Danganronpa Voice Actor Returns For Master Detective Archives: Rain Code Nintendo Life
source
Role of income and government responsiveness in reducing the death toll from floods in Indian states | Scientific Reports – Nature.com
Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 16978 (2022)
Metrics details
Floods are the most commonly occurring natural disasters in India due to India’s unique geographical location and socioeconomic conditions. Frequent flooding causes enormous loss of human lives and damage crops and public utilities. Furthermore, floods adversely affect economic development and increase the government’s financial burden by increasing spending on various disaster mitigation measures. Recent empirical literature based on cross-national comparisons shows that disaster fatalities and damages are monotonically decreasing in per capita income. We challenge this view on the monotonic negative relationship between income and flood damages. We examine the non-monotonic (inverted U-shaped) relationship between per capita income and flood impact in terms of deaths, people affected, and damages due to floods in 19 major Indian states from 1980 to 2011, using Poisson and Tobit estimation methods. In particular, deaths and the population affected by floods increase with a turning point of income up to 882 US$ and 578 US$, respectively, and diminishes thereafter. Our results confirm an inverted U-shaped relationship between income and fatalities and the population affected by floods. In addition to income, we argue that government responsiveness plays an essential role in mitigating the risk of floods. We employ the fixed-effect Poisson estimation method to examine the government’s role in protecting people against disaster risk, focusing on regional differences in India. Deaths from floods remain non-linear and follow the inverted U-pattern with respect to government responsiveness. However, the effect of government responsiveness on flood fatalities and flood damages is statistically insignificant. Our results further suggest that high-income states experience a lower death toll from floods. The high-income (rich) states are capable of incurring a higher threshold level of income and higher natural calamity expenditure to reduce flood fatalities and protect the population affected by floods than the low-income (poor) states. The poor states have minimal resources and face severe financial constraints to reduce the death toll from floods. From the perspective of public policy, the poor states, in particular, require an increase in income, better governance, and effective disaster management policies to mitigate flood impact.
India is one of the most flood-affected nations globally after China (Emergency Events Database, (EM-DAT))1. India’s geo-climatic conditions have caused severe flood fatalities and damages. Moreover, other factors such as higher flood-prone regions, irregular rainfall, higher population density, deforestation, illegal constructions, and environmental degradation have contributed to increasing flood damage in the Indian states. According to the EM-DAT, 194 floods occurred in China, which is the highest among the nations, followed by India (190), Indonesia (126), Philippines (109), and Bangladesh (69) over the period 1980 to 2011. Overall, in India, floods account for 53%, followed by cyclones (21%), landslides (10%), cold waves (6.4%), earthquakes (4.2%), and droughts (2%) over the same period. Flood is recorded as the costliest disaster in India, accounting for 68% of economic losses over all-natural disasters damages. It is India’s second most lethal disaster after the earthquake. Between 1980 and 2011, floods were the costliest among all disasters in India, accounting for 68% of total disaster-related damages, followed by cyclones (16%), earthquakes (10%), droughts (4%), hear-wave (0.8%), cold-wave (0.29%) and landslides (0.11%). Moreover, earthquake is the most lethal disaster in India, accounting for 39 percent of deaths considering all-natural disaster deaths, followed by floods (32%), Cyclones (17%), heat-wave (6%), cold-wave (4%), landslides (2%), and droughts (03%).
India lost around 0.46% of gross domestic product (GDP), damages to crops stood at 0.18% of GDP, 1.6 million houses were damaged, damage to public utilities stood at around 0.21% of GDP, and 6% of the rural population were affected due to floods annually2. In addition, flood impact builds fiscal pressure on the government through spending on flood protection measures and creating flood-resilient infrastructure. Based on the socioeconomic condition of the states, high-income (rich) states in India have experienced lower flood fatalities, and fewer people have been adversely affected than the low-income (poor) states. Moreover, rich states spend more on post-disaster mitigation measures than poor states (See Supplementary Information, Appendix Table A.1). Many empirical studies show that countries with higher per capita income experience lower disaster deaths than developing countries3,4. We argue that per capita income is not adequate to minimize the disaster impacts. Therefore, the government’s role is also crucial in protecting citizens against natural disasters. In this context, few studies show that stronger institutions and improved governance help reduce deaths from natural disasters3,5. The Indian government spends around 0.23% of Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) on relief distribution, evacuation, and rehabilitation measures (see Appendix Table A.1). Still, this proportion of public expenditure directed toward disaster risk reduction is not adequate for India. We argue that in addition to increasing per capita income level, the extent of government intervention should be enhanced to implement better disaster management efforts to mitigate the disaster risk in Indian states.
First time in the empirical literature6, analyzed the non-linear (inverted U-shaped) relationship between per capita income and various pollution indicators. Subsequently, in the economics of disaster literature, a few studies have empirically shown a non-linear (inverted U-shaped) relationship between disaster risk and income using cross-country panel data7,8,9. These studies show that initially, disaster risk increases with income and then declines when income has reached a certain threshold level. In the Indian context, no empirical study has addressed the inverted U-type relationship between flood fatalities and per capita income. We argue that flood fatalities and damages initially increase with increasing per capita income, and then deaths and damages decline when per capita income increases further. In a developing economy like India, societies spend more income on basic needs in the initial phase, and less money is spent on safety and disaster preparedness measures. Over the period, when society’s per capita income increases, the demand for safety rises because income provides insurance against natural disasters.
Similarly, we examine the inverted U-shaped relationship between government responsiveness and flood fatalities. The primary reason is that the government spends more on social security programs such as poverty reduction, health, and education in the initial phase. Therefore, fewer resources are devoted to disaster management efforts. This is consistent with the idea that individuals tend to spend more on basic consumption needs in the initial period and spend less income on disaster preparedness activities. Over the period, society’s demand for disaster mitigation measures increases, and therefore, eventually, the government budgetary allocation increases towards disaster risk reduction measures. Given that disaster preparedness and responses depend on the nation’s wealth and governance structure, we focus on two essential components: economic development (proxied by per capita income) and better governance (proxied by natural calamity expenditure) that can help mitigate damages and fatalities from natural disasters.
In this framework, our paper examines the impact of income and government responsiveness on fatalities and damages caused by floods in Indian states. Using a state-wise panel data on annual deaths and population affected due to floods in 19 Indian states from 1980 to 2011, our study has the following objectives: First, do income and flood fatalities (and population affected) exhibit a non-linear (inverted U-type) relationship in all Indian states? Second, when flood disasters occur, how many fewer deaths are caused in high-income (rich) Indian states than in low-income (poor) states. Third, does government responsiveness (proxied by natural calamity expenditure) reduce the flood impact (measured by deaths and population affected due to floods)? Government responsiveness is described as how the government responds during and in post-flooding situations and provides necessary services to citizens to minimize the flooding impact. This also includes ex-ante measures such as building up flood-resilient infrastructure and devising suitable flood control measures to alleviate flood risk.
We employ a fixed effect (FE) Poisson and FE negative binomial methods to achieve the aforementioned objectives. To analyze regional heterogeneity, we divide the Indian states into high-income (rich) and low-income (poor) states, following10. The low-income states include states located in India’s north and eastern parts. All states are not equally affected by floods and are also not capable of spending substantially on natural disasters due to their locational disadvantages and lack of disaster-resilient infrastructure. For instance, the north-east and east states are highly vulnerable to floods and belong to the category of low-income states (see Appendix Table A.1).
We contribute to the literature by highlighting the non-monotonic relationship between per capita income and flood impact (measured by deaths and population affected by floods). We argue that flood fatalities and damages initially increase with an increase in income and then it declines when income rises further. Second, we argue that government responsiveness (proxied by natural calamity expenditure) also exhibits a non-linear relationship with deaths and damages caused by floods. The impact of per capita income and government responsiveness on flood fatalities is studied for India’s high-income and low-income states while controlling socioeconomic factors, political alignment, and severity of floods. In the context of India, no empirical work exists that explains the non-linear relationship between income and deaths and damages caused by floods. Our focus on regional differences in India has much potential. In addition to income, institutions also play a critical role in protecting Indian states from disaster shocks. An empirical analysis of government responsiveness to mitigate flood disaster risk is missing in the literature. Therefore, we fill the gap by measuring the quantitative importance of government responsiveness to reducing flood impact.
Several empirical studies confirmed that higher Gross Domestic Product (GDP) per capita reduces disaster damages and fatalities11,12,13. These studies using macro panel data argued that countries with a higher GDP per capita experience lower deaths and damages from natural disasters. Parida11 employed instrumental variables (IV) Poisson and fixed effect (FE) Tobit estimation methods to examine the impact of economic development on flood fatalities and damages in Indian states. The results suggest that states with higher per capita income help reduce fatalities and damages. Anbarci et al.12 examined the impact of income inequality and per capita income on earthquake fatalities using cross country dataset. The FE negative binomial result shows that income inequality minimizes the earthquake fatalities. Strömberg13 examined the impact of per capita income and the role of governance on disaster fatalities using data from high, middle, and low-income countries. The ordinary least squares and instrumental variable (IV) estimates confirm that countries with better governance and higher income help minimize deaths from disasters. The study also shows that developed countries experience 70% lower deaths than low-income countries.
Toya and Skidmore4 emphasized the two essential components of the disaster-income-safety relationship. Using the ordinary least squares (OLS) estimation method, they showed that, on the one hand, a higher level of income raises the private demand for safety. On the other hand, high income enables individuals and countries to be better equipped to respond to disaster risks by employing several precautionary measures. Kahn3 used Zero-inflated negative binomial estimation to examine the impact of institutions’ quality and economic development on disaster fatalities. Their empirical findings show that fatalities reduce as income increases and that the number of deaths is higher in less democratic countries than in more democratic countries. Sadowski and Sutter14 examined the impact of income, occurrence of hurricanes, and higher population density on hurricane damages and fatalities in the United States. The Poisson regression estimates indicate that income is negatively related to damages while the occurrence of hurricanes is positively associated with fatalities.
Keefer et al.15 examined the relationship between earthquake propensity and earthquake fatalities using a zero-inflated negative binomial model. The empirical results confirm that mortality is lower in countries with higher earthquake propensity because of higher investment in earthquake preparedness. Cavallo et al.16 examined the economic losses due to the earthquake in Haiti. The fixed effects estimates confirm that higher earthquake mortalities lead to an increase in the damage caused by the earthquake in Haiti. Escaleras and Register17 employed a quantile regression method to analyze the relationship between fiscal decentralization and death from natural disasters using a cross-country dataset from 1972 to 2000. The results confirm that higher sub-national expenditure helps mitigate the death from disasters. In sum, all these studies suggest that fatalities and damages due to floods are monotonically decreasing in per capita income.
In contrast, another set of studies shows that the relationship between GDP per capita (or income per capita) and deaths and damages from natural disasters is not always monotonic; instead, it is non-monotonic that is characterized by an inverted U-shaped relationship, where damages from disasters initially increase and then finally decrease with income. Kellenberg and Mobarak7 examined the non-linear (inverted U-type) relation between income and deaths from disasters using negative binomial and pooled generalized least squares (GLS) methods. The results confirm that disaster deaths increase until a certain threshold level of GDP per capita is reached and then decline when the GDP per capita crosses the threshold level. Ferreira et al.9 evaluated the non-linear relation between economic development and flood fatalities using FE Poisson and FE negative binomial. The results show that income produces a significant indirect effect on flood fatalities and that this effect is non-monotonic, with net reductions in disaster deaths taking place in low-income countries. Schumacher and Strobl8 showed that the non-linear relationship between economic losses caused by disasters and economic development depends on how the particular countries are exposed to disasters. Using the Tobit estimation method, they empirically showed how countries with a low disaster risk face increasing losses in the initial stage, followed by a phase where they face decreasing losses with increasing economic development. Results suggest an inverted U-shaped relationship between economic development and disaster losses for the countries with low disaster risk. At the same time, countries experiencing a high risk of disasters suffer decreasing losses initially and then increasing ones with rising economic development.
Besides GDP per capita’s impact, countries with improved institutional quality experience a lower impact of deaths and lower economic damages from natural disasters3. Raschky5 analyzed the relationship between the institution’s role and losses from natural disasters using cross country dataset. The OLS estimates show that better institutions (a proxy of government stability) that bring an improved allocation of resources help reduce disaster losses. North18 pointed out that countries with better institutions and governance structures invest more in physical and human capital and efficiently utilize their factor endowment. This shows a nation’s ability to mitigate the adverse impacts of natural disasters when equipped with better institutions and effective governance. Garrett and Sobel19 employed the Poisson regression model to analyze the relationship between disaster declaration and allocation of disaster expenditure in an election year in the United States. The empirical results confirm that disaster declarations are higher in states with political importance to the presidents. Besley and Burgess20 analyzed the political economy of government responsiveness using state-wise data in India. The FE estimates show that greater flood damages and higher newspaper circulation improve government responsiveness in the Indian states.
We estimate three equations to analyze the non-linear (inverted U-type) relationship between per capita income and flood measures such as fatalities, the population affected, and damages due to floods in high-and low-income states of India.
where s represents State {1….19} and t represents the year {1980…2011}, (FF_{st}) denote fatalities in state s and year t, (PA_{st} ) indicates population affected due to floods, and (FD_{st }) denotes natural logarithm of the ratio of flood damage over Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP); ( ln{text{PCY}}_{{{text{st}} – 1}}) is the natural logarithm of lag of per capita income (PCI), (lnPCY_{st – 1}^{2}) denotes the squared natural logarithm of per capita income (PCI) that captures the non-linearities between income and flood fatalities. This implies (beta_{1} > 0 ;and; beta_{2} < 0), revealing an inverted U-shaped relationship between flood fatalities and (ln{text{PCY}}_{{{text{it}} – 1}}). In Eq. (1) the turning point of PCI where flood fatalities (FF) are at a maximum, is given by: (frac{{partial FF_{it} }}{{partial lnPCI_{it – 1} }} = beta_{1} + 2beta_{2} lnPCI_{it – 1} = 0,{text{turning point }}left( {uptau } right) = {text{exp}}left( {frac{{ – beta_{1} }}{{2beta_{2} }} } right)). (left( {frac{NCE}{{GSDP}}} right)_{st – 1}) is the lag of the ratio of natural calamity expenditure (NCE) over GSDP and (left( {frac{NCE}{{GSDP}}} right)_{st – 1}^{2}) is the squared lag of the ratio of natural calamity expenditure (NCE) over GSDP. These two variables capture the non-linear relationship between natural calamity expenditure and flood fatalities. In Eq. (1), (beta_{3} > 0 ;and; beta_{4} < 0) reveal an inverted U-shaped relationship between flood fatalities and natural calamity expenditure (NCE). The turning point of natural calamity expenditure where flood fatalities (FF) are at the maximum is given by (frac{{partial FF_{it} }}{{partial left( {frac{NCE}{{GSDP}}} right)_{st – 1} }} = beta_{3} + 2beta_{4} left( {frac{NCE}{{GSDP}}} right)_{st – 1} = 0, {text{turning point }}left( {uptau } right) = left( {frac{{ – beta_{3} }}{{2beta_{4} }} } right).)
In Eq. (2), (alpha_{1} > 0; and ;alpha_{2} < 0) reveal an inverted U-shaped relationship between the population affected and PCI. The turning point of PCI at which the population affected is maximum is given by (left( {uptau } right) = {text{exp}}left( {frac{{ – alpha_{1} }}{{2alpha_{2} }} } right)). In addition, (alpha_{3} > 0; and; alpha_{4} < 0) represent the inverted U-shaped relationship between the population affected and NCE. In other words, the turning point of NCE where the population affected are at the maximum, is given by (left( {uptau } right) = left( {frac{{ – alpha_{3} }}{{2alpha_{4} }} } right)). In Eq. (3), (delta_{1} > 0; and; delta_{2} < 0) show the inverted U-shaped relationship between flood damages and PCI. The turning point of PCI at which flood damages are at the maximum, is given by (left( {uptau } right) = {text{exp}}left( {frac{{ – delta_{1} }}{{2delta_{2} }} } right)). Moreover, (delta_{3} > 0 and delta_{4} < 0), which reveals an inverted U-shaped relationship between flood damages and NCE. The turning point of NCE at which flood damages are at the maximum, is given by (left( {uptau } right) = {text{exp}}left( {frac{{ – delta_{3} }}{{2delta_{4} }} } right)).
({text{SED}}_{{text{st }}}) is the state election dummy equal to 1 for the years in which elections are held in a State; otherwise, it is zero. ({text{NED}}_{{text{st }}} { }) is the national election dummy, which is equal to 1 for the years in which elections are held at the national-level; otherwise, it is zero. ({text{PAD}}_{{text{st }}}) takes on a value of 1 if the State and Centre have the same political party in power; otherwise, it is zero. The flood-affected area dummies (AD) are created by categorizing the state-wise flood-affected area into four categories. This helps control flood magnitude in the empirical analysis. For a detailed discussion, see the section on ‘Data sources.’
The variable of interest is economic development (proxied by the lag of PCI and squared lag of PCI). The other variable of interest is the lag of government responsiveness and the squared lag of government responsiveness (proxied by natural calamities expenditure as % of GSDP). The control variables (({text{Z}}_{{{text{st}} – 1{ }}} )) are common to all three econometric specifications. These variables include proxies for coping strategies, such as financial development (measured as total credit outstanding as a percentage of GSDP), forest cover (measured as log of forest cover/total state area), and flood control and prevention expenditure measures. The other control variables include rural head count ratio: the number of rural people living below the poverty line (as a percentage of rural population), population density, the severity of floods, an election year, and political alignment. We have used the 1-year lagged values of the explanatory variables to control for potential endogeneity issues. (theta_{s} ) is time-invariant state-specific fixed effects whereas (gamma_{t}) captures time-specific heterogeneity. (mu_{st}) is a normally distributed error term.
