The appeals court found that Michigan litigants failed to show their First Amendment rights were violated when they were denied access to court recordings.
CINCINNATI (CN) — A pair of Michigan litigants do not have a fundamental right to the audio recordings of their court proceedings, the Sixth Circuit held Thursday.
The three-judge panel found that Kolu Stevens and Claudette Greenhoe failed to show they were entitled to the court-made recordings under the First Amendment.
“For our part, we have found no case establishing the historical availability of audio recordings of court proceedings when a party can attend a trial, receive a transcript, and request the right to record the proceedings themselves,” wrote U.S. Circuit Judge Karen Moore, a Clinton appointee, in a 15-page opinion.
The ruling culminated out of two separate legal cases in Michigan. According to court documents, Greenhoe and her husband were involved in a matter before the Bay County Probate Court while Stevens was a party to case before the Family Division of the Antrim County Circuit Court
In both cases, the parties sought and were denied the audio recordings of their proceedings, which they tried to get based on their belief that the court transcripts contained serious errors.
They filed a federal lawsuit challenging the denials but U.S. District Judge Paul Maloney ruled against them, finding that no First Amendment rights were violated when the courts denied access to the recordings.
During oral arguments before the Sixth Circuit in June, attorney Philip Ellison argued that his clients were wrongfully denied the recordings as the state of Michigan had designed such recordings as “court records.”
Moore wrote that while courts have established a First Amendment right to court records, the label a state places on specific records is not all encompassing for First Amendment access rights.
The ruling states that the U.S. Supreme Court has given lower courts instructions to look to “experience and logic” when determining whether a specific set of materials are subject to access under the First Amendment, and that Greenhoe and Stevens failed to advance an argument that addressed that fact.
“As a result, we need not consider whether these local courts entered findings sufficient to support their bans on providing audio recordings, because Appellants have not shown that they had a First Amendment right to access the recordings to begin with,” Moore wrote. “In sum, Appellants have failed to present any argument as to the relevant legal test. These Appellants therefore have not shown a violation of First Amendment guarantees under the circumstances of this case.”
Ellison expressed disappointment in the court’s ruling in a statement Thursday.
“We have received the Sixth Circuit’s opinion and are disappointed by its unpublished decision,” the attorney said. “The opinion is being carefully studied and evaluated to guide our next steps on an important constitutional challenge specifically seeking to infuse needed transparency into important state courts throughout Michigan and beyond.”
Joining Moore in the unanimous ruling were U.S. Circuit Judges Danny Boggs, a Reagan appointee, and Richard Griffin, appointed by George W. Bush.
Sign up for the Top 8, a roundup of the day’s top stories delivered directly to your inbox Monday through Friday.
Sixth Circuit rules against access to court audio records – Courthouse News Service
Tory leadership race: Truss takes on Sunak in Manchester – as it happened – The Guardian
The two candidates faced questions from Conservative members on the NHS, trade unions, and energy bills
Michael Gove has backed Rishi Sunak to be the next Conservative leader, accusing Liz Truss of taking a “holiday from reality”.
He told The Times: “I do not expect to be in government again. But it was the privilege of my life to spend 11 years in the cabinet under three prime ministers. I know what the job requires. And Rishi has it.”
Gove, who was sacked as the levelling up secretary by Boris Johnson, added: “And here I am deeply concerned that the framing of the leadership debate by many has been a holiday from reality.
“The answer to the cost-of-living crisis cannot be simply to reject further ‘handouts’ and cut tax.”
Labour has urged Boris Johnson to recall parliament next week so the government can offer more help to struggling households before the announcement of the new energy price cap. The opposition has written to the prime minister and both Tory leadership candidates warning that it is a “crucial deadline” for government action to tackle soaring energy bills, after inflation topped 10% for the first time in 40 years.
At the latest hustings in Manchester, Liz Truss sidestepped a question about a 2009 report which she co-authored emerging today which called for doctors pay to be cut by 10%. She said doctors and nurses “feel like they are being told what to do from Whitehall rather than understanding the situation in their local area and being able to respond to their patients’ needs”. The foreign secretary also called for more transparency about the police’s record on fighting crime and having league tables for forces.
At the hustings, Rishi Sunak was asked how he will deal with trade unions and said: “We need to crack on and pass a piece of legislation,” he says, referring to the minimum service bill which means they will not be able to hold the country “to ransom”. On crime, Sunak said he wants a new unit in the National Crime Agency to deal with grooming gangs and says we need to record the ethnicity of perpetrators.
A former executive at the oil company BP has called for increases to the energy price cap to be scrapped and for suppliers that fail to help households struggling with bills to be nationalised. Nick Butler, who worked for BP for almost 30 years and was group vice-president for strategy and development, said that expected rises in the cap should be abandoned by the industry regulator, Ofgem, which he said had been “overwhelmed by events” after turmoil in the global energy markets sent 29 British energy retailers to the wall.
Conservative leadership frontrunner Liz Truss has been accused of showing “her true colours” in an 2009 paper promoting government spending cuts including slashing doctors’ pay. Truss called for patients to be charged to see their GP and for doctors’ pay to be slashed by 10% in a controversial report she co-authored when she was deputy director of the Reform thinktank, TalkTV discovered.
Railway changes will be imposed if workers do not agree to new deals, the transport secretary, Grant Shapps, has said. The Conservative party has repeatedly targeted unions with criticism, in a move that the Trades Union Congress has argued is deliberately “picking a fight” for electoral purposes.
The frontrunner to be the UK’s next prime minister has made her views on unions clear: she has approvingly tweeted a report that she intends to make striking more difficult. “New laws will make it harder to call strikes and also guarantee minimum levels of service are maintained on public transport”, according to a report by the Daily Express, a newspaper which is strongly pro-government and is supporting Truss in the Conservative leadership race.
The under-fire rail operator Avanti West Coast has been “rewarded for failure”, Labour said, after the company was paid more than £17m in taxpayers’ money by ministers for performance and management fees in just two years, despite being the worst-performing operator on the rail network. The figures from 2019-20 and 2020-21 include almost £4m in bonuses to Avanti for “operational performance”, “customer experience” and “acting as a good and efficient operator”.
The UK’s transport department has announced £130m of funding for England’s bus network to make up for shortfalls in revenues caused by the coronavirus pandemic. The cash would help to cover six months of operations by the private companies who run England’s buses from October 2022 to March 2023, the government said.
A green thinktank has criticised Rishi Sunak’s promise to protect farmland from solar farms, saying biofuels use 77 times the amount of arable land. Dustin Benton, policy director at Green Alliance, said: “Solar energy isn’t standing in the way of food production in the UK. Instead, solar panels generate cheap, clean energy that doesn’t depend on Russia, and provide income to farmers too.”
Rishi Sunak’s campaign has hit out at frontrunner Liz Truss after she declined to attend a hustings organised by the National Farmers’ Union. Farmers now expect Truss to take part in a hustings with the NFU in September, after she was initially accused of snubbing the organisation by deciding not to attend the event on Friday.
Constituents of the Covid rule-breaking MP Margaret Ferrier are said to be “aghast” that she remains in post, as calls for her to resign gathered pace after she pleaded guilty on Thursday to “culpably and recklessly” exposing the public to the virus. The former Scottish National party politician, who now sits as an independent MP for Rutherglen and Hamilton West, faced immediate calls to stand down.
And that brings the hustings to an end.
The remaining hustings are Birmingham on August 23, Norwich on August 25 and London on August 31.
Truss was criticised by an audience member for “sounding like Labour” in wanting to “borrow £50 billion”.
The foreign secretary did not address the criticism but said her fundamental view is that high taxes fail to bring money in to the Exchequer.
Asked by an audience member whether she would build more houses to solve the housing crisis, Truss instead cites her plans to help people secure mortgages and criticised the planning system.
Truss declares she does “support fracking in areas where there is local support”, adding that the local communities should stand to benefit.
The foreign secretary also backs nuclear power and with drilling in the North Sea.
Asked whether local objections from “Nimbys” should be overruled, Truss says local communities need to be shown the benefits and this involves “encouraging” rather than overruling.
Sunak earlier spoke about wanting his football team Southampton to beat Manchester United this weekend, despite them in fact being scheduled to face Leicester City.
He was asked at the Manchester hustings how as a Southampton FC fan how he would get back to winning ways.
“I’m going to be unpopular for saying it here, starting by beating United this weekend,” he said.
Southampton are not due to play Manchester United until August 27.
Truss suggested that retired doctors could be asked to help clear the Covid backlog after many returned to work to help at the start of the pandemic.
Truss said doctors and nurses “feel like they are being told what to do from Whitehall rather than understanding the situation in their local area and being able to respond to their patients’ needs”.
Earlier today, a 2009 report Ms Truss co-authored came to light, which called for doctors pay to be cut by 10%.
Truss also suggested senior police staff could be removed from their posts if their force performs poorly in her league table.
It is now Truss’s turn for some questions.
The foreign secretary calls for more transparency about the police’s record on fighting crime and having league tables for forces.
“It does help the police be held to account,” she added.
Vocalise 3 By Heavyocity Review: An Emotionally-Atmospheric Library For Kontakt – Magnetic Magazine
Heavyocity
Heavyocity continues to produce high-quality instruments with the release of Vocalise 3. This latest installment in the Vocalise line is even more flexible and valuable than its predecessors.
Buy This Plugin Right Now Via Plugin Boutique!
The library also features several new and improved features, including:
With these new features, Vocalise 3 is the complete vocal library available for Kontakt. On top of everything else, Vocalise 3 has a wide range of rhythmic pedals and intervals, along with whispers and stacked combinations. Vocalise 3 is a small but powerful vocal tool that can be used in many different ways.
If you're looking for creepy, ethereal vocals to take center stage in your ambient tracks, or you need to be able to tweak background whispers or phrases to use in your latest progressive house or organic house production, Vocalise 3 is flexible enough to be used in literally any genre you are working. And after experimenting with the sound design on this virtual instrument, I found that the best results always came from stacking capabilities of phrases, the whisper function, and the rhythmic pedals to create a unique vocal.
