Kristin Chenoweth, Kenny Ortega & Monarch Media Team For ‘1300 Miles To Broadway’ Docuseries On Chenoweth’s Broadway Bootcamp – Deadline
By Matt Grobar
Film Reporter
EXCLUSIVE: Kristin Chenoweth (Schmigadoon!), Kenny Ortega (Julie and the Phantoms) and producers Alan Powell, Steve Barnett and Vicky Patel of Monarch Media are teaming for the docuseries 1300 Miles to Broadway. Inspired by Chenoweth’s Broadway Bootcamp, the series introduces 8th to 12th graders to the world of performing arts through master classes in acting, singing and dancing, and goes on the emotional journey with them as they prepare for a future as performers.
Chenoweth launched Broadway Bootcamp at the Broken Arrow Performing Arts Center in her Oklahoma hometown of Broken Arrow in 2015, to give talented local kids a taste of real Broadway talent, working with them one-on-one. She brought Broadway director, actor and producer Richard Jay-Alexander into the fold four years ago to strengthen the program. All editions of the camp have taken place in-person with the exception of 2021’s, which was held virtually amidst the pandemic, with kids from 33 states and 8 countries participating.
This year, Chenoweth hosts two groups of students from around the world for her one-of-a-kind camps, which take place in the Performing Arts Center’s Kristin Chenoweth Theatre, having secured the participation of world class performing artists and teachers from Broadway, television and film including this year’s Camp Director Ortega, as well as Musical Director and Broadway Conductor Mary Mitchell Campbell, actor-musician Jordan Fisher, Kevin Chamberlin, Faith Prince, Owen Patrick Joyner, Booboo Stewart, Madison Reyes and Academy, Grammy and Tony Award-winning lyricist Stephen Schwartz.
Within the course of one week at camp, the series documents the life-changing breakthroughs and friendships made. Camp highlights include students participating in master classes with Chenoweth and other high-level professionals including Schwartz and Chenoweth’s vocal coach, Celeste Simone. The one-week camps for 13- to 15-year-olds and 16- to 18-year-olds culminate in an emotional and entertaining student-faculty live performance.
Michael Orland, Nate Patten and Cynthia Kortman Westphal serve as the camp’s musical directors and vocal coaches, with Tyler Hanes, Kelly Devine, Paul Becker, Deidre Goodwin, Kaitlyn Frank and Alif Sankey as its choreographers. Simone leads voice coaching, with Faith Prince, Lara Teeter, Zak Barnett and Kevin Chamberlin as acting teachers.
Ortega is directing the series and exec producing alongside Chenoweth, Powell, Barnett and Patel, with Paul Becker, Scott Lochmus, Louanne Madorma and Kim Vento producing. Monarch will take the project to market.
Chenoweth says that with Broadway Bootcamp, she wanted “to inspire youth from all over the world,” having achieved that goal over the course of the last seven years. “It goes to show you no matter where you’re from, if you do the work, you can do it,” she told Deadline. “My main goal at camp is to inspire, which is easy when you’re working with folks like Kenny Ortega, Paul Becker, Louanne Madorma, and Kim Vento. With help from Alan Powell, Steve Barnett and Vicky Patel of Monarch Media, audiences will now be able to see what makes the KCBBC experience so magical.”
“The joy I have felt working alongside Kristin and our Broadway Boot Camp team has filled my heart with an unforgettable life and creative experience. The love, imagination, and aspirational energy the kids and faculty brought to the camp each day seem to lift us off the ground. The music, laughter, breakthroughs, and personal transformations were life-changing,” said Ortega. “I’m so grateful to Kristin for inviting me to be this year’s camp and documentary director and to our Monarch partners produceorial and investment support. It has put me in that creative space that I live for.
“We share the enjoyment of working with young people, providing them with a non-judgmental atmosphere to grow as artists providing them with education, experience and the tools to own the self-confidence needed to pursue a career in the performing arts. We look forward to sharing this special and unique camp experience with the world and especially with all the Dreamers out there,” continued the series’ director-EP. “My favorite things is “discovery” and this documentary and camp are loaded with it! Careers will be born from this camp!”
“We’ll be rooting for these kids as we see them day one entering the theater, observing them in dance, acting, improv and music workshops, classes, and rehearsals,” added Monarch Media’s Powell. “The families join the kids for the bootcamp concert grand finale and it’s an incredibly special moment.”
Chenoweth is an Emmy- and Tony Award-winning actor and singer who co-stars on Apple TV+’s Emmy-winning musical comedy series Schmigadoon!, which has been renewed for a second season. She recently starred alongside Stephan James and J.K. Simmons in the STXfilms sports drama National Champions, also starring in the Netflix film Holidate. Other notable credits include Pushing Daisies, The West Wing, Glee, Disney’s Descendants and stage performances including Kristin Chenoweth: For the Girls, On the Twentieth Century and Wicked. Other recent releases from the multi-hyphenate include her first picture book What Will I Do with My Love Today and the holiday album HAPPINESS is…Christmas!.
Ortega is an Emmy- and DGA Award-winning director, producer and choreographer whose credits include the Netflix series Julie and the Phantoms, Disney’s High School Musical franchise, Hocus Pocus, Newsies, the Michael Jackson documentary This is It, and many world events, concerts and theatrical productions.
Monarch’s Barnett, Powell and Patel are currently in post-production on Something Here, a musical previously known as the Untitled Florida Georgia Line Project, and are prepping to shoot Road to Bethlehem, which will be directed by The Prom‘s producer and executive music producer, Adam Anders. They are currently developing an English-language remake of the Spanish-language film La Lista, from director Alvaro Diaz Lorenzo. Previous credits include the Netflix feature A Week Away.
Chenoweth is repped by CAA, 3 Arts Entertainment and Schreck Rose Dapello; Ortega by A3 Artists Agency, McDonald Selznick Associates and Hansen, Jacobson, Teller.
Subscribe to Deadline Breaking News Alerts and keep your inbox happy.
Signup for Breaking News Alerts & Newsletters
Get our latest storiesin the feed of your favorite networks
We want to hear from you! Send us a tip using our annonymous form.
Sign up for our breaking news alerts
Deadline is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2022 Deadline Hollywood, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Emergent second law for non-equilibrium steady states – Nature.com
Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Nature Communications volume 13, Article number: 5084 (2022)
727
5
Metrics details
The Gibbs distribution universally characterizes states of thermal equilibrium. In order to extend the Gibbs distribution to non-equilibrium steady states, one must relate the self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}(x)=-!log ({P}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}(x))) of microstate x to measurable physical quantities. This is a central problem in non-equilibrium statistical physics. By considering open systems described by stochastic dynamics which become deterministic in the macroscopic limit, we show that changes ({{Delta }}{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}={{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({x}_{t})-{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({x}_{0})) in steady state self-information along deterministic trajectories can be bounded by the macroscopic entropy production Σ. This bound takes the form of an emergent second law ({{Sigma }}+{k}_{b}{{Delta }}{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}},ge ,0), which contains the usual second law Σ ≥ 0 as a corollary, and is saturated in the linear regime close to equilibrium. We thus obtain a tighter version of the second law of thermodynamics that provides a link between the deterministic relaxation of a system and the non-equilibrium fluctuations at steady state. In addition to its fundamental value, our result leads to novel methods for computing non-equilibrium distributions, providing a deterministic alternative to Gillespie simulations or spectral methods.
When a system is at equilibrium with its environment (i.e., when no energy currents are exchanged) the probability of a given microstate x is given by the Gibbs distribution1,2,3
where (beta={({k}_{b}T)}^{-1}) is the inverse temperature of the environment, Φ(x) is the free energy of microstate x (for states with no internal entropy, Φ(x) is just the energy), and (Z={sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}exp (-beta {{Phi }}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))) is the partition function. This central result of equilibrium statistical physics has universal validity and its relevance in most areas of physics cannot be overstated. A natural question is whether or not a similar result also holds for nonequilibrium steady states (NESSs), when the system is maintained out of thermal equilibrium by external drives and subjected to constant flows of energy or matter. In this case, one can always write the steady state distribution over microstates as
in terms of the self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})), also known as fluctuating entropy4,5. In order to provide a useful generalization of the Gibbs distribution to NESSs one must relate the self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) to measurable physical quantities. This quest has a long history, starting with the seminal contributions of Lebowitz and MacLennan6,7,8 and followed by other works9,10,11,12,13,14,15. However, it still remains an open problem in non-equilibrium statistical physics, since previous formal results are simply not practical in computations, due to the fact that they involve averages over stochastic trajectories.
In this work we prove, for a very general class of open systems displaying a macroscopic limit where a deterministic dynamics emerges, the following fundamental bound on changes of self-information:
where ({{Sigma }}=intnolimits_{0}^{t}dt^{prime} dot {{{Sigma }}}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t^{prime} })/T) is the entropy production along a deterministic trajectory from microstate x0 to microstate xt. For example, let us consider the case of chemical reaction networks. The concentrations x = (x1, x2, ⋯ ) of different chemical species reacting in a solution are stochastic quantities, and their evolution is therefore described by a probability distribution Pt(x) at time t. As the volume V of the solution is increased, the distribution Pt(x) becomes strongly localised around the most probable values xt for the concentrations at time t, and these values follow a deterministic dynamics that is in general nonlinear (given in this case by the chemical rate equations). An analogous situation is encountered in electronic circuits, where the state variables x are now the voltages at the nodes of a circuit, and the macroscopic limit corresponds to increasing the typical capacitance C of the nodes (as well as the conductivity of the conduction channels connecting pairs of nodes). The remarkable feature of the result in Eq. (3) is that it provides a link between the deterministic dynamics that emerges in the macroscopic limit and the fluctuations observed at steady state. For example, in an electronic circuit powered by voltage sources and working at temperature T, the entropy production rate is (dot{{{Sigma }}}=-!dot{Q}/T), where (-dot{Q}) is the rate of heat dissipation by the conductive elements of the circuit, that can be easily evaluated at the deterministic level. Then, by Eq. (3), the quantity (-{{Sigma }}/{k}_{b}=intnolimits_{0}^{t}dt^{prime} dot {Q}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t^{prime} })/({k}_{b}T)) provides a lower bound to the change of steady state self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})-{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{0})) along a trajectory. To arrive at our main result in Eq. (3) we consider stochastic systems with a well defined macroscopic limit in which the self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}(x)) can be shown to be extensive, and Eq. (3) is strictly valid in that limit. However, as we also show, our results can be applied to micro or mesoscopic systems whenever sub-extensive contributions to ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}(x)) can be neglected. We interpret our result as an emergent second law of thermodynamics, that is stronger than the usual second law Σ ≥ 0. This last inequality is recovered from Eq. (3) by considering the fact that ({{Delta }}{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}={{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})-{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{0})le 0) (to dominant order in the macroscopic limit, the steady state self-information is a Lyapunov function of the deterministic dynamics16). In addition to its conceptual value, our result offers a practical tool to approximate or bound non-equilibrium distributions, that can typically only be accessed via stochastic numerical methods (for example the Gillespie algorithm). In contrast, Eq. (3) only requires to know the deterministic dynamics of the system, which is directly given by the well known network analysis techniques commonly applied in electronic circuits and chemical reaction networks. Furthermore, the inequality in Eq. (3) is saturated close to equilibrium, leading to a powerful linear response theory17. As an example, we apply our results to a realistic model of non-equilibrium electronic memory: the normal implementation of SRAM (static random access memory) cells in CMOS (complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor) technology. These memories have a non-equilibrium phase transition from a monostable phase to a bistable phase that allows the storage of a bit of information. As we will see, the transition is well captured by Eq. (3), which also allows to bound the probability of fluctuations around the deterministic fixed points. Finally, we show that a general coarse-graining procedure generates equivalent models with minimal entropy production, and that in this way the bound in Eq. (3) becomes tighter. When applied to the CMOS memory, this improved bound enables the full reconstruction of the steady state distribution arbitrarily away from equilibrium.
To obtain Eq. (3) we consider stochastic systems described by autonomous Markov jump processes. Thus, let ({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}in {{mathbb{N}}}^{k}}) be the set of possible states of the system, and λρ(n) be the rates at which jumps n → n + Δρ occur, for ρ = ± 1, ± 2, ⋯ and Δ−ρ = −Δρ (ρ indexes a possible jump and Δρ is the corresponding change in the state). Each state has energy E(n) and internal entropy S(n). Thermodynamic consistency is introduced by the local detailed balance (LDB) condition18,19. It relates the forward and backward jump rates of a given transition with the associated entropy production:
In the previous equation, Φ(n) = E(n) − TS(n) is the free energy of state n, and Wρ(n) is the non-conservative work provided by external sources during the transition. For simplicity, we have considered isothermal conditions at inverse temperature (beta={({k}_{b}T)}^{-1}), and therefore the system is taken away from equilibrium by the external work sources alone. More general situations in which a system interacts with several reservoirs at different temperatures can be treated in the same way, this time in terms of a Massieu potential taking the place of βΦ(n)18. Important classes of systems accepting the previous description are chemical reaction networks and electronic circuits, which are powered by chemical or electrostatic potential differences, respectively. Note that, by energy conservation, the heat provided by the environment during transition n → n + Δρ is Qρ(n) = E(n + Δρ) − E(n) − Wρ(n), and therefore kbσρ = − Qρ(n)/T + S(n + Δρ) − S(n).