The outcome variables are flood fatalities and population affected in Eqs. (1) and (2), respectively. Flood fatalities and population affected are measured as the number of people who were killed and affected due to floods in different states in the respective years. Both the outcome variables are non-negative count variables. As shown in Appendix Table A.1, the variances of the two variables exceed their respective means implying that flood fatalities and population affected variables are overdispersed. This violates the normality assumption of the Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) model. In this particular case, the OLS method of estimation yields biased results. Therefore, using FE Poisson and Negative Binomial models is more appropriate to estimate Eqs. (1) and (2). In particular, the overdispersion of dependent variables violates the fundamental assumption of the FE Poisson model. Therefore, the Negative Binomial is favoured over the FE Poisson. The Deviance goodness-of-fit and Pearson goodness-of-fit test results suggest that FE Negative binomial is appropriate in our dataset. However, overdispersion test results suggest that the FE Poisson estimate is appropriate for our dataset (See Appendix Table A.2)21. Therefore, we have estimated both models.
However, as9 pointed out, a limitation of the negative binomial is that it controls less robustly for unobserved time-invariant country-specific heterogeneity. Furthermore, FE Negative Binomial efficiently controls the time-invariant unobserved fixed effects when the number of cross-sectional units is less than 20 (in our case, the number of states = 19)22. In contrast to the Negative Binomial, the FE Poisson completely controls the unobserved time-invariant fixed effects, which could be a plausible cause of overdispersion9,23. We estimate Eqs. (1) and (2) using both FE Negative Binomial and FE Poisson methods, keeping in mind the advantages and disadvantages of both models. A few studies used FE Negative Binomial and FE Poisson estimates in the disaster fatalities dataset9,11. We apply the FE Tobit estimation technique to estimate Eq. (3) as the outcome variable is flood damages (FD_{st }) is defined as ln [ (left( { frac{Total ;Damages }{{GSDP}}} right) + 1 ]) has a lot of observations that have zero values.
In this study, we have compiled data for India’s 19 major states from 1980 to 2011. The state-wise flood information such as fatalities, the population affected, flood damages, and area affected by floods are taken from Central Water Commission (CWC)24 reports, Ministry of Jal Shakti, Department of Water Resources, River Development and Ganga Rejuvenation, Government of India. The CWC reports do not provide state-wise flood magnitude, one of the important measures to determine the severity of floods. Thus, we have followed the method described by25 for estimating the state-wise severity of floods. To measure the severity of a flood, we have divided the area affected by floods into four categories for 19 states from 1980 to 2011. The first quartile (the area affected is less than 25%) denoted by less severe flood dummy is set equal to 1; otherwise, zero; the second quartile (moderate flood), the state-wise area affected by floods lies between 25 and 49% is equal to 1; otherwise, zero; the third quartile (high flood), the area affected by floods lies between 50 and 74% is equal to 1; otherwise zero; the fourth quartile (severe flood), the area affected by floods lie above 75% is equal to 1; otherwise zero. For a detailed discussion regarding the definition of all categories of the flood magnitude, see Appendix Table A.1.
We have taken Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP) data at a constant price from the Ministry of Statistics and Program Implementation, Government of India. The natural calamity expenditure and expenditure for flood control are taken from the Reserve Bank of India. The forest cover data are taken from Land Use Statistics. The financial development (proxied by credit outstanding) has been taken from the Economic and Political Weekly (EPW) research foundation. The state-wise population data are available decennially from the Census of India. We have linearly interpolated the population data to fill up the gap year population. The rural poverty head count ratio data for each State is taken from the Planning Commission’s26 report.
We have included dummies for state elections, national elections, and political alignment in our econometric specification. State elections and political alignment between the centre and states influence the degree of flood fatalities, and healthy centre-state coordination is required to mitigate the effects of floods11. The election data are taken from the Election Commission of India. We have constructed the political alignment dummy using the Election Commission of India dataset. The definition and summary statistics of all variables are shown in Appendix Table A.1.
On average, 93 people were killed annually, and around 2 million people were affected due to floods in major 19 over the period 1980–2011. The average per capita income is Rs. 21,774 (712 US$), and the government spends around 0.233% of GSDP on natural calamities. Based on per capita income, as suggested by10, we have divided our dataset into high-income (rich) and low-income (poor) states. The low-income states include the north-east and east states of India. The 9 high-income states are Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Karnataka, Kerala, Maharashtra, Punjab, and Tamil Nadu. The 10 poor states (including north-east and east states) include Assam, Bihar, Jammu and Kashmir, Madhya Pradesh, Manipur, Odisha, Rajasthan, Tripura, Utter Pradesh, West Bengal.
In the high-income states, on average, around 80 people were killed, and 1.06 million were affected due to floods over the period 1980–2011. Moreover, high-income states’ average per capita income is Rs. 27,794.76 (908.3 US$), and direct government spending for evacuation, relief distribution, and rehabilitation purposes is around 0.24% of GSDP. In the low-income states, 105 people were killed, and around 3 million people were affected annually. The average per capita income of low-income states is Rs.16354.6 (534.5 US$), and expenditure on natural calamities is around 0.23% of GSDP. The data shows that more people were killed, and many people were affected due to floods in low-income states than in high-income states. In addition, the high-income states are better-off due to their initial conditions of higher per capita income and expenditures on natural calamities than the low-income states.
The regression results of FE negative binomial and FE Poisson estimates for Eq. (1) are reported in Table 1. The outcome variable is flood fatalities in all states. We use both regression models for estimation purposes because one model is advantageous over another. FE Poisson model controls more efficiently time-invariant unobserved state-specific heterogeneity. We introduce year dummy and state dummy to control time-variant and time-invariant unobserved state heterogeneity factors in all regression estimates. Also, we include cluster standard errors at the state level in all estimates.
The coefficient of per capita income (PCI) is positive, and its squared coefficient is negative and significant without taking into account control variables in FE Poisson estimation (see column C1 of Table 1). These results indicate a non-linear relationship between deaths from floods and per capita income, and it follows an inverted U-shaped relation with respect to per capita income. Our findings are mirror findings by7,9. The turning point estimate of PCI is Rs. 38,803 (1268 US$), which lies at the 90th percentile distribution of our data sample (see column C1). The results imply that deaths from floods increase when per capita income is less than the turning point of PCI at Rs. 38,803 (1268 US$), and deaths decline further when income rises beyond the turning point of PCI at Rs. 38,803 (1268 US$).
Still, we find the inverted U-shaped relationship between flood fatalities and PCI after considering other control variables such as disaster adaptation measures and political factors (see column C2 of Table 1). The turning point of PCI is 38,424 (1256 US$), which is lower than Rs. 38,803 (1268 US$). In our final regression estimates, the relation for PCI remains inverted U-shaped after controlling flood magnitude in column C3. The coefficient plots are shown in Fig. 1a–c, which explain the non-linear relationship between per capita income and flood deaths for All, high-income, and low-income states. Here, we provide the plot for the key variables used in the study. The coefficient of PCI is positive, and the coefficient of its squared term is negative, which shows that flood fatalities in all states are higher in the initial phase, and then deaths decline as PCI increases further.
Coefficient plot—flood fatalities and income and Government responsiveness.
The turning points of per capita income are estimated using the linear and quadratic coefficients of the respective variables. Moreover, we use sample data to estimate the percentile value of the turning point of per capita income. In all states, the turning point of PCI is Rs. 26,980 (882 US$), which indicates that fatalities increase initially till the threshold income and thereafter decline with a further rise in PCI (see Fig. 2). We calculate the flood-related deaths using our sample data. The number of deaths from floods is 47,328 when the PCI is less than the turning point. When PCI crosses the turning point income, the flood fatalities reduce to 9408.
Turning point for flood fatalities with respect to per capita income-all states, high-income, and low-income states.
The magnitude of the turning point of PCI declines further from 1268 US$ to 882 US$ (lies at the 75th percentile distribution of our data) after controlling socio-economic and political covariates. Our estimates suggest that flood fatalities increase with increasing PCI up to 882 US$, then it declines when PCI is above 882 US$. We argue that we find the non-linear (inverted U-shaped) relationship in all three estimations (see columns C1, C2, and C3 of Table 1); however, the magnitude of the turning point of PCI varies.
We also estimate Eq. (1) using FE Poisson model to examine the non-linear (inverted U-shaped) relationship between per capita income and flood deaths for high-income and low-income states. The Poisson estimates are presented in Appendix Table A.3. To account for regional differences, we segregate our data into high-and low-income states. Higher flood fatalities and larger number of people are affected by floods in low-income states due to their higher poverty levels (measured by head count ratio) and inadequate disaster-resilient infrastructure (proxied by public expenditure on flood control and irrigation) (see Appendix Table A.1).
In the case of high-income states, we find that the coefficient of the linear term of per capita income is positive and statistically significant, and the coefficient of the squared term of income is negative and significant. This implies that the behavior of flood deaths is highly non-linear and follows the inverted U-pattern with respect to per capita income for high-income states (see Appendix Table A.3). This nonlinear relationship between flood deaths and income is presented in Fig. 1b. High-income states experience a lower level of flood deaths because higher income and stronger financial sectors help mitigate the effects of floods. Our estimates show a turning point of Rs. 40,764 (1332 US$), which suggests that flood deaths increase with a per capita income of less than Rs. 40,764 and then deaths decrease in per capita income for high-income states. Flood fatalities stood at 19,177 when the per capita income was less than the turning point income. As PCI crosses the turning point income, flood fatalities reduce to 3912 (see Fig. 2). Therefore, we find the existence of non-linearity (inverted U-shaped), as suggested by the theory.
For low-income states, the positive coefficient on per capita income and the negative coefficient on squared per capita income indicate the non-linear (inverted U-type) relationship between income and flood fatalities (see Appendix Table A.3). However, both coefficients are insignificant, implying that the non-linear relationship is weak. Our estimates show that deaths from floods are 25,025 when the PCI is less than the turning point income of Rs. 17,886 (585 US$). Furthermore, if PCI crosses the turning point income, flood fatalities reduce to 8622 (see Fig. 2). We find that low-income states experience higher deaths from floods than high-income states. This is because of the initial conditions of poverty and lack of adequate infrastructure in poor states.
Apart from income’s role in preventing flood fatalities, government responsiveness (proxied by government expenditure on natural calamities) plays a crucial role in mitigating flood fatalities (see Table 1). The coefficients of natural calamity expenditure are positive, and the squared terms are negative and insignificant. This implies an inverted U-shaped relationship between natural calamity expenditure and flood fatalities; however, this relationship is weak (see column C1 of Table 1). Furthermore, the relation remains inverted U-type with respect to natural calamity expenditure after considering other control variables (columns C2–C3 of Table 1). Moreover, it can be observed that the parametric estimates of the FE Poisson model are larger than their negative binomial estimates. The larger magnitudes of coefficients of variables in the FE Poisson estimate can be attributed to complete control for unobserved state-specific effects9. The coefficient plots are shown in Fig. 1a–c, which explain the non-linear relationship between government responsiveness and flood deaths for All, high-income, and low-income states. Flood fatalities increase with government responsiveness at low levels of governance and decrease with responsiveness at high levels of governance.
The turning point of the natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP is 0.87 (lies at 97% percentile, column C3 of Table 1). The estimates suggest that flood fatalities increase when natural calamity expenditure (NCE) as a percentage of GSDP is less than 0.87%, then it declines further when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP is above 0.87%, but the relationship is weak. The inverted U-type relationship between NCE and deaths from floods is shown in Fig. 3. The results suggest that the current government expenditure for the mitigation of flood risk is not adequate. Around 53,200 people have been killed in all states due to floods when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP is lower than 0.87% (turning point). Nearly 3536 people have died when the turning point of NCE as a percentage of GSDP reaches above 0.87%. Therefore, higher government spending to protect citizens against natural calamities is essential to reduce flood mortality.
Turning point for flood fatalities with Government responsiveness—all states, high-income, and low-income states.
In high-income states, flood fatalities are 22,883 when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP is lower than 1.46% (turning point). Flood deaths reduce to 206 when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP crosses the turning point. The results suggest that rich states with better spending on natural disasters suffer less death from floods. Greater government spending helps mitigate the effects of floods. However, low-income states with relatively lower ability to spend on disasters experience a U-shaped relationship between flood fatalities and government responsiveness. The governance responsiveness turning point lies outside our dataset, suggesting that government responsiveness provides protection but at a diminishing rate. This implies that states with lower income and inadequate government responsiveness are more likely to suffer greater flood-related deaths than developed states. This is consistent with4 findings, which suggest that countries with higher economic development are less likely to experience disaster deaths.
Additionally, disaster adaptation measures such as financial development, forest cover, and flood control expenditure are not sufficient to alleviate flood fatalities. The state election and existing political alignment between State and the Centre help to minimize flood fatalities. This finding is consistent with the results of11. The findings suggest that the central government releases favorable grants and soft loans to respective state governments with the same or coalition political party ruling the State. Moreover, if a flood disaster occurs in the state election year, incumbent state governments try to manage the flood calamity efficiently. The management work further helps the ruling government to enhance its prospects of winning the election. Also, the flood magnitude dummy (moderate, high, and severe) is positively related to flood fatalities (see column C3). This is in line with the findings of9 and11. The less developed states with a higher poverty ratio and higher population density are likely to experience higher flood fatalities.
We evaluate the impact of PCI and government responsiveness on the population affected by floods, controlling for socio-political and flood magnitudes in high-and low-income states. The FE Poisson method is used to estimate Eq. (2), and the results are reported in Tables 3 and Appendix A.2. Our results show that an inverted U-type relationship between per capita income and the population affected by floods exists in all states, high-income, and low-income states. However, the inverted U-shaped relationship with respect to income is not significant for the low-income states. Therefore, a significant increase in PCI is required to mitigate the effects from floods in the poor states. The coefficient plots are shown in Fig. 4a–c, which shows the non-linear relationship between PCI and the population affected by floods in All, high-income, and low-income states.
Coefficient plot—population affected and Income and Government responsiveness.
We estimate the turning point of PCI at which the population affected by floods is the maximum (see Fig. 5). The population affected was 855.9 million in all states when the PCI was less than the turning point PCI (578 US$). Thereafter, the population affected by floods declined by 343.7 million when income crossed the turning point PCI. The population affected in high-income states was 179.7 million when the PCI was less than the turning point PCI (647 US$). When income crossed the turning point PCI, the population affected reduced to 126.1 million. In low-income states, the population affected was 839.7 million when the PCI was less than the turning point PCI (850 US$). When income crossed the turning point PCI, the population affected reduced to 54.2 million. We conclude that poor states require higher turning point PCI to lessen the number of people affected by floods than rich states.
Turning point for population affected by floods with per capita income-all states, high income, and low-income states.
In addition, we employ the FE Poisson estimation method to examine the non-linear relationship between government responsiveness and the population affected by floods in All, high-income, and low-income states using Eq. (2). The results of Poisson estimates are shown in Table 2 and Appendix Table A.3, and the coefficient plot of the key variables is shown in Fig. 4a–c. The estimated results show an inverted U-shaped relationship between government responsiveness and the population affected by floods in high-income and low-income states; however, the inverted U-type relation is weak for both states. The result concludes that government responsiveness is still ineffective in mitigating the disastrous flood impact in Indian states.
We also estimate the turning point of government responsiveness and the number of people affected by floods below and above the turning point of government responsiveness (see Fig. 6). In all states, population affected was 1149.6 million when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP was lower than 0.9% of GSDP (turning point). The number of persons affected reduced to 50.02 million when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP crossed the turning point. In high-income states, the population affected was 278.6 million when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP was lower than 1.15% of GSDP. If government responsiveness crossed the turning point, the number of persons affected reduced to 17.1 million. In low-income states, the population affected was 256 million when natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP was lower than 0.13% of GSDP. If government responsiveness crossed the turning point, the population affected reduced to 637.9 million.
Turning point for population affected by floods with Government responsiveness—all states, high income, and low-income states.
Moreover, financial development, forest cover, and flood control expenditure have no significant effect on lowering the population affected by floods. On the other hand, the occurrences of state elections have significantly declined the flood impacts. Furthermore, the flood magnitude dummies remain significant in all Poisson specifications, implying that a larger population is affected due to severe flooding.
We estimate Eq. (2) using FE negative binomial for robust results, and results are presented in columns C4–C6 in Table 2. This exercise is done only for all Indian states. The inverted U-shaped relationship remains the same with respect to PCI. However, the turning point of income moderately varies with the FE Poisson estimate. In addition, non-linear relation is continued with respect to natural calamity expenditure throughout the models (see Table 2). Moreover, results show that severe floods adversely affect the population in Indian states. In sum, the FE negative binomial produces mirror results of FE Poisson estimates.
We evaluate the effect of PCI and government responsiveness on flood damages, controlling socio-political and severity of floods. Using the FE Tobit model, we estimate Eq. (3), and the results are presented in Table 3. The outcome variable is flood damage over GSDP, which consists of many zeros, and the data is truncated from below. Therefore, it is appropriate to use Tobit estimation in our dataset. The flood damages include damage to crops, houses, and public infrastructure, all expressed in monetary values. We control year and state fixed effects, and standard errors are clustered at the state level in all regression models. The coefficient on the lag of PCI is positive and significant, and its squared term is negative and significant without considering control variables.
The results confirm that an inverted U pattern with respect to PCI has been established (see column C1 of Table 3). The inverted U pattern is sustained with respect to PCI after considering economic, political, and flood severity variables (see columns C2–C3 of Table 3). The estimated turning point of PCI in all models exceeded the PCI’s maximum value in our sample, implying that a higher PCI is needed to reduce flood damage. These results are consistent with the findings of8. They found an inverted U-shaped relationship between damages due to floods and per capita income using a cross-country dataset spanning 1980–2004. Besides PCI’s role in mitigating the flood damages, government responsiveness (measured by government expenditure on natural calamity) plays an essential role in mitigating flood damages in Indian states. The coefficient of natural calamity expenditure is positive, and its squared term is negative and significant, except for the model shown in column C1. The results follow an inverted-U pattern with respect to natural calamity expenditure throughout the models. We also estimate the non-linear relationship between PCI and flood damages in high and low-income states. The Tobit estimates show an inverted U-shaped relation between PCI and flood damages in high and low-income states. However, the relationship is weak for the low-income states. The coefficients plot of these results is shown in the Appendix Fig. A.1 (see Supplementary Information).
The turning point of natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP marginally increased from 0.81% in column C1 to 1.1% in column C3. This suggests that flood damages increase with a rise in natural calamity expenditure as a percentage of GSDP up to 1.1%; thereafter, it declines with increasing natural calamity expenditure. In addition, a higher flood magnitude yields greater flood damage. Controlling flood magnitude and total area under forest cover, we find that financial development and expenditure on flood control measures have no impact on flood damage. Furthermore, we find that the state election year and political alignment have little effect on reducing flood damages to some extent.