Need More Free Vocal Processing Plugins? We Got You…
The Gravity engine is very versatile and can be used to create pulses, soundscapes, and drones from any content. If you want to add ethereal vocals to your tracks that will make them more beautiful and haunting, Vocalise 3 is a great place to look!
Vocalise 3 is a powerful creative tool for any producer, regardless of the genre that they are producing.
As a professional dance music producer, I instantly fired this thing up. I began scrolling through ambient, cascading vocal lines that would be perfect for some chilled-out melodic house or some anthemic progressive tracks. The blissful euphoria and somber melancholia these patches inspire are second to none. And that's just in the base patches! Using the intricate sequencing, panning, and modulation parameters baked into the engine allows you to turn a straightforward melodic vocal rift into some next-gen sounding vocal instrument for cutting-edge productions that are sure to pop on the dancefloor and stream platforms.
Check Out Budakid's Favorite Plugins For Melodic House Here
The next obvious choice would be cinematic music. The ambient and often unclearly-defined vocal lines in Vocalise 3's bank of presets are perfect for producing background music and sync library music.
I mean to offer the phrase "unclearly-defined" in the above section as a compliment.
Why?
Because the vast majority of vocal samples and plugins that Vocalise 3 is competing with offer crystal clear vocals that you can spot in a crowd instantly. This means you often drop hundreds of dollars to get your hands on a vocal library that sounds like all the others out there. But, the modulation and personalization that the Vocalise 3 offers mean you can easily use the same sounds as another producer and arrive at entirely different results in your productions.
That alone is enough to recommend this plugin to any producer, regardless of the genre they are making.
Vocalise 3 is compatible with Kontakt Player (free) or Kontakt 6.7.1. It includes 7GB of content, which downloads as 4.38GB. Vocalise 3 contains a variety of presets across five categories: Melodic Phrases, Intervals, Rhythmic Pedals, Scapes and Drones, and Vowels.
The library is packed with emotive, hypnotic, and sensual vocal performances, catchy one-shots, and riffs meticulously processed to fit right into your productions (even the tempo-synced melodic phrases). Two outstanding vocalists, Carla and Kristin, recorded the vocals at Heavyocity's studio in New York. Unfortunately, we don't know the last names of the singers, or else we would reach out to thank them personally!
This is an experience that anyone looking for a new vocal instrument should not miss. The library that comes with it is usable. The virtual vocal device uses the unrivaled Gravity engine, which offers sound design creativity that is unfound in any other Kontakt engine.
Heavyocity's Vocalise 3 is elegantly divine and brilliantly crafted.
Purchase The Library Here
Managing Editor at Magnetic Magazine – Former Marketing Manager at the Hyperbits Masterclass – Writer, Content Strategist, Music Producer, and Record Label Manager
Artist Spotlight: Beach Bunny is constantly raising their musical expectations – The Post
Clearly, Beach Bunny is not just a one-hit wonder with only TikTok followers as their fan-base. Instead, they are a group that is constantly raising their musical expectations, creating work that is a reflection of their adolescence and inner turmoil (Photo provided via @beachbunn.y on Instagram).
Beach Bunny was originally a solo project headed by frontwoman Lili Trifilio, a singer-songwriter from Illinois who was recording her own music, including her 2015 musical debut “6 Weeks” and an EP called "Animalism." A year later, she released her second and third EPs, "Pool Party "and "Crybaby."
Yet, Trifilio needed back-up, especially as a woman trying to make her mark on the alternative-indie music scene. Shortly after the release of Crybaby, she enlisted the help of three new band members, Aidan Cada, Jon Alvarado and Matt Henkels, sporting the new stage name Beach Bunny.
In 2018, the band dropped their first EP together, and Trifilio’s fourth, titled "Prom Queen." The EP allowed Beach Bunny to truly mark their territory in music, gaining the attention of those on TikTok with its lead single of the same name, “Prom Queen.”
The EP revealed Trifilio’s perspective on the diet culture, eating disorders and physical appearance of young women, making the body of work a poignant, vulnerable statement that proved the band’s full understanding of what it means to struggle with your identity and sense of belonging.
Receiving a seal of approval by young music listeners around the world, Beach Bunny took the success of their EP in stride and continued to create, signing to independent record label Mom+Pop the following year.
As a result of this record deal came Beach Bunny’s first full-length album, "Honeymoon," which dropped shy of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. The album appeared on The New York Times and The Rolling Stone’s “Best Albums of 2020” pieces, a sure sign that the band was moving in the right direction sonically.
After dealing with touring setbacks and delayed music production, Beach Bunny came back more resilient than ever with another EP in 2021 called "Blame Game." Following their return came collaborations with major artists such as Teagan and Sara on “Cloud 9” and MARINA on “I Love You But I Love Me More.”
While these collaborations pushed Beach Bunny to build on other artists’ techniques and lyricism, the band wanted to do even more. This meant pushing outside of their comfort zones, thus unveiling their most recent sophomore album, "Emotional Creature."
Emotional Creature is only a month old, but sees Trifilio and her bandmates explore a new theme: love. From the high intensity of “Oxygen,” a confessional song that sees the frontwoman admit to her feelings for someone to the 90s rom-com inspired “Entropy,” the album has received rave reviews from fans alike.
Recently, The Rolling Stone reviewed the album saying, “It’s empowering to see Trifilio own the full spectrum of her emotions, and it’s what cements Beach Bunny’s latest record as a masterclass in confessional rock and roll.”
Likewise, mxdwn music said, “Whether a listener is reliving their teenage days or currently in their teenage days, Emotional Creature is a fun record for all to enjoy and to get lost in the feels.”
Now, the band is preparing for their performance at Wonderbus Music & Arts Festival in Columbus this upcoming weekend, while also gearing up for a US and European tour.
Clearly, Beach Bunny is not just a one-hit wonder with only TikTok followers as their fan-base. Instead, they are a group that is constantly raising their musical expectations, creating work that is a reflection of their adolescence and inner turmoil.
@grace_koe
[email protected]
Federal lawsuit alleges Lexington Police Department 'terrorizes' Black citizens – Mississippi Today
Any amount helps us keep producing quality journalism for Mississippi.
Mississippi Today
Nonprofit Mississippi News
Black residents in a small Delta town have been subjected to excessive force, intimidation and false arrests by its police force for over a year, a federal lawsuit alleges.
JULIAN, a civil rights organization, is asking the court to issue a temporary restraining order against the Lexington Police Department to prevent mistreatment against residents.
“It’s both unconscionable and illegal for Lexington residents to be terrorized and live in fear of the police department whose job is to protect them,” Jill Collen Jefferson, president and founder of JULIAN, said in a statement.
Subjects of the lawsuit are the city, police department, Interim Police Chief Charles Henderson and former Chief Sam Dobbins. The lawsuit was filed Tuesday in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi.
Lexington, which has a population of about 1,800 people, is 86% Black. It is located in one of the state’s poorest counties – Holmes County.
The lawsuit says former chief Dobbins and interim chief have violated Black residents’ constitutional rights for over a year and continue to. That behavior has included retaliation against residents who speak out against police, false arrests, baseless vehicle searches and unreasonable force by police.
Over 200 Black citizens formally or informally complained about treatment by Lexington police in the past year, according to the lawsuit.
The lawsuit comes a month after an audio recording surfaced of Dobbins making racist and homophobic language and bragging about killing multiple people as a member of the police force.
Robert Lee Hooker, a Black officer who resigned from the Lexington police department, recorded the conversation with Dobbins and gave it to JULIAN. The Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting first reported the recording.
“Justified, bro’,” Dobbins said in the recording. “I shot that n—– 119 times, OK?”
“I don’t give a f— if you kill a motherf—er in cold blood,” he said in another portion of the recording.
A day later, the Board of Aldermen fired Dobbins in a 3-2 vote and made Henderson the interim chief.
When reached for comment about the lawsuit, Dobbins declined to comment to the Mississippi Center for Investigative Reporting Tuesday.
Five Black men who experienced retaliation, arrest and other mistreatment by Lexington police are plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
Plaintiffs Robert and Darius Harris, who are brothers, were approached by officers on New Year’s Eve and threatened to arrest them for violating the city’s fireworks ordinance, according to the lawsuit. The men asked them to leave their home and verbally resisted the threats.
Stills from cell phone footage accompany what happened next: Robert Harris raising his hand to ask police to stand down as his brother stands behind him. Darius Harris on the ground after an officer used a taser on him. Police, including Dobbins, shining a flashlight and trying to give Darius Harris commands while he is still being tased. Officers arresting Darius Harris as he lays on the ground.
Plaintiffs are also asking the court to award the plaintiffs compensatory damages and punitive damages against Dobbins and Hendersen, attorneys fees and court costs.
Community members have also expressed concern about Henderson’s appointment. In its statement, JULIAN said he is a protege of Dobbins and also has a troubling reputation.
In the lawsuit, Henderson is accused of authorizing misconduct of Lexington police officers against Black residents. He has also used excessive force, including during an incident where he and a group of officers broke down the door of a 60-year-old woman’s home without a warrant, arrested her, hosed her down with a fire hose and left her outside during wintertime, according to the lawsuit.
Lexington Mayor Robin McCrory, City Attorney Katherine Barrett Riley and Henderson were not immediately available for comment Wednesday.
The organization has also contacted the U.S. Attorney’s Office and FBI to call for a federal investigation of systemic racism in both the city’s police department and municipal government as a whole.
“The culture of Lexington is corrupt,” the lawsuit states.
Our continued and thorough coverage is only possible with your help. Keep our investigations going by becoming a Mississippi Today member today.
