Blog

Trump asks supreme court to intervene in Mar-a-Lago special master dispute – The Guardian US

Appellate court ruling prevented special master from examining 100 files seized from Mar-a-Lago with classification markings
Donald Trump on Tuesday asked the US supreme court to partially reverse an appellate court decision that prevented the special master, reviewing for privilege protections materials seized by the FBI from his Mar-a-Lago resort in August, from examining 100 documents with classification markings.
The motion to vacate the ruling by the US appeals court for the 11th circuit represents the former president’s final chance to reinsert the 100 documents into the special master review – and potentially exclude some from the investigation into whether he illegally retained national defense information
In the emergency request, Trump’s lawyers argued that the appellate court lacked jurisdiction to overrule the trial judge and decide that the justice department should regain access to the 100 documents and that the special master should be prohibited from examining them in the review.
The technical motion contended that although the 11th circuit was not wrong to allow the justice department to regain access to the 100 documents for its criminal investigation, it lacked jurisdiction to curtail the special master process.
The motion hinged on the doctrine of “pendent appellate jurisdiction”, which generally disfavors appeals for non-final, or interlocutory, decisions: it should not have intervened in the scope of the special master review since the trial judge’s order was procedural and not an injunction.
“That appointment order is simply not appealable on an interlocutory basis,” the filing said. “Nevertheless, the 11th circuit granted a stay of the special master order, effectively compromising the integrity of the well-established policy against piecemeal appellate review.”
In that sense, Trump’s motion was narrow, seeking only to have the special master be able review the 100 documents for potential privilege protections while leaving alone the 11th circuit decision to allow the justice department to use the materials for the criminal investigation.
Trump will face significant challenges even if the supreme court hears the case, even though the bench is dominated by six conservative justices – three of whom he appointed – who have previously shown deference to executive branch powers.
Just to meet the procedural criteria to vacate a lower court stay, legal experts said, Trump would have to show the supreme court that it needs to intervene because he is suffering irreparable harm – which his lawyers did not appear to address directly in the 37-page filing.
Lawyers for Trump also contended that the seized materials could be marked classified for national security purposes and simultaneously be personal documents – a position the justice department has previously said is impossible, with which the 11th circuit indicated it agreed.
The Trump motion was silent on whether Trump actually declassified any of the documents, as he has claimed publicly. It instead suggested the supreme court consider the case on the basis that Trump had the power to do so, and might have done so, without providing evidence.
The filing came two days into the new supreme court session, and after the justice department asked the 11th circuit to fast-track its own appeal against the appointment of a special master, arguing that the process was impeding the criminal investigation.
The justice department, aiming to capitalize on the decision Trump has now appealed, contended the special master should never have been appointed because the US district court judge, Aileen Cannon, misapplied a four-part test that allowed her to exercise jurisdiction.
In the ruling that stopped the 100 documents from being reviewed by the special master, the 11th circuit agreed with the justice department that Cannon was wrong on the first “Richey” test, regarding whether the government displayed “callous disregard” for Trump’s constitutional rights in seizing materials.
Cannon determined that Trump did not suffer callous disregard, and instead based her decision to grant a special master on the other tests. But the 11th circuit said Trump’s failure to satisfy the first callous-disregard standard alone was sufficient to dismiss his request.
“The absence of this ‘indispensa[ble]’ factor in the Richey analysis is reason enough to conclude that the district court abused its discretion in exercising equitable jurisdiction here,” ruled the three-judge panel on the 11th circuit that included two Trump appointees.
Though the appellate court was only narrowly deciding the question of whether the special master should examine the 100 documents in the review and whether the justice department could regain access to them, the government argued the reasoning suggested there should be no special master.

source

Testimony reveals disturbing details surrounding Cupcake McKinney's death – WLBT

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (WBRC) – A jury was seated Monday in the first trial involving the death and disappearance of Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney. Patrick Stallworth will stand trial on two federal kidnapping charges. He also faces a state capital murder count.
Follow our coverage of the trial from start to finish in this story.
Day 3: Wednesday, October 5, 2022 – final update:
Some of the information in this update may be difficult to read or inappropriate for some audiences.
Wednesday was an emotionally challenging afternoon in court. The government called FBI Special Agent Stanley Ruffin, who recovered 3-year-old Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney’s body.
Ruffin was part of a large team assigned to search a landfill where trash was dumped from local apartments.
“Did you know it was a body right away?” asked Assistant United States Attorney and Criminal Chief Lloyd Peeples.
“I saw what I thought was a doll lying there,” Ruffin described. “For a moment everything slowed down, I closed my eyes and tried to make sure what I saw was real.”
Ruffin had trouble speaking as he recalled Cupcake’s body being put in a bag to be transported for an autopsy. At this point, she’d been missing for 10 days.
Due to the nature of the case and the burden of proof the government must meet, they had to show the jury very sensitive images of Cupcake in the landfill. Quickly, several jurors became emotional, wiping away tears. The court quickly timed the shots, holding them for no more than three seconds each, warning the jury in advance of a new picture so they were prepared.
As a seasoned 26-year veteran agent, Ruffin admitted he’d seen a lot of things, however, everyone involved in this recovery had to go through counseling.
“I was involved in 9/11 and thought it would be the worst thing I had experienced, but I had never experienced something like that with a child,” he stated.
Ruffin retired shortly after this assignment in Birmingham.
Dr. Daniel Dye, M.D., the forensic pathologist who performed Cupcake’s autopsy, testified next.
Dye explained the decomposition in this case posed a challenge to his work. He confirmed Cupcake had a contusion on her head, pointing toward the hairline area, with swelling on the side of the face that could be associated with blunt force trauma.
Dye ruled the cause of death in this case asphyxia, or suffocation, and agreed that injury could be associated with the head being pressed down against a hard object. This is consistent with a recorded statement Stallworth made to police, explaining his girlfriend Derick Brown killed Cupcake by putting her hand over the child’s nose and mouth until she couldn’t breathe.
The toxicology report also found methamphetamine and Trazadone in the child’s system, stating this also played a role in Cupcake’s death.
The government called Birmingham Police Sergeant Talana Brown, who was also involved in interviewing both Stallworth and Brown in the initial phases of the investigation.
The prosecution started by playing an interview with Stallworth’s co-defendant Derick Brown. In the interview, Brown insinuates Stallworth dumped Cupcake’s body in a dumpster. Talana Brown testified she passed along that tip FBI.
During cross-examination, Talana Brown testified that Derick Brown lied to police early in the investigation. The defense worked to shift the focus away from earlier testimony, which questioned whether Stallworth was forthcoming with authorities.
Defense attorney Derrick Collins showed the jury a video recording of one of Derick Brown’s interviews with police.
“I’ll lie on him if y’all want me to,” Brown told police, referencing Stallworth. “I’m not going to jail for anybody… what do y’all want me to say?”
FBI Cellular Analyst Blake Downing was called as the last witness of the day. Downing was tasked with tracking Stallworth’s cell phone during the investigation. He testified about the technology used to determine Stallworth’s location through the phone signal.
The government and the defense are expected to rest on Thursday. The jury could begin deliberations Friday morning.
Day 3: Wednesday, October 5, 2022 – 12 p.m. update:
Some of the information in this update may be difficult to read or inappropriate for some audiences.
On Wednesday morning, prosecutors began to peel back the layers of the investigation into Kamille “Cupcake” McKinney’s disappearance and death, and how Patrick Stallworth and Derick Brown were developed as suspects in the case.
The first witness of the day: Birmingham Police Detective Jonathan Ross, who oversaw the investigation and massive search effort.
The prosecution spent more than an hour playing video and audio recordings from Stallworth’s interviews with police.
The jury first saw a portion of Stallworth’s initial recorded interview with police on Oct. 13, 2019. During that meeting, Stallworth said he was at Tom Brown Village, which correlated with the same day and time of Cupcake’s disappearance. Stallworth stated he walked around the area and saw children playing with a mouse, consistent with the video the jury saw on Tuesday, which showed a man approaching two toddlers at Tom Brown Village.
The second recording took jurors back to the interview room at BPD the day Cupcake’s body was recovered. Stallworth requested to speak to Ross.
Jurors attentively read the transcript off the screen as the lengthy audio recording played from that interview. During this meeting, Stallworth told police Brown brought a baby home and killed her.
Stallworth told officers he woke up and saw a baby on the couch next to Brown and didn’t know how the child made it to his house.
“I told her you need to go, you need to get this baby out of here,” Stallworth told police. “I said, this ain’t your baby.”
Stallworth said he went back to sleep and when he woke up the baby was gone.
“I asked her where it was, and she said she took it back,” Stallworth stated. “She kept trying to talk about the baby and how she wanted to keep the baby.”
He revealed to police that Brown wanted him to “do some things to the child,” referencing inappropriately touching the toddler.
An investigator asked Stallworth whether forensic examiners would find his DNA during Cupcake’s autopsy.
“She killed her,” sobbed Stallworth. “I tried to keep her from choking that baby.”
Police asked them to show how she choked the baby and he held up his hand over his nose and mouth, according to the recording.
Assistant United States Attorney Blake Milner paused the recording asked Ross clarify the general crux of their conversation.
“He watched Derick Brown put his hands over her nose and mouth and kill Cupcake, and then took out the trash?” Milner questioned.
Ross responded, “That’s correct.”
Defense attorney Derrick Collins cross-examined Ross, asking the detective to confirm the statements Stallworth made to police that were true. Ross agreed Stallworth told the truth about being in Tom Brown Village and stopping at various service stations.
The court recessed at noon, testimony will resume at 1 p.m.
While the witnesses haven’t moved as quickly as expected, the government still believes it will rest Thursday.
Day 2: Tuesday, October 4, 2022 – final update:
Prosecutors spent the remainder of the day two calling witnesses and introducing evidence that would put Patrick Stallworth at Tom Brown Village around the time Cupcake went missing.
The government used surveillance video to reconstruct a timeline of Stallworth’s day which started around noon. An initial video shows Stallworth purchasing candy at a service station, other video later that afternoon showed what appears to be the Toyota Sequoia registered to Stallworth’s co-defendant Derick Brown stop and speak to some girls walking near Hayes K-8 school.
A 14-year-old girl who attended athletic practice at Hayes testified that she and her friend were stopped by a man and woman in the Toyota as they walked home. Her testimony revealed the man, who’s suspected to be Stallworth, asked her if she’d seen someone they were looking for, then asked her if she wanted any candy. The teen said that’s when her friend spoke up.
“She told me to run,” the student said. “We ran down the alley in the projects.”
When asked if she could pick that man out in the courtroom, there was strong hesitation. Stallworth looks noticeably different from his mugshot taken in 2019.
A grainy piece of video from a neighbor’s surveillance camera showed a man approach two toddler-aged children playing in a field. The FBI Agent Jonathan Spaeth testified the time of the video correlates with the timeframe Cupcake was reported missing.
Defense attorney Derrick Collins cross-examined the Spaeth asking whether he could prove that was Stallworth on the video.
“It’s consistent with a person like Stallworth,” Spaeth replied.
Collins pressed Spaeth, questioning whether he could prove that was Cupcake.
“This was right near Cupcake’s house [where she was that night], this toddler is wearing shorts, I know she was wearing shorts.” Other evidence, including statements Stallworth made to police pointed to him being at Tom Brown Village that evening. According to video from one of his interviews with Birmingham Police, he and Brown were in Tom Brown Village searching for the father of Brown’s children.
The final video showed the Toyota Sequoia pull up to another service station after the time Cupcake was reported missing. Brown is seen exiting the passenger door and walking inside the business, which is consistent with testimony that Stallworth was driving that night.
FBI Agent Kyle King testified that he was part of the group that served a search warrant at Stallworth’s apartment on October 18, 2019, days after the disappearance. At this time, search efforts to locate Cupcake were still underway. The prosecution filed through pictures of the apartment as the FBI found it, showing a picture of a mattress with a plastic cover with a noticeable a red stain. The cover appeared to be consistent with the plastic material that often covers new mattresses.
Today the jury was able to see that plastic cover in person. Two FBI agents opened the evidence packaging and unfolded it in front of the jury. During opening statements, the prosecution said an expert witness would testify that both defendants DNA and Cupcake’s DNA were found on a plastic mattress cover inside Stallworth’s apartment.
The government called nearly a dozen witnesses Tuesday. They’re expected to have at least one more day full day of testimony before resting their case. The trial resumes Wednesday morning.
Day 2: Tuesday, October 4, 2022 – 12 p.m. update:
The government took jurors to the home where Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney was kidnapped to begin day two of the trial.
Shenita Long lived in Tom Brown Village in Avondale where McKinney and her family visited on Oct. 12, 2019.
Long testified McKinney and her daughter Ava were best friends. When McKinney and her family arrived, Long said Ava and McKinney ran to play at a birthday party outside her apartment.
When it was time for McKinney and her family to leave, Long said McKinney’s older brother ran inside and said he couldn’t find her.
Long said her daughter looked startled.
“I asked Ava – where was Cupcake,” Long testified. “She said ‘Cupcake got in the car with that man, he took her to get candy at the store.’”
The defense worked to keep this testimony off the record, arguing the validity of a statement made by a child, which was overruled.
Long recounted everyone feverishly began searching for McKinney, going door to door while others searched local service stations.
“People started searching and we found her shoes in the backyard, that’s when we knew she was really missing,” Long recalled.
Less than an hour later, Long called 911 to report McKinney’s disappearance.
Body camera video from the responding officer showed Long, McKinney’s mother, April Thomas, and several children outside searching for McKinney. The children gave the officer a vehicle description: a blue Toyota with a brown bumper. Evidence showed the vehicle registered to Derick Brown, Stallworth’s girlfriend and co-defendant, was a blue Toyota Sequoia with gold trim.
The government also called the FBI Case Agent Eric Salvador, who recounted the initial days of the investigation and how the agency developed its case.
Assistant United States Attorney Lloyd Peeples used Salvador’s testimony to introduce various surveillance videos he collected during the investigation. The videos reconstructed Stallworth and Brown’s movements throughout the day McKinney was kidnapped. One of the videos shows Stallworth purchasing candy around noon at a service station, which parallels to testimony McKinney was lured away with candy. Another video showed the defendants stopping at a service station in the blue Toyota SUV later that day. Brown was seen exiting the passenger door and walked inside the store. The court recessed for lunch after noon; testimony will resume after 1 p.m.
Day 1: Monday, October 3, 2022 – 8 p.m. update:
A sixteen person jury was seated in Patrick Stallworth’s federal kidnapping trial Monday. It took attorneys roughly five hours to strike a jury in the high-profile case. The jury composition: thirteen women and three men. Stallworth elected not to move the trial to a different division which would pull jurors from outside Jefferson County.
Attorneys spent only an hour with the jury late Monday outlining what they can expect to see during the trial.
During opening statements, Assistant United States Attorney Lloyd Peeples, Criminal Division Chief, promised jurors the government would present evidence that linked Stallworth with McKinney’s disappearance and death.
“I will warn you that some of this evidence will not be easy to see or hear, but in order to bring justice we are going to ask that you do exactly that,” Peeples explained.
The evidence previewed by the government included phone records, DNA evidence from Stallworth’s apartment, DNA evidence from McKinney’s autopsy and recordings from Stallworth’s five meetings with law enforcement.
Peeples alleged Stallworth’s statements to law enforcement shifted over the course of the investigation.
“Shortly after Kamille’s body was recovered, the defendant admits to knowing things that only Cupcake’s kidnapper would know,” stated Peeples.
Peeples pointed to new evidence, a text message Stallworth sent from the Jefferson County Jail.
“A text message sent ten days after Kamille’s body was found, a message that said, “I’m sorry I did this. It was an accident, that poor baby’s family”,” Peeples quoted to the jury.
Defense Attorney Derrick Collins quickly told the jury there’s only one fact established in this case right.
“The only fact is that Mr. Stallworth is an innocent man,” Collins explained to the jury.
Collins said Stallworth wasn’t involved in the crime and went as far to say the government doesn’t have the evidence to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.
“I can tell you who did it,” Collins said of McKinney’s kidnapping. “She’s the author behind all of this – Derick Brown.”
Brown is Stallworth’s co-defendant and girlfriend. Collins shifted the blame to Brown, stating she couldn’t handle losing custody of her children, which prompted McKinney’s kidnapping.
“Evidence will show my client didn’t know [Brown] kidnapped Cupcake,” Collins told the jury.
The government called McKinney’s mother, April Thomas, as their first witness.
Thomas described October 12, 2019 to the jury; the day of McKinney’s disappearance and the last time she saw her daughter alive. Thomas and her children were visiting a family member’s house in Tom Brown Village where Cupcake often played with her cousins. As the sun began to set, Thomas asked her son to go tell Cupcake it’s time to go home.
“He was panicked, he came in and said he couldn’t find her,” Thomas recalled. “I looked and couldn’t find her – all I found were her shoes. I was sick to my stomach.”
Thomas was the first and final witness of the day. The government expects to call upwards of twenty witnesses over the course of the trial. Testimony resumes Tuesday morning.
“All that was left behind were here shoes, for her mother to find… Her body was found mixed in with trash, discarded, and left for more then ten days.” – Prosecutor Lloyd Peeples

Prosecutors say Meth Amphetamine was found in Cupcake’s body
—
Day 1: Monday, October 3, 2022 – 8 a.m. preview:
One of the defendants accused in the disappearance and death of three-year old Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney will stand trial this week on federal kidnapping counts.
Prosecutors allege Patrick Stallworth and Derick Brown used candy to lure McKinney away from a birthday party in Tom Brown Village in October 2019. Following an extensive city-wide search, McKinney’s body was recovered in a dumpster a week later. Forensic evidence indicated McKinney likely fought for her life; testimony revealed Stallworth’s DNA was found under McKinney’s fingernails. During a state court hearing, investigators also testified DNA evidence from McKinney, Stallworth and Brown was found on a plastic bed cover in the couple’s apartment. Both face federal kidnapping charges and capital murder.
A jury is expected to be seated in Stallworth’s federal kidnapping trial on Monday October 3. In previous hearings, Chief Judge Scott Coogler anticipated opening statements would begin Monday afternoon with jury deliberations slated for later in the week. It’s unclear how many witnesses will be called. Stallworth elected not to move the trial to Tuscaloosa, which summons potential jurors from Tuscaloosa and Walker Counties. The Department of Justice elected not to seek the death penalty in this case.
Leading up to trial, both Stallworth and Brown’s defense argued to suppress statements they independently made to police in the initial phases of the investigation. Stallworth’s motion was denied, a ruling hasn’t been entered in Brown’s case. Brown’s kidnapping trial is scheduled for November in Tuscaloosa, Brown’s change of venue request was granted earlier this year. After the federal cases are adjudicated, both are scheduled to stand trial on state capital murder counts. If found guilty, they could face the death penalty.
Get news alerts in the Apple App Store and Google Play Store or subscribe to our email newsletter here.
Copyright 2022 WBRC. All rights reserved.

source

Collaboration is key for Highnote and Beatmaker launches – Music Ally





The digital marketing guide: expert insight, case studies, fresh approaches, and overlooked opportunities.
The latest and best jobs in the global music industry
Brief, deep analysis of essential music business stuff: every week, in about 20 mins.
Essential international guides, packed with data, interviews, strategies, and local insight.
Twice-monthly reports on the newest platforms – to help you find a competitive edge.
Music Ally Ltd., Holborn Studios,
49-50 Eagle Wharf Rd, London, N1 7ED,
United Kingdom
Music Ally is a Registered Learning Provider 10029483

source

Security forces audio recordings allowed as evidence in trial involving Colin Duffy – The Irish News

Recordings from covert listening devices have been allowed as evidence in a long-running terror trial in Belfast.
However a portion of voice recognition evidence which attributes the recordings to three suspects has been excluded in the trial, which has been running for almost a decade.
Colin Duffy, of Forest Glade in Lurgan, Henry Fitzsimons of Dunmore Mews, Belfast, and Alex McCrory of Sliabh Dubh View in Belfast, are charged with directing terrorism and membership of an illegal organisation, namely the IRA.
Fitzsimons and McCrory are also charged with attempting to murder police officers in a gun attack on the Crumlin Road in north Belfast on December 5, 2013, and with possessing two firearms and ammunition used in the attack.
They have denied the charges.
The trio were granted bail in 2016 after spending more than two years on remand.
 
 
The key evidence being used by the prosecution is a quantity of audio which was recorded by the security forces from listening devices planted at various points in Demesne Park in Lurgan, Co Armagh.
The devices picked up a conversation which the prosecution contends was an incriminating discussion between the three defendants.
The prosecution argues the recordings show Fitzsimons and McCrory were “intimately involved” in the Crumlin Road gun attack and that they knew of it, approved it and, in effect, signed off on it before it took place.
 