The contribution of our work is that we focus on the effects of two important dimensions of development: per capita income and government responsiveness on flood fatalities, the population affected, and damages due to floods. We use state-level panel data of 19 Indian states over the period 1980–2011. To take into account the aspect of regional heterogeneity, our entire sample is divided into high-income (rich) and low-income (poor) states. We find evidence of a non-linear (inverted U-shaped) relationship between per capita income and flood impact (measured via flood fatalities, the population affected, and flood damages) in high-income states. In the initial phases, deaths from floods increase in income but then start decreasing once those states continue to grow as income crosses the turning point. This inverted U-shaped relationship between per capita income and flood-related deaths is weak for low-income states. A plausible reason is that the poor states are not equally capable of generating adequate revenues and hence find it difficult to mitigate the effects of disasters. As11 has pointed out that states with higher per capita income are relatively more capable of investing in flood-precautionary measures such as rehabilitation, evacuation, relief distribution, and disaster warning systems.
Apart from analyzing the role of per capita income, we examine the relationship between the role of government responsiveness (using natural calamity expenditure) and deaths and damages caused by floods in high-income and low-income states. Interestingly, the estimate of expenditure on natural calamity is positive, and its squared term is negative, implying that the inverted U-type relationship remains intact. These estimates are statistically insignificant, indicating that government responsiveness has a lesser impact on reducing flood fatalities and the population affected in Indian states. Other factors, such as financial development, forest cover, and flood control expenditures, have no significant impact on reducing flood fatalities and damages. The state election has significantly reduced flood fatalities and flood damages, while political alignment between both center and State has little effect on minimizing flood impact. Moreover, the high severity of floods has caused greater damage and more fatalities.
To sum up, our empirical results suggest that states with higher per capita income can spend more on flood control and mitigation measures and constructing flood-resilient infrastructure to minimize flood impact. Moreover, the current level of government responsiveness is not adequate to mitigate flood fatalities and damages in both high-income and low-income states. In particular, the low-income states need special government attention to reduce the adverse effects of floods. We argue that the government must spend more on rehabilitation, relief distribution, evacuation, and flood warning measures to minimize future flood risk. In addition, other measures, such as long-term flood management policy, increased government spending on flood control and irrigation, and allowing forest cover to grow can considerably reduce the flood impact in Indian states.
The raw data of this study are being shared. For this, all authors have given their consents to share these materials.
EM-DAT. Emergency Events Database (EM-DAT): The International Disaster Database. (2020). https://www.emdat.be/
Parida, Y. & Dash, D. P. Rethinking the effect of floods and financial development on economic growth. Indian Growth Dev. Rev. 13, 485–503 (2019).
Article Google Scholar
Kahn, M. E. The death toll from natural disasters: The role of income, geography, and institutions. Rev. Econ. Stat. 87, 271–284 (2005).
Article Google Scholar
Toya, H. & Skidmore, M. Economic development and the impacts of natural disasters’. Econ. Lett. 94, 20–25 (2007).
Article Google Scholar
Raschky, P. A. Institutions and the losses from natural disasters. Nat. Hazard. 8, 627–634 (2008).
Article Google Scholar
Grossman, G. M. & Krueger, A. B. Economic growth and the environment. Q. J. Econ. 110, 353–377 (1995).
Article Google Scholar
Kellenberg, D. K. & Mobarak, A. M. Does rising income increase or decrease damage risk from natural disasters?. J. Urban Econ. 63, 788–802 (2008).
Article Google Scholar
Schumacher, I. & Strobl, E. Economic development and losses due to natural disasters: The role of hazard exposure. Ecol. Econ. 72, 97–105 (2011).
Article Google Scholar
Ferreira, S., Hamilton, K. & Vincent, J. R. Does development reduce fatalities from natural disasters? New evidence for floods. Environ. Dev. Econ. 18, 649–679 (2013).
Article Google Scholar
Mukherjee, S., Chakraborty, D. & Sikdar, S. Three decades of human development across Indian states: Inclusive growth or perpetual disparity? Working Paper No. 2014-139. National Institute of Public Finance and Policy. (2014).
Parida, Y. Economic impact of floods in the Indian states. Environ. Dev. Econ. 25, 267–290 (2020).
Article Google Scholar
Anbarci, N., Escaleras, M. & Register, C. A. Earthquake fatalities: The interaction of nature and political economy. J. Public Econ. 89, 1907–1933 (2005).
Article Google Scholar
Strömberg, D. Natural disasters, economic development, and humanitarian aid’. J. Econ. Perspect. 21, 199–222 (2007).
Article Google Scholar
Sadowski, N. C. & Sutter, D. Hurricane fatalities and hurricane damages: Are safer hurricanes more damaging?. South. Econ. J. 72, 422–432 (2005).
Google Scholar
Keefer, P., Neumayer, E. & Plümper, T. Earthquake propensity and the politics of mortality prevention. World Dev. 39, 1530–1541 (2011).
Article Google Scholar
Cavallo, E., Powell, A. & Becerra, O. Estimating the direct economic damages of the earthquake in Haiti. Econ. J. 120, F298–F312 (2010).
Article Google Scholar
Escaleras, M. & Register, C. A. Fiscal decentralization and natural hazard risks. Public Choice 151, 165–183 (2012).
Article Google Scholar
North, D. C. Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance 1990 (Cambridge University Press, 1990).
Book Google Scholar
Garrett, T. A. & Sobel, R. S. The political economy of FEMA disaster payments. Econ. Inq. 41, 496–509 (2007).
Article Google Scholar
Besley, T. & Burgess, R. The political economy of government responsiveness: Theory and evidence from India. Q. J. Econ. 117, 1415–1451 (2002).
Article Google Scholar
Cameron, A. C. & Trivedi, P. K. Microeconometrics Using Stata (revised edn) (Stata Press, 2009).
MATH Google Scholar
Hilbe, J. M. Negative Binomial Regression 2nd edn. (Cambridge University Press, 2011).
Book Google Scholar
Wooldridge, J. M. Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data (MIT Press, 2002).
MATH Google Scholar
Central Water Commission (CWC). State-Wise Data on Damage Caused due to Floods During 1953–2011 (Government of India, 2011).
Google Scholar
Parida, Y., Dash, D. P., Bhardwaj, P. & Chowdhury, J. R. Effects of drought and flood on farmer suicides in Indian states: An empirical analysis. Econ. Disasters Clim. Change 2, 159–180 (2018).
Article Google Scholar
Planning Commission. Report of the Expert Group to Review the Methodology for Measurement of Poverty (Government of India, 2014).
Google Scholar
Download references
Special thanks to B.N. Goldar and Rituparna Kaushik for their valuable comments and suggestions. An earlier draft was presented at the 9th Annual Conference of the Italian Association of Environmental and Resource Economists (IAERE) and the 26th Annual Conference European Association of Environmental and Resource Economists (EAERE), 2012. We thank conference participants for their valuable comments and suggestions. This manuscript was awarded a Participation Grant by the 26th Annual EAERE conference, 2021. An earlier draft of the manuscript is available as a working paper at the Institute of Rural Management Anand at https://www.irma.ac.in/uploads/randp/pdf/WP–318—For-web-20210120151134.pdf.
Department of Economics, FLAME University, Pune, India
Yashobanta Parida & Joyita Roy Chowdhury
Department of Economics, Delhi School of Economics, University of Delhi, New Delhi, India
Swati Saini
School of Management and Entrepreneurship – IIT Jodhpur, Jodhpur, India
Devi Prasad Dash
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
Y.P. contributed to the design, empirical analysis and data collection parts, revision of draft. J.R.C. contributed to the empirical discussion, revision of draft, and empirical analysis. S.S. contributed to writing the old draft. D.P.D. contributed to writing the literature section in the old draft and revised the new draft.
Correspondence to Yashobanta Parida, Joyita Roy Chowdhury, Swati Saini or Devi Prasad Dash.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Parida, Y., Roy Chowdhury, J., Saini, S. et al. Role of income and government responsiveness in reducing the death toll from floods in Indian states. Sci Rep 12, 16978 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21334-w
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21334-w
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.
Kohta Nozane swaps World Superbike for Moto2 with VR46 Master Camp – Crash
After two seasons in World Superbike, Kohta Nozane will switch to the Moto2 world championship in 2023, riding for the Yamaha VR46 Master Camp Team.
Previously part of Yamaha’s Japanese MotoGP test team, Nozane was propelled into a surprise race debut for the Tech3 team at Motegi 2017 (pictured) following Jonas Folger’s sudden withdraw on health grounds.
Nozane caught the eye of factory Yamaha legend Valentino Rossi on his way to posting the 13th best time, a fraction behind The Doctor, during the wet Friday practice.
“[He’s] very good,” Rossi said. “I followed him and he was fast. He has some experience with the M1, but I think that he hasn’t ridden the M1 since March. He is very young and I think he can be a very good Japanese rider for MotoGP…”
Unfortunately for the Japanese, he then suffered a fracture in his right-hand during FP4 and – after impressing further by setting set the ninth fastest time in warm-up – fell again in the early laps of the wet race.
Still only 26, Nozane hasn’t raced in MotoGP since, but won the Japanese Superbike title in 2020, leading to a World Superbike seat with GRT Yamaha for 2021 and 2022.
Nozane’s wet weather skills took him to what remains his best WorldSBK result of seventh in last year’s Mandalika finale and he has failed to crack the top ten so far this season.
But Yamaha is keeping faith and will now move Nozane to the Moto2 class, where he made his world championship debut as a wild-card with FTR in 2012 followed by three rides on a MotoBI/TSR chassis in 2013 (best finish of 16th).
Nozane said: “I was able to win the JSB1000 title in 2020, and since then I‘ve spent two years in WorldSBK. It‘s been a big challenge trying to get results, and I‘ve had a lot of difficult races so far, but I‘ve also learned a lot and gained a lot of experience.
“For 2023, I‘ll make a fresh start and compete in Moto2. I realize this will also be a big undertaking, but I‘ll do my best to produce some great races for my fans and for Yamaha.”
“We are excited to announce that we will welcome Kohta Nozane to our Yamaha VR46 Master Camp Team for the 2023 season,” added Tetsu Ono, general manager of Yamaha’s motorsports strategy division
“He is one of the best riders in Asia who has Yamaha bLU cRU experience. We will start a new chapter with him with the goal of showing everyone motorsports excitement.
“We will also continue to promote talented riders from Asia. We hope everyone will follow our challenge in Moto2.”
2023 will be the second year of the VR46/Yamaha Master Camp team, which currently runs Manuel Gonzalez and Keminth Kubo.
“I’m pleased to welcome Japanese rider Kohta Nozane to the team for 2023,” said sports director Gelete Nieto. “With this signing, we will strengthen our team even more in our second year of participation in the Moto2 category.
“I want to thank Yamaha for all the effort and support they are putting into this project. I am sure that together we will achieve great results.”
VR46’s own Moto2 team will start a new partnership with Fantic next season.
©1999-2022 Crash Media Group
The total or partial reproduction of text, photographs or illustrations is not permitted in any form.
St. Pete Halloween Events: Pumpkin Patches, Block Parties, Art Bazaar – St. Pete, FL Patch
ST. PETERSBURG, FL — Just weeks away from Halloween, businesses and organizations throughout St. Petersburg are getting spooky for the season.
Check out these upcoming Halloween events for both families and adults.
St. Pete Pier Pumpkin Patch
When: Through Oct. 16, hours vary
Where: St. Pete Pier
Admission: Free
This traditional pumpkin patch has more than 5,000 pumpkins from small to giant for purchase, as well as photo opportunities and other activities.
Edgey Halloween
When: Oct. 21, 8 p.m.
Where: Nova, 535 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Street N.
Admission: Tickets start at $10 per person
This event features the Shiso Crispy food truck, burlesque and fire dancing, costume contests, and more. A portion of proceeds benefit The Last Prisoner Project.
Haunted Cabaret
When: Oct. 21, 8 to 10 p.m.; Oct. 22, 7:30 to 9 p.m. and 10 to 11:30 p.m.; and Oct. 23, 3 to 4:30 p.m.
Where: Studio Grand Central & The Off-Central Players, 2260 1st Ave. S.
Admission: $35 per person
Featuring the music of “Rocky Horror Picture Show” and other classic Halloween songs.
Monster’s Brawl
When: Oct. 21, 8 to 11 p.m.
Where: 601 14th Street S.
Admission: Free
Wrestling show presented by Tampa Bay Pro Wrestling and Dream Women’s Wrestling.
Hauntizaar Halloween Art Bazaar
When: Oct. 22, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Where: The Studio@620.
Admission: Free
Hauntizaar Halloween and Day of the Dead Arts Bazaar bring together the best local dark arts for your shopping pleasure.
Haunted Hike
When: Oct. 22, 6 to 9 p.m.
Where: St. Petersburg’s Euclid St. Paul neighborhood.
Admission: $8 per adult, $5 per child
This family-friendly haunted tour features decorated homes, interactive scenes, candy giveaways and a block party. Funds raised are donated to charity.
Bar Crawl Nation: St. Pete Halloween
When: Oct. 22, 6 p.m.
Where: Sign in at One Night Stand, 149 1st Ave. N., by 9 p.m.
Admission: $19.99 per person
This costumed bar crawl offers exclusive specials, free cover, spooky giveaways at various downtown St. Petersburg bars.
Lecture: Dali’s Ghosts
When: Oct. 27, 6 to 7 p.m.
Where: The Dali Museum, One Dali Blvd.
Admission: Free
This Halloween-themed lecture by Peter Tush, curator of education at the museum, will explore the spectral domain of Dali’s art.
Read No More: St. Pete Murder House
When: Oct. 28-29, tours at 6, 7, 8 and 9 p.m.
Where: South St. Petersburg address disclosed to ticketholders
Admission: $18 per person
Tour a series of short, scary plays to learn about the hauntings and history of the St. Pete Murder House. Each play is written and produced by teams of local writers and actors.
“Rocky Horror Picture Show” Party
When: Oct. 28-29, 8 p.m. to 2 a.m.
Where: No Vacancy, 937 Central Ave.
Admission: Free
Featuring drink specials, costume contests with prizes, and the sounds of DJ Danny Vintage and DJ CyberMousey.
Nun-O-Ween Halloween Party & Costume Contest
When: Oct. 29, 7 p.m.
Where: Salty Nun, 2501 Central Ave.
Admission: Free
Featuring a costume contest and music from DJ Shannon C.
La Luchaween
When: Oct. 29, 8 p.m.
Where: The Palladium at St. Petersburg College.
Admission: $20 per adult, $10 per child.
This evening of music and film features the ghastly trio, La Lucha, scoring classic horror films of the silent film era. This event is hosted by Eugenie Bondurant.
Creature Feature Halloween Drag & Burlesque Show
When: Oct. 29, 8 p.m.
Where: Overflow Brewing Company
Admission: Free
Features frighteningly fun performances by Nilla Bean, Mister Cister, Taryn Hearts and Sorcha Mercy. Dress up for the costume contest; winner gets a bar tab.
Halloween on Central 2
When: Oct. 30, noon to 5 p.m.
Where: Central Avenue will shut down to cars from MLK to 31st Street for a massive Halloween block party.
Admission: Free to attend block party (check local businesses for specific events)
Last year’s event drew more than 70,000 people.
Have a Halloween event to add to this list? Email [email protected].
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.
By a master's hands in the Colorado mountains, the bamboo fly rod lives on – Colorado Springs Gazette
Daily Weather Report
Powered By:
Mike Clark, 75, and his sole employee, Kathy Jensen, take a lunch break to fish the North Saint Vrain Creek in Lyons on Sept. 26.
Kathy Jensen uses a variety of silk thread, seen at top, to customize each bamboo fly-fishing rod she and Mike Clark make at South Creek Ltd. The details of a South Creek Ltd. rod are seen above. Each rod is signed and numbered by Mike Clark, as seen at right.
Mike Clark and his sole employee at South Creek Ltd., Kathy Jensen, call a lunch break and fish the North Saint Vrain Creek in Lyons on a recent Monday. Clark makes about 25 bamboo fly rods a year. “I can’t stand at that bench like I used to,” he says.
Mike Clark’s sole employee, Kathy Jensen, uses a variety of silk thread to customize each bamboo fishing rod made by the two at South Creek Ltd. in Lyons.
Mike Clark and Kathy Jensen close shop and head out for a fishing break Monday, Sept. 26, 2022, at the South Creek, Ltd., storefront on Main Street in Lyons. Colo. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Mike Clark and his sole employee Kathy Jensen take a lunch break to fish the North Saint Vrain Creek in Lyons, Colo., Monday, Sept. 26, 2022. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Each bamboo fly fishing rod made at South Creek, Ltd., is signed and numbered by Mike Clark. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Mike Clark, 75, shows a piece of the spilt bamboo that will join other pieces to create one of his bamboo fishing rods Monday, Sept. 26, 2022, at his shop in Lyons, Colo. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Mike Clark sits in his shop along Main Street in Lyons, Colo., Monday, Sept. 26, 2022. Clark started making his custom bamboo fly rods in 1979.(The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Features writer
Mike Clark, 75, and his sole employee, Kathy Jensen, take a lunch break to fish the North Saint Vrain Creek in Lyons on Sept. 26.
Kathy Jensen uses a variety of silk thread, seen at top, to customize each bamboo fly-fishing rod she and Mike Clark make at South Creek Ltd. The details of a South Creek Ltd. rod are seen above. Each rod is signed and numbered by Mike Clark, as seen at right.
Mike Clark and Kathy Jensen close shop and head out for a fishing break Monday, Sept. 26, 2022, at the South Creek, Ltd., storefront on Main Street in Lyons. Colo. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Each bamboo fly fishing rod made at South Creek, Ltd., is signed and numbered by Mike Clark. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Mike Clark, 75, shows a piece of the spilt bamboo that will join other pieces to create one of his bamboo fishing rods Monday, Sept. 26, 2022, at his shop in Lyons, Colo. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
LYONS • It’s not often Mike Clark shows guests to the back of his shop. It is, after all, his space. His domain. A little, wooden world of fine, meticulous work.
