal Government and the Länder, by the German Research Foundation (DFG) under GRK2274, as well as by the Technical University of Munich—Institute for Advanced Study.
These authors contributed equally: Maximilian E. Lochschmidt and Melina Gassenhuber.
These authors jointly supervised this work: Franz Pfeiffer and Daniela Pfeiffer.
Chair of Biomedical Physics, Department of Physics, School of Natural Sciences, Technical University of Munich, 85748, Garching, Germany
Maximilian E. Lochschmidt, Johannes Hammel, Lorenz Birnbacher, Madleen Busse & Franz Pfeiffer
Department of Diagnostics and Interventional Radiology, School of Medicine, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, Technical University of Munich, 81675, Munich, Germany
Melina Gassenhuber, Johannes Hammel, Lorenz Birnbacher, Marcus R. Makowski, Franz Pfeiffer & Daniela Pfeiffer
Munich Institute of Biomedical Engineering, Technical University of Munich, 85748, Garching, Germany
Madleen Busse & Franz Pfeiffer
Institute for Advanced Study, Technical University of Munich, 85748, Garching, Germany
Franz Pfeiffer & Daniela Pfeiffer
Department of Diagnostic and Interventional Neuroradiology, School of Medicine, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, Technical University of Munich, 81675, Munich, Germany
Isabelle Riederer, Tobias Boeckh-Behrens & Claus Zimmer
Department of Neurology, School of Medicine, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, Technical University of Munich, 81675, Munich, Germany
Benno Ikenberg & Silke Wunderlich
Department of Neuropathology, School of Medicine, Klinikum Rechts der Isar, Technical University of Munich, 81675, Munich, Germany
Friederike Liesche-Starnecker & Jürgen Schlegel
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
J.H., D.P., I.R. and F.P. conceived the original idea. M.L. was responsible for the development of the algorithm, the preparation of specimens to test the model, and for the preparation of the figures. M.G. was responsible for the CT measurements and histological analysis of the clots. J.H., I.R., M.G., D.P., F.P., M.B., T.B., B.I., S.W. and F.L. delivered technical assistance and solutions. M.L. wrote the manuscript. D.P., F.P. and I.R. directed the project. D.P., F.P., I.R., J.H., M.G., L.B., M.B., T.B., B.I., S.W., F.L., J.S., M.M. and C.Z. reviewed the manuscript.
Correspondence to Maximilian E. Lochschmidt.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Lochschmidt, M.E., Gassenhuber, M., Riederer, I. et al. Five material tissue decomposition by dual energy computed tomography. Sci Rep 12, 17117 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21193-5
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21193-5
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports (Sci Rep) ISSN 2045-2322 (online)
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

source

Your Weekly Roundup of Movies: Billy Eichner Falls for Luke Macfarlane in “Bros” – Willamette Week