 
However, the authenticity of this audio, voice recognition evidence and CCTV evidence has been challenged during the case, which is being heard in a Diplock non-jury trial.
Today, Mr Justice O’Hara gave his ruling on a voir dire application brought by the defence.
He said the vast majority of evidence in the case has been called, and it is his task to rule whether any evidence should be excluded on the basis of fairness.
Mr Justice O’Hara said scrutiny has “revealed inconsistencies in the prosecution evidence”.
He went on to say he has “misgivings about the way in which the prosecution evidence was given”, particularly by a number of security forces witnesses, who he said “appeared to have been trained to be vague and unforthcoming in certain respects”.
“But having said that, in light of all of the evidence, the authenticity of the recordings cannot reasonably or sensibly be doubted,” he said, pointing to expert evidence that manipulation of the recordings “would be unachievable”.
Mr Justice O’Hara also ruled that evidence attributing voice recordings to the three suspects is not admissible, but allowed CCTV evidence.
Another hearing is to be held before October 14 to review the future running of the case.
Get the day’s headlines delivered directly to your inbox

source

Features | A Quietus Interview | The Goyt Method: An Interview With The Orielles – The Quietus

As they prepare to release their ambitious third album Tableau, The Orielles speak to Fergal Kinney about how Greater Manchester’s underground culture, putting faith in a first-time producer, and cooking each other’s tea inspired a major creative leap forward
Photos by Neelam Vela
The Goyt Valley is a blustery, tree-lined moorland around the river Goyt, located just outside Buxton on the border between Cheshire and Derbyshire. Textile mills, long emptied, give way to the wide-open valley which is reputed to be haunted by the ghost of a woman whose husband drowned in the river. She passes out the centuries wailing for her lover’s unlikely return. The Goyt Valley also lends its name to what The Orielles term The Goyt Method. The process would unlock and become central to the creation of Tableau, the band’s third album and first double record.
“We were at a studio in Goyt Mill,” remembers drummer Sidonie Hand-Halford, sat outside an East London pub. “We were doing some remixing, and we realised that having all of these stems, it was like having access to all of these paints. A huge colour palette. You could do that with anything, we realised, and the outcome could be millions of variations.” What, they wondered, if they were to apply that process not just to a remix but to their own work? In-between albums at the time, the band knew that this lightbulb moment would dictate where things would go next.
“We discovered how many avenues were open to us,” agrees vocalist Esmé Hand-Halford, “by taking an acoustic sound, and throwing it through a load of electronic plugins, and really effective randomisation methods, we could make it sound really different to the original source.” The album became governed by the band’s internal shorthand – to Goyt it.
The Orielles formed in the West Yorkshire market town of Halifax over a decade ago when they were in their teens, and gained a foothold as part of the indie and DIY scene around Manchester and Salford, where the band all live today. In 2017, they signed to Heavenly Recordings. Their second single for the label, the slippery nine-minute prog track ‘Sugar Tastes Like Salt’, would be early evidence of a band with far more exploratory impulses than they may have been given credit (the track was also subject to a terrific, dubbed out remix by Andrew Weatherall.) Where 2018’s Silver Dollar Moment was an assured debut of lo-fi indie pop, 2020’s superior Disco Volador would convincingly fuse the spectral pop of Stereolab and Broadcast with the tight avant-funk of A Certain Ratio (whose Jez Kerr was an important early mentor to the group.) When lockdown hit, the band even directed and scored their own art film, La Vita Olistica. None of this, though, would particularly anticipate the sounds heard across Tableau. Though seldom in thrall to influences or especially referential, the double album at points evokes Burial, Sonic Youth, FKA Twigs, Yo La Tengo, free jazz and the last two Radiohead records.
What happened? “In the past,” explains Esmé, “we’d resigned ourselves to the idea that it wasn’t possible to make something that sounds like it’s from the present or the future.” All in their early to mid twenties, for the first time the band found themselves all listening to far more contemporary music than sounds from the past. “Revisiting our processes means that what we were discussing was exactly the present and the future, we found our own view of what stuff should sound like now.”
The vibrant new music culture around Greater Manchester helped too. “All Night Flights in Stockport is such a well curated shop,” enthuses Sidonie, “also, things like going to White Hotel nights together, enjoying the music so much that the following day, you’re seeking out what they’re playing and chatting about it, all very nerdy.”
“It was how we were listening to music too,” says Henry Carlyle-Wade, the band’s guitarist. The oblique, downer sounds that have so far typified electronic music in the early 21st century became part of The Orielles’ language. “A lot of modern stuff is dark and introspective. It came from electronic DJs, people who do all of their work in the computer, we’re very interested in what they can do.”
The band knew that their new methodology could create something that, for the first time in their careers, would look the present moment firmly in the eye. How to get there? First, record as much as possible in adherence to The Goyt Method. Second, there would be no demoing of material (two album cycles had led the band to be suspicious of albums that ended up as “posh demos”). Third, the band would self-produce in collaboration with friend and relatively unknown North West producer Joel Anthony Patchett (who engineered on the first two Orielles records.) “Because we’ve got our communications and angle, he’s one of the only people that’s musically connecting with us,” explains Esmé. Though the record is Patchett’s first production credit, the band speak of him as an equal collaborator on the record and central to its scope and ambition.

“Imagine trying to achieve what we did with someone who we met for the first time on the first day in the studio?” says Henry, shaking his head, “it would be nearly impossible. We didn’t want someone who would think we were pissing around for hours. How can you explore the possibilities if someone thinks they know better? We don’t know, and that’s the best part of it.”
Esmé points to The Beatles’ Get Back as an example of good studio practices. “It wasn’t a reference point while we were writing, but they write it all on the spot together. That’s really what music should be. It isn’t making demos for a record label, who then throw a few grand at it. The time spent in the studio should be the time spent experimenting.”
“We decided not to overwrite anything either,” furthers Henry, “not really any structural things, and just see what would happen when we played these songs as they were being recorded. Because we had unfinished songs it forced us into a corner of being completely creative. We felt free. Maybe other people might have felt pressure but that wasn’t the case for us.”
Having convinced their record label, the band and Patchett devised two residential studio stays in Eastbourne and the Midlands town of Alcester. The decision to work in a residential stay was as much culinary as it was sonic. “Cooking together helps break down the barriers,” enthuses Esmé. “Showing people new ideas musically is easier if you’re also cooking them a breakfast or if they’re going to cook you a tea. On a rookie level, if you’ve got the same things in your gut, the outcome is going to be more in sync.” It also afforded the band the opportunity to work at their own schedule. “You get the ick sometimes if you work for too long,” explains Henry, “and we got the ick. From a sonic and spiritual perspective, too, we needed the high ceilings. It puts us in a better place to be able to explore that emotional palette.”
For the band, the high point of the sessions was Patchett bringing in the Northern Session Collective, the innovative string section led by Lancashire violinist Isabella Baker. In line with the album’s rigid commitment to chance, the band did not want to hear the scores that Patchett had written until the recording itself.
“We’d just planned to have strings on these four or five songs,” explains Sidonie, “but at the last minute we had an hour or so left. We had the song ‘Improvisation 001’, in which we all improvise, and it was a one take thing for us. We asked them to do the same, just improvise. We said we weren’t going to judge, just listen to it and react. And they did.”
Improvisation and chance would become central to Tableau, and The Orielles cultivated processes beyond simply jamming. They embraced automatic lyric writing, use of Brian Eno and Peter Schmidt’s Oblique Strategies cards, and Sidonie developing an interest in US jazz trumpeter Wadada Leo Smith’s concept of graphic scoring of music – the abstract, conceptual notation method that utilises the interplay of shapes and colour.
“I like the element of randomness, working within the bounds of what you’re given,” explains Henry, “we came to remix the album recently, and we had all these stems, all the songs, all these endless, endless possibilities. We put everything into online Wheel Of Fortune style spinners, so it was completely random, and the machine decided we’d take a drum track from here, a synth track from there.”
“It harkens back to early ideas of cybernetics in the 1960s, that computer technology could decide the elements,” ,” says Sidonie, “Look at the DALL-E AI art simulator. Just handing it to a robot to decide how we use it.”
For The Orielles, part of what has enabled them to develop their current work is what happens if you don’t become a hype band. “We discuss trends a lot, between the three of us, whether it’s fashion or film or music,” explains Henry, “British music moves so fast, these cycles and trends and trying to predict the future. It means you can see stuff for what it is, which is a trend no more than Crocs being back in right now. If you can identify substance, then you can reject everything that you just see through.” The three-piece would discuss their favourite acts – Sonic Youth, The Pastels, Yo La Tengo – and observe how those acts had found longevity.

Esmé introduced the group to the concept of the Lindy Effect, the idea that the longer a non-perishable item or idea has been around, the longer it’s likely to persist into the future. Introduced in a 1964 New Republican article by the writer Albert Goldman, the concept initially referred to Lindy’s Delicatessen on Broadway, where comedians would gather and talk shop, and the concept developed when discussing the impermanence of comedians who would oversaturate themselves early on in their career. Mathematicians like Nassim Taleb and Benoit Mandelbrot would take the idea from an anecdotal one to a mathematical formulation.
“There’s certain Lindy approaches to music,” Esmé argues, “it’s rejecting the idea of being a hype band. It might be really enjoyable for a year, but what about its lifespan?” It helped, too, that the band were at a formative age when they encountered the fevered egos of the hype artist in clubs and festival backstage areas across the UK. “You speak to those bands now, without naming any names,” says Sidonie, “and there’s something not even creative about them, they hate it now.”
For the future, the band are simply looking forward to taking Tableau out to two live shows – at Manchester’s Stoller Hall and Hackney’s EartH – where they will perform the record in full with the Northern Session Collective. When I speak to the band, they are in the thick of rehearsals for these shows. “You fall back in love with certain songs and out of love with others, the cycle does keep changing,” explains Esmé, “and then going forward next year, we’ve got certain songs that we’ve not played out as much and we’re definitely going to focus on, other ones will be put back for a bit. We’re constantly reinventing how our live sound is.”
“We’ve always loved the live sound being a completely different entity to the album anyway,” says Sidonie, “who is to say we can’t Goyt the whole thing for a live set?”
The Orielles’ Tableau is released on October 7 via Heavenly Recordings
Share this article: Post to Facebook Post to Twitter add to del.icio.us Digg it Stumble It! Post to Reddit
If you love what we do, you can help tQ to continue bringing you the best in cultural criticism and new music by joining one of our subscription tiers. As well as the unparalleled joy of keeping the publication alive, you’ll receive benefits including exclusive editorial, podcasts, and specially-commissioned music by some of our favourite artists. To find out more, click here.
Support tQ’s work by becoming a subscriber and enjoy the benefits of bonus essays, podcasts and exclusively-commissioned new music. To find out more, click here.
As a wholly independent publication, we rely entirely on our ad bookings to keep The Quietus going. Please whitelist our site in order to continue to access The Quietus.

source

Intraspecies characterization of bacteria via evolutionary modeling of protein domains | Scientific Reports – Nature.com

