Opinion: Four ways the Inflation Reduction Act doesn’t live up to the hype CNN
source
Press Release | Press Releases | Newsroom | U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer of New York – Senator Schumer
Schumer-Led American Rescue Plan Gave New York 2nd Largest Investment From SSBCI In The Country At Over $500M, Federal Investment That Will Expand Investment And Opportunities for Entrepreneurs, Small Businesses, and Underserved Businesses Across The State
On The Heels of Schumer’s CHIPS & Science Bill To Bring Semiconductor Production Back From Overseas, And Inflation Reduction Act To Strengthen America’s Clean Energy Manufacturing, Schumer Is Delivering BIG Fed Investment To Restore Upstate NY As An Innovation And Manufacturing Powerhouse, Driving Major New Opportunities for Entrepreneurship and Small Businesses
Schumer: New York Small Businesses Will Get A $500M Boost To Recover And Lead The Way In New Industries And Rebuilding The Economy
After delivering on historic investment in the State Small Business Credit Initiative (SSBCI) as part of the American Rescue Plan, U.S. Senate Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer announced today that the U.S. Treasury Department has approved New York’s application for SSBCI funding for up to $501 million. This federal investment will be used to increase access to capital and new contracting opportunities, as well as promote entrepreneurship, particularly in rural and underserved areas, helping small businesses recover from the pandemic and deal with increased costs and supply chain challenges.
“This historic $500 million federal investment is the shot in the arm New York’s small businesses need to recover from the pandemic and rebuild our local economies. This federal assistance will help support underserved businesses, invest in entrepreneurs and small businesses in key industries like manufacturing and clean energy to address the nation’s supply chain challenges, and create good-paying jobs in the communities that need them most,” said Senator Schumer. “As majority leader, I fought to secure the State Small Business Credit Initiative federal investment as part of the American Rescue Plan to meet the unprecedented challenges faced by the nation’s small businesses during the pandemic and I am proud to now deliver this federal funding for New York to build up the state’s small businesses and manufacturing base to accelerate our recovery, and drive our economy into the future.”
“This is an historic investment in entrepreneurship, small business growth, and innovation through the American Rescue Plan that will help reduce barriers to capital access for traditionally underserved communities,” said Secretary of the Treasury Janet L. Yellen. “I’m excited to see how SSBCI funds will promote equitable economic growth in New York and across the country.”
Schumer, who helped to include $10 billion for SSBCI in the American Rescue Plan, said this federal funding is expected to leverage up to $10 of private investment for every $1 of SSBCI capital funding, significantly increasing access to capital for entrepreneurs and small businesses, including underserved businesses like minority- and women-owned and rural businesses. New York State will be able to use this funding to create venture capital programs, loan participation programs, loan guarantee programs, collateral support programs, capital access programs and programs to help small and underserved businesses compete for government contracts, including projects funded by the bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act.
Schumer said that investments like the SSBCI federal funding is also key to strengthening New York’s small manufacturers and can help entrepreneurs and innovators grow new manufacturing jobs in New York to fill immediate and future supply chain gaps, helping make more in New York, and helping alleviate the national supply chain crisis. Earlier this year, Schumer wrote to Secretary Yellen to push for the Administration to work with states on utilizing SSBCI funding to support manufacturing and innovation. Schumer’s CHIPS & Science Act and Inflation Reduction Act are also driving major new growth in American manufacturing, and this SSBCI funding for New York will help more of the state’s entrepreneurs and small businesses invest and succeed as part of that new opportunity in manufacturing and clean energy.
New York has already been putting the funding Schumer has delivered for this program previously to work helping to boost minority owned and underserved businesses across the state. For example, New York has allocated over $154 million to the Emerging & Regional Manager Multi-Fund Program, which provides equity support to small businesses by investing through private venture capital funds. Empire State Development will provide SSBCI capital support to venture capital funds with diverse and emerging fund managers. In addition, New York has allocated funds to two programs designed to help small and underserved businesses compete for government contracts, including through an existing program that saw 75% of its support for potential contractors going to minority- and women-owned businesses.
Senator Schumer has been leading the charge for robust federal relief for small businesses. Since the start of the pandemic, the senator has secured:
New York will also fund a loan program to make low-cost capital available to more small businesses and nonprofit organizations by partnering with Community Development Financial Institution (CDFI) lenders. Throughout the pandemic, Schumer has fought for expanding support for the CDFI network to expand access to capital and technical assistance for underserved businesses and nonprofits.
A copy of Schumer’s original joint letter to U.S. Department of Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen appears below:
Dear Secretary Yellen:
We write to request that the Department of the Treasury work with states to use funds from the American Rescue Plan Act-funded State Small Business Credit Initiative (SSBCI) to address the urgent need to bring manufacturing back to the United States to strengthen domestic supply chains, prevent delays and disruptions, and lower prices for American families. The manufacturing sector accounted for the largest share of total loans and investments under the previous round of SSBCI funding, and we hope to see robust investments in domestic manufacturing using the funding provided through the American Rescue Plan.
Treasury has taken an important step in the right direction by including in the initial SSBCI guidance direction to states to consider the benefits of investments in small and mid-size enterprise manufacturing and supply chain resiliency as they design other capital support programs. We appreciate that the Administration recently expressed an interest in convening a roundtable of key stakeholders, and we ask that Treasury consider hosting regional workshops to share best practices for helping states adopt investment strategies targeting supply chain weaknesses, particularly investment in minority-owned and rural small businesses.
We have already worked together on reviving American manufacturing, and our collective efforts have delivered real results: 367,000 new American manufacturing jobs were created last year, the most in nearly 30 years, fueled by an expansion of manufacturing activity every month that has recovered domestic manufacturing growth to pre-pandemic levels. Challenges remain, however, especially for smaller and disadvantaged manufacturers. Manufacturers have larger capital requirements than many other sectors and need access to ready capital.
Small and medium-sized manufacturers, which account for 98 percent of domestic manufacturers, face particular difficulties accessing capital to invest in equipment and facility upgrades, affecting their productivity. A National Science Foundation-funded study found that only 0.4 percent of private venture capital dollars invested in the U.S. went to manufacturing, starving the sector of the investment needed for scaling production here in America. Minority-owned, rural, and other socially and economically disadvantaged manufacturers face additional hurdles in accessing the capital they need to succeed.
The SSBCI is an important tool for strengthening America’s small manufacturers, including providing the capital to expand the domestic production of critical goods that can fill immediate and future supply chain gaps in technologies like semiconductors, batteries, and other innovation industries. Along with encouraging venture capital investments, the SSBCI can also provide collateral support programs, loan guarantee, and loan participation programs which can support smaller manufacturers.
In addition to regional roundtables to help states make use of the SSBCI to support manufacturing, we request that Treasury help coordinate other federal resources to support state efforts like the Commerce Department’s Manufacturing Extension Partnership, Manufacturing USA institutes, and Minority Business Development Agency centers. State agencies implementing the SSBCI can turn to intermediaries, working with federal partners to help educate lenders and venture capital investors about the unique needs of manufacturers, to support capital flowing to manufacturing and supply chain needs. For example, states should plan interventions that deploy SSBCI towards ownership transitions among the estimated 125,000 small manufacturers that are at risk of closure when their owners are expected to retire, helping to prevent the loss of these companies. Treasury should also consider support for jurisdictions adding innovative financing tools to deploy SSBCI program dollars effectively in supporting the unique cash flow attributes of manufacturers and supply chain industries.
The SSBCI application for technical assistance (TA), due in late June 2022, also creates a window of opportunity to target support to small manufacturers. Congress gave Treasury the flexibility to deploy these funds, including the authority to partner with the Commerce Department, on issues like manufacturing and diverse ownership. We believe Treasury should incorporate advice for manufacturers specifically in the forthcoming TA guidelines. TA funds will also be an important opportunity to strengthen the role of Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) in manufacturing, as they will likely be one of the key entities deploying SSBCI-backed debt products. CDFIs also provide, or have strong partnerships with organizations that provide, technical assistance to support growing manufacturing businesses, particularly those in rural areas or those owned by Americans in traditionally-marginalized communities.
We believe that funding from the SSBCI will support more resilient domestic supply chains and lead to a stronger manufacturing sector that will strengthen our economy and communities for generations. We thank you for considering our perspective and we look forward to your response.
Sincerely,
###
Please be advised that due to the implementation of enhanced mail screening procedures, all mail sent to my state offices will experience a two to three week delay in delivery.
In the meantime, if you have an urgent matter, the best way to reach me is by phone at (202) 224-6542 or through any of my eight district offices.
Drew University Master of Science in Finance Students Learn From Industry Leaders – Drew Today
Tags: Caspersen, finance, Homepage
August 2022 – One critical component of Drew’s Master of Science in Finance (MFin) program is the inclusion of industry expert guest speakers.
Steve Firestone, assistant teaching professor of finance and director of the MFin program, regularly organizes several of them throughout a given course.
Enlarge
“Having guest speakers was the most helpful experience throughout the year and this capstone course,” said Nate Race G’22.
The latest guest was Katie Stockton, founder and managing partner of Fairlead Strategies, a frequent guest on CNBC and Bloomberg News as a leading authority on technical analysis of equities, cryptocurrency, and other assets.
“The opportunity to hear from and engage with financial experts like Katie Stockton is part of what sets Drew’s MFin program apart,” said Jon Gates C’22, who is among the first MFin students earning Drew’s new concentration in financial engineering.
“During her time with our capstone class, she demystified some complex aspects of technical analysis and demonstrated how it ca inform investment decisions. She encouraged us to incorporate technical analysis into our financial research and provided concrete examples of how we could do it.”
Stockton joined a list of guests that included Mike Maestas, managing director of alternative assets at Schwab Charitable Trust and Ben Lynch C’11, ETF trader at Bank of America Merrill Lynch.
“Actually meeting people in the real world and hearing them explain their experiences has given me and my classmates great ideas on how to pursue a career in the finance field,” said Race.
For the students, the value of hearing from experts was just one of many aspects of the MFin program that make a mark.
“Drew’s business/finance program has greatly influenced me as an individual as I have learned so much in the financial field, but also learned about myself through the process,” said Race.
“I would not be where I am today without the constant effort of all my professors and I am extremely thankful for that.”
Written by [email protected]
Written by [email protected]
Written by [email protected]
Written by [email protected]
Written by [email protected]
Written by [email protected]
Usyk vs AJ: Watch Oleksandr Usyk vs Anthony Joshua weigh-in LIVE! – Sky Sports
Watch live exclusive coverage as the fighters hit the scales for the Oleksandr Usyk vs Anthony Joshua weigh-in; don’t miss Usyk vs AJ 2 live on Sky Sports Box Office on Saturday
Friday 19 August 2022 13:30, UK
Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player
This stream has now ended.
With one day to go before Anthony Joshua and Oleksandr Usyk collide in their monumental rematch live and exclusive on Sky Sports Box Office, the fighters take to the scales for the weigh-in.
Joshua is looking to reclaim his place at the top of the heavyweight division and win back the IBF, WBO and WBA heavyweight titles that Usyk won in spectacular fashion when he dethroned Joshua last year.
Their weights will be a key indicator of how each fighter might be planning on approaching the fight tomorrow night.
Watch the free stream today from 12.30pm of the undercard and main event weigh-ins.
The bill also features Olympic silver medallist Ben Whittaker, having his second professional fight after making a stunning pro debut at the end of last month.
Book Usyk v Joshua 2 now!
Book Usyk-Joshua 2 if you’re not a Sky customer
Usyk v Joshua 2: How to book the fight
Callum Smith is looking to keep his dream of becoming a two-weight world champion alive in a tricky title eliminator against Mathieu Bauderlique.
Heavyweight contenders Filip Hrgovic and Zhilei Zhang are fighting to emerge as one of the main challengers for the Usyk-Joshua winner.
Ramla Ali and Crystal Garcia Nova will become the first women to box in an international event in Saudi Arabia.
Plus, Badou Jack, Andrew Tabiti and more feature on the bill.
Anthony Joshua’s huge heavyweight rematch against Oleksandr Usyk is on Saturday August 20, live on Sky Sports Box Office. Book Usyk vs Joshua 2 now!
© 2022 Sky UK
The Challenges And Wonders Of Preserving Legacy Recordings – Sonic State
As part of its ongoing mission to promote awareness and appreciation of high-quality professional audio through market leadership, communication and education, the Professional Audio Manufacturers Alliance (PAMA) will hold its newest online presentation this Thursday, August 18, at 12 p.m. EDT/ 9 a.m. PDT, titled “The Challenges and Wonders of Preserving Legacy Recordings” with presenter Kelly Pribble, Director of Media Recovery Technology at Iron Mountain Entertainment Services (pictured above). This is what they have to say about it…
Original master recordings from well-known artists and labels like Bob Dylan, RUSH, Mariah Carey and SUN Records face a myriad of natural degradation and storage-related issues that are threatening irreplaceable analog recording archives. Legacy digital tape recordings, many on short-lived and now all-but-obsolete formats, have their own concerns. Pribble will discuss the challenges encountered in preserving master recordings to avoid the possible permanent loss of these legendary resources. He’ll also address the monetization of archived recordings and how technology can help.