The probability distribution Pt(n) over the states of the system at time t evolves according to the master equation
From the master equation and the LDB conditions one can derive the energy balance
and the usual version of the second law:
where jρ(n) = λρ(n)Pt(n) is the current associated to transition ρ. In the previous equations, (langle S rangle={sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}}{P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})left(S({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})-{k}_{b}right.log ({P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}))) is the entropy of the system, (langle E rangle={sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}}E({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}){P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})) is the average energy, and ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{e}) is the entropy flow rate, given by
where we also defined the heat rate (langle dot{Q}rangle) (the work rate (langle dot{W}rangle) is analogously defined as (langle dot{W}rangle={sum}_{rho,{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}}{W}_{rho}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}),{j}_{rho}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}))). Finally, Eq. (7) can be also expressed as:
where (leftlangle Frightrangle=leftlangle Erightrangle – Tleftlangle Srightrangle) is the non-equilibrium free energy.
If the support of Pt(n) can be restricted to a finite subspace of the state space, the Perron-Frobenius theorem states that the master equation in Eq. (5) has a unique steady state Pss(n). Once the steady state is attained, the entropy production rate (dot{{{Sigma }}}) matches the entropy flow rate ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{e}). An interesting decomposition of the entropy production rate can be obtained by considering the relative entropy (D={sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}}{P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})log ({P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})/{P}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}))) between the instantaneous distribution Pt(n) and the steady state distribution Pss(n). Then, it is possible to show that (dot{{{Sigma }}}={dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}}+{dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{na}}}}}}}}},) where
and
are the adiabatic and non-adiabatic contributions to the entropy production rate (dot{{{Sigma }}}), respectively. In Eq. (10) we have introduced the steady state probability currents ({j}_{rho }^{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})={lambda }_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}){P}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})). The non-adiabatic contribution ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{na}}}}}}}}}) is related to the relaxation of the system towards the steady state, since it vanishes when the steady state is reached. This is further evidenced by the identity in the second line of Eq. (11): a reduction in the relative entropy between Pt(n) and Pss(n) leads to a positive non-adiabatic entropy production. The adiabatic contribution ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}}) corresponds to the dissipation of ‘housekeeping heat’20,21, and at steady state matches the entropy flow rate ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{e}}}}}}}}}). An important property of the previous decomposition is that both contributions are individually positive: ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}},ge ,0) and ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{na}}}}}}}}},ge ,0)22,23,24,25. Thus, the last inequality and the second line in Eq. (11) imply that the relative entropy D decreases monotonically, and since D is positive by definition, it is a Lyapunov function for the stochastic dynamics.
In the following we will assume the existence of a scale parameter Ω controlling the size of the system in question. For example, Ω can be taken to be the volume V of the solution in well-mixed chemical reaction networks, or the typical value C of capacitance in the case of electronic circuits (see the example below). In addition, we will assume that for large Ω i) that the typical values of the density x ≡ n/Ω are intensive, ii) that the internal energy and entropy functions E(Ωx) and S(Ωx) are extensive, and iii) that the transition rates λρ(Ωx) are also extensive. Under those conditions, the probability distribution Pt(x) satisfies a large deviations (LD) principle17,26,27:
which just means that the limit ({I}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv mathop{lim }limits_{{{Omega }}to infty }-log ({P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))/{{Omega }}) is well defined. Then, It(x) is a positive, time-dependent ‘rate function’, since it gives the rate at which the probability of fluctuation x decays with the scale. Note that, by Eq. (12), the steady state self-information introduced in Eq. (2) satisfies ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={{Omega }}{I}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) to dominant order in the macroscopic limit. In other words, the large deviations principle states that the instantaneous self-information ({{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv -!log ({P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))) is an extensive quantity26, and we can think of the rate function as the self-information density. Thus, in the following we will consider the ansatz ({P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={e}^{-{{Omega }}{I}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})}/{Z}_{t}), with ({Z}_{t}equiv {sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}{e}^{-{{Omega }}{I}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})}), as an approximation to the actual time-dependent distribution. This amounts to neglecting sub-extensive contributions to the instantaneous self-information. As explained below, It(x) takes its minimum value It(xt) = 0 at the deterministic trajectory xt, which is equivalent to Pt(x) = δ(x − xt) for Ω → ∞. Plugging the previous ansatz in the master equation of Eq. (5) we note that ({lambda }_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}-{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}_{rho }/{{Omega }}){P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}-{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}_{rho }/{{Omega }})simeq {lambda }_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}){P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}){e}^{{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}_{rho }cdot nabla {I}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})}) to dominant order in Ω → ∞. Noting also that (log ({Z}_{t})) is sub-extensive, it is possible to see that It(x) evolves according to
where ({omega }_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv mathop{lim }nolimits_{{{Omega }}to infty }{lambda }_{rho }({{Omega }}{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})/{{Omega }}) are the scaled jump rates17,28. In a similar way, in the macroscopic limit the LDB conditions in Eq. (4) take the form
in terms of the free energy density (phi ({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv mathop{lim }limits_{{{Omega }}to infty }{{Phi }}({{Omega }}{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})/{{Omega }}) (internal energy and entropy densities ϵ(x) and s(x) satisfying ϕ(x) = ϵ(x) − Ts(x) can be defined in the same way). For the work contributions in Eq. (14) we are abusing notation by writing ({W}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})=mathop{lim }limits_{{{Omega }}to infty }{W}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}={{Omega }}{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})). Note that we assume that work contributions are intensive. This is justified since they are given by the product of two intensive quantities: a thermodynamic force (for example a potential difference), and the change in a conserved quantity (mass, charge, etc) during a single jump29. However, note also that the work rate (langle dot{W}rangle) will be extensive in general due to the extensivity of the transition rates.
Many classes of systems satisfy the previous scaling assumptions besides the examples already mentioned. Additional examples include non-equilibrium many-body problems like the driven Potts model30,31, reaction-diffusion models32,33, and asymmetric exclusion processes32,34.
From Eq. (12) we see that as Ω is increased, Pt(x) is increasingly localised around the minimum of the rate function It(x), which is the most probable value. Also, deviations from that typical state are exponentially suppressed in Ω. Thus, the limit Ω → ∞ is a macroscopic low-noise limit where a deterministic dynamic emerges. In fact, from Eq. (13) one can show that the evolution of the minima xt of It(x) is ruled by the closed non-linear differential equations
where iρ(x) ≡ ωρ(x) − ω−ρ(x) are the scaled deterministic currents17. The vector field u(x) corresponds to the deterministic drift in state space. For chemical reaction networks the dynamical equations in Eq. (15) are the chemical rate equations, while for electronic circuits they are provided by regular circuit analysis.
In the following section we obtain bounds for the steady state rate function Iss(x), that according to Eq. (13) satisfies:
The positivity of the adiabatic and non-adiabatic contributions to the entropy production, ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}},ge ,0) and ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{na}}}}}}}}},ge ,0), in addition to the usual second law (dot{{{Sigma }}},ge ,0), have been called the ‘three faces of the second law’23. In28, the inequality ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{na}}}}}}}}}=-!{k}_{b}{d}_{t}D,ge ,0) was put forward as an ‘emergent’ second law. There, ({{{{{{{mathcal{F}}}}}}}}={k}_{b}D) was interpreted as an alternative non-equilibrium free energy, with a balance equation ({d}_{t}{{{{{{{mathcal{F}}}}}}}}={dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}}-dot{{{Sigma }}}le 0) (note the analogy with Eq. (9)). Then, the adiabatic contribution ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{a}) was interpreted as an energy input, which at steady state balances the dissipation (dot{{{Sigma }}}). Although this point of view is compelling, it is hindered by the fact that there is no clear interpretation of ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}}) away from the steady state, that would allow to compute this quantity in terms of actual physical currents. In this work we take the other possible road, and investigate the interpretation and consequences of ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}},ge ,0). We begin by rewriting Eq. (10) using the LDB conditions of Eq. (4) and the definition of ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}) in Eq. (2), obtaining:
where we have defined (leftlangle {{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}rightrangle={sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}}{{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}){P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})) as the average of the steady state self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})=-!log ({P}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}))) and (leftlangle {S}_{{{{{{{{rm{sh}}}}}}}}}rightrangle=-{k}_{b}{sum }_{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}}{P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})log ({P}_{t}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}))) as the Shannon contribution to the system entropy, computed over the instantaneous distribution. Eq. (17) has been already obtained in22,23,24, although it was not explicitly written in terms of the self-information ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}). It is important to note that (leftlangle {S}_{{{{{{{{rm{sh}}}}}}}}}rightrangle) is sub-extensive in Ω (according to Eq. (12), it grows as (log ({{Omega }}))), and therefore can be neglected in the macroscopic limit. Thus, changes in average self-information can be bounded by the entropy production, that can in turn be computed or measured in terms of actual energy and entropy flows (see Eqs. (7) and (8)). However, the result in Eq. (17) is not yet in a useful form, since the average (leftlangle {{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}rightrangle) does not depend only on ({{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})), the unknown quantity we are interested in, but also on the instantaneous distribution Pt(n), that is also typically unknown. This issue is circumvented in the macroscopic limit, since in that case Pt(x) is strongly localised around the deterministic values xt, and therefore (leftlangle {{{{{{{mathcal{I}}}}}}}}rightrangle simeq {{Omega }}{I}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{{x}}}}}}}_{t}}})) to dominant order in Ω → ∞. Thus, in the same limit, Eq. (17) for the adiabatic entropy production rate ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}}) reduces to
where we have defined (dot{sigma }({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})=mathop{lim }limits_{{{Omega }}to infty }dot{{{Sigma }}}/{{Omega }}) as the scaled macroscopic limit of the entropy production rate (({dot{sigma }}_{{{{{{{{rm{a}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})) is defined in a similar way). Eq. (18) is a more rigorous version of our central result in Eq. (3), which is obtained by integrating Eq. (18) along deterministic trajectories (satisfying Eq. (15)) and multiplying by the scale factor. It is also useful to write down the first and second laws in the macroscopic limit. The energy balance in Eq. (6) reduces to
where the scaled heat and work rates for state x are defined as (dot{q}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={sum }_{rho ,{ > },0}{i}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}){Q}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) and (dot{w}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={sum }_{rho ,{ > },0}{i}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}){W}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})), respectively. Finally, again neglecting the sub-extensive Shannon contribution (leftlangle {S}_{{{{{{{{rm{sh}}}}}}}}}rightrangle), the second law in Eq. (7) reduces to
We will now show that to first order in the work contributions Wρ(x) the inequality in Eq. (18) is saturated. In first place we rewrite Eq. (18) using the macroscopic first and second laws in Eqs. (19) and (20):
where we also used ϕ(x) = ϵ(x) − Ts(x) and that dtF(xt) = u(xt) ⋅ ∇ F(xt) for any function F(x). Secondly, we note that in detailed-balanced settings (i.e., if Wρ(x) = 0 ∀ ρ, x) the steady state rate function is just Iss(x) = βϕ(x) (up to a constant), in accordance to the Gibbs distribution (this follows from Eqs. (14) and (16)). Thus, the difference g(x) ≡ Iss(x) − βϕ(x) appearing in Eq. (18) quantifies the deviations from thermal equilibrium. Expanding Eq. (16) to first order in Wρ(x) and g(x), it can be shown that
where ({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{u}}}}}}}}}^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={sum }_{rho ,{ > },0}{i}_{rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}){{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}_{rho }) and ({dot{w}}^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={sum }_{rho ,{ > },0}{i}_{rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}){W}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) are the lowest-order deterministic drift and work rate, respectively17. These are defined in terms of the detailed-balanced deterministic currents ({i}_{rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})={omega }_{rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})-{omega }_{-rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) constructed from the scaled transition rates evaluated at Wρ(x) = 0 that, according to the LDB conditions of Eq. (14), satisfy (log ({omega }_{rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})/{omega }_{-rho }^{(0)}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))=-beta {{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}_{rho }cdot nabla phi ({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})). Comparing the result of Eq. (22) with Eq. (21), we see that ({dot{{{Sigma }}}}_{a}=0) to linear order in Wρ(x). Then, in the linear response regime we can write:
where the integration is performed along trajectories solving the detailed-balanced deterministic dynamics dtxt = u(0)(xt).
In order to illustrate our results we will consider the model of a low-power CMOS memory cell developed in35,36, that we review in the Supplementary Note 1. This model involves two CMOS inverters connected in a loop, and each inverter is composed of two MOS transistors. There are two degrees of freedom: voltages v1 and v2, that can take values spaced by the elementary voltage ve = qe/C, where qe is the positive electron charge and C is a value of capacitance that increases with the scale of the MOS transistors. Thus, in this context the scale parameter can be taken to be Ω = VT/ve, where VT = kbT/qe is the thermal voltage. In the following all voltages will be expressed in units of VT. Figure 1 shows a typical steady state distribution in the bistable phase, and three different deterministic trajectories. The logical state of the memory is codified in the sign of the variable x = v1 − v2. The rate function Iss(x) along the x axis in Fig. 1 can be computed exactly36:
where Vdd is the powering voltage that takes the memory out of thermal equilibrium, (L(x,{V}_{{{{{{{{rm{dd}}}}}}}}})={{{{{{{{rm{Li}}}}}}}}}_{2}left(-exp ({V}_{{{{{{{{rm{dd}}}}}}}}}+x(1+2/{{{{{{{rm{n}}}}}}}}))right)), and Li2( ⋅ ) is the polylogarithm function of second order. Also, n ≥ 1 is a parameter that characterizes the transistors (the slope factor), and that will be fixed to n = 1 in the following. In the Supplementary Note 1 we show that the rate function in Eq. (24) provides an essentially exact description of the steady state distribution for scale parameters as low as Ω = 10 (i.e., states with at most tens of electrons are appreciably populated). Thus, sub-extensive contributions to the self-information can be safely neglected in this case, even away from the strict macroscopic limit.