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 16595 (2022)
Metrics details
The ability to detect and characterize bacteria within a biological sample is crucial for the monitoring of infections and epidemics, as well as for the study of human health and its relationship with commensal microorganisms. To this aim, a commonly used technique is the 16S rRNA gene targeted sequencing. PCR-amplified 16S sequences derived from the sample of interest are usually clustered into the so-called Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) based on pairwise similarities. Then, representative OTU sequences are compared with reference (human-made) databases to derive their phylogeny and taxonomic classification. Here, we propose a new reference-free approach to define the phylogenetic distance between bacteria based on protein domains, which are the evolving units of proteins. We extract the protein domain profiles of 3368 bacterial genomes and we use an ecological approach to model their Relative Species Abundance distribution. Based on the model parameters, we then derive a new measurement of phylogenetic distance. Finally, we show that such model-based distance is capable of detecting differences between bacteria in cases in which the 16S rRNA-based method fails, providing a possibly complementary approach , which is particularly promising for the analysis of bacterial populations measured by shotgun sequencing.
The accurate identification and classification of bacteria is essential for epidemiological surveillance, as well as for the study and understanding of specific ecosystems such as the human microbiome. Bacterial classification, however, is a complex problem, especially at the intraspecies level. Commonly used methods include the reconstruction of phylogenetic trees based on the comparison of specific molecular sequences (e.g. 16S rRNA gene) with reference databases, which contain annotated sequences of previously classified bacteria . This allows to generate the so-called taxonomic classification of the sampled bacteria.
The basic unit of classification in taxonomy is usually the species level. While such resolution may be sufficient for other domains of life, the intraspecies level of bacteria includes high amounts of genomic and phenot ypic variation, through which strains of bacteria belonging to the same species manifest highly different behaviours1. For instance, different strains can infect different hosts2,3,4, or even more extremely, some bacterial species can have both pathogenic and non-pathogenic isolates1,5. The 16S rRNA gene is commonly used for bacterial classification since random mutations of the 16S rRNA gene sequence serve as a proxy of evolutionary time6. However, bacterial classification based on 16S rRNA gene has low phylogenetic power at the intraspecies level, where functional diversification of strains is faster than random mutations of the 16S rRNA gene6. Various alternative approaches to estimate the bacterial phylogeny have hence been proposed7,8,9. Such methods mainly start from specific bacterial molecular sequences and either compute a distance matrix or model the substitution process through which the molecular sequences have evolved. In both cases, the appropriate choice of the specific molecular sequences to be investigated is crucial. The chosen sequences have to satisfy two conditions for the phylogenetic reconstruction to be successful: orthologs of sequences have to be shared by the tested bacteria and they have to contain a vertical phylogenetic signal. Approaches that use a single molecular sequence, such as 16S rRNA, may work well at higher taxonomic levels, but they are usually too generic to differentiate species or strains. A popular method which overcomes this problem while still controlling the phylogenetic noise is multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA)10,11, which simultaneously uses sequences of seven housekeeping genes. However, phylogenetic signals are not equally distributed across the genome and, while some classes of genes are expected to perform better for phylogenetic inference than others12, the choice of the specific set of genes to be used is still a matter of debate.
Here, we develop a new measurement of evolutionary distance derived from the ecological modeling of the protein domains that populate the bacterial genome and we propose to exploit such distance to deepen the characterization of bacteria at the intraspecies level. Our method does not rely on the selection of a specific set of genes or molecular sequences, but is based on the ecological modelling of the whole set of protein domains within the bacterial genome. Protein domains are segments of proteins and are defined as substructures produced by any contiguous part of a polypeptide chain that can fold independently of the rest of the protein into a compact and stable structure13,14. Studies on the conformation, function and evolution of proteins suggest to consider the protein as a molecule composed of a set of independent protein domains, which constitute its organizational units, so as its evolutionary components. The evolution of living organisms, or rather, the proteome evolution, is caused by the occurrence of random modifications of the genetic code and these events affect each protein domain independently. Protein domain duplication, mutation, recombination, relocation and horizontal transfer are in fact the main mechanisms that allow the outbreak of proteins with new functionalities, thereby contributing to the emergence of complexity15,16,17. As a matter of fact, the relationship between protein domain evolution and phylogeny has already been investigated in previous works, with findings suggesting a connection between the two. On the one hand the phylogeny of hundreds of organisms (including more than 100 bacteria) has been reconstructed satisfactorily (i.e., in good agreement with the classical taxonomy) based on the presence or absence of protein domain superfamilies18, or based on specific patterns of protein domains19. On the other hand the evolutionary origin and history of protein domains has been reconstructed based on the taxonomic tree of organisms20.
Taking an ecological approach, we here focus on the dynamic processes that led to the current configuration of protein domains, assuming that this could highlight important aspects of the evolution of genomes, proteins, and organisms. The proposed phylogeny will then be based on the evolutionary model of protein domains, incorporating the parameters estimated from such model.
In the past, various models of evolution have been proposed for protein domains, each linked to a particular distribution of the protein domains frequencies. This distribution is what in ecology is called Relative Species Abundance distribution (RSA). It is a measure of the biodiversity of an ecosystem, in our case the set of protein domain families that populate the genome, and can be used to fit real data in order to verify the validity of the underlying ecological hypothesis. Among the proposed ecological models for protein domains, the birth-death-innovation one stands out. The RSA distribution predicted by this model is a Pareto distribution and it fits the RSA of a wide range of genome-associated quantities well, including protein domains21,22.
Here, we consider a generalization of the birth-death-innovation model21 in which both demographic and environmental noise are added to the model. Environmental stochasticity is due to environmental changes which act simultaneously on all individuals while demographic stochasticity reflects the reproduction differences among individuals within a population. A suitable generalized model was developed by S. Engen and R. Lande in 199623,24, who proposed that the RSA distribution could be a Poisson Log-Normal or a Negative Binomial, depending on the assumptions.
Following Engen and Lande’s derivation23,24, we make the neutral ecological equivalence assumption that the evolutionary dynamics is the same for all the protein domain families. In this way, we will not need to introduce protein domain family-specific indices for the evolutionary rates in the following equations25. As in Engen and Lande’s papers, we also assume that protein domain families enter the protein domain community (i.e. the genome) at times generated by an inhomogeneous Poisson process (see Supplementary Material or, for more details, Karlin and Taylor textbooks26,27) with rate (omega (t)) and that they evolve independently of each other. Denoting the present time as (t=0), speciations (i.e. arrivals of new protein domain families in the genome) up to now have then occurred at negative times, generated by (omega (t)). Let the distribution of the abundance X(t) at time (t=0) of a protein domain family entering the genome at time (-t < 0) be f(x; t) and let p(t) be the probability that it has not gone extinct. Then, Engen and Lande showed that the abundances x of the protein domain families in the community are generated by an inhomogeneous Poisson process with rate
Now, we let the process for each protein domain family be a diffusion process (see Supplementary Material) which is a solution of the stochastic growth equation
where x still indicates the number of individuals within a protein domain family (i.e., its abundance), r is the constant growth rate ((r = b-d), where b is the birth rate and d is the death rate), g(x) is a density regulation function, (sigma ^2_r = sigma _e^2 + sigma _d^2/x) is the sum of the environmental ((sigma _e^2)) and demographic ((sigma _d^2/x)) stochasticities, and the process B(t) is a standard Brownian motion, so that (frac{dB(t)}{dt}) is the so-called white noise. It can be shown (see Supplementary Material) that the diffusion process which solves the stochastic differential Eq. (2) has infinitesimal mean (m(x) = [r+sigma ^2_d/(2x)+sigma ^2_e/2]x – xg(x)) which can be rewritten as (m(x)=[r-g(x)]x + (1/2)sigma ^2_d + (1/2)sigma ^2_ex). The noise term hence turns out to be composed by a multiplicative part (i.e., the environmental noise, which acts on the whole population of family domains), and an additive one (i.e., the demographic noise, which acts on individuals within the population and whose effect is thus stronger in smaller populations).
If protein domain families evolve independently from each other, then Engen and Lande showed that their abundances are generated by an inhomogeneous Poisson process with rate (lambda (x)) (see Supplementary Material). Specifically, depending on which assumptions are made on the model parameters, the predicted RSA distribution could be a Poisson Log-Normal, a Negative Binomial, or a Log-Series distribution.
Engen and Lande showed that if we consider the Gompertzian density regulation function23,28 (g(x)=gamma ln (x+epsilon )) , where (gamma) is a constant and (epsilon =sigma _d^2/sigma _e^2), then
where (omega _0) is the speciation parameter and (alpha = frac{2}{sigma _e^2}e^{frac{gamma }{sigma _e^2}left[ ln(1+epsilon ) -frac{r}{gamma } right] ^2}). When (epsilon ll x), (lambda (x)) can be approximated to a Log-Normal distribution
with parameters (mu = r/gamma) and (sigma ^2 = sigma ^2_{e}/2 gamma). This implies that the RSA distribution of protein domains would be a Poisson Log-Normal with parameters (mu) and (sigma ^2).
If instead, we consider a linear density regulation function24 (g(x)=eta x), where (eta) is a constant, then
where (omega _0) is the speciation parameter, (epsilon =sigma _d^2/sigma _e^2) and (a = frac{2 e^{2(1+epsilon )eta /sigma ^2_e}}{sigma ^2_e(1+epsilon )^{2(r+eta epsilon )/sigma ^2_e}}). When (epsilon ll x), (lambda (x)) is now a Gamma distribution with shape (alpha =2(r+eta epsilon )/sigma ^2_e) and rate (beta =2eta /sigma ^2_e), and the RSA distribution of protein domains is a Negative Binomial
with dispersion (alpha) and success rate ({q}=sigma ^2_e/(2eta + sigma ^2_e)).
Finally, if we consider the limit of Eq. (6) in which the dispersion parameter (alpha) tends to zero, the Negative Binomial density function [Eq. (6)] converges to a Log-Series
that hence represents a special case of Negative Binomial model when (2(r+eta epsilon )/sigma ^2_e rightarrow 0).
Here, we aim to model the evolution of protein domains within the genome using Engen and Lande’s theoretical framework. Specifically, modeling the protein domain RSA of thousands of bacterial genomes, we intend to provide a novel phylogenetic characterization of bacteria.
We hypothesize that new protein domain families are generated in the genome at times specified by an inhomogeneous Poisson process and that different families are mutually independent. Within the protein domain families, we assume that the evolutionary dynamics can be described by a stochastic birth-death process in which: (i) the growth rate r is constant; (ii) both environmental and demographic noise are included; iii) density regulation function is either linear or Gompertzian. The growth rate r can be interpreted as the rate by which a protein domain family gets a new copy inside the genome. This unifies two different events, the birth and death of protein domains which correspond to protein domain duplication and protein domain inactivation/deletion. Regarding the two noise terms ((sigma _d^2) and (sigma _e^2)), the demographic variance (sigma _d^2) captures small differences in duplication or survival between different individual domains which belong to the same protein domain family, while the environmental variance (sigma _e^2) represents larger scale disruptions of the proteome which act on all protein domains within the family simultaneously. Events such as horizontal gene transfer are an example of environmental stochasticity. The role of the density regulation, g(x), is to keep the abundance of protein domain family from diverging. This is usually a consequence of the limited availability of resources in the community, and it can be related to the limited size of the genome (and consequently of the proteome) in the contest of protein domains29.
The modeling of protein domain RSA within bacterial genomes will allow us to derive a novel measurement of phylogenetic distance. Specifically, we will show that the Poisson Log-Normal distribution [Eq. (4)] is the one that best fits the empirical RSA of bacterial protein domain families and we will derive our novel phylogenetic distance based on its two parameters (mu = r/gamma) and (sigma ^2 = sigma ^2_{e}/2 gamma), together with the protein domains density within the bacterial genome, as detailed in the “Materials and methods” section. In the following, we will show how such distance is related to the usual 16S rRNA gene-based and taxonomic classifications of bacteria and how it constitutes a promising measurement to investigate the bacterial phylogeny at the intraspecies level, where both 16S rRNA and taxonomic classification fail.
The protein domain RSA distributions of 3368 bacterial genomes were obtained as detailed in the “Materials and methods” section. Briefly, for each bacterial genome we retrieved all the identifiable protein domains. Then, we computed the RSA by counting the number of protein domains belonging to each protein domain family.
Three evolutionary hypotheses were tested by fitting the empirical RSAs with the Log-Series [Eq. (7)], the Negative Binomial (Eq. (6)) and the Poisson Log-Normal (Eq. (4)) distribution (Fig. 1a). According to the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC)30, in (99.97%) of bacteria the selected model was the Poisson Log-Normal (Fig. 1b). This model performed better than both the Log-Series and the Negative Binomial and described the data well, with an average (R^2) of 0.97 (minimum (R^2)=0.86). The selection of the Poisson Log-Normal model instead of the Negative Binomial or the Log-Series, implies that the protein domains evolution process is characterized by a Gompertzian density regulation function ((g(x)=gamma ln (x+epsilon ))) rather than a linear one ((g(x)=eta x)). This suggests an asymmetric process in which the proliferation rate for low abundant protein domains is faster than for the high abundant ones.
Fit of protein domains RSA. (a) Example of protein domains Preston plot fitted with three different distributions: the Poisson Log-Normal, the Negative Binomial and the Log-Series. Results refer to the bacterial genome (text {GCA}_000717515). The Negative Binomial and the Log-Series fit overlap. This implies that the dispersion parameter (alpha) of the Negative Binomial distribution (see Eq. (6)) is close to zero. The mean and the median of the dispersion parameter obtained for the 3368 bacterial genomes are ({2.67times 10^{-4}}) and ({2.62times 10^{-7}}), in agreement with the observed overlap. (b) Distribution of the difference between the AIC obtained with the Poisson Log-Normal model (PL) and the Log-Series (LS) or the Negative Binomial (NB) model, considering all the 3368 bacterial genomes.
The examination of the Poisson Log-Normal scale ((mu)) and location ((sigma ^2)) parameters (see Eq. (4) and Supplementary Material) estimated by the fitting procedure for each bacterial genome, allows us to reveal further features of the evolutionary process of protein domains.
First of all, Fig. 2 shows that (mu) has negative values in all bacterial genomes. Recalling that (mu =r/gamma), where r is the growth rate and (gamma) is the multiplicative constant of the Gompertzian function, which must be positive, this implies that the growth rate of protein domains, r, is also negative. Notice that the growth rate can be expressed as the difference between the birth and the death rate, (r=b-d). Hence, a negative r means that the death rate is greater than the birth rate ((d > b)). In the evolutionary model of protein domains, the birth rate b has the meaning of duplication rate, while the death rate d is the rate at which protein domains are deactivated. A negative r hence implies that protein domain deactivation, which is related to the accumulation of events which disrupt the coding sequence of protein domains, happens at a faster rate than the duplication of the whole protein domain sequence within the genome.
Distribution of species according to the model parameters. Scatter plot of Poisson Log-Normal parameters (mu) versus (sigma ^2) obtained fitting the protein domains RSAs. Only species represented by at least 10 different strains were included in the plot, for a total of 1173 bacterial genomes which belong to 48 different species. Different colors represent different species as indicated in the legend.
Furthermore, the plot of (mu) as a function of (sigma ^2) (Fig. 2) highlights the negative linear relationship between (mu) and (sigma ^2). Such relationship can also be deduced mathematically.
Starting from the expressions (mu =r/gamma) and (sigma ^2=sigma _e^2 / 2gamma), and after simple algebraic manipulation, we can in fact obtain that (mu = 2rsigma ^2 / sigma _e^2), which explains the negative linear relationship between the two parameters.
Besides the negative relationship, the plot of (mu) versus (sigma ^2) also highlights the presence of clusters of bacterial genomes with similar ecological features, which are pictured in the plot as roughly parallel stripes (Fig. 2). When we depict bacterial strains belonging to the same species using the same color, it emerges that the stripes are related to the bacterial taxonomy. This result motivates us to introduce a new approach to bacterial phylogeny based on the ecological modeling of protein domains and the consequent estimation of the parameters (mu) and (sigma ^2).
We propose to calculate the pairwise evolutionary distances between bacteria based on three parameters: the Poisson Log-Normal scale and location parameters discussed above ((mu) and (sigma)), and the density of protein domains in the bacterial genome. Such density describes to which extend the whole bacterial genome is populated with protein domains and it hence constitutes an additional feature of the protein domain ecological dynamics. As detailed in the Materials and Methods, the distance between bacteria is specifically computed as the 3D euclidean distance in the scaled space of (mu), (sigma), and protein domain density. In the following, we refer to such distance as ‘RSA distance’.
To evaluate the bacterial interrelationships derived from the RSA distances, we compared our results with both the bacterial taxonomic classification and the 16S rRNA gene-based phylogeny. Specifically, starting from the RSA distance matrix we computed a hierarchical clustering of bacteria and we compared the resulting clusters with those obtained from the 16S rRNA gene-based distance matrix. Both clustering results were then compared with the bacterial taxonomic classification.
Notice that the usage of both 16S rRNA phylogeny and bacterial taxonomic classification allows us to exploit the complementary information that these two approaches provide, despite their intrinsic connection. Namely, modern microbial taxonomy is mostly based on 16S rRNA gene6 and, on the other hand, the cutoffs commonly used in 16S rRNA phylogeny originated from phenotype-based taxonomy31. However, while taxonomy allows us to assign human interpretable names to bacteria, to associate such names with phenotypic properties, and to classify bacteria into a predefined hierarchy, 16S rRNA phylogeny provides a quantitative measurement of the evolutionary distance between bacteria that can be compared with the RSA distance without setting any pre-defined threshold. Moreover, the usage of 16S rRNA phylogeny allows us to investigate the bacterial relationships at the intraspecies level, for which the taxonomic classification is not available.
As detailed in the Materials and Methods, 16S rRNA distances were calculated based on the bacterial 16S rRNA gene reference sequences, following the standard procedure32. Taxonomic classification, instead, was retrieved from NCBI and included the following levels: phylum, class, order, family, genus and species. In order to obtain a comparable number of clusters from all three methods, we considered separately each taxonomic level and we cut the 16S rRNA and the RSA -based hierarchical trees so as to get a number of clusters equivalent to the number of taxa available at the selected taxonomic level.
At each taxonomic level, the Normalized Mutual Information (NMI) was used as a measurement of agreement between different clustering solutions33. Notice that, while the theoretical range of the NMI score is the interval (left[ 0,1right]), NMI is biased towards clustering solutions with more clusters and fewer data points34. Consequently, the baseline of NMI score in practise is not zero and relatively high NMI scores can be an artifact caused by the low ratio between number of bacteria and number of taxonomic groups. To make the comparison fair, we used simulations to calculate the baseline NMI for each taxonomic level (box plots of Fig. 3).
As expected by their intrinsic relationship, taxonomy and 16S rRNA phylogeny show high agreement (red dots in Fig. 3). RSA-based clusters, instead, show a certain deviation from both taxonomy (blue dots in Fig. 3) and phylogeny (green dots in Fig. 3). For both comparisons, however, the NMI scores are still evidently higher than the baseline, signifying that the RSA model captures phylogenetic signals to a certain degree. Comparing the obtained NMI scores with the baseline, we notice that the agreement between RSA-based clusters and both taxonomy and phylogeny increases at lower taxonomic levels, reaching the maximum at species level. Taking as ground truth the taxonomic classification, the total purity of the RSA-based clusters at species level is 0.65, signifying that 65% of bacteria are correctly classified.
Comparison between the three clustering results at different taxonomic levels. NMI scores (y-axis) are calculated as a measurement of agreement between clusters based on: RSA method and taxonomy (blue), 16S rRNA gene and taxonomy (red), RSA method and 16S rRNA gene (green). Different taxonomic levels are considered for the comparison: phylum, class, order, family, genus and species (x-axis). The box plots represent the baselines of NMI score and are based on simulations.
To assess the robustness and stability of the RSA-based phylogeny, with regard to the choice of protein domains, we randomly selected subsamples of protein domains in different proportions (from (10%) to 90% of all protein domains). The reconstructed phylogenetic trees were then compared with the phylogenetic tree obtained using all protein domains (see Materials and Methods for details), and the correlation between the trees was calculated (see Supplementary Fig. S6). As expected, with larger proportions of protein domains taken into account, the correlation between subsample-based phylogeny and base phylogeny increases. For larger subsampling proportions, the compared phylogenetic trees are in good agreement: for a subsample with 90% of protein domains, the mean cophenetic correlation is equal to 0.74, and the mean common-nodes-correlation is equal to 0.68. We notice that the common-nodes-correlation is more stable compared to the cophenetic correlation, as expected since cophenetic correlation is affected by the height of the phylogenetic trees. The results suggest that the overall structure of the phylogenies is stable even for smaller subsampling proportions, while subsampling height of the branches correlates with the full-data height only at larger subsampling proportions.
To evaluate the intraspecies composition obtained from the RSA-based clustering, we selected the subset of species for which at least 10 different strains were present in our data (48 species). Among them, we selected the species where hierarchical clustering showed a clear separation of clusters (including outliers) and for which published literature characterizing at least some of the strains was available (6 out of 48 species). For these 6 species, we again assessed the robustness and stability of RSA phylogenies, as detailed in the “Materials and methods” section. Our results suggest (see Supplementary Fig. S7) that the subsample-based phylogenies are in good agreement with the full-data phylogenies, especially for larger subsampling proportions. We notice the correlations is larger than in the case of phylogenetic trees for randomly selected 100 bacteria (Supplementary Fig. S6), especially for certain species (i.e., Xanthomonas citri). This could be attributed to the smaller size of the phylogenetic tree. However, the species with similar phylogenetic tree size still show differences in correlation (i.e., Xanthomonas citri and Francisella tularensis), suggesting that the RSA-based distance matrix between the strains of Xanthomonas citri carries stronger phylogenetic signal. Comparing 6 observed species with the randomly sampled subsets of 100 bacteria, we can analogously conclude that the RSA-captured phylogenetic signal is stronger within the species. In the following, we discuss the results obtained for the 6 selected bacterial species in more details.
(Previous page.) Hierarchical clustering of bacteria at the intraspecies level, comparing solutions obtained by RSA and 16S rRNA method. Each subplot shows a tanglegram with RSA-based dendrogram on the left and 16S rRNA-based dendrogram on the right. Lines connect the same bacteria from two dendrograms. The color/type of the line represents the feature of the bacterium it connects. (a) 22 strains of Xanthomonas citri belong to two different pathovars: A (orange) and (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) (purple). (b) 10 strains of Chlamydia pneumoniae are isolated from different tissues: conjuctival (yellow), respiratory (magenta) and vascular (violet). 9 strains represented with solid line are human (Homo sapiens) pathogens while the one strain represented by dashed line is koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) pathogen. (c) 14 strains of Vibrio cholerae are colored based on their karyotype. 11 strains have two circular chromosomes Chr1 ((sim 3) Mb) and Chr2 ((sim 1) Mb) (magenta). 2 strains have one (sim)4 Mb long circular chromosome (yellow). One strain has three chromosomes Chr1 ((sim)3 Mb), Chr2 ((sim)1 Mb) and Chr3 ((sim)1 Mb) (violet).
Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri (XCC) and Chlamydia pneumoniae (Cpn) are two species whose subspecies can infect different hosts. Here we show that the RSA-based method correctly discriminates such subspecies even when their divergence is not detected comparing the 16S rRNA gene sequences.
Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri (XCC) is a causal agent of citrus canker type A, a bacterial disease affecting different plants from the genus Citrus. While citrus canker A infects most citrus species, two of its variants, A* and (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}), have a much more limited host range with XCC pathotype (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) infecting only Key lime (C. aurantifolia) and alemow (C. macrophylla)2. Our data set includes 17 strains of XCC pathotype A and 5 strains of XCC pathotype (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}})2. RSA-based clustering of the 22 XCC strains identifies two separated clusters (Fig. 4a, left) which coincide with the two XCC pathotypes. Concurrently, clustering based on 16S rRNA gene fails to identify the two pathotypes of XCC (Fig. 4a, right). This suggests that even though pathotypes A and (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) have different hosts, their diversification is not reflected in the variability of the 16S rRNA gene. On the other hand, modeling the protein domain RSA of the two pathotypes succesfully captures the different functions of their proteomes.
Another important aspect of the citrus canker is the geographical spread of the disease. The 22 strains of XCC included in our data set have diverse geographical origin. While all (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) strains were sampled from USA, strains of pathotype A originate from USA, Brazil and China. RSA clustering of 17 A-type strains colored by their sampling location shows a geographical pattern (Supplementary Fig. S2) similar to the one obtained by Patané et al.2 using a maximum likelihood tree based on 1785 concatenated unicopy genes, with the only exception of strain jx-6 ((text {GCA}_001028285)) coming from China.