One might say magic happens here, if they are so romantically inclined to the bamboo fly rod. Clark is not all that inclined, a man of few words between drags from his Marlboro Red.
More inclined was Norman Maclean, who wrote: “Grace comes by art, and art does not come easy.” Clark does not like being called an artist. He is not an artist making something to be displayed. He is rather a craftsman making something to be used, a tool — and ideally by someone who is more serious about fishing than they are about the Maclean-inspired movie, “A River Runs Through It.”
Around a craftsman, it tends to be messy. “Sorry,” the bearded, ponytailed 75-year-old says to his guests, slowly bending over. “I’ll get those cat treats out of the way.”
Mike Clark and his sole employee at South Creek Ltd., Kathy Jensen, call a lunch break and fish the North Saint Vrain Creek in Lyons on a recent Monday. Clark makes about 25 bamboo fly rods a year. “I can’t stand at that bench like I used to,” he says.
Patch and Smudge live with Clark here in the business that doubles as his home. South Creek Ltd. is a plainly named business for a plain man. Built over four decades, Clark’s reputation is anything but.
Just ask John Gierach, the author and fly-fishing legend who happens to live nearby in these river-cut mountains of northern Colorado.
“I’ve had people come out and visit me and say, ‘Can we go see Mike?’ Like they’re asking if I can get them an audience with Mahatma Ghandi or something,” Gierach says. “He’s known as one of the old masters.”
An old master of a rare, centuries-old craft.
Long before today’s graphite and fiberglass rods, there was bamboo. The mighty grass rises 12 feet high in a corner of Clark’s shop, shipped from China. Clark spends his days transforming it, not so unlike 19th-century master Hiram Leonard.
Culms are split and tapered into smaller strips, sanded and planed and glued together to a point measuring so many thousandths of an inch. It’s a precise, slow process also of varnishing, silk-wrapping, heating, cooling and waiting. It’s a process Clark refuses to change, just like his hand tools from 1979. That’s when he built his first bamboo fly rod.
Mike Clark and his sole employee Kathy Jensen take a lunch break to fish the North Saint Vrain Creek in Lyons, Colo., Monday, Sept. 26, 2022. (The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
The product is a dream for the purist of the sport’s pure — something of an Excalibur starting around $3,000.
And few, Gierach says, are producing like Clark.
“I know some rod makers, they’re hobbyists who make a couple of rods a year and sell them,” Gierach says. “But Mike, you know, he lives above his shop, he turns on the lights, walks down the staircase, pets the cats, gets a cup of coffee and goes to work.”
Still, due to his refusal of machines and extra manpower, his supply is limited. Clark says he’s making around 25 rods a year. “I can’t stand at that bench like I used to,” he says.
His wait list hovers around three years. “At one time, the backlog was almost six years,” he says. “That’s when I said, ‘That’s enough.’”
That’s when he enlisted his sole employee of today, Kathy Jensen. She was an unlikely choice, a transplant from the California tech world. They met at the local coffee shop.
“I told him, ‘I’ve never picked up any rod, let alone a fly rod. I don’t know anything,’” she says. “He said, ‘Perfect. When can you start?’”
Mike Clark sits in his shop along Main Street in Lyons, Colo., Monday, Sept. 26, 2022. Clark started making his custom bamboo fly rods in 1979.(The Gazette, Christian Murdock)
Now she specializes in the rod’s aesthetics — the finishing flourishes of metals, woods and colorful wraps. Nothing too colorful, Jensen warns customers, at Clark’s behest. Earth tones, she implores.
“We like to make traditional kind of rods,” Jensen says. “Not carnival rods.”
She likes that creative part of the job more than the paperwork and customer service. But someone has to tend to that part.
“That damn tin block over there,” Clark says, motioning to the computer, “I hate it.”
He’d rather do away with his cellphone, too. “Only three people have the number, and that’s the way it’ll stay,” he says.
Clark is no romantic, and yet he’s best described by poetry framed on the wall. It’s a testament by the late writer Robert Traver.
Mike Clark’s sole employee, Kathy Jensen, uses a variety of silk thread to customize each bamboo fishing rod made by the two at South Creek Ltd. in Lyons.
“I fish because I love to; because I love the environs where trout are found, which are invariably beautiful, and hate the environs where crowds of people are found, which are invariably ugly,” Traver professed. He loved fishing “because, in a world where most men seem to spend their lives doing things they hate, my fishing is at once an endless source of delight and an act of small rebellion.”
Before making bamboo fly rods, Clark hated what he did. He hated the job that had him plowing snow and towing cars around Boulder County, that had his Motorola buzzing in the middle of the night for emergencies.
And before that, out of high school in Lakewood, he hated his time in Vietnam. He returned to an ungrateful nation in 1969.
“I hid for about nine months,” Clark says.
He moved to the mountains. He did a lot of fishing. He did what he did in his childhood, always looking forward to the weekends when his dad loaded the camper and in the crisp, early mornings, the family embarked to some far-off lake.
His dad fished with bamboo. Clark thought about that in hard times, thought about casting it in the yard as a kid. It was, he later decided, the simplest representation of the simplicity he sought.
So he would put more of that into the world — one rod at a time, hand-made after hand-made.
And so he continues today, unrelenting, uncompromising.
“I think it’s perfectionism,” Gierach says. “You want to do it just as well as it can be done, or as well as you can do it. And you never quite decide, OK, I’ve got it nailed down.”
But Clark is learning to draw boundaries. Someone recently called about coming in for business. It’d be Wednesday or Thursday, the caller said.
“Make it Tuesday or Thursday,” Clark countered. “Wednesday, I’m going fishing.”
Even if you’ve got the money to spend — starting around $3,000 — you might have to wait a few years to get your own, custom bamboo fly rod at South Creek Ltd. Maker Mike Clark has a long wait list. But you can check out pre-used rods at the shop, where Clark also keeps a personal collection.
415 Main Street, Lyons; 303-823-6402, southcreekltd.com
You get a few different reactions when you’re seen riding a unicycle in the mountains.
Features writer
Seth is a features writer at The Gazette, covering the outdoors and the people and places making Colorado colorful.
{{description}}
Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items.
The city of Colorado Springs is weighing whether to gate Old Stage Road to reduce late-night shooting across private property, vandalism, lighting fireworks, dumping and other illegal activity.
Simi and Bella Shmurda: two Afrobeats stars reveal a growing tendency to abuse Fela Kuti – The Conversation
Research Fellow, Rhodes University
Garhe Osiebe does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.
Rhodes University provides funding as a partner of The Conversation AFRICA.
View all partners
There can no longer be any doubt that Fela Anikulapo-Kuti, the legendary Nigerian musician, activist and father of Afrobeat music, has become an easy career booster for today’s Afrobeats artists who are undergoing creative droughts.
Fela’s invention, Afrobeat, is an ensemble and performance-based category that blends jazz, funk, rock and traditional West African chant and rhythms. It originated in the early 1970s through continued experimentation after a stint with highlife music. Afrobeats, however, is a 21st century creation of beat-heavy electronic pop music from Nigeria with steadily growing global audiences. It’s become an umbrella term describing the music of contemporary West African stars, including the likes of Wizkid, Burna Boy and Tems.
Over the course of a decade (2010-2020), Afrobeats stars managed to appropriate the text, synthesise the sound, conjure the appearance and invoke the name and symbolisms of Fela in their works in various ways, often as a tribute.
Since my last major study on how Afrobeats uses and reframes Fela, several Afrobeats practitioners have laboured – and failed – to tap from him in exciting new ways.
In fact, the post-2020 class has reached for Fela’s source in ways that barely recognise the stature of the late icon. As I have noted elsewhere, Nigerian artists often resort to activism pranks to shore up their creative deficiencies. Indeed, there is a sense that an association with the Fela brand and imagery confers on an artist some sort of critical ethos – one which audiences are beginning to see through.
Read more: The daughters and sons of Fela in African Pop
Two recent examples form the crux of my argument: Woman by Simi (2021) and New Born Fela by Bella Shmurda (2022). It is noteworthy that both singles represent their first attempt at openly drawing from Fela.
While Simi had to invoke the works of Fela, a renowned anti-feminist, to make a feminist point, Shmurda opted to become the new born version of an icon no one expects a reincarnation of. Particularly in the latter case, it was done to the detriment of musical coherence and logic.
Simi is a 34-year-old Nigerian female Afrobeats artist known as “studio brat” because she is quite adept at mixing and mastering music. (Fela’s dexterity with several instruments informed his christening as a “musician’s musician”, whereas the pioneers of Afrobeats have been berated for their inability to play musical instruments. The scenario is, however, different with contemporary Afrobeats, where many artists are producer-musicians with foundations in playing instruments or in music production.)
In her unapologetically feminist single Woman, Simi samples copious (at least five) Afrobeat works from Fela – demonstrating the breadth of how his catalogue could be applied, while taking a swipe at the age-long suppressions that women have faced.
In the process, Simi alters Fela’s texts to suit her immediate purposes even as her lyrics in Woman sharply contrast the message in his song Lady. Fela advances subordination as a virtue of the traditional African woman. Simi, however, has had enough of females submitting to males while also facing intimidation from society.
At the heart of Woman is the contradiction between a feminist ethos and all that Fela represented. Yet this doesn’t deter Simi from pursuing a successful single in a brazen manifestation of robbing Peter to pay Paul. Fela’s essence might have been antithetical to any and everything feminist, but his songs may be applied in conveying such a message – so long as the artist smiles all the way to the bank.
At 25, Bella Shmurda is a newer age Afrobeats practitioner. Since gaining prominence with the single Vision 2020 (2019), he has been unable to sustain a coherent musical direction. Indeed, subsequent successful singles like Cash App (2020) and Rush (2021) have done little to present him as an artist with a consistent style or philosophy.
To put it simply, to many Afrobeats audiences, Bella Shmurda is a confused artist whose music has never stood for anything distinguishable. So it wasn’t surprising when he released the single New Born Fela.
In the song, Bella Shmurda is preoccupied with rebranding himself as a sort of modern day incarnation of Fela. It feels like he and his team came up with a title and then proceeded to write lyrics to make it work. The outcome is forced and unconvincing and the single faded away almost at once.
There is almost nothing about New Born Fela that invokes any meaningful thoughts on Fela. It was merely a catchy title invoked by a drowning artist who seemed to care little about how he would be portrayed once audiences figured out how hollow his material was. While the video strives to capture the aesthetics that defined Fela’s Afrobeat Queens, Bella Shmurda himself falls starkly short of replicating Fela.
Unsurprisingly, Bella Shmurda has followed New Born Fela with the single Philo (2022), another far cry from any of his previous works.
While it may be convenient and useful to be inspired by Fela in order to borrow his influence and spirit, these two recent applications suggest a sort of desperation – even an outright opportunism on the part of today’s artists.
One keen Afrobeats listener in Lagos, Nigeria offered what should be food for thought for contemporary Afrobeats artists:
We have seen Fela, we have heard Fela. Now we want to see you.
Write an article and join a growing community of more than 153,300 academics and researchers from 4,489 institutions.
Register now
Copyright © 2010–2022, The Conversation US, Inc.
Epidemic Sound launches web series to profile its musicians – Music Ally
The digital marketing guide: expert insight, case studies, fresh approaches, and overlooked opportunities.
The latest and best jobs in the global music industry
Brief, deep analysis of essential music business stuff: every week, in about 20 mins.
Essential international guides, packed with data, interviews, strategies, and local insight.
Twice-monthly reports on the newest platforms – to help you find a competitive edge.
Music Ally Ltd., Holborn Studios,
49-50 Eagle Wharf Rd, London, N1 7ED,
United Kingdom
Music Ally is a Registered Learning Provider 10029483
City hosts meeting on right-of-way design standards Nov. 3 | News List – City of Sarasota
Services
The public is invited to learn about proposed updates to the City of Sarasota Engineering Design Criteria Manual (EDCM) during a meeting Thursday, Nov. 3 from 5 p.m. to 6 :30 p.m. in the SRQ Media Studio within the City Hall Annex, 1565 First Street.
The EDCM is a guide for staff, developers and engineers with established design standards for roads, trails, and sidewalks within the right-of-way. The revised EDCM will include three new chapters for solid waste, public art and landscaping.
During the meeting, the EDCM and its purpose will be explained plus best practices, and existing infrastructure challenges that may be resolved through EDCM updates.
For more information visit www.SarasotaFL.gov/government/EDCM
Our vision is to be a world-class community and treasured destination, with enduring natural beauty, charm and diversity.
City Hall 1565 1st Street, Sarasota, FL 34236 | (941) 263-6000 | Contact Us | Pay Online
Social Media Info – Custodian of Public Records – Advisory Board Members eMail Portal
Flood Information
City Websites Accessibility Statement
Website Design by Granicus – Connecting People and Government
How Wav Monopoly is changing the Audio Industry with DIY Solutions – PR Newswire
Searching for your content…
In-Language News
Contact Us
888-776-0942
from 8 AM – 10 PM ET
News provided by
Oct 10, 2022, 17:05 ET
Share this article
MIAMI, Oct. 10, 2022 /PRNewswire/ — As the industry of audio production matures, there is an increasing demand for higher quality and more polished recordings. This has led to a rise in the popularity of digital audio workstations, or DAWs. DAWs offer a wide range of features and options that allow users to create professional-sounding recordings.
However, many DAWs and Plugins can cost thousands of dollars and the learning curve can be very discouraging. These factors can put them out of reach for many independent musicians.
The goal at Wav Monopoly is to revolutionize the way recording artists create high-quality music.
This is where Wav Monopoly comes in. Wav Monopoly offers a wide variety of vocal presets specifically designed for use with popular DAWs. These vocal presets are designed to improve the sound quality of recordings and make the production process faster and easier.
Wav Monopoly’s vocal presets are changing the landscape of the audio industry by making high-quality recordings more accessible to a wider range of people. By offering affordable and easy-to-use solutions like a BPM Finder, Wav Monopoly is making it possible for more people to create professional-sounding recordings. This is leading to a new wave of independent musicians and producers who are able to compete with major label records which is the aim of the Founder Quinton Lord.
Wav Monopoly believes that everyone should have access to mainstream quality music, regardless of their budget. That’s why they offer a variety of services and products like Vocal Presets or a BPM Finder that can help you get the most out of your recordings.
In addition, they offer a wide range of tutorials and articles on their website. Whether you’re just getting started in the world of music production or you’re a seasoned pro, they have something for you.
All in all, the goal at Wav Monopoly is to revolutionize the way recording artists create high-quality music. To help unsigned and independent recording artists who may not have expertise in mixing and mastering, by providing them with industry level vocal presets and tools like a BPM Finder. This will empower them to reach the next level of success by putting them on the same playing field as mainstream artists. And to transform the music industry by altering its course and opening doors for all recording artists to create high-quality records.
SOURCE Wav Monopoly
Cision Distribution 888-776-0942
from 8 AM – 9 PM ET
JID and Smino announce co-headlining 2023 tour – The FADER
JID and Smino have announced a co-headlining 2023 North American tour. Dubbed “Luv is 4Ever” (a fusion of the titles of the two rappers’ 2022 albums), the 32-date run is set to break ground on January 22 at Seattle’s Paramount Theatre, stopping in 21 states and three Canadian provinces before the dust settles on March 29 at Marathon Music Works in Nashville. Tickets go on sale this Friday (October 14) at 10 a.m. local time via LuvIs4Ever.com.
JID — the Atlanta-born, -bred, and -based emcee at the forefront of the retro-sounding, forward-thinking rap group Spillage Village — released his third LP, The Forever Story, in August and performed songs from across his brief but fruitful solo career with help from an eight-piece backing band at NPR’s Tiny Desk studio the following month. Smino — born and raised in St. Louis but based in Chicago for most of his adult life — recently announced his own third studio album, Luv 4 Rent, with its J. Cole-featuring lead single, “90 Proof.” That record is due out October 28.
JID and Smino have collaborated previously on 2020’s “Baguetti” (produced by Kenny Beats) and both appear on the 2019 Dreamville posse cut “1993” alongside J. Cole, Cozz, EarthGang, and Buddy, from the label compilation Revenge of the Dreamers III: Director’s Cut.
View the poster and dates for their 2023 tour below.
January 22 – Seattle, WA – Paramount Theatre
January 24 – Vancouver, BC – PNE Forum
January 26 – Portland, OR – Roseland Theater
January 28 – Oakland, CA – The Fox
January 31 – Los Angeles, CA – Hollywood Palladium
February 2 – San Diego, CA – SOMA San Diego
February 3 – Phoenix, AZ – The Van Buren
February 8 – Salt Lake City, UT – The Complex
February 10 – Denver, CO – The Mission Ballroom
February 13 – Dallas, TX – South Side Ballroom
February 14 – Austin, TX – Stubb’s Waller Creek Amphitheater
February 15 – San Antonio, TX – Aztec Theatre
February 16 – Houston, TX – Bayou Music Center
February 18 – Atlanta, CA – Coca-Cola Roxy
February 21 – St. Petersburg, FL – Jannus Live
February 22 – Miami, FL – Oasis Wynwood
February 24 – Charlotte, NC – The Fillmore Charlotte
February 26 – Silver Spring, MD – The Fillmore Silver Spring
March 1 – Philadelphia, PA – The Fillmore Philadelphia
March 3 – New York, NY – Terminal 5
March 7 – Wallingford, CT – Dome at Toyota Oakdale Theatre
March 9 – Boston, MA – House of Blues Boston
March 12 – Montreal, QC – MTELUS
March 15 – Toronto, ON – HISTORY
March 17 – Detroit, MI – The Fillmore Detroit
March 18 – Grand Rapids, MI – GLC Live at 20 Monroe
March 21 – Chicago, IL – Byline Bank Aragon Ballroom
March 23 – Madison, WI – The Sylvee
March 24 – Minneapolis, MN – The Fillmore Minneapolis
March 25 – Kansas City, MO – Arvest Bank Theatre at the Midland
March 28 – Cincinnati, OH – The Andrew J Brady Music Center
March 29 – Nashville, TN – Marathon Music Works
Analysis of the robustness and dynamics of spin-locking preparations for the detection of oscillatory magnetic fields | Scientific Reports – Nature.com
Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 16965 (2022)
Metrics details
Extracting quantitative information of neuronal signals by non-invasive imaging is an outstanding challenge for understanding brain function and pathology. However, state-of-the-art techniques offer low sensitivity to deep electrical sources. Stimulus induced rotary saturation is a recently proposed magnetic resonance imaging sequence that detects oscillatory magnetic fields using a spin-lock preparation. Phantom experiments and simulations proved its efficiency and sensitivity, but the susceptibility of the method to field inhomogeneities is still not well understood. In this study, we simulated and analyzed the dynamic of three spin-lock preparations and their response to field inhomogeneities in the presence of a resonant oscillating field. We show that the composite spin-lock preparation is more robust against field variations within the double resonance effect. In addition, we tested the capability of the chosen composite spin-lock preparation to recover information about the spectral components of a composite signal. This study sets the bases to move one step further towards the clinical application of MR-based neuronal current imaging.