Kelly Pribble, Director of Media Recovery Technology at Iron Mountain Entertainment Services (IMES), is a veteran studio engineer, studio builder, archivist and inventor. In March 2022, he was issued a patent for Media Recovery Technology. Before joining Iron Mountain, Pribble reopened the legendary Nashville “Quadrafonic Sound Studio” in 1988. The next year he purchased the building next door and built an additional three studios, providing Nashville with its largest recording complex at that time. After more than a decade of running Quad Studios, Pribble left Nashville for London, where he worked closely with record producer Martin Terefe. Together they built “Kensaltown Studios” in West London, an eight-studio complex that still thrives today as one of West London’s premier studio locations. With a career spanning over three decades, Pribble has worked extensively in Nashville, London, New York City and Rio de Janeiro.
About PAMA:
Founded in 2003, the Professional Audio Manufacturers Alliance (PAMA) is the collective voice and forum for the leading manufacturers of professional audio products and the people who use them. PAMA member companies conduct business worldwide in support of high-quality audio across a wide range of industries – pursuing the state of the art in technology and practice to enable audio professionals to elevate their craft and delight listeners and audiences every day. PAMA’s mission is to promote awareness and appreciation of high-quality professional audio through market leadership, communication and education. Our core customers are pro-audio professionals around the world with an interest in promoting high-quality audio. Learn more at www.pamalliance.org.
Event Registration:
We chat with the developers
Officially announced today, price
Pre Sunroof gig at Superbooth
New native instrument from the Spark range
To flash drive, more
Copyright Sonic State Ltd © 1995-2022. All rights reserved.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission from Sonic State is prohibited.
Hey there, we use Cookies to customize your experience on Sonicstate.com
Cheney releases concession call audio in tit-for-tat with her primary foe – POLITICO
Elections
After Harriet Hageman said her Wyoming GOP opponent didn't concede, the Cheney campaign provided a recording. And the Hageman camp pushed right back.
By Olivia Beavers
Link Copied
After Donald Trump-backed Harriet Hageman claimed Wednesday night that Rep. Liz Cheney never fully conceded their Wyoming GOP primary race, the defeated incumbent released her receipts.
Hageman told Fox News that Cheney had “left a very brief two-second message on my cell phone” Tuesday night, without addressing “any kind of concession or anything else.” According to audio provided by the Cheney campaign to POLITICO, however, Cheney called Hageman to concede the race at 8:13 p.m. on Tuesday night.
Audible in the recording is an aide notifying Cheney that the Associated Press had just called the race for her opponent.
“Hi, Harriet, it is Liz Cheney calling,” Cheney is heard saying in the audio. “It is about 8:13 on Tuesday the 16th, I’m calling to concede the election and congratulate you on the win. Thanks.”
The recording contradicts the narrative Hageman offered host Sean Hannity on Wednesday about Cheney’s call on primary night.
“I haven’t had any other contact with Liz Cheney. She made the one effort and all she said was ‘Hello, Harriet.’ And then that was the end of it,” Hageman said. When Hannity sought to clarify that she was alleging Cheney had “just said ‘Hello, Harriet’ and then hung up,” Hageman reiterated: “That was the end of the call, yes.”
After publication of the Cheney campaign’s recording, a Hageman spokesperson provided a video of their own. It shows a phone ostensibly belonging to Hageman playing a message identified as coming from Cheney’s number. The message as played on-screen contains only Cheney’s two-word greeting before sound cuts off for more than 10 more seconds.
In an interview with POLITICO on Wednesday, Cheney said she had tried to call Hageman three times, but ultimately left a voicemail before she took the stage at her election night party. Cheney added that she never heard back from Hageman.
As a separate response to Cheney’s own narrative, a Hageman spokesperson released a second video that shows the GOP nominee’s call log from Tuesday night. It includes only one message directly from Cheney, though they said Hageman’s team received other communications from elsewhere in the defeated incumbent’s campaign.
The Cheney campaign’s release of the audio recording after Hageman appeared on Fox News comes as the defeated Trump critic prepares to expend significant resources to prevent him from returning to the White House, including the launch of a new outside group.
Link Copied
© 2022 POLITICO LLC
Zedd Opens Up About Next Album, Reunites With Maren Morris for Bubbly Collab, "Make You Say" – EDM.com
Sophia Matinazad
Co-produced by BEAUZ and co-written with Charlie Puth, the record arrives over four years since the release of "The Middle."
It's hard to believe it's been almost five years since Zedd and Maren Morris released "The Middle." Feel old yet?
The two have now reunited for "Make You Say," a bubbly collab co-written with Charlie Puth and produced alongside dance music production duo BEAUZ.
Zedd said the new track "is the kickoff of a new chapter" as he records his next album, his first since 2015's chart-topping True Colors. Speaking with Zane Lowe of Apple Music 1, he opened up about the album's musical direction.
"My next big project is my album and I started that before the pandemic. I actually sent you a song that I was working on. That is a little bit darker," Zedd said. "The feeling of the album is going to have some happy moments and some hands-up moments, but that is still my direction for the record. It's going to be dance-heavy, but I'm trying to incorporate some of my early influences in the song I sent you, which is a little bit dark and twisted to classical music, which I'm remaking an old classical piece. So that's my next big project, but it's definitely going to live in the dance world."
Nadia Ali's vocals are as powerful as ever in Vini Vici's electrifying rework of "Rapture."
Co-produced by BEAUZ and co-written with Charlie Puth, the record arrives over four years since the release of "The Middle."
“Hypnotic” marks the third single from Malaa's forthcoming debut album, "DON MALAA."
Zedd also reflected on "The Middle" and gushed about reuniting with Morris, who said she "had big shoes to fill" after being tasked with replacing Puth's vocal on the original demo.
"The first time with 'The Middle,' it was just her voice," Zedd said. "At that time when I heard the vocal, I actually didn't know much about Maren's background or what kind of music she comes from. I just heard a demo. I don't even know if the file was labeled anything that would give away who the vocalist was. I literally just listened for the color and I think Maren's voice just has everything that a good voice needs. It's got character. You immediately can tell who it is. She has this amazing rasp, which to me is always a bit of emotion that I look for."
You can find "Make You Say" on streaming platforms here.
Facebook: facebook.com/Zedd
Twitter: twitter.com/Zedd
Instagram: instagram.com/Zedd
Spotify: spoti.fi/2CoYpk2
Facebook: facebook.com/beauzworld
Twitter: twitter.com/beauz_world
Instagram: instagram.com/beauzworld
Spotify: spoti.fi/3cztr7C
Facebook: facebook.com/marenmorris
Twitter: twitter.com/MarenMorris
Instagram: instagram.com/marenmorris
Spotify: spoti.fi/3whNhii
Sign up for the latest news, exclusive giveaways & more.
Zedd said the lyrics of “You’ve Got To Let Go If You Want To Be Free” are a “coping mechanism” for his bouts with anxiety.
Ahead of their fourth full-length album, The Chainsmokers’ Drew Taggart said the duo are “more inspired” now than they’ve been in four years.
The new single also comes with a branded merch bundle.
Zedd also cryptically announced a forthcoming Twitch event.
The release of “Sentio” fittingly arrives in the thick of festival season.
Zedd’s electro house roots shine in his blood-pumping remix of Grabbitz’s VALORANT Champions anthem.
The album was released in celebration of Francis’ 34th birthday.
“Lifetime,” which features Ty Dolla $ign and 070 Shake, will appear on a new Swedish House Mafia album in the works.
Bound on optimal local discrimination of multipartite quantum states | Scientific Reports – Nature.com
Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 14130 (2022)
1
Metrics details
We consider the unambiguous discrimination of multipartite quantum states and provide an upper bound for the maximum success probability of optimal local discrimination. We also provide a necessary and sufficient condition to realize the upper bound. We further establish a necessary and sufficient condition for this upper bound to be saturated. Finally, we illustrate our results using examples in multidimensional multipartite quantum systems.
Quantum nonlocality is a quintessential phenomenon of multipartite quantum systems which does not have any classical counterpart. Entanglement is one of the most representative nonlocal quantum correlations which cannot be realized only by local operations and classical communication (LOCC)1,2. It is known that the nonlocal property of quantum entanglement can be used as a resource in many quantum information processing tasks3.
Quantum nonlocal phenomenon can also arise in multipartite quantum state discrimination, which is an essential process for efficient information transfer in quantum communication. In general, orthogonal quantum states can be discriminated with certainty, whereas such discrimination is impossible for nonorthogonal quantum states. Along this line, state discrimination strategies are needed to discriminate nonorthogonal quantum states at least with some nonzero probability4,5,6,7. However, some orthogonal states of multipartite quantum systems cannot be discriminated with certainty when the available measurements are limited to LOCC measurements8. As orthogonal states can always be discriminated with certainty when there is no limitation of possible measurement, this limited discrimination ability of LOCC measurement reveals the nonlocal phenomenon inherent in quantum state discrimination.
Nonlocal phenomenon of quantum state discrimination can also arise in discriminating nonorthogonal states of multipartite quantum systems; it is known that some nonorthogonal states cannot be optimally discriminated using only LOCC9,10,11. For this reason, much attention has been shown for the optimal local discrimination of multipartite quantum states12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19. Nevertheless, realizing optimal local discrimination still remains a challenging task because it is hard to have a good mathematical characterization of LOCC.
One efficient way to overcome this difficulty is to investigate possible upper bounds for the maximum success probability of optimal local discrimination. For a better understanding of optimal local discrimination, it is also important to establish good conditions realizing such upper bounds. Recently, an upper bound of maximum success probability was established in local minimum-error discrimination of bipartite quantum states. Moreover, a necessary and sufficient condition was also provided for this upper bound to be saturated20.
Here, we consider unambiguous discrimination (UD)21,22,23,24 among multipartite quantum states of arbitrary dimensions and provide an upper bound for the maximum success probability of optimal local discrimination. Moreover, we provide a necessary and sufficient condition to realize this upper bound. We also establish a necessary and sufficient condition for this upper bound to be saturated. Finally, we illustrate our results using examples in multidimensional multipartite quantum systems.
This paper is organized as follows. In the “Results” Section, we first recall the definition and some properties about separable operators and separable measurements in multipartite quantum systems. We further recall the definition of UD and provide some useful properties of optimal UD (Proposition 1). As the main results of this paper, we provide an upper bound for the maximum success probability of optimal local discrimination by using a certain class of Hermitian operators acting on multipartite Hilbert space (Theorem 1). Moreover, we provide a necessary and sufficient condition for the Hermitian operator to realize this upper bound (Theorem 2 and Corollary 1). We also establish a necessary and sufficient condition for this upper bound to be saturated (Corollary 2). We illustrate our results by examples in multidimensional multipartite quantum systems (Examples 1 and 2). In the “Methods” Section, we provide a detail proof of Theorem 1. In the “Discussion” Section, we summarize our results and discuss possible future works related to our results.
In multipartite quantum systems, a state is described by a density operator (rho ) acting on a multipartite Hilbert space ({mathscr {H}}=bigotimes_{k=1}^{m}{mathscr {H}}_{k}) consisting of the subsystems ({mathscr {H}}_{k}cong {mathbb {C}}^{d_{k}}) with (mgeqslant 2) and positive integers (d_{k}) for (k=1,ldots ,m). A measurement is expressed by a positive operator-valued measure(POVM) ({M_{i}}_{i}) that is a set of positive-semidefinite operators (M_{i}succeq 0) on ({mathscr {H}}) satisfying completeness relation (sum _{i}M_{i}=mathbbm {1}), where (mathbbm {1}) is the identity operator on ({mathscr {H}}). The probability of obtaining the measurement outcome corresponding to (M_{j}) is (mathrm {Tr}(rho M_{j})) for the prepared state (rho ).
A positive-semidefinite operator E (not necessarily a state) on ({mathscr {H}}) is called separable if it can be represented as a summation of positive-semidefinite product operators, that is,
where (E_{l,k}) is a positive-semidefinite operator on ({mathscr {H}}_{k}) for each (k=1,ldots ,m). We denote the set of all positive-semidefinite separable operators on ({mathscr {H}}) as
A measurement ({M_{i}}_{i}) is called a LOCC measurement if it can be implemented by LOCC, and it is called separable if (M_{i}in mathrm {SEP}) for all i. It is known that every LOCC measurement is separable1.
A simple example of LOCC measurement is ({M_{1,i_{1}}otimes cdots otimes M_{m,i_{m}}}_{i_{1},ldots ,i_{m}}) where ({M_{l,i_{l}}}_{i_{l}}) is a POVM on the lth subsystem for each (l=1,ldots ,m). This separable measurement can be implemented by local measurements and classical communication; For each (l=1,ldots ,m), a local measurement ({M_{l,i_{l}}}_{i_{l}}) is performed on the lth subsystem; If it is confirmed through classical communication that the measurement result of the lth subsystem is (M_{l,i_{l}}) for each (l=1,ldots ,m), the measurement result of the whole system becomes (M_{1,i_{1}}otimes cdots otimes M_{m,i_{m}}). Thus, ({M_{1,i_{1}}otimes cdots otimes M_{m,i_{m}}}_{i_{1},ldots ,i_{m}}) is a LOCC measurement.
Here, we consider the situation of discriminating multipartite quantum states (rho _{1},ldots ,rho _{n}) where the state (rho _{i}) is prepared with the probability (eta _{i}). We denote this situation as an ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}). Moreover, we consider the discrimination of the multipartite state ensemble (mathscr {E}) using a measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) where (M_{0}) gives inconclusive results about the prepared state and (M_{i}) provides conclusive results of (rho _{i}) for each (i=1,ldots ,n). For the conclusive results to be unambiguous, so-called no-error condition is required;
By defining
Eq. (3) can be rewritten as
We say that a measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) is unambiguous if it satisfies the no-error condition in Eq. (5).