Exact steady state distribution for Vdd = 1.4 and ve = 0.1. The orange, cyan and grey lines show three deterministic trajectories for the same parameters and different initial conditions, with the arrows indicating the direction of motion.
In Fig. 2a we show that there is a non-equilibrium transition from a monostable phase into the bistable phase that allows the storage of a bit of information, occurring at the critical powering voltage ({V}_{{{{{{{{rm{dd}}}}}}}}}^{*}=ln (2)). We also compare the exact rate function in Eq. (24) with the linear response approximation obtained from Eq. (23) for different powering voltages. Remarkably, despite it is only expected to be valid close to equilibrium, the linear response approximation captures the transition to bistability and continues to be a reasonable approximation well into the bistable phase. The reason is that in this case the second order non-equilibrium correction vanishes (as can be checked by expanding Eq. (24) in Vdd), and therefore the linear response approximation is actually valid up to order ({V}_{{{{{{{{rm{dd}}}}}}}}}^{3}).
a Rate function Iss(x) for different values of the powering voltage Vdd. We also compare Iss(x) with the linear response approximation obtained from Eq. (23) for Vdd = 1.2. b Illustration of the bound to I(xt) in Eq. (18) for two different deterministic trajectories starting at x0 = 2 and x0 = 4 (Vdd = 3). c Bound to Iss(x0) for a fixed xt according to Eq. (18), for xt = x* ± 2δ ((delta=1/sqrt{2{{Omega }}}), Ω = 10, and Vdd = 3).
In Fig. 2b the exact rate function Iss(xt) along a deterministic trajectory xt is compared with the lower bound ({I}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({x}_{0})-intnolimits_{0}^{t}dt^{prime} dot{sigma }({x}_{t^{prime} })/{k}_{b}), for two different trajectories starting at x0 = 2 and x0 = 4, with y0 = 0 in both cases (as shown in Fig. 1, deterministic trajectories initialized in the x axis remain in it). In both cases the trajectory xt approaches the fixed point x* ≃ Vdd = 3. We see that ({I}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({x}_{0})-intnolimits_{0}^{t}dt^{prime} dot{sigma }({x}_{t^{prime} })/{k}_{b}) is indeed a lower bound to Iss(xt), in accordance with Eq. (18). Note that this bound diverges when the trajectory approaches the fixed point x*. The reason is that once xt ≃ x*, the entropy production (intnolimits_{0}^{t}dt^{prime} dot{sigma }({x}_{t^{prime} })) just continuously integrates the steady state heat dissipation rate (-dot{q}({x}^{*})) (see Eq. (20)). The linear response approximation avoids this issue since the lowest-order work rate ({dot{w}}^{(0)}(x)) vanishes at the equilibrium fixed point (see Eq. (23)). The divergence can be also avoided by the coarse-graining procedure discussed in the next section. Alternatively, Eq. (18) can be considered an upper bound to I(x0) for a fixed final point xt. This is shown in Fig. 2c, for final points xt = x* ± 2δ, where (delta=1/sqrt{2{{Omega }}}) estimates the variance of the fluctuations around the fixed point.
The fact that in Fig. 2b, c the bounds are much tighter to one side of the fixed point than the other can be traced back to the different speeds at which the fixed point is approached. To show this, in Fig. 3 we have plotted the entropy production rate (dot{sigma }) and the speed ∣dx/dt∣ as a function of x for Vdd = 3. In Fig. 3a we see that (dot{sigma }) is minimized close to the deterministic fixed points (this is a design feature of CMOS devices, in order to minimize the static power consumption, which is however not zero). Also, we see that (dot{sigma }) is actually lower to the left of the fixed point at x ≃ 3 than to the right. However, in Fig. 3b we see that the speed dx/dt at which the fixed point is approached is also lower to the left side, resulting in a larger total entropy production (intnolimits_{0}^{t}dt^{prime} dot{sigma }({x}_{t^{prime} })=intnolimits_{{x}_{0}}^{{x}_{t}}dx dot{sigma }(x)/(dx/dt)), and a looser bound in Fig. 2b, c.
a Deterministic entropy production rate (dot{sigma }), and (b) deterministic speed ∣dx/dt∣ as a function of x for Vdd = 3 (see the Supplementary Note 1 for the definition of the timescale τ).
Our main result in Eq. (18) allows to obtain information about the steady state fluctuations by just measuring the physical entropy production along deterministic trajectories. However, if we consider the mathematical problem of bounding the steady state fluctuations given the transition rates λρ(n), then the full power of our result is achieved by considering a ‘coarse-grained’ entropy production that is in general a lower bound to the actual physical one, as we now explain. In first place we notice that different sets of transition rates {λρ(n)} might lead to the same master equation (Eq. (5)) and consequently the same steady state and emerging deterministic dynamics (Eq. (15)), while giving rise to different entropy production rates (Eq. (7)). This is due to the fact that the entropy production depends on how a given stochastic dynamics is split into thermodynamically distinct processes, each of them satisfying a different LDB condition. In particular, the entropy production is not invariant under coarse-graining of the transition rates23,37. Specifically, consider that we lump together all transitions going from state n to state ({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}}+{tilde{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}}_{rho }) into a single transition with rate
In this way, the jump vectors ({{tilde{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}}_{rho }}) associated to the coarse-grained rates ({tilde{lambda }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})) are all distinct (({tilde{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}}_{rho },ne, {tilde{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}}_{rho ^{prime} }) if (rho ,ne, rho ^{prime})). It is easy to check that rates ({tilde{{lambda }_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})}}) and {λρ(n)} lead to the same master equation. However, the entropy production rate (dot{{{Pi }}}) corresponding to the rates ({tilde{{lambda }_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{n}}}}}}}})}}) is always a lower bound of the original one23:
An important property of (dot{{{Pi }}}) is that, whenever the emerging deterministic dynamics has fixed point attractors, its macroscopic version (dot{pi }({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})equiv mathop{lim }nolimits_{{{Omega }}to infty }dot{{{Pi }}}/{{Omega }}={sum }_{rho ,{ > },0}({tilde{omega }}_{rho }({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})-{tilde{omega }}_{-rho }({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t}))log ({tilde{omega }}_{rho }({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t})/{tilde{omega }}_{-rho }({{{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}}_{t}))) vanishes at the fixed points (see the Supplementary Note 2 for a detailed discussion). Thus, the bound obtained using the entropy production rate (dot{pi }) is free from the divergence as the fixed point is approached. In the case of the CMOS memory, this is shown in Fig. 4 for the two trajectories along the x axis of Fig. 1. We see that not only the divergence is avoided, but that the bound matches the exact rate function (see below).
Illustration of the bound to I(xt) from Eq. (18) in terms of the entropy production rate (dot{pi }) for the cyan and orange trajectories in Fig. 1, starting respectively at x0 = 0.2 and x0 = 2.6 (Vdd = 1.4).
In analogy with Eq. (14), whenever the log-ratio ({tilde{sigma }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv log ({tilde{omega }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})/{tilde{omega }}_{-rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))) of the scaled coarse-grained rates can be expressed as the gradient of a state function (-tilde{phi }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) along the direction ({tilde{{{{{{{{boldsymbol{Delta }}}}}}}}}}_{rho }), the steady state rate function will be just ({I}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})=tilde{phi }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) (up to a constant). In that case, the system can be considered to be at equilibrium at the coarse-grained level. Under some conditions, one can easily test if ({tilde{sigma }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) derives from a gradient by just checking if the generalized curl ({f}_{rho,rho ^{prime} }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv {partial }_{{x}_{rho }}{tilde{sigma }}_{rho ^{prime} }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})-{partial }_{{x}_{rho ^{prime} }}{tilde{sigma }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})) vanishes for all ρ, (rho ^{prime}), and x (see the Supplementary Note 2). If that is the case, then the bound in Eq. (18) in terms of the entropy production rate (dot{pi }) is saturated, and one can fully reconstruct the steady-state rate function in terms of the deterministic dynamics.
In the CMOS memory the state space is two dimensional and therefore there is a single curl component f(x), or vorticity. In Fig. 5 we show the vorticity f(x) for the same parameters as in Fig. 1. We see that the model is genuinely non-equilibrium even at the coarse-grained level. However, we also see that the vorticity vanishes at the x and y axes, which explains why the bound in Fig. 4 matches the exact rate function. Finally, we study how the bound in terms of the coarse-grained entropy production rate (dot{pi }) performs for the gray trajectory in Figs. 1 and 5, that starts in and goes through areas of non-vanishing vorticity, and thus genuinely out of equilibrium. Since in this case we do not have the exact rate function to compare with, we compare the bound with the estimation of the rate function ({I}_{{{{{{{{rm{est}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})=-!log ({P}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))/{{Omega }}) obtained from the exact steady state distribution. Iest(x) is only defined for the discrete set of voltages v1 and v2 that are a multiple of the elementary voltage ve, and in the comparison we choose the closest values of v1 and v2 to the continuous deterministic trajectory xt, obtaining a stepwise function. The results are shown in Fig. 6. We see that even in this case our bound provides an accurate approximation of the probability distribution. This shows that the emergent second law in terms of the coarse-grained entropy production has the potential to offer a deterministic alternative to Gillespie simulations and spectral methods. As an example, we provide in the Supplementary Note 3 a full reconstruction of the steady state distribution of the CMOS memory.
Vorticity f(x) of the vector field with components ({tilde{sigma }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})equiv log ({tilde{omega }}_{rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})/{tilde{omega }}_{-rho }({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))), ρ = 1, 2, for the CMOS memory model (Vdd = 1.4 and ve = 0.1, as in Fig. 1). The orange, cyan and grey lines correspond to the same deterministic trajectories of deterministic trajectories of Fig. 1.
Comparison of the upper bound to Iss(x0) in terms of the coarse-grained entropy production rate (dot{pi }) for the points in the gray trajectory in Figs. 1 and 5 with the function ({I}_{{{{{{{{rm{est}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}})=-log ({P}_{{{{{{{{rm{ss}}}}}}}}}({{{{{{{boldsymbol{x}}}}}}}}))/{{Omega }}) obtained from the exact steady state distribution.
It is important to note that the bound given by the emergent second law in terms of the mathematical entropy production in Eq. (26) can be applied to any Markov jump process displaying a macroscopic limit, irrespective of whether it represents a thermodynamically consistent stochastic dynamics or not (the only restriction is that for each jump the reverse jump should also be possible). For example, our results can be relevant in stochastic population38,39 or gene expression40,41 models.
For systems accepting a description in terms of Markov jump processes, our results unveil a fundamental connection between the deterministic dynamics that emerges in a macroscopic limit and the non-equilibrium fluctuations at steady state. This is given by an inequality that can be interpreted as an emergent second law. In fact, it is a tighter version of the usual second law, that is saturated in the linear response regime. As shown in the Supplementary Note 4, the emergent second law can be alternatively understood as a generalized fluctuation-dissipation relation. The practical value of our result lies in the fact that the probability of non-equilibrium fluctuations is hard to evaluate, while the deterministic dynamics is directly given by standard methods. The corresponding linear response theory, working at the level of the rate function, was shown in17 to be highly accurate in some model systems, with a regime of validity beyond that of usual linear response theories. Our result can also be employed in combination with numerical or experimental approaches: once normal or moderately rare fluctuations have been sampled and characterized, Eq. (3) can be used to bound the probability of very rare fluctuations, that otherwise would require extremely long simulation times. In addition, the refinement of our result by a coarse-graining procedure leads to novel numerical techniques to compute non-equilibrium distributions, that only rely on the deterministic dynamics and thus offer an alternative to stochastic simulations or spectral methods.
As a final comment, we note that the extensivity assumptions defining the macroscopic limit we have considered are a very natural extension of the usual notion of extensivity in equilibrium thermodynamics. The only additional requirements, besides the extensivity of the free energy associated to each state, are the extensivity of the jump rates between different states, and the intensivity of the work contributions. These natural requirements lead to an extensive non-equilibrium self-information, whose dominant contribution is constrained by our emergent second law, and that at equilibrium reduces to the regular extensive free energy.
As explained in the main text, the emergent second law can be obtained from the fact that the adiabatic contribution to the entropy production rate is positive. The proof of this fact can be found in the mentioned references. The details of the model in the example are given in the Supplementary Note 1. The properties of the coarse grained entropy production are discussed in the Supplementary Note 2. In the Supplementary Note 3 we show how the emergent second law can provide an alternative to stochastic simulations or spectral methods. Finally, in the Supplementary Note 4 we make explicit the connection between the emergent second law derived here and fluctuation-dissipation relations.
All the data shown in the figures can be easily reproduced from the given information, and is also available at the Git repository https://github.com/nfreitas/emergent-second-law.git.
The scripts used to generate the data shown in the plots are available at the Git repository: https://github.com/nfreitas/emergent-second-law.git.
Goldstein, S., Lebowitz, J. L., Tumulka, R. & Zanghì, N. Canonical typicality. Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 050403 (2006).
ADS MathSciNet PubMed Article Google Scholar
Popescu, S., Short, A. J. & Winter, A. Entanglement and the foundations of statistical mechanics. Nat. Phys. 2, 754–758 (2006).
CAS Article Google Scholar
Georgii, H.-O.: Gibbs Measures and Phase Transitions. De Gruyter, Berlin, Germany https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110250329/html (2011).
Einstein, A. Theorie der Opaleszenz von homogenen Flüssigkeiten und Flüssigkeitsgemischen in der Nähe des kritischen Zustandes. Annalen der Physik 338, 1275–1298 (1910).