By listening more intently and understanding the people who make up Mississippi’s communities, our reporters put a human face on how policy affects everyday Mississippians. We’re listening closely to our readers to help us continue to align our work with the needs and priorities of people from all across Mississippi. Please take a few minutes to tell us what’s on your mind by clicking the button below.![]()
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
by Mina Corpuz, Mississippi Today
August 17, 2022
This <a target="_blank" href="https://mississippitoday.org/2022/08/17/federal-lawsuit-alleges-lexington-police-department-terrorizes-black-citizens/">article</a> first appeared on <a target="_blank" href="https://mississippitoday.org">Mississippi Today</a> and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.<img src="https://mlc5rw8mrqi2.i.optimole.com/cb:Fone.76a/w:auto/h:auto/q:80/f:best/ig:avif/https://i0.wp.com/mississippitoday.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/MT_square-thumb.jpg?fit=150%2C150&ssl=1" style="width:1em;height:1em;margin-left:10px;"><img id="republication-tracker-tool-source" src="https://mississippitoday.org/?republication-pixel=true&post=1079367&ga=UA-75003810-1" style="width:1px;height:1px;">
Mina, a California native, covers the criminal justice system. Before joining Mississippi Today, she was a reporter for the Clarion Ledger and newspapers in Massachusetts. Her work has appeared in the Los Angeles Times, Boston Globe and USA Today.
We believe that an informed Mississippi is a better Mississippi. We center readers in everything we do, informing–and engaging–Mississippians through reporting, podcasts, events and online communities.
Founded in 2016 as the state’s first nonprofit, nonpartisan newsroom, Mississippi Today’s roots in Capitol coverage have grown to encompass a myriad of beats beyond politics and policy, including education, public health, justice, environment, equity, and, yes, sports.
Learn More
By clicking submit, you agree to share your email address with Mississippi Today. We do not sell or share your information with anyone.
a proud member of the
following organizations:
How COVID-19 Changed the Court Reporting Industry for the Better – JD Supra

The story of how the legal profession embraced technology almost overnight in order to keep the justice system functioning through the COVID-19 pandemic is by now a familiar one.
Just as Dorothy discovered in The Wizard of Oz that she always had the ability to return to Kansas, so too lawyers discovered they always had the ability to conduct depositions remotely. All that was necessary was the resolve to do so (and a few rule changes).
Prior to 2020, few depositions were in fact conducted other than in-person. But today the vast majority of depositions are fully remote. The percentage of depositions conducted with at least one party participating remotely – i.e., both “remote” and “hybrid” depositions – is, we believe, near 80 percent at present.
Less familiar is the story of the effect that COVID-19 has had on the court reporters who provide deposition services. Although the court reporting industry was ready (anxious, in fact) in 2020 to provide remote depositions, when the litigation environment changed rapidly with the pandemic, the work routines of court reporters underwent a prompt and profound transformation as well.
Travel time vanished from court reporters’ calendars. Technology budgets ballooned. And some court reporters found themselves in novel situations that, in retrospect, seem inevitable in an adversarial setting where all participants can’t see each other all the time.
The pandemic greatly reduced travel for court reporters. This change was welcome in an industry where the existing pool of qualified court reporters struggles to meet the demand for deposition services.
With remote depositions, court reporters can work from a home office, scheduling depositions back-to-back throughout the day, with no time required for travel between physical locations. Before the pandemic, travel time was accepted without question as part of the job. It made as much sense to fret over travel time as to worry about the weather.
Chris Willette, formerly a court reporter and agency owner who now serves as Esquire’s Vice President of Acquisition Strategy, says that the elimination of travel time between reporting jobs has transformed the industry. The result has been a boon to both lawyers and court reporters.
“Attorneys sometimes found it challenging to move cases toward settlement due to court reporter availability to cover depositions,” Willette says. “Now we’re available to cover more depositions because we’re not sitting in traffic. That’s a significant shift in the profession.”
Travel time to in-person depositions is wasted time for court reporters regardless of the markets they serve. Driving 60 interstate miles to a nearby city, or commuting six miles across a large urban area, can easily eat up enough time to conduct an additional remote deposition in a typical court reporter’s day. With remote, litigators experience a greater opportunity to schedule their depositions sooner. And court reporters can make more productive use of time in what is, for most, a very long workday.
Just like everyone else in the legal system, court reporters have had to purchase additional technology in order to meet the new demand for remote depositions. They’ve had to outfit private, secure home offices in which to work. They’ve acquired new video cameras and improved headphones to make sure they have the best opportunity to accurately capture testimony during remote depositions.
Upgrades have also been necessary for the court reporter’s broadband Internet connection and in-home Wifi routers. Having a network connection robust enough to capably carry both audio and video is the cost of doing business for court reporters these days. Just as was the case with in-person depositions, all parties involved in a remote deposition expect that the court reporter will be the most reliable recorder of the questions and answers from everyone involved. Occasional technology glitches are not really an option for court reporters.
Many court reporters have also found it necessary to purchase a second computer for their home offices – the first to support the work of transcribing and (in some cases) transmitting realtime testimony; and the second computer for the videoconferencing technology that carries the audio and video of the other participants.
Court reporters are also taking advantage of innovations that have continued to evolve even during the pandemic. These new technologies allow court reporters to do a better job in less time.
To the outside observer, the stenotype machines that court reporters use to capture testimony have changed little during the past several decades. Appearances are deceiving, however. While the outward appearance of the stenotype machine has remained somewhat the same, under the hood these machines are now highly capable computerized devices.
Stenographic machines, combined with a skilled stenographic reporter, which once produced a paper roll of inscrutable letter combinations, which had to be dictated and then typed up into a usable transcript, today are able to instantly generate text for real-time viewing in the same room or streaming over the Internet. The final edited transcript can be delivered in specialized formats used by litigation management tools such LexisNexis Textmap and LiveNote Portable. Court reporters can produce fully searchable transcripts, often with hyperlinks to supporting materials and embedded exhibits.
Anir Dutta, president of Stenograph LLC, the leading supplier of stenotype machines and software for the court reporting industry, believes that technological innovation promises to bring even more efficiency to the court reporter’s workflow.
Consider, for example, that after a deposition is concluded, most court reporters spend about 1-2 hours editing the transcript for each hour of deposition time.
According to Dutta, automatic speech recognition technologies can cut that editing time in half. “The ability to use automatic speech recognition to cut the editing time down is a key productivity game-changer that will make the court reporter much more efficient,” he says.
Automatic speech recognition technology has the capability of instantly zeroing in on problem areas in a deposition transcript that might take a long time for the court reporter to identify. When a court reporter captures an audio recording of deposition testimony contemporaneously with the court reporter’s own transcription, ASR can quickly analyze both files and find the problematic “hotspots” that require the court reporter’s attention.
“ASR can actually just focus on those hotspots and provide its checking functionality to the court reporter as a tool to get to those problematic areas quickly so the court reporter doesn’t have to go through 300 pages of transcript when maybe only a very few pages need real editing attention,” Dutta says.
Technology investments notwithstanding, remote depositions ca n present challenges that are not easily overcome.
With a traditional in-person deposition, the lawyers can see when the court reporter is marking exhibits or engaged in some other administrative task that calls for a pause in the questioning. In a remote deposition, the court reporter’s hands are not always on camera, which means that the lawyers may not be able to tell when the court reporter is ready to proceed. For this reason, cameras should be placed in such a way that everyone is “on the same page,” visually speaking, as much as possible. It is also helpful for all participants to agree at the outset not to proceed unless everyone audibly signifies assent to begin, or resume, questioning.
A related challenge occurs when the court reporter is unable to determine who is speaking. The speaker may be off-camera, or there may be cross-talk that is obscuring the identity of the speaker. Here again, proper positioning of the video cameras and discipline to avoid cross-talk will largely solve this issue.
Another challenge unique to the remote reporting environment is the occasional request from attorneys that the court reporter be physically present with the deponent when all other participants are remote. This request may be prompted by a concern that the court reporter must be present with the deponent when administering the oath (usually an unfounded concern given recent court rule changes), or by a concern that the presence of the court reporter with the deponent will minimize opportunities for outside influences to spoil the integrity of the deposition. Court reporters may, in addition to capturing the record in an impartial manner, employ additional measures designed to ensure the integrity of the record – such as seeking clarifications or making sure that deposition participants are not talking over each other. However, the ultimate responsibility for ensuring the integrity of the deposition process rests with the lawyers, both as a matter of law and professional ethics.
We believe that the court reporting industry is providing better service today to its customers than was possible before the COVID-19 pandemic struck. Individual court reporters, the backbone of the business, serve more users than ever by traveling less and leveraging technologies that create more accurate transcripts in less time.
See more »
Refine your interests »
This website uses cookies to improve user experience, track anonymous site usage, store authorization tokens and permit sharing on social media networks. By continuing to browse this website you accept the use of cookies. Click here to read more about how we use cookies.
Back to Top
Explore 2022 Readers’ Choice Awards
Copyright © JD Supra, LLC
🌱 First Scottish Heritage Day + Femme Akoi Ribbon-Cutting Ceremony – Patch
Morning, friends! Kristen here with your Wednesday edition of the Dunedin Daily, filled with everything you need to know about what’s happening locally.
First, today’s weather:
A stray afternoon t-storm. High: 90 Low: 79.
👀 Attention local businesses & marketers: Attract more customers in Dunedin by sponsoring this daily newsletter, which gets read by the same people you’re trying to reach. Click here to learn more.
Here are the top three stories today in Dunedin:
Dunedin Daily Pic of the Day:
Want to see your Dunedin photo here? Submit it to [email protected] for consideration! Please confirm in the email that you own the rights to the photo, and that Patch has permission to republish it.
Today in Dunedin:
From my notebook:
More from our sponsors — thanks for supporting local news!
Featured businesses:
Events:
You’re officially in the loop for today! See you all tomorrow morning for your next update.
Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.