The optimal UD of (mathscr {E}) is to minimize the probability of obtaining inconclusive results. Equivalently, the optimal UD of (mathscr {E}) is to achieve the optimal success probability of (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}) defined as
where the maximum is taken over all possible unambiguous measurements. The following proposition provide a necessary and sufficient condition of an optimal unambiguous measurement realizing (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E}))25.
For given ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}), an unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) provides the optimal success probability (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})) if and only if there is a Hermitian operator K satisfying the following condition,
where (mathrm {Pos}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,ldots ,n)) is the dual set of (mathrm {Pos}_{i}(mathscr {E})) defined as
In this case, we have
For each (mathrm {Pos}_{i}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (4), we denote the subset of separable operators,
The unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) is called separable if
where (mathrm {SEP}) is defined in Eq. (2).
When the available measurements are limited to separable unambiguous measurements, we denote the maximum success probability by
We use (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})) to denote the maximum of success probability that can be obtained using LOCC unambiguous measurements, that is,
For a given ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}), we define (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) as the minimum quantity
over all possible Hermitian operator H satisfying
where (mathrm {SEP}^{*}) and (mathrm {SEP}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,ldots ,n)) are the dual sets of (mathrm {SEP}) and (mathrm {SEP}_{i}(mathscr {E})) in Eqs. (2) and (10), respectively, that is,
Note that (mathrm {SEP}^{*}) contains all positive-semidefinite operators because every element of (mathrm {SEP}) is positive semidefinite. Due to the similar reason, (mathrm {SEP}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,ldots ,n)) contains all positive-semidefinite operators.
The following theorem shows that (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) is equal to (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (12). The proof of Theorem 1 is provided in the “Methods” Section.
For a multipartite quantum state ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}),
For a given ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}), the following theorem provides a necessary and sufficient condition on a Hermitian operator H to realize (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})).
For a multipartite quantum state ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}), a Hermitian operator H satisfying Condition (15) gives (q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) if and only if there is a separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) such that,
In this case, we have
For the necessity, suppose that H is a Hermitian operator providing (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). We also denote ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) as a separable unambiguous measurement giving (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). From Conditions (11) and (15), we have
We also note that
where the first equality follows from (sum _{i=0}^{n}M_{i}=mathbbm {1}), the second equality is due to the assumption of H and ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}), and the last equality is by Theorem 1. Inequality (20) and Eq. (21) lead us to Condition (18). Therefore, ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) is a separable unambiguous measurement satisfying Condition (18).
For the sufficiency, we assume that ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) is a separable unambiguous measurement and H is a Hermitian operator satisfying Conditions (15) and (18). This assumption implies,
where the first equality follows from Theorem 1, the second equality is from Condition (18), the last equality is due to (sum _{i=0}^{n}M_{i}=mathbbm {1}), and the first and second inequalities are from the definitions of (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) and (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})), respectively. Inequality (22) leads us to (mathrm {Tr}H=q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})). Therefore, H is a Hermitian operator giving (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). (square )
From Theorems 1 and 2, we have the following corollary providing a necessary and sufficient condition on a separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) to realize (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})).
For a multipartite quantum state ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}), a separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) gives (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) if and only if there is a Hermitian operator H satisfying Conditions (15) and (18). In this case, we have,
Moreover, we have the following corollary that provides the relative ordering between (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})) and (q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})).
For a multipartite quantum state ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}),
where the equality holds if and only if there is a LOCC unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) and a Hermitian operator H satisfying Conditions (15) and (18).
Since every LOCC measurement is separable, (p_mathrm{L}(mathscr {E})leqslant p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). Moreover, (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})=p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) if and only if there is a LOCC unambiguous measurement realizing (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})). Thus, we can show from Theorem 1 and Corollary 1 that our statement is true. (square )
Here, we provide the following example of two-qubit state ensemble (mathscr {E}) to illustrate how our results can be used to obtain (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})), (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})), and (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})).
Let us consider the two-qubit state ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{3}) consisting of three product states with equal prior probabilities,
To obtain (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})), we use the unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{3}) with
and Hermitian operator
where
are the Bell states in two-qubit systems. We will show the unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{3}) and the Hermitian operator K satisfy the conditions of Proposition 1 for the ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{3}) in Eq. (25).
For K of Eq. (27), Condition (7a) is obvious and Condition (7b) is also true due to the orthogonality of Bell states. For Condition (7c), we first note (|Psi _{-}rangle !langle Psi _{-}|) is orthogonal to each (rho _{i}), that is, (mathrm {Tr}(|Psi _{-}rangle !langle Psi _{-}|rho _{i})=0), (i=1,2,3). Moreover, (|Phi _{i}rangle !langle Phi _{i}|) is orthogonal to (rho _{j}) for all (i,j=1,2,3) with (ine j). Thus, we have
for the ensemble (mathscr {E}) of Eq. (25). Now, a straightforward calculation leads us to
and this implies
for all E in (mathrm {Pos}_{i}(mathscr {E})). From the definition of (mathrm {Pos}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (8), we have (K-eta _{i}rho _{i}in mathrm {Pos}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})) for each (i=1,2,3), and this shows the validity of Condition (7c). Finally, Condition (7d) naturally follows from Eqs. (26) and (30). From Proposition 1, the optimal success probability (p_mathrm{G}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (6) is
To obtain (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (14), let us consider the Hermitian operator
and the separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{3}) consisting of
where
We will show the Hermitian operator H and the separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{3}) satisfy the conditions of Theorem 2 for the ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{3}) in Eq. (25).
For H of Eq. (33), Condition (15a) holds due to the argument after Eq. (16) and Condition (18a) is also true from the fact that (|Psi _{-}rangle ) is orthogonal to (|1rangle otimes |1rangle ),(|mu _{+}rangle otimes |mu _{+}rangle ),(|mu _{-}rangle otimes |mu _{-}rangle ). For Condition (15b), we first note every positive-semidefinite product operator orthogonal to (rho _{2}) and (rho _{3}) is proportional to (|mu _{+}rangle !langle mu _{+}|otimes |mu _{-}rangle !langle mu _{-}|) or (|mu _{-}rangle !langle mu _{-}|otimes |mu _{+}rangle !langle mu _{+}|). Moreover, every positive-semidefinite product operator orthogonal to (rho _{1}) and (rho _{3(2)}) is proportional to (|mu _{+(-)}rangle !langle mu _{+(-)}|otimes |1rangle !langle 1|) or (|1rangle !langle 1|otimes |mu _{+(-)}rangle !langle mu _{+(-)}|). Thus, we have
for the ensemble (mathscr {E}) of Eq. (25). Now, a straightforward calculation leads us to
and this implies
for all E in (mathrm {SEP}_{i}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,2,3)). From the definition of (mathrm {SEP}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,2,3)) in Eq. (16), we have (H-eta _{i}rho _{i}in mathrm {SEP}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})) for each (i=1,2,3), and this shows the validity of Condition (15b). Finally, Condition (18b) naturally follows from Eqs. (34) and (37). From Theorem 2, the minimum quantity (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (14) is
We also note that the POVM ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{3}) with Eq. (34) is a LOCC measurement because it can be implemented by performing the same local measurement ({frac{2}{3}|1rangle langle 1|,frac{2}{3}|mu _{+}rangle !langle mu _{+}|,frac{2}{3}|mu _{-}rangle !langle mu _{-}|}) on two subsystems. Thus, Corollary 2 and Eq. (39) lead us to
Now, we provide another example of mixed-state ensemble in multipartite high-dimensional quantum systems to illustrate the application of our results in obtaining (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})), (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})), and (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})).
For any integer (dgeqslant 3), let us consider the following ((d-1))-qudit state ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{d}) consisting of d mixed states with equal prior probabilities,
where (oplus ) denotes modulo-d addition. To obtain (p_mathrm{G}(mathscr {E})), we use the unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{d}) with
and Hermitian operator
We will show the unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{d}) and the Hermitian operator K satisfy the conditions of Proposition 1 for the ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{d}) in Eq. (41).
For K of Eq. (43), Condition (7a) is obvious and Condition (7b) is also true due to the orthogonality of ({|Lambda _{i}rangle ,|Omega _{i}rangle }_{i=1}^{d}). For Condition (7c), we first note both (|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Lambda _{i}|) and (|Omega _{i}rangle !langle Omega _{i}|) are orthogonal to (rho _{j}), that is, (mathrm {Tr}(|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Lambda _{i}|rho _{j})=mathrm {Tr}(|Omega _{i}rangle !langle Omega _{i}|rho _{j})=0), for all (i,j=1,ldots ,d) with (ine j).
Let (O_{1}) be the set of all positive semidefinite operators orthogonal to (rho _{1}). From the definition of (rho _{i}) in Eq. (41), we have
Now, let (O_{j}) be the set of all positive semidefinite operators orthogonal to (rho _{j}) for each (j=2,ldots ,d). Similarly, we have
where
From the definition of (mathrm {Pos}_{i}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (4), we have
for the ensemble (mathscr {E}) of Eq. (41). Moreover, a straightforward calculation leads us to
This implies Eq. (31) for all E in (mathrm {Pos}_{i}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,ldots ,d)). From the definition of (mathrm {Pos}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (8), we have (K-eta _{i}rho _{i}in mathrm {Pos}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})) for each (i=1,ldots ,d), and this shows the validity of Condition (7c). Finally, Condition (7d) naturally follows from Eqs. (42) and (48). Therefore, the optimal success probability (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (6) is
To obtain (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (14), let us consider the Hermitian operator
and the separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{d}) consisting of
where ({|Lambda _{j}rangle }_{j=1}^{d}) is defined in Eq. (41). We will show the Hermitian operator H and the separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{d}) satisfy the conditions of Theorem 2 for the ensemble (mathscr {E}={eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{d}) in Eq. (41).
For H of Eq. (50), Condition (15a) is satisfied from the argument after Eq. (16) and Condition (18a) is also true due to the orthogonality of ({|Lambda _{i}rangle }_{i=1}^{d}). For Condition (15b), we first note that (|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Lambda _{i}|) is obviously separable for all (i=1,ldots ,d). However, (|Omega _{i}rangle !langle Omega _{i}|) is not separable for each (i=1,ldots ,d) because the reduced density operator of (|Omega _{i}rangle !langle Omega _{i}|) onto any qudit subsystem is not rank one.
For each (i=1,ldots ,d), we also note that (|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Lambda _{i}|) is the only pure product state acting on the subspace spanned by (|Lambda _{i}rangle ) and (|Omega _{i}rangle ). To see this, let us consider any pure state ((c_{1}|Lambda _{i}rangle +c_{2}|Omega _{i}rangle )(c_{1}^{*}langle Lambda _{i}|+c_{2}^{*}langle Omega _{i}|)) on the subspace spanned by (|Lambda _{i}rangle ) and (|Omega _{i}rangle ) with complex numbers (c_{1}) and (c_{2}) such that (|c_{1}|^{2}+|c_{2}|^{2}=1). Due to the definitions of (|Lambda _{i}rangle ) and (|Omega _{i}rangle ) in Eq. (41), it is straightforward to show that any partial trace of (|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Omega _{i}|) is the zero operator. Thus, the reduced density operator of ((c_{1}|Lambda _{i}rangle +c_{2}|Omega _{i}rangle )(c_{1}^{*}langle Lambda _{i}|+c_{2}^{*}langle Omega _{i}|)) is
where ({mathbb {S}}) is any (alpha )-qudit subsystem with (alpha <d-1). If (c_{2}) is nonzero, then the reduced density operator in Eq. (52) is not rank one because (|Omega _{i}rangle !langle Omega _{i}|) is not separable, which implies that ((c_{1}|Lambda _{i}rangle +c_{2}|Omega _{i}rangle )(c_{1}^{*}langle Lambda _{i}|+c_{2}^{*}langle Omega _{i}|)) is not separable. Thus, (|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Lambda _{i}|) is the only pure product state acting on the subspace spanned by (|Lambda _{i}rangle ) and (|Omega _{i}rangle ).
Now, let us consider (mathrm {SEP}_{i}(mathscr {E})) of the ensemble (mathscr {E}) in Eq. (41) for each (i=1,ldots ,d). From Eq. (47) and the definition of (mathrm {SEP}_{i}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (10), we have
Because any separable state is a convex combination of pure product states and (|Lambda _{i}rangle !langle Lambda _{i}|) is the only pure product state acting on the subspace spanned by (|Lambda _{i}rangle ) and (|Omega _{i}rangle ), we have
Moreover, a straightforward calculation leads us to
which implies (mathrm {Tr}[(H-eta _{i}rho _{i})E]=0) for all E in (mathrm {SEP}_{i}(mathscr {E})). Thus, we have (H-eta _{i}rho _{i}in mathrm {SEP}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})), and this shows the validity of Condition (15b) for each (i=1,ldots ,d). Finally, Condition (18b) naturally follows from Eqs. (51) and (55).
From Theorem 2, the minimum quantity (q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (14) is
Moreover, the POVM ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{d}) with Eq. (51) is a LOCC measurement since it can be implemented by performing the same local measurement ({|irangle !langle i|}_{i=0}^{d-1}) on all subsystems. Thus, Corollary 2 and Eq. (56) lead us to
Examples 1 and 2 are special cases that (p_mathrm{L}(mathscr {E})=p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})), or equivalently (p_mathrm{L}(mathscr {E})=q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). We also note that there exist separable-state ensembles with (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})<q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})), therefore (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})<p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})). A well-known example with (p_mathrm{L}(mathscr {E})<p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) is the domino state ensemble which can be perfectly discriminated by separable measurements but not by LOCC measurements8.