For what concerns Chlamydia pneumoniae (Cpn), this is an obligate intercellular parasite which is widespread in human population and causes acute respiratory disease. Besides humans, different animal species can be infected with Chlamydia pneumoniae. Our data set includes 9 strains which infect humans (Homo sapiens) and 1 strain isolated from koala (Phascolarctos cinereus). RSA-based clustering clearly separates such isolate from the group of highly similar human isolates (Fig. 4b, left). This result is confirmed by 16S rRNA-based clustering (Fig. 4b, right) and is in agreeement with previous results in which the comparison of four human-derived isolates and the koala strain LPCoLN ((text {GCA}_000024145)) through whole-genome sequencing showed a much higher variation between human and koala-derived strains than within the human-derived strains35.
Another peculiarity of Chlamydia pneumoniae is tissue tropism. The human-derived strains of Chlamydia pneumoniae can in fact be divided into conjuctival, raspiratory and vascular based on their tissue of origin. Cpn tissue tropism was the focus of the study conducted by Weinmaier et al., where whole-genome sequences of multiple Cpn strains isolated from different human anatomical sites were compared and animal isolates were used as outgroup3. Weinmaier et al. found a good agreement between the anatomical origin of strains and the maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree based on all SNPs. However, they could not obtain a clear separation between anatomical subgroups of Cpn. Our results show that the RSA-based method partially succeeds in separating subspecies related to different tissues (Fig. 4b, left). The RSA-based dendrogram, in fact, shows a cluster of four respiratory bacteria. However, it does not separate the other subspecies by infection site, suggesting that tissue tropism is not entirely captured by our method.
In some cases, subspecies of the same species are characterized by global differences in the genome composition. This is, for example, the case of Vibrio cholerae and Buchnera aphidicola. Here, we show that the RSA-based model is able to capture such differences and to discriminate subspecies with known different genomic peculiarities.
Vibrio cholerae is the causative agent of cholera disease. Its genome is normally composed of two chromosomes: Chr1 ((sim 3) Mb) and Chr2 ((sim 1) Mb). However, some strains show a different karyotype. The two strains (1154text {-}74) ((text {GCA}_000969235)) and (10432text {-}62) ((text {GCA}_000969265)), for instance, underwent the process of chromosomal fusion and possess only one (sim 4) Mb long circular chromosome, which shows a high degree of synteny with the two chromosomes of the more common strains36. The strain (text {TSY}216) ((text {GCA}001045415)), on the other hand, besides having the original two chromosomes, also contains an additional (sim 1) Mb long replicon, which does not share any conserved region with Chr1 and Chr237. For these reasons, we expect the single- and two-chromosome strains to be phylogenetically closer to each other than to the three-chromosome strain, which contains the extra replicon. The 16S rRNA gene-based clustering, however, does not identify any clear separation between the three types of strains (Fig. 4c, right). As a matter of fact, all the 16S rRNA gene copies of all the Vibrio cholerae strains included in our data set are located on (sim 3) Mb long chromosome, which shows high synteny across all strains. It is therefore not surprising that the comparison of the 16S rRNA genes does not capture the global genomic differences that exist between the considered strains. On the other hand, the results obtained with the RSA-based clustering show a clear distinction of the strains with different genomic structure (Fig. 4c, left). The reason for the success of the RSA-based method lies in the theoretical definition of RSA-based distance. In fact, the RSA-based distance depends on the Poisson Log-Normal location parameter (sigma ^2), which increases with the genome length (Supplementary Fig. S1): by definition, (sigma ^2 = sigma _e^2 / 2gamma), and, while the environmental noise (sigma _e^2) can be reasonably considered independent of the genome length, the density regulation (gamma) is expected to be stronger for smaller genomes, which repesent a scarcer environment with less resources.
Buchnera aphidicola is a bacterial species in mutualistic endosymbiotic relationship with different aphids (members of superfamily Aphidoidea). As many endosymbionts, Buchnera aphidicola underwent the process of genome reduction as an adaptation to the host-associated lifestyle and has a genome with length (<1) Mb. One of the main processes which contributed to genome reduction is gene inactivation followed by progressive gene disintegration38. An intermediate step of this process is pseudogenization. For this reason, we expect the number of pseudogenes within a genome to be related to its evolutionary state and strains with similar numbers of pseudogenes to be phylogenetically similar. Among the 13 strains of Buchnera aphidicola available in our data set, we observe a high variability in the number of pseudogenes, with 12 strains having between 7 and 63, and one strain (JF98, (text {GCA}_000183305)) having 176 pseudogenes. Since the total number of genes (considering both protein coding genes and pseudogenes) is similar in all strains, this implies that JF98 has a smaller proteome compared to the others. Our results show that the divergence of strain JF98 from the others is evident from the RSA-based clustering (Supplementary Fig. S3-a, left), while it is not clear from the 16S rRNA-based one (Supplementary Fig. S3-a, right).
On the other hand, another outstanding property of the Buchnera aphidicola strains is their capability to infect different hosts. Focusing on this aspect, we notice that the RSA-based clustering only partially agrees with a grouping of the strains based on the infected host. The 16S rRNA-based method, instead, finds more coherent results (Supplementary Fig. S3-b), possibly due to the fact that endosymbionts and their hosts tend to co-evolve together once their endosymbiotic relationship starts4.
For several species in our data set, the RSA-based phylogenic tree indicates the presence of outlier strains (see Supplementary Fig. S8). For two of such species (Listeria monocytogenes and Francisella tularensis), in particular, we were able to find bibliographic information at the strain level which provides a biological explanation to our findings.
Listeria monocytogenes is a food-borne pathogenic bacterium which causes listeriosis in humans. From the 48 Listeria monocytogenes strains present in our data set, RSA-based clustering identifies a subgroup of two strains (Supplementary Fig. S4). These two strains, La111 ((text {GCA}_000382925)) and N53-1 ((text {GCA}_000382945)), seem to have very similar proteome composition which differs from that of the other strains. Holch et al. investigated strains La111 and N53-1 in their study on bacterial persistence in Listeria monocytogenes39. Based on whole-genome analysis, the authors found that these two strains, which were isolated 6 years apart from different Danish fish processors, are extremely similar and collectively different from the other analyzed strains, in agreement with our RSA-based results.
Francisella tularensis, instead, is an intracellular bacterium which is a causal agent of tularemia. Our data set includes 25 Francisella tularensis strains from different subspecies: tularensis, holarctica, mediasiatica and novicida. While neither RSA- nor 16S rRNA-based clustering accurately separate subspecies of Francisella tularensis, the RSA method identifies one outlier, strain TIGB03 ((text {GCA}_000248415)) (Supplementary Fig. S5). Unlike the other 24 virulent strains, strain TIGB03 is an attenuated tularensis strain. This strain was described by Modise et al. as an attenuated O-antigen mutant of the virulent strain TI0902 ((text {GCA}_000248435))5. Indeed, we notice that 16S rRNA genes of these two strains are identical (Supplementary Fig. S5) and thus 16S rRNA-based clustering is unable to detect the mutant strain. Comparing whole-genome sequences of strains TIGB03 and TI0902, Modise et al. found 31 nonsynonymous point mutations and a 75.9 kb long duplicated region in the mutant strain TIGB03. However, such long duplication does not make TIGB03 an outlier in terms of genome length (the genome length of TIGB03 is 1.97 Mb and that of the other 24 strains included in our study ranges from 1.86 to 2.05 Mb). This indicates that the presence of nonsynomymous mutations led to different proteome composition, which is recognized by our method.
The de novo clustering of phylogenetically similar metagenomes is a crucial step for the study of bacterial populations. To this aim, a typical approach is the pairwise comparison of 16S rRNA sequences derived from the biological sample of interest. After computing the pairwise distance matrix, clusters are defined based on a custom similarity threshold. Then, clusters are usually compared to databases of annotated sequences to derive the taxonomic classification, that is to associate human-made hierarchical labels (bacterial names) to the detected metagenomes. While taxonomic classification allows to recognize known bacteria and their phenotype, de novo clustering potentially allows to obtain a higher resolution of the bacterial population at the intraspecies level, unaffected by the possible bias of human-made classifications.
Here, we proposed to measure the phylogenetic distance between bacteria, based on their genomic evolving units: protein domains. Specifically, we exploited the ecological modeling of ecosystems proposed by Engen and Lande23 to describe the evolution of protein domains, considering them as ‘species’ that populate the genome. Based on such modeling, we derived a new phylogenetic distance that can be computed fitting the protein domains Relative Species Abundance distribution (RSA). We showed that clustering the bacterial genomes based on 16S rRNA or exploiting our model allows to capture different features in terms of both genome composition (e.g. presence of additional replicon, pseudogenes, duplicated regions, or nonsynomymous mutations) and bacterial phenotype (e.g. infected host). Our results hence open to the possibility of developing an algorithm in which both pieces of information are exploited to obtain an overall best inference of bacterial phylogeny. This will hopefully be part of future works.
The proposed approach is especially promising when samples are analysed by means of shotgun sequencing, rather than 16S rRNA sequencing40. Indeed, 16S rRNA sequencing is a powerful method to detect and compare metagenomes. However, it is limited by being based on the measurement of a single gene. On the other hand, information on the whole metagenome can be derived when using shotgun sequencing40. In terms of phylogeny, 16S rRNA sequencing detects only metagenomic divergences which directly affect the 16S rRNA gene, and its ability to discriminate metagenomes at the intraspecies level is therefore limited6. Our RSA-based method, on the other hand, provides a global measurement based on the whole proteome. As highlighted by our results, these two approaches are hence somehow complementary, being the RSA-based method more sensitive to evolutionary processes that affect the metagenome globally, possibly leaving the 16S rRNA gene unaffected, and the 16S rRNA-based method being instead more sensitive when such gene is involved, such as in the case of Buchnera aphidicola. Overall, our results show that the RSA-based approach is a promising method that could be exploited to study the metagenomic composition of samples, in particular when shotgun sequencing is performed and the whole metagenome could be reconstructed, though experimental validation would be required to definitely assess the efficacy of our approach.
The genome sequences of 3370 bacteria were downloaded from the NCBI database41. Draft genome sequences were discarded and only the higher quality fully circular genome sequences were retained. GeneBank files containing genome sequences and existing annotations were retrieved from the NCBI database and imported into the Semantic Annotation Platform for Prokaryotes42 using the EMBL/GBK to RDF SAPP module. De novo identification of genetic elements (gene calling) was performed using Prodigal (2.6)43 with codon table 11, which is recommanded when dealing with bacterial genomes. Dedicated SPARQL queries were built to extract all proteins and their sequences from the RDF triplestore used by SAPP to store the intermediate results. InterProScan44 was used to identify protein domains in the corresponding sequences. Due to the high number of distinct protein sequences to be analyzed, the SURFsara GRID infrastructure was used45 to concurrently analyze the sequences. Dedicated SPARQL queries were used to retrieve all the identified domains and assign them to the originating protein and bacterial genome. Finally, the matrix generating module from SAPP was used to generate a matrix containing the number of instances of the detected domain (domain abundance) for each of the studied genomes and for each of the identified protein domains. Overall 3370 bacterial genomes were analyzed and 13,934 distinct domains were identified.
Protein domains RSAs were fitted with the Maximum Likelihood Estimation method implemented in R “sads” package v.0.4.246. Data were modelled with a truncated Poisson Log-Normal, a truncated Log-Series and a truncated Negative Binomial distribution, so that to test and compare different ecological hypothesis. In all cases, truncation was performed to exclude the zero abundance class, that is not observable in empirical data. Two bacterial genomes which couldn’t be fitted due to extreme RSA distributions are (text {GCA}_000200735) and (text {GCA}_000831405). After removal of these bacteria, we proceeded with the analysis of the remaining 3368 bacterial genomes. Akaike Information Criterion (AIC)30 and R-squared were computed to assess the models performances and for model selection.
Fitting truncated Poisson Log-Normal distribution to protein domain RSA, we obtained estimates (mu) and (sigma) for 3368 bacteria. In addition to Poisson Log-Normal parameters, we calculated protein domain density for every bacteria as ratio between total number of protein domains present in the genome and the genome length. RSA distance between each pair of bacteria was calculated as 3D euclidean distance in the scaled space of (mu), (sigma) and protein domain density. Scaling was performed independently at each dimension subtracting the mean and dividing by standard deviation.
In order to calculate phylogenetic distances based on 16S rRNA gene, we used the silva database47 to retrieve the 16S rRNA reference sequences of the bacterial species for which protein domain data were available. For 48 bacteria, the 16S rRNA sequence was not present, so we considered only the remaining 3320 bacteria for the following analysis. Since the same bacterial genome can have multiple different copies of 16S rRNA gene, as 16S rRNA distance between a pair of bacteria we used the mean pairwise distance between all pairs of 16S rRNA sequences within two genomes48. The alignment of 16S rRNA sequences and calculation of distances was performed with mothur32 “pairwise.seqs” function with default parameters.
For each taxonomic level, we considered only bacteria for which the classification was known and which belonged to a taxonomic group with at least 10 members. As a result, we analysed 3270, 3148, 3032, 2714, 2139 and 161 bacteria at phylum, class, order, family, genus and species level, respectively. They belonged to 14, 20, 48, 63, 54 and 48 different taxonomic groups. Hierarchical clustering was performed on both RSA and 16S rRNA distance matrices. For RSA clustering we used Ward’s minimum variance method while for 16S rRNA we used average linkage method. The Ward’s method was used to minimize the total in-cluster variance49. Since this method is based on Euclidean distance, it couldn’t be applied to 16S rRNA distance matrix. To get clustering solutions for RSA and 16S rRNA, we cut the hierarchical tree fixing the number of clusters to the number of taxa at the selected taxonomic level. Finally, we used the NMI score as a measure of clustering agreement between the three approaches: RSA, 16S and predefined taxonomy. To calculate the baseline for the NMI score, we compared the taxonomy with clustering solutions based on simulations. For the fixed number of clusters and data points, each simulation assigned random cluster to each data point. Purity of a RSA cluster with respect to taxonomy is calculated as the ratio between the size of the cluster’s most abundant taxonomic group and the cluster size. The total purity of the RSA clustering solution is a weighted average of its clusters’ purities where weight is a cluster size.
To assess the robustness and stability of RSA-based phylogeny, regarding the choice of protein domains, we randomly selected subsamples of protein domains and we compared the obtained subsample-based results with the one obtained when all protein domains were used. Specifically, we subsampled protein domains in various proportions (ranging from 0.1 to 0.9), then we fitted the subsampled protein domain RSA distribution with Poisson LogNormal distribution and we used the estimated parameters to calculate the phylogeny of the examined bacteria, following the same methodology used when considering all protein domains. The obtained subsample-based phylogeny (i.e., dendrogram) was then compared to the full-data-based phylogeny calculating the correlation between dendrograms. Two different correlation measurements were used, cophenetic correlation and correlation based on common nodes (i.e., nodes that have the same list of leaves). For the calculations, the function “cor.dendlist” from the R “dendextend” package v.1.14.050 was used. For every subsampling proportion (0.1–0.9), 100 bacteria were randomly chosen from 3368 available bacteria and a random subsample of protein domains was taken from the remaining protein domains (which were present in at least one of the chosen bacteria). The correlation between two 100-leaf dendrograms (computed with all protein domains and with a chosen subsample of protein domains) was calculated. The procedure was repeated for 50 times, resulting in 50 correlation measurements for every subsampling proportion. Additionally, robustness and stability of phylogeny was assessed for 6 bacterial species (Xanthomonas citri, Vibrio cholerae, Francisella tularensis, Buchnera aphidicola, Listeria monocytogenes, Chlamydia pneumoniae). For every bacterial species and for different subsampling proportions (from 0.1 to 0.9), with 100 repeats, a subsample of protein domains was randomly selected and subsample-based phylogeny of the species was recontructed. Correlations between the full-data dendrogram and the 100 subsample-based dendrograms were calculated. Subsequently, the mean and standard deviation of correlation was obtained for every species and every subsampling proportion.
The datasets analysed during the current study are available in the NCBI repository41 (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/). The complete list of accession numbers (GenBank IDs) is provided in the Supplementary material.
Lan, R. & Reeves, P. R. Intraspecies variation in bacterial genomes: the need for a species genome concept. Trends Microbiol. 8, 396–401 (2000).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Patané, J. S. et al. Origin and diversification of xanthomonas citri subsp. citri pathotypes revealed by inclusive phylogenomic, dating, and biogeographic analyses. BMC Genomics20, 700 (2019).
Weinmaier, T. et al. Genomic factors related to tissue tropism in chlamydia pneumoniae infection. BMC Genomics 16, 268 (2015).
Article  Google Scholar 
Baumann, P. Biology of bacteriocyte-associated endosymbionts of plant sap-sucking insects. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 59, 155–189 (2005).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Modise, T. et al. Genomic comparison between a virulent type a1 strain of francisella tularensis and its attenuated o-antigen mutant (2012).
Janda, J. M. & Abbott, S. L. 16s rrna gene sequencing for bacterial identification in the diagnostic laboratory: pluses, perils, and pitfalls. J. Clin. Microbiol. 45, 2761–2764 (2007).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Felsenstein, J. Inferring phylogenies (Sinauer Associates is an imprint of Oxford University Press, 2004), 2 edn.
Zhu, Q. et al. Phylogenomics of 10,575 genomes reveals evolutionary proximity between domains bacteria and archaea. Nat. Commun. 10, 1–14 (2019).
Article  Google Scholar 
Ciccarelli, F. D. et al. Toward automatic reconstruction of a highly resolved tree of life. Science 311, 1283–1287 (2006).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Gevers, D. et al. Re-evaluating prokaryotic species. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 3, 733 (2005).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Hanage, W. P., Fraser, C. & Spratt, B. G. Sequences, sequence clusters and bacterial species. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 361, 1917–1927 (2006).
Article  Google Scholar 
Comas, I., Moya, A. & González-Candelas, F. Phylogenetic signal and functional categories in proteobacteria genomes. BMC Evol. Biol. 7, S7 (2007).
Article  Google Scholar 
Ponting, C. P. & Russell, R. R. The natural history of protein domains. Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 31, 45–71 (2002).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Alberts, B. et al.Molecular biology of the cell (Garland Science, Taylor a Francis Group, 2014), 6 edn.
Xie, X., Jin, J. & Mao, Y. Evolutionary versatility of eukaryotic protein domains revealed by their bigram networks. BMC Evol. Biol. 11, 242 (2011).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Chothia, C., Gough, J., Vogel, C. & Teichmann, S. A. Evolution of the protein repertoire. Science 300, 1701–1703 (2003).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Nasir, A., Kim, K. M. & Caetano-Anollés, G. Global patterns of protein domain gain and loss in superkingdoms. PLoS Comput. Biol. 10, e1003452 (2014).
Article  Google Scholar 
Yang, S., Doolittle, R. F. & Bourne, P. E. Phylogeny determined by protein domain content. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 102, 373–378 (2005).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Wang, M. & Caetano-Anollés, G. Global phylogeny determined by the combination of protein domains in proteomes. Mol. Biol. Evol. 23, 2444–2454 (2006).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Yang, S. & Bourne, P. E. The evolutionary history of protein domains viewed by species phylogeny. PLoS ONE 4, e8378 (2009).
Article  Google Scholar 
Karev, G. P., Wolf, Y. I., Rzhetsky, A. Y., Berezovskaya, F. S. & Koonin, E. V. Birth and death of protein domains: a simple model of evolution explains power law behavior. BMC Evol. Biol. 2, 1–26 (2002).
Article  Google Scholar 
Luscombe, N. M., Qian, J., Zhang, Z., Johnson, T. & Gerstein, M. The dominance of the population by a selected few: power-law behaviour applies to a wide variety of genomic properties. Genome Biol. 3, 1–7 (2002).
Article  Google Scholar 
Engen, S. & Lande, R. Population dynamic models generating the lognormal species abundance distribution. Math. Biosci. 132, 169–183 (1996).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Engen, S. & Lande, R. Population dynamic models generating species abundance distributions of the gamma type. J. Theor. Biol. 178, 325–331 (1996).
Article  Google Scholar 
Hubbell, S. P. The unified neutral theory of biodiversity and biogeography (Princeton University Press, 2011), 1 edn.
Karlin, S. & Taylor, H. M. A first course in stochastic processes (Academic Press, 1975), 2 edn.
Karlin, S. & Taylor, H. M. A second course in stochastic processes (Academic Press, 1981), 1 edn.
Gompertz, B. On the nature of the function expressive of the law of human mortality, and on a new mode of determining the value of life contingencies. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. 513–583 (1825).
Hidalgo, O. et al. Is there an upper limit to genome size. Trends Plant Sci. 22, 567–573 (2017).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Burnham, K. P., Anderson, D. R. & Huyvaert, K. P. AIC model selection and multimodel inference in behavioral ecology: some background, observations, and comparisons. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 65, 23–35 (2011).
Article  Google Scholar 
Cohan, F. M. What are bacterial species?. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 56, 457–487 (2002).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Schloss, P. D. et al. Introducing mothur: open-source, platform-independent, community-supported software for describing and comparing microbial communities. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 75, 7537–7541 (2009).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Estévez, P. A., Tesmer, M., Perez, C. A. & Zurada, J. M. Normalized mutual information feature selection. IEEE Trans. Neural Netw. 20, 189–201 (2009).
Article  Google Scholar 
Romano, S., Bailey, J., Nguyen, V. & Verspoor, K. Standardized mutual information for clustering comparisons: one step further in adjustment for chance. In International Conference on Machine Learning, 1143–1151 (2014).
Myers, G. et al. Evidence that human chlamydia pneumoniae was zoonotically acquired. J. Bacteriol. 191, 7225–7233 (2009).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Xie, G. et al. Exception to the rule: genomic characterization of naturally occurring unusual vibrio cholerae strains with a single chromosome. Int. J. Genomics, 2017 (2017).
Okada, K. et al. Characterization of 3 megabase-sized circular replicons from vibrio cholerae. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 21, 1262 (2015).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Gómez-Valero, L., Latorre, A. & Silva, F. J. The evolutionary fate of nonfunctional DNA in the bacterial endosymbiont Buchnera aphidicola. Mol. Biol. Evol. 21, 2172–2181 (2004).
Article  Google Scholar 
Holch, A. et al. Genome sequencing identifies two nearly unchanged strains of persistent listeria monocytogenes isolated at two different fish processing plants sampled 6 years apart. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 79, 2944–2951 (2013).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Durazzi, F. et al. Comparison between 16s rRNA and shotgun sequencing data for the taxonomic characterization of the gut microbiota. Sci. Rep. 11, 1–10 (2021).
Article  Google Scholar 
Wheeler, D. L. et al. Database resources of the national center for biotechnology information. Nucleic Acids Res. 28, 10–14 (2000).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Koehorst, J. J. et al. Sapp: functional genome annotation and analysis through a semantic framework using fair principles. Bioinformatics 34, 1401–1403 (2018).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Hyatt, D. et al. Prodigal: prokaryotic gene recognition and translation initiation site identification. BMC Bioinform. 11, 119 (2010).
Article  Google Scholar 
Jones, P. et al. Interproscan 5: genome-scale protein function classification. Bioinformatics 30, 1236–1240 (2014).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Surf. https://www.surf.nl/en.
Prado, P. I., Miranda, D. M. & Chalom, A. Package sads. MASS (2018).
Quast, C. et al. The Silva ribosomal RNA gene database project: improved data processing and web-based tools. Nucleic Acids Res. 41, D590–D596 (2012).
Article  Google Scholar 
Větrovskỳ, T. & Baldrian, P. The variability of the 16s rRNA gene in bacterial genomes and its consequences for bacterial community analyses. PLoS ONE 8, e57923 (2013).
Article  Google Scholar 
Ward, J. H. Jr. Hierarchical grouping to optimize an objective function. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 58, 236–244 (1963).
MathSciNet  Article  Google Scholar 
Galili, T. dendextend: an R package for visualizing, adjusting, and comparing trees of hierarchical clustering. Bioinformatics 31, 3718–20 (2015).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Download references
This work was supported by the European Union’s H2020 research and innovation programme “VEO” Grant no. 874735, and by the H2020-MSCA-ITN “IMforFuture” Grant no. 721815.
Department of Physics and Astronomy ‘Augusto Righi’, University of Bologna, 40127, Bologna, Italy
Iva Budimir, Daniele Dall’Olio, Alessandra Merlotti & Daniel Remondini
Department of Experimental, Diagnostic and Specialty Medicine, University of Bologna, 40138, Bologna, Italy
Enrico Giampieri, Martina Tarozzi, Nico Curti, Gastone Castellani & Claudia Sala
Laboratory of Systems and Synthetic Biology, Wageningen University and Research, 6708 WE, Wageningen, The Netherlands
Edoardo Saccenti & Maria Suarez-Diez
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
C.S., G.C., and D.R. conceived the analysis. E.S. and M.S.D conducted the bioinformatic analysis. I.B, C.S, E.G, and D.D. conducted the statistical analysis and modeling. E.G. and N.C. optimized the code. I.B., C.S., M.T., A.M. and N.C. processed the results and performed the bibliographic analysis. All authors reviewed the manuscript.
Correspondence to Gastone Castellani.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Budimir, I., Giampieri, E., Saccenti, E. et al. Intraspecies characterization of bacteria via evolutionary modeling of protein domains. Sci Rep 12, 16595 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21036-3
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21036-3
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports (Sci Rep) ISSN 2045-2322 (online)
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