Chelsea Manning, Brooklyn D.J. – The New York Times
Advertisement
Supported by
Before she orchestrated the largest intelligence leak in U.S. history, Ms. Manning was known to D.J. on occasion. On Friday night, she shook off the cobwebs in Bushwick.
Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.
Nicolas Mejía, a 22-year-old D.J. from the Cypress Hills section of Brooklyn, had been spinning records in small clubs around New York for just under a year when a call came in from a much larger venue. Elsewhere, a huge club in Bushwick, was hosting the latest installment of Sksksks, its traveling hyperpop dance party in August, and its organizers wanted the D.J. to perform the opening set.
Elsewhere is a sprawling complex that has hosted big-name experimental pop artists like Sophie and Kim Petras — this particular party would bring six up-and-coming acts to the venue’s main hall. But when the complete roster of D.J.s dropped on Instagram in the days leading up to the party, Nicolas Mejía, who performs as D4rkcircles, noticed that one particular artist on the lineup, a newcomer to the Brooklyn electronic scene, was generating more buzz than any of the other performers combined.
Who was Chelsea Manning, the D.J. wondered, and why was everyone talking about her?
It wasn’t a stage name: Chelsea Elizabeth Manning, the former Army intelligence analyst whose leak of hundreds of thousands of classified documents detailing U.S. military operations in Iraq and Afghanistan earned her a 35-year prison sentence (commuted after a presidential intercession), is indeed a D.J. And late Friday night, clad in light-up cat ears and tinted sunglasses, Ms. Manning played an hour of fast-paced dance music to a throng of writhing partygoers, some of whom were unaware that the D.J. blasting Britney Spears remixes had spent years of her life in a maximum-security military prison for disclosing secrets of U.S. military campaigns in the Middle East.
“There’s a large population of the world, or at least this country, that disagrees with what she’s done,” said David Chan, who created Sksksks. “But from my perspective, she’s a national hero.”
Mr. Chan — a party promoter and D.J. better known in New York nightlife circles as Thelimitdoesnotexist — said he hadn’t been aiming to make a political statement by inviting Ms. Manning to play at Elsewhere. While brainstorming potential artists for the Sksksks party, which is geared toward queer and trans partygoers, Mr. Chan stumbled across a 2018 article published in The Outline in which Ms. Manning (who is transgender) revealed her background in D.J.ing and electronic music production.
Unsure whether she would respond, Mr. Chan messaged Ms. Manning on Instagram to ask whether the former army intelligence analyst would be interested in returning to her raver roots. “My art is booking an act people talk about,” Mr. Chan said. “There was something about it that was funny, and really cool.”
To Mr. Chan’s surprise, Ms. Manning replied. She was in.
Hours before Ms. Manning pressed play on her first track of the night, Mr. Chan (who also performed) was scuttling around Elsewhere, tweaking feedback on microphones and fussing with strobe lights. Bass thumped like thunder in the empty, cavernous hall, then cut out — technical difficulties.
Around 10:30 p.m., attendees started trickling in, sporting furry leg warmers, mesh tops and elf-ear prosthetics. Some partygoers made a beeline for the dance floor, where they immediately began thrashing to a remix of “How to Save a Life” by the Fray. Others, like Miles Raymer and Callie Richards, a couple who said they had ended up at the rave “kind of by accident,” decided to people watch from the smoking section until Ms. Manning came on at midnight.
“We kind of thought it would be a funny thing to do on our way home from our date in the city,” Ms. Raymer said.
Ms. Raymer, a trans freelance music journalist and critic, has attended raves since the 1990s, but she said she found the event a little strange. “This whole party is really giving internet people IRL,” she said. “There’s a certain kind of awkward coming-out-from-behind-the-screen sort of energy. If you spend a lot of time on social media with a lot of trans girls, there’s a certain kind of nerdy, internet-steeped girl who is very much in the building tonight.”
Thomas Wynne, a veteran Sksksks attendee who sat perched on Elsewhere’s staircase, concurred with Ms. Raymer’s assessment, adding that the party felt a little more “Reddit” than normal.
“It attracted a different clientele from the usual event,” Mr. Wynne said. “If you look at the crowd, you can kind of tell who’s here for Chelsea Manning. Not in a bad way, but it stands out.”
James Ko, an associate creative director in Bushwick who was wearing bright pink boots, was one such attendee. “I love Chelsea,” Mx. Ko said. “I literally wrote her fan mail when she was in jail and everything, so I definitely wanted to support her for her first D.J. event.” (According to Ms. Manning’s Twitter account, Friday night’s event was her first D.J. gig in 15 years.)
Mx. Ko, who is trans and nonbinary, sees Ms. Manning’s life as a story about perseverance on the margins. “She’s a big inspiration in terms of getting out there and living a life that’s defined by her transness but not solely by her transness,” Mx. Ko said. “Her journey is kind of a microcosm of the trans experience. We all go through our own stuff, but to think about being in that kind of isolation and confinement — I think a lot of trans people can identify with that.”
For Ms. Manning, it was a long road back to the dance floor. She was initially arrested in 2010 after providing WikiLeaks, the online intelligence organization founded by Julian Assange, with classified material that included footage of American soldiers chuckling after fatally firing at several civilians, including two Reuters journalists, in a 2007 helicopter attack in Baghdad.
Convicted in 2013 on charges including six counts of violating the Espionage Act and sentenced to 35 years in prison, Ms. Manning spent six years at Fort Leavenworth, a men’s military prison in Kansas, where a struggle to secure gender-affirming care behind bars took a significant toll on her mental health. (Ms. Manning tried to end her own life twice while incarcerated at Fort Leavenworth.)
In 2017, President Barack Obama commuted all but four months of Ms. Manning’s remaining prison sentence, an act of clemency sharply criticized by several prominent Republicans at the time. She was jailed again, for 10 months, in 2019 for refusing to testify before a grand jury investigating WikiLeaks.
At Elsewhere, however, not everyone was aware of Ms. Manning’s extraordinary journey to the Bushwick nightclub. Passing through the rooftop bar, a group of men attending Elsewhere’s other party that night could be overheard explaining Ms. Manning’s significance to one another. (“So she’s, like, Julian Assange? It’s like if Assange was D.J.ing right now? I’m there for it.”)
Around 12:30, the crowd erupted as Ms. Manning stepped into the D.J. booth. Over a pulsing beat, a disembodied voice intoned: “What is reality? Can you describe your way to joy and connection? What is love? Show me love. Tonight, in this house, we begin the third summer of love.” When the beat dropped, the dance floor let out a collective yowl as the music picked up speed.
Ms. Manning played Charli XCX. She played drum and bass. She remixed the theme music from the HBO show “Succession.”
“I had a feeling that she was going to play transgirl-video-game-nightcore-hyperpop music, and it kind of delivered,” said David Yoakum, a partygoer who was there to support a D.J. who performs as Swan Meat, scheduled to close out the night. “I think it was great.”
Backstage in the green room, Ms. Manning had gained a new fan. “She was so good,” D4rkcircles proclaimed. “Major queen.”
As the red digital clock on the D.J. booth ticked past 3 in the morning, Swan Meat, dressed in an anime-printed bodysuit, was having a cigarette to ready herself for her set. “It’s really cool to be part of a burgeoning scene, post-Covid,” she said through tobacco smoke. “I may be playing to an empty room as people clear out, but it’s still fabulous.”
Advertisement
Media organizations and civil libertarians sue to stop Arizona law that restricts recording videos of cops – Iowa Capital Dispatch
Protesters in Phoenix clash with Phoenix police officers in riot gear on June 23, 2020. Under a 2022 law criminalizing taking video of police within eight feet of them, the person filming this video could have faced up to 30 days in jail. (Screenshot via YouTube/Arizona Mirror)
A coalition of news organizations, including the Arizona Mirror, and civil libertarians filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday to block a new Arizona law that would make it a crime to take video of police officers in some situations, arguing that it violates the First Amendment.
“If it goes into effect, HB2319 would have a dramatic chilling effect on Arizonans who wish to exercise their First Amendment right to record video of law enforcement officials performing their duties in public,” attorneys for the Mirror and other plaintiffs wrote in a motion asking a federal judge to stop the law from being enforced, known as a preliminary injunction.
The new law is scheduled to go into effect on Sept. 24, and would outlaw video recording of police officers within eight feet of where “law enforcement activity” is taking place. If a person does not stop after being told to, they face a class 3 misdemeanor and up to 30 days in jail.
“States Newsroom and the Arizona Mirror are dedicated to informing people about the decisions and activities of public officials,” said Andrea Verykoukis, the deputy director of States Newsroom, which publishes the Mirror. “There is nothing more essential to this task than the First Amendment right of every Arizonan to gather and share information about their elected representatives and law enforcement officers paid with public money.
“We look forward to a ruling that will prevent this chilling and unconstitutional law from taking effect.”
The plaintiffs in the legal challenge are the Mirror and States Newsroom; the Arizona Broadcasters Association; the Arizona Newspapers Association; the parent company of Fox 10 Phoenix; the parent company of KTVK 3TV, KPHO CBS 5 News and KOLD News 13; KPNX 12 News; NBCUniversal, which owns Telemundo Arizona; the National Press Photographers Association; Phoenix Newspapers Inc., which owns The Arizona Republic; Scripps Media, which owns ABC15 in Phoenix and KGUN9 in Tucson; and the ACLU of Arizona.
The law, which was created by House Bill 2319 earlier this year, is an obvious violation of the First Amendment rights of all Arizonans, including journalists, the lawsuit states. The new law’s legislative sponsor, Fountain Hills Republican state Rep. John Kavanagh, knew there were constitutional problems, as did legislative attorneys, who warned lawmakers that the restrictions flew in the face of previous court rulings.
Courts have long ruled that the First Amendment protects not only the publication of videos, but also the act of recording them — particularly videos of public officers in public places.
In striking down an Idaho law that barred video recordings in agricultural facilities, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected the argument that such videos weren’t protected by the First Amendment, ruling that would be “akin to saying that even though a book is protected by the First Amendment, the process of writing the book is not.”