Neuroscience seeks to understand brain activity and its pathologies but still struggles to extract electrical neuronal information in a non-invasive way. Non-invasive detection methods such as electroencephalogram1 and magnetoencephalogram2 measure electric potential and magnetic fields on the scalp and reconstruct the location of the electric sources. Unfortunately, the sensitivity of these methods is limited for in-depth activity sources3,4. On the other hand, conventional functional magnetic resonance (fMRI) detects ({T}_{2}) and ({T}_{2}^{*}) changes generated by blood oxygenation levels on the brain (BOLD contrast)5. This technique presents good spatial resolution, but it measures neuronal activity indirectly, and the hemodynamic response function limits its temporal resolution6.
Stimulus Induced Rotational Saturation (SIRS) is an MRI-based sequence with the potential to directly detect neuronal activity with sufficient spatial resolution7. The SIRS contrast is based on the interaction between the magnetization locked by a spin-lock (SL) pulse and an oscillating magnetic field induced by neuronal activity. Several studies proved the capabilities of the method with simulations and phantom experiments7,8,9,10,11. Even more, the dependence of the contrast with the change of the excitation angle has been proposed as a new method for direct functional connectivity measurements12.
The susceptibility of the SL preparations to ({B}_{0}) and ({B}_{1}) inhomogeneities hinders the further development and clinical application of this approach12,13. However, researchers in the field of ({T}_{1rho }) relaxometry thoroughly studied the use of composite SL pulses to reduce the effect of field imperfections14,15,16,17. Furthermore, some researchers within the SIRS community tested and used composite pulses8,9,18. But, to the best of our knowledge, no comprehensive study of the influence of the double resonance effect in combination with field inhomogeneities has been presented. Magnetization dynamics during a spin-lock pulse changes radically in the presence of an oscillating resonant field. Here, we present a simulation model based on rotation matrices that allow us to study the new dynamics and capture the effect of any oscillating field over time. We studied three well known SL preparations, the basic or standard SL pulse (BASL), the rotary echo SL pulse (RESL), and the composite rotary echo SL pulse (CRESL). Using the simulator and phantom experiments, we define the optimal strategy by examining the response of the preparations to field imperfections considering the new dynamics.
Finally, to validate the chosen preparation in more realistic conditions, we studied the filter properties of the preparation in the presence of composite signals. Physiological signals fluctuate in time and are composed of multiple frequencies19,20,21. In addition, certain pathologies manifest with neuronal activity at specific frequencies. For example, high-frequency oscillations (HFOs) are considered markers of the seizure onset zone in epilepsy22,23. This case is noteworthy because non-invasively outlining the seizure onset zone can have a direct impact on patient care quality. Therefore, we consider that the next step to take towards the clinical application of the SIRS sequence is a more realistic signal analysis. The use of a repetitive acquisition of successive measurements with and without SL preparation has previously been proposed24. With this method, the BOLD effect and image artifacts are minimized by dividing the two signals. In the second part of this work, we tested the ability of this acquisition method to reconstruct the frequency distribution of multi-frequency signals.
The purpose of this study is to advance research towards the clinical application of the SIRS technique. First, we define the optimal SL preparation and metric to detect oscillating fields in the presence of field inhomogeneities and second, we analyzed the response of the chosen preparation to composite signals.
The dynamics of the magnetization with the BASL preparation in the presence of simple sinusoidal oscillating fields has been analytically described25. However, modulated oscillating fields are more representative of those found in physiological activity. In general, it is not possible to analytically describe these fields, and numerical simulations are the only option. Among the numerical simulation methods, solving differential equations9 and stepwise constant rotations as presented in this work, give similar results. Based on previous bibliography in the ({T}_{1rho }) field15,16,17, where composite and refocusing SL pulses were developed, we decided to adopt the rotation matrix method presented in those works and added the influence of an arbitrary oscillating target field. Figure 1a shows the conventional SIRS sequence formed by a spin-locking pulse followed by a single shot EPI readout. A traditional SL pulse, like the one shown in Fig. 1b(i), consists of three RF pulses. After a tip-down pulse of duration ({T}_{td}), the magnetization in the simple rotating frame ((widehat{x},widehat{y},widehat{z})) is
Here ({varvec{M}}left(0right)=[mathrm{0,0},{M}_{0z}]) is the initial magnetization, and ({{varvec{R}}}_{widehat{x}}(-alpha )) represents a matrix rotation around (widehat{x}) as defined in Supplementary information 1, with (alpha) the rotation angle of ideally 90°. Imperfections in the transmitted ({B}_{1}) field can vary significantly across the sample, deviating (alpha) from the ideal value depending on the location r by (alpha ({varvec{r}})=gamma {B}_{1}left({varvec{r}}right){T}_{td}). The second RF applied along (widehat{y}) is the SL pulse ({B}_{SL}={omega }_{SL}/gamma), of duration ({T}_{SL}) with ({omega }_{SL}=2pi {F}_{SL}) the induced angular frequency. ({{varvec{B}}}_{{varvec{S}}{varvec{L}}}) locks the magnetization in the transverse plane, represented by
where (theta ={omega }_{SL}{T}_{SL}). In the presence of ({B}_{0}) inhomogeneities, the magnetization will rotate around the effective field ({{varvec{B}}}_{{varvec{e}}{varvec{f}}{varvec{f}}}=frac{{omega }_{SL}}{gamma }widehat{y}+frac{Delta {omega }_{0}}{gamma }widehat{z}) that forms an angle (beta =mathrm{arctan}(frac{Delta {omega }_{0}}{{omega }_{SL}})) to (widehat{y}), where (Delta {omega }_{0}={omega }_{0}-{omega }_{RF}) is the off-resonant frequency. The effective rotation angle is then given by ({theta }_{eff}={omega }_{eff}{T}_{SL}=sqrt{{{omega }_{SL}}^{2}+Delta {upomega }_{0}^{2}}{T}_{SL})15,17. This results in
Finally, a tip-up pulse of duration ({T}_{td}) tilts the magnetization back to the longitudinal axis, in the same way as Eq. (1) but for a rotation ({{varvec{R}}}_{widehat{x}}left(alpha right)). After preparation, a gradient spoiler in (hat{z}) eliminates the remanent transverse magnetization. The spoiler is followed by a slice selective 90° excitation and an echo-planar imaging (EPI) readout, as shown in Fig. 1a. Although a fast single-shot readout is preferred for functional imaging, the acquisition could be replaced by another sequence.
Pulse sequence, SL preparations and magnetization dynamics. (a) Pulse sequence diagram for a conventional SIRS preparation (BASL) followed by an echo planar imaging (EPI) acquisition. An exemplary oscillating target field ((B_{z} )) is shown, the initial phase ((varphi)) corresponds to the phase at the beginning of the SL pulse. (b) RF pulses that define the three SL preparations studied in this work: (i) basic SL preparation (BASL), (ii) rotary echo SL pulse (RESL) and (iii) composite rotary echo SL pulse (CRESL). (c) Representative diagram of the magnetization dynamic for the SL preparations showed in (b) when in the presence of a resonant oscillating field applied along (hat{z}). The trajectory is color-coded to differentiate the effect of each RF pulse.
We can now consider the dynamic under the influence of an arbitrary target field ({{varvec{B}}}_{{varvec{N}}{varvec{C}}}left(tright)) along (widehat{z}). In its simplest form, this field is represented by ({{varvec{B}}}_{{varvec{N}}{varvec{C}}}left(tright)={B}_{NC} sin({omega }_{NC}t+varphi )widehat{z}), with ({B}_{NC}), ({omega }_{NC}), and (varphi) the amplitude, frequency, and initial phase of the field, respectively. Considering the magnetization direction and the change in the amplitude of the target field constant during each time-step (dt), the SL period is represented at each instant (tau) by a stepwise rotation of the form
where (beta ^{prime}) and ({omega }_{eff}^{{prime}}) are the redefinition of (beta) and ({omega }_{eff}) as
and
If the field is in resonance with the induced SL frequency i.e., ({omega }_{NC}={omega }_{SL}), ({{varvec{B}}}_{{varvec{N}}{varvec{C}}}) acts as an excitation pulse and tilts the magnetization away from the SL direction. After the preparation, the drop in the longitudinal magnetization depends on the torque generated by the oscillating target field. We can further generalize Eq. (4) to consider that the target field could be along an arbitrary axis (see Supplementary information 1).
Finally, the magnetization in the presence of relaxation is modified as ({varvec{M}}left(tau right)= {varvec{A}}boldsymbol{ }{varvec{M}}(tau -dt)+{varvec{B}}), where the matrices ({varvec{A}}) and ({varvec{B}}) represent the effect of the standard ({T}_{1}) and ({T}_{2}) relaxation times (see Supplementary information 1). In our implementation, each rotation must be infinitesimal and within each step dt, two relaxations of dt/2 are considered before and after the infinitesimal rotation. In this way, Eq. (1) becomes:
and Eq. (4) changes to
where ({{varvec{A}}}_{{varvec{rho}}}) and ({{varvec{B}}}_{{varvec{rho}}}) represent the relaxations in the rotating frame of reference (see Supplementary information 1).
We validated the rotation matrices simulator using the comparison with both analytical and numerical models (see Supplementary information 1).
The dynamic response of the magnetization under the BASL preparation in the presence of a resonant oscillating field is shown in Fig. 1c(i).
The RESL preparation divides the SL pulse into two parts with equal duration and opposite phase, as shown in Fig. 1b(ii). This pulse attempts to cancel out the error in the alpha angle generated by ({B}_{1}) inhomogeneity14. Figure 1c(ii) illustrates the magnetization dynamics for RESL under the influence of a resonant target field. To simulate this preparation, the sign of ({omega }_{eff}^{{prime}}left(tau right)) is inverted in Eq. (8), when (n=frac{{T}_{SL}}{2dt}). The sign change adds a phase dependence to the RESL contrast. Depending on the initial phase, and the relation between ({T}_{SL}) and (F_{SL}), the distance to the SL axis gained during the first part of the pulse, could be compensated during the second half. We show this effect in more detail in the following sections.
Finally, the CRESL preparation adds a (180^circ) RF pulse along (hat{y}) between the two halves of the SL pulse, i.e., when (n = frac{{T_{SL} }}{2dt}) and the last pulse is equal to the tip-down. The 180° pulse compensates for the phase accumulated due to the influence of (B_{0}) inhomogeneities. Figure 1b(iii) shows the pulse sequence, and Fig. 1c(iii) shows the dynamics of the double resonance effect under this preparation. As in RESL, the CRESL contrast is also dependent on the initial phase, however, the response differs due to the delay in time generated by the (180^circ) pulse.
The double rotating system is generally used to show the magnetization dynamics during an SL pulse12,13. We presented this dynamic in Supplementary information 2.
The simulator was programmed in MATLAB (R2019b) using the method presented in “Magnetization dynamics under spin-lock preparations schemes” section, together with the rotation and relaxation matrices shown in Supplementary information 1. Parameters that must be given to the simulator related to the sample are the relaxation times of the tissue and the target field as a function of time. Sequence control parameters are (F_{SL}), (T_{SL}), (T_{R}), (T_{E}), number of slices (always 1 for this work) and repetition number. In this way, the entire sequence time can be simulated, considering relaxation in preparation, readout and waiting times (time between slices, preparations without SL).
We performed measurements in a 3T whole-body MR scanner (Siemens Medical Solutions, Erlangen, Germany), using a Single-Shot-EPI readout with fixed parameters: (T_{E} = 29.8) ms, Matrix size = 64 × 64, FOV = 210 × 210 mm, Bandwidth = 1950 Hz/pixel, and slice thickness = 5 mm. The value of (T_{R}) will depend on the selected value of (T_{SL}). For the simulations, the relaxation times match the values measured on the phantom using commercial sequences. (T_{1} = 1270) ms and (T_{2} = 200) ms. We estimated (T_{1rho }) using a custom-made sequence that varies the duration of the spin-lock time (T_{SL}) for a CRESL preparation and fitting the exponential formula (M = M_{0} e^{{ – T_{SL} /T_{1rho } }}) obtaining (T_{1rho } = 165) ms.
Figure 2 shows the experimental setup used in this study. The phantom consists of a copper loop coil in the middle of a 17 cm diameter plastic sphere filled with saline solution to control the relaxation times. We positioned the phantom such that the loop is in the (xy) plane and the target oscillating field results in the (B_{0}) field direction.
Diagram of the experimental setup. (a) A function generator is connected to a 12.2 Ω resistor in parallel with a 22 nF capacitor to avoid high-frequency coupling. The circuit is connected to a loop coil of isolated copper wire inside a plastic sphere filled with a solution of water and ({text{MnCl}}_{2}) (0.07 mmol). Diameter measures are in mm. (b) Picture of the phantom connected to the function generator outside the scanner room.
The coil connects to the function generator (Rigol DG1022Z) through the circuit shown in Fig. 2a. The generator allows controlling the amplitude, frequency, and initial phase of the output signal. The external trigger of the scanner gives the signal to the generator to start the output. For the experiments with composite signals, we designed them using MATLAB and imported the data files into the generator using a 1024Sa/s firing rate.
RESL and CRESL compensate for the influence that (B_{1}) inhomogeneity has on the excitation angle (alpha). However, the error in the amplitude of the SL pulse is not corrected and this will affect the (F_{SL}) value. To correct for this effect, we performed a manual calibration of the SL amplitude using the CRESL preparation and applied the fitted correction for each SL pulse amplitude used in this work (more detail on Supplementary information 3).
The first set of experiments was designed to compare the performance of the three Spin-lock preparations with respect to initial phase dependence, robustness to field imperfections, and frequency selectivity.
To study the dependence with the initial phase (varphi), we simulated the sequence in the resonance condition ((omega_{NC} = omega_{SL} = 2pi 90) Hz) as a function of (T_{SL}) and (varphi), for the three preparations shown in Fig. 1b. For each value of (T_{SL}) moving between 70 and 100 ms in 1 ms steps, (varphi) varies between (left[ { – pi ,pi } right]) in 0.1 rad steps. The simulations did not consider (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) inhomogeneities for this analysis.
To better visualize the phase dependency, we simulated and measured the signal contrast as a function of (T_{SL}) for random and non-random phases. The presented signal contrast was calculated as the ratio between the signal with and without the oscillating initial field ((M/M_{0} )). For random phases, 100 repetitions were taken and averaged for each (T_{SL}). For non-random phases, we set the initial phase to 0 and 30 repetitions were acquired and averaged for each point.
To evaluate the robustness of the contrast against (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) imperfections, we calculated the standard deviation of the contrast for all the possible values of the initial phase (varphi) varying between (left[ { – pi ,pi } right]) in 0.1 rad steps. The map consists of the standard deviation for each combination of the field inhomogeneities. We considered (B_{1}) imperfections to deviate the (alpha) angle (pm 5^circ) from the desired 90° value (equivalent to a 0.1 ppm variation around the optimal 100 Hz frequency for a 2.5 ms excitation pulse), and (B_{0}) inhomogeneity to vary the off-resonance frequency in a (left[ { – 30,30} right]) Hz range.
To evaluate the capability of the SIRS preparations to filter specific frequency components, we simulated and measured the contrast for a fixed (F_{SL} = 90) Hz while varying the frequency of the target field. (omega_{NC} /2pi) changed between 60 and 120 Hz in 5 Hz steps with amplitude 75 nT and initial random phase. 100 repetitions were acquired and averaged for each point. We repeated this procedure for each (T_{SL}) in the range of 70 to 100 ms in 5 ms steps. For each value of (T_{SL}), we estimated the full-width half maximum (FWHM) and used it as a measure of selectivity of the filter. The simulation was performed for the same parameters, raffling a random phase for each repetition.
In this section, we investigated the capability of CRESL to be used as a filter of frequency components when in the presence of composite signals. First, we measured a signal represented by (Sleft( t right) = aleft( t right)sinleft( {2pi 53t} right) + left( {1 – aleft( t right)} right)sinleft( {2pi 97t} right)) where the piecewise constant parameter (aleft( t right)) changes its value every 30 s intervals assuming the values (left( {0,frac{1}{4},frac{1}{2},frac{3}{4},1} right)). Then, the amplitudes of the 97 and 53 Hz components vary every 30 s but the maximum signal amplitude remains constant throughout the experiment. We chose these frequencies because their separation is greater than the bandwidth of the preparation and because their period is not a multiple of (T_{R}), and therefore there is no repeated phases of the oscillation throughout the experiment. The signal was acquired for (F_{SL} = 53) Hz and (F_{SL} = 97) Hz, with (T_{SL} = 100) ms, and (T_{R}) = 1017 ms, 206 repetitions were performed that account to 210 s. Measurements consist of successive repetitions alternating (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) acquisitions. (SL_{on}) acquisitions were described in “Magnetization dynamics under spin-lock preparations schemes” section and (SL_{off}) acquisitions are a non-prepared EPI readout where the first (T_{SL}) ms are left empty. The double resonance effect cannot be separated from other factors influencing the contrast (BOLD, image artifacts, physiological noise, etc.). Here, we propose to use the division of the successive (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) acquisitions to filter out the spurious effects encoded by the common EPI readout. Therefore, after the acquisition, the point-to-point division ((ppdleft( t right))) of the signals (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) was calculated. Each frequency component is computed as the standard deviation of the (ppd) for each time block.