source

Disco Elysium Studio Accused Of Ousting Creators, Dev Says It's 'Bad News' For Sequel – Kotaku

Some of the core developers behind beloved 2019 indie RPG Disco Elysium, including the author of the novel it’s based on, are no longer working at the studio that created it. The news was revealed in a blog post written by an editor on the game, Martin Luiga, who claims studio leadership at ZA/UM forced out the lead designers at the end of 2021 and has kept it secret ever since. According to two sources familiar with the situation, the studio hasn’t been transparent about what exactly happened with staff either.
ZA/UM started out as a collective of artists in Estonia before later turning into a studio of the same name to develop one of its members’ books into a Dungeons & Dragons-inspired examination of political economy and self loathing. ZA/UM the studio is based out of the UK, and in 2019 released Disco Elysium, which became a critical and financial success, racking up multiple game of the year awards.
“I, Martin Luiga, a founding member and Secretary of the ZA/UM cultural association, as well as the assembler of most of the core team, am hereby dissolving the ZA/UM cultural association (not to be confused with the ZA/UM company, on which subject I would note that neither Kurvitz, Hindpere nor Rostov are working there since the end of last year and their leaving the company was involuntary,” the former ZA/UM developer wrote in an October 1 Medium post. “Which would seem like bad news for the loving fans that are waiting for the Disco sequel.”
Read More: A Year Later, I Still Can’t Stop Thinking About Disco Elysium
Robert Kurvitz was the lead designer on whose novel the game was based. Aleksander Rostov was the lead artist whose impressionistic oil paintings defined the aesthetic of the game. And Helen Hindpere was one of the main writers on the game’s exceptional script, who accepted the prize for best new indie game of the year from presenter Reggie Fils-Aime at the 2019 Game Awards. Rostov confirmed the departures in a tweet attributed to all three members.
Spooky and scary
Something video games have over their film counterparts when it comes to horror is the player’s agency. Sure, watching the slasher claim their next victim can get a jumpscare out of you, but you know what’s scarier? Knowing you had the power to stop it. Watching someone slowly open a door and enter a dark room is unnerving, but having to do it yourself will send shivers down your spine and paralyze you with fear.
According to two sources familiar with the situation, the studio’s internal announcement of Kurvitz’s departure late last year also contained a threat of possible legal action against him. Any split would have been made messier by Kurvitz and Rostov being shareholders in the studio, the sources said. It’s also clear ZA/UM has gone out of its way to try and keep the situation quiet. Kotaku reached out for an interview with Kurvitz in February. The studio declined on his behalf, but provided no indication the developer had already left the company.
While it’s not clear exactly why Kurvitz, Rostov, and Hindpere are no longer working at ZA/UM, Luiga’s post and subsequent comments and tweets insinuate that the core team was pushed out by the business side of the studio. “The money people come from a background which says you gotta grab when you can even when it in fact does not make much economic sense,” he tweeted.
In response to one commenter claiming “the suits have killed disco,” Luiga posted a picture of the game’s executive producers, Tõnis Haavel and Kaur Kender. Haavel was previously convicted of investment fraud in Estonia, while Kender was the one who initially persuaded Kurvitz to write the book that would later inspire Disco Elysium. “Once we got Kaur on board, everything really started flowing because Kaur has this superpower that’s very important in capitalism,” Kurvitz told Gamesradar in 2020. “He understands money.” Earlier this year, Amazon inked a deal with DJ2 Entertainment, the production company currently planning film adaptations of Disco Elysium and a bunch of other games.
While ZA/UM hasn’t officially announced a sequel to Disco Elysium, Kurvitz had previously spoken about wanting to do what Baldur’s Gate 2 did for Baldur’s Gate 1, heavily implying that one was in the works. Job listings spotted earlier this year included one for an environmental artist that mentioned expanded worlds and “sci-fi,” as well as one for a sales monitizations specialist.
The studio hasn’t yet commented directly on the latest allegations either. “Like any video game, the development of Disco Elysium was and still is a collective effort, with every team member’s contribution essential and valued as part of a greater whole,” a spokesperson for ZA/UM told Kotaku in a statement. “At this time, we have no further comment to make other than the ZA/UM creative team’s focus remains on the development of our next project, and we are excited to share more news on this with you all soon.”
Luiga, Kurvitz, Rostov, and Hindpere did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
     

source

Loretta Lynn's 'Van Lear Rose': a gift from a songwriting master – Tennessean

source

'Moonrise' Anime Series: Coming to Netflix in 2024 and What We Know So Far – What's on Netflix

‘Moonrise’ Anime Series: Coming to Netflix in 2024 and What We Know So Far  What’s on Netflix
source

Titus Andronicus: The Will to Live Album Review – Pitchfork

Titus Andronicus: The Will to Live Album Review  Pitchfork
source

How to get into Vanderbilt's master's degree program in computer science – Fortune

Not all students enrolled in Vanderbilt University’s online master’s program in computer science have followed a traditional path in the industry. Degree candidates come from a wide variety of life experiences and professional backgrounds: the auto industry, banking and finance, music and entertainment, education, engineering, and more. Still, Vanderbilt’s admissions team is looking for some knowledge of computer science, an undergraduate degree, and a proven success record in a given field.
“The folks in our program that don’t have a strict computer science background, have been working in an industry and have already been successful there,” says Jules White, associate dean of strategic learning programs at the Vanderbilt University School of Engineering. “It is very competitive. The worst thing we can do is let someone in who isn’t prepared.”
The program, which ranks No. 1 on Fortune’s list of the best online master’s degree programs in computer science, accepted 52% of applicants for the 2020–21 school year. It currently has between 110 and 120 students per graduating class, offering up to 10 courses to choose from each semester. 
Through interviews with two administrators from Vanderbilt, this article will help guide you through the steps you’ll need to take to get into this top-ranked computer science program:
Going back to school for a master’s degree proves to be worthwhile for thousands of students each year, but it does require a commitment of time and money. Vanderbilt’s computer science master’s is a robust program, demanding up to 20 hours per week outside the classroom in related work. The online curriculum is a direct mirror of what’s offered to students who attend in person on campus. 
“There’s an average of eight years experience in the program,” says White, noting that the Vanderbilt coursework aims to meet the needs and experience level of an experienced student body. “They are more senior and looking to move on to that next step. We have a really superb set of students.”
In the classroom, Vanderbilt faculty aim to offer students hands-on learning through the school’s 30-credit curriculum over three to six terms. Coursework in cloud computing, computer science theory, software engineering, cybersecurity, and more make for an interdisciplinary approach with top-notch professors in a highly academic setting. 
What’s more, master’s degree students in computer science should be prepared for additional commitments outside the classroom. Vanderbilt’s program hopes to help students build a network and peer group to foster sharing of ideas; help with job hunting after graduation; and further build the Vanderbilt alumni community. 
Like many graduate degree programs, Vanderbilt requires several elements in the application, including letters of recommendation and essays. While the school’s selection process doesn’t rely on GRE scores, it does require a solid 3.2 GPA in undergraduate work for admission—but life and work experience carry a tremendous amount of weight, too. 
“If someone is the CTO at a major company, I couldn’t care less what their GPA was,” says White. “There’s always a balance of how you compare across age groups, experiences, and education levels. We are trying to find people who are going to be engaged, and it’s the right time and right fit.”
Overall, Vanderbilt is looking for students who have a solid educational background, life experience, and a clear sense of what’s next in their careers. 
To secure an acceptance letter from Vanderbilt, it’s important to focus on what makes you a unique asset to the program. Applicants come from all age groups, industries, and experience levels, so being able to share research, side projects, or internships during the application process help would-be students stand out from the competition, according to White. 
Demonstrating an innovative or entrepreneurial spirit can accomplish the same. “If someone hasn’t had a strong academic background or internship, having an entrepreneurial background is another thing,” says White. “They are going beyond what they are learning or taking what they learn in class and applying it in unique and novel ways; that’s a great indicator.”
More students are coming to the online program from nontraditional and unconventional professional and academic backgrounds, according to Joanne Wang, assistant dean for professional and external education programs at Vanderbilt. “The online program gives people an opportunity they wouldn’t have had,” she says. “Maybe they know how to code or did a boot camp. This gives them an opportunity to formalize their degree.” 
That’s why, Wang adds, being able to show the way you think, what sorts of projects you’ve worked on, and how you solve problems in the application process is increasingly important. 
People pursuing a career in computer science must be comfortable with the continuous learning that’s inherent to this field—and your application is a good opportunity to demonstrate your flexibility. 
“As a computer scientist, there’s one thing I can guarantee you: The specifics, the languages, the technology, it will be completely different in 10 years,” says White. “You’ll have to relearn if you want to stay relevant. You’ll have to be retraining yourself to advance.” 
Leveraging your essay or letters of recommendation to show how you’ve learned and capitalized on new skills throughout your career or undergraduate work will show the Vanderbilt admissions team that you can not only handle the rigor of learning new skills in the program, but that you’ll carry that effort over time as technology and innovation continue to shape the industry as a whole. 
White says computer scientists who’ve advanced over time in their careers are already at an advantage. “If you see someone progressing professionally—it’s unlikely you can’t manage that,” he adds. “There’s always the person who is a 10x software engineer. They are always retraining themselves but also understand the fundamental principles. That type of person is very successful in this program.”
See how the schools you’re considering fared in Fortune’s rankings of the best master’s degree programs in data science (in person and online), nursing, computer science, cybersecurity, psychology, public health, and business analytics, as well as the best doctorate in education programs and MBA programs (part-time, executive, full-time, and online).

source

How To Mix And Master in FL Studio | Hindi | Free Giveaway Alert

Stock Market Today: Dow, S&P Live Updates for Oct. 5 – Bloomberg

Bloomberg Surveillance. Live from London and New York, bringing insight on global markets and the top business stories of the day.
The economy and markets are “under surveillance”. Bloomberg Surveillance, covering the latest news in finance, economics and investments.
Part social gathering spaces, part retail meccas, malls were once the centerpiece of the suburban American experience. Now, faced with challenges from all sides, most are barely hanging on. Here’s what happened to American malls.
Ghana Hikes Rates Again to Curb Fastest Inflation in Two Decades
World Bank Cuts India Growth Forecast Citing Global Risks
The CEO of Royal Albert Hall Sees Little Threat From Spotify
Peloton to Cut 500 More Jobs in Effort to Save the Company
Uber Revives Self-Driving Taxi Dreams, Plans to Start This Year
Uber Revives Self-Driving Taxi Dreams, Plans to Start This Year
Elon Musk’s Twitter Takeover Slightly Less of a Done Deal, Shares Suggest
Peloton to Cut 500 More Jobs in Effort to Save the Company
Kim Jong Un’s Silence as Missiles Fly Shows Shift in Strategy
Nord Stream Leaks Caused by Detonations in Sign of Sabotage
Sanctioned Russian Billionaire’s Superyacht Turns Up in Hong Kong
UK Proposes Easing Pension Fee Cap in Win for Private Equity
Brittney Griner At ‘Weakest Moment’ in Russia, Her Wife Says
The CEO of Royal Albert Hall Sees Little Threat From Spotify
Have You Seen the Latest Polls? Now Forget Them. Here’s Why.
OPEC+ Cuts Are Just One Headache for Oil Markets
Ian Shows Band-Aids Won’t Solve Florida’s Insurance Crisis
‘I Am Energy’: Inside the Bang Billionaire’s Reeling Empire
The Massive Gas Field That Europe Can’t Use
How Hidden Risks at Pension Funds Almost Toppled Britain’s Bond Market
Banks Sent $1 Billion to South Sudan for Food and Medicine That Vanished, Probe Finds
‘Scrubs’ Producer Eric Weinberg Charged With 18 Counts in Sex Assaults on 5 Women
This Cardboard-Clad SUV Would Be Better for Your Wallet and the Environment
North America Heat Waves Led to Unprecedented Ice Melt in Greenland
Michigan Lures $1.6 Billion Battery Factory in Fight for EV Jobs 
How to Solve the Great Urban Restroom Shortage
Hong Kong Seeing Rebound in Shared Offices After City Opens Up 
Animoca Charts Path from Gaming Studio to Crypto VC
Crypto Lender Nexo’s Co-Founders Rebuff Insolvency Speculation
Hamilton Lane Preps Tokenized Funds to Draw Individual Investors

For many stock traders, it felt just about right that the market would take a breather after the dramatic rally of the past couple of days.
After a bounce that started around noon in New York and was attributed to a big options trade, the S&P 500 came back lower again. For a market plagued by fears about a recession and the Federal Reserve’s struggles to tame high inflation, the rebound from this year’s bottom has maybe gone too far, too fast.

source

Kingdom Hearts: Who Is The Master Of Masters? – TheGamer

There are a lot of secrets hiding beneath that hood.
In 2002, Square Enix developed a game that was unlike any we’d ever seen. The studio found a magical recipe by combining the charming, loveable characters of Disney with the rugged, overly emotional characters of Final Fantasy. The result was the birth of Kingdom Hearts, a story about three friends seeking adventure and a fateful battle between light and darkness.
RELATED: Kingdom Hearts Timeline, Explained
The Kingdom Hearts series contains 13 games that span multiple platforms. Fans of the series will be the first to tell you the plot is extremely convoluted, as many games occur at different points of the overarching timeline. But at the center of it all is a mysterious cloaked man who goes by the Master of Masters. The importance of this character can easily be lost in the chaos, so let’s dive into who exactly is this hooded figure.
Before Sora dreamed of leaving the comforts of Destiny Islands, the Master of Masters also wished to seek other worlds. As a young boy, the Keyblade War ravaged his world and he lost many loved ones in the battles. He swore to defeat the Darkness and trained himself in becoming a Keyblade Master. When he grew older, the Master of Masters left his homeworld and arrived in Daybreak Town, where he began crafting his master plan.
First, the Master of Masters created a Keyblade from one of his eyes called the Gazing Eye. He used this Keyblade and his innate powers of foresight to create the Book of Prophecies. This book would depict specific events in the future, but not the complete future. However, the Gazing Eye allowed him to also see through the weapon, so by combining both the Keyblade and the Book of Prophecies, the Master of Masters could foresee the future.
During his early time in Daybreak Town, the Master of Masters became somewhat acquainted with Darkness. Because he could foresee the future, the Master of Masters wasn’t afraid of Darkness, and ultimately, was more powerful than Darkness. But in order to completely defeat the entity, he had to follow a strict plan that would take several lifetimes to come to fruition. Creating the Book of Prophecies was the first step; next, the Master of Masters assembled his disciples.
The Master of Masters continued studying the X-blade, and when he felt that his powers reached their limit, he decided to take in six apprentices: Luxu, Ira, Gula, Invi, Aced, and Ava. The Master created Keyblades from each of their hearts and began training them to become Keyblade Masters. In addition to gifting them their own Keyblades, the Master of Masters also bestowed a copy of the Book of Prophecies to each apprentice, except Luxu.
Related: Kingdom Hearts: Why Is Sora So Special?
Excluding Luxu wasn’t by accident. In order for the Master’s plan of defeating Darkness to take shape, he had to first alienate Luxu from the rest of the Foretellers. The Master tells Luxu of his plan that there will be 13 forms of Darkness, to which seven of them shall be defeated by the Foretellers. The other forms of Darkness would be left up to the future generations of Light. Confused by the notion of using the others as pawns, Luxu reluctantly proceeds with the Master’s plan. But because of the Book of Prophecies and the Gazing Eye, the Master knew Luxu would have his doubts, and that’s why he was branded the Traitor.
Once the Foretellers had achieved the status of Keyblade Master, the Master of Masters set the final phase of his plan. He elected Ira to be the leader of the Foretellers and convinced Aced to be his right-hand man. Knowing that Aced would try to wrestle command from Ira at the first sight of complacency, Ira would be forced to take action against the Darkness. Ira’s actions would set the next Keyblade War into motion, which was paramount for the Master’s plan. Ultimately, the Master’s plan worked to perfection, as the Keyblade War occurred at the hands of Xehanort and Luxu, disguised as Xigbar.
It’s believed that the Master of Masters either derived from Quadratum or he found it in his early travels. The Master of Masters described Quadratum as a “world where neither light nor darkness can be controlled” to Darkness in Daybreak Town. After the Master of Masters trains the Foretellers and appoints Ira as his successor, it’s assumed that he disappears to Quadratum.
Although the Master of Masters orchestrated the entire Kingdom Hearts story, he did it primarily from the shadows. His mere presence could be missed entirely without playing key games like Kingdom Hearts X, and when he appears at the end of Kingdom Hearts 3, he’s just a cloaked figure. But his appearance at the end of Kingdom Hearts 3, combined with the first reveal trailer of Kingdom Hearts 4 showing Quadratum, implied that the Master of Masters will continue playing a key role in the series moving forward.
NEXT: Kingdom Hearts: What Is The X-Blade?
Avery Feyrer earned a Bachelor’s Degree in Journalism from the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication at Arizona State University. He experienced working as a Web Content Editor at the local sports radio station in Arizona, before realizing his true passions were in games. Avery began writing game reviews for his website (coffeescorner.com) before becoming a regular contributor to MP1st, and now, a Staff Writer for TheGamer. You can find Avery on Twitter @CoffeeBlack_910.

source

Suzan-Lori Parks Is on Broadway, Off Broadway and Everywhere Else – The New York Times

Advertisement
Supported by
The first African American woman to win the Pulitzer Prize in drama has four shows this season. “If you can hear the world singing, it’s your job to write it down,” she said.
Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.