ADS MATH Article Google Scholar
Seifert, U. Entropy production along a stochastic trajectory and an integral fluctuation theorem. Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 040602 (2005).
ADS PubMed Article Google Scholar
Lebowitz, J. L. & Bergmann, P. G. Irreversible gibbsian ensembles. Ann. Phys. 1, 1–23 (1957).
ADS MathSciNet CAS MATH Article Google Scholar
Lebowitz, J. Stationary nonequilibrium gibbsian ensembles. Phys. Rev. 114, 1192 (1959).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
McLennan Jr, J. A. Statistical mechanics of the steady state. Phys. Rev. 115, 1405 (1959).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Zubarev, D. N. Nonequilibrium Statistical Thermodynamics. (Consultants Bureau New York,1974)
Zubarev, D. Nonequilibrium statistical operator as a generalization of gibbs distribution for nonequilibrium case. Cond. Matt. Phys 4, 19 (1994)
Komatsu, T. S. & Nakagawa, N. Expression for the stationary distribution in nonequilibrium steady states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 030601 (2008).
ADS PubMed Article Google Scholar
Maes, C. & Netočny`, K. Rigorous meaning of mclennan ensembles. J. Mathematical Phys. 51, 015219 (2010).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Colangeli, M., Maes, C. & Wynants, B. A meaningful expansion around detailed balance. J. Phys. A: Math. Theoretic. 44, 095001 (2011).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Dhar, A., Saito, K. & Hänggi, P. Nonequilibrium density-matrix description of steady-state quantum transport. Phys. Rev. E 85, 011126 (2012).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Ness, H. Nonequilibrium density matrix for quantum transport: Hershfield approach as a mclennan-zubarev form of the statistical operator. Phys. Rev. E 88, 022121 (2013).
ADS CAS Article Google Scholar
Gang, H. Lyapounov function and stationary probability distributions. Zeitschrift für Physik B Condensed Matter 65, 103–106 (1986).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Freitas, N., Falasco, G. & Esposito, M. Linear response in large deviations theory: a method to compute non-equilibrium distributions. N. J. Phys. 23, 093003 (2021).
MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Rao, R. & Esposito, M. Conservation laws shape dissipation. N. J. Phys. 20, 023007 (2018).
Article Google Scholar
Maes, C. Local detailed balance. SciPost Phys. Lect. Notes 32, 1–17 (2021).
Google Scholar
Hatano, T. & Sasa, S.-i. Steady-state thermodynamics of langevin systems. Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3463 (2001).
ADS CAS PubMed Article Google Scholar
Speck, T. & Seifert, U. Integral fluctuation theorem for the housekeeping heat. J. Phys. A: Math. General 38, 581 (2005).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Esposito, M., Harbola, U. & Mukamel, S. Entropy fluctuation theorems in driven open systems: Application to electron counting statistics. Phys. Rev. E 76, 031132 (2007).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Esposito, M. & Van den Broeck, C. Three faces of the second law. I. Master equation formulation. Phys. Rev. E 82, 011143 (2010).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Ge, H. & Qian, H. Physical origins of entropy production, free energy dissipation, and their mathematical representations. Phys. Rev. E 81, 051133 (2010).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Rao, R. & Esposito, M. Detailed fluctuation theorems: A unifying perspective. Entropy 20, 635 (2018).
ADS MathSciNet PubMed Central Article Google Scholar
Touchette, H. The large deviation approach to statistical mechanics. Phys. Rep. 478, 1–69 (2009).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Touchette, H., Harris, R. J.: Large deviation approach to nonequilibrium systems. arXiv 1110.5216. https://doi.org/10.1002/9783527658701.ch11 (2011).
Ge, H. & Qian, H. Mesoscopic kinetic basis of macroscopic chemical thermodynamics: A mathematical theory. Phys. Rev. E 94, 052150 (2016).
ADS MathSciNet PubMed Article Google Scholar
Rao, R. & Esposito, M. Conservation laws shape dissipation. N. J. Phys. 20, 023007 (2018).
Article Google Scholar
Herpich, T., Thingna, J. & Esposito, M. Collective Power: Minimal Model for Thermodynamics of Nonequilibrium Phase Transitions. Phys. Rev. X 8, 031056 (2018).
CAS Google Scholar
Herpich, T., Cossetto, T., Falasco, G. & Esposito, M. Stochastic thermodynamics of all-to-all interacting many-body systems. N. J. Phys. 22, 063005 (2020).
MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Bertini, L., De Sole, A., Gabrielli, D., Jona-Lasinio, G. & Landim, C. Macroscopic fluctuation theory. Rev. Mod. Phys. 87, 593–636 (2015).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Falasco, G., Rao, R. & Esposito, M. Information Thermodynamics of Turing Patterns. Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 108301 (2018).
ADS MathSciNet CAS PubMed Article Google Scholar
Enaud, C. & Derrida, B. Large Deviation Functional of the Weakly Asymmetric Exclusion Process. J. Stat. Phys. 114, 537–562 (2004).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Freitas, N., Delvenne, J.-C. & Esposito, M. Stochastic Thermodynamics of Nonlinear Electronic Circuits: A Realistic Framework for Computing Around kT. Phys. Rev. X 11, 031064 (2021).
CAS Google Scholar
Freitas, N., Proesmans, K. & Esposito, M. Reliability and entropy production in nonequilibrium electronic memories. Phys. Rev. E 105, 034107 (2022).
ADS MathSciNet CAS PubMed Article Google Scholar
Esposito, M. Stochastic thermodynamics under coarse graining. Phys. Rev. E 85, 041125 (2012).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Assaf, M. & Meerson, B. WKB theory of large deviations in stochastic populations. J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 50, 263001 (2017).
ADS MathSciNet MATH Article Google Scholar
Riccardo, R. & Stanislas, L. Evolutionary dynamics, evolutionary forces, and robustness: A nonequilibrium statistical mechanics perspective. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 119, 2112083119 (2022).
MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Vahid, S. & Swain Peter, S. Analytical distributions for stochastic gene expression. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA. 105, 17256–17261 (2008).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Bokes, P., Borri, A., Palumbo, P. & Singh, A. Mixture distributions in a stochastic gene expression model with delayed feedback: a WKB approximation approach. J. Math. Biol. 81, 343–367 (2020).
MathSciNet PubMed PubMed Central MATH Article Google Scholar
Download references
We acknowledge funding from the INTER project “TheCirco” (INTER/FNRS/20/15074473) and CORE project “NTEC” (C19/MS/13664907), funded by the Fonds National de la Recherche (FNR, Luxembourg), and from the European Research Council, project NanoThermo (ERC-2015-CoGAgreement No. 681456). The authors applied a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license to any Author Accepted Manuscript version arising from this submission.
These authors contributed equally: José Nahuel Freitas, Massimiliano Esposito.
Complex Systems and Statistical Mechanics, Department of Physics and Materials Science, University of Luxembourg, 162a, avenue de la Faïencerie, Luxembourg, L-1511, Luxembourg, Luxembourg
José Nahuel Freitas & Massimiliano Esposito
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
J.N.F. and M.E. contributed equally to all aspects of this work.
Correspondence to José Nahuel Freitas or Massimiliano Esposito.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Nature Communications thanks Fabien Paillusson, and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Freitas, J.N., Esposito, M. Emergent second law for non-equilibrium steady states. Nat Commun 13, 5084 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-32700-7
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-32700-7
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
Advanced search
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.
Controversy at summer program sparks conversation on FGLI belonging – Yale Daily News
First-generation, low-income students and counselors spoke to the News about controversies that negatively impacted the First-Year Scholars at Yale program in the wake of the College Council’s first statement of the year.
Jordan Fitzgerald & Isaac Yu
Staff Reporters
Yale Daily News
Controversy has swirled surrounding a popular summer program for incoming first-generation, low-income students.
Over the summer, two Yale administrators reprimanded students at the First-Year Scholars at Yale program for “trashing” the residential college they lived in. But some students said the deans’ language left them feeling targeted due to their socioeconomic and racial background, prompting an apology email from the deans. Afterwards, many students left happy with the program. But a Yale College Council statement released on August 30 reignited tensions around the incident, causing some FSY counselors and students to say that the YCC statement lacked context.
The News spoke to five students, one counselor and one residential director involved in FSY, as well as multiple Yale administrators and YCC representatives. Some students said the incident damaged their trust in Yale but also felt that the YCC’s statement oversimplified the situation.
First-years told the News that the program — a six-week summer program meant to give incoming students from first-generation, low-income backgrounds the opportunity to take summer courses at Yale provided a space to adjust to campus before entering “Big Yale”— a term used among some FGLI students that may cause feelings of displacement.
“I hope this event doesn’t give the program a bad reputation,” said Noah Dee ’26, an FSY participant. “I think it’s a program that should continue.”
Students, counselors and administrators maintained that the program should continue to be seen as a crucial part of the FGLI community and an opportunity to spur future progress on inclusion and belonging at Yale.
Students were hurt by a disciplinary meeting that caught them by surprise
First-Year Scholars at Yale, founded in 2013, was entirely remote in 2020 and 2021 and returned in-person for the first time in three years this summer. Participants lived in Trumbull College alongside a small number of students taking part in other summer programs.
In the first weeks of FSY, a series of residential issues began to alarm the program’s residential directors, who notified the program’s associated adult faculty. According to counselors and students, problems included “trashing” physical spaces in the college, which counselors said created extra work for Yale’s facilities staff.
On July 6, a week after the program began, students were brought into Dunham Laboratory for a discussion of quantitative reasoning courses. Immediately after the event, two administrators — Yale Summer Session Dean Jeanne Follansbee and Timothy Dwight College Dean Sarah Mahurin — spoke to students about their behavior, emphasizing a need to respect the facilities and personnel and to take the program more seriously.
Some students said that the approach, however, used language that was off-putting to them and left them feeling ambushed.
“All of a sudden, you have the deans, and they’re giving a speech,” Joseph Elsayyid ’26 said. “It just felt humiliating. My own counselor told me she was shocked by [what happened].”
This was also the first time the cohort had interacted with the deans, the students confirmed.
Counselors and residential directors said they noticed negative reactions during the meeting and immediately began planning small group meetings for that night. Students, counselors and residential directors hoped to use the meetings to address students’ concerns over the nature of the meeting and language used.
“We split up into separate rooms … and acknowledged the issue,” said Solomon Gonzalez ’23, one of the FSY counselors. “It was very serious, and people were able to speak their minds without much guidance. They were very honest with their opinions but also very respectful.”
Controversy hinged on interpretations of several key phrases
The News obtained a partial audio recording of the meeting, which captured comments from Mahurin and members of the FSY committee.
Follansbee’s comments are absent from the recording, but students present at the event said Follansbee repeated the word “privilege” several times when she addressed the group — emphasizing the “privilege” of attending FSY. According to the five students, that word choice struck some in the room as tone-deaf, considering FSY caters to underserved and underrepresented first-years.
When she addressed the group, Mahurin made a similar comment in the middle of a speech.
“Please know, y’all don’t have to do this,” Mahurin said in the recording. “And by this I mean FSY. I’m not going to tell y’all anymore about what a privilege it is to be here.”
Mahurin added that the participants were not “matriculated Yale students yet,” though she emphasized that any student who chose to leave FSY would still be welcome back for the fall term.
Mahurin also gave the audience a piece of advice she said she repeats to incoming students every year: “Don’t be stupid. Don’t be tacky.”
Jorge Anaya — Assistant Director of Student Engagement at the Yale College Dean’s Office, who was in TD before he graduated in 2019 — confirmed that this is a catchphrase of Mahurin’s, which Anaya still tries to adhere to. The usage of the phrase was confirmed by three current TD students as well as previous FSY participants.
Mahurin declined to speak with the News but said that interested students can meet with her for a conversation.
But some students said that the meeting left them at a loss.
“It was very aggressive and kind of broke that sense of community that FSY was supposed to foster,” said Dee.
In a July 6 email to the FSY students, residential directors and members of the FSY committee, many of whom are senior administrators, both Follansbee and Mahurin apologized for their statements.
Not all students — not even all FGLI students — get to attend FSY, Follansbee wrote, and she apologized for the “unwanted implications” of the word “privilege.”
Mahurin clarified that she used the word “matriculate” in an administrative sense. No one in the class of 2026, whether or not they participated in FSY, would be considered matriculated Yale students until the fall, she said.
“You are absolutely Yale students,” Mahurin said in the email. “Your place here is not in question.”
In the email, the deans offered to meet in-person with students who wanted to discuss the event further. Paul McKinley, Yale’s senior associate dean of Strategic Initiatives and Communications, would not confirm how many students chose to meet with Follansbee and Mahurin.
Follansbee was unavailable for comment.
Though one student said they found the apology disingenuous, others said they appreciated the acknowledgement.
“[Mahurin’s] speech did cause a lot of divisions,” Dee said. “She just wanted the best for the facilities staff. She made a mistake, she owned up to it, let’s move on.”
The residential directors and counselors led sessions to discuss the issue, which four students said were helpful. They hosted what some students described as an “apology” ice cream social. By the time the program wrapped up on Aug. 10, students said they had forgotten about the incident.
FSY students feel that the Yale College Council overreacted in its statement
Discussion about what happened had died down by the end of the summer, and the five students say they left with warm feelings towards the residential directors and other students.
Several told the News they were surprised when the Yale College Council released a statement detailing an account of the events and calling for better administrative behavior and engagement with FGLI students.
“We, the YCC, see these acts for what they truly are,” the statement read. “Yale perpetuates a problematic culture of gratitude from its FGLI and BIPOC students.”