Delineating the seizure onset zone in refractory epilepsy patients is, in our view, the most relevant clinical application for this sequence. This application requires locating that part of the brain having the highest component of frequencies associated with the epileptogenic activity. Therefore, the second experiment tested the sequence capability to reconstruct frequency components of individually acquired signals. Four signals intend to represent four different voxels of the brain. They all consist of a 60 s 0.1 Hz sinusoidal with an amplitude of (x = 81) nT and a 30 Hz sine of amplitude (x/2) is added the last 30 s. For signals 2, 3, and 4, a 90 Hz sine is added with amplitude (0.1x) and divided into blocks of 20, 10, and 2 s, respectively. To calculate the components of the original signal, we applied a bandpass filter of 20 Hz around the target frequency and computed the standard deviation. We measured each signal in time alternating (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) acquisitions, setting (F_{SL}) to 30,60 and 90 Hz, with (T_{SL} = 100) ms and (T_{R}) = 324 ms. 186 repetitions were taken to account for the 60 s signal duration. We chose these frequencies to comprehend the influence that slow variations of the signal can have on the detection of small amplitude fast oscillations. Finally, we reconstructed the frequency components for each (F_{SL}) as the standard deviation of the (ppd) signal.
Figure 3a shows the simulated contrast for the three preparations as a function of (T_{SL}) and the initial phase of the target field (varphi). As seen in Fig. 3a(i), BASL is independent of the initial phase and sets the contrast upper limit when all the phases are averaged for a given (T_{SL}). Figure 3a(ii, iii) demonstrate the phase dependence for RESL and CRESL. Depending on the (T_{SL}) value, the opposite phase in the second SL pulse refocuses the accumulated contrast, creating the shown stripped pattern. The pattern is shifted between RESL and CRESL due to the delay in (M/M_{0}) generated by the 180° pulse. The average contrast in all the phases for RESL and CRESL is half of that of BASL for a given (T_{SL}).
SIRS contrast dependence with phase. (a) Simulated contrast amplitude as a function of (T_{SL}) and the initial phase of the target oscillating field (varphi) for a sinusoidal field in resonance with the SL pulse for (i) BASL, (ii) RESL and (iii) CRESL. (b) Measurement and simulation of the contrast in resonance condition as a function of (T_{SL}) for the cases of triggered ((varphi = 0), circles and plain lines) and averaged non-triggered signal (random initial phase, triangles, and dashed lines). (B_{NC}) = 75 nT, (omega_{NC} = omega_{SL} = 2pi 90Hz).
Figure 3b compares the simulated signal without inhomogeneity with measurements for both triggered ((varphi = 0)) and averaged non-triggered initial phase ((varphi) varying in the range [− (pi),(pi)]). As shown in Fig. 3b(i), field imperfections induce oscillations in BASL, decreasing its average contrast. For certain values of (T_{SL}), the signal in resonance ((M)) is higher than the signal without resonant field ((M_{0})), generating a contrast greater than one. This counterintuitive result can be explained by analyzing the magnetization dynamics for different field inhomogeneity values (a detailed analysis can be found in Supplementary information 4). (B_{0}) inhomogeneities also influence the RESL contrast, but the theoretical curve qualitatively represents the experimental signal. For CRESL, instead, the signal corresponds best to its theoretical value for both the phase zero and the mean contrast cases.
Given the oscillating behavior showed in Fig. 3, we defined the signal contrast as the standard deviation of all the random phases. Figure 4 shows the variation of the contrast for the three preparations as a function of both (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) inhomogeneities for two different values of (T_{SL}) when fixing (F_{SL} = 90 Hz). The maximum std of the contrast is minimum for the CRESL case ((sigma < 4.2%) for both cases). RESL is highly dependent on (B_{0}) changes and the relationship (T_{SL} /F_{SL}) ((sigma < 17.5%) for the worst case). BASL is susceptible to both (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) inhomogeneities and therefore diagonal patterns are observed ((sigma < 13.4%) for both cases). The uncertainty of flip angle between 85 and 95 degree corresponds to that of spin-lock frequency between 85 and 95 Hz. When also considering the influence of the spin-lock frequency error, the maximum variation values are 13.1%, 18.3% and 4.2% for BASL, RESL and CRESL respectively. Therefore, this effect is small enough to ignore. This means that CRESL is the most robust against (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) inhomogeneities when using the standard deviation as the featured metric.
Simulated contrast variation map (signal standard deviation (sigma)) as a function of the excitation angle α (°) and the frequency offset (Delta omega_{0}) (Hz) in resonance condition, (omega_{NC} = omega_{SL} = 2pi 90Hz). (a) For (T_{SL}) = 90 ms: (i) BASL ((sigma < 13.4% )), (ii) RESL ((sigma < 17.5% )), and (iii) CRESL ((sigma < 3.7% )). (b) For (T_{SL}) = 100 ms: (i) BASL ((sigma < 12.8% )), (ii) RESL ((sigma < 4.3% )), and (iii) CRESL ((sigma < 4.2% )).
Figure 5 shows the simulation and measurement of the FWHM as a function of (T_{SL}) for CRESL and BASL. For BASL, the simulation without considering inhomogeneities sub-estimates the measured bandwidth. Still, it remains lower than the CRESL case for the entire (T_{SL}) range by about 10 Hz. The FWHM diminishes when increasing (T_{SL}) for both preparations, i.e., the longer the preparation time, the higher the frequency selectivity. Due to hardware constraints, (T_{SL} = 100) ms is the maximum allowed value, setting the bandwidth to 12 Hz and 17 Hz for BASL and CRESL, respectively. For this (T_{SL}), and with the minimum possible (T_{R}) value, the specific absorption rate (SAR) limits the highest usable (F_{SL}) to 220 Hz (for more details in SAR estimation see Supplementary information 5).
Simulation and measurement of the FWHM of the double resonance effect for BASL and CRESL preparations as a function of (T_{SL}). For both cases (B_{NC} = 75) nT, (omega_{SL} = 2pi 90) Hz.
Figure 6a shows the measurement of the (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) signals in time for (F_{SL}) set to 53 and 97 Hz. The signal behavior is qualitatively well represented by the simulation shown in Fig. 6b. Figure 6c shows the point-to-point division (ppd) between the signals on and off, and Fig. 6d the corresponding simulation. Finally, Fig. 6e, f present the measured and simulated normalized components of the two target frequencies. The average error for the normalized std(ppd) between the simulated and measured signal is of 8.6%. This value does not consider the intervals that were normalized to 1. In addition, attempts to fit the curve with the simulator using the initial phase and SL frequency as fit parameters failed to converge.
Sequence response to a composite signal. (a) Measured and (b) simulated (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) signals as a function of time for (F_{SL}) set at 53 Hz and 97 Hz. (c) Measured and (d) simulated ppd between (SL_{on}) and (SL_{off}) as a function of time for the two frequencies used in (a). (e) Measured and (f) simulated normalized frequency component every 30 s block.
Figure 7 shows the response of the CRESL sequence to the acquisition of individual signals with different frequency components. Panel (a) shows the input signals and panel (b) the frequency components corresponding to each signal. Panel (c) shows the components reconstructed from the measurement and panel (d) from the simulation. The 0.1 Hz ripple appears in the measured signal even if the (F_{SL}) is 30, 60 or 90 Hz, resulting in a higher ratio in each channel. In the same way, signal amplitude is higher than expected at 60 Hz. From the time-acquired signal (see Supplementary information 6), it is seen that such erroneous detection is caused by traces of the 0.1 Hz oscillation, that decrease for increasing (F_{SL}). Nevertheless, if the signals represent different volumes in an image, the method can correctly locate the volume with the highest amount of 90 Hz, despite its small amplitude.
Component reconstruction of individual signals. (a) Input signals composed of a 0.1 Hz with a 30 Hz sine the last 30 s. A 90 Hz sine is added in 20, 10, and 2 s blocks for signals 2, 3, and 4 respectively, the shaded areas indicate the location of the 90 Hz wave. (b) Frequency components of the signals showed in (a) at 30, 60 and 90 Hz. (c) Components reconstructed from measurement with (F_{SL}) fixed at 30, 60 and 90 Hz. (d) Frequency components reconstructed from the simulation with the same parameters as in the measurement.
We found that the acquisition of the SIRS signal in time will have an oscillating behavior and the reason behind the oscillations depends on the type of SL preparation. According to Fig. 3a, the rotary preparations will oscillate due to the phase of the oscillating field and the relation between (T_{SL}) and (F_{SL}), as was previously suggested by18. In addition, the theoretical BASL signal does not depend on the phase and presents the contrast upper limit when averaging in all the possible phases. However, Fig. 3b shows that in practice, (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) inhomogeneities induce oscillations also for the BASL approach, deviating the contrast from the theoretical value. RESL has a mixed behavior, being dependent on (B_{0}) and the initial phase of the oscillating field and finally, CRESL oscillates exclusively due to the initial phase.
The optimal contrast to locate oscillating fields should depend solely on the double resonance effect and not on the spatial variation of the (B_{0}) and (B_{1}) fields. Given the unavoidable oscillating nature of the contrast, and as it was previously suggested for the SLOE approach18,26, we adopted the standard deviation as a metric to quantify the influence of the target field. Within this metric, according to Fig. 4, CRESL is the most robust preparation even within the double resonance dynamic, which further supports the idea firstly proved in the field of (T_{1rho }) relaxation15,16. On the other hand, RESL still depends on the heterogeneities of (B_{0}) (Fig. 4a(ii)), and for certain combinations of (T_{SL}) and (F_{SL}), RESL presents the highest variability. Therefore, we have discarded it in the following analysis.
The analysis of the bandwidth presented in Fig. 5 shows that BASL is in average more selective than CRESL for about 10 Hz in the studied range. This would indicate that BASL can better separate closer frequency components of a composite signal. In addition, Fig. 5 shows that the bandwidth can be reduced by increasing (T_{SL}). Nevertheless, the Specific Absorption Rate (SAR) and the scanner’s hardware constraints will limit the highest (T_{SL}) value. To avoid these limitations, (T_{R}) must grow, but this means lowering the temporal resolution when signals are acquired in time. Therefore, the trade-off between increasing frequency selectivity and lowering the temporal resolution must be considered for future applications (further SAR analysis is presented in Supplementary information 5).
Based on the results of the analysis of the SL preparation, we decided to adopt the CRESL method due to its robustness. Using this preparation, we tested the response to composite signals by acquiring the signal over time. When analyzing a signal that varies the amplitude of its frequency components in a step-wise manner over time, the simulator and the measured signal showed the same empirical behavior, as is shown in Fig. 6a, b. However, there are several differences between them in terms of waveform and the number of peaks and the reconstructed components showed in Fig. 6e, f present a variation of 8.6%. Furthermore, a measurement fit using the SL frequency and the initial phase of the field as free parameters failed to converge. Although this analysis is limited to a qualitative evaluation only, both ppd signals showed changes in amplitude that represent the expected changes in the ratios of each block.
Our last experiment aimed to test the sequence capability to reconstruct frequency components of individually acquired signals without including prior information during post-processing. As shown in Fig. 7, the high amplitude of the low frequency variation induces a detection despite not being in resonance (see also Supplementary information 6). This effect was not seen in the simulator. We hypothesize that this effect is because the simulator does not consider the influence of the sequence during image acquisition, which affects both the acquisition with and without SL. This reveals a limitation of the proposed ppd metric. The point-to-point division of the signals on and off is designed to eliminate artifacts detected in the readout part of the sequence, however, those artifacts will only be filtered out when they are either static or vary slower than (2T_{R}) (time it takes to acquire two consecutives on and off signals). Despite this, the proportions shown follow the same behavior as the frequency components. The signal manages to reconstruct which channel has the highest amount of high-frequency component. This proof of principle experiment is promising for the application of this sequence to create a map where each pixel amplitude represents the activation at a given frequency. It also shows that it is necessary to make the simulator more complex to include the effect of image acquisition, as has been previously proposed27.
In summary, there were two main findings in this work. First, the double resonance signal is oscillatory for the three studied preparations. From the analysis of these oscillations, it was found that CRESL is the most robust against field inhomogeneities when using the std(ppd) as a metric. Second, the ppd signal can separate and estimate the amplitude of frequency components within individually acquired composite signals. However, there are two strong limitations of this method. The first one, common to the three SL preparations, is that the susceptibility of the SL amplitude to (B_{1}) is countered with the SL calibration but not corrected. This calibration requires extra measurements. The second one is that multiples acquisitions are necessary for a reliable calculation of the std(ppd). This in turn requires that the resonant oscillating field is present during sufficiently long periods of time. This would require the analysis of more realistic signals to evaluate the clinical usefulness. These results suggest that the metric and preparation studied can be used in future research for the characterization of physiological signals.
We investigated the magnetization dynamics of three Spin-lock preparations in the presence of a resonant oscillating field and characterized the influence of field inhomogeneities. By simulations and phantom experiments, we found that all three spin-lock preparations exhibit an oscillating contrast as a function of time. Due to the oscillating behavior, we used the standard deviation of the signal as a metric to quantify the influence of the target field. We showed the std metric within the CRESL preparation is the most robust against field inhomogeneities even in the presence of the double resonance effect.
By acquiring composite signals with the chosen CRESL preparation, we found that is possible to distinguish the frequency components of individual signals composed of multiple frequencies. These results indicate that the CRESL-prepared SIRS sequence has the potential to be used for the detection and localization of oscillating fields with frequencies associated with specific pathologies. In the future, we aim to assess the detection limit of the presented methods under realistic physiological and pathological conditions.
Simulation source codes and data can be shared upon reasonable request to M.C.
Michel, C. M. & Murray, M. M. Towards the utilization of EEG as a brain imaging tool. Neuroimage 61, 371–385 (2012).
Article Google Scholar
Hämäläinen, M., Hari, R., Ilmoniemi, R. J., Knuutila, J. & Lounasmaa, O. V. Magnetoencephalography theory, instrumentation, and applications to noninvasive studies of the working human brain. Rev. Mod. Phys. 65, 413–497 (1993).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Barkley, G. L. & Baumgartner, C. MEG and EEG in epilepsy. J. Clin. Neurophysiol. 20, 163–178 (2003).
Article Google Scholar
Ahlfors, S. P., Han, J., Belliveau, J. W. & Hämäläinen, M. S. Sensitivity of MEG and EEG to source orientation. Brain Topogr. 23, 227–232 (2010).
Article Google Scholar
Ogawa, S., Lee, T. M., Kay, A. R. & Tank, D. W. Brain magnetic resonance imaging with contrast dependent on blood oxygenation. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 87, 9868–9872 (1990).
ADS CAS Article Google Scholar
Logothetis, N. K. What we can do and what we cannot do with fMRI. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature06976.
Witzel, T., Lin, F. H., Rosen, B. R. & Wald, L. L. Stimulus-induced Rotary Saturation (SIRS): A potential method for the detection of neuronal currents with MRI. Neuroimage 42, 1357–1365 (2008).
Article Google Scholar
Halpern-Manners, N. W., Bajaj, V. S., Teisseyre, T. Z. & Pines, A. Magnetic resonance imaging of oscillating electrical currents. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1003146107/-/DCSupplemental.
Sheng, J. et al. A comprehensive study of sensitivity in measuring oscillatory magnetic fields using rotary saturation pulse sequences. Magn. Reson. Imaging 34, 326–333 (2016).
Article Google Scholar
Ueda, H., Ito, Y., Oida, T., Taniguchi, Y. & Kobayashi, T. Detection of tiny oscillatory magnetic fields using low-field MRI: A combined phantom and simulation study. J. Magn. Reson. 319, 106828 (2020).
CAS Article Google Scholar
Nagahara, S., Ueno, M. & Kobayashi, T. Spin-lock imaging for direct detection of oscillating magnetic fields with MRI: Simulations and phantom studies. Adv. Biomed. Eng. 2, 63–71 (2013).
Article Google Scholar
Ito, Y., Ueno, M. & Kobayashi, T. Neural magnetic field dependent fMRI toward direct functional connectivity measurements: A phantom study. Sci. Rep. 10 (2020).
Sogabe, T., Ueda, H., Ito, Y., Taniguchi, Y. & Kobayashi, T. Dependence of stimulus-induced rotary saturation on the direction of target oscillating magnetic fields: A phantom and simulation study. J. Magn. Reson. 321, 106849 (2020).
CAS Article Google Scholar
Charagundla, S. R., Borthakur, A., Leigh, J. S. & Reddy, R. Artifacts in T1ρ-weighted imaging: Correction with a self-compensating spin-locking pulse. J. Magn. Reson. 162, 113–121 (2003).
ADS CAS Article Google Scholar
Witschey, W. R. T. et al. Artifacts in T1ρ-weighted imaging: Compensation for B1 and B0 field imperfections. J. Magn. Reson. 186, 75–85 (2007).
ADS CAS Article Google Scholar
Wáng, Y.-X.J. et al. T1ρ magnetic resonance: basic physics principles and applications in knee and intervertebral disc imaging. Quant. Imaging Med. Surg. 5, 858–85885 (2015).
PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar
Yuan, J. et al. Quantification of T 1ρrelaxation by using rotary echo spin-lock pulses in the presence of B 0inhomogeneity. Phys. Med. Biol. 57, 5003–5016 (2012).
Article Google Scholar
Jiang, X. et al. Detection of subnanotesla oscillatory magnetic fields using MRI. Magn. Reson. Med. 75, 519–526 (2016).
Article Google Scholar
Gonzalez Andino, S. L. et al. Measuring the complexity of time series: An application to neurophysiological signals. Hum. Brain Mapp. 11, 46–57 (2000).
CAS Article Google Scholar
Buzsáki, G., Anastassiou, C. A. & Koch, C. The origin of extracellular fields and currents—EEG, ECoG, LFP and spikes. Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 2012(13), 407–420 (2012).
Article Google Scholar
Wang, X. J. Neurophysiological and computational principles of cortical rhythms in cognition. Physiol. Rev. 90, 1195 (2010).
Article Google Scholar
Khosravani, H. et al. Spatial localization and time-dependant changes of electrographic high frequency oscillations in human temporal lobe epilepsy. Epilepsia 50, 605–616 (2009).
Article Google Scholar
Charupanit, K., Sen-Gupta, I., Lin, J. J. & Lopour, B. A. Amplitude of high frequency oscillations as a biomarker of the seizure onset zone. Clin. Neurophysiol. 131, 2542–2550 (2020).