Suzan-Lori Parks is drawn to archways. Early on in her New York life, long before she became one of the nation’s most acclaimed playwrights, she lived above a McDonald’s on Sixth Avenue — the Golden Arches. Then she moved out by Brooklyn’s Grand Army Plaza, with its triumphal Soldiers and Sailors Memorial Arch. Now she lives in an apartment overlooking the marble monument honoring the nation’s first president at the entrance to Washington Square Park.
“It’s very symbolic,” Parks told me. “I’m always orienting myself to arches.”
Arches, of course, are gateways, portals between one world and another, and Parks is endlessly thinking about other worlds.
This season, audiences will have ample opportunity to join her.
A starry 20th-anniversary revival of “Topdog/Underdog,” her Pulitzer Prize-winning fable about two brothers, three-card monte and one troubling inheritance, is in previews on Broadway. “Sally & Tom,” a new play about Parks’s two favorite subjects, history and theater, but also about Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings, has just begun performances at the Guthrie Theater in Minneapolis. “Plays for the Plague Year,” Parks’s diaristic musings on the first year of the Covid-19 pandemic and a coincident string of deaths, including those of Black Americans killed by police officers, is to be presented next month at Joe’s Pub, with Parks onstage singing and starring. And “The Harder They Come,” her musical adaptation of the 1972 outlaw film with a reggae score, will be staged at the Public Theater early next year.
“I’m like a bard,” she said. “I want to sing the songs for the people, and have them remember who they are.”
At this point in her career, Parks, who in 2002 became the first African American woman to win the Pulitzer Prize in drama, is a revered figure, regularly described as one of the greatest contemporary playwrights.
“She occupies pretty hallowed air: She’s the one who walks among us,” said the playwright Branden Jacobs-Jenkins, who teaches playwriting and performance studies at Yale.
“She’s the reigning empress of the Black and weird in theater,” he said. “And she really is the most successful dramatist of the avant-garde working today.”
PARKS HAS BEEN TELLING STORIES since she was a child. She wrote songs. She tried writing a novel. There was a period when she made her own newspaper, called The Daily Daily, reporting on what she saw through a Vermont attic window. (She was born in Kentucky, and moved frequently because her father was in the military.)
While an undergraduate at Mount Holyoke, she had the good fortune to take a creative-writing class at nearby Hampshire College with James Baldwin, who suggested she try playwriting, and, even though she feared he was just trying to politely steer her away from prose, she did. “That’s what I’m doing still,” she said. “Trying theater.”
Her apartment is filled with evidence of a furiously busy creative life: shelves heaving with plastic crates containing thoughts on pending and possible projects; elements of a second novel marinating on a wallboard cloaked by a blanket; index cards in Ziploc bags; a laptop perched on a crate atop the dining table; lyric revisions in notebooks on a music stand by an ever-at-the-ready guitar. (She is a songwriter who occasionally performs with a band; this season’s four productions all feature music she wrote.)
“Writing, I think, is related to being kind of like a witch,” she said as she showed me around. “Writing is magical. I loved mythology, and folk tales, and I could hear them — old stories — not in a recording of something that somebody living in my presence had told me, but if you listen, you can hear organizational principles of nature, which includes the history of people, which is narrative.”
So writing is listening? “Not in a passive way,” she said. “I’m on the hunt.” By this point, she was on her feet, pantomiming the stalking stance of a wild cat, preparing to pounce. “You’re being drawn toward it, and you’re reeling it in at the same time, like a fisher.”
As she talked, she kept cutting herself off, reaching for ways to differentiate her craft. “There’s a lot of writers who have ideas, and they have an agenda, and that’s cool,” she said. “I think I’m something else.”
Digging in to the question of why she writes, she became more and more expansive, reflecting on the songlines of Indigenous Australians, which connect geography and mythology.
“We have our songlines too — we just forgot them a long time ago,” she said. “They’re encoded in all the religious texts. They’re in African folk tales. They’re in the stories that your mom or your grandmother taught you. They’re there, and I can’t get them out of my head.”
“If you can hear the world singing,” she added, “it’s your job to write it down, because that’s the calling.”
PARKS IS NOW 59, and her work has been in production for 35 years. In 1989, the first time The New York Times reviewed her work, the critic Mel Gussow declared her “the year’s most promising new playwright.” In 2018, my critic colleagues at The Times declared “Topdog/Underdog” the best American play of the previous quarter century; explaining the choice, Ben Brantley, who was then the paper’s co-chief theater critic, described Parks as “a specialist in the warping weight of American history,” and declared, “Suzan-Lori Parks has emerged as the most consistently inventive, and venturesome, American dramatist working today.”
“She is a genre in and of herself,” said the playwright James Ijames, who won this year’s Pulitzer Prize in drama for “Fat Ham.” And what is that genre? “It is formally really dazzling, in terms of how she structures the play; there is humor underpinned with horror and political satire; there’s this real thread of the blues and folkways and things that are just root Black American signifiers; it’s musical, it’s whimsical, it’s playful, and it’s dangerous — all of the stuff that’s so exciting to see onstage.”
Her early plays were experimental (“opaque,” Brantley once wrote). The recent plays have been more accessible, for which Parks makes no apologies.
“People — not you, but people — when they ask that question, they’re like, ‘Oh, so now you’re selling out! You’re getting more mainstream and you’re not being true to your roots!’” she said. “Oh, no. I’m becoming more and more and more true. Trust me on this one: I’m following the spirit, no doubt. So, yeah, ‘Plays for the Plague Year’ looks like real life, cause it is. So maybe we ought to think about what am I writing about, and if I’m true to what I’m writing about.”
Reflecting her singular stature, Parks has an unusual perch from which to work: She is a writer in residence at the Public Theater, where she receives a full-time salary and benefits. At the Public, she also conducts one of her great ongoing experiments, “Watch Me Work,” a series of events, in-person before the pandemic and online now, at which anyone can work on their own writing while she works on hers, and then they talk about creativity. Early in the pandemic, Parks held such sessions online every day.
“Her great subject,” said the Public’s artistic director, Oskar Eustis, “is freedom. It’s both what she writes about, and how she writes.”
As part of her arrangement with the Public, Parks is also an arts professor at N.Y.U., which is how she wound up across from Washington Square Park, where she lives in faculty housing with her husband, Christian Konopka, and their 11-year-old son. For years, they shared one bedroom; this summer, they finally scored an upgrade, just 70 steps down the hall (their son counted), but now with a bit more space and that archward view.
She has surrounded herself with a striking number of good-luck charms: not only the pink unicorn balance board on which she stands while typing, but also a tray of unicorn plushies; James Baldwin and Frida Kahlo votive candles; a hamsa wall hanging she picked up at a flea market; milagro hearts from Mexico; Buddha, Ganesh, rabbit and turtle figurines; and a deck of tarot cards (yes, she did a basic reading for me; I drew the high priestess card). Also: she has tattooed into one arm, three times, a yoga sutra in Sanskrit that she translated as “submit your will to the will of God.” (She calls herself a “faith-based, spiritual-based person,” and is also a longtime practitioner of Ashtanga yoga, which she does every morning, after meditation and before writing.)
“All the help I can get, baby,” she said.
THE MANY ARTIFACTS on display in her apartment include a shelf set up as a shrine to Baldwin, a dollar bill Parks collected when, feeling the need to perform, she tried busking in a subway station, and a “Black Lives Matter” placard she held at protests during the summer of 2020, when she also signed the “We See You White American Theater” petition, written by an anonymous collective, calling for changes in the industry.
“Hey, I’m angry as the next Black woman,” she said. “And yet, to get through this, we need to also listen — listen to the voice of anger, listen to the voice of love, listen to the voice of wisdom, listen to the voice of history.”
She added, “Let’s not just stand around telling people that they suck. At least where I come from, that’s not a conversation, and, at least where I come from, that’s not good dialogue.”
The tone of some of the conversation around diversity in theater is clearly a concern of hers — that’s obvious in “Plays for the Plague Year,” which, in the most recent draft, contains a playlet called “The Black Police,” in which three “Black Cops” approach a “writer,” played by Parks, and say, “We’re here to talk with you about your blackness/Why you work with who you work with.”
In our interview, Parks said she was troubled by “the policing of Black people by Black people, and not just in the arts,” adding, “we have to wake up to the ways we are policing each other to our detriment.”
“No more trauma-based writing!” she said. “These are rules. And Suzan-Lori Parks does not like to be policed. Any policing cuts me off from hearing the spirit. Sometimes the spirit sings a song of trauma. I’m not supposed to extend my hand to that spirit that is hurting because it’s no longer marketable, or because I should be only extending my hand to the spirits who are singing a song of joy? That’s not how I want to conduct my artistic life.”
She also said she is troubled by how much anger, at the Public Theater and elsewhere, has been directed at white women. “Not to say that Karen doesn’t exist. Yes, yes, yes. But it’s interesting that on our mission to dismantle the patriarchy, we sure did go after a lot of white women. If you talk about it, it’s ‘You’re supporting white supremacy.’ No, I’m not. I’m supporting nuanced conversation. And I think a lot of that got lost, and lot of times we just stayed silent when the loudest voice in the room was talking, and the loudest voice in the room is not always the voice of wisdom.”
THIS SEASON, SHE’S PIVOTING back toward the stage after a stretch of film work in which she wrote the screenplay for “The United States vs. Billie Holiday,” and was a writer, showrunner and executive producer of “Genius: Aretha,” both of which were released last year.
At the start of the pandemic, she assigned herself the project that became “Plays for the Plague Year,” writing one short play each day for 13 months. The discipline was a familiar one: In 2002, after winning the Pulitzer, she began “365 Days/365 Plays,” then she did another daily playwriting exercise during the first 100 days of the Trump presidency. The pandemic play is part personal history — how the coronavirus affected Parks and her family — and part requiem for those who died during that period, from George Floyd to Parks’s first husband. The play, like much of Parks’s work, features songs she wrote. “I was moved into other states, where I wasn’t just documenting what happened that day, but I wanted to sing,” she said.
She’s got plenty still to come — she’s still polishing “The Harder They Come,” which will feature songs by Jimmy Cliff and others, including Parks, who said the story, set in Jamaica, “really captures a beautiful people in their struggle.” She’s then hoping to turn to that second novel (a first, “Getting Mother’s Body,” was published in 2003).
She is planning a screen adaptation of “Topdog,” as well as a new segment of her Civil War drama “Father Comes Home From the Wars” (so far, three parts have been staged; she said she expects to write nine or 12). Also: she’s writing the book, music and lyrics for an Afrofuturist musical, “Jubilee,” that she’s developing with Bard College; “Jubilee,” inspired by “Treemonisha,” a Scott Joplin opera that was staged on Broadway in 1975, is about a woman who establishes a new society on the site of a former plantation.
On a recent afternoon in Minneapolis, Parks settled in behind a folding table to watch a stumble-through of “Sally & Tom,” which is being developed in association with the Public, where it is expected to be staged next fall. The work, directed by Steve H. Broadnax III, is structured as a play-within-a-play — it depicts a contemporary New York theater company in the final days of rehearsing a new play about Jefferson’s relationship with Hemings, an enslaved woman. Parks has had a longtime interest in Jefferson and Hemings, and at one point had worked on a television project about the relationship that never got made; the play, she said, is not a straight historical drama, but “about how the world is made, and how we live in this country.”
The protagonist is a playwright who, like Parks, is warm but exacting, and is rewriting and restructuring the show as opening night nears. When I asked Joseph Haj, the Guthrie’s artistic director, how much he thought the play was about Parks, he at first shrugged it off, saying artists are always present in their work. After the run-through, he grabbed me to amend his remarks. “I take back everything I said,” he said. “I see her all over this.”
Kristen Ariza, who is playing the playwright as well as Hemings (the fictional playwright stars in her own play) said “the play is full of humor, until it’s not.”
“It feels so meta, because we’re doing the play, within the play, and we’re doing all these things like within the play,” she said. “She’s constantly questioning, ‘Does this fit? Is it working? Is it flowing correctly? She’s hearing our voices and adding things and making things work better as we go.”
A few days later, Parks was in Times Square, watching an invited dress rehearsal for “Topdog/Underdog.” The set is draped in a floor-to-ceiling gold-dipped American flag, meant, the director, Kenny Leon, told me, to reflect the way commerce infuses the culture.
Two actors who have enjoyed success onscreen, Corey Hawkins (“In the Heights”) and Yahya Abdul-Mateen II (“Watchmen,” “Aquaman”), play the story’s brothers, mischievously named Lincoln and Booth. They share a shabby apartment; Lincoln, fatefully, works as a Lincoln impersonator at an amusement park where patrons pretend to assassinate him, while Booth makes ends meet by shoplifting. Their relationship to each other, to truth-telling, and to their shared history is at the heart of the story.
Both actors encountered the play as undergraduates; Hawkins was a stagehand on a production at Juilliard, and Abdul-Mateen read a few scenes as Booth while at Berkeley. “It’s the first piece of material that I ever performed on a stage that I felt like was written for someone like me,” Abdul-Mateen said.
Like many people I spoke with, Abdul-Mateen was particularly struck by Parks’s ear for dialogue. “It’s as if she eavesdropped on these two characters,” he said, “and just wrote everything down as she heard it.”
Hawkins called the play “an ode to young Black men who don’t always get to live out loud.” And he is embracing that opportunity — one night, he called Parks at 2 a.m. to discuss a section of the play; she has also helped him learn the guitar, which he had not played before getting this role. “There’s something very grounding about that peace that she carries,” he said. “When she walks in the room, she carries the ancestors, the people we’re trying to honor, with her.”
Shortly after we hung up, my phone rang: Hawkins again, this time with a reverential plea. “Make us proud, man,” he said. “She’s a national treasure for us.”
Advertisement

source

Russia-Ukraine war: Russians flee Lyman as Ukrainian troops retake city a day after Putin’s illegal annexation – as it happened – The Guardian

Russian defence ministry says troops have withdrawn amid ‘threat of encirclement’
Russian troops have pulled out of the town of the strategic city of Lyman in eastern Ukraine “due to the risk to be encircled” and moved to “more advantageous frontiers”, Russia’s ministry of defence said via Telegram on Saturday.
Ukraine forces encircled Russian forces in the eastern town earlier on Saturday where Russia’s forces at Lyman totalled about 5,000 to 5,500 soldiers. Ukrainian soldiers were later seen raising the nation’s flag before the entrance sign to the city.
The retreat comes a day after Vladimir Putin signed “accession treaties” formalising Russia’s illegal annexation of four occupied regions in Ukraine, marking the largest forcible takeover of territory in Europe since the second world war.
Serhii Cherevatyi, spokesperson for Ukraine’s eastern forces, previously said:

Lyman is important because it is the next step towards the liberation of the Ukrainian Donbas. It is an opportunity to go further to Kreminna and Sievierodonetsk, and it is psychologically very important.
It’s slightly past 11pm in Kyiv. Here’s where things stand:
Germany’s defence minister, Christine Lambrecht, made a surprise visit to Ukraine on Saturday, her first since Russia’s invasion in February as Kyiv urges Berlin to send it battle tanks. Lambrecht visited the southern port city of Odesa, the German defence ministry said, without saying how long the trip had lasted. It added on Twitter that she had met her Ukrainian counterpart, Oleksii Reznikov.
The Nord Stream 2 pipeline is no longer leaking under the Baltic Sea because an equilibrium has been reached between the gas and water pressure. “The water pressure has more or less closed the pipeline so that the gas which is inside can’t go out,” Nord Stream 2 spokesman Ulrich Lissek told AFP.
Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy, said fighting was continuing in the key town of Lyman, which Russia said earlier in the day its troops had abandoned to avoid being trapped. “The Ukrainian flag is already in Lyman in the Donetsk region. Fighting is still going on there,” Zelenskiy said in his nightly video address.
Belarus is preparing to receive Russian soldiers and equipment, the Kyiv Independent reports. There are currently around 1,000 Russian soldiers in the country.
Yuliya Kovaliv, Ukraine’s ambassador to Canada, said her country holds Russia to account for violating Ukraine’s sovereign airspace by bombing airports, which goes against the 1944 agreement that set out core principles for global aviation. “It is important that all the ICAO members addressed such a drastic breach of the Chicago Convention,” she told Reuters.
After Russia failed to win enough votes for re-election to the United Nation’s aviation agency’s governing council, the French representative told the assembly: “When we have votes in our countries, if we don’t like the result, we don’t ask for another vote.” Russia had a place on ICAO’s 36-member council as one of the “states of chief importance in air transport”. Other members include the G7 countries, China, Brazil and Australia.
Liz Truss has said a series of explosions that severely damaged Russia’s undersea Nord Stream gas pipelines were an act of sabotage. In a joint report delivered to the United Nations last week, the Danish and Swedish governments have claimed that the leaks in the Nord Stream gas pipelines, which can carry gas to Germany, were caused by blasts equivalent to the power of “several hundred kilograms of explosive.”
Ramzan Kadyrov, head of Russia’s region of Chechnya, said Moscow should consider using a low-yield nuclear weapon in Ukraine after a major new defeat on the battlefield. In a message on Telegram addressing Russia’s loss of its stronghold of Lyman in eastern Ukraine, Kadyrov wrote: “In my personal opinion, more drastic measures should be taken, right up to the declaration of martial law in the border areas and the use of low-yield nuclear weapons.”
Germany’s defence minister Christine Lambrecht made a surprise visit to Ukraine on Saturday, her first since Russia’s invasion in February as Kyiv urges Berlin to send it battle tanks, Agence France-Presse reports.
Lambrecht visited the southern port city of Odesa, the German defence ministry said in a statement, without saying how long the trip had lasted. It added on Twitter that she had met her Ukrainian counterpart, Oleksii Reznikov.
+++NEWS+++ Verteidigungsministerin Lambrecht traf heute in der Ukraine ihren Amtskollegen @oleksiireznikov. Wir unterstützen unsere Freunde solange es nötig ist. 🇩🇪🤝🇺🇦 pic.twitter.com/wOBGgV2skS
So far, no Nato country has supplied western battle tanks to Kyiv, despite Ukraine repeatedly asking for Germany to supply it with Leopard battle tanks to assist in its counter-attack against Russia.
Chancellor Olaf Scholz has said he doesn’t want to go it alone on arms supplies and will only take decisions in consultation with his western allies. Berlin has instead struck deals with third countries, which transfer heavy weapons to Ukraine – in exchange for receiving supplies from Germany.
Lambrecht’s visit came a day after the Russian president, Vladimir Putin, declared the annexation of the Ukrainian regions of Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia and Kherson.
These annexations have been unanimously condemned by Ukraine’s allies.
The Nord Stream 2 pipeline is no longer leaking under the Baltic Sea because an equilibrium has been reached between the gas and water pressure, Agence France-Presse reports.

“The water pressure has more or less closed the pipeline so that the gas which is inside can’t go out,” Nord Stream 2 spokesman Ulrich Lissek told AFP.
“The conclusion is that there is still gas in the pipeline,” he added.
When asked how much gas was believed to be in the pipeline, Lissek said: “That is the one-million-dollar question.”
Information on the status of the Nord Stream 1 pipeline leak, which was significantly larger, was not immediately available.
While the pipelines are not currently in operation, they both still contained gas before they fell victim to apparent sabotage, producing four leaks.
Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskiy on Saturday said fighting was continuing in the key town of Lyman, which Russia said earlier in the day its troops had abandoned to avoid being trapped.

“The Ukrainian flag is already in Lyman in the Donetsk region. Fighting is still going on there,” Zelenskiy said in his nightly video address.
Belarus is preparing to receive Russian soldiers and equipment, the Kyiv Independent reports.
⚡️Ukraine intelligence: Belarus prepares to receive Russian soldiers, equipment.

Defense Ministry’s Intelligence Directorate confirmed that Belarus is preparing to welcome up to 20,000 Russian soldiers.

There are currently about 1,000 Russian soldiers in Belarus.
On Russia’s failure to win enough votes for re-election to the United Nations’ aviation agency’s governing council, Yuliya Kovaliv, Ukraine’s ambassador to Canada, said her country holds Russia to account for violating Ukraine’s sovereign airspace by bombing airports, which goes against the 1944 agreement that set out core principles for global aviation.
“It is important that all the ICAO members addressed such a drastic breach of the Chicago Convention,” she told Reuters.
It took Alina three goes at the local conscription centre to get her husband out of Russia’s war in Ukraine.
She knew the local officials managing the mobilisation in her town south of Makhachkala, the capital of Dagestan, she said. So when her husband, who has health problems because of his weight and served in the army more than 15 years ago, was called up, she began hassling them to review his case.
“I told them: ‘What war?’ Have they gone crazy?’ And the top [official] just gave me this sad look,” she said.
But as protests broke out last week in Dagestan and anger grew over the conscription, she said, something changed. Suddenly, they told her that her husband’s call-up was a mistake.
After Russia failed to win enough votes for re-election to the United Nation’s aviation agency’s governing council, the French representative told the assembly: “When we have votes in our countries, if we don’t like the result, we don’t ask for another vote.”
Russia, along with the G7, China, Brazil and Australia, held spots as “states of chief importance in air transport” on ICAO’s 36-member council.
“We’d like to express regret regarding the outcome of the voting,” the Russian representative said.
“We view this as a purely political step and has nothing to do with Russia’s position in the field of civil aviation.”
Russia closed its airspace to airlines from 36 countries, including all 27 members of the European Union, in response to Ukraine-related sanctions targeting its aviation sector following Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine, Reuters reported.
Ukraine’s minister for foreign affairs, Dmytro Kuleba, has thanked the US for its latest assistance package.
In today’s call with @SecBlinken, I thanked the U.S. for its unfaltering support, including the latest $12.35 bln in new security and budgetary assistance. Secretary assured that regardless of any Putin’s illegal steps, the U.S. will keep supporting Ukraine in our just struggle.
Here is some more background on Ramzan Kadyrov’s comments that Moscow should consider using a low-yield nuclear weapon in Ukraine after a major new defeat on the battlefield.
Russia has the world’s largest atomic arsenal, including low-yield tactical nuclear weapons that are designed to be deployed against opposing armies.
Other top Putin allies, including former president Dmitry Medvedev, have suggested that Russia may need to resort to nuclear weapons, but Kadyrov’s call was the most urgent and explicit, Reuters reports.
The influential ruler of the Caucasus region of Chechnya has been a vocal champion of the war in Ukraine, with Chechen forces forming part of the vanguard of the Russian army there. Kadyrov is widely believed to be personally close to Putin, who appointed him to govern restive Chechnya in 2007.
In his message, Kadyrov described Colonel-General Alexander Lapin, commander of the Russian forces fighting at Lyman, as a “mediocrity”, and suggested that he should be demoted to private and stripped of his medals.
“Due to a lack of elementary military logistics, today we have abandoned several settlements and a large piece of territory,” he said.
Kadyrov said that two weeks before he had raised the possibility of a defeat at Lyman with Valery Gerasimov, chief of Russia’s general staff, but that Gerasimov had dismissed the idea.
Liz Truss has said a series of explosions that severely damaged Russia’s undersea Nord Stream gas pipelines were an act of sabotage.
In a joint report delivered to the United Nations last week, the Danish and Swedish governments have claimed that the leaks in the Nord Stream gas pipelines, which can carry gas to Germany, were caused by blasts equivalent to the power of “several hundred kilograms of explosive”.
The UK prime minister was updated on developments in the situation unfolding in the Baltic Sea as she engaged in talks with her Danish counterpart, Mette Frederiksen, in Downing Street on Saturday.
Suspicions have been rising in western capitals that the explosions on the pipelines were attacks carried out by Russia as a means of intensifying pressure in western governments over energy supplies. Russia’s President Vladimir Putin has dismissed any such claims and said in a speech on Friday that “Anglo Saxons” were responsible.
Ramzan Kadyrov, head of Russia’s region of Chechnya, said Moscow should consider using a low-yield nuclear weapon in Ukraine after a major new defeat on the battlefield.
In a message on Telegram addressing Russia’s loss of its stronghold of Lyman in eastern Ukraine, Kadyrov wrote: “In my personal opinion, more drastic measures should be taken, right up to the declaration of martial law in the border areas and the use of low-yield nuclear weapons”.
Kadyrov was speaking a day after President Vladimir Putin proclaimed the annexation of four Ukrainian regions – including Donetsk, where Lyman is located – and placed them under Russia’s nuclear umbrella, saying Moscow would defend the lands it had seized “with all our strength and all our means”, Reuters reports.

source

Printability and microstructure of directed energy deposited SS316l-IN718 multi-material: numerical modeling and experimental analysis | Scientific Reports – Nature.com