And the U.S. Supreme Court “has consistently recognized a right to gather news, and recording police and other government officials is newsgathering,” attorneys for the news organizations and the ACLU noted in their filings. In a 1972 case, the high court ruled that “freedom of the press could be eviscerated” without First Amendment protections for seeking out the news.
The new Arizona law also targets video recordings specifically, while ignoring other types of speech, the lawsuit claims. While it purports to prevent interference with officers, the law does nothing to forbid anyone from approaching within eight feet of an officer for any other reason — even “while holding up a phone for some other purpose, such as catching a Pokemon, or video recording non-law enforcement activity, or being within eight feet of an officer taking a still photo, or writing notes about what the officer is doing, or even making an audio recording of a police encounter.”
The lawsuit points to existing state and local laws that prohibit interfering with police officers that can already be enforced. And those laws are clear, unlike HB2319, the lawsuit claims.
“There is no evidence to show that a person holding a cell phone that happens to be recording is an interference with law enforcement activity, while a person walking by on the same sidewalk holding the same phone but texting or taking pictures with it is not,” the plaintiffs argued. “This irrational distinction … highlights the law’s true purpose: preventing recording, not interference or distraction.”
The way the law is written, it effectively “creates moving bubbles around every officer” within which it might be a crime to record video. And that gives every police officer in Arizona the authority to “create the crime” simply by approaching someone who is filming them.
“Where a group of police officers making an arrest do not want to be recorded, one officer from that group can order a halt to recording, move towards the person recording and, as soon as that officer comes within eight feet of the person, immediately find them in violation of the law and subject to arrest — even though it is the officer’s approach that triggered the alleged violation,” the attorneys for the media and ACLU argued.
The law requires that a warning to stop recording must be issued before filming can be considered a crime, but it’s not at all clear how that would work, as there’s no guidance as to what qualifies as “previously” receiving a warning.
“Is it five minutes? An hour? A day? Does the warning have to be from an officer involved in the activity being recorded? What if another officer arrives after the ‘no recording’ order is given and tells the videographer to go ahead and start recording again?” the attorneys argued.
About this story
The story was originally published by Arizona Mirror, which is part of States Newsroom, along with Iowa Capital Dispatch. States Newsroom is a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Arizona Mirror maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Jim Small for questions: [email protected]. Follow Arizona Mirror on Facebook and Twitter.
by Jim Small, Iowa Capital Dispatch
August 23, 2022
by Jim Small, Iowa Capital Dispatch
August 23, 2022
A coalition of news organizations, including the Arizona Mirror, and civil libertarians filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday to block a new Arizona law that would make it a crime to take video of police officers in some situations, arguing that it violates the First Amendment.
“If it goes into effect, HB2319 would have a dramatic chilling effect on Arizonans who wish to exercise their First Amendment right to record video of law enforcement officials performing their duties in public,” attorneys for the Mirror and other plaintiffs wrote in a motion asking a federal judge to stop the law from being enforced, known as a preliminary injunction.
The new law is scheduled to go into effect on Sept. 24, and would outlaw video recording of police officers within eight feet of where “law enforcement activity” is taking place. If a person does not stop after being told to, they face a class 3 misdemeanor and up to 30 days in jail.
“States Newsroom and the Arizona Mirror are dedicated to informing people about the decisions and activities of public officials,” said Andrea Verykoukis, the deputy director of States Newsroom, which publishes the Mirror. “There is nothing more essential to this task than the First Amendment right of every Arizonan to gather and share information about their elected representatives and law enforcement officers paid with public money.
“We look forward to a ruling that will prevent this chilling and unconstitutional law from taking effect.”
The plaintiffs in the legal challenge are the Mirror and States Newsroom; the Arizona Broadcasters Association; the Arizona Newspapers Association; the parent company of Fox 10 Phoenix; the parent company of KTVK 3TV, KPHO CBS 5 News and KOLD News 13; KPNX 12 News; NBCUniversal, which owns Telemundo Arizona; the National Press Photographers Association; Phoenix Newspapers Inc., which owns The Arizona Republic; Scripps Media, which owns ABC15 in Phoenix and KGUN9 in Tucson; and the ACLU of Arizona.
The law, which was created by House Bill 2319 earlier this year, is an obvious violation of the First Amendment rights of all Arizonans, including journalists, the lawsuit states. The new law’s legislative sponsor, Fountain Hills Republican state Rep. John Kavanagh, knew there were constitutional problems, as did legislative attorneys, who warned lawmakers that the restrictions flew in the face of previous court rulings.
Courts have long ruled that the First Amendment protects not only the publication of videos, but also the act of recording them — particularly videos of public officers in public places.
In striking down an Idaho law that barred video recordings in agricultural facilities, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals rejected the argument that such videos weren’t protected by the First Amendment, ruling that would be “akin to saying that even though a book is protected by the First Amendment, the process of writing the book is not.”
And the U.S. Supreme Court “has consistently recognized a right to gather news, and recording police and other government officials is newsgathering,” attorneys for the news organizations and the ACLU noted in their filings. In a 1972 case, the high court ruled that “freedom of the press could be eviscerated” without First Amendment protections for seeking out the news.
The new Arizona law also targets video recordings specifically, while ignoring other types of speech, the lawsuit claims. While it purports to prevent interference with officers, the law does nothing to forbid anyone from approaching within eight feet of an officer for any other reason — even “while holding up a phone for some other purpose, such as catching a Pokemon, or video recording non-law enforcement activity, or being within eight feet of an officer taking a still photo, or writing notes about what the officer is doing, or even making an audio recording of a police encounter.”
The lawsuit points to existing state and local laws that prohibit interfering with police officers that can already be enforced. And those laws are clear, unlike HB2319, the lawsuit claims.
“There is no evidence to show that a person holding a cell phone that happens to be recording is an interference with law enforcement activity, while a person walking by on the same sidewalk holding the same phone but texting or taking pictures with it is not,” the plaintiffs argued. “This irrational distinction … highlights the law’s true purpose: preventing recording, not interference or distraction.”
The way the law is written, it effectively “creates moving bubbles around every officer” within which it might be a crime to record video. And that gives every police officer in Arizona the authority to “create the crime” simply by approaching someone who is filming them.
“Where a group of police officers making an arrest do not want to be recorded, one officer from that group can order a halt to recording, move towards the person recording and, as soon as that officer comes within eight feet of the person, immediately find them in violation of the law and subject to arrest — even though it is the officer’s approach that triggered the alleged violation,” the attorneys for the media and ACLU argued.
The law requires that a warning to stop recording must be issued before filming can be considered a crime, but it’s not at all clear how that would work, as there’s no guidance as to what qualifies as “previously” receiving a warning.
“Is it five minutes? An hour? A day? Does the warning have to be from an officer involved in the activity being recorded? What if another officer arrives after the ‘no recording’ order is given and tells the videographer to go ahead and start recording again?” the attorneys argued.
About this story
The story was originally published by Arizona Mirror, which is part of States Newsroom, along with Iowa Capital Dispatch. States Newsroom is a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Arizona Mirror maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Jim Small for questions: [email protected]. Follow Arizona Mirror on Facebook and Twitter.
Iowa Capital Dispatch is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Iowa Capital Dispatch maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Kathie Obradovich for questions: [email protected]. Follow Iowa Capital Dispatch on Facebook and Twitter.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.
Jim Small is a reporter for the Arizona Mirror. He’s a native Arizonan and has covered state government, policy and politics since 2004, with a focus on investigative and in-depth policy reporting, first as a reporter for the Arizona Capitol Times, then as editor of the paper and its prestigious sister publications, the Yellow Sheet Report and Arizona Legislative Report. Under his guidance, the Capitol Times won numerous state, regional and national awards for its accountability journalism and probing investigations into state government operations.
DEMOCRACY TOOLKIT
© Iowa Capital Dispatch, 2022
Iowans value integrity in their government. Free and independent journalism is what keeps our public servants accountable and responsive to the people. That’s why Iowa Capital Dispatch, a nonprofit, independent source for quality journalism, is working every day to keep you informed about what government officials are doing with your money, your freedom and your safety.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site.
Murdaugh defense says state has recordings from just before killings – WRDW
CHARLESTON, S.C. (WCSC) – Alex Murdaugh’s defense team says prosecutors have audio and video recordings taken a short time before Murdaugh’s wife and son were shot to death.
The claim comes in response to a prosecution motion for a blanket protective order the defense team says would restrict their use of the evidence, violating Murdaugh’s constitutional rights.
In that filing, Murdaugh’s attorneys allege that agents with the State Law Enforcement Division, “acting at the direction of the Attorney General’s Office, played portions of a video and audio recording obtained from Paul’s phone to Murdaugh’s family members.”
The defense says it believes the recording was shown to the family without obtaining an order authorizing the disclosure of the information to potential witnesses or third parties.
“In any event, on the recording, Paul is taking a video of his friend’s dog, who Paul was concerned about,” the documents state. “Apparently, a conversation between Maggie, Paul and Alex is also captured on this recording. Family members report that Maggie, Paul and Alex are having a convivial conversation about the behavior of their own dog, Bubba. There is absolutely no indication of a disagreement or dispute between Paul, Maggie, and Alex, according to family members who viewed the recording. However, the State contends that within minutes after this convivial, light-hearted conversation, Alex murdered both Maggie and Paul for no apparent reason.”
The defense also claims a news story about the recording did not include any information about the nature of the conversation and how “incongruent the tone and tenor of the conversation is to the State’s theory of the case.”
“Perhaps this crucial information was intentionally omitted from the media leak to portray Alex Murdaugh in the worst possible light,” the documents state. “Regardless, the State has disclosed this information in violation of this Court’s order sealing the search warrant application and the materials obtained in the searches.”