Bros (from left) Aaron (Luke Macfarlane) and Bobby (Billy Eichner) in Bros, co-written, produced and directed by Nicholas Stoller. (Photo Credit: Nicole Rivelli/Universal Pictures)
BROS
**** From meeting cute to racing through the streets of New York in search of a climactic kiss, romantic comedies are rife with rituals. These moments can feel stale and obligatory, but in Bros, the sting of truth is expressed through the grandeur of fiction. Billy Eichner (who wrote the film with director Nicholas Stoller) stars as Bobby Lieber, a gay, single podcaster numbly living his life one monosyllabic Grindr hookup at a time. Despite his jaded posturing, Bobby is drawn to Aaron (Luke Macfarlane), a dashing stranger whom he first sees bathed in beatific blue light at a club. In temperament, they couldn’t be more different—Bobby relishes being the director of a soon-to-open LGBTQ+ history museum, whereas Aaron resists his dream of being a chocolatier because he fears it’s too “faggy.” Can true love transcend insecurity? Just because the answer is familiar doesn’t mean it isn’t moving. While Bros has fine broad-comedy flourishes—including Bobby raging at a bust of Pete Buttigieg in a moment of romantic anguish—it is at its best when it is at its most tender. “Vulnerability is not a boner killer,” a friend tells Bobby. Bros takes those words to heart, embracing the emotional rawness that defines When Harry Met Sally… and You’ve Got Mail, both of which Bobby references. Eichner and Stoller simultaneously carry on and transcend the legacy of those films—theirs is the first rom-com from a major studio with an all-LGTQ principal cast—but they wear the mantle of importance lightly. At a time when hope is a limited resource, the most radical thing about Bros is that it’s a joy. R. BENNETT CAMPBELL FERGUSON. Academy, Cinema 21, City Center, Clackamas, Evergreen Parkway, Laurelhurst, Living Room, Lloyd Center, Mill Plain, Oak Grove, Progress Ridge, St. Johns Twin, Studio One, Tigard.
AMSTERDAM
**** In 1933, Maj. Gen. Smedley Butler testified to Congress about an attempted coup orchestrated by fascism-adoring industrialists who sought to overthrow President Franklin D. Roosevelt. While Butler’s account was dismissed by many, a special House committee confirmed parts of his story, which has been skillfully stitched into Amsterdam, a poignant and witty historical remix from director David O. Russell (American Hustle). Rather than start at the corrosive heart of what is now known as the Business Plot, Russell shows the conspiracy taking shape through the eyes of Burt (Christian Bale) and Harold (John David Washington), two World War I veterans falsely accused of murder. Valerie (Margot Robbie), a former nurse who saved their lives during the war, helps them enlist Maj. Gen. Dillenbeck (Robert De Niro, playing a Smedley Butler analog) to catch the culprit, but Russell is in no rush to solve a mystery. Leisurely and lovingly, he wraps us in the fabric of Burt, Harold and Valerie’s lives, dwelling on details that are both unnerving and beautiful, like the tea set that Valerie fashions from shrapnel. If Amsterdam believes anything, it’s that democracy is defined by the seemingly small things that make a human being an individual, absurd as they may be. That’s why the climax offers a rousing tribute to radical niceness and the gloriously silly spectacle of Burt singing, getting high, and teaming up with a British secret agent played by Austin Powers himself, Mike Myers. “You gotta fight to protect kindness,” Burt declares. He’s right, but he and Amsterdam are also fighting to protect something else: the liberating, life-giving power of ridiculousness. R. BENNETT CAMPBELL FERGUSON. Bagdad, Cinemagic, City Center, Clackamas, Evergreen Parkway, Fox Tower, Laurelhurst, Living Room, Lloyd Center, Oak Grove, St. Johns Twin, Studio One, Tigard.
HOLD ME TIGHT
*** In the soft morning light, a mother named Clarisse (Vicky Krieps) packs a bag and ghosts her family, like the setup to a French Where’d You Go, Bernadette. Here, there’s more ennui and chain-smoking, along with Krieps expertly suggesting volumes of conflicted imagination behind a soft smile (as she did equally well in last year’s Bergman Island). Cut back to the abandoned family; they’re trying to survive without Clarisse. Back to Clarisse; she’s unwell, drinking too much without them. Her daughter’s prodigious piano playing emanates through the home and simultaneously from the tape deck of Clarisse’s getaway car. Editor Francois Gedigier works furiously to establish this mirroring, and director Mathieu Amalric (best known for his performances in Munich and The Diving Bell and the Butterfly) shows us split worlds, each with a great absence that generates something new. Though it owes a debt to Memento, Hold Me Tight trades more in near-telepathic visions than puzzle pieces. Krieps brilliantly employs her preternatural normalcy to ground a character whose new life on the road seems fueled by emotion alone. While none of the other performances in the film equals Krieps’, the dense illusion of a broken family rewards your attention. Is Clarisse running, or running to stand still? NR. CHANCE SOLEM-PFEIFER. Living Room.
THE WOMAN KING
*** The Woman King rejects the notion that its responsibility is to teach African history in two hours. Instead, it tells a tale of pride, dignity and agency against the backdrop of the fascinating Kingdom of Dahomey. In short, filmmaker Gina Prince-Bythewood (who wrote for A Different World and directed Love & Basketball and The Old Guard) and a stellar cast bring the legendary Agoji warrior women to life. Davis does an amazing job of playing Davis, without ever seeming to embody the persona of a stoic African warrior. Luckily for the film, this hardly matters. The sheer force she brings as an actor provides the essential emotional beats that a more authentic portrayal might have asked her to sacrifice. Set in 1823, the film finds the Dahomey in a cyclical conflict with a neighboring tribe, enriching themselves with the sale of each other’s prisoners to the international slave trade—and King Ghezo (John Boyega) of the Dahomey is being pressured to abandon the practice. The Woman King is directed at a Black audience, but it’s a movie for everybody, despite prerelease critics’ assumption it was an inaccurate depiction of the “noble” Africans murdering their “evil” white oppressors. And if the mere existence of the film causes those with racial animus to inadvertently study some African history? Cool. PG-13. RAY GILL JR. Bridgeport, Cascade, City Center, Clackamas, Division, Evergreen Parkway, Lloyd Center, Mill Plain, Oak Grove, Pioneer Place, Progress Ridge, Studio One, Tigard, Vancouver Mall, Vancouver Plaza.
We’ll send you a newsletter with what you need to know every week.