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 16600 (2022)
Metrics details
In the present paper, the interrelated aspects of additive manufacturing-microstructure-property in directed energy deposition of SS316L-IN718 multi-material were studied through numerical modeling and experimental evaluation. The printability concept and solidification principles were used for this purpose. The printability analysis showed that the SS316L section is more susceptible to composition change and lack of fusion, respectively due to the high equilibrium vapor pressure of manganese and the more efficient heat loss in the initial layers. However, the IN718 section is more prone to distortion due to the formation of a larger melt pool, with a maximum thermal strain of 3.95 × 10−3 in the last layer. As the process continues, due to heat accumulation and extension of the melt pool, the cooling rate decreases and the undercooling level increases, which respectively result in coarser microstructure and more instability of solidification front in the build direction, as also observed in the experimental results. The difference is that the dendritic microstructure of the IN718 section, due to the eutectic reaction L → γ + Laves, is formed on a smaller scale compared to the cellular microstructure of the SS316L section. Also, the decrease in cooling rate caused the secondary phase fraction in each section (delta ferrite in SS316L and Laves in IN718) to increase almost linearly. However, the hardness calculation and measurement showed similarly, even though with the transition from SS316L to IN718 the hardness is significantly increased due to higher yield strength of the matrix and the presence of Laves intermetallic phase (~ 260 HV0.3), the hardness in each section decreases slightly due to the coarsening of the microstructure from the initial layer to the final.
Nowadays, many engineering structures are made up of multiple materials. This is because meeting various service and performance requirements can hardly be satisfied by one material. Therefore, it is often necessary to use dissimilar materials together. This has led to the generalization of the concept of “multi-material structures” in the engineering sciences. Hence, the role of multi-material structures has been proven and many studies have been done on them in the past. Nevertheless, the evolution of modern additive manufacturing (AM) technology, with distinct advantages such as the ability to produce integrated near net shape complex parts in one step, cost-effectiveness for small-scale production, and high-level customization, has eliminated many of the limitations of conventional manufacturing methods and opened up new dimensions to the development and research of multi-materials1,2. From the subset of metal additive manufacturing processes as the fastest growing sector of AM today3, the directed energy deposition (DED) and the powder bed fusion (PBF) are both of interest in the fabrication of multi-materials. However, DED has become more popular due to its greater flexibility in changing chemical composition during processing4. According to the studies conducted so far, metallic multi-materials processed by DED can be classified based on the type of alloy (mainly Ti, Fe, and Ni alloys) and build strategy (bimetallic, functionally graded, and hybrid materials)5.
Stainless steels/nickel-based superalloys multi-materials are of the most widely used combinations in critical energy industries due to their cost-performance balance tailored to service requirements6. Therefore, given this issue and the inherent characteristics of AM, some of which were mentioned above, various research studies have been done on the additive manufacturing of this type of multi-material in recent years. Lin et al.7,8 studied the microstructure evolution and phase formation in laser rapid forming (LRF) of SS316L/Rene88DT graded material. Shah et al.9 investigated the effect of laser direct metal deposition (LDMD) parameters on the development of SS316L/IN718 graded structure. Savitha et al.10 in a study on additive manufacturing of SS316/IN625 dual materials observed that the yield strength is always comparable to the weaker component (SS316), while Zhang et al.11 in a similar study obtained the yield strength and tensile strength of gradient samples close to IN625 and SS316L, respectively. Carroll et al.12 in determining the cause of cracking in a graded structure fabricated from SS304L and IN625 by DED, demonstrated the role of metal monocarbides in the form of (Mo, Nb)C using thermodynamic modeling by CALculation of PHAse Diagrams (CALPHAD) method. Su et al.13 investigated the effect of various gradient composition in laser additive manufacturing of SS316L/IN718 functionally graded material. They reported that the best combination of mechanical properties (tensile strength of 527.05 MPa and elongation of 26.21%) were obtained with a composition change step of 10%. In another study, Kim et al.14 observed that the formation of defects (pores and cracks) occurs in certain chemical composition ranges of the SS316L/IN718 structure affected by ceramic oxides and their subsequent propagation in the direction of intermetallic and carbide compounds. Moreover, thermal and residual stresses concentrated at the grain boundaries exacerbated the formation of these defects.
An overview of previous studies suggests that most of the efforts have been focused on the experimental study of one aspect of the processing, structure, and properties (materials paradigm) of stainless steel/nickel-based superalloys multi-material. However, given the importance of all the interrelated aspects of the materials paradigm, a comprehensive understanding and the possibility of predicting them in the additive manufacturing of multi-materials can lead to a better framework for controlling them. In addition, the numerical approach can provide a smoother path to achieve that by reducing the time and cost spent on various experiments. Therefore, in the present study, the concept of printability was used through finite element modeling to investigate processing challenges of 316 low carbon stainless steel (SS316L)-Inconel 718 (IN718) multi-material by DED. Also, solidification principles were applied by the modeling results to evaluate the microstructure characteristics and estimate the properties of the multi-material. Besides, experimental studies have been used to better support and analyze numerical results.
In the numerical study, heat transfer modeling during the manufacturing process of multi-material structure, consisting of 7 layers of SS316L alloy and 7 layers of IN718 alloy, was performed by the finite element method (FEM). First, the geometry of a single layer deposition (Fig. 1a) was modeled and after finding the appropriate mesh size, the modeling procedure was repeated using the element birth and death technique for the subsequent layers until the design was completed. It is worth noting that the surfaces of the deposited layers were assumed flat for simplification. The governing equation of the problem (transient heat transfer) can be expressed as follows:
where (x), (y), and (z) are the transverse, building, and laser scanning directions, respectively, and k is the thermal conductivity, (T) is the temperature, (rho ) is the density, ({C}_{p}) is the specific heat, (t) is the time, and (dot{Q}) is the rate of internal heat generation (here by phase change). Also, the matrix form of the differential Eq. (1) can be written as follows:
where, (left[Lright]) and (left[Dright]) are the vector differential operator and conduction coefficient matrices, respectively, which are expressed as:
(a) The geometry of the single-layer deposition (mm). The deposition thickness was considered 0.8 mm according to the results obtained in experimental evaluations. (b) The double ellipsoidal heat source model and its parameters.
The initial and boundary conditions are expressed in Eqs. (5) and (6), respectively:
where ({T}_{a}) is the ambient temperature (298 K), (n) is surface normal, ({h}_{c}) is convection coefficient, (sigma ) is the Stephen–Boltzmann constant, (varepsilon ) is emissivity and (q) is the heat flux generated by the laser beam. Obviously, for surfaces other than those irradiated by the laser beam, the amount of heat flux ((q)) is zero in Eq. (6) and also the heat loss due to radiation (third term) can be ignored. It should be noted that for convenience and to avoid non-linearization due to the radiation heat loss, the third term in Eq. (6) was removed, and instead of ({h}_{c}) a previously developed effective heat transfer coefficient ((h))15 was used, which is a combination of both:
where the units of (h), and (T) are W/m2 K and K, respectively.
Also, to model the laser heat source, owing to the necessity of using the laser conduction mode in the AM process and the experimental observation of the melt pool geometry in the cross-section, a double ellipsoidal power density distribution was considered as shown in Fig. 1b16. In this model, the power density distribution in the front and rear quadrants are defined by the following equations, respectively:
where (Q) is the effective laser power (W), (v) is the scanning velocity (m/s), and (a), (b), ({c}_{1}), and ({c}_{2}) are independent values in determining how the heat flux is distributed. ({f}_{f}) and ({f}_{r}) are the heat fractions for the front and rear quadrants, respectively, with a relation of ({f}_{f}) + ({f}_{r}) = 2 between them.
In this study, the FEM software ABAQUS v. 6.14 was employed to solve the governing heat transfer equation. To increase the solution accuracy, the thermophysical properties as a function of temperature for SS316L and IN718 alloys were extracted from Refs.17,18, respectively, and defined in the software. Also, to take into account the heat transfer due to fluid flow in the melt pool, it was assumed that the thermal conductivity of materials above the solidus temperature up to 3000 K increases linearly with a factor of about three19. Figure 2 shows the mesh system consisting of DC3D8 hexahedral elements used for the final model after the mesh sensitivity analysis. It should be noted that due to the geometric symmetry, only half of it (longitudinal section) was modeled to reduce the calculations. Also, since there is a high thermal gradient in the deposition path, finer meshes were used in that area, as shown in Fig. 2. Finally, 191,808 elements and 226,820 nodes were used for the modeling. Besides, The ABAQUS user subroutine DFLUX was utilized to apply the laser heat flux according to the double ellipsoidal distribution model (Eqs. 8, 9) as a function of the location and time.
The mesh system used for the final model (14-layer structure).
SS316L and IN718 gas-atomized powders with average diameters of 110 and 70 µm, respectively, and SS316L substrate with dimensions of 40 × 40 × 5 mm were used as raw materials. The chemical compositions of the powders are presented in Table 1. A DED additive manufacturing machine with specifications of 1 kW continuous-wave fiber laser of 1080 nm wavelength and ~ 1 mm spot diameter (YFL-1000 model, National Laser Center of Iran), four-channel nozzle delivering powder coaxial with the laser beam, twin powder feeder (model PF 200, Noura, Iran), carrier and shielding Ar gas, and CNC table with 3 degrees of freedom, was employed to fabricate the multi-material sample.
The multi-material structure was fabricated according to Fig. 3a as a unidirectional thin-wall consisting of 7 layers of SS316L and 7 layers of IN718 under the processing parameters presented in Table 2. To validate the FE model, the thermal history (temperature–time diagram) was recorded during the process using a K-type thermocouple (Fig. 3b) embedded in the middle and below the deposition path. The results were compared with the thermal history obtained from the corresponding location in the simulated model. Figure 4 shows the SS316L-IN718 multi-material structure fabricated according to the design shown in Fig. 3a.
(a) Schematic of the multi-material structure (the thermocouple location: in the middle of the laser scanning/deposition path and 1 mm below the substrate surface). (b) Thermocouple and data logger used to measure temperature during the process.
(a) Front view and (b) side view of the SS316L-IN718 multi-material structure fabricated according to Fig. 3a.
To study the metallurgical features of the multi-material, a cross-section was cut from the mid-length of the structure using an electric discharge machine (EDM) and after preparing its surface by standard metallographic methods, it was etched by holding in 15 mL HCl + 5 mL HNO3 solution for 10 s. The optical microscopy (Olympus, Japan) and scanning electron microscopy (FEI ESEM QUANTA 200, USA) were used to qualitatively evaluate the microstructure and quantify its characteristics by ImageJ software. Also, a semi-quantitative evaluation of the constituent elements distribution and the composition of possible phases in the microstructure was performed by an X-ray dispersive energy spectroscope (EDAX EDS Silicon Drift 2017, USA) used in the SEM. The hardness variations in the build direction were measured using a Vickers microhardness tester (Buehler, Japan) on the prepared section at intervals of every 500 µm with a 300 gf load and a dwell time of 10 s. As well, three microhardness measurements were taken at each height of the structure and the mean value was reported to minimize the measurement error.
The concept of printability is the ability of an alloy to resist distortion, chemical composition changes, and lack of fusion as common defects in the additive manufacturing of metal parts20. Similar to the universal concept of weldability in the science of welding metallurgy21, the development of printability can facilitate the challenging selection of the printing process and its parameters for the desired alloy(s) by establishing a comprehensive database and reducing the risk of common defects without additional cost and time22. In this section, after validating the FE model and presenting the initial results, the distortion, chemical composition changes, and lack of fusion defects will be examined for the multi-material.
Figure 5 shows a comparison of the thermal histories obtained from the thermal model and measured by the thermocouple in the same location (in the middle of the deposition length and 1 mm below the substrate surface). As can be seen, the acceptable difference between the numerical and experimental results indicates the proper accuracy of the thermal model, and therefore other results that can be derived from it can be trusted. Figure 6 shows the longitudinal section of simulated melt pools for even layers in the SS316L-IN718 multi-material structure. What can be understood is that as the process progresses, the melt pool size, the extent of re-melting of the previously deposited layers, and the peak temperature increase, which is to be expected given the physics of the problem. The mentioned phenomena can be attributed to two factors: (a) reducing the heat sink effect by the substrate as the process progresses (heat accumulation) and (b) the difference in thermal properties of the base alloys, such as a certain difference in their solidification temperature ranges (SS316L: 1460–1420 ℃ and IN718: 1336–1260 ℃). What is important is the influence of these factors on the printability indicators and the microstructural aspects of the multi-material, which are discussed in this section and the next section, respectively.
Comparison of thermal histories obtained from the FE model (red) and experimental measurements (blue) at the same location.
Temperature field (℃) and the simulated melt pool (gray zone) in the mid-length of layers (a) 2, (b) 4, (c) 6, (d) 8, (e) 10, and (f) 12.
Thermal distortion during the process depends on the alloy properties and the process parameters. The tendency to distortion can be calculated using the maximum thermal strain criterion. Recently, a non-dimensional thermal strain parameter, ({varepsilon }^{*}) (representative of the maximum thermal strain), as a function of alloy properties and process parameters has been developed based on Buckingham’s π-theorem20:
where (beta ) is the volume expansion coefficient, (Delta T) is the difference between peak temperature and ambient temperature, (t) is the deposition time, (H) is the heat input per unit length, (EI) is the flexural rigidity, and (rho ) is the alloy density. The Fourier number (F), which represents the ratio of heat transfer to heat accumulation, can also be rewritten as (alpha /vw), where (alpha ) is the thermal diffusion coefficient, (v) is the beam scanning velocity, and (w) is the length of the melt pool. As can be seen in Fig. 7, with increasing number of layers, the thermal strain generally increases due to the weakening of heat transfer from the melt pool to the substrate and consequently the higher temperature difference ((Delta T)). More importantly, by changing the material from SS316L to IN718, the increase in thermal strain is more noticeable and accompanied by a mutation, the reason for which can be traced to the difference in properties of the two alloys. As mentioned earlier, the IN718 alloy with a lower solidification temperature range results in a larger melt pool (compare Fig. 6d–f to (a–c)). In other words, with a completely different increase in melt pool length ((w)), the much smaller Fourier number ((F)) is placed in Eq. (10). Therefore, a higher thermal strain is accumulated the IN718 section of the multi-material structure. This indicates that the IN718 section is more sensitive to thermal strain and should be given priority in adjusting the AM process parameters to reduce thermal strain based on Eq. (10).
Thermal strain parameter (({varepsilon }^{*})) variations in different layers of multi-material structure.
Since some alloying elements have higher vapor pressure than others, selective vaporization of alloying elements in AM is highly probable which can lead to a considerable change in the chemical composition of the alloy and thus a decrease in its properties such as strength, hardness, and corrosion resistance. The Langmuir equation can be used to estimate the vaporization fluxes of alloying elements, ({J}_{i})20:
where ({P}_{i}) is the vapor pressure of element (i) over the alloy, ({M}_{i}) is the molecular weight of element (i), (R) is the gas constant, (T) is the temperature, and (lambda ) (= 0.05) is a positive fraction related to the condensation of vaporized atoms. Also, the following equation can be used to calculate the amount of vaporized material, (Delta {m}_{i}):
where (v) is the beam scanning velocity, (L) is the deposition length, and ({A}_{s}) is the surface area of the melt pool. Given the volume of deposited material ((V)), the weight percentage of element (i) after vaporization (({W}_{f})) can be obtained by Eq. (13):
where (rho ) is the density and ({W}_{i}) is the initial weight percentage of element (i) in the powder. Figure 8 shows the composition change of the most volatile alloying elements (Mn in SS316L and Cr in IN718) in different layers of the multi-material structure due to vaporization during the DED process. In each section, as the number of layers increases, the loss of alloying elements by vaporization increases due to the higher peak temperature. However, despite higher temperatures experienced in the upper section of the multi-material (i.e. IN718), the composition change in the SS316L section is more severe for the Mn element due to its higher equilibrium vapor pressure. It can be concluded that in the multi-material structure, the SS316L section is more susceptible to composition change, and to minimize it, it should be given priority in controlling the process parameters according to Eq. (13).
Composition change due to vaporization for elements with the highest vapor pressure in different layers of the multi-material structure.
Although the penetration depth is affected by the processing conditions, different alloys in the same processing conditions show different penetration depths due to their unique thermophysical properties, which indicates different susceptibility of each to lack of fusion defect. The sufficient fusion and proper interlayer bonding can be measured by the simple index of lack of fusion, (LF)20:
where (d) is the penetration depth of the melt pool, and (h) is the thickness of the deposited layer. To get a proper bonding between the layers, the penetration depth must be always greater or equal to the layer thickness or in other words LF must be greater or equal to 1. Increasing the dimensions of the melt pool in the upper layers of the multi-material, which can be seen in Fig. 9a by the two indicators of length and depth of the melt pool, reduces the probability of lack of fusion. Therefore, as Fig. 9b shows, the lack of fusion index ((LF)) has an increasing trend with increasing the number of layers due to heat accumulation, and more specifically, in the transition from SS316L to IN718, this trend is distinguished by a greater slope due to the lower solidification temperature range of IN718. In other words, in the SS316L section and especially in the initial layers, lack of fusion defect is more likely to occur, resulting in inadequate bonding between the layers. Therefore, this section of the multi-material structure plays a decisive role in adjusting the process parameters according to Eq. (14) to achieve an integrated structure without lack of fusion.
The variations of (a) the length and depth of the melt pool and (b) the (LF) index in the build direction.
Figure 10a shows the thermal cycles in the mid-length of layers 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, and 14. The thermal cycles are unique to each layer (such in terms of peak temperature and reheating times), which can play an important role in determining the features of the layers, especially in the micro scale. To compare and discuss better, the time derivative of the temperature for each thermal cycle (as in Fig. 10b for the thermal cycle of layer 2) was used to obtain quantitative indicators, such as cooling rate.
(a) Thermal cycles in the middle position of the lengths of layers 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, and 14. (b) The first-order derivative of temperature with respect to time for the thermal cycle of layer 2 in (a).
Figure 11a shows the average cooling rate in the solidification range for each layer. As expected, as the height of structure increases, the cooling rate decreases in the build direction due to heat accumulation and extension of the melt pool. As well, the changes in the cellular/dendritic arm spacing (lambda ) (µm) can be anticipated according to the average cooling rate in each layer using the following equation:
where (CR) is the cooling rate (K/s), and (b) and (n) are the material constants with values of 80 and 0.33 for stainless steel and 39.8 and 0.3 for nickel-based superalloy, respectively23. As shown in Fig. 11b, consistent with the results obtained from the micrographs of corresponding layers (Fig. 12), the microstructure size (i.e. cellular/dendritic arm spacing, (lambda )), in both SS316L and IN718 sections increased independently from one layer to another in the build direction, due to the reduction of cooling rate and as a result more time for growth. However, due to the occurrence of the eutectic reaction L → γ + Laves in the IN718 section (Fig. 12d–f), which will be further explained, a finer microstructure was formed in layers 8–14, despite following the above-mentioned trend. It is also noteworthy that in previous similar studies, a very fine microstructure in the range of 3–10 microns has been observed23,24.
The variations of (a) the cooling rate in the solidification range and (b) the microstructure size (i.e. cellular/dendritic arm spacing, (lambda )) in the build direction.
The cross-section microstructure of SS316L layers: (a) 2, (b) 4, (c) 6 and IN718 layers: (d) 8, (e) 10, and (f) 12. The numbered arrows show the different contrasts selected for EDS analysis and the possible phases.
On the other hand, by determining the temperature gradient ((G)) through the numerical model for each layer in the build direction and having the cooling rate in the relevant position, the advancing velocity of the solidification front or solidification rate ((R)) can also be calculated for each layer ((CR=Gcdot R)). Figure 13a shows that in the upper layers the temperature gradient decreases, and the solidification rate increases due to heat accumulation. Such changes along the structure height, by decreasing the (G/R) ratio (Fig. 13b) can lead to an increase in undercooling and therefore more instability of the solidification front according to the following inequality25:
where ({m}_{L}), ({C}_{s}^{*}), ({k}_{0}), and ({D}_{L}) are the slope of the liquidus line, the solid composition at the interface, the distribution coefficient, and the diffusion coefficient in the melt, respectively. Although thermodynamic calculations can make a more accurate assessment, by changing the material to IN718 rich in various alloying elements, especially with low distribution coefficients (molybdenum and niobium), the ({C}_{s}^{*}) and ({k}_{0}) variables on the right side of inequality (16) increase and decrease respectively, both of which, in addition to the decrease in the (G/R) ratio, cause further instability of the solidification front according to the inequality. As can be realized by comparing the micrographs presented in Fig. 10, the solidification morphology in layers 1–7 (SS316L section) is cellular and in layers 8–14 (IN718 section) is dendritic. However, at the almost defect-free interface of adjacent layers, as shown in Fig. 14a,b for the interface between layers 7 and 8, a planar solidification is observed in a short distance less than 10 µm. It is contrary to the general rule, which can be due to more local temperature gradient at the interface of two adjacent layers than the internal areas of each layer. It is also noteworthy here that the dilution effect between adjacent layers has led to a slight deviation from the primary multi-material design, and the formation of a transition zone and a kind of gradation at the interface of the two alloys, which can be observed by EDS line analysis in Fig. 14c and as reported in some previous studies10,11.
The variations of (a) temperature gradient ((G)) and solidification rate ((R)) and (b) undercooling ((G/R)) in the build direction.
(a) Optical microstructure of the interface between layers 7 and 8. (b) SEM micrograph of the area specified in (a). The distance between the two dashed lines in (b) shows the range of planar solidification. (c) EDS line analysis along the specified path in (b) showing the transition zone at the interface.
Another characteristic feature of the microstructure of each layer is its chemical distribution and phase composition. Figure 15 shows a set of EDS analysis results from areas with different contrasts in the microstructures presented in Fig. 12 (numbered arrows). Considering the results and matching them with previous studies26,27, the multi-material microstructure in the SS316L section mostly consists of austenite phase and a small amount of the delta ferrite phase (δ) in the intercellular regions (Fig. 15a,b, respectively). Also, in the IN718 section, the microstructure consists of the gamma matrix phase (γ) and the intermetallic compound of Laves in the interdendritic regions (Fig. 15c,d, respectively). In fact, during non-equilibrium solidification in both sections, elements with lower distribution coefficients (Cr, Mo, and Si in SS316L and Nb, Mo, Si, and Ti in IN718) were segregated in the intercellular/dendritic regions, and by providing the necessary driving force, have led to the nucleation and growth of the mentioned secondary phases in the final stages of solidification. However, the size and distribution of the secondary phases are not uniform due to different cooling rates during solidification in different layers. As can be seen in Fig. 16, fraction of ferrite and Laves phases in layers 2–6 and 8–12, respectively, increased almost linearly with decreasing cooling rate. This is because by reducing the cooling rate, more time is provided for the diffusion of alloying elements and thus their microsegregation. It should be noted that the thermal cycles caused by the deposition of subsequent layers do not have a significant effect on the secondary phases resulting from solidification through solid-state diffusion, because the necessary temperature and time are not provided to modify or dissolve them28.
The results of chemical analysis and possible phases from the tip position the of arrows (a) 1 and (b) 2 in Fig. 12c and arrows (c) 3 and (d) 4 in Fig. 12f.
Variations in the fraction of ferrite and Laves phases with the cooling rate (during solidification) in different layers and the linear regression analysis of each.
It is possible to predict the hardness distribution along the structure using the thermal analysis results and the following relationships:
where in Eq. (17), known as the Hall–Patch relationship, ({sigma }_{y}), ({sigma }_{0}), (k), and ({d}_{g}) are the yield stress (MPa), friction stress (MPa), locking parameter (Mpa µm−1/2), and grain size (µm), respectively. There is no doubt that the grain size is different from the cell/dendrite size of the solidification structure, but for the additive manufactured samples, good compatibility has been observed in the Hall-Patch relationship when grain size (({d}_{g})) is replaced with cell/dendrite size (λ)24. Therefore, the cell/dendrite size was used instead of the grain size in this prediction. The constants ({sigma }_{0}) and (k) were also considered to be 194 MPa and 695 Mpa µm-1/2 for SS316L29 and 325 MPa and 750 Mpa µm−1/2 for IN71830, respectively. In Eq. (18), (HV) and (m) are Vickers hardness (kgf/mm2) and Mayer’s index, respectively, and (m) was considered to be 2.25 for both alloys24. Figure 17 illustrates the microhardness distribution along the cross-section of the multi-material structure by experimental measurement and numerical calculation. As shown, there is a fair correlation between the results obtained from the two methods, though the influence of other strengthening mechanisms (solid solution and secondary phase strengthening) which are not directly included as independent terms in Eq. (17), can be considered as the reason for the difference between the numerical and experimental results, especially in the IN718 section. A further explanation that, in the SS316L section, despite the expected hardness drop from layers 1–7 due to the increase in microstructure size, it is almost uniform. This can be due to equal competition between the two mechanisms of hardness reduction (microstructure coarsening) and hardness increase (ferrite phase reinforcement by decreasing the cooling rate) in this section with increasing the structure height. However, with the transition to the IN718 section, the hardness increases significantly due to higher yield strength of the matrix phase and the presence of the Laves intermetallic phase, and then, it decreases slightly with the coarsening of the microstructure in layers 8–14.
Microhardness variations along the cross-section of the multi-material structure.
In this research, with the aim of comprehensive understanding and the possibility of predicting different aspects of the materials paradigm in additive manufacturing of multi-materials, the printability and microstructure evolution of SS316L-IN718 multi-material fabricated by the directed energy deposition method were studied through numerical modeling and experimental analysis. The main results are as follows:
Printability analysis of the multi-material showed that, in general, distortion and composition change defects are more pronounced with increasing the number of layers due to heat accumulation. In contrast, lack of fusion is more likely to happen in the initial layers due to more efficient heat loss through the substrate.
Due to the difference in the thermophysical properties of the base materials, the IN718 section with a maximum thermal strain of 3.95 × 10−3 in the last layer is more sensitive to distortion, and on the other side, the SS316L section with vaporization of more than 0.9% of Mn element in the sixth layer and also the lack of fusion index close to 1 in the initial layers is more susceptible to composition change and lack of fusion.
Although with the progress of the deposition process, a coarser solidification structure is formed due to the reduction of cooling rate, it was shown experimentally and numerically that the occurrence of the eutectic reaction L → γ + Laves in the IN718 section causes this rule to be discriminated by a finer microstructure in layers 8–14, despite following the general trend.
Calculation of the ratio of temperature gradient ((G)) and solidification rate ((R)) in the build direction and matching it with the relevant microstructures showed that the cellular solidification of SS316L section can be separated from the dendritic solidification of IN718 section by decreasing the (G/R) ratio (increasing undercooling) to approximately 55 K s/mm2, besides the influence of increasing the concentration of alloying elements with low distribution coefficients. However, a very narrow planar solidification mode is also visible at the interface of adjacent layers due to the higher local gradient temperature.
The fraction of secondary phases (delta ferrite in SS316L and Laves in IN718) resulting from non-equilibrium solidification in the intercellular/dendritic regions increases almost linearly (with different slopes) due to the reduction of cooling rate in the build direction of the multi-material.
The prediction and measurement of hardness in the build direction similarly showed the highest hardness in the IN718 section (~ 260 HV0.3) due to higher yield strength of the matrix and the presence of the Laves intermetallic phase. Nevertheless, the hardness variations in each multi-material section with increasing number of layers, due to microstructure coarsening (hardness reduction factor) along with secondary phase reinforcement (hardness increase factor), has been mild and somewhat decreasing.
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article.
DebRoy, T. et al. Additive manufacturing of metallic components–process, structure and properties. Prog. Mater. Sci. 92, 112–224 (2018).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Bandyopadhyay, A. & Heer, B. Additive manufacturing of multi-material structures. Mater. Sci. Eng. R. Rep. 129, 1–16 (2018).
Article  Google Scholar 
DebRoy, T. et al. Scientific, technological and economic issues in metal printing and their solutions. Nat. Mater. 18, 1026–1032 (2019).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Ghanavati, R. & Naffakh-Moosavy, H. Additive manufacturing of functionally graded metallic materials: A review of experimental and numerical studies. J. Market. Res. 13, 1628–1664 (2021).
CAS  Google Scholar 
Feenstra, D. R. et al. Critical review of the state of the art in multi-material fabrication via directed energy deposition. Curr. Opin. Solid State Mater. Sci. 25, 100924 (2021).
ADS  Article  Google Scholar 
Rodriguez, J., Hoefer, K., Haelsig, A. & Mayr, P. Functionally graded SS 316L to Ni-based structures produced by 3D plasma metal deposition. Metals. 9, 620 (2019).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Lin, X., Yue, T. M., Yang, H. O. & Huang, W. D. Laser rapid forming of SS316L/Rene88DT graded material. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 391, 325–336 (2005).
Article  Google Scholar 
Lin, X. & Yue, T. M. Phase formation and microstructure evolution in laser rapid forming of graded SS316L/Rene88DT alloy. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 402, 294–306 (2005).
Article  Google Scholar 
Shah, K. et al. Parametric study of development of Inconel-steel functionally graded materials by laser direct metal deposition. Mater. Des. 54, 531–538 (2014).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Savitha, U. et al. Chemical analysis, structure and mechanical properties of discrete and compositionally graded SS316–IN625 dual materials. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 647, 344–352 (2015).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Zhang, X., Chen, Y. & Liou, F. Fabrication of SS316L-IN625 functionally graded materials by powder-fed directed energy deposition. Sci. Technol. Weld. Joining 24, 504–516 (2019).
Article  Google Scholar 
Carroll, B. E. et al. Functionally graded material of 304L stainless steel and inconel 625 fabricated by directed energy deposition: Characterization and thermodynamic modeling. Acta Mater. 108, 46–54 (2016).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Su, Y., Chen, B., Tan, C., Song, X. & Feng, J. Influence of composition gradient variation on the microstructure and mechanical properties of 316 L/Inconel718 functionally graded material fabricated by laser additive manufacturing. J. Mater. Process. Technol. 283, 116702 (2020).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Kim, S. H. et al. Selective compositional range exclusion via directed energy deposition to produce a defect-free Inconel 718/SS 316L functionally graded material. Addit. Manuf. 47, 102288 (2021).
CAS  Google Scholar 
Manvatkar, V. D., Gokhale, A. A., Reddy, G. J., Savitha, U. & De, A. Investigation on laser engineered net shaping of multilayered structures in H13 tool steel. J. Laser Appl. 27, 032010 (2015).
ADS  Article  Google Scholar 
Goldak, J. A. & Akhlaghi, M. Computational Welding Mechanics (Springer Science & Business Media, 2006).
Google Scholar 
Davis, J. R. Stainless Steels (ASM International, 1994).
Google Scholar 
Davis, J. R. Nickel, Cobalt, and Their Alloys (ASM International, 2000).
Google Scholar 
De, A. & DebRoy, T. A smart model to estimate effective thermal conductivity and viscosity in the weld pool. J. Appl. Phys. 95, 5230–5240 (2004).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Mukherjee, T., Zuback, J. S., De, A. & DebRoy, T. Printability of alloys for additive manufacturing. Sci. Rep. 6, 1–8 (2016).
Article  Google Scholar 
Lippold, J. C. Welding Metallurgy and Weldability (Wiley, 2014).
Google Scholar 
Mukherjee, T. & DebRoy, T. Printability of 316 stainless steel. Sci. Technol. Weld. Joining 24, 412–419 (2019).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Zheng, B., Zhou, Y., Smugeresky, J. E., Schoenung, J. M. & Lavernia, E. J. Thermal behavior and microstructure evolution during laser deposition with laser-engineered net shaping: Part II. Experimental investigation and discussion. Metall. Mater. Trans. A. 39, 2237–2245 (2008).
Article  Google Scholar 
Manvatkar, V., De, A. & DebRoy, T. Heat transfer and material flow during laser assisted multi-layer additive manufacturing. J. Appl. Phys. 116, 124905 (2014).
ADS  Article  Google Scholar 
Flemings, M. C. Solidification. Metall. Mater. Trans. B. 5, 2121–2134 (1974).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Zhang, C. H. et al. Multi-layer functional graded stainless steel fabricated by laser melting deposition. Vacuum 141, 181–187 (2017).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Ghanavati, R., Naffakh-Moosavy, H. & Moradi, M. Additive manufacturing of thin-walled SS316L-IN718 functionally graded materials by direct laser metal deposition. J. Market. Res. 15, 2673–2685 (2021).
CAS  Google Scholar 
Kumara, C., Balachandramurthi, A. R., Goel, S., Hanning, F. & Moverare, J. Toward a better understanding of phase transformations in additive manufacturing of Alloy 718. Materialia. 13, 100862 (2020).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Wang, Z., Palmer, T. A. & Beese, A. M. Effect of processing parameters on microstructure and tensile properties of austenitic stainless steel 304L made by directed energy deposition additive manufacturing. Acta Mater. 110, 226–235 (2016).
ADS  CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Gallmeyer, T. G. et al. Knowledge of process-structure-property relationships to engineer better heat treatments for laser powder bed fusion additive manufactured Inconel 718. Addit. Manuf. 31, 100977 (2020).
CAS  Google Scholar 
Download references
The authors would like to appreciate the financial support of this research by the National Science Foundation of Iran (Grant no. 99011515).
Department of Materials Engineering, Tarbiat Modares University (TMU), PO Box 14115-143, Tehran, Iran
Reza Ghanavati & Homam Naffakh-Moosavy
Faculty of Arts, Science and Technology, University of Northampton, Northampton, NN1 5PH, UK
Mahmoud Moradi
Department of Mechanical Engineering, California State University, Los Angeles, CA, 90032, USA
Mohsen Eshraghi
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
R.G. wrote the main manuscript text and H.N.-M. supervised the research. All authors reviewed the manuscript.
Correspondence to Homam Naffakh-Moosavy.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Ghanavati, R., Naffakh-Moosavy, H., Moradi, M. et al. Printability and microstructure of directed energy deposited SS316l-IN718 multi-material: numerical modeling and experimental analysis. Sci Rep 12, 16600 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21077-8
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21077-8
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports (Sci Rep) ISSN 2045-2322 (online)
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