In this paper, we have considered the situation of unambiguously discriminating multipartite quantum states, and provided an upper bound (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) for the maximum success probability of optimal local discrimination (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})). We have further established a necessary and sufficient condition for the Hermitian operator H to realize (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). Moreover, we have provided a necessary and sufficient condition for the upper bound (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) to be saturated. Finally, we have illustrated our results by examples in multidimensional multipartite quantum systems.
We remark that finding (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})) and (q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) in unambiguously discriminating separable quantum states can be useful in studying the phenomenon of nonlocality without entanglement(NLWE)8. For the optimal UD of a separable-state ensemble ({eta _{i},rho _{i}}_{i=1}^{n}), the NLWE phenomenon occurs when (p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})) cannot be realized only by LOCC, that is, (p_{mathrm{L}}(mathscr {E})<p_mathrm{G}(mathscr {E})). Due to Corollary 2, (q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})<p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})) means (p_mathrm{L}(mathscr {E})<p_{mathrm{G}}(mathscr {E})), therefore the occurrence of NLWE. It is a natural future work to find good bounds on optimal local discrimination in other generalized state discrimination strategies such as an optimal discrimination with a fixed rate of inconclusive results26,27,28,29,30.
In this section, we prove Theorem 1 by showing that
Let us assume that ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) is a separable unambiguous measurement realizing (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) and H is a Hermitian operator giving (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})). Since this assumption implies Conditions (11) and (15), we have
which lead us to
where the second equality is due to (sum _{i=0}^{n}M_{i}=mathbbm {1}). Therefore, Inequality (58a) holds.
We first prove Inequality (58b) when (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})=0). In this case, we claim that every (Min mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) satisfies (mathrm {Tr}(rho _{j}M)=0) for each (j=1,ldots ,n). To see this, suppose that there is a positive-semidefinite product operator (Ein mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) with (mathrm {Tr}(rho _{j}E)>0). Since (mathbbm {1}-E/mathrm {Tr}E) is obvious separable, the following POVM ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) is a separable unambiguous measurement:
where (0_{{mathscr {H}}}) is the zero operator on ({mathscr {H}}).
Moreover, the measurement of (61) gives
From Inequality (62) and the definition of (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})), we have (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})>0), a contradiction. Therefore, there is no positive-semidefinite product operator (Ein mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) with (mathrm {Tr}(rho _{j}E)>0). Since every positive-semidefinite separable operator can be represented as a summation of positive-semidefinite product operators, we have
for all (Min mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})). Equation (63) together with the definition of (mathrm {SEP}_{j}^{*}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (16) imply that
for any real number a and (j in left{ 1,ldots ,nright} ).
By letting (H =0_{{mathscr {H}}}), we trivially have
For each (i=1,ldots ,n), we also have
where the inclusion is from Eq. (64). Equations (65) and (66) imply that (H=0_{{mathscr {H}}}) satisfies Condition (15), therefore
where the inequality is due to the definition of (q_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})). Thus, Inequality (67) and the assumption (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})=0) lead us to Inequality (58b).
Now, we prove Inequality (58b) when (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})>0).
If (Ein mathrm {SEP}^{*}) and (Ene 0_{{mathscr {H}}}), then (mathrm {Tr}E>0), where (0_{{mathscr {H}}}) is the zero operator on ({mathscr {H}}).
The proof is by contradiction. We first note that (mathrm {Tr}E=mathrm {Tr}(mathbbm {1}E)geqslant 0) because (Ein mathrm {SEP}^{*}) and the identity operator (mathbbm {1}) is obviously separable. Thus, let us suppose (mathrm {Tr}E=0).
For an arbitrary orthonormal product basis ({|e_{i}rangle }_{i=1}^{D}) of the multipartite Hilbert space ({mathscr {H}}=bigotimes _{k=1}^{m}{mathscr {H}}_{k}), we have
where D is the dimension of ({mathscr {H}}). From (Ein mathrm {SEP}^{*}) and (|e_{i}rangle !langle e_{i}|in mathrm {SEP}) for all (i=1,ldots ,D), we have
Equation (68) and Inequality (69) lead us to (mathrm {Tr}(E|e_{i}rangle !langle e_{i}|)=0) for all (i=1,ldots ,D). Since the choice of ({|e_{i}rangle }_{i=1}^{D}) can be arbitrary, (mathrm {Tr}(E|erangle !langle e|)=0) for any product vector (|erangle in {mathscr {H}}), therefore
We note that (mathrm {SEP}) spans the set of all Hermitian operators on ({mathscr {H}}). To see this, we first note that the set of all positive-semidefinite operators on ({mathscr {H}}_{k}) spans the set of all Hermitian operators on ({mathscr {H}}_{k}) for each (k=1,ldots ,m). Moreover, every Hermitian operator A on ({mathscr {H}}) can be represented as a summation of product Hermitian operators,
where (A_{l,k}) is a Hermitian operator on ({mathscr {H}}_{k}) for each (k=1,ldots ,m). Therefore, Eq. (70) leads us to (mathrm {Tr}(EF)=0) for any Hermitian operator F on ({mathscr {H}}). This means (E=0_{{mathscr {H}}}), a contradiction. Thus, (mathrm {Tr}E>0). (square )
Let us consider the set,
where ({mathbb {R}}) is the set of all real numbers and ({mathbb {H}}) is the set of all Hermitian operators on the multipartite Hilbert space ({mathscr {H}}). We note that (S(mathscr {E})) is a convex set due to the convexity of (mathrm {SEP}) and (mathrm {SEP}_{i}(mathscr {E}))((i=1,ldots ,n)) in Eqs. (2) and (10). Moreover, (S(mathscr {E})) does not have the origin ((0,0_{{mathscr {H}}})) of ({mathbb {R}}times {mathbb {H}}) otherwise there exists a separable unambiguous measurement ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) with (sum _{i=1}^{n}eta _{i}mathrm {Tr}(rho _{i}M_{i})>p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})), and this contradicts the optimality of (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (12). We also note that the Cartesian product ({mathbb {R}}times {mathbb {H}}) can be considered as a real vector space with an inner product defined as
Since (S(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (72) and the single-element set ({(0,0_{{mathscr {H}}})}) are disjoint convex sets, it follows from separating hyperplane theorem31,32 that there is ((gamma ,Gamma )in {mathbb {R}}times {mathbb {H}}) such that
Suppose
where (mathrm {SEP}^{*}) and (mathrm {SEP}_{i}^{*}(mathscr {E})) are defined in Eq. (16). From Conditions (75b), (75c), and (75d), the Hermitian operator (H=Gamma /gamma ) satisfies Condition (15). Thus, the definition of (q_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) in Eq. (14) leads us to
Moreover, Condition (75a) and the definition of (H=Gamma /gamma ) imply
Inequalities (76) and (77) complete the proof of Inequality (58b).
The rest of this section is to prove Conditions (75a), (75b), (75c), and (75d).
From Eq. (73), Inequality (74b) can be rewritten as,
for all (p>p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) and all ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) satisfying Condition (11). If (M_{i}=0_{{mathscr {H}}}) for all (i=0,1,ldots ,n), Inequality (78) becomes Inequality (75a) by taking the limit of p to (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})). (square )
For an arbitrary (M_{0}in mathrm {SEP}) and (M_{i}=0) for all (i=1,ldots ,n), ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) clearly satisfies Condition (11). In this case, Inequality (78) becomes
by taking the limit of p to (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})).
Suppose (Gamma notin mathrm {SEP}^{*}), then there exists (Min mathrm {SEP}) with (mathrm {Tr}(MGamma )<0). We note that (Min mathrm {SEP}) implies (tMin mathrm {SEP}) for any (t>0). Thus, ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) with (M_{0}=tM) for (t>0) and (M_{i}=0) for all (i=1,ldots ,n) also satisfies Condition (11). Now, Inequality (79) can be rewritten as,
Since Inequality (80) is true for arbitrary large (t>0), (gamma p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) can also be arbitrary large. However, this contradicts that both (gamma ) and (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) are finite. Thus, (Gamma in mathrm {SEP}^{*}), which completes the proof of (75b). (square )
The proof method is analogous to that of (75b). For each (jin {1,ldots ,n}), let us consider an arbitrary (M_{j}in mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) and (M_{i}=0) for all (i=0,1,ldots ,n) with (ine j). In this case, ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) clearly satisfies Condition (11) and Inequality (78) becomes
by taking the limit of p to (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})).
Suppose (Gamma -gamma eta _{j}rho _{j}notin mathrm {SEP}_{j}^{*}(mathscr {E})), then there exists (Min mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) with (mathrm {Tr}[M(Gamma -gamma eta _{j}rho _{j})]<0). We note that (Min mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) implies (tMin mathrm {SEP}_{j}(mathscr {E})) for any (t>0). Thus, ({M_{i}}_{i=0}^{n}) consisting of (M_{j}=tM) for (t>0) and (M_{i}=0) for all (i=0,1,ldots ,n) with (ine j) also satisfies Condition (11). Now, Inequality (81) can be rewritten as,
Since Inequality (82) is true for arbitrary large (t>0), (gamma p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})) can also be arbitrary large. However, this contradicts that both (gamma ) and (p_mathrm{SEP}(mathscr {E})) are finite. Thus, (Gamma -gamma eta _{j}rho _{j}in mathrm {SEP}_{j}^{*}(mathscr {E})), which completes the proof of (75c). (square )
Suppose (Gamma ne 0_{{mathscr {H}}}). From Lemma 1 together with Inequality (75b), we have (mathrm {Tr}Gamma >0). Thus, Inequality (75a) and the fact that (mathrm {Tr}Gamma >0) guarantee (gamma >0).
Now, suppose (Gamma =0_{{mathscr {H}}}). We have (gamma ne 0), otherwise a contradiction to Condition (74a). The strict positivity of (gamma ) follows from Inequality (75a) with (mathrm {Tr}Gamma =0) and (p_{mathrm{SEP}}(mathscr {E})>0). Thus, Inequality (75d) holds regardless of (Gamma ). (square )
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article.
Chitambar, E., Leung, D., Mančinska, L., Ozols, M. & Winter, A. Everything you always wanted to know about LOCC (but were afraid to ask). Commun. Math. Phys. 328, 303 (2014).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Horodecki, R., Horodecki, P., Horodecki, M. & Horodecki, K. Quantum entanglement. Rev. Mod. Phys. 81, 865 (2009).
ADS MathSciNet CAS MATH Google Scholar
Chitambar, E. & Gour, G. Quantum resource theories. Rev. Mod. Phys. 91, 025001 (2019).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Chefles, A. Quantum state discrimination. Contemp. Phys. 41, 401 (2000).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Barnett, S. M. & Croke, S. Quantum state discrimination. Adv. Opt. Photon. 1, 238 (2009).
CAS Article Google Scholar
Bergou, J. A. Discrimination of quantum states. J. Mod. Opt. 57, 160 (2010).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Bae, J. & Kwek, L.-C. Quantum state discrimination and its applications. J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 48, 083001 (2015).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Bennett, C. H. et al. Quantum nonlocality without entanglement. Phys. Rev. A 59, 1070 (1999).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Peres, A. & Wootters, W. K. Optimal detection of quantum information. Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 1119 (1991).
ADS CAS Article Google Scholar
Duan, R., Feng, Y., Ji, Z. & Ying, M. Distinguishing arbitrary multipartite basis unambiguously using local operations and classical communication. Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 230502 (2007).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Chitambar, E. & Hsieh, M.-H. Revisiting the optimal detection of quantum information. Phys. Rev. A 88, 020302(R) (2013).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Ghosh, S., Kar, G., Roy, A., Sen, A. & Sen, U. Distinguishability of bell states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 277902 (2001).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Walgate, J. & Hardy, L. Nonlocality, asymmetry, and distinguishing bipartite states. Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 147901 (2002).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Fan, H. Distinguishability and indistinguishability by local operations and classical communication. Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 177905 (2004).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Duan, R., Feng, Y., Xin, Y. & Ying, M. Distinguishability of quantum states by separable operations. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 55, 1320 (2009).
MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Chitambar, E., Duan, R. & Hsieh, M.-H. When do local operations and classical communication suffice for two-qubit state discrimination?. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 60, 1549 (2014).
MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Bandyopadhyay, S. et al. Limitations on separable measurements by convex optimization. IEEE Trans. Inf. Theory 61, 3593 (2015).
MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Bandyopadhyay, S. & Russo, V. Entanglement cost of discriminating noisy bell states by local operations and classical communication. Phys. Rev. A 104, 032429 (2021).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Zhang, J.-H., Zhang, F.-L., Wang, Z.-X., Lai, L.-M. & Fei, S.-M. Discriminating bipartite mixed states by local operations. Phys. Rev. A 101, 032316 (2020).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Ha, D. & Kim, J. S. Bound on local minimum-error discrimination of bipartite quantum states. Phys. Rev. A 105, 032421 (2022).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Ivanovic, I. D. How to differentiate between non-orthogonal states. Phys. Lett. A 123, 257 (1987).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Peres, A. How to differentiate between non-orthogonal states. Phys. Lett. A 128, 19 (1988).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Dieks, D. Overlap and distinguishability of quantum states. Phys. Lett. A 126, 303 (1988).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Zhang, J.-H., Zhang, F.-L., Wang, Z.-X., Yang, H. & Fei, S.-M. Unambiguous state discrimination with intrinsic coherence. Entropy 24, 18 (2022).