The defense goes on to allege that now that the time has come for the Attorney General’s Office to disclose a “mountain of evidence” against their client, the Attorney General “refuses to comply with his discovery obligations until the Court imposes a gag order and other restrictions” on Murdaugh and his attorneys.
Murdaugh’s attorneys call the state’s claim that the motion is “only intended to prevent the dissemination of any evidence in this case except as is necessary for the state and defense to prepare for and litigate any hearings and trial” hypocritical.
“For months on end, the state’s prosecutors have selectively leaked information about evidence obtained through sealed search warrants to various media outlets,” the defense states.
They say any reports about an audio recording from Paul Murdaugh’s phone that allegedly places Alex Murdaugh at the scene of the murders would have been obtained through a search warrant issued under seal. That seal, they say, would prohibit the disclosure of information obtained from these searches.
The state, in its motion for the protective order, argued the case has generated significant public attention and that evidence in the case “contains sensitive information which should remain protected unless and until it is used in court.” Prosecutors also say a standard state grand jury protective order already exists for state grand jury evidence and as some of it is relevant to the murder cases, “it makes sense for all of the evidence to be handled pursuant to the similar rules.”
Attorney General’s Office spokesman Robert Kittle said the office did not have a comment on the defense’s claims, referring questions to the state’s motion for the protective order, which read in part:
The state has no desire to preclude the defense from any discovery and has every intent of moving this case to a public trial as soon as praticeable. As soon as the two discovery issues are addressed and the court green lights it, discovery will be sent. For these reasons, the state moves for issuance of an order unsealing search warrants in this case as well as a temporary protective order pending this court’s decision as to whether it should be made permanent.
Copyright 2022 WCSC. All rights reserved.
Get To Know WavGrind – Muzique Magazine
By
How did you come by your brand name?
Our production name is WavGrind. WAV is an audio format, and our audience is filled with hard-working talented producers who “grind”. Our sample packs also help producers with writer’s block and boost producers’ creativity which helps them stay on the grind.
When did you discover your love for your craft and what made you realize you wanted to pursue a career in it?
I learned to play guitar back when I was 8, and I really had a passion for music. When I was in high school I really liked the idea of producing music. A the time I Was really into EDM music which is why I started producing EDM songs. Eventually, my taste for music shifted more towards R&B and hip-hop which is when I started making beats and sample packs. I ended up working with a lot of talented artists and producers and eventually launched https://wavgrind.com/
To what or whom do you accredit your sense of style?
I was influenced by producers and artists such as Metro Boomin, Nick Mira, Martin Garrix, Murda Beatz, and many more. I learned a lot from their style of music.
On your current project, how did you come up with the concept?
Our most recent projects have incorporated a lot of live instruments and vocals. A lot of producers use VSTs or plugins to create their melodies, which can sometimes lack the “life” and “feeling” that live instruments and samples can achieve. This is why sampling is so powerful. We’ve released a lot of melodies we created using live guitar, piano, flutes, vocals, and more.
What are some of your greatest challenges, and what is your greatest attribute when it comes to your work ethic?
I think building a talented team and group is the most important, but also most challenging element when it comes to growing. Having a good team can save you a lot of time, and help diversify the sound of your music. It can take time but help you evolve and put out quality music quicker.
Are you the best at what you do in your opinion?
I definitely don’t think I’m the best producer, but the samples we put out on https://wavgrind.com/ are some of the best you’ll find on the internet. Not only are they extremely high quality, but they are royalty-free, perfectly formatted and organized, and at a massive discount.
What are your plans for the near future?
I plan on growing WavGrind, bringing more producers onto the team, and working with a lot of artists and producers.
How can fans find you?
You can find us on https://wavgrind.com/ or on our social media @wavgrind
FOR MORE NEWS AND ARTICLES, CONNECT WITH US ON MUZIQUE MAGAZINE, FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, AND TWITTER
Founder & Editor-In-Chief of Muzique Magazine Alfred Munoz, is an American Army Veteran, and Entrepreneur with over 20 years of experience in the Music Industry, Leadership, Management, and Branding.
We caught up with Bud’da, the multi-platinum selling record producer to chat all things Muzique! Hi Bud’da,…
There is no question that the music industry as a whole has an indelible effect on…
Cross pendants divided the world of fashion in half. Many believe that they shouldn’t be worn…
Thimoj NFT is the most famous French NFT company. Record transfers, a growing value, a newly…
How did you come by your brand name? When I was young people called me ”Flap”…
How did you come by your stage name? My name is KEWMOO. I got my name…
Copyright © 2022 Apex One Holdings, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
KATATONIA Announce Fall 2022 North American Headline Tour; THE OCEAN COLLECTIVE And CELLAR DARLING To Provide Support – bravewords.com
August 23, 2022, a day ago
news heavy metal katatonia the ocean collective cellar darling
Melancholic metal masters, Katatonia, are thrilled to return to North American shores this fall after a five year absence – announcing a massive 2022 headline tour featuring support from progressive metal frontrunners The Ocean Collective and prog-folk force Cellar Darling.
The tour is set to begin on November 9 in Washington, DC and will visit several major cities into December, coming to an end on December 10 in Tampa, FL. Tickets for this can’t-miss tour go on sale to the public on Friday, August 26 at 11 AM, local time. Visit katatonia.com
Fontman Jonas Renske states: ”North America! We are very pleased to announce that we are coming back to your shores for a full headline tour, starting on November 9 in Washington, DC and going through to December 10 in Tampa, FL. Support will come from our talented friends in The Ocean Collective and Cellar Darling. We haven’t toured North America since 2017, so this return is way overdue. See you all later this fall!”
North American tour dates:
November
9 – Washington, DC – Black Cat
10 – Worcester, MA – Palladium
11 – New York, NY – Sony Hall
12 – Philadelphia, PA – Underground Arts
13 – Harrisburg, PA – Harrisburg Midtown Arts Center
15 – Quebec City, QC – Impérial Bell
16 – Montreal, QC – Le Studio TD
18 – Toronto, ON – Opera House
19 – Pittsburgh, PA – Thunderbird Music Hall
20- Chicago, IL – Metro
22- Denver, CO – Oriental Theater
23 – Salt Lake City, UT – Soundwell
25 – Portland, OR – Hawthorne Theatre
26 – Vancouver, BC – Rickshaw Theatre
27 – Seattle, WA – The Crocodile
29 – Roseville, CA – Goldfield Trading Post
30 – San Francisco, CA – Great American Music Hall
December
2 – Los Angeles, CA – 1720
3 – San Diego, CA – Brick by Brick
4 – Mesa, AZ – Nile Theater
6 – Austin, TX – Come and Take It Live (+Soen as direct support)
7 – Dallas, TX – Amplified Live (+Soen as direct support)
9 – Atlanta, GA – Hell at The Masquerade
10 – Tampa, FL – The Orpheum
Find the band’s complete tour itinerary here.
Piercing through the core in 1991 when Katatonia was brought to life by the inimitable Jonas Renkse (now vocalist) and renowned guitarist Anders Nyström, the unit has taken a fascinating journey from their heavy atmospheric extreme metal beginnings in the early 90s underground metal scene to their current status as a unique, free-spirited progressive rock amalgamation that stretches beyond the boundaries of standard music. Each stunning work of Katatonia is tantamount to a cathartic experience – from their seminal debut, the legendary Dance Of December Souls (1993), to their most recent haunting masterpiece, the critically acclaimed City Burials (2020) – the latter marking their most successful release to date (debuting at #6 GER, #5 FI, etc).
The five-piece has never failed in evolving its sound and unique identity into something that is known as one of Sweden’s top-notch musical forces today.
Katatonia officially announced their signing with Napalm Records in June 2022. Stay tuned for more exciting news coming soon!
Katatonia are:
Jonas Renske – Vocals
Anders Nyström – Guitars
Roger Öjersson – Guitars
Niklas Sandin – Bass
Daniel Moilanen – Drums
(Photo – Ester Segarra)
August 23, 2022, a day ago
review heavy metal stratovarius
August 23, 2022, a day ago
review black death mournful congregation
August 18, 2022, 6 days ago
review heavy metal toxik
August 16, 2022, a week ago
review hard rock jean beauvoir
August 15, 2022, a week ago
review black death singularity
August 15, 2022, a week ago
review black death static abyss
August 12, 2022, a week ago
review heavy metal hell fire
August 10, 2022, 2 weeks ago
review tzompantli black death
August 9, 2022, 2 weeks ago
review heavy metal edguy rarities
August 5, 2022, 2 weeks ago
review heavy metal hard rock iconic
OPINIONISTA: Reflections on the life of Ahmed Kathrada, a titan of SA democracy and equality – Daily Maverick
More specifically, we’d like those who can afford to pay to start paying. What it comes down to is whether or not you value Daily Maverick. Think of us in terms of your daily cappuccino from your favourite coffee shop. It costs around R35. That’s R1,050 per month on frothy milk. Don’t get us wrong, we’re almost exclusively fuelled by coffee. BUT maybe R200 of that R1,050 could go to the journalism that’s fighting for the country?
We don’t dictate how much we’d like our readers to contribute. After all, how much you value our work is subjective (and frankly, every amount helps). At R200, you get it back in Uber Eats and ride vouchers every month, but that’s just a suggestion. A little less than a week’s worth of cappuccinos.
We can’t survive on hope and our own determination. Our country is going to be considerably worse off if we don’t have a strong, sustainable news media. If you’re rejigging your budgets, and it comes to choosing between frothy milk and Daily Maverick, we hope you might reconsider that cappuccino.
We need your help. And we’re not ashamed to ask for it.
Our mission is to Defend Truth. Join Maverick Insider.
Edward Kieswetter is Commissioner of the South African Revenue Service.
If our very dearly beloved Ahmed Kathrada was here today he would ask ‘What’s all this fuss about”? He would likely argue that there is no need to ‘memorialise my life through a permanent exhibition at Constitutional Hill, or anywhere for that matter.’