source

Buffalo International Film Festival celebrates art, community and diversity – University at Buffalo The Spectrum

Members of the community filed into the North Park Theatre to cheer on the films of their friends and loved ones.
The Buffalo International Film Festival wrapped up on Monday night after five busy days of screenings, panels and performances across the city. 
The 16th iteration of the event — otherwise known as its “Sweet BIFFteen” — was an uplifting celebration of film, art and community that featured over 160 independent films from Western New York and beyond.
Opening night of the festival kicked off at the historic North Park Theatre, a single-screen cinema on Hertel Avenue. Audience members filed into the gorgeous theatre for the Opening Night Gala: a screening of “Bashira,” the directorial debut of animator and special effects artist Nickson Fong. The trippy horror-musical film, inspired by a Japanese legend, was an appropriate choice to start the weekend. Like many of the films featured at BIFF, “Bashira” was filmed in and around Buffalo. 
Audience members were pleased to recognize beloved Buffalo locations like the Theatre District and Venu — a favorite of many UB students. 
But more significantly, the film was produced with an entirely local crew. 
“Everyone [on the crew] was Buffalo local,” Mitzi Akaha, one of the stars of the film, said. “Because it’s such a tight community, they’ve worked on every film that’s come through Buffalo… they got to share this rich culture of what filmmaking is like here.”
“Bunker,” another WNY-produced film, had its world premiere on Saturday night. Adrian Langley’s World War I thriller was filmed entirely at Buffalo FilmWorks, a local studio. 
The film — a body horror sci-fi flick about soldiers who must confront an evil presence while trapped underground — was a hit with the audience. 
Though a small city, Buffalo is no stranger to major film productions. It’s become something of a hotspot over the past few years, with huge filmmakers like Guillermo del Toro and John Krasinski passing through. 
But a big part of BIFF’s mission is to highlight the independent, grassroots films that have come out of the area, not the big Hollywood productions.
The close-knit, community-oriented quality of the festival attracts up-and-coming filmmakers looking to grow and expand their network. Paul-Daniel Torres, a director whose short film was screened as part of BIFF’s “Racial Justice in View” short film program, cited BIFF as one of the best festivals he’s participated in.
“It’s really everything a festival should be,” Torres said. “It’s a place that makes quality films accessible to all types of people, but also allows itself to be a training ground for young filmmakers.”
That type of accessibility is something truly unique to BIFF. At other festivals, it might cost upwards of $30 to attend a screening with a filmmaker; at BIFF, it’s always affordable, if not completely free.
“I think it’s an important part of a production ecosystem in any major city to have a real film festival,” Anna Scime, BIFF’s executive director, said. “Buffalo is one of the poorest cities in the nation. I think something like 30% of people in the city of Buffalo live below the poverty line… so we really do care that we have full access for everyone.”
One of the festival’s most special moments came on Sunday night at the screening of “WNY Stories,” a compilation of short films entirely produced in the Buffalo area. The incredibly diverse block included music videos, documentaries and animated video essays, all from people who call Western New York their home.
The feeling of hometown pride was tangible as members of the community filed into the North Park Theatre to cheer on their friends and loved ones. 
The 16th Buffalo International Film Festival kicked off at the historic North Park Theatre on Oct. 6.
One of the screening’s more Buffalo-centric selections was the music video for rock band Handsome Jack’s song “Roll It,” which follows the musicians as they push their broken-down tour van around the streets of Buffalo. It was a fun and vibrant tribute to the Queen City, with cameos from places like Revolver Records and Highmark Stadium. (Yes, someone in the audience did let out a resounding “Go Bills!”)
A particularly moving moment came during “I’ll Find a Way or Make One — A Rosie Story.” The short documentary profiled Viola Hippert, a 97-year-old Lackawanna native who worked for Bell Aircraft during World War II. She was one of many “Rosie the Riveters,” American women who picked up factory jobs during the war and changed the status quo for women in the workplace.
Hippert herself was in attendance, watching her story play out on the big screen for the first time. The audience was clearly charmed by her sense of humor, her toughness and her many stories; they laughed and cheered throughout the film. When it was over, the crowd erupted in the loudest applause of the night.
This display of unity and joy is exactly what Scime strived to create at the festival.
“I would say that it’s really community-focused,” Scime said. “Our real mission is diversity, inclusion, amplifying all different kinds of voices… but also bringing together our community.”
Meret Kelsey is an assistant arts editor and can be reached at [email protected]
Meret Kelsey is an assistant arts editor at The Spectrum.