source

Absolute Label Services – Digital Production Manager (UK) – Music Business Worldwide

Digital Production Manager

Full-Time (UK) Hybrid working
Absolute Label Services, powered by Utopia, is looking for a Digital Production Manager with a passion for music and tech to join our growing team. A Utopia Music company, Absolute Label Services is one of the most established label services companies in the world.
It has a proven track record of powering successful campaigns and providing routes to market for a wide range of independent artists, managers and labels. The company’s diverse client base ranges from developing talent such as Jake Isaac, edbl and Au/Ra to household names including Deep Purple, Beverly Knight and McFly.
Our dedicated team is the backbone of our world-class service and we’re currently looking for the newest member of the Absolute family.
We are currently seeking an experienced Digital Production Manager to work in our Digital department and alongside various in-house departments to deliver first-class service to our eclectic roster of labels and artists.
Reporting to the Head of Digital, you will be responsible for ensuring release assets and metadata are accurate and complete while maintaining compliancy with our partners to ensure content is delivered to platforms as scheduled in accordance with all required standards.
With meticulous attention to detail, an ability to multi-task and impeccable organisational skills, you will be passionate about providing exceptional customer service and familiar with XML, DDEX and digital music supply chain operations,
The successful candidate will have a minimum of 3 years’ experience in a similar role and a passion for where music and tech intersect.
The closing date for applications is Monday the 24th of October.
Please email your CV (or equivalent) to [email protected] referencing the job title ‘Digital Production Manager’ in the subject line. You do not need to provide a cover letter. Shortlisted applicants will be invited to a videocall interview.
You’re welcome to apply to any of our roles regardless of your race, gender, neurodiversity, sexual orientation, religion, disability, or parental responsibility. We are open to making reasonable adjustments to both the job spec and interview process to be fully inclusive and you’re welcome to let us know about these at any point during the recruitment process or in your initial CV email.
This is full time role. Typical office hours are Monday to Thursday 09:30 – 18:00 and on Fridays we finish at 17:00.
Music Business Jobs is the most effective way for the global music industry to find the best candidates for their open positions.
In addition to being seen by over 300,000 monthly unique readers online, our listings are also emailed direct to more than 50,000 professional subscribers every week – across the US, UK, Europe, Asia-Pacific and beyond.
Click through below for details on how to submit a Music Business Jobs listing – and learn why our advertisers ‘strongly recommend’ us to their peers…

source

Salisbury University: A liberal arts education that is second to none – Study International News

In 2020 alone, the media and entertainment industry reeled in US$2 trillion across the globe and some US$500 billion in the US. Now that things are picking up for media markets, there are endless opportunities for aspiring artists to thrive, something that many higher education institutes are beginning to realise.
Nestled in “Maryland’s Coastal College Town,” however, lies a public university that has been helping students find their own voices through a wide range of excellent visual and performing arts programmes since 1989. Salisbury University’s Fulton School of Liberal Arts is a pioneer when it comes to providing an outstanding US liberal arts education. Outcomes prove this: Nine students earned the prestigious Fulbright Student Award for the 2022-23 academic year. Lecturer and sculpture technician Laura West was also awarded a Fulbright grant to conduct research at the West University of Timișoara.
Little wonder Salisbury was named one of the US’s best colleges by The Princeton Review — its strategic location, state-of-the-art facilities, diverse student body, award-winning and dedicated faculty members, and extensive offerings lead to promising graduates and stellar results. Class of 2020 music and theatre major Jay Copeland, for example, made the Top Seven on American Idol whereas six voice students from the Music Programme received awards or honours in the annual National Association of Teachers of Singing (NATS) Student Auditions.
At the Music, Theatre and Dance Department, students are discovering their personal artistry, Source: Salisbury University
How is this possible? For starters, the Music, Theatre and Dance Department fosters an environment that encourages innovative performances and designs so students can discover their personal artistry. They also have the chance to work one-on-one with faculty mentors such as Blake Harris, an assistant professor of the Theatre Programme. According to Harris, lecturers work with each student to determine where their talents and academic interests lie.
“Our course focuses on creating individualised experiences for students. We do not want to turn you into someone you are not; rather, we train you to live up to the fullest potential of the artist you can become,” says Harris. “One of our most exciting modules is Devising Theatre, a course in which students get to create a group-generated performance by the end of the term. The students are guided through a process of developing actions, texts, and characters that will result in an original and relevant performance performed at the end of the term.”
What’s unique about the Music, Theatre, and Dance programmes is that they all have specialised tracks (Traditional, Instrumental Performance, Music Technology, Vocal Performance, Teacher Certification, Design and Production, and Performance, Dance minor, Music minor, Music Production minor, and Theatre minor), so that students can focus on a niche.
The Art Department functions in a similar vein — the Art BA programme includes tracks in Art History, Two-dimensional Studio, Three-dimensional Studio, and Visual Communications whereas the Art BFA programme has tracks in Ceramics, Drawing, Graphic Design, Hot Glass, New Media, Painting, Photography, and Sculpture.
“All of the Studio Art classes involve an understanding and awareness of the world we live in,” said art professor Jinchul Kim, an award-winning painter himself. “Students are learning to apply the fundamental process of picture-making by exercising powers of visual perception in painting and drawing. Students demonstrate their confidence in media for their artistic expression.”
Salisbury students live up to the fullest potential of the artist they can become. Source: Salisbury University
Learning opportunities don’t just stop there — Salisbury students can gain first-hand experience that prepares them for the future, whether that is in graduate school or in their careers. Through intense studio experiences, student exhibitions, Career Connections, and talks by visiting professionals, arts and fine arts students go on to attend internationally recognised MA or MFA programmes around the world. Faculty say such opportunities help students develop their vision and identity.
Art BFA major  Aita can attest to this: “The professors we have right now are active artists. While working with them, we get to experience what life will be like out in the world. I was working with a faculty member for a year and did an internship, and was hired to work with them afterwards. Once the show came up, I was given the opportunity to fly out to Colorado Springs and help him install.”
For Music graduate   Todd, the programme made him feel like he had found a second family. He described the students and faculty members as “a group of people that can help you achieve what you really wish to do”.
He agrees with Alec. “These professors have had international careers as conductors, as soloists, as small ensemble members,” he says.
Indeed, the satisfactory student experience at Salisbury is what makes it a hotspot for budding artists. “If you have the motivation to seek out and pursue an undergraduate experience second to none, you can get it here at Salisbury University,” said Maarten Pereboom, Dean of the Fulton School of Liberal Arts. “You will have faculty here who support you.”
As they often say at Salisbury University, apply today to make tomorrow yours.
Follow Salisbury University on Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Flickr, YouTube, and Instagram.

source

HURRICANE IAN: Businesses open and available – WGCU

United Way
Sunshine Ace Hardware
Community Cooperative
Fireservice
Global Roofing & Contracting
Lloyd Roofing
Florida Storm Windows
Raymond Building Supply

Health


Advocate Radiation Oncology
Avow Hospice
Elite DNA Behavioral Health
Healthcare Network
NAMI Collier County
SalusCare

Family & Child Services


Better Together
Boys & Girls Club of Collier County
Child Care of Southwest Florida
Family Initiative
Guadalupe Center

Restaurants


Fort Myers Brewing Company
Shoeless Joe’s Sports Café
Norman Love Confections:
The Library Pizza and Pub
Del Mar Naples  
Ocean Prime
Maverick Grille
Chicken Salad Chick
Professional Services
CRS Technology
Goldstein, Buckley, Cechman, Rice & Purtz, PA
Priority Marketing

Other Services


Carroll & Carroll
Conservancy of Southwest Florida’s von Arx Wildlife Hospital
Charity for Change
Comerica – Naples Banking Center
Cypress Plumbing
Edison National Bank
Elite Jets
Guadalupe Resale Shop
IMAG
Integrity Employee Leasing
Partners in Care
Pro-Tec Plumbing & Air
OFDC Commercial Interiors
Studio+
TwinCutz

source

‹ Previous Next ›