This was the first statement made by the incoming slate of representatives that was elected last April. The statement was pitched, written and approved by select senators rather than by full vote, though YCC President Leleda Beraki ’24 explained that such statements are not required to be voted on, as per the YCC constitution.
The statement made several errors, several FSY students and counselors said. Most prominently, it claims that FSY students were not given access to events such as Broadway shows in New York City as other summer program students were, when in fact these opportunities were made available to FSY students as well.
“(The statement) made it sound like we received no care and attention when in reality, we had counselors…” said Adam Brewster ’26. “In reality, we were better off.”
Additionally, some students felt that the statement did not accurately reflect the program’s general positive effects, the degree to which non-FSY students contributed to residential issues, and the administration’s response to the disciplinary meeting’s aftermath.
Beraki defended the statement in an email to the News.
“I definitely think this statement has flaws, like most things, but it has already resulted in counselors and students reaching out to the YCC with ways they think the program can improve,” Beraki said. “The focus of this statement was not intended to be on administrators themselves, but rather to spark a larger conversation on how resources made for FGLI students need to be better, while also bringing a certain level of accountability to those who provide these resources.”
The statement was taken down and reposted on Instagram without Follansbee’s and Mahurin’s names.
The students who spoke to the News said they feared the YCC’s statement had opened the door to overly critical discourse of FSY itself and could potentially discourage future participants or lead to loss of funding.
Looking around the Trumbull Common Room, Evan Losey ’26 recalled sleeping in the air-conditioned space with fellow participants on particularly warm nights. It was here and in other Trumbull spaces, he said, that participants formed lifelong friendships that have continued to ease their transitions to life at Yale this semester.
“It was rough, but it was overall a very constructive experience,” Evan Losey ’26. “One of the best programs I’ve been to.”
Four different FSY participants told the News that they formed significant friendships and would do the program over again if given the chance.
The incident has become part of an ongoing discussion around being FGLI at Yale
Between 2013 and 2021, the percentage of undergraduate students eligible for Pell grants has risen from less than 13 percent to 19 percent. The number of first-generation college students has also grown from below 13 percent to almost 18 percent over the same period, equating to 500 more Pell-eligible and 400 more first-generation students than there were nine years ago.
Over the same period, the number of FSY participants has increased as well. This year’s cohort is almost three times the size of 2013’s inaugural class, according to dean of Undergraduate Admissions and Financial Aid Jeremiah Quinlan, who was not present at FSY events this summer.
FSY was also larger than it had been when the program last ran in person in 2019, growing from 72 to 91 students.
This expansion was one of several growing pains with this summer’s round of FSY, according to residential counselor Darnell Battle ’21.
The residential directors and administrators said that FSY was heavily impacted by the lack of a faculty coordinator who could liaise between students and the FSY Council, a group of administrators including Follansbee. No person had been nominated to replace the outgoing director, Michael Fitzpatrick, so the position went unfilled throughout the summer.
“There was a vacuum of administrative support,” Battle said. “It was really challenging to run the program, with recent graduates and Yale College students doing most of the work on the ground and building the community.”
Despite the incident, three students said that they found the residential directors and counselors to be helpful resources and gradually became closer to them each week.
FSY’s enlargement slots into a broader effort to support FGLI students, though many report that there are still challenges to studying at an elite university like Yale.
McKinley said that the Offices of Student Affairs and Student Engagement will invite FSY students to talk about their experiences. Ezana Tedla ’25, a YCC Senator and FGLI student who was involved in crafting the YCC’s statement on the matter, told the News that she hopes all students will feel comfortable sharing their experiences with the YCC.
Beraki, who identified herself as FGLI in her email, said that her plans for supporting FGLI students lies primarily in partnering with FGLI-focused student organizations.
“While FGLI students should have the loudest voices and be at the forefront of these conversations, the burden of improving structural issues and program failures should not always fall on those affected by them,” Beraki wrote to the News.
FSY was founded in 2013.
Why 9/11 special master Kenneth Feinberg wouldn't take on Trump documents case – CBS News
Watch CBS News
/ CBS News
Lawyer Kenneth Feinberg estimates he’s taken on about “half a dozen” of the nation’s most difficult tasks as special master over the years.
He oversaw the September 11th Victims Compensation Fund during former President George W. Bush’s administration. He administered a similar fund for victims of the Deepwater Horizon spill during the Obama administration. He also oversaw CEO pay for companies that received government bailouts during the 2008 financial crisis.
However, in an exclusive interview, he told CBS News senior investigative correspondent Catherine Herridge that if he were asked to be special master in the case involving the documents seized from former President Donald Trump’s Florida residence, the answer would be no.
“I would not,” Feinberg said Friday. “I don’t have that skill set. I have some security clearances over the years. I still have security clearances. But that level of security clearance, coupled with the special — really, the special expertise that I think an individual would have to have, leads me to believe that I’m not the right person for this assignment.”
On the question of whether he’s been approached, Feinberg retorted, “Thank goodness, no.”
Feinberg noted that the special master will have to “brace” themselves for a “politically charged assignment” in which they could receive credible threats and have their background scrutinized.
“This is a political appointment,” Feinberg said. “Now I agree there are very substantive national security concerns. But this is already, you know, if you’re asked to do this, brace yourself one side or the other, they’re going to be looking at how you behaved in grammar school. And never mind it was 70 years ago, or 60 years ago. I mean, this is political warfare of the type that we’ve been seeing over the last decade. And it’s very, very problematic.”
A special master is an independent third party appointed by a court, or by the executive branch, to carry out action on its behalf. The range of functions performed can vary widely. In this case, Feinberg said the skills necessary for the job are “unique.”
“First of all, does the special master have the resume – highly sensitive national secret information? Is there somebody out there with that experience, and that clearance, to review these highly sensitive documents,” Feinberg said.
He noted that in instances where he has been appointed, like the Deepwater Horizon and 9/11 cases, “there was no objection” to his appointment and “all sides” were “hoping for a prompt resolution.”
Those cases involved compensation for victims. The Trump case, he said, is different.
“This case will be politically charged from the get-go,” Feinberg said. “Will somebody be willing to brace themselves to take the heat? Because there will be heat.”
Feinberg also questioned whether the courts should even have a role in assessing the security threat posed by the storage of those documents with classified markings which were found at Mar-a-Lago.
“The idea that the judiciary will intervene in what is essentially a highly skilled executive branch function of classifying documents – I don’t think it is a good idea for the judiciary to get involved,” he said, noting that the matter of appointing a special master for the case will be reviewed by the appellate court.
“And the idea that this is a judicial function, I’m very dubious about that,” Feinberg said. “The department and the national security agencies, the CIA, they have information and valuable insight into all of this. And I’m not sure a federal judge, district court or appellate court really has that sophistication and that experience to be able to make those conclusions second guessing allegedly.”
The Justice Department and Trump’s legal team were to submit a list of potential special master candidates acceptable to both parties by Friday. Feinberg doubts that a “consensus candidate” exists.
“I think it’s very likely that the judge will have to appoint someone that she deems appropriate over the objection of one side or the other,” he told Herridge. “I don’t see the two sides getting together. But again, that’ll await an appellate review if there’s going to be a special master at all.”
In any case, he has some advice for any of those possible candidates
“What makes these assignments so unique and so difficult is the emotional overhang, the political overhang,” Feinberg said. “And I would ask, or I would suggest to anybody who’s considering this: think long and hard. There are people over the years in the national security apparatus who have wonderful resumes, exemplary service to the people of this country. Now, you’re being asked to take on an assignment that has the potential to tarnish that reputation and bring you into the political polarization of
First published on September 9, 2022 / 9:42 PM
© 2022 CBS Interactive Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Copyright ©2022 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
No one collected the rifle: Convicted felon now charged with Richmond police officer's attempted murder got plea deal after 'shocking failure' – WTHR
Next up in 5
Example video title will go here for this video
RICHMOND, Ind. — When a prosecutor charged Philip Lee last month with the attempted murder of Richmond Police Ofc. Seara Burton, it was just the latest in a long list of felonies that have kept a habitual criminal behind bars for 22 of the past 28 years.
Lee’s previous charges include possession of marijuana and cocaine, burglary, battery, escape, auto theft and perjury – just to name a few. During his previous encounters with law enforcement, police reports show Lee repeatedly attempted to flee from officers and, in some cases, bite them and try to steal their service weapons.
In November 2017, when Lee plead guilty to resisting law enforcement, a probable cause affidavit filed by a Richmond Police officer stated, “Officers were aware that Lee claimed he was not going back to jail and would shoot any officer or agent that encountered him.”
So a plea deal offered to Lee in 2018 – a deal that allowed him to serve less than four years in state prison instead of a possible ten years behind bars – raised questions, especially after the convicted felon shot and critically injured a police officer just a few months after his release.
13 Investigates has now learned why Lee got that plea deal: investigators failed to collect critical evidence at the crime scene.
A 2017 arrest could have sent Phillip Lee to prison for a decade, but his attorney negotiated a deal for a much lighter sentence.
Court documents show Lee was arrested in 2017 at his girlfriend’s North 20th Street home in Richmond when he tested positive for methamphetamine, cocaine and THC during an unannounced parole check.
At the time, an officer identified in court documents as a Wayne County Sheriff’s deputy also found a loaded rifle propped up against a wall between the living room and kitchen, according to a probable cause affidavit. (13News has since discovered an error in the court paperwork. The officer worked for the Richmond Police Department, not the sheriff’s department.)
Wayne County Prosecutor Michael Shipman charged Lee with multiple felonies including possession of narcotics and possession of a syringe, as well as possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon. But the firearm charge – the most serious one Lee faced – was dropped as part of a plea deal despite Lee’s violent history and threats against police.
RELATED: ‘Surrounded by her family’ | Richmond PD chief says Ofc. Seara Burton being moved to hospice
The prosecutor agreed to dismiss the firearm charge in exchange for a guilty plea to the drug charges. As a habitual criminal with at least three previous felony convictions, Lee received a four-year sentence instead of a possible ten.
He served that sentence at several Indiana state prisons before earning his release this January.
Seven months later, Lee followed through on the threat he made in 2017. When Ofc. Burton approached him in early August during a stop for suspected drug activity, the convicted felon shot Burton in the head. Had Lee been convicted of the firearm charge, he likely would have been in prison at least until 2023 based on the state’s recommended sentencing guidelines.
To better understand why a habitual violent offender with a history of violence and threats against law enforcement was offered a plea agreement, 13 Investigates requested an audio recording of Lee’s 2018 sentencing hearing in Wayne County Superior Court.
The recording reveals the prosecutor did not have the evidence needed to pursue the serious firearm charge against Lee. During the hearing, Shipman told Superior Court Judge Charles Todd:
“There’s no forensic analysis done to confirm that Mr. Lee’s fingerprints were on there, any kind of DNA evidence. It’s just one of those ‘it was in the home type of things,’ therefore he was arrested for it. And his co-defendant, Ms. White, has taken responsibility for several of the items inside the home, and so we felt there was an evidentiary dispute about who actually possessed that firearm since it wasn’t specifically linked to Mr. Lee, although it was found inside the home. And we recognized that should it proceed to trial, that’s going to be an evidentiary issue for a jury to consider, and there may be a reasonable doubt raised as to that particular issue. And so we agreed to kind of come to a middle ground here where he would plead to the drug offenses that he did commit and the other offenses would be dismissed for that specific reason.”
Todd accepted the plea agreement after finding the deal to be “reasonable.”
But the sentencing hearing raises another important question: Why didn’t the prosecutor have the necessary forensic evidence to proceed with the charge?
Shipman responded to that question this week, and his answer casts doubts on how law enforcement and parole officers conducted their investigation.
This week, in response to questions from 13 Investigates, Shipman explained the reason he did not test the rifle to see if Lee’s fingerprints were on the weapon.
“The rifle which supported the charge was not collected by police and placed into evidence storage at RPD [Richmond Police Department],” he told 13News. “We learned this after Mr. Lee was arrested. We could not prove the Serious Violent Felon count because the rifle was not available to present to a jury. It was important to collect the rifle as evidence so that it could be tested for fingerprints, DNA, etc. Since it was not available, no testing could be done to prove who possessed the rifle.”
He also said after the charge was filed, Lee’s girlfriend claimed the rifle belonged to her and that multiple people in and out of the home also had access to the rifle, making it “not possible to circumstantially prove that Mr. Lee exclusively possessed the rifle.”
His conclusion: “Due to this lack of evidence and other factors described above, I could not prove the SVF charge beyond a reasonable doubt. I was legally and ethically obligated to dismiss the charge.”
A Richmond Police evidence sheet shows the law enforcement official who accompanied parole officers to Lee’s parole visit collected three pieces of drug-related evidence (plastic bags containing plant matter, a vial containing red liquid and a glass pipe that contained residue) — but not the rifle located at the scene.
Veteran law enforcement officials contacted by 13News question the decision to not take the firearm into custody.
“I’m confused as to why it was not seized. That is very curious to me,” said Lawrence Hunter, a police consultant and retired police captain who served 24 years with the Waterbury (Conn.) Police Department. “When there is a firearm in a home where a felon is known to be living — not just visiting but living — generally it is standard operating procedure to take possession of the firearm to perform tests on it to see if others crimes have been committed with it and to see if the felon has come in contact with the firearm.”
Hunter said not seizing a firearm, especially when it’s not clear who the weapon belongs to, is likely an oversight.
“It could be a mistake – a very costly one as we see the results that have come back to harm law enforcement directly,” he said.