ADS MathSciNet Article Google Scholar
Eldar, Y. C., Stojnic, M. & Hassibi, B. Optimal quantum detectors for unambiguous detection of mixed states. Phys. Rev. A 69, 062318 (2004).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Chefles, A. & Barnett, S. M. Strategies for discriminating between non-orthogonal quantum states. J. Mod. Opt. 45, 1295–1302 (1998).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Zhang, C.-W., Li, C.-F. & Guo, G.-C. General strategies for discrimination of quantum states. Phys. Lett. A 261, 25–29 (1999).
ADS MathSciNet CAS Article Google Scholar
Fiurášek, J. & Ježek, M. Optimal discrimination of mixed quantum states involving inconclusive results. Phys. Rev. A 67, 012321 (2003).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Bagan, E., Muñoz-Tapia, R., Olivares-Rentería, G. A. & Bergou, J. A. Optimal discrimination of quantum states with a fixed rate of inconclusive outcomes. Phys. Rev. A 86, 040303 (2012).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Herzog, U. Optimal measurements for the discrimination of quantum states with a fixed rate of inconclusive results. Phys. Rev. A 91, 042338 (2015).
ADS Article Google Scholar
Boyd, S. & Vandenberghe, L. Convex optimization (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2004).
Book Google Scholar
When (A) and (B) are disjoint convex sets in a real vector space (V) with an inner product (langle cdot ,cdot rangle ), there exist (xin {mathbb{R}}) and (vec{v}in V) such that (vec{v}ne vec{0}) and (langle vec{a},vec{v}rangle leqslant xleqslant langle vec{b},vec{v}rangle ) for all (vec{a}in A) and all (vec{b}in B).
Download references
This work was supported by Basic Science Research Program(NRF-2020R1F1A1A010501270) and Quantum Computing Technology Development Program(NRF-2020M3E4A1080088) through the National Research Foundation of Korea(NRF) grant funded by the Korea government(Ministry of Science and ICT).
Department of Applied Mathematics and Institute of Natural Sciences, Kyung Hee University, Yongin, 17104, Republic of Korea
Donghoon Ha & Jeong San Kim
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
D.H. and J.S.K. contributed to design the ideas, perform the calculations, analyze the results and write the manuscript.
Correspondence to Jeong San Kim.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Ha, D., Kim, J.S. Bound on optimal local discrimination of multipartite quantum states. Sci Rep 12, 14130 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-18496-y
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-18496-y
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
Advanced search
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.
Cooler Master GM27-FQS Review: Accurate Color and High Performance – Tom's Hardware
Tom’s Hardware is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s why you can trust us.
By published
The Cooler Master GM27-FQS delivers excellent image quality and gaming performance at a reasonable price. It supports HDR though the picture doesn’t look much different than its SDR counterpart. With unique styling and a solid build, it’s a good match for mid-priced gaming systems.
Accurate color with little adjustment needed
Excellent video processing
Unique lighting feature and styling
Good value
No extra contrast in HDR mode
The QHD 165 Hz category is filled with capable gaming monitors that deliver a lot of performance for the money. They represent the sweet spot of value and performance with snappy response, smooth motion and high frame rates. And with fewer pixels to move around than an Ultra HD screen, they don’t require a high-end video card to drive them to their full potential.
Cooler Master is a bit off the beaten path when it comes to display brands, but their monitors have proven capable with solid build quality, color accuracy and high performance. I’ll be looking at its latest 27-inch QHD screen – the GM27-FQS. It runs at 165 Hz with Adaptive-Sync, HDR10 and extended color. It also offers selectable color gamuts (a rarity) and a slick lighting feature that stands out from the competition among the best gaming monitors.
The GM27-FQS starts with a quick IPS panel capable of a 1ms MPRT response time. Adaptive-Sync works on both FreeSync and G-Sync platforms over a 48-165 Hz range. This monitor has not been certified by Nvidia, but I saw no issues during testing with either Radeon or GeForce video cards. It also includes a backlight strobe option for blur reduction that works instead of Adaptive-Sync.
Image quality is assured by a wide color gamut that covers just under 92% of DCI-P3, according to my measurements. That puts it slightly above average for the category and adds to the value factor. Color is very accurate as well. I discovered that calibration is completely unnecessary. Even when I tried a few tweaks, I could not make the picture any better. I also found selectable color gamuts for all the major standards from sRGB to Rec.2020. Their performance varies a bit; I’ll show you more about that on page four.
The GM27-FQS has unique styling elements starting with a panel with an upper portion that is just seven millimeters thick. There’s a component bulge at the bottom, but this particular aesthetic more often seen in OLED displays.
The LED lighting feature is something I haven’t seen before. Cooler Master calls it the Halo Stand, and it indeed looks like a halo. A soft glow of multiple colors emanates from the base which is shaped like the Cooler Master logo. Its effects can be controlled with a desktop app.
The GM27-FQS looks to be a very capable gaming monitor equally adept at work or play. At $410 at this writing, it looks like a good value as well. Let’s take a look.
The GM27-FQS comes well-protected in a carton filled with crumbly foam. The base attaches to the upright with a captive bolt. Find the four fasteners and the included Phillips-head screwdriver to mate the panel to the stand. Once complete, the package is fairly light in weight but rock solid. Bundled accessories include an external power supply, USB-C lighting cable for the base, DisplayPort and HDMI.
The GM27-FQS is all about appearing thin. The upper portion of the panel is very slim, just 7 mm thick. The bezel is also 7 mm wide and flush around the top and sides. The bottom trim is a little wider at 13 mm, but it too is barely there. Only a minuscule Cooler Master logo is molded into it. The screen’s anti-glare layer is similar to what’s found on nearly every computer monitor and provides a sharp and grain-free image with no glare.
The Halo LED comes from the base, where you’ll see an opaque diffusion cover that emits a rainbow of colors. There aren’t any controls for it in the OSD, but if you download the MasterPlus app from Cooler Master, you can alter the light show. A USB-C cable is required to power it, which comes in the box. It can be connected to the panel’s USB output or to a wall wart if you have one available. Running the cable between the panel and the base is a bit clunky, so I connected it to a spare charging brick I had lying around.
The side view shows how thin the upper part of the GM27-FQS is. This styling is more commonly seen in OLED panels, though I’ve seen a few other LCDs like this. Not only does it look cool, but it puts the stand mounting point lower on the panel, so it sits higher. With the stand at full extension, the center of the screen is at eye level, so I can keep the monitor perfectly vertical. The height adjustment range is 110mm or around 4.4 inches. You also get 5/20 degrees tilt, 15 degrees swivel and a 90-degree portrait mode. Movements are smooth and firm with no play.
The input panel is up and under but fairly easy to access. Two HDMI 2.0, one DisplayPort 1.2 and one USB-C port make up the video connections. You also get a 3.5 mm headphone jack. There are no built-in speakers. USB is version 3.0, and there are two downstream ports and one upstream.
The GM27-FQS’ OSD is controlled by five buttons around the back right. The lowest key is a power toggle. The buttons click with a quality feel, though I missed having a joystick. I’ve been spoiled for sure.
The OSD packs a lot into just a few sub-menus. There are eight task-specific picture modes, including one for users needing compensation for color blindness. Each mode has different options like a black stabilizer to control the black level, dynamic contrast and a blue light filter. Standard is the best mode because it opens up all the image controls.
Color Adjust has many things not commonly seen outside the professional genre. In addition to color temp and gamma presets, you can select the color gamut. I tested all the presets and found sRGB and DCI-P3 to follow their standards closely, but Adobe RGB and BT.2020 were off the mark. The GM27-FQS is accurate when compared to DCI-P3, but the gamut does not get larger than that.
The gaming options are found in the Setup Menu. A four-level overdrive is included, but settings above Normal cause too much ghosting around moving objects. Motion Clearness is an effective backlight strobe with three levels. You have to turn off Adaptive-Sync, but the strobe does increase motion resolution. The highest level is the smoothest and cuts light output by around 30%.
In the GM27-FQS’ Standard mode, you can go with factory default settings and see good color accuracy with a slightly warm white point. The easiest fix is to select the DCI-P3 color gamut in the Color Space sub-menu. No further calibration is required, and in fact, adjusting the User color temp won’t make any visible improvement. This is a very accurate monitor. I noted that selecting any Color Space options besides Auto locked out the color temp presets. I’ll show you charts from all the different modes on page four. If you want the lowest possible error values, try my settings below.
In HDR mode, you can calibrate grayscale and adjust brightness and contrast if you wish. This is something very few HDR monitors allow. That mode is also pretty accurate and doesn’t require any adjustment for a good image.
Cooler Master bills the GM27-FQS as a versatile monitor and in that category, it delivers. With 109ppi pixel density, it’s well suited to just about any work task, whether text or graphics-based. It has a bright and colorful image that’s not over-saturated or harsh in any way. The anti-glare layer is tightly fit, which makes the picture very sharp and detailed. Contrast is about average for an IPS panel, but I had no complaints when working in Photoshop, browsing the web or watching video content. There are no built-in speakers, so I had to plug in a pair of headphones to watch YouTube.
HDR has little impact on the Windows desktop and doesn’t add much more to gaming. Color is a bit more saturated which is a good thing, but there is no more contrast than SDR. Blacks are slightly deeper, but some shadow detail is hard to see as a result. The GM27-FQS purposely rides a little dark in its HDR shadow and mid-tone areas to increase perceived contrast. Of the three HDR modes, Movie looked the best. I could increase dark detail by using the Standard mode’s Lightness slider, but this made the image look flat.
Continuing my quest through the blood-soaked worlds of Doom Eternal, I enjoyed the super-saturated red hues that were a bit bolder in their HDR versions. I had to tweak the game’s HDR settings to bring shadow detail out more. This reduced contrast a little, but the alternative is to be more often surprised by enemies lurking in dark spaces.
Video processing is nicely implemented here. The GM27-FQS is one of the quicker 165 Hz screens I’ve tested, and it showed in a higher frag count when I played Doom Eternal’s horde mode. This monitor category is still the king of the price/performance ratio with near-competition level response for a reasonable cost. I could play with equal precision on both FreeSync and G-Sync PCs with frame rates at or near the maximum of 165 fps.
Cooler Master includes a backlight strobe for blur reduction as an alternative to Adaptive-Sync. It is effective at its intended task and doesn’t cut light output too much. I only needed the Low setting to achieve smoother motion with almost no cost in brightness. I saw a few frame tears with AS turned off, but the strobe is a viable and useful feature for those who prefer it. The overdrive is also effective on its lowest setting of the four available. Higher options caused visible ghosting which reduced motion resolution. The GM27-FQS is indeed a versatile monitor that serves well for work, gaming or entertainment.
Current page: Features and Specifications
Christian Eberle is a Contributing Editor for Tom’s Hardware US. He’s a veteran reviewer of A/V equipment, specializing in monitors.
Get instant access to breaking news, in-depth reviews and helpful tips.
Thank you for signing up to Tom’s Hardware. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.
Tom’s Hardware is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab).
© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.
Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro vs. Google Pixel Buds Pro: Which wireless earbuds win? – Tom's Guide
Tom’s Guide is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s why you can trust us.
By published
The Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro go head-to-head with the Google Pixel Buds Pro — which are the winning Android companion?
A Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 vs. Google Pixel Buds Pro comparison is essential if you’re searching for the best noise-cancelling earbuds to pair with your Android device.
The Galaxy Buds 2 Pro replaces the Tom’s Guide award-winning Galaxy Buds Pro and welcomes several upgrades in term of design, sound, and wireless performance. On the other end, you have the Google Pixel Buds Pro, an excellent representation of Google’s true wireless lineup and an easy match for Pixel smartphone owners.
Both models share many of the same features, including active noise cancellation (ANC), customizable sound settings, voice activation, and wireless charging, just to name a few. They also come with their own set of exclusive perks. As for the better investment – let’s find out.
The Galaxy Buds Pro 2 are set to go on sale on August 26 at $229 and can be pre-ordered via the Samsung store (opens in new tab). Samsung is offering an exclusive $75 credit when you trade-in any Galaxy Buds (opens in new tab) in any condition, along with $30 Samsung credit and a free Wireless Charger with your purchase. You’ll want to take advantage of this deal since a price drop isn’t likely to be available until the holidays at the earliest.
Meanwhile, Google launched the Pixel Buds Pro at $199. There are no special deals right now. These buds do not come with a USB-C charging cable either.
Based on features and supplied charging solutions, the advantage in value goes to the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro.
Make sure to bookmark our best headphones deals page to know about the latest wireless earbuds sales.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro
Build quality is sturdy between the two models, composed entirely of durable plastic and furnished with a nice soft-rubberized finish on the front. The Galaxy Buds 2 Pro have a higher than most waterproofing certification rated at IPX7 (which means they can submerged to a depth of 1 meter for up to 30 minutes). The Pixel Buds Pro offer sweat and water resistance for the buds to IPX4 to protect against water splashes, while the charging case is rated at IPX2. Speaking of which, Samsung and Google’s cases are two of the most attractive in the category: compact, chic, and carry friendly.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro
Winner: Google Pixel Buds Pro
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro
However, there are other features outside of the Galaxy Wearable app. You have one-tap Easy Pair (Galaxy devices only) and Auto Switch to automatically jump from one device to another. Bluetooth 5.3 provides lengthy wireless range and comes with LE Audio support, which Samsung claims will arrive “later this year.” Samsung TV connectivity (2022 models) comes part of the package as well.