Article Google Scholar
Kiefer, C., Abela, E., Schindler, K. & Wiest, R. Focal Epilepsy: MR imaging of nonhemodynamic field effects by using a Phase-cycled Stimulus-induced Rotary saturation approach with Spin-Lock preparation. Radiology 280, 237–243 (2016).
Article Google Scholar
Ueda, H. et al. Dynamics of magnetization under stimulus-induced rotary saturation sequence. J. Magn. Reson. 295, 38–44 (2018).
ADS CAS Article Google Scholar
Coletti, C., Domsch, S., Vos, F. & Weingartner, S. Functional MRI of neuro-electro-magnetic oscillations: Statistical processing in the presence of system imperfections. In Proceedings of the 2020 IEEE EMBS Conference on Biomedical Engineering and Sciences, IECBES 2020 172–177 (2021). https://doi.org/10.1109/IECBES48179.2021.9398751.
Ueda, H., Ito, Y., Oida, T., Taniguchi, Y. & Kobayashi, T. Magnetic resonance imaging simulation with spin-lock preparations to detect tiny oscillatory magnetic fields. J. Magn. Reson. 324, 106910 (2021).
CAS Article Google Scholar
Download references
This study was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF) within the project: Predict and Monitor Epilepsy After a First Seizure: The Swiss-First Study (SNSF, CRSII5-180365, PI Roland Wiest), the Kernen-Fonds für Epileptische and the Schweizerische Epilesieliga Forschunsgpreis 2018 (Swiss league against epilepsy). We thank Hans Slotboom, Guodong Weng and Andreas Federspiel (Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Neuroradiology, Support Centre for Advanced Neuroimaging (SCAN), University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland) for their essential discussion of the work. We also thank Regina Reissmann (Biomedical analyst, NEUR, Inselspital, Bern) and Thierry Rumo (Medical technician, DT, Inselspital, Bern) for the technical help in the implementation of the phantom.
Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Neuroradiology, Support Center for Advanced Neuroimaging (SCAN), University of Bern, Freiburgstrasse 16, 3010, Bern, Switzerland
Milena Capiglioni, Federico Turco, Roland Wiest & Claus Kiefer
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
All authors conceived the idea of this work. M.C. designed the experiments, implemented the simulations, and wrote the manuscript. M.C. and F.T. performed the measurements and analyzed the data. C.K. and R.W. supervised this study. All authors provided discussion and reviewed the manuscript.
Correspondence to Milena Capiglioni.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Capiglioni, M., Turco, F., Wiest, R. et al. Analysis of the robustness and dynamics of spin-locking preparations for the detection of oscillatory magnetic fields. Sci Rep 12, 16965 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21232-1
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21232-1
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.
For Chileans blinded in police violence, making music has become one path to healing – Iowa Public Radio
SANTIAGO, Chile — At a recording studio in downtown Santiago, musicians are noodling on guitars and adjusting the drum kit as they set up for a jam session that’s part rehearsal, part therapy.
All 10 members of the band, called Hacía la Victoria, Spanish for “Onward to Victory,” sustained serious eye injuries during clashes with police who used tear gas and shotguns against anti-government protesters in 2019.
The band’s lyrics focus on police brutality as well as the musicians’ pain, confusion and frustration over what happened to them. In one song, “Así fue,” or “That’s what happened,” guitarist Sergio Concha recalls the day the demonstrations broke out, when he was hit in the left eye with a shotgun pellet while taking part in the protests.
While playing the song, he says, “It feels like going back to that moment, when all of Santiago was on fire, when there were barricades in the streets, when masked protesters fought the police, and when I was in the hospital with my eye patched.”
During five months of demonstrations, about 30 people were killed while more than 450 protesters were left partially blind when they were hit in the face with shotgun pellets or tear gas canisters fired by the police to control the crowds, according to Chile’s National Human Rights Institute.
César Muñoz, a senior researcher in South America for Human Rights Watch, says the police lacked training in crowd control. Their shotgun shells usually contained metal rather than less damaging rubber pellets. And instead of firing from a safer distance and pointing toward the lower extremities of protesters, he says, agents often fired their shotguns straight at them from short range.
“It was kind of shocking to me,” Muñoz tells NPR.
Meanwhile, the victims of eye injuries became high-profile symbols of the protest movement, which was triggered by an increase in subway fares but expanded to include calls for more affordable housing, health care and education and better access to decent jobs and pensions. One of the victims, Fabiola Campillai — who lost sight permanently in both eyes after being hit in the face with a tear gas canister — was elected to the Chilean Senate last year.
But instead of denouncing the police brutality, some Chileans labeled the injured protesters “troublemakers” who got what they deserved, says Diego Leppez, who was hit in the face with a tear gas canister that fractured his nose and left his right eye blind.
Survivors of eye injuries are easily identifiable because it’s hard to hide their injuries. Some wear black eye patches or, as in the case of Sen. Campillai, their appearance is altered.
Leppez says he has been jeered at in the supermarket and on the streets of Santiago and has been treated for depression. Protesting for a better Chile “turned into a really big sacrifice,” he says. “In my case, it cost me an eye.”
The members of Hacía la Victoria have found a path to recovery through music.
The idea for the band was hatched during Zoom meetings between eye-injury victims during the COVID-19 pandemic. Several were musicians and once the quarantines ended, they started jamming together.
The band’s rhythmic and emotional foundation is 23-year-old Gustavo Gatica. He was studying psychology at a Santiago university when the protests broke out. He joined in, but during one of the marches, Gatica was hit in the face with shotgun pellets, leaving him totally blind.
To take out his own frustrations, Gatica took up drumming and then joined Hacía la Victoria. Remembering that another protester who sustained an eye injury took his own life last year, Gatica says: “It’s really important to have a circle of support.”
Andrés López, a filmmaker and one of the band’s vocalists, feels the same way. With most people, he finds it awkward to talk about the shotgun pellet that left him blind in his right eye. But with his bandmates, he can open up.
“With these guys, it’s very easy,” López says during a break in the rehearsal.
Songwriter and vocalist César Galloso adds: “There have been a lot of ups and downs, mentally and physically. But this musical project has helped a lot. We understand each other because we all went through the same thing.”
The band plays a mix of genres, from hip hop to reggae to heavy metal. As it gains more attention, Hacía la Victoria has been playing in public nearly every week and has recorded several songs.
But its members are most proud of the fact that their protests helped change Chile.
For one thing, the country now has a left-wing government headed by President Gabriel Boric, a former student leader who is trying to address some of the protesters’ demands.
“That’s an important first step,” says Gatica, the drummer.
But there have also been disappointments. On Sept. 4, a progressive new draft constitution — strongly supported by the protest movement — was overwhelmingly rejected by Chilean voters.
That’s why, in spite of their injuries, Gatica and the other band members insist they will remain active — both on stage and on the streets.
Copyright 2022 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.
Google and Harmonai reveal their latest AI music models – Music Ally
The digital marketing guide: expert insight, case studies, fresh approaches, and overlooked opportunities.
The latest and best jobs in the global music industry
Brief, deep analysis of essential music business stuff: every week, in about 20 mins.
Essential international guides, packed with data, interviews, strategies, and local insight.
Twice-monthly reports on the newest platforms – to help you find a competitive edge.
Music Ally Ltd., Holborn Studios,
49-50 Eagle Wharf Rd, London, N1 7ED,
United Kingdom
Music Ally is a Registered Learning Provider 10029483
Music Production Equipment Market Size to Record USD 1.27 Billion Growth, Rising number of music festivals and live events to be a Key Trend – Technavio – PR Newswire
Searching for your content…
In-Language News
Contact Us
888-776-0942
from 8 AM – 10 PM ET
News provided by
Oct 10, 2022, 06:45 ET
Share this article
NEW YORK, Oct. 10, 2022 /PRNewswire/ — The music production equipment market size is expected to grow by USD 1.27 billion at a CAGR of 2.44 % between 2021 to 2026, according to Technavio’s latest market report. One of the key trends in the music production equipment market includes the rising number of music festivals and live events. The large base of the young population, coupled with a surge in disposable income, has led more people to spend on such live events. Hence, the increasing number of live performances and concerts by musicians, artists, dancers, and comedians will play a major role in driving the growth of the global music production equipment market during the forecast period. Get a comprehensive report summary describing the market size and forecast along with research methodology Download Free Sample Report.
The music production equipment market is fragmented due to the presence of many global, regional, and local vendors. Vendors are deploying growth strategies such as brand, labor, quality, and innovation to compete in the market. They are also placing a strong emphasis on creating novel products as well as establishing their brands and brand equity.
The music production equipment market has been segmented into the type (public address equipment, digital keyboards, studio headphones, DJ gear, and music synthesizers) and geography (APAC, North America, Europe, South America, and Middle East and Africa). By type, the public address equipment will grow during the forecast period with the rising number of live public events and public congregations, which is propelling the demand for public address equipment globally. By geography, APAC will account for 41%% of the market’s growth during the forecast period, with the rising adoption of music production equipment by developing countries, such as India, China, Indonesia, and Thailand, owing to the increasing disposable income, rapid urbanization, and improvements in living standards will facilitate the music production equipment market growth in APAC over the forecast period. To gain insights into the factors impacting the growth of the market Download Free Sample Report.
The rising number of musicians and artists is one of the major drivers impacting the music production equipment market growth. The emergence of upcoming musicians and artists has changed the era of music. They are creating and introducing new songs and mixing songs to produce remix tracks. To grab the attention of fans, musicians are also organizing music events through concert promoters or live event organizers. Hence, the rising number of live events is expected to accelerate the demand for music production equipment, which, in turn, will drive the growth of the market.
Music Production Equipment Market Scope
Report Coverage
Details
Page number
120
Base year
2021
Forecast period
2022-2026
Growth momentum & CAGR
Accelerate at a CAGR of 2.44%
Market growth 2022-2026
USD 1.27 billion
Market structure
Fragmented
YoY growth (%)
1.61
Regional analysis
APAC, North America, Europe, South America, and Middle East and Africa
Performing market contribution
APAC at 41%
Key consumer countries
US, Canada, China, Japan, Germany, and UK
Competitive landscape
Leading companies, competitive strategies, consumer engagement scope
Companies profiled
Ableton AG, Audio Technica US Inc., Avid Technology Inc., Blackstar Amplification Ltd., C. F. Martin and Co. Inc., D Addario and Co. Inc., Fender Musical Instruments Corp., Gibson Brands Inc., Headstock Distribution Ltd, Kawai Musical Instruments Mfg. Co. Ltd., KORG Inc., KROTOS Ltd., Marshall Amplification, QRS Music Technologies Inc., Roland Corp., Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Sennheiser Electronic GmbH and Co. KG, Shure Inc., Sony Group Corp, Steinway Musical Instruments, Teufel, and Yamaha Corp.
Market Dynamics
Parent market analysis, Market growth inducers and obstacles, Fast-growing and slow-growing segment analysis, COVID-19 impact and future consumer dynamics, and market condition analysis for the forecast period.
Customization purview
If our report has not included the data that you are looking for, you can reach out to our analysts and get segments customized.
1 Executive Summary
2 Market Landscape
3 Market Sizing
4 Five Forces Analysis
5 Market Segmentation by Type
6 Customer Landscape
7 Geographic Landscape
8 Drivers, Challenges, and Trends
9 Vendor Landscape
10 Vendor Analysis
11 Appendix
Technavio is a leading global technology research and advisory company. Their research and analysis focuses on emerging market trends and provides actionable insights to help businesses identify market opportunities and develop effective strategies to optimize their market positions. With over 500 specialized analysts, Technavio’s report library consists of more than 17,000 reports and counting, covering 800 technologies, spanning 50 countries. Their client base consists of enterprises of all sizes, including more than 100 Fortune 500 companies. This growing client base relies on Technavio’s comprehensive coverage, extensive research, and actionable market insights to identify opportunities in existing and potential markets and assess their competitive positions within changing market scenarios.
Contact
Technavio Research
Jesse Maida
Media & Marketing Executive
US: +1 844 364 1100
UK: +44 203 893 3200
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.technavio.com/
SOURCE Technavio
More news releases in similar topics
Cision Distribution 888-776-0942
from 8 AM – 9 PM ET
New York Comic Con 2022: Exclusive Photos Of Stars At HL's NYCC Studio – Hollywood Life – HollywoodLife
Hollywood Life
Latest Hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News
HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio is back and better than ever! After a 2-year absence due to the COVID-19 pandemic, HollywoodLife was thrilled to have its first exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio since 2019. Over the course of NYCC weekend, the cast and stars of your favorite shows stopped by for an exclusive portrait session with HL’s photo director, Paige Kindlick.
‘One Of Us Is Lying’ started off HollywoodLife’s portrait studio. Cast members Cooper van Grootel, Marianly Tejada, Annalisa Cochrane, and Chibuikem Uche were the first to step in front of the camera. ‘Titans’ star Brenton Thwaites returned to HollywoodLife’s portrait studio in 2022.
‘The Wheel of Time’ creator Rafe Judkins and stars Madeleine Madden, Ceara Coveney, Dónal Finn, Daniel Henney, and Marcus Rutherford stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio for the first time. Other stars included ‘Star Trek: Strange New World’s Melissa Navia, the ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons’ cast and crew, and ‘The Winchesters’ cast. See all the exclusive photos from HollywoodLife’s newest NYCC portrait studio in our gallery now.
Meg Donnelly repped a Winchester shirt at HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio. She plays Mary Winchester in The CW series ‘The Winchesters.’
Drake Rodger stopped by HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio with co-star Meg Donnelly. He plays John Winchester in ‘The Winchesters.
Feeling vampy! Jacob Batalon, Em Haine, and Savannah Basley stopped by HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio.
Jacob Batalon gave off the ultimate cool vibes at HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio. The ‘Spider-Man’ alum stars in the new series ‘Reginald the Vampire.’
Em Haine and Savannah Basley posed for HollywoodLife’s New York Comic Con portrait studio. They star as Sarah Kinney and Angela in ‘Reginald the Vampire.’
Strike a pose, there’s nothing to it. ‘Reginald the Vampire’ star Em Haine wowed at HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio.
Savannah Basley looked stunning at HollywoodLife’s NYCC portrait studio. Savannah stars as Angela in the new SYFY series ‘Reginald the Vampire.’
Cooper van Grootel, Marianly Tejada, Annalisa Cochrane, and Chibuikem Uche were part of HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. ‘One Of Us Is Lying’ season 2 will premiere October 21 on Peacock.
Marianly Tejada wowed in red at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. She portrays Bronwyn in ‘One Of Us Is Lying.’
Cooper van Grootel rocked shades while posing at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. He plays Nate in ‘One Of Us Is Lying.’
Addy Prentiss forever! Annalisa Cochrane stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio.
Chibuikem Uche looked as suave as ever at HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. He portrays Cooper Clay in ‘One Of Us Is Lying.’
Natewyn for the win! Cooper van Grootel and Marianly Tejada posed together at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio.
One of us is red-hot! Marianly Tejada dazzled in red at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio.
Basking in the green light. Annalisa Cochrane looked stunning at HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio.
The ultimate cool guy vibes. Cooper van Grootel posed for HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio.
The one and only Mr. Uche! Chibuikem Uche looked dashing at HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio.
The fab four! Cooper van Grootel, Marianly Tejada, Annalisa Cochrane, and Chibuikem Uche helped kick off HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio.
Brenton Thwaites was red-hot at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. The actor is promoting his HBO Max series ‘Titans.’
Brenton Thwaites struck a pose at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. The actor plays Dick Grayson/Nightwing in ‘Titans.’
‘The Wheel of Time’ stars Madeleine Madden, Ceara Coveney, Dónal Finn, Daniel Henney, and Marcus Rutherford, as well as creator Rafe Judkins, stopped by HollywoodLife’s 2022 New York Comic Con portrait studio. The cast is promoting season 2 of the Prime Video series.
Madeleine Madden dazzled at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. She plays Egwene Al’Vere in ‘The Wheel of Time.’
Ceara Coveney shined at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. The actress plays Elayne Trakand in ‘The Wheel of Time.’
Dónal Finn stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. He plays Mat Cauthon in ‘The Wheel of Time.’
Rafe Judkins joined ‘The Wheel of Time’ cast at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. He is the creator and executive producer of the Prime Video series.
Daniel Henney looked handsome at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. The actor plays Lan Mandragoran in ‘The Wheel of Time.’
Marcus Rutherford stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. The actor plays Perrin Aybara in ‘The Wheel of Time.’
All love here! ‘The Wheel of Time’ stars Madeleine Madden, Ceara Coveney, Dónal Finn, Daniel Henney, and Marcus Rutherford, along with Rafe Judkins, showed off their smiles at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio.
‘Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ star Melissa Navia stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. She plays Erica Ortegas in the Paramount+ series.
‘Star Trek: Strange New Worlds’ star Melissa Navia posed at HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. The Paramount+ show’s second season is expected to premiere in 2023.
The cast and filmmakers posed together at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. The cast includes Jack Dylan Grazer, Jack Griffo, Laura Bailey, and Travis Willingham. The filmmakers are Matthew Peters, Rick Morales, and Jeremy Adams.
Jack Dylan Grazer showed off his smile at HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. The ‘It’ alum voices Jonathan Kent/Superboy in ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
The cast and filmmakers came to NYCC to promote the upcoming ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’ The film is Warner Bros. Animation’s first-ever all-CG animated, feature-length film.
Jack Griffo threw up some peace signs when he stopped by HollywoodLife’s New York Comic Con portrait studio. He voices Damian Wayne/Robin in ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Jack Dylan Grazer and Jack Griffo goofed around at HollywoodLife’s New York Comic Con portrait studio. They voice the roles of Jonathan Kent and Damian Wayne in ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Laura Bailey was a vision at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. She voices Lois Lane in ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Travis Willingham stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. He voices Clark Kent/Superman in ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Laura Bailey and Travis Willingham posed together at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. They voice the iconic characters of Lois Lane and Clark Kent in ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Jeremy Adams at HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. He is the writer of ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Matthew Peters stopped by HollywoodLife’s exclusive NYCC portrait studio. He is the director of ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Rick Morales showed off his Superman T-shirt while at HollywoodLife’s exclusive New York Comic Con portrait studio. He is one of the producers of ‘Batman and Superman: Battle of the Super Sons.’