13News also spoke with a longtime prosecutor in another Indiana county who said he had never heard of a case in which a weapon was not seized by police when it was found in a home where a serious violent felon was living.
“That just doesn’t happen, and if it happened in my county and came through my office, I’d flip out and get a search warrant to go back and get that weapon,” said the prosecutor, who asked not to be identified due to the sensitivity of the case. “That’s shocking to me because that gun should have been collected. The system failed and it’s a shocking failure.”
The prosecutor also questioned Shipman’s claim that it was not possible for him to prove that Mr. Lee “exclusively possessed the rifle.”
He said proving exclusive possession is not required to successfully prosecute a convicted felon under Indiana’s law for possession of a firearm by a serious violent felon. Instead, a prosecutor would need only to prove the felon had “actual” or “constructive” possession of the weapon.
Actual possession means the individual was holding the firearm or had it on their person. Constructive possession means an individual had knowledge that a weapon was in their residence and had access to it.
“I don’t buy the argument that the case couldn’t be prosecuted,” said the prosecutor who spoke to 13News on the condition of anonymity. “Even if the firearm belonged to someone else, if he lived there and the gun was leaning against a wall in a common area, he flat-out possessed that gun. It’s not a hard case to win.”
13News contacted the Wayne County Sheriff’s Department to ask why the person identified as a sheriff’s deputy in the probable cause affidavit did not collect the rifle seen at the home where Lee was living.
Sheriff Randy Retter told 13News he had no record of that individual ever working for the Wayne County Sheriff’s Office.
“I’m not sure how he was mistaken as a deputy, and believe he was an officer with the Richmond Police Department during incident you are inquiring about,” he wrote.
RELATED: Man accused of shooting Richmond police officer makes 1st court appearance
13 Investigates contacted the officer listed in the court document, and he confirmed he was actually employed by the Richmond Police Department at the time of the investigation. He is now a member of the department’s detective bureau.
13 Investigates has asked both the Richmond Police Department and the officer why he did not seize the rifle found in the home where Lee was living in 2017.
Richmond Police Chief Michael Britt responded Friday afternoon.
“The facts of this case are under review at this time. I may be in a better position to make an informed response next week,” he wrote. “My staff have been directed, by me, not to make any statements on this matter and all responses would come from me.”
13 Investigates is still waiting for the officer to provide an answer.
13News also contacted the Indiana Department of Correction (which oversees the state’s parole program) to ask why parole officers did not collect the rifle. The department told 13News it is the responsibility of police — not parole officers — to collect evidence.
“Parole agents are not law enforcement officers so when they believe a crime has been committed, they contact local law enforcement to investigate and collect evidence needed to pursue prosecution. That was done in this case, and a parole violation was issued for violations found during that visit,” said IDOC chief communications officer Annie Goeller.
Following the shooting, Lee is back in jail awaiting trial for two counts of attempted murder. According to Richmond Police, Burton is in a Richmond-area hospice facility after her family decided to remove her from life support.
Editor’s Note: This story has been updated to reflect an error in the probable cause affidavit filed by the Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office in 2017. That court document incorrectly identified the law enforcement officer – at the home where Lee was arrested – as a sheriff’s deputy. He in fact worked for the Richmond Police Department.
Paid Advertisement
Notifications can be turned off anytime in the browser settings.
IKEA to launch the OBEGRÄNSAD collection in collaboration with Swedish House Mafia – About IKEA
Shop at IKEA?
Choose your IKEA retail website
Shop at IKEA?
Choose your IKEA retail website
IKEA and Swedish House Mafia have teamed up to democratise music production at home and enable the many music lovers to unleash their creativity. The result is the OBEGRÄNSAD collection, with more than 20 products, which will be launched globally in October 2022.
IKEA and electronic music artists Swedish House Mafia set to explore music and creativity at home and make everyday life easier for those who produce, perform, play, or listen to music. The result of the collaboration is OBEGRÄNSAD, a limited collection that will enable the many rising creatives in music and digital arts to build the perfect home studio at an affordable price.
The OBEGRÄNSAD collection, which means unlimited in Swedish, targets everyone who values music experience at home and beyond: music fans, music producers, DJs, and all creators with limited means but unlimited creativity. Technology development has enabled democratisation of music and music production, and the collection aims to support the creative pursuits of the many people creating, performing, and enjoying music at home.
The collection is built on the band’s insights about the needs of those starting their music or creative career.
“Since we were kids, we have valued the IKEA approach of making things affordable and available for a lot of people. We used to find a creative way to make IKEA furniture to accommodate our teenage lives as creatives, so the collaboration’s purpose was formed around our own personal journey in life”, says Swedish House Mafia.
The collection consists of more than 20 clever home furnishing solutions for producing and performing music in the home setup – as well as solutions for listening to music and creating a relaxed atmosphere. The collection includes a record player, LED work, wall and floor lamps, a clock; laptop, tablet, speaker, and record stands; a desk, two options of shelving units, an armchair, four options of bags, including an accessory, a record and a laptop bag, rug, and sleepers in two sizes, a throw and a cushion cover.
“We wanted to simplify the process for people to create music. Hopefully, our collection inspires and enables more people to be more creative within their home, and it does not have to be restricted to only music making. It can be so much more”, says Swedish House Mafia.
The up-and-coming DJs and music producers will hopefully appreciate the OBEGRÄNSAD shelving unit, the remake of KALLAX which is designed with an extra space for amplifiers and a higher unit, the OBEGRÄNSAD desk with speaker stands and a pull-out shelf, as well as the OBEGRÄNSAD stands for laptop, tablet, and speakers. A mix of lighting – including ambient light in the OBEGRÄNSAD clock – and soft furnishings are essential for bringing the right mood and getting into creative flow.
The OBEGRÄNSAD collection is designed as an affordable collection with a classic black aesthetic and minimalistic, sleek design that supports the technology and how it is used. As Swedish House Mafia put it: ”the design in our collection features a timeless theme with a distinct trace of our DNA”. The solutions will easily add smart functionality to the existing space – or help build an affordable home studio from scratch.
“Look at the collection and the complexity of it: lights, furniture, tech. That would not have been possible with just any collaboration, but collaboration is in the essence of Swedish House Mafia. It’s in everything they do”, says Friso Wiersma, IKEA in-house designer.
How the OBEGRÄNSAD collection was developed
Share this page
Topics
Related news
Healthy and sustainable living
Design
23 August 2022
Collaborations
Innovation
Healthy and sustainable living
08 August 2022
Collections
Design
Social entrepreneurship
29 June 2022
Get the latest news in your inbox
Subscribe to news
Seized oil tanker remains under arrest in Eq Guinea – Argus Media
View all articles
Notice: By accessing this site you agree that you will not copy or reproduce any part of its contents (including, but not limited to, single prices, graphs or news content) in any form or for any purpose whatsoever without the prior written consent of the publisher.
© 2022 Argus Media group. All rights reserved.
Point Blank Tutorial: How to Make Lo-fi Hip-Hop Chords in Ableton Live – Magnetic Magazine
The term lo-fi comes from “low fidelity,” which refers to a low-quality recording with audible imperfections. These can include anything from background noise to performance mistakes and recordings created with inexpensive equipment. Lo-fi hip-hop is a popular sub-genre within the lo-fi sound that couples these techniques with simplistic rap beats.
Whether you’re new to the world of lo-fi beats or you’ve spent countless hours watching Lofi Girl and her cat (if you know, you know), this tutorial is perfect for helping you adorn your music with that dreamy aesthetic.
At Point Blank Los Angeles, PB’s lecturers can teach you the ins and outs of music production, DJing, singing and songwriting, music business and more. Join the Point Blank LA family today.
To kick off the tutorial, Adal fires up Ableton Live’s stock Drum Rack plugin to load in his electric piano samples. Once his hand-selected rotation of chords is loaded into the Drum Rack, the producer transposes them so that they stay in key with each other during the beat-making process. He adjusts the choke group so that when he triggers a new sample, it cuts off the current one playing and doesn’t overlap and muddy the sound. Once his rack is customized to taste, Adal sets the project to 84 BPM and programs in a chord progression before throwing in a drum loop to bring his lo-fi chords to life.
If you’re keen to make some lo-fi hip-hop chords using the same pack as PB’s lecturer, you can download it from Ableton for free. Want to learn more about crafting beats of your own? Then check out Point Blank’s LA-based Beatmaking Classes.
ASU alum works toward equitable society following recent master's degree – ASU News Now
The School of Politics and Global Studies is laying the foundation for success in graduate school by creating access to opportunities that spark interest and passion, benefiting students well beyond college years.
Arizona State University political science alum Kayla Green recently graduated from American University School of International Service with a Master of Arts in international affairs.
Kayla Green Download Full Image
Green self-designed the regional and thematic concentrations of her degree in order to become a well-informed expert in her area of study.
“My MA gave me a greater comprehension of Africa’s colonial history, comparative political economy, economic development, peace building and so much more,” Green said.
Her time at ASU studying at the School of Politics and Global Studies gave Green a strong foundation that allowed her to transition into the international affairs realm.
Through ASU’s Global Education Office, Green was able to complete three study abroad programs, each with an internship component.
“I used these work experiences on my resume to make myself a stronger candidate for graduate programs and other job opportunities,” Green said.
During her time abroad, Green had the opportunity to study in Ghana, Italy and in Washington, D.C., through the ASU Capital Scholars Program. It was abroad where she developed her passion for African affairs and gained life changing experiences that helped shape her academic journey.
Green recommends that all ASU students complete at least one study abroad trip to enhance their passions and gain hands-on experience in the workforce. Although she needed to take out student loans to help fund these opportunities, the programs she completed have helped cultivate her academic and professional experience.
“These experiences certainly set me up for success, but I also needed to take out student loans to fund these experiences that I am still paying off; that’s not a reality I want to shy away from,” Green said.
Green is currently positioned as an Africa Program Fellow in the Business Council for International Understanding, an organization that offers commercial diplomacy services to leading organizations and governments around the world to help promote the expansion and understanding of global trade and commerce.
In her position, Green works closely with the Africa unit, where she conducts research, manages correspondence and assists with program writing.
Green hopes to eventually become a development practitioner in Sub-Saharan Africa, where she can help countries with fast-growing populations expand the capacity of their institutions to better provide resources and opportunities for their citizens.
Green’s wish is that everyone lives in an equitable society with “autonomy over their own lives,” in which success is not restricted based on where you were born or what your socioeconomic situation is.
“Everyone deserves the right to self-actualization, and if I can in some way expand access to this in the development sector, that would be a dream come true,” she said.
Student Journalist, School of Politics and Global Studies
805-603-7619 [email protected]
Arizona State Women’s Golf will play in Arizona five times during a highly anticipated 2022-23 campaign. …
Arizona State Women’s Golf will play in Arizona five times during a highly anticipated 2022-23 campaign.
Download Full Image
INTERNATIONAL VOICES PROJECT Announces Its Return To Live Performances for 12th Season – Broadway World
Get local news, offers & more…
International Voices Project has announced its return to live performances with the 12th season of play readings by playwrights from around the world, September 12 – 28, at the Instituto Cervantes of Chicago, 31 W. Ohio St. Live readings are held Mondays and Wednesday with an audience talk back and Q+A with key members of that night’s production immediately following the readings.
Doors open at 6 p.m. with readings beginning at 6:30 p.m. The series is presented in collaboration with theatre companies, consulates and other cultural institutions in Chicago. The International Voices Project is the largest event of its kind in the country and introduces Chicago audiences to some of the most exciting voices on the international theater scene. Performances are free to the public and reservations are required. More information on the 2022 season may be found at IVPChicago.org.
“International Voices Project looks forward to welcoming audiences back to celebrate the power of theatre with a global perspective,” said Executive Director Patrizia Acerra. “We are proud that in our 12th season, we continue to give a stage to international voices and Chicago theater companies and talent at no cost to the audience. We encourage all to experience this year’s line up with new playwrights and new stories from around the world.”
The International Voices Project 2022 schedule includes:
Monday, Sept. 12 at 6:30 p.m.
Spain
“The Mapmaker”
Director: Iraida Tapias
Playwright: Juan Mayorga
Partner: Water People Theatre
Translator: Jerelyn Johnson
In present-day Warsaw, Blanca hears the legend of the ghetto cartographer. According to that legend, an old cartographer was determined, while everything was dying around him, to draw the map of that world in danger; but since his legs no longer supported him, since he couldn’t look for the data he needed, it was a girl who went out to look for them for him. Blanca will take the legend for truth and she will launch herself, obsessively, in search of the old map and, without knowing it, in search of herself. The cartographer is a work about that search and about that legend.
Wednesday, Sept. 14 at 6:30 p.m.
Palestine
The Shroud Maker
Director: Rohina Malik
Playwright: Ahmed Masoud
Partners: Intercultural Music Production, Uprising Theater, Medina Theatre Collective
From the critically-acclaimed Palestinian writer Ahmed Masoud, who was born and raised in Gaza, comes the story of Hajja Souad, an 80-year old Palestinian woman living on the besieged Gaza Strip, who knows about business. She has survived decades of wars and oppression through making shrouds for the dead. A compelling black comedy, The Shroud Maker delves deep into the intimate life of ordinary Palestinians to weave a highly distinctive path through Palestine’s turbulent past and present. Loosely based on a real-life character still living in Gaza, this one-woman comedy weaves comic fantasy and satire with true stories told first hand to the writer and offers a vivid portrait of Palestinian life in Gaza underscored with humor.
Monday, Sept. 19 at 6:30 p.m.