The Galaxy Buds 2 Pro might not have launched with multipoint technology, but Samsung could always look to add it in a future update.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro
The Pixel Buds Pro are a serviceable calling headset, but they have a more muffled sound than the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro. Not to mention the volume level during calls is very low.
Winner: Samsung Galaxy Buds 2 Pro
A full charge from Google’s buds equates to 7 to 11 hours, with the charging case holding between 20 to 31 hours. That’s better than average. As for the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro, they disappoint with 5 to 8 hours per charge. Samsung’s charging case holds between 18 to 29 hours, depending how you use the buds.
Both models support quick and wireless charging, but the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro has reverse wireless charging and comes with a USB-C charging cable.
Winner: Tie
We’ve got the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro winning by a fair margin. Those who own a Galaxy smartphone will receive the full Samsung treatment (e.g., 360 Audio, PowerShare, Scalable Codec), while other Android users can still enjoy premium sound and noise cancellation. Not everything is a hit (Bixby voice activation and battery life in particular could do with improving), but the Galaxy Buds 2 Pro are the winning option and offer the greater value overall.
That doesn’t mean to completely dismiss the Pixel Buds Pro as a potential Android companion. Google has designed their best wireless earbuds to date, combining robust ANC with striking sound and Google smarts. Improvements in battery life and touch controls are also greatly appreciated. If only the Pixel Buds Pro came with more features and a secure fit.
Next: Check out the best noise-cancelling earbuds to find out where each ranks compared to the rest of the models we’ve reviewed.
A lifestyle journalist with an affinity for consumer products, Alex has over a decade of experience and has worked with popular publications such as Complex, Thrillist, Men’s Health, Gear Patrol, AskMen, and Hoop Magazine. He currently focuses on audio, reviewing the most coveted headphones in the market for both Tom’s Guide and Laptop Magazine.
Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
Thank you for signing up to Tom’s Guide. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.
Tom’s Guide is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab).
© Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.
Federal Records – Jamaica Observer
The Jamaica Observer’s Entertainment Desk continues with the 45th of its biweekly feature looking at seminal moments that have helped shape Jamaica over the past 60 years.
The music produced in Jamaica during the 1970s is oftentimes regarded as reggae’s golden age. That decade is synonymous with Rasta and militant songs by Bob Marley, Peter Tosh, and Burning Spear.
At Federal Records, however, artistes and musicians had a different focus. For most of the 1970s, singer/songwriters like Ernie Smith, Ken Lazarus, and Pluto Shervington recorded a number of easy-listening hit songs for the company, which was owned by the Khouri family.
Federal Records was also the hub for famous acts like Paul Simon and The Rolling Stones who, respectively, recorded their hit song Mother and Child Reunion and album Goat Head Soup, there.
Robbie Lyn was pianist for the Now Generation, house band at Federal Records. His colleagues included the Chung brothers, Mikey and Geoffrey, who played guitars; bass player Val Douglas; keyboardist Earl “Wire” Lindo; and drummer Mikey “Boo” Richards.
Lyn went to Federal when there was a change in the family guard.
“Richard would be mostly in charge, taking over from his Dad [and founder] Ken. Paul [younger brother] dealt mostly with the actual music production assisted by seldom-mentioned Jerome Francique, a Trinidadian trombone player who was noted for being in the band Tomorrow’s Children. The musicians for the recording sessions were collectively known as Now Gen, which had a house band arrangement with Federal and we worked, I think, three days per week for a period of time which I don’t really remember,” Lyn recalled.
Some of the hits Now Generation played on were Pitta Patta, Life is Just For Living, and Duppy Gunman (Ernie Smith), Ram Goat Liver and Your Honour (Pluto Shervington), Hail The Man (Ken Lazarus), and Play the Music by Tinga Stewart, which won the 1974 Festival Song Competition.
Ken Khouri’s business savvy in the 1950s paved the way for Federal’s remarkable success a decade later and in the 1970s. Born in St Mary to a Jamaican mother and Lebanese father, he got into the music business during the late 1940s, recording calypsonians such as Lord Flea, then officially started Federal Records in September 1954.
The Federal studio became the go-to facility for producers, including Leslie Kong, Prince Buster, and Clement Dodd. It is where Marley recorded Judge Not, his first song, in 1962. Three years later, singer Hopeton Lewis cut Take It Easy, reputedly the first rock steady song, at Federal.
Federal hit a purple patch in the late 1960s when American singer Johnny Nash recorded his massive hit single Hold Me Tight for the company and Bob Andy’s cover of Joe South’s Games People Play was another sizable seller.
In 1974 Federal Records had another monster hit with Ken Boothe’s reggae version of Everything I Own, originally done by American soft rock group Bread.
Despite all these achievements, Paul Khouri says his father and Federal Records never got the respect they deserved from Jamaicans.
“People have this notion that Bob Marley started reggae – we created rock steady and formulated reggae,” he said in a 2002 interview with the Observer.
Ken Khouri never received a national honour from the Jamaican Government. In August 2003, one month before his death at age 86, he was honoured at the Tributes To The Greats ceremony in Kingston; one month later, the Institute of Jamaica named him and Island Records founder Chris Blackwell among 12 recipients of its Musgrave Medal.
The Khouris sold Federal Records to Marley’s family in 1981. The compound is headquarters for Tuff Gong International.
As for the Now Generation Band, Lyn and Val Douglas are the only survivors. Like Smith, Shervington, and Lazarus they are still musically active.
Now you can read the Jamaica Observer ePaper anytime, anywhere. The Jamaica Observer ePaper is available to you at home or at work, and is the same edition as the printed copy available at
HOUSE RULES
Should You Use Audio Cables as Tone Controls? – Audioholics
Cables as Tone Controls
In this article we discuss if cables should be used as tone controls to alter the sound of your system or if they should be transparent and accurately transfer the signal without alteration.
The cable debate has to be one of the most contentious in the world of audio. Do cables make a difference, and if so, how much of a difference? Are expensive cables worth the money? Are they even better at all? Among audiophiles, attitudes about cables are all over the map. Heck, even among cable manufacturers, there’s no consensus. Some purveyors of pricey, exotic cables claim that swapping out your old cables will transform your whole system. And they make these claims without providing any explanation as to how their products work, or what makes them sound better than another option. Other cable manufacturers, like Audioquest, do offer some insight into the thinking behind their designs, but doing so just opens the floor for criticism and questioning from skeptics with the technical background and engineering knowledge necessary to challenge their approach to cable design.
Then you have companies, like Blue Jeans Cable, claiming that a simple and affordable (but properly engineered) cable is plenty good enough, and that the expensive stuff won’t actually sound any better. Some members of the audiophile public are open-minded (open-eared?) folks who only care about their own listening experience, and aren’t worried about measurements or technical details. They might say, “If it sounds good to me, what else matters? I don’t need to understand exactly how my new dishwasher works — I can tell that the dishes are cleaner!” On the other hand, there are listeners with a more technical attitude and a healthy skepticism of products that they view as snake oil. These are people who need to know how and why things work. They see audio engineering as more of a science than an art. They might say, “Of course measurements are important; these are devices designed to carry, manipulate, and reproduce an electrical signal. Someone has to design and build these things — they don’t just materialize from fairy dust. If two cables behave the same electrically, they must sound the same! If you hear differences between them, it’s all in your head.”
“Only poorly designed cables are sonically distinguishable”
— Gene DellaSala, Audioholics
Why Do Audiophiles Fall for Placebo Effect – YouTube Discussion
And this brings us to a YouTube video recently published by Chief Audioholic Gene DellaSala, discussing the placebo effect as it pertains to audio. Gene explains that the expectation of a change or improvement in sound quality can cause listeners to believe that such a change has occurred, even when no meaningful change has been made. We know that the human mind is powerful enough to convince participants in pharmaceutical trials that a simple sugar pill has reduced their pain, cured their nausea, or altered their mood. It’s NOT hard to imagine that the same concept is at work when an audiophile swaps out an old, inexpensive cable for a shiny new one with thick conductors, silver-plated connectors, and a beautifully-woven jacket. (In 2020, Audioholics reviewer James Larson wrote a thorough and well-researched article discussing the ways in which a listener’s expectations and general state of mind affect the perception of what is heard.) Gene’s video sparked a lively discussion in the comments about the potential use of cables as tone controls. That is, if you believe that various cables sound a little different from each other, is it worthwhile to try lots of different ones to tweak the sound of your system so it’s more to your liking? It sounds reasonable enough, and to some it might even sound like fun. There’s nothing wrong with that — even Gene says he’s all for experimenting. After all, you’re not hurting anyone. But Gene will also be quick to tell you that it’s not going to be the most effective, nor the most cost-effective, way to get the best sound from your system. Personally, I am not as much of a cable skeptic as Gene is, and I believe that I have heard real differences among cables. (And I appreciate the fact that, here at Audioholics, you can admit to this sort of thing without being burned at the stake.) But Gene and I are in complete agreement that there are other ways to tweak or improve the sound of your system that will have much more significant results — both measurable and audible — than buying new cables.
Cables as Tone Controls? – YouTube Discussion
“Anybody is welcome to experiment and see what they like. Even if there is no electrical difference or acoustical difference, even if the placebo (effect) is factoring in… do what you like. Do what makes you happy… (but) it takes a really bad cable to make a measurable difference. Room acoustics and EQ are far more effective tools at optimizing sound than using poorly-designed cables as tone controls.”
— Gene DellaSala
One of the most effective ways to improve the sound of an audio system is to pay attention to the acoustics of the room. To be fair, it’s not an easy task to achieve an acoustically ideal environment without an awful lot of expertise and free rein to apply whatever kind of room treatments are needed — even if they make your living room look like a recording studio. But throughout Gene’s career in the audio industry, providing both professional consultations and friendly advice, he’s seen his fair share of high-quality audio gear shoved unceremoniously into rooms with vast, uncovered windows and hard tile floors with no rugs. Without some absorption, there’s simply no way to achieve good sound. Even the careful application of curtains and area rugs can start to change things for the better. On the other hand, Gene has also seen countless over-treated home theaters with so much absorption that the sound is stiff and lifeless. (This is one of the most common reasons why some people can’t get satisfying two-channel audio performance from a home theater.) Although the subject is complicated, there’s no doubt that room acoustics play a much bigger role in your system’s sound than cables ever could. To get started on your room acoustics journey, check out our many articles on the subject, such as Room Reflections & Human Adaptation for Small Room Acoustics by Dr. Floyd Toole, or this video discussion with Anthony Grimani about Room Acoustics and General Placement Guidelines.
Room Acoustics Summary & Placement Guidelines – YouTube Discussion
More than 50% of the sound quality you perceive comes from the acoustical character of the room. How come? More than 50% of what enters your ears is from sound waves that have bounced around the room surfaces after leaving your speakers! It stands to reason, then, that you should pay some serious attention to those room surfaces. Acoustics may seem like a complicated and confusing art form, but by following some simple rules, you can in fact get great results. Apply absorption to about 15% of your wall and ceiling surface area. The absorption material should be at least 2-inch-thick (5 cm) dense fibrous material and should be spread out evenly throughout the room. Apply scattering surfaces (diffusion) to another 15-20% of your wall and ceiling area. Diffusion should be at least 2 inches (preferably 4-6 inches) deep and interleaved with the absorption. Use 2D diffusion (scatters into a plane) towards the front of the room and 3D diffusion (scatters into a hemisphere) towards the back and on the ceiling. Include some form of bass absorption, usually placed in the front or back corners of the room. Bass traps should be made of dense fiber foam material 18-24 inches deep. Models that have a semi-rigid front plate offer improved performance.
— Anthony Grimani, expert in Home Theater Acoustics and Design
The placement of your loudspeakers and your listening seats is another area in which small changes can make a real difference, often without costing you a dime. Have you ever walked into a friend’s listening room to find an expensive center-channel speaker sitting on the floor, or large tower speakers jammed up against the walls? If you have, then you know that proper speaker placement can make or break the sound of an audio system. My brother got married recently, and because he didn’t have time for a bachelor party, his friend Seth invited the guys over for a casual dinner and hangout at his swanky Los Angeles townhouse. Seth had recently bought a new audio system and was keen to show me his beautiful turntable and KEF loudspeakers. He said he planned to upgrade his stereo receiver to something more stylish and high-end. There was nothing wrong with the gear, but the sound was awful. Those KEF speakers were not equidistant from the main listening area, nor were they at the same height (one was on a tall shelf, the other on a side table). They weren’t even facing in the same direction! Seth could spend ten grand on a new amp, but it wouldn’t make a difference with the speakers set up like that. New cables? Forget about it. I sighed with relief when he asked if I had any suggestions about improving the sound.