source

Hispanic Heritage Month: Celebrating Elena Quevedo '83 – SBC News

To complement the Sweet Briar Multicultural Center’s celebration of Hispanic Heritage Month, we are highlighting Elena Quevedo, ’83. She is the principal at Cardinal Consulting for Nonprofits, LLC, a full-service consultancy practice focusing on fundraising, governance, marketing, strategic planning and board retreats within the nonprofit sector. We asked Elena some questions about Sweet Briar, Hispanic Heritage Month and her own story.
Sweet Briar: What does Hispanic heritage mean to you, and how has your heritage shaped who you are today? 
Elena Quevedo ’83: I was born and bred in Quito, Ecuador, and came to the U.S. in 1978 to finish high school, college and graduate school. I have also lived in France and Spain. I identify as both Ecuadorian and American. Being exposed to multiple cultures and multiple languages offers you a much wider worldview. You can contextualize things better and understand the relativity of cultural norms around the world. You acquire a broader bird’s eye view of life. To quote Mark Twain, “Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness.” I am proud of my heritage, and whenever I am able, I try to break down common stereotypes about people of Hispanic descent. There are over 500 million Spanish speakers around the world, and needless to say, we are not a homogenous, ethnic or racial group. We are a tremendously diverse group of people bound by one language. One of my pet peeves is that government forms continuously ask if I am “racially” Hispanic. Notice that no other group is currently singled out. My response based on my DNA is usually 94% Iberian, 3% Indigenous Native South American and 3% Neanderthal. Do not let others define you. Find out who you are or who you wish to be.
SB: Please share your best career advice that you would give a Sweet Briar Hispanic/LatinX student. 
EQ: Expose yourself to as many new things as possible during your four years. These are years of exploration and personal growth. Take advantage of it. You will never have that kind of freedom again. The best job candidate, in my eyes, is a well-rounded student who is intellectually curious. Intellectual curiosity will force you to question things and figure out how to go around the proverbial brick wall. Also, understand that nothing is set in stone. Very few people continue to work in areas related to their majors for the rest of their lives. I think this is wonderful! I have had three professional iterations (art history professor, nonprofit professional and consultant) and have very much enjoyed them. What you wish to do today will probably not be the same 10 years from now. I find that to be fantastic because it will force personal growth. Being flexible and resilient is the key in life, and perseverance when you have found the one thing (for now).
Find one or more mentors. There is very little that one is afraid to try or unwilling to do when you know you have cheerleaders behind you cheering all the way.
SB: Please share how your Sweet Briar education impacted you both personally and professionally. 
EQ: I was not aware of the quality of education I was receiving until I got to graduate school. I attended an elite program in art and archeology in New York City that took only 25 students every year, and 10 of those students pursued the rarefied field of art conservation. I was the only student not to have attended an Ivy League school. It was extremely intimidating, even just in the first week. I very quickly realized I was one of the few women literally sitting at the table and not at the periphery of the seminar rooms. I was one of the few women interrupting and asking questions. Professor Aileen Laing ’57 and the art history department at Sweet Briar gifted me with a superb education, and I felt not only prepared but also soon took leadership roles within the school (Institute of Fine Arts at NYU). It is only when you experience education at other institutions that you realize the value of a Sweet Briar education. To quote Elizabeth Warren, “If you don’t have a seat at the table, you are probably on the menu.” Sweet Briar gave me confidence and the drive to reach for the stars. It is because of this gift that I volunteer and help the College as much as I can. My gratitude is boundless.
SB: How do you feel you are breaking barriers in the workplace as a woman? 
EQ: I have had to break gender, ethnic stereotypes, and size barriers during my career (I am 5′ 1″). Seemingly innocuous comments such as: “You don’t look Hispanic,”  “Gosh, your English is amazing” or “You looked way taller in Zoom” signal negative preconceived notions that will negatively impact whether you are hired, respected, and valued. It happens all the time. As a woman, being “mansplained” ad nauseam is continuous. And yet, I can’t say my experiences are anywhere near what black or brown women endure every single day.
SB: How have you responded to these barriers over the years?
EQ: I have worked harder and persevered until I felt I was at a level or higher plane than the competition. Having a Ph.D. gives me a veneer of intelligence that has been very helpful. Now that I am 61, I have proudly become a “difficult woman.” I am confident, I speak my mind, and I am not afraid of confrontations. I am very comfortable in my own skin. That is the freedom that comes with age. I wish I had arrived at this point when I was 30! For all you college kids, I highly recommend Karen Karbo’s “In Praise of Difficult Women: Life Lessons from 29 Heroines Who Dared to Break the Rules.”
Amy Ostroth
P | 540-230-7100
E | [email protected]