Norway
Give Me A Happily Ever After
Playwright: Marius Leknes Snekkevag
Director: Breahan Pautsch
Translator: Kyle Korynta
Director: Breahan Pautsch
Welcome to Life! Fasten your seatbelts, it’s gonna be a bumpy ride! Living is scary, will we be okay in the end?
Wednesday, Sept. 21at 6:30 p.m.
Germany
Turks, Fire
Playwright: Özlem Özgül Dündar
Director: Anna Bahow
Translator: Neil Blackadder
When a residential house is engulfed in flames five people are killed, three children and two women. The perpetrators are youths from the neighborhood. The name of the small town is soon known nationwide thanks to a flurry of media reports. But the nation’s attention soon turns elsewhere to other, more pressing issues. The 1993 arson attack in Solingen is the starting point for Turks, Fire. Writing with great sensitivity and precision, Özlem Özgül Dündar searches for a language to describe those harrowing events that permits all the various perspectives of a space to exist. The resulting play retains a painful relevance for today’s social and political climate.
Monday, Sept. 26 at 6:30 p.m.
Ukraine
Three Plays:
Call Them By Their Names
The Peed-Upon Armored Personnel
A Dictionary of Emotions in War Time
Playwrights: Tetyana Kitsenko, Oksana Gritsenko and Elena Astasyeva
Director: Warner Crocker
Translators: John Freedman, John Freedman/Natalia Bratus, John Freedman/Natalia Bratus
Three voices meld together chronicling thoughts, emotions and horror from the war in Ukraine as it begins and changes the world. Call Them By Their Names by Tetyan Kitsenko, The Peed-Upon Armored Personnel Carrier by Oskana Gritsenko, and A Dictionary of Emotions in a Time of War by Elena Astasyeva immediately transports the audience to the moments that changed the world in an instant and presage a rupture that will take generations to heal.
Wednesday, Sept. 28 at 6:30 p.m.
Poland
Totentanz: Black Night, Black Death
Playwright: Ishbel Szatrawska
Director: Michael Mejia
Partner: Trap Door Theatre
Translator: Soren Gauger
March of 2020, Bergamo, the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Francesca, a former model and her husband, Luca, a television host, have invited some neighbors to an illegal dinner. This innocent social evening gradually turns into a quarrel over the pandemic, Italy, European values, social solidarity and political and ideological views in the crisis situation. Totentanz: Black Night, Black Death was a finalist for a Polish national award, the Gdynia Dramaturgical Prize, in 2021; it has been translated into English, German, Ukrainian, and Danish.
The International Voices Project champions the work of global playwrights by creating opportunities to experience new and contemporary international plays in urban settings and on stages in Chicago. IVP celebrates the mother tongue and foster work that brings native languages to the forefront. From its inception, Chicago was conceived as the crossroads of the country. The rail lines that crossed the city now symbolize the role that Chicago will play in the future: as the center of international dialogue and design, creating opportunities for artists and audiences alike to experience the most engaging and provocative new plays from around the world. We foster new translations, support the work of translators, and create ongoing relationships with playwrights from the five continents.
First Folio to Open Final Season with JEEVES INTERVENES in November
Lyric Opera of Chicago to Present ERNANI Beginning This Week
Photos: First Look at DREAMGIRLS in Performance at Paramount Theatre
Review: MURDER ON THE ORIENT EXPRESS at Drury Lane Theatre
Hot stories
Victory Gardens Theater Dismisses Remaining Staff Following Unionization Effort
Photos: First Look at THE NOTEBOOK Musical
Possibilities Theater Company To Open Season with Zack Peercys GREETINGS
Ginger Minj to Star as Winifred in HOCUS POCUS HALLOWEEN BASH Tour
BroadwayWorld TV
News + special offers for Broadway Shows
Chicago SHOWS
Recommended for You
Sign-Up for Chicago News
Follow Us
BWW Sister Sites
Apps
From church band to full-fledged music production – Jamaica Observer
KINGSTON, Jamaica — For Jermarle Shirley, music production was a life-long calling. His genesis rooted in his days as a member of his church band, the St Catherine Brass band, the creative found his true love in production at age 16, and the rest as they say it is history.
Today, what started out as him testing his skills at something he always enjoyed has burgeoned into a blossoming career that sees him rubbing shoulders and sharing musical thoughts with some of Jamaica’s most recognisable talents.
“I grew up doing music and I once was a selector that used to play Mello Construction sound system. I started my producing skill in 2013 when I use to mix for a few young artistes. That’s where I found my love for producing. Music however, has been a love since I was going to Church,” he told OBSERVER ONLINE.
Shirley, who goes by the alias Joshie Dan, is the brains behind Day One Productions, a label that hopes to thrust conscious music into the spotlight like never before. Shirley, who prides himself on creating music that oozes positivity, says while he will not limit himself in terms of the genre of music he dabbles in, is fully focused on strengthening the reggae sector. His most recent production, Irie Victory Riddim, he says, will aid in his efforts to shine a light on music that will uplift listeners.
“I have always been someone who is highly conscious. I believe in positive music and the impact it can have on the mindsets of listeners. My latest project will show that. It’s called the Irie Victory Riddim, and it features the likes of Nesbeth, Nature Ellis, Junior Morgan, Brian Gold and Jah Izrehl,” he said.
“From you hear the artistes on the project, you already know what kind of vibe the music will give and if you don’t, then the name of the project should. At Day One Productions, we’re all about ‘irie’ vibes, victory over all things negative. The music already has enough of that. What the industry needs more of is positivity and consciousness.”
The 32-year-old said the project was also inspired by his love for the ‘one-drop’ beat. For him nothing beats authentic Jamaican music and he wanted to take listeners on a nostalgic journey back to what many dubbed as music’s glory days.
“I was inspired to do this project because people kept telling me they miss having an authentic one drop juggling and as a music lover I understood what they meant. There’s just something about that music that makes you feel good inside and that’s what I want to do with Day One Productions,” he said. “I want to make music that is authentic, inspirational, educational, unifying and spiritual. I also wanted to do something that was fun and easy on the ears. The songs by the artistes on this ‘riddim’ are all that and more.”
Irie Victory Riddim was released back in July and Shirley says so far, it has been receiving great feedback.
“The love for the riddim has been great so far. I just want people to tune in some more. This is the kind of music you want to feed your soul. It will not only make you feel good but will leave you feeling like nothing can get you down.”
The songs on Irie Victory Riddim can be found on all digital platforms islandwide.
Now you can read the Jamaica Observer ePaper anytime, anywhere. The Jamaica Observer ePaper is available to you at home or at work, and is the same edition as the printed copy available at
HOUSE RULES
Honea becomes the 16th master chief petty officer of the Navy – NavyTimes.com
Master Chief James Honea became the Navy’s 16th chief petty officer of the Navy Thursday during a ceremony at the U.S. Naval Academy in Annapolis, Maryland.
Honea, a sailor for 35 years, most recently served as the senior enlisted leader for U.S. Indo-Pacific Command and was described by Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Mike Gilday as having “saltwater running through his veins,” according to a video recording of the ceremony posted online.
During Thursday’s ceremony, Gilday praised outgoing MCPON Russell Smith, who became “MCPON 15″ in August 2018, as a “true leader” who never shied away from tough assignments.
“You’re a chief to the core and a sailor who’s dedicated to sailors,” Gilday told Smith. “You care for sailors like few other leaders I have met in the Navy.”
“As you go ashore for the final time, know that this nation and our Navy are forever grateful for your lifetime of honorable service,” Gilday said.
As Honea takes on the role of the Navy’s top enlisted sailor, the sea service has yet to publicly disclose the findings of an internal investigation into his predecessor, MCPON Smith.
Navy Times reported in February that the Naval Inspector General was investigating Smith over allegations of misconduct.
But to date, the Navy has not formally clarified the outcome of that investigation and Smith did not return a phone message this week seeking a comment on the investigation’s status.
Sitting on stage next to Smith Thursday was retired Adm. Bill Moran, the former vice CNO who was slated to become CNO before his sudden retirement in 2019.
That retirement came after a Defense Department investigation found Moran used personal email for official business, including with an officer dogged by sexual harassment allegations.
The former admiral praised Smith during Thursday’s ceremony for always meeting the moment.
“We are, all of us, forever your shipmates and friends, personally and professionally blessed to have served alongside you,” Moran said. “You will be missed.”
During his speech, Smith jokingly recalled how he once told the former Chief of Naval Personnel, retired Vice Adm. John Nowell, that the F-word was “the word of the proletariat,” and that if Nowell used that word around the chiefs mess, he would be fine.
“He looked at me, like, it worked!” Smith recalled to audience laughter.
Smith enlisted in 1988 and spent most of Thursday’s speech praising those with whom he forged a bond over the decades.
“The value for me has always lied in the relationships, the friends and shipmates who have become my family,” he said. “I’ve had this Navy family carry me for the past 34 years, and I know no one has been so fortunate as I in that regard.”
Geoff is a senior staff reporter for Military Times, focusing on the Navy. He covered Iraq and Afghanistan extensively and was most recently a reporter at the Chicago Tribune. He welcomes any and all kinds of tips at [email protected].
Navy Times © 2022
Navy Times © 2022
SC Democrats call on US Senate nominee to quit race against US Sen. Tim Scott – Greenville News
COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The South Carolina Democrat vying to oust Republican U.S. Sen. Tim Scott is facing calls from within her own party to fold her campaign, following the publication of additional leaked audio in which she appears to make disparaging remarks about her constituents.
The calls for state Rep. Krystle Matthews to withdraw just two months ahead of the general election came Thursday in reaction to leaked audio published by conservative activist group Project Veritas of Matthews speaking to one of its members, without her knowledge.
Sitting in a restaurant, Matthews, who is Black, is heard saying that she represents a “mostly white” district, adding, of white voters: “I keep them right here — like under my thumbs. … Otherwise, they get out of control — like kids.”
In a statement, Matthews acknowledged her voice on the recording, calling Project Veritas a “satirical MAGA Powered news outlet.”
The compilation also features more of Matthews’ conversation, parts of which were previously published by Project Veritas, in which she spoke to an inmate about funding her campaign with “dope boy money” and having Democrats run as Republicans, saying “secret sleepers” represent “the only way you’re gonna change the dynamics in South Carolina.”
At the time of the earlier release, ahead of South Carolina’s June primary runoff, Matthews confirmed to The Associated Press that it was her voice on the tape but said the edited audio of a “tongue-in-cheek” exchange didn’t reflect the full picture.
Matthews won the runoff to face Scott, who is seeking what he’s said will be his final Senate term and is among South Carolina’s most popular politicians. The Black Republican is widely expected to win the general election in South Carolina, where no Democrat has won a statewide race in more than 15 years.
On Thursday, Democrats including gubernatorial nominee Joe Cunningham said he concurred with state Rep. Justin Bamberg, who in an op-ed published online called Matthews “toxic.”
“If any of our white counterparts had said the same thing with regards to blacks, the minority community, including myself, would be up in arms calling for that member’s immediate resignation,” Bamberg added.
In a statement provided to AP, Cunningham said that “there is absolutely no place in our political discourse” for Matthews’ comments, adding that “the Democratic Party cannot and should not tolerate such behavior from our elected officials and candidates.”
State Sen. Brad Hutto, Democrats’ leader in that chamber — who was also his party’s nominee to challenge U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham in 2014 — echoed Cunningham’s comments about Matthews’ Senate bid, telling AP, “When candidates of either party start making irresponsible statements, beyond what party they’re from, they need to reevaluate their candidacy, and that’s what needs to happen here.”
One of the fellow Democrats Matthews defeated, Catherine Fleming Bruce, told AP she agreed with the calls for Matthews to step aside, saying the nominee “has made it impossible for her to be that standard bearer, representing our state’s diverse population.”
Trav Robertson, chairman of the state’s Democrats, emphasized on Thursday that Matthews didn’t represent the party’s perspective but stopped short of urging her to quit her campaign, which he said was “becoming a distraction to other Democrats on the ballot.”
“If I were advising her campaign, I would focus on her getting reelected to the (state) House of Representatives,” Robertson told AP.
Were Matthews to suspend her campaign, her name would likely still remain on ballots, which party officials said were already being produced for overseas voters. With no third-party candidate in the race, Scott’s name is the only other that would appear.
“Regardless of race, I love everyone,” Matthews said in her statement. “One thing you can learn from Project Veritas’s first audio attack on me, is obviously I have no biases toward a certain ethnic group.”
___
James Pollard contributed to this report.
ASU Music Theatre and Opera 2022–23 season provides range of opportunities for students, audiences – ASU News Now
Arizona State University’s Music Theatre and Opera 2022–23 season is filled with full-scale productions after two years of smaller productions due to COVID-19.
“We are still taking precautions, but this year’s season is focused on providing as many opportunities for students as possible, creating a season that our audience is excited to see, while, at the same time, continuing to diversify and expand our repertoire,” said Brian DeMaris, artistic director of Music Theatre and Opera and associate professor in the School of Music, Dance and Theatre.
ASU Music Theatre and Opera 2022–23 season Download Full Image
DeMaris said the specific productions for each season are selected from a list of titles submitted for consideration by anyone in the School of Music, Dance and Theatre. The program’s faculty, staff and open-access Student Leadership Team then narrow down the submissions into a short list based on the season’s pedagogical goals.
“We then work with other areas and community partners to identify dates and titles that work in tandem with the countless other performances on campus and in the community to ensure maximum impact,” DeMaris said.