I was reminded of this unusual scenario when watching a recent video by PS Audio’s Paul McGowan. (I’m a fan of PS Audio electronics, though Gene questions McGowan’s enthusiasm for high-end Audioquest cables.) In the video, Paul says that “loudspeaker setup is probably the most important thing that you’re ever going to do to get great sound. Everything else pales (in comparison). Even the best speakers in the world, improperly set up, sound like dog doo.” Hard to argue with that. With a two-channel system, it’s not rocket science. Start with an equilateral triangle, in which the listening position is the same distance from each speaker as the two speakers are from each other. Give the speakers some breathing room from the front and side walls, and then do some experimenting with various changes. As long as the two speakers remain equidistant from the listening position, you can move things around, changing the sound as you do so, until you find what you like. With a home theater, things get more complicated, but there are plenty of guidelines from pros like Anthony Grimani about proper speaker angles, distances, and so on. If you need more hands-on help, seeking a consultation from Gene or from a professional home theater installer can be a cost-effective way to get moving in the right direction.
You wouldn’t believe how much the sound of a speaker changes based on its position in the room. Even movements of 6 inches can have a profound effect! Your goal should be to position the speakers to achieve smooth, neutral frequency response…. At the same time, the speakers need to be at specific places relative to the screen and seats. This can make for a maddening set of compromises and contradictions. You have to play within the limits of the rules. The interaction between the room and subwoofers is even more dramatic. Changes of 1 foot (30cm) in subwoofer placement can have a 20 dB effect on the sound level at some frequencies.
— Anthony Grimani
Maybe you have your speaker placement dialed in to perfection, or maybe there’s no easy way to move your speakers because they’re installed behind an acoustically transparent screen or bolted to the walls. You still have the option of moving your listening seat, and doing so can function as a positional EQ. When you move your listening seat forward or backward, you’re altering the frequency response that you’re hearing at that listening position. In many cases, one of the most beneficial changes that you can make is to move the seats away from the back wall, even if your room setup dictates that you can only come forward a small distance. If you have the flexibility, it’s generally ideal to place the listening seat into the room about one quarter of the length of the room. (So if your room is 20 feet long, you’d want 5 feet between your listening position and the rear wall.) This arrangement puts the listening position outside of the pressure maximum area toward the back of the room, where standing waves and uneven bass are all but guaranteed to cause trouble.
The sound at various seating locations changes in much the same way that speakers change when you move them around the room. This is especially true for lower frequencies, as the standing waves and speaker-to-boundary interference effects are very location-dependent. Try moving your seats a bit forward or back in the room and take note of the effect. Using an analyzer with a good microphone will confirm your observations. While we’re on the topic of seats, a headrest with leather or vinyl surface placed near your ears will totally mess up the higher frequencies due to short sound reflections hitting back at your ears. Use lower headrests or seats with upholstery rather than reflective surfaces.
— Anthony Grimani
Finally, if you’re hoping to make any kind of change (be it slight or significant) to the sound of your audio system, the use of parametric EQ or digital room correction can be a powerful tool. According to Gene, if you use tone controls or parametric EQ, you can vary the response of your system by 10dB or more very easily, and that kind of change isn’t just audible — it’s downright obvious. By comparison, Gene says the differences between cables are incredibly minor. When he measured equal lengths of standard 10 gauge and 14 gauge speaker cable against the expensive Thunderbird cable from Audioquest, Gene found that the differences were within tenths of a dB. He says that those minor differences were attributable to differences in resistance in the cables. (The higher the resistance, the more insertion loss you get, which means you’re going to lose signal level. But changes of tenths of a dB should be extremely faint.) These days, there are powerful digital EQ solutions built into most AV receivers and processors, and you can even find them in some two-channel gear (from companies like NAD, Anthem, JBL, and Lyngdorf). Anthem’s proprietary ARC Genesis software is very effective. High-end receivers from Denon and Marantz use Audyssey MultEQ XT32, while McIntosh’s best AV processors use Lyngdorf’s RoomPerfect solution. Trinnov is famous for its powerful room correction solution. In my opinion, the best of the third-party room correction programs is Dirac Live, which boasts the use of “state-of-the-art, patented algorithms to analyze and digitally reduce room impact and enhance speaker performance. Dirac Live delivers a larger sweet spot, accurate staging, clarity, voice intelligibility, and a deeper, tighter bass not otherwise possible. Fully tunable to your preference.” That last bit is key. All of these room-correction solutions can automatically compensate for certain room acoustics problems, changing the sound of your system so that it better matches a pre-determined response curve. But you’re also free to shape the sound however you want, and these transformations can be pretty incredible. Dirac can be found in a wide variety of home theater electronics, from the $1,200 Pioneer Elite VSX-LX305 receiver to the $24,000 StormAudio ISP MK2 processor in Gene’s home theater. Though Dirac is featured in some of NAD’s integrated amps and in the JBL Synthesis SA750 integrated amp, automatic room correction in general is less common in two-channel amps. But that doesn’t mean it can’t be part of your two-channel system. The digital signal processing technology company miniDSP makes powerful and reasonably-priced DSP devices that deliver Dirac Live into any stereo system. For example, the $799 miniDSP DDRC-22D is a digital-in, digital-out box that can be installed between a digital source (such as a streamer) and a DAC. The $949 miniDSP SHD Studio is both a Roon Ready streamer and a Dirac Live DSP solution in one. If you need analog outputs, miniDSP makes other models that offer them. Gene also has had positive experiences in the past using miniDSP hardware to handle multi-subwoofer optimization. I know many people in the audio industry, including both Gene and Paul McGowan, who aren’t big fans of using full-range EQ, preferring instead to correct only the bass region. Dirac allows you to choose the frequency range to be corrected, whether that’s everything below 500 Hz or 5 kHz.
When using Dirac you take a series of room acoustical measurements, (and) then it plots a normalized average of how your speakers and/or subwoofers are behaving in your room for both frequency and impulse response. This is really important because frequency response is not everything for sound quality, but it’s extremely influential to what we hear for tonal balance, overall musical translation, high frequency detail and energy, sound stage, bass power, presence, and depth. And probably most important is the impact on the overall system’s sonic balance. What’s very important to know is the frequency response you hear from a pair of speakers is not 100% the speakers; it’s the combination of the speaker and the room interaction. That means it’s the sound that comes out of the speakers mixed with the reflected sound or echo of the speakers sound that reflects off all your walls, ceiling, and floor that we are listening to, and the reflections affect the sound significantly. This you see more from looking at the impulse response because you can see reflections that are happening in your room at set delayed times, and this can be converted into distance to identify where those reflections are.
— Terry Ellis, audio reviewer and Dirac Live calibrator
Digital EQ solutions are an obvious boon to home theater enthusiasts and audiophiles who lean toward digital files and small silver discs, but what about the old-school, analog-only guys? If you steer clear of digital room correction because the thought of digitizing your vinyl sends a chill of ones and zeroes down your spine, you might be thinking that EQ isn’t for you. Should you consider using cables to tweak the sound of your system? Consider instead investing in an analog equalizer. Though not as common or as popular as they once were, these useful bits of hardware still exist and can dramatically change the sound of your system, allowing you to make less-than-stellar recordings sound better than you thought possible. (They can also make everything sound terrible if you don’t know how to use them, but the only way to learn is to give it a go.) Schiit Audio currently makes three analog EQ devices, ranging in price from $149 to $1499
As I mentioned earlier, I’m not a hardcore cable skeptic, and I do believe that cables can sound different from each other. Whether you agree with that idea or not, the reality is that many other factors have a much greater effect on sound quality. So if you want to tweak the sound of your system, and you’ve been considering doing so by swapping out your cables, you’ll have much more luck by addressing room acoustics, fiddling with loudspeaker and listening seat placement, and/or applying EQ. If you’ve done all of those things and you still want to try out some expensive cables to see if they change the sound of your system, you have my blessing. (Just don’t tell Gene.)
So the question remains – Do you use cables as tone controls? Please give us your answer in the related forum thread below.
Jacob is a music-lover and audiophile who enjoys convincing his friends to buy audio gear that they can’t afford. He’s also a freelance writer and editor based in Los Angeles.
Confused about what AV Gear to buy or how to set it up? Join our Exclusive Audioholics E-Book Membership Program!
Copyright © 1998–2022 Audioholics, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Accessibility
All Bands on Deck: Meet Outside the Frame – Boise State University The Arbiter Online
Welcome to the new age of industrial disco. A band of three individuals in San Diego, California, are on the rise as they continue to make, release and perform their music. Their newfound sound encapsulates the identity they strive for as a band.
Meet Outside the Frame.
Senior music major Nate Williams, senior management major Max Conahey and senior music major Daniel Jaime all attend San Diego State University (SDSU), and continue to release new music, hoping to make it big in the world of rock.
The band’s name, Outside the Frame, not only stems from a famous lyric in a Queens of the Stone Age song, but it also represents the band’s background and what they stand for.
“We feel it represents us in a way that we are outside the box-type thinkers as well as musicians,” Conahey said. “We like stuff that’s not as mainstream in the grand scheme of rock music.”
Guitarist Max Conahey and bassist Nate Williams met in middle school in California. They picked up some instruments to mess around with and eventually realized that they wanted to showcase their talents to their friends and family. From there, Outside the Frame was born.
“The band really took shape the second half of junior year, and then senior year, we finally solidified Outside the Frame as the identity under which we started writing music,” Williams said. “We finally put stuff out around senior year and have been doing it from there.”
Outside the Frame has taken a liking to various bands of various genres to inspire their work. For Williams, Nine Inch Nails and Boston Manor have been huge influences for his music production. For Conahey, he has found sparks of influence in some of Billie Eilish’s recent works.
“I respect [Eilish] as a musician so I definitely take inspiration from the look and feel of her entire portfolio, especially in her most recent album [Happier Than Ever],” Conahey said.
For any musical artist, live music performances hit an all-time low during the COVID-19 pandemic. For Outside the Frame, this meant time to recuperate, find a new sound and write new music. All three members are full-time students at San Diego State University who are simultaneously juggling jobs, band practice and academics.
“There is a problem that every band, especially in college has — what do we need to do to get to the next point, and how much of that are we actually able to accomplish with our full plate of being full time college students, pursuing careers outside the band and managing our time?” Williams said.
For the past three years, Outside the Frame has taken a direct route in producing music, releasing sounds that follow their influences. This is all about to change. With the variety in influences that the band looks up to, their direction and sound is beginning to change drastically.
Their new song “Carousel” is an example of this.
“‘Carousel’ is nothing like any of our old stuff, even though It still has the rock feel,” Conahey said. “We have come to a consensus that we’re going to be making more pop inspired dance music mixed with darker rock tones that we all have our roots from, and it’s a fusion that I coined as industrial disco, but we’ll see how that plays out.”
Williams has gained experience with music composition from high school and college which has aided the band in their drive for a new sound. There is more precision that goes into their music, now that they have a planned direction of their new works.
“I’d say our new sound is a lot more calculated and precise,” Williams said. “There’s a lot more thought going into each individual piece, kind of seeing what fits, where before it was pretty straightforward with instrumentation. There wasn’t any really synthesizers or anything but now we’re bringing in more sounds that are outside of the box for a rock band.”
The rewards post-pandemic greatly outweighed the challenges for this musical trio. As aspiring musicians in the rock music world, it is highly rewarding to become recognized by fans and other bands, which is what Outside the Frame has experienced post pandemic.
“I had a pretty cool experience at our last show where these two fans stopped me outside and expressed their admiration for our music, and I had no idea who they were,” Conahey said. “It’s cool to see genuine grassroots of people who are just fans of us and our music. It’s validating for sure.”
Playing in front of their friends and family is one thing, but for this youthful band, getting recognized by strangers in the street makes the journey that much more rewarding.
“Getting to play to people who actually enjoy our stuff, whether they’ve heard us before, or it’s the first time that they’re seeing us is the thing that really makes it worth it,” Williams said.
Their new single “Carousel” will be available on Aug. 20 on all music streaming platforms. Make sure to check out their social media for more updates on the band’s new releases this year.
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
![]()
Online Editor: Ashley Clark at [email protected]
Call us:
Arbiter Staff: (208)-426-6308
Sales Team: (208)-426-6302
Pokemon World Championships Reveal New Unite Map, Master EX Ash & Pikachu Sync Pair, And More – TheGamer
Pokemon fans will have to be a little patient for the big Scarlet & Violet news.
The 2022 Pokemon World Championships kicked off today in London. The four-day, invitation-only event will host tournaments for top competitors in Pokemon Sword & Shield, Pokken Tournament, Pokemon TCG, and for the first time, Pokemon Go and Pokemon Unite. The event kicked off with an opening ceremony where Pokemon Company president and CEO Tsunekazu Ishihara welcomed attendees back with big news for Unite and Masters EX, as well as a tease of Scarlet & Violet and TCG news to come.
Pokemon Masters EX players can look forward to Ash & Pikachu joining the game as a Sync Pair starting Wednesday, August 27. Surprisingly, this is the first official appearance of Ash in any video game. The two first appeared in a Masters EX story update last month, but you'll finally be able to scout the pair starting next week. Ash & Pikachu will introduce a brand new move type called buddy moves that deal bonus damage. The new trailer also revealed that the Trainer Lodge, a new area where players can get to know famous trainers like Cynthia, Blue, and Lillie, will be available in-game starting August 24.
Pokemon Unite is getting its first new map next month. The Theia Sky Ruins offers some subtle changes to the layout of the classic Aeos arena and will feature brand new Wild Pokemon, different objectives, and a new boss: Rayquaza. Theia Sky Ruins will be available for both ranked and standard battles starting September 2.
To conclude the opening ceremony, Ishihara teased some news for Pokemon Scarlet & Violet and the Pokemon TCG. Those reveals are coming this Sunday during the closing ceremonies, but it's expected that we'll get another look at Scarlet & Violet's Paldea region, as well as some details about the next Pokemon TCG base set.