source

US: Mercedes-Benz EQ Sales Reached New Record In Q3 2022 – InsideEVs

Mercedes-Benz reports 87,682 car and van sales in the US during the third quarter of 2022 (up 23% year-over-year). This positive result has enabled the company to increase the year-to-date sales to 262,456 vehicles (up 3.5%).
The most important outcome for us is that Mercedes-Benz’ all-electric car sales further accelerated and reached a new quarterly record.
The company sold 2,717 units, which is about 3.1% of the total volume and a noticeable improvement over around 2,000 units in the previous two quarters.
Mercedes-Benz explains that sales improved thanks to the two new models, which arrived in September: the EQB (see price info) and the locally produced EQS SUV (see price info), which joins the EQS (sedan).
Mercedes-Benz EQ sales in the US:
So far this year, Mercedes-Benz sold close to 7,000 electric cars in the US, which is not bad for the beginning of the transition to BEVs.
Mercedes-Benz EQ sales year-to-date:
Electric car sales are expected to further grow, as there are more models on the horizon (the Mercedes-Benz EQE is next) as well as new configurations of existing models.
Dimitris Psillakis, President and CEO of MBUSA said:
“Our Mercedes-EQ electric offensive accelerated in September with the arrival of the EQB and US-built EQS SUV at dealerships, two exciting new electric models in high demand segments. With the upcoming launch of the highly anticipated EQE Sedan, we expect a strong close the final quarter of 2022.”
For reference, in Q3 Audi sold 3,911 all-electric cars, BMW 4,337, Porsche 1,325, and Volvo over 200. It means that when it comes to BEVs, Mercedes-Benz remains in the middle of the pack of established premium/luxury brands from Europe.
Mercedes-Benz sales in the US:
More about Mercedes-Benz
Car Buying Service
Get upfront price offers on local inventory.
Search for:
Trending
About this article

source

Russia-Ukraine war live updates: Drone strikes hit Kyiv; Putin to meet Erdogan – The Washington Post

Russia-Ukraine war live updates: Drone strikes hit Kyiv; Putin to meet Erdogan  The Washington Post
source

Inabnet honored as a master surgeon educator by American College of Surgeons – UKNow