With reference to the preamble in our Constitution that we “Recognise the injustices of our past; Honour those who suffered for justice and freedom in our land; Respect those who have worked to build and develop our country; Uncle Kathy would:
He would make no demands for memorialisation at all, and yet it is for precisely these reasons that we are exactly where we need to be today:
There are many things that I will cherish since the first time I met Ahmed Kathrada almost 18 years ago, including accompanying him the Robben Island on four occasions. What is indelibly etched in me, though, was standing at Kathy’s bed about five hours before he would breathe his final breath. I stood there quietly crying as I thought of the disturbing and painful concerns he had felt and expressed during the final months of his life. He saw how the very purpose of his life and the lives of other giants of his generation — the Mandelas, the Sisulus, the Tambos, the Mbekis to name a few — were being placed at risk by an emerging generation of leaders, many of whom were failing to honour the promise of our constitution to:
Instead, Ahmed Kathrada in his final years, as witnessed by many of us, found himself experiencing a shift:
We have become a society more divided and void of true social cohesion — characterised by greed, violence and corruption.
Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations
In the past few years, I have personally had a ringside seat to the devastating effect of State Capture. Where institutions like SARS, the NPA, the Hawks, other departments and critical SOEs became personal fiefdoms used to serve a corrupt intent instead of the interest of all South Africans. I can attest that the damage through State Capture is real beyond anything the Nugent or Zondo Commissions could ever fully capture or describe. It is deeply systemic and will take persistent efforts, fearless resilience and years to repair. Anyone still in denial about State Capture is either complicit or still undermining the very work to root out corruption.
In fact, we are not yet in the clear — these corrupt and collusive elements that seek to undermine the integrity and capability of the state still lurk actively within these institutions.
We should remind ourselves every day that Corruption is not only a government phenomenon. It is a societal phenomenon.
The Kathrada generations were ordinary men and women like us. They weren’t perfect. They were aware of their own human frailties. They did not possess superhuman abilities. But what set them apart was:
What do we as a society do to ensure we honour the life of Kathy and those of his generation?
Lastly, and most importantly, if there’s one thing we’ve learnt it’s that Goverment on its own can never address our challenges and fix SA — we need strong social partnerships.
Social activism at grassroots level brought us our 1994 democracy. The next phase of our democracy will only come about through the resilient efforts of social activism at grassroots level.
That’s where organisations such as the Ahmed Kathrada Foundation (AFK) have an inordinate role to play and why the spirit and qualities of Ahmed Kathrada must be our guiding compass.
To do so, the AKF must increasingly create greater independence from conventional party politics and continue its quest to be a truly inclusive force for change; embrace our true South African-ness based on the timeless values of non-sexism, non-racism, and definitely place our common interest as a nation above the narrow interest of individuals or factions.
I am particularly encouraged by the next generation of young people — we depend on you to take this work forward.
May this exhibition in honour of Uncle Kathy remind us that there’s much work to be done.
Thank you. DM
Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.
Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.
All Comments 3
Unfortunately for uncle Kathy, he backed the wrong horse. The ANC have for past decades proven this over and over. We need to stop celebrating people who backed the ANC above the people for so long. Their end of life admissions to the failures of their beloved ANC are way too late. We now live in a state of anarchy and these celebrated cadres are the fathers of this anarchy and downfall of this country. No doubt uncle Kathy and many other struggle icons who have passed on, still voted for the ANC until the death.
Nothing is more important than this last statement – “place our common interest – above the narrow interest of individuals or factions.”
As the great Hillel said, “If not now, when?”
I feel it is inappropriate for a serving civil servant such as Kieswetter to be publicly be singing the praises of a politician. Given that Kieswetter is the Head of SARS, and that Kathrada was a communist, it is doubly inappropriate.
Daily Maverick © All rights reserved
There are many great benefits to being a Maverick Insider. Removing advertising from your browsing experience is one of them – we don’t just block ads, we redesign our pages to look smarter and load faster.
Click here to see other benefits and to sign-up to our reader community supporting quality, independent journalism.
Select which newsletters you’d like to receive
What is the Best Software for Live Video Streaming? – UrbanMatter
Table of Contents
Reviews of 6 Main Softwares by Talkytimes
Are you aware that the video industry is modernizing? We are evolving from a period of motionless video streaming to conversational live streaming. As humans, we normally want things to be sharp and brief, and anything that will make us spend quality time engaging will be worth it. So, as a streamer, your fans crave fascinating content with interactive components, no matter how short or long it is.
You may be wondering how to align with the latest trends and innovations in the video world. Well, getting streaming software is the next big thing you should consider. Streaming software will enable you to perform live streams, discuss with your followers, include interactive subjects, receive revenues, and do other additional stuff.
Research has shown that 79% of mobile usage will go towards video by 2022. And this figure will most likely keep increasing. Hence, understanding the usage of streaming software is crucial. However, selecting the best streaming software is critical to your business. There are plenty of alternatives on the market, and choosing the right one can be overwhelming.
Because of this, we have decided to discuss some of the best streaming software available on the market to enable you to make informed choices on the one suitable for your use on the Talkytimes or other streaming platforms.
Let’s jump right in!
The Wirecast software lets you stream live videos from your computer and create an interactive connection between your performances and the viewers. Wirecast software can capture videos from many gadgets, like PCs, cameras, network feeds, iOS cameras, and a host of others.
Users can handily personalize their transmissions by employing downward thirds, transitions, enlivened titles, and live button selections. It provides multi-configuration encoding abilities for live streaming, including CDN.
This software is famously utilized for performances like playing games, teaching, announcements, athletics, live occasions, and churches. The software has a free trial option and a paid subscription version, which you can obtain from an online shop. Also, Wirecast is compatible with macOS and Windows.
Some features of Wirecast are:
You can sign up now on the Talkytimes live streaming platform to start using the Wirecast software for your live video streams.
This effective streaming software features concurrent streaming, documenting, and production. It is a very powerful encoding software created by StudioCoast. vMix 24 is compatible with just Windows and can be launched on a Mac via Boot Camp if the device carries a Windows compartment.
The vMix encoder supports a vast number of inputs, like cameras at up to 4K resolution, video files like AVI, mp4, MPEG-2, WMV, etc., audio files like mp3 and WAV, web browsers, PowerPoint, images, heavy tones, web cameras, DVDs, playlists, etc.
Also, this software contains native support for multi-bitrate live videos, which is extremely beneficial to experienced streamers who place high importance on the user experience. vMix supports the NDI, which delivers your safeguarded stream upload over green screens.
Here are some vital features of vMix:
This cloud-based streaming aid allows you to stream videos consecutively to more than 30 channels simultaneously, including Talkytimes, Allcreate, Twitch, YouTube, etc. Restream is one of the limited streaming software packages that permits Real-time Platform and channel toggling. That means you can add additional live streaming channels without quitting your transmission.
Restream has features like Restream Events that enable you to plan and disclose your videos in advance to create enthusiasm. However, this element is exclusively accessible to Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn streamers.
Also, with Restream, you can assess your streaming progress across many channels using a single dashboard. You can recognize the most prominent aspect of your broadcast, the peak moment, the entire number of watchers, viewed minutes grouped by the channel, etc.
Other features include:
This is by far the best streaming software. It can stream and tape live and pre-taped videos and release them to more than forty (40) social media channels. If you have pre-recorded videos, you can record and then plan your publishing to social media channels up to sixty (60) days ahead.
Also, when streaming live videos, you can bond OneStream software with several streaming devices, configure this device, and begin multicasting. Planning pre-recorded streams is also great and simple. All you need to do is upload a video file, select a date & period, and choose your streaming platform like Talkytimes, Allcreate, YouTube, Twitch, Facebook, etc.
Other important features of OneStream:
This popular and proficient streaming software device fully supports live streaming demands. UStream Producer enables its users to include songs, videos, and pictures on their channels. It has a straightforward drag and drop feature that makes it simpler to analyze files from the PC to complete rapid multi-channel streaming.
Users can handily create a layer background symphony, including pre-recorded videos and live camera snapshots. This software is widely employed in preparing keynote speeches and PowerPoint presentations.
Here are some other features of the Ustream Producer software:
This is a cloud-based software for use on platforms like Talkytimes, Allcreate, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, etc. It provides multiple stream overlays, sufficient template options, and adequate support to customize your streams with more proficiency. For example, there is a provision to use the “coming back” and “launching shortly” screens for your streaming episode.
Streamlabs OBS comes with an application store that provides 46 apps to assist you with accomplishing better automation, streaming to many platforms simultaneously, several means of interacting with followers, and strong and in-depth analytics.
Other features include:
In this article, we have taken the time to share the best streaming software on the market. You can now make your choices based on the one that is suitable for you. If you are ready to launch your stream, you can sign up at the Talkytimes streaming platform to start creating live streams and publishing them to your target audience while generating multiple revenue streams.

Here at UrbanMatter, we pride ourselves on leading the charge when it comes to entertainment. Need ideas? News? Info? From venues, restaurants, and bars to events, festivals, and music — we’ve got you covered.
200 N LaSalle St Ste 1540 Chicago, IL 60601
E: [email protected]
P: 630.864.5270
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Built, Powered, & Developed By: Youtech
Studio Technologies Announces Advanced Broadcast Audio Solutions for IBC 2022 – Commercial Integrator
The company will display its latest intercom and announcer’s consoles, a new “Dante Bridge” and more at IBC 2022.
Studio Technologies, Skokie Ill.-based manufacturer of audio, video and fiber-optic solutions, announced its latest solutions at IBC 2022. The products include its Model 209 Talent Console, Model 354 Talk Station, Model 5304 Intercom Station, Model 5422A Dante Intercom Audio Engine and Model 5482 Dante Bridge.
Like many of the Studio Technologies products, these units support Dante Audio-over-Ethernet (AoE) technology for direct integration into contemporary applications. They are also compatible with AES67, SMPTE ST 2110 and support Audinate’s Dante Domain Manager software application.