Follow Us:
HollywoodLife
Legal
News
Connect
Tim Enso: "I’m a big fan of Middle Eastern culture and I really love their melodies" – Electronic Groove
EG caught up with Tim Enso to learn more about the drop of his ‘Babylon’ EP on Sudam Recordings, his summer, future projects, and more.
EG: Hi Tim! Welcome to EG. It’s a pleasure to have you here with us. Where are you based right now? How have things been going this year?
Tim Enso: Hi guys, thank you for having me! It’s a pleasure to be featured on EG. I currently live in Los Angeles, California. Everything is going pretty well so far.
EG: What was your Summer like? Any particular highlights?
Tim Enso: Summer was great as always, it’s my favorite season of the year. A lot of parties, especially my favorite daytime ones, and the main highlight was my first trip to Burning Man this year. It was incredible, it’s hard to explain how cool it was. In my opinion, it is the best music festival I’ve ever been to.
EG: By the way, congratulations on the release of your ‘Babylon’ EP on Sudam Recordings! What has the initial reception been like?
Tim Enso: Thank you. It is actually my first EP release so far and I’m really happy to collaborate with Sudam Recordings. We have received a lot of positive feedback from distinguished DJs so far.
EG: Coming from a more ‘classical’ background, how did you come to blend Eastern melodies with electronic music?
Tim Enso: I’m a big fan of Middle Eastern culture and I really love their melodies. Plus it’s a trendy vibe now in electronic music, especially in the deep house scene, so I kind of inspired by these sounds.
EG: What does your studio look like at the moment? Any new soft or hardware that you’d recommend?
Tim Enso: I have what they call a “bedroom studio” right now, but would love to have my own studio in the future. I work with Ableton and I think it’s the best software for electronic music. I use it a lot.
EG: How do you keep entertained when you’re not in the studio? Any good books, movies, or series you’d recommend?
Tim Enso: When I’m not working on my projects, I enjoy reading business books about the music industry, listening to some lifestyle podcasts, working out at the gym, and I also practice meditation and Qigong. My favorite book is ‘The Teachings of Don Juan’, by Carlos Castaneda.
EG: What’s next for Tim Enso? What particular milestones are you looking forwards to now?
Tim Enso: I’m currently working on our new project called ‘Heart of Gold’, with my good friend Gareth Berrow. It’s our DJ duo known for cinematically flowing disco house dance grooves and live saxophone performances.
EG: Thank you so much for your time, Tim! We wish you all the best for the future.
Tim Enso: Thank you EG!
TIm Enso’s ‘Babylon’ EP is out now via Sudam Recordings. Purchase your copy here.
Follow Tim Enso: SoundCloud | Instagram | Facebook | Spotify
Sinca is a Montreal-based artist with a deftly-crafted dance-floor sound, fusing hypnotic grooves, powerful baselines,…
Kevin Knapp is a force to be reckoned with, a musical heavyweight known for his…
Originally hailing from Cork, Wukah aka Gavin Desmond now lives in London teaching music production…
Door County Brewing Company – Production Manager – Brewbound.com Craft Beer Job Listing – Brewbound.com
Job Title: Production Manager
Hours: Full Time
Location: Our Brewery in Baileys Harbor, WI
Reports To: CBO and COO
Door County Brewing Co. and Hacienda Beer Co. are seeking a full-time Production Manager to join our small team at our brewery in Baileys Harbor, Wisconsin. The ideal candidate will train under our current Director of Brewing Operations (who is transitioning into running their own brewing project) over the course of 2-4 months.
The Production Manager will be responsible for managing all aspects of beer production for both our experimental Hacienda Beer Co. brand (produced in-house) and our larger Door County Brewing Co. brand (primarily contract brewed at a nearby facility). The Production Manager is a technical expert for all daily brewery operations and oversees the entire production team.
This employee must be a hard-working, responsible, and self-motivated individual with a passion for craft beer and a desire to continue learning and growing within the brewing industry. The candidate must be someone who leads by example in following procedure and policy, is proactive, and helps to maintain the highest standards of employee development and performance. The candidate needs to be ready to be flexible in their schedule and be available to work long hours if needed to get projects done and meet operations schedules.
This employee must also have sufficient experience to feel comfortable stepping in to produce wort on our 2-vessel 15-barrel QTS brewhouse, develop new recipes, and improve quality and consistency in collaboration with our Lead Brewer.
All applicants must be willing to move to Door County, WI—a picturesque area along Lake Michigan in Northern Wisconsin that has a heavy influx of seasonal residents and tourists.
To apply, please send your resume, a short cover letter, and a minimum of 3 professional references to [email protected].
Key Responsibilities:
Production Oversight, Management, and Planning
Manage and coordinate brewing schedule based on understanding of production times, proper yeast management, and demand from wholesale distribution and taprooms.
Manage inventory of finished products, allocating between distribution and taproom to maintain freshness and diversity in all sales channels.
Work with Production Team at all stages of the brewing and packaging processes to ensure quality of finished product.
Continually improve production processes to achieve and enhance the quality of products.
Work with Lead Brewer to formulate new recipes, taking into consideration both budget and current market trends in both distribution and taproom.
Manage contract brewing relationship: coordinate the brewing schedule, manage raw material inventory, implement recipe improvements to improve product quality and save cost, and coordinate outgoing product shipments from contract brewer to wholesale distribution partners and taprooms.
Coordinate and stay in constant communication with management team to forecast brewery costs and ensure profitability of brewing operations.
Work with Production Team to ensure production SOPs stay up-to-date and help to create new ones as needed.
Develop and implement effective communication channels with Production Team, including keeping them informed of important company updates and getting their feedback on a regular basis.
Review labor data regularly to ensure Production Team is staffed efficiently and appropriately.
Manage and oversee warehouse usage and organization to ensure efficient use of space and to accommodate other department needs.
Work with Production Team to maintain the highest standards of cleanliness and organization throughout the brewery.
Track and manage preventative and required maintenance schedules for all equipment used in production, including scheduling and coordination with government agencies and service providers for annual inspections of equipment, as needed.
Commission and source additional production equipment as needed in coordination with management and Lead Brewer.
Product Development
Work on all aspects of product development and formulation, including recipe formulation, package design, and materials procurement.
Coordinate and collaborate with management, vendors, and designers to bring product vision to reality while always maintaining high quality standards.
Manage collaborative projects with other breweries, which can include recipe formulation, communication with collaboration partners, materials procurement, and scheduling.
Raw Material Management
Procure all raw materials, chemicals, and other supplies required to create the finished beer.
Develop and maintain excellent working relationships with all suppliers of raw materials, packaging, and brewing equipment, and identify new suppliers to find competitive prices.
Manage contracts for hops and other raw materials by developing annual forecasts based on available data and planning.
Production Software Management
Handle and ensure that all brewing and production information is entered into the brewery’s enterprise software system, Ekos. This includes: creating new brands, creating and managing batches, recording all movement and usage of raw materials and finished product inventory, creating purchase orders, and sending invoices.
Work with the Accounting Department to ensure all information is entered correctly and continually develop and improve procedures.
Supervise month-end and year-end inventories of brewery raw materials and finished goods.
Pull reports from Ekos, and work with other Departments, to develop forecasts for planning and scheduling brews and procurement.
Required Experience/Qualifications:
Minimum of 3 years of extensive experience managing people in manufacturing and warehouse environments.
Minimum of 2 years direct, relevant experience in manufacturing and operations in the beer industry.
Extensive knowledge of all aspects of craft brewing, from grain to glass.
Ability to communicate effectively with customers, manufacturing partners, and colleagues.
Experience with Ekos software, or similar production management software.
Proficient knowledge of basic accounting principles.
Proficiency with modern office software, including Google Workspace (Drive, Docs, Sheets).
Excellent planning, organizational, problem-solving, and decision-making skills.
Strategic mindset, anticipating needs and issues which will arrive through growth and proactively offering ideas and solutions to position the company for success.
Physical Requirements:
Able to lift 55 lbs overhead.
Able to maneuver equipment in tight spaces.
Able to stack and maneuver 165 lb kegs.
Able to work on your feet for 8+ hours at a time.
Able to work in tight spaces where twisting, reaching, and climbing is required.
Compensation & Benefits:
Competitive pay rate for an experienced individual with the right skills, starting at $55,000-65,000/year
Medical and dental insurance.
Paid vacation and sick time.
401(k) plan.
Numerous job-related perks.
About Door County Brewing Co. and Hacienda Beer Co.:
Founded in 2012, Door County Brewing Co. has grown into a community establishment in Baileys Harbor. We focus on brewing clean, approachable beers for the Door County community—beers that pair perfectly with the activities that bring people to our beautiful peninsula along Lake Michigan. Each DCBC beer has a unique story connecting it to Door County, so even after you leave the county, we hope you can reminisce about and continue to enjoy a little piece of our home through DCBC beer. DCBC beer is distributed throughout most of Wisconsin and in select markets in Illinois.
Hacienda Beer Co. was launched in 2017 as an experimental side project to Door County Brewing Co. Hacienda focuses on creating modern, experimental beers—where our goal is to utilize creative brewing processes and ingredients to showcase bold and unique aromas and flavors in beer. Since its inception, Hacienda has made a name for itself for its highly flavorful and expressive beers, covering the full spectrum of beer styles—from subtle lagers and mixed-fermentation saisons to expressive IPAs to bold imperial stouts. Hacienda is distributed to select markets in Wisconsin, Illinois, and Minnesota.
We have two taprooms serving our beer—our Music Hall in Baileys Harbor and our North Ave. Taproom & Kitchen in Milwaukee. These taprooms provide us with a direct feedback loop with our loyal customer base and give us the opportunity to tell our story through beer.
Job Title:
Production Manager
Company:
Door County Brewing Company
Employment Type:
Full Time
Compensation/Salary:
$55,000.00 – $65,000.00 per Year
Industry Sectors:
Beer – Brewing/Brewery Jobs
Date Posted:
10/11/2022
Get notified by email whenever new jobs that match your criteria become available.
©2010-2022 BevNET.com®, Inc. (Legal terms)
Master Chief Dancing, 'Gettin Ass' With Megan Thee Stallion Is A Thing That Happened This Weekend – Kotaku
We’ve seen a bad news story coming out of TwitchCon, now let’s instead turn our attention towards something else.
As part of the con’s musical celebrations last night, Megan Thee Stallion played a set. And for whatever reason, it featured Master Chief—complete with accreditation lanyard, because this is TwitchCon, not the United Nations Space Command—living his best life on stage alongside her. At some points he was dancing in a way that I have seen best described as “gettin ass” (NSFW warning for some of the language in these vids):
That is not just dancing. John 117 is not up there side-shuffling in the background, gently bopping along to the beat on his own. Whoever is in that suit is amongst it.
Here’s another shot:
Best Prime Day Deal
Watch your content come to life in over 8 million pixels. Each pixel turns on and off independently so you'll see your content with perfect black, over a billion rich colors and infinite contrast for a viewing experience like no other.
And another:
And another, this one a bit longer and showing the crowd absolutely losing their minds:
UPDATE: Here’s the best look:
Twerking aficionados will note this is the second time this year that Megan Thee Stallion has danced with a large green person, after her appearance in the Marvel TV series She-Hulk. Fans of Shrek and Frankenstein’s Monster should now be on high alert.
It was announced last week that Megan Thee Stallion would be headlining TwitchCon’s concert at Petco Park, a show that also featured Kim Petras, Meet Me @ the Altar, DJ Lani Love and TIGERMOMTOY.
TwitchCon, back with big crowds for the first time since 2019, kicked off on Friday and runs until later this evening. Note when looking at this footage of large groups of humans huddled together (taking place off-site, with the main event taking place at the San Diego Convention Centre), that when the show was first announced its health and safety guidelines with relation to Covid were almost “non-existent.” Only after a fan backlash did Twitch implement a policy whereby “attendees will now be required to wear masks indoors,” and that “all attendees must provide proof of vaccination or a negative covid test taken within 72 hours of the event.”
Second 'Imran' audio leaks in a day, featuring another purported discussion on cipher – DAWN.com
PTI chairman Imran Khan, and former minister Shireen Mazari and Asad Umar. — File photo
Yet another alleged audio of former prime minister Imran Khan was leaked to social media on Friday, the latest in a series of recordings purportedly featuring the PTI chief talking about the cipher with PTI leaders Shireen Mazari and Asad Umar.
The audio — slightly longer than a minute — is the second that was released in a day featuring the PTI chairman. In a rally this afternoon, Imran claimed the PML-N was behind a “new game of fake audios”.
In the latest clip, the trio are discussing the cipher and allegedly strategising on how to “play it up in the public”.
At the start of the audio, the voice believed to be of Umar is heard saying: “Another point is in hindsight that whatever we are doing now should have been done at least ten days ago.”
“The impact of this letter is far-reaching and it has reached all over the world,” Imran allegedly responds.
Another voice, believed to be of Mazari interrupts, saying, “The Chinese even have issued an official statement condemning the US intervention in the internal affairs of Pakistan.”
Imran then allegedly details the strategy, saying “the public is with us and we must ensure that the pressure must be at such a height that whoever goes to the assembly for voting must be branded for life and you have to brand them as Mir Jafar and Mir Sadiq”.
The PTI chief then purportedly presses his party leaders to “spoon-feed people as their minds are currently fertile grounds”.
Mazari later said the clip has “cut-pasted bits” because she was midway through her sentence and “a different bit of conversation is pasted then the remainder of my sentence”.
“Not that there is anything incriminating in entire audio so let PML-N ‘journo’ mouthpieces get their thrills!” she added.
Earlier in the day, an audio recording leaked of a voice — sounding like Imran’s — discussing “buying five” and “numbers game”. “You have a misunderstanding that now the number game is complete […] don’t think this is over.”
“You see, 48 hours is a long, long time. Big things are happening. I am making my own moves that we can’t make public,” Imran purportedly says in the 54-second clip.
The PTI chief allegedly goes on to say that he “is buying five”.
“I have given the message that those five are very important. And tell them that if they secure these five […] and if he secures 10, then the game will be in our hands. The nation at this moment is alarmed. Across the board, people want us to win somehow.
“Hence, don’t worry about whether this is right or wrong […] even if they break one, it would create a huge difference,” the voice, believed to be Imran’s, adds.
The audio clips released on Friday raise the number of clips allegedly featuring the PTI chairman to four. Of the four clips, three centre on the cipher, and one on alleged horsetrading.
Last week, an audio clip purportedly revealed a conversation between Imran and then principal secretary Azam Khan about the cipher — shared by Asad Majeed, the then envoy to the US — which Imran has used to peddle his foreign conspiracy narrative.
In the clip, the former prime minister allegedly tells Azam to “play up” the cipher and turn it into a foreign plot to oust his government but adds that there is no need to name any country.
A day later, another clip surfaced — supposedly a continuation of the conversation in the previous recording — purportedly featuring PTI leaders Asad Umar and Shah Mahmood Qureshi discussing the “foreign conspiracy” cipher with the former premier and ex-principal secretary.
On Friday PTI leader Fawad Chaudhry did not disavow the contents of the latest audio clip but said that “everyone knows where and how the audios are being made”.
In a tweet, the former minister asked: “By joining voices such as these will you prove NRO 2 to be valid?”
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif later in the day said the “latest audio leak exposes the hypocrisy of Imran Niazi”. He added: “Someone who does not tire of lecturing nation on morality is himself blantantly involved in immoral horse trading. His fraudulent nature is being exposed every day. Niazi’s anti-state actions make him unfit for high office.”
Meanwhile, Information Minister Marriyum Aurangzeb has said the latest audio leaks were a “slap on face” of narrative of the PTI chief that he had been conveying to people in his rallies.
“He has been calling horse-trading shirk in his rallies but audio leaks have revealed that he was also involved in it,” the minister said in a press conference in Islamabad today.

She said Imran must be questioned about audio leaks and his acts that allegedly sabotaged national security.
“He played these games without weighing their pros and cons,” Aurangzeb said.
She said Imran “fooled” the masses, adding he must be questioned about it and the nation must now recognise “his plan”.
Meanwhile, PML-N Vice President Maryam Nawaz reacted to the latest audio leak, saying the “double face of this man must be exposed before the public”, adding that the PTI chief had no moral courage to apologise to his people.
Maryam also read out a transcript of the latest leak, saying he had no courage to name anyone as he allegedly asked his party members to “spoon feed people with reference to Mir Jafer and Mir Sadiq”.
“His thoughts in the leaked audio imply that he is asking for a deal to return to power again and if denied, he is threatening to take a belligerent approach,” she added.
What began as an alleged and potentially embarrassing audio leak seems to have turned into an all-out national security incident as a slew of audio recordings of conversations between key government figures — including Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, PML-N leader Maryam Nawaz and some members of the federal cabinet — were released last month.
The content of the recordings appear to be informal conversations in the PM Office — as opposed to recorded phone conversations.
First, a recording of PM Shehbaz surfaced where he was discussing with an unidentified official the possibility of facilitating the import of Indian machinery for a power project that was a concern of Maryam Nawaz Sharif’s son-in-law, Raheel.
Further recordings surfaced a day later, which were shared on social media by several PTI leaders, concerning former finance minister Miftah Ismail and the resignations of PTI lawmakers from the National Assembly.
One clip purportedly features a conversation between PML-N Vice President Maryam and the premier about Miftah, wherein a voice thought to belong to the former says he “doesn’t know what he is doing” and wishes for the return of PML-N stalwart Ishaq Dar.
A second clip allegedly concerns a conversation between the prime minister, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif, Law Minister Azam Nazeer Tarar, Interior Minister Rana Sanaullah and Ayaz Sadiq about the resignations of PTI lawmakers from the National Assembly.
A third clip purportedly features a conversation between Maryam Nawaz and PM Shehbaz regarding the return of former army chief retired Gen Pervez Musharraf.
PM Shehbaz has termed the surfacing of audio leaks a “very serious lapse” and announced that a high-level committee would be constituted to probe the matter.
At the same time, the premier has also said that Imran’s audio leaks were “an irrefutable endorsement” that the PTI chief was the “biggest liar on the face of the earth”.
Compunode.com Pvt. Ltd. (www.compunode.com).Designed for Dawn.
Copyright © 2022, Dawn
Scribe Publishing Platform