LEXINGTON, Ky. (Oct. 12, 2022)­ — William B. Inabnet III, M.D., surgeon-in-chief at UK HealthCare and chair of the Department of Surgery in the University of Kentucky College of Medicine, was one of the 65 esteemed surgeon educators inducted into the American College of Surgeons (ACS) Academy of Master Surgeon Educators on Sept. 30. This is an honorary distinction that recognizes surgeon educators who have devoted their careers to surgical education and are considered premier leaders in their respective fields.
Inabnet joins fellow UK College of Medicine faculty members Sandra Beck, M.D., and Jitesh Patel, M.D., who were inducted in as master surgeon educators in 2020. Patel was recently named division chief of colon and rectal surgery and Beck has been named vice chair of surgery education in the Department of Surgery.
Inabnet became chair of the Department of Surgery in September 2019. Prior to accepting his appointment with UK, Inabnet served as the Eugene W. Friedman, M.D., Professor of Surgery with the Mount Sinai Health System in New York City and as surgical director of the Diabetes, Obesity and Metabolism Institute at the Icahn School of Medicine. With the expansion of Mount Sinai, he also served as the system chief of endocrine surgery for the eight-hospital Mount Sinai Health System and served as Chair of Surgery at Mount Sinai Beth Israel.
An international authority in the field of minimally invasive endocrine surgery, Inabnet is a pioneer of new techniques in minimal access endocrine neck surgery as well as adrenal and pancreatic surgery. In 1998, he performed the first endoscopic thyroid resection in the U.S. He is also a leader in the field of minimally invasive metabolic surgery with an interest in obesity, disorders of the endocrine system, and beta cell metabolism. Under his leadership the Mount Sinai Weight Loss Surgery Program has become one of the premier programs in the world.
The ACS Academy of Master Surgeon Educators works to advance the science and practice of education across all surgical specialties. Individuals are selected as members, associate members or affiliate members following a stringent peer review process. This year’s class includes members (27 inductees), associate members (36 inductees) and affiliate members (two inductees). The first inaugural class was inducted in 2018 and the academy has since grown to include 301 members, associate members and affiliate members who represent six surgical specialties other than general surgery. Inductees are from 22 states and the District of Columbia. They come from seven countries in addition to those from the United States.
Once inducted, Academy members actively engage in advancing the Academy’s programs and goals, which are to advance the science and practice of innovative lifelong surgical education, training, and scholarship in the changing milieu of health care; foster the exchange of creative ideas and collaboration; support the development and recognition of faculty; underscore the importance of lifelong surgical education and training; positively impact quality and patient safety through lifelong surgical education and training; disseminate advances in education and training to all surgeons; and offer mentorship to surgeon educators throughout their professional careers.
“This academy of preeminent surgeon educators has been making landmark contributions to surgical education and is introducing many transformational changes in surgical education that will endure into the future,” said Ajit K. Sachdeva, M.D., director of the ACS Division of Education and co-chair of the Steering Committee of the academy. “We look forward to leveraging the expertise of the members as we explore innovations that will continue to advance the field of surgical education and positively impact the careers of surgical educators.”
Academy members collaborate on and publish significant works of scholarship and participate in fireside chats, Grand Rounds Series and the Academy Symposium, an annual conference that brings together academy members to exchange best practices and discuss critical topics in surgical education. Through dynamic programming, members have addressed the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on surgical training, physician wellness and disparities in surgical education, among several other initiatives. The academy continues to focus on outreach to surgeon educators from across the globe, with a special emphasis on engaging surgeon educators from low-middle income countries. With this year’s induction ceremony, the academy will include more than 50 international members, representing 24 countries outside of the U.S.
“In addition to the recognition bestowed on highly deserving individuals, the academy is a vital, living body. It is a think tank, an impactful organization that explores and cultivates new innovations and interventions in an effort to establish best practices in surgical education,” said L.D. Britt, M.D., past president of the ACS, and co-chair of the Steering Committee of the academy.
To learn more about the Academy of Master Surgeon Educators, please visit the academy’s homepage.
About the American College of Surgeons
The American College of Surgeons is a scientific and educational organization of surgeons that was founded in 1913 to raise the standards of surgical practice and improve the quality of care for all surgical patients. The college is dedicated to the ethical and competent practice of surgery. Its achievements have significantly influenced the course of scientific surgery in America and have established it as an influential advocate for all surgical patients. The college has more than 84,000 members and is the largest organization of surgeons in the world. For more information, visit www.facs.org.
The University of Kentucky is increasingly the first choice for students, faculty and staff to pursue their passions and their professional goals. In the last two years, Forbes has named UK among the best employers for diversity, and INSIGHT into Diversity recognized us as a Diversity Champion four years running. UK is ranked among the top 30 campuses in the nation for LGBTQ* inclusion and safety. UK has been judged a “Great College to Work for” three years in a row, and UK is among only 22 universities in the country on Forbes’ list of “America’s Best Employers.”  We are ranked among the top 10 percent of public institutions for research expenditures — a tangible symbol of our breadth and depth as a university focused on discovery that changes lives and communities. And our patients know and appreciate the fact that UK HealthCare has been named the state’s top hospital for five straight years. Accolades and honors are great. But they are more important for what they represent: the idea that creating a community of belonging and commitment to excellence is how we honor our mission to be not simply the University of Kentucky, but the University for Kentucky.

source

Bass, Caruso focus on how to bridge L.A.'s racial divides – Los Angeles Times

Two days after racist comments on a secret audio recording rocked Los Angeles’ political leadership, the two candidates for mayor debated Tuesday night in a sober discussion that largely focused on which of them is best positioned to bridge racial divides and bring the city together.
The matchup between U.S. Rep. Karen Bass and developer Rick Caruso at Brokaw News Center in Universal City came hours after a large crowd packed L.A. City Hall chanting “fuera” — “out” in Spanish — and called for the resignations of top city officials, one of several moves Tuesday that left the future of L.A.’s leadership in doubt.
Bass contended that her experience as a lawmaker in Sacramento and Washington and, before that, as an organizer in South Los Angeles, made her uniquely qualified to form coalitions and bring about much-needed changes on racial strife, policing and homelessness.
Businessman Rick Caruso said he was better positioned to be a change agent, stating that the existing political leadership has failed.
The debate was hosted by NBC4 chief political reporter and anchor Conan Nolan, NBC4 anchor Colleen Williams and Noticiero Telemundo52 news anchor Dunia Elvir.
Speaking first, Caruso said he would fight for “a just, equitable and inclusive city.”