The opening production, “Daughter of the Regiment,” is a fun and funny French operetta. “Head Over Heels,” an energetic show based on the hit tunes of the Go-Go’s, breaks boundaries and will feature an all female-identifying rock band. “The Rake’s Progress,” a masterpiece by Igor Stravinsky featuring the words of W. H. Auden, is a rare performance of a monumental and challenging work, and — to DeMaris’ knowledge — the first time the work has been produced in Arizona.
“Into the Woods,” which was selected because of the ways in which ASU students can tell the story and portray the characters, is a complex and uplifting musical with a timeless quality that allows the story to resonate with audiences of all ages and eras. The work speaks to many people, DeMaris said, not only because of Stephen Sondheim’s recent passing, but because of the figurative “woods” many have been through during the pandemic.
Songs from “Liquid Days,” led by graduate student Mario Yniguez, is ASU’s first stage production of an opera by the prolific composer Philip Glass. “Little Women,” a timeless female-driven story, is the second entirely student-led production and provides students with the opportunity to select, design, build, direct and choreograph their own show.
“Our student lab process provides opportunities for student leadership and community building, while simultaneously enabling students to try their hand in skills outside of performing on stage,” DeMaris said.
Individual student performers will be featured in the class of 2023 Musical Theatre Showcase and in multiple cabaret performances, including the annual student-led Holiday Cabaret and Color Cabaret.
Tickets are available online in advance through the Herberger Institute Box Office. Ticket prices and venues vary. Face coverings are recommended in School of Music, Dance and Theatre indoor performance spaces. University COVID-19 information may be found at coronavirus.asu.edu.
2022-23 ASU Music Theatre and Opera Season
“Daughter of the Regiment”
7:30 p.m., Sept. 23 and 24
2 p.m., Sept. 25
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
Music by Gaetano Donizetti
Libretto by Jules-Henri Vernoy de Saint-Georges and Jean-François
English dialogue by Ruth and Thomas Martin
“Songs from Liquid Days” (student lab production)
7:30 p.m., Oct. 28 and 29
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
Music by Philip Glass
Libretto by Paul Simon, Suzanne Vega, David Byrne and Laurie Anderson
“Head Over Heels”
7:30 p.m., Nov. 17,18 and 19
2 p.m., Nov. 20
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
Songs by The Go-Go’s
Based on “The Arcadia” by Sir Philip Sidney
Conceived by and original book by Jeff Whitty
Adaptation by James Magruder
Holiday Cabaret
7:30 p.m., Nov. 29
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
“Little Women, the Broadway Musical” (student lab production)
7:30p.m., Jan. 13 and 14
2 p.m, Jan. 15
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
Book by Allen Knee
Music by Jason Howland
Lyrics by Mindi Dickstein
Based on the novel by Louisa May Alcott
Color Cabaret
7:30 p.m., Feb. 4
2 p.m., Feb. 5
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
“The Rake’s Progress”
7:30 p.m., Feb. 24 and 25
2 p.m., Feb. 26
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
Music by Igor Stravinsky
Libretto by W. H. Auden and Chester Kallman
“Into the Woods”
7:30 p.m., April 14, 15, 20, 21 and 22
2 p.m., April 16 and 23
Purchase tickets
Evelyn Smith Music Theatre
Book by James Lapine
Music and Lyrics by Stephen Sondheim
Musical Theatre Showcase
7:30 p.m., April 25
location TBD
All Herberger Institute students, faculty and staff are eligible for complimentary tickets to most events (see policies). Click buy tickets to obtain your complimentary tickets using your 10-digit ASU ID as the promo code.
“The Daughter of the Regiment” by Gaetano Donizetti is presented under license from G. Schirmer Inc. and Associated Music Publishers, copyright owners. “Head Over Heels” is produced by special arrangement with Broadway Licensing. “Little Women, The Broadway Musical” and “Into the Woods” are presented through special arrangement with Music Theatre International (MTI). All authorized performance materials are also supplied by MTI. “The Rake’s Progress” is presented by arrangement with Boosey & Hawkes, Inc., publisher and copyright owner.
communications specialist, School of Music
480-727-7189 [email protected]
As part of ASU’s celebration of Hispanic Heritage Month, ASU Wind Bands launches their 2022–23 season on Sept. 15 at ASU Gammage with a concert featuring composers representing Argentina, Colombia, Cuba and Mexico.Joining them on stage are students from ASU Dance, CONDER|dance and Grupo BombAZo, a collective of Phoenix-based musicians.“The focus of this year’s concert season is collaboration…
As part of ASU’s celebration of Hispanic Heritage Month, ASU Wind Bands launches their 2022–23 season on Sept. 15 at ASU Gammage with a concert featuring composers representing Argentina, Colombia, Cuba and Mexico.
Joining them on stage are students from ASU Dance, CONDER|dance and Grupo BombAZo, a collective of Phoenix-based musicians.
ASU Wind Bands Download Full Image
“The focus of this year’s concert season is collaboration,” said Jason Caslor, director of bands at ASU.
In addition to connecting with fellow musicians in two public high schools though joint concerts, Caslor said the wind bands have planned on-campus collaborations with ASU Dance, ASU Theatre, The Sidney Poitier New American Film School, the ASU Composition Studio and the ASU Choral Program.
Other guest artists joining them this year include composer Shuying Li, conductors Gillian MacKay and Leah McGray, and ASU faculty Nathan De’Shon Myers (baritone), Joe Burgstaller (trumpet), Brad Edwards (trombone) and Albie Micklich (bassoon).
“We are always looking for ways to bring guest artists to campus that will inspire and share their unique perspectives with our student musicians,” said Jamal Duncan, ASU’s associate director of bands.
“We also think it is important to showcase the incredibly talented artists in the School of Music, Dance and Theatre,” Caslor said. “Sharing the stage with them is always a privilege.”
October sees the ASU Chamber Winds and the Maroon and Gold Band at the Madison Center for the Arts to present music that ranges from intimate chamber music to repertoire requiring a large concert band. November has the Wind Symphony and Wind Ensemble at ASU Gammage for an evening inspired by the works of William Shakespeare, Langston Hughes and Nina Simone. The Wind Symphony glides into Thanksgiving with DMA conducting student Dylan Maddix’s recital that fittingly focuses on the theme of “home.”
Spring concerts include “Hollywood!” in January, Paul Hindemith’s epic “Symphony in Bb” in February, a side-by-side with Tempe High School in March and an April performance of David Maslanka’s “Traveler.” The Wind Symphony and Maroon and Gold Band close the season in late April celebrating the successes and accomplishments of the students.
To view the 2022–23 full season and concert repertoire, visit the ASU Wind Bands website. Face coverings are recommended in School of Music, Dance and Theatre indoor performance spaces. University COVID-19 information can be found at coronavirus.asu.edu.
ASU Wind Bands 2022–23 season
ASU Wind Ensemble and Wind Symphony
“Celebrating Hispanic and Latinx Heritage Month”
7:30 p.m., Thursday, Sept. 15 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
ASU Chamber Winds and Maroon and Gold Band
7:30 p.m., Tuesday, Oct. 4 | Tickets
Madison Center for the Arts, Phoenix
ASU Wind Ensemble and Mountain Ridge High School Band
7 p.m., Wednesday, Oct. 5
Mountain Ridge High School
ASU Wind Ensemble and Wind Symphony
“From Shakespeare to Simone”
7:30 p.m., Thursday, Nov. 2 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
ASU Wind Ensemble
“Home”
7:30 p.m., Wednesday, Nov. 21
Organ Hall
ASU Wind Symphony and Maroon and Gold Band
“Give Us This Day”
7:30 p.m., Tuesday, Nov. 29 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
ASU Wind Ensemble
“Hollywood!”
7:30 p.m, Friday, Jan. 27, 2023 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
ASU Chamber Winds
7:30 p.m., Wednesday, Feb. 8, 2023
Katzin Concert Hall
ASU Maroon and Gold Band and Philharmonia
7:30 p.m., Tuesday, Feb. 14, 2023| Tickets
ASU Gammage
ASU Wind Ensemble and Wind Symphony
“From Venice With Love”
7:30 p.m, Wednesday, Feb. 15, 2023 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
Wind Symphony and Tempe High School Band
7 p.m., Wednesday, March 22, 2023
Tempe High School
ASU Wind Ensemble
7:30 p.m., Wednesday, April 12, 2023 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
ASU Wind Symphony & Maroon and Gold Band
“Stokowski’s Bells”
7:30 p.m., Tuesday, April 25, 2023 | Tickets
ASU Gammage
Tickets for ASU Gammage concerts are available for $12 at the ASU Gammage Box Office or can be purchased online at Ticketmaster (fees apply) for the general public. All students with an ASU, college or school ID, and all Herberger Institute faculty and staff are eligible for complimentary tickets.
communications specialist, School of Music
480-727-7189 [email protected]
Contact us
The Mid-Tier Power Index: 21-40 results revealed – Accountancy Age
Accountancy Age’s new ranking will champion excellence among the industry’s mid-tier
The first wave of results in Accountancy Age’s brand new ranking, the Mid-Tier Power Index (MTPI), has been revealed.
Today’s announcement includes the firms ranked 21-40, which are as follows:
Firm
Position
Saffery Champness LLP
21
EQ Accountants LLP
22
Lubbock Fine
23
Wilson Partners Limited
24
Barnes Roffe LLP
25
Bevan Buckland LLP
26
Gerald Edelman
27
Raffingers
28
Buzzacott
29
Champion Group
30
Sedulo
31
Albert Goodman LLP
32
Ross Brooke Ltd
33
dns accountants
34
Mercer & Hole
35
The Affinity Group
36
WSM Partners LLP
37
Chiene + Tait
38
HURST
39
Wilson Wright
40
The announcement of the top 20 is set for Friday, September 16, 2022.
The inaugural MTPI ranking seeks to reward and recognise mid-tier firms in the UK that champion true accountancy excellence, with organisations judged on four key categories: Achievement of Business Goals, People Development, Revenue Growth and Exceptional Client Delivery.
Topping the scores in this first wave was Saffery Champness. The firm has excelled within the Achievement of Business Goals category, demonstrating investment in its employer brand in addition to a series of learning and development initiatives.
Scotlands’ EQ Accountants shone in the Exceptional Client Delivery category. This was largely expressed through increased visibility, with measures such as increased availability for out-of-hours calls or on-premises meetings.
In the Revenue Growth category, Lubbock Fine particularly stood out to our judging panel. Despite the turbulent economic picture and changing market conditions, it has taken on 346 new clients during the past year and is projected to see a £1.4m uptick in annual revenue.
Finally, Berkshire-based Wilson Partners boasted a number of achievements in the People Development category. Employees’ wellbeing, aspirations and their impact on the local community are core to the firm’s overall vision, it said.
The new ranking is designed to place the spotlight on the UK accountancy industry’s mid-tier. Firms are judged and ranked on a series of qualitative criteria, rather than quantitative metrics alone such as fee income.
Our entrants have been carefully judged by a panel of experts from across the UK accountancy industry, including partners, directors and chief executives from a selection of leading accounting firms and professional bodies. They are as follows:
The MPTI will join Accountancy Age’s portfolio of industry-leading rankings, sitting alongside the annual 35 under 35 and 50+50.
More about:
Stephen Heathcote, CEO of PrimeGlobal, highlights five essential steps all firms should take to be ESG ready Read More…
Firms must tighten their scrutiny of candidates whilst also bolstering their IT skills development infrastructure, experts say Read More…
With more organisations adopting a hybrid working model, managing employees’ security habits is a bigger challenge than ever, explains John Edwards, C…
Nearly half of accountants have left a role due to a lack of training opportunities, new research indicates Read More…
Just four days remain for UK accounting firms to secure their entries for the brand new industry ranking Read More…
Burnout is leading to mistakes as survey finds 85% of accountants reopened their books at least once over the last year to fix errors Read More…
Time is running out for firms to secure their entries for the Accountancy Age’s new ranking Read More…
The FRC intervention to prevent cheating in the UK follows huge fines issued to firms in the US, Australia, and Canada Read More…
Copyright © 2022 Accountancy Age
Watch Washington vs. Portland State: TV channel, live stream info, start time – CBS Sports
Play Now
Football Pick’em
Play Now
College Football Pick’em
Start or Sit (NFC Home Games)
Talking the business of sports
Portland State @ Washington
Current Records: Portland State 0-1; Washington 1-0
Last Season Records: Washington 4-8; Portland State 5-6
The Washington Huskies will stay at home another week and welcome the Portland State Vikings at 4 p.m. ET Sept. 10 at Alaska Airlines Field at Husky Stadium. Washington earned a 41-3 in their most recent contest in September of 2016.
The Huskies entered their matchup last week as the heavy favorite, and they fully lived up to the hype. They took their game against the Kent State Golden Flashes by a conclusive 45-20 score. The game was all but wrapped up at the end of the third, by which point Washington had established a 38-13 advantage. QB Michael Penix Jr. had a stellar game for Washington as he passed for four TDs and 345 yards on 39 attempts.
Meanwhile, Portland State was within striking distance but couldn’t close the gap last Thursday as they fell 21-17 to the San Jose State Spartans.
Washington’s victory lifted them to 1-0 while Portland State’s loss dropped them down to 0-1. We’ll find out if Washington can add another positive mark to their record or if the Vikings can shake off the defeat and take the spring out of Washington’s step.
Washington won the only game these two teams have played in the last eight years.
© 2004-2022 CBS Interactive. All Rights Reserved.
CBS Sports is a registered trademark of CBS Broadcasting Inc. Commissioner.com is a registered trademark of CBS Interactive Inc.
Images by Getty Images and US Presswire
SHOP ANASTASIA
MOCKINGBIRD MUG
NEXT BWW EVENTS STREAM