“We continue to develop innovative audio solutions for modern, Dante-enabled applications,” says Gordon Kapes, president of Studio Technologies. “We’re excited to have our European team meet with an array of production personnel at IBC and demonstrate how they can seamlessly incorporate these products into their workflows.”
Additionally, depending on the specific Studio Technologies product, users can configure through a web browser or the free STcontroller software application. Production personnel can use STcontroller to quickly and easily configure units’ operating capabilities to meet the exact workflow needs. STcontroller is available in versions compatible with the WinOS and macOS operating systems.
Also Read: Studio Technologies Announces Model 392 Visual Indicator Unit
“I’m looking forward to showcasing Studio Technologies’ advanced solutions to the European market at IBC,” adds Mark Townsend, sales manager for international markets at Studio Technologies. “Getting back onto the IBC show floor will help to continue to grow Studio Technologies’ reputation as a leading Dante exponent.”
Commercial Integrator is dedicated to addressing the technological and business needs of professional integrators who serve the small and midsize business market. Whether you design, sell, service, or install… work on offices, churches, hospitals, schools or restaurants, Commercial Integrator is the dedicated resource you need.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Organizations are seeing a boon when implementing AV over IP technology, and integrators are finding happy customers when installing AV over IP. In this webinar, you’ll learn exactly why you need AV over IP.
After attending this free webinar from Commercial Integrator and TechDecisions you’ll understand what you need – and everything you can do – to ensure you get the best UC services for your organization working together.
CI Manufacturers Directory
(formerly our Buyers Guide)
Learn More About the
Windows Collaboration Display
Commercial Integrator is the first publication dedicated to addressing the business needs of professional integrators who serve the small and midsize business (SMB) market. Beyond products and installations, each issue tackles operational topics like job-estimating, project-bidding and big-picture market forecasting and more.
Stay up to date with the latest news and products for commercial integrators, sent straight to your inbox. With several options available, ranging from product coverage to the latest happenings of the industry, we strive to deliver the news you want in the most convenient way possible.
Follow Us On
Ⓒ 2022 Emerald X, LLC. All rights reserved.
Ink Master Cast Revealed: Which Returning Tattoo Artists Have Designs on the $250000 Prize? – TVLine
By
Paramount+ has revealed the lineup of returning tattoo artists who will be competing in Ink Master‘s 14th season, which will begin streaming on Wednesday, Sept. 7.
As previously announced, the new, 10-episode season will be hosted by Joel Madden, lead vocalist for the pop/punk band Good Charlotte and co-founder of music companies Veeps and MDDN, while the three new judges are Ryan Ashley, the first female tattoo artist to win Ink Master (in Season 8); Nikko Hurtado, one of the world’s best color realism artists; and Ami James, a well-known Japanese tattoo specialist and entrepreneur with almost 30 years of experience.
Former host Dave Navarro returns to the series as the “Master of Chaos,” introducing crazy twists and game-changing bombs to the competition.
This season’s contestants are described as “legendary fan-favorite artists” from previous Ink Master installments, facing off in “some of the biggest, most exciting and epic challenges seen in the history of the competition.” In addition to the title of “Ink Master,” the winner will take home the show’s biggest prize yet — a whopping $250,000.
“The legends will need to prove they possess the high level skills that sets an Ink Master apart: composition, precision, color theory, finesse, stamina and endurance,” the description continues. “With stakes higher than they’ve ever been, a single misstep could send them home and, in the end, only one artist will walk away with the title.”
Ink Master originally aired for 13 seasons on Spike/Paramount Network, birthing three spinoffs in the process — Ink Master: Redemption, Ink Master: Angels and Ink Master: Grudge Match.
Review the returning cast below, and get in your early votes for the next Ink Master champion.
Harvey Weinstein Granted Appeal On NY Conviction, Could Get Bail…
College Football in Ireland Renews Rivalry for Notre Dame’s…
Barbie Ferreira Says She’s Not Returning for ‘Euphoria’ Season…
From ‘Moon Knight’ to ‘Pam & Tommy,’ Emmy-Nominated Costumes…
Review: How Do Skullcandy’s Dime 2 Budget Wireless Earbuds…
TVLine is a part of Penske Media Corporation. © 2022 TVLine Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
PMC Entertainment
Powered by WordPress VIP
This Puzzle Game Is A Fun, Affordable Way To Learn Electronic Music – Kotaku
Advertisement
Released in September of last year, The Signal State was a surprising and fun way to translate the process of making modular synth patches into cool logic puzzles—which is kind of what modular synthesis is all about in the first place. In a new update, developer Reckoner Industries has added a fun new sandbox mode to the game that lets you dive into the more creative side of modular synthesis. Instead of tackling puzzles, you can now just toy around and create cool sounds, seeing and hearing what happens when you plug different things into one another while learning how these instruments work at a fraction of the real-world cost. The results translate well to the real thing, which is particularly cool if you’re looking for a fun opportunity to learn how to create synth patches in a friendly, affordable environment.
The Signal State, available for Windows and Mac on Steam and GOG, takes the most fundamental concept of how modular synthesizers work and wraps a post-apocalyptic plot around it. The game takes what are basically “modules,” discrete sound devices that have specific functions and can connect to other sound devices via voltage not too dissimilar from how a GPU works in a computer, and characterizes them as components necessary to rebuild various electrical systems on a farm. Through its puzzles, you learn how to route voltage in different directions, while also being tasked with choosing the right modules to affect the flow and amount of voltage in a circuit. It’s a super chill, but challenging, logic puzzle game that closely mirrors what it’s like to work with a real Eurorack synthesizer.
Previously, the only way to play with The Signal State’s modular devices was to go through puzzles that often had very specific, if not a little mind-bending, solutions. You couldn’t actually just connect modules together into “patches” and see what kinds of sounds develop. With the addition of the new sandbox mode, however, the developer has added some new modules that let you explore the fundamentals of modular synthesis and sequencer-based music.
While this new mode is far from a reason to abandon a real synthesizer or even complex software synths like VCV Rack, the new mode is kind of a perfect set of training wheels for understanding how a modular synth works. The answer, as veterans are likely aware, is all about where the voltage is coming from and where it’s going.
“Training wheels” are kind of a perfect way to describe this game and this new mode, because if you really want to get into the very awesome (and potentially very expensive) world of modular synthesis, this game will help you cover the basics, but if you really get sucked into this world, you’ll have to consider pro-audio software or gear if you want to go further. That’s not a point of criticism; this game will cover the basics in ways that many folks don’t know when diving into the real thing. On top of that, The Signal State does a little bit of the fundamental work for you behind the scenes, and in that it can feel a little restricting and confusing to those who already know how to use the real-world equivalent of these instruments.
Get started with a free Xbox game
Right now there is a promotion where you can get a free digital game with your purchase of an Xbox Series S. The digital game options include Elden Ring, Forza Horizon 5, Halo Infinite, LEGO Star Wars Skywalker Saga, NFL Madden 23, and Saints Row.
Most of the game’s way of routing an audio signal, for example, doesn’t really track with how these devices work in the real world. As an artist who works with modular and semi-modular synthesizers, I actually struggled a bit to figure out how to get things working. And I ended up creating music that felt more rigid than what I know I can make on an actual synth. Also, the way it works with its clocks feels strange to me, and the low-frequency oscillator module (LFO) doesn’t totally behave the way I’m used to it behaving in a real-world synth. I felt less self-conscious about my early struggles when I watched electronic musician Benn Jordan stumble a bit in the beginning too on his stream of the new mode.
As someone who’s quite familiar with musical instruments and synths, there are a handful of things I would do differently if I was teaching someone. The way the game handles the actual sound-generating modules, for example, isn’t the way I’d go about breaking down the principles of sound design and electronic music, but that’s not a loss, just a difference in what Reckoner Industries thinks makes sense for a stripped down, beginner-friendly environment. For all of the little ways I found myself saying “yeah, I’d teach a student differently,” the game completely makes up for it by providing a far easier approach to learning with clear explanations, hints for when you get stuck, and very handy visualizations of where voltage is going and how much.
That said, if you do jump into the real world of modular synthesis after playing The Signal State, be ready for some growing pains that are par for the course when graduating to a higher level of music making. On the whole, this game will give you the vocabulary and perspectives necessary to cover the very basics of designing a “patch,” which is just a term to refer to a specific arrangement of modules and how they’re connected.
The only real critique I have concerns ambient music that the game just plays over sandbox mode which, while it sounds pretty, can be very distracting and isn’t too great for a learning experience, since you may not know where that sound is coming from. You can mitigate it by selecting “sync” in the “System Source.” Turning down the music in the game’s settings will kill all sound, so it would be nice to have a dedicated option to kill the background music for the sake of learning and exploration.
While real music production software like VCV Rack is free and The Signal State is not, if you’re a beginner, you might find this game to be more helpful, as it offers tips and more clearly spells out the exact function of each module, which is something most pro-audio software doesn’t do. Also, modular synthesis can get really, really expensive. So learning on a $20 game might save you from making some costly mistakes in the future, such as spending money on gear you don’t yet know how to use or don’t actually have a use for. Buying an expensive piece of audio gear and then not using it is super normal for musicians (like that $3,000 custom guitar that’s been sitting in my closet for the last few years…), but The Signal State will help you avoid a lot of expensive bumps in the road that many fledgling musicians come across. But expect the real-world equivalent of what’s in this game to be expensive. I put a very simple synth together this year with just five modules for around $1,000. A perpetual $20 lesson in the form of this game can be a lifesaver if you’re serious. Then you can move onto VCV and go from there.
If you go through all of the game’s main puzzles and spend enough time in sandbox mode exploring and planning out patches, you’ll be way more ahead of where most people are when they get into Eurorack. So have fun making all the beeping sounds, setting up fun sequences, and try not to spend too much money after you plan out a real synth on modulargrid.net. Tip: Buy used and look for DIY kits. You’ll save a ton of money.