“We cannot tolerate hate speech or racism,” he added. “Certainly we can never tolerate it at the leadership level. What’s happened, it’s completely unacceptable and those who did it need to be held accountable.”
California
Rick Caruso and Karen Bass are running for Los Angeles mayor. Here is your guide to the race.

The businessman, who builds upscale shopping malls, said he would focus on the needs of the general public, unlike other elected officials at City Hall who he said operated in a “back room” where they “carve up the city for their own special interest for themselves.”

He intimated that Bass was tied to “corruption,” which was a reference to the congresswoman’s ties to USC and a nearly $100,000 scholarship she received to get a master’s degree in social work.
The dean who gave Bass the scholarship pleaded guilty in a federal bribery case in which City Councilman Mark Ridley-Thomas has also been charged, but federal officials have stated Bass isn’t a target in the investigation.
Caruso said the only positive element of the release of the audio recording that revealed City Council President Nury Martinez demeaning Black people and indigenous Mexican people was that it threw “the doors wide open and a big light came in,” revealing a “broken” system at City Hall.

“The reason homelessness is out of control is because the system is broken. The reason crime is out of control is because the system is broken,” Caruso said. “We need to change the direction. We need to [elect] new leadership that isn’t corrupt. That changes the direction of the city and makes it more livable.”
Bass said that while Caruso could talk about bringing in change and fresh ideas, she had spent decades actually working with a multiracial coalition in South Los Angeles.
She said the furor over the audio recordings of Martinez and fellow council members Kevin de León and Gil Cedillo was just the latest in a string of crises in the city that began with homelessness, housing affordability and public safety.

“Now, in the last 72 hours, another crisis has come to the forefront,” Bass said. “It is important to take stock, but it’s more important to move forward. There needs to be an investigation and those officials must resign. But that’s not enough. We need a new direction in L.A. and new leadership that will make sure we reject the politics of divide and conquer.”
She then pointed to her work as a community organizer, saying she had the credibility to heal the wounds between Latino and Black residents and leaders.
Before winning election to the state Assembly and Congress, Bass’ work in Los Angeles centered on the Community Coalition, a group that fought for economic and political opportunities for the working class.

When the topic turned to crime, Bass also mentioned her work in the 1990s at 85th and Broadway.
“Crips and Bloods, 1,000 homicides that year,” Bass said. ”I quit my job at teaching and went to the heart of the problem to bring communities together to solve crime.”
The debate lacked some of the fiery exchanges seen in last week’s matchup, and at points, the two complimented each other.

The sharpest exchange of the evening came when the moderators asked whether the candidates would pledge not to raise taxes to help homelessness.
Caruso quickly said he would make that pledge, calling Los Angeles one of the highest-taxed cities in the nation. Bass replied: “I would not make that pledge,” later adding that a crisis could develop that would require higher taxes.
“If people are dying on our streets and it is necessary, I might do that. I think there’s a lot of things to do before that,” she said.

Bass also dismissed Caruso’s attack on her for refusing to take a position. “To stand here and lie and pledge that I’m going to do something … I’m going to do whatever it takes to solve this problem.”
Bass said that she would seek to hire more police officers, and also work to get officers who are on desk jobs on the streets. Caruso touted his plan to hire 1,500 officers — although he faces challenges in getting them in quickly — and appeared to allude to past City Hall policy moves, such as cutting the LAPD in 2020 and moving the money to social services.
California
Mike Bonin reminded us that his colleagues’ petty, self-serving schemes have insulted a metropolis.

“The decisions that were made about defunding the police, disrespecting police, and not making sure the police have the support to do their job well — we are paying a price for that,” Caruso said.
Asked about homelessness, Caruso said government had failed businesses and he’d take a firmer line on rules that have to do with where people can sit, sleep or lie.
“At a certain point in time we’re not going to allow encampments on the streets,” he said. Bass was also insistent that streets are not for sleeping, but said the city can’t just jail people, warning it creates a cycle where people spend a few days in jail and go back to the street.

Bass pointed out as well that Caruso had never built a unit of affordable housing, while he lambasted her at various points for not doing enough to address homelessness during her congressional tenure.
Besides homelessness, the issues of the recent audio scandal dominated the debate.
Martinez, who resigned as City Council president on Monday, announced Tuesday that she was taking a leave of absence. De León and Cedillo have both apologized for their roles.

On a question about the racial turmoil in the city, Elvir, the Telemundo52 anchor, pointed out that “the next mayor of Los Angeles will be either an African American woman or a white man.”
Caruso interjected: “I’m Italian,” to smiles and chuckles all around.
Elvir responded: “Italian American.”
Caruso, seeming to suggest a link between his heritage and much of the city’s population, replied with a smile: “That’s Latin, thank you.”
Get Group Therapy
Life is stressful. Our weekly mental wellness newsletter can help.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
Follow Us
Dakota Smith covers Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti and City Hall for the Los Angeles Times.
Follow Us
James Rainey has covered multiple presidential elections, the media and the environment, mostly at the Los Angeles Times, which he first joined in 1984. He was part of Times teams that won three Pulitzer Prizes.

Follow Us
Benjamin Oreskes is a general assignment reporter in the Los Angeles Times’ California section.
California
California
Opinion
Opinion
Politics
Food
Food
Television
California

California

California

California

California

Subscribe for unlimited access
Follow Us

source

Ultimate Podcast Setup

More than 100,000 students are trying to live on $26 a day. How is this the norm in Australia? – The Guardian

We can’t expect young people to thrive at university if they live significantly below the poverty line
Unless you are privileged, getting a university degree is becoming harder and harder. With indexation on Hecs-Help debts increasing amid a cost-of-living crisis, rising rents and an increase in casualised and below minimum wage jobs, students are suffering.
Last week the National Union of Students released our report Locked Out of Youth Allowance: Student Poverty & Centrelink in Australia. Drawing from surveys, interviews, polling and economic modelling, the report highlights the vivid intersectionality between being young and being poor.
We have been hearing for years about students who are struggling, students coming to our doors in tears because they have nowhere to sleep. We now have the numbers that show just how grim the world is for many students.
The age of independence, according to Services Australia, is now 22. This means your ability to claim student welfare including youth allowance is means tested on your parent’s income until you turn 22, unless there are exceptional circumstances. One student told the union: “If the age of independence had been lower, I would have been able to get away from my abusive parents at a younger age.”
Eight per cent of students who are unable to access youth allowance said it worsened their experience of family violence and kept them living in an unsafe environment. “The scariest part of it was that I needed verification from my parents that it was unreasonable to live at home,” 23-year-old Darcy said. The system requires many young people to rely on their abusers signing their ticket to safety. What a horrific notion.
Services Australia doesn’t help this situation either. It demands police reports, psychologists’ reports and statements from parents – things which are often inaccessible in a time of need.
A well-funded and accessible social security policy can change lives. Darcy explained how receiving the Covid supplement was the first time in their life they had experienced financial stability: “It’s actually this easy to not suffer.” The supplement highlighted that this suffering is not necessary: and that student poverty is a consequence of government policy.
It would cost the budget approximately $5.3bn to lower the age of independence to 18. This would allow 450,000 students to be lifted out of poverty and increase their standard of living. How can we possibly expect young people to be happy, healthy and thriving at university if they are living significantly below the poverty line?
University education is returning to a place where only the privileged few who have pre-existing support are able to attend. This is especially true for students moving out to study. During orientation weeks this year, we travelled around the country talking to students about their issues. It was tragic to hear how many students were suffering due to the illogical and bureaucratic rules surrounding youth allowance. We now know that more than half of students who live out of home to study aren’t able to access youth allowance. Additionally, 110,000 students are attempting to live on a mere $26 a day. One in seven students are regularly skipping meals because of financial hardship. A student we talked to remarked that they dumpster dived a lot to survive.
How is this the norm in Australia? We don’t understand how the Albanese government is willing to give out stage-three tax cuts that will predominantly benefit wealthy Australian homeowners, yet unwilling to take a position on whether it will end student poverty by providing an essential safety net for young renters.
Polling undertaken for NUS found that 58% of people support the government lowering the age of independence from 22 to 18, so full-time students can access Centrelink support while they study. Meanwhile, Labor is persisting with stage-three tax cuts – which could easily go towards ending student poverty – despite only 22% of people in support of them. It’s a no-brainer that the government should give support to those in poverty rather than those already on comfortable salaries.
The Albanese Government has the power to end student poverty in the next budget by lowering Centrelink’s age of independence from 22 to 18, lifting social security payments to above the poverty line (at least $88 a day), adjusting Centrelink payments twice a year with the cost of living, and updating rent assistance payments in line with market rents.
The ball is in your court, Albo.
Georgie Beatty is the president of the National Union of Students and Billy Zimmermann is the NUS welfare officer

source

‹ Previous Next ›