This year's World Championships is the first to be held in three years, and the only Worlds event that's ever been hosted outside of North America. It's taking place at ExCel London from Thursday to Sunday. Non-competing attendees have the opportunity to watch the tournaments, join a learn-to-play TCG session, and shop at the World Championships-exclusive Pokemon Center.
Eric Switzer is the Livestream News Editor for TheGamer as well as the lead for VR and Tech. He has written about comics and film for Bloody Disgusting and VFXwire. He is a graduate of University of Missouri – Columbia and Vancouver Film School. Eric loves board games, fan conventions, new technology, and his sweet sweet kitties Bruce and Babs. Favorite games include Destiny 2, Kingdom Hearts, Super Metroid, and Prey…but mostly Prey. His favorite Pokémon is Umbreon.
ON THE RISE: Singer/Songwriter Gemma Laurence On Breathing Life Into Her Sophomore Album! – Icon Vs. Icon
The Source For All Things Pop Culture
Singer/Songwriter Gemma Laurence is a force to be reckoned with! After releasing her single “Adrienne” last year, the Coastal Maine-raised, Brooklyn-based DIY artist was met with an overwhelmingly positive response. She has received glowing praise from Under The Radar, EARMILK, Audiofemme, Country Queer, and Northern Transmissions, to name a few. She played packed rooms across NYC, from Rockwood to Mercury Lounge, selling out The Bowery Electric and The Broadway. NPR Music called her an “Up-and-comer” in the Sapphic folk music scene. To top it off, she recently had the opportunity to perform one of her original songs on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon.
After a whirlwind few months, Laurence recently announced that she would be releasing her sophomore album, ‘Lavender,’ this November. This ambitious new album marks a new chapter for the Sapphic folk artist. Without forgoing her signature lush acoustic soundscapes that drew listeners into the world of “Adrienne,” Laurence is going electric with her latest offering. And she’s not going back. Recorded, mixed, and produced by Charles Dahlke (of The Brazen Youth) at Ashlawn Recording Company in Lyme, CT, mastered by Andrew Goldring (Juliet Sunflower, Billy Martin), and workshopped with Steve Varney (of Gregory Alan Isakov), “Lavender” features Will Orchard on lead guitar, Micah Rubin (of The Brazen Youth) on drums, and Charlie Dahlke on bass, backing vocals, and piano. Marking a departure from the songwriter’s previous stripped-back solo work, “Lavender” feels expansive yet intimate, setting the stage for the artist’s new chapter in her story.
Jason Price of Icon Vs. Icon recently caught up with Gemma Laurence to discuss all aspects of her blossoming career. Along the way, she offers an inside look into her creative process, her evolution as a songwriter, and breathing life into her forthcoming album, ‘Lavender.’
You’ve been making quite a name for yourself as an artist. So let’s go back to the start. First, tell us a bit about how you grew up.
I grew up in Maine, which is where I am right now. I’ve been playing piano and guitar ever since I was a kid. I took up the banjo as a camp counselor, where I taught music to kids when I needed a second instrument to accompany them. I was teaching them the guitar. I would give them my guitar, and they would play, and I had a little banjo to play alongside it. That’s when I started experimenting with new instrumentation and began writing more music because I was no longer just thinking in guitar or piano terms. I learned how to layer all these different instruments and arrange a song. My first album came out in 2019. That was all banjo, very folky, Americana, stripped down, simple songs. It was all songs that I had been working on for years. Now, I am working on new materials with drums, bass, and all of these different arrangements. It’s been a big arc to learn what my style is or signature is when it comes to songwriting. Growing up in Maine around a lot of nature and other folk musicians was highly influential to me.
What is one of your fondest memories of your early days as a songwriter?
That’s a good question. The first time I ever wrote a song, I was 12 years old when I went to summer camp. I guess I’m a big camp person! [laughs] I got extremely restless at rest hour. I’m sure you can hear it in my voice, I talk very quickly, and I’m always doing things. I’m just a very hyper person! [laughs] So, a few of my friends and I went out to the baseball field and would write songs during rest hour. I wrote a song called “Got No Mail,” which was a song about not getting any mail from my parents while I was at camp. Side note! They sent me a lot of mail but just not every single day! [laughs] Props to my parents for being like, “We’re going to set expectations and send you one extremely thoughtful note a week…,” as opposed to daily care packages daily with notes saying, “I love you, I miss you, come home!” I wrote that song, which was very silly, but people seemed to like it. That made me think that I should start doing it more often. I wrote many silly songs like that as a kid and kept doing it through high school and college. As I moved forward, I started developing my style and writing much more personal stuff. So, writing “Got No Mail” at summer camp was a highlight in my early career! [laughs]
When did you choose to pursue your passion for music professionally?
I never thought about doing it professionally until I got to college. I was involved with the open mic scene at Middlebury, where I went to school in Vermont. I was going to an open mic called “WOMP” every week. It became such a safe space for me! I’d show up there and could perform whatever I had been working on, and everybody was so receptive, kind, and lovely. Around that time, I recorded a song with one of my friends. When we finished recording, he said, “So, you’re going to do this professionally, right?” I was like, “What?!” [laughs] I was 18 and a philosophy major at the time. I didn’t know what I was going to do with that degree, let alone what I was going to do afterward! [laughs]
Ultimately, I changed to an English major because I couldn’t stand the people who did philosophy! But anyways! [laughs] I never really considered it, and I didn’t make much music in college apart from performing. I’ve never been great at music theory, and I’d never done any big shows. So for most of my time in college, I had been thinking about going into academia. That is what my dad had done. He is a college professor, and my Mom is a writer, so I always felt I would go the academic route.
Fast forward four years, and I was about to graduate. I moved to New York just for a summer to do an internship. I started to play open mics all over the city. I would go to Astoria on Monday for the open mic there. Then I would go down to Williamsburg to Pete’s Candy Store for their open mic. Before I knew it, I was bopping around all over, every night, five days a week, with my guitar in hand! I met many great people in the process, many of whom are still my friends. It’s such a diverse, rich community. Experiencing it made me say, “I want to do this!” I realized that all these people had day jobs but were still seriously pursuing music. I was like, “I can do that too!” That’s when I knew this wasn’t just a fancy. I’ve wanted to do this for a long time. I knew I wanted to be in New York and to be performing. I didn’t know if I would ever make money doing it or if it would be a career, but I knew it’s what I wanted to do, along with whatever else I was going to do to supplement that.
Is there anyone in your family with the same musical DNA as you?
I recently discovered I had a long-lost cousin, a big neo-soul/R&B/jazz artist. His name is Oscar Jerome, and he rocks! I would describe his work as Rex Orange County meets Joy Crookes meets Hope Tala. It’s that kind of vibe! I recently found out about him. Before that, I thought I had no musicians in the family other than an aunt who does choir. My dad grew up singing hymns at the Naval Academy in the UK. He’s British! [laughs] My Mom sang me lullabies, but no one pursued it seriously other than that long-lost cousin! My parents were always really encouraging. They loved listening to music, but pursuing it professionally was never in their blood. Frankly, it’s just been a me thing! [laughs]
What I’m doing now does come down to my parents being so supportive from a young age. They took me to piano lessons because I wanted to learn. They were never the type who were like, “You need to be doing piano lessons to become a protege!” [laughs] They were very much like, “What do you want to do?” I was like, “Girl Scouts! Lacrosse! Soccer! Music lessons!” To their credit, they were like, “Okay! Let’s see how long you’ve got until you burn out!” [laughs] I did, probably around the time I was eight, but I stuck with music!
With piano, I worked on it pretty hard! It never really felt right because I did classical piano. I felt like the rigid structure of that didn’t suit me. I like listening to songs and kind of figuring it out. My piano teacher also taught guitar. So, one day I asked him if we could try the guitar. He said, “Yeah, sure. Do you have a guitar?” I was like, “Nope!” He told me to find one, and we’d figure it out. [laughs] I asked around, and this kind on my school bus gave me his half-sized nylon stringed toy guitar. I played on that for the first five years! [laughs] I continued practicing and started writing songs and listening to songs to figure out what was happening. I quickly realized that I have a better ear for music than reading music and all the technical stuff. That’s how I got here, all of these years later!
You mentioned that your songwriting had become more personal through the years. That’s a big step to take, but it’s something that comes through beautifully in your music.
Thank you! I feel like it was a very natural progression. I would describe myself as a very open and vulnerable person. I like being comfortable with that vulnerability. The more honest, open, and vulnerable I am in front of others when I’m performing, the more connection I get! I started writing more heartfelt songs when I was around 17 or 18 years old. I was in high school and going through a lot. I started writing those songs as a reaction to what was going on in my life. Something heartbreaking would happen, like loss, a breakup, or a death in the family, and I would write a song immediately afterward to process it. It was more for me than it was for anyone else. I would perform them, and people would come to me afterward and tell me that the songs resonated with them. That means so much to me, and it made me realize that the more personal and honest I wrote, the more it connected with people.
As time has passed, I’ve started writing music more as a response and less as a reaction. I’m looking back more in retrospect, and my life now is much less chaotic than it was when I was a teenager. I’m sure that holds true for many people. Now, I’m looking back on past experiences and drawing from those. I look back on friendships, how they’ve evolved, how my queerness came to light, how I came out, the people I’ve been in love with in the past, and people who have come into my life more recently. I’m sitting with that more.
Additionally, I’m reading more poetry and novels to develop more vocabulary to create a narrative around the song that’s more than, “Oh, you broke up with me, and I’m hurt now!” [laughs] Instead, it is more like, “I remember golden hour. 4 o’clock in October in Morningside Heights. Walking down the streets with this person, having free whiskey samples at a farmer’s market, and getting accidentally super drunk!” I want to write a song about that! I’m leaning more on the sensory parts of memories now than the emotional gut reaction.
What lessons did you learn early on that resonate with you as you move forward in your career?
That’s an excellent question. I talked to a lot of people that I looked up to. I think the best advice I got was to be humble and to ask questions. You’ll never figure it out on your own, so you need to ask people for their advice and insights. I constantly talked to the people I looked up to at college who ran the open mics or did other shows. I’d ask stuff like, “Hey, what’s your secret? How did you get to where you are now?” Essentially, they told me that practicing all the time and treating it as a business was essential. I don’t think that can be emphasized enough. If you’re trying to do music professionally, taking it seriously and treating it like a business is essential. You want to get the right team behind it, even if it’s just yourself. You must dedicate weekly time to practice, working on setlists, reaching out to venues, or performing to get your chops up!
Once you’ve done all that, you have to keep at it! I took a few music marketing classes during the pandemic. I went to Berklee Online to do some research because I knew I wanted to work in the industry and learn more about it from that perspective. I learned so much! That class made it crystal clear — It’s not going to be a hobby. It’s going to be a lot of work, and it’s not going to happen overnight. So many people think they have to wait for their big break or until their “Tik-Tok famous,” and then it’s all going to work out when you hit X amount of streams. That’s not how it works because it’s such an ongoing process. You have to have a lot of endurance. I think perseverance, endurance, and humility are crucial elements.
You’ve been hard at work on your sophomore album, ‘Lavender.’ So how did the ball get rolling for this one?
I’m so excited to release this album! I’ve been sitting on it for a while now. Apart from the single I put out in October of 2021, I haven’t released any new music since the Summer of 2019. So, it’s been a minute! [laughs] I wrote all these songs over the pandemic when I was holed up on the coast of Main at my parent’s house. I had planned to move to New York after graduating in February of 2020. Bad timing! [laughs] That led me to move back to Maine and take several music production/business classes online. I was also working on my stuff along the way. Many of these songs are very nostalgic and have a lot of yearning. As I mentioned, much of it draws these images from memories. For me, it is about taking these sights, smells, and textures, drawing all of those things together, and quilting them into this fabric or soundscape. It’s slightly different from the stuff I’ve done before just because it’s a little more fleshed out, lush and atmospheric. Additionally, many more musicians, instruments, and collaborators are involved in creating this world.
I recorded one track on my own. It’s a song called “Canyon Moon.” That one I produced on my own and then met producer Charlie Dahlke (The Brazen Youth) through a friend online. He loved my stuff and that song. I had all of these iPhone demos, and he said, “Do you want to come down and record?” I was like, “Heck, yeah!” He has this beautiful farmhouse recording studio out of Lyme, Connecticut. He said, “Just come with the songs you want to do, and we will do the thing!” His band, The Brazen Youth, is genuinely great. They are folk-rock, so it’s a similar palette to what I do. So I collaborated with him, guitarist Will Orchard, and Micah Rubin, their drummer. It was just fantastic! We recorded the whole album in a week, and now it’s almost here! I released one of the singles, “Adrienne,” this past Fall. I just sat on it for a while to see how it resonated as I brainstormed about how I wanted to put out the album. I ended up deciding to work with Better Company Records, who’s this excellent indie label. They are putting out the album in November. I couldn’t be more excited because they are fantastic people! Everyone involved in making this record has been amazing and is excellent at their jobs!
Tell us about “Adrienne” and how the song began to take shape.
That song is inspired by an Adrienne Rich poem from “21 Love Poems,” a collection in “The Dream of A Common Language.” A lot of these songs are inspired by poets. As I mentioned, I was an English major in college, so I’ve been into reading poetry for a while. I got into it during my year abroad at Oxford. I was introduced to Adrienne Rich by a person a couple of years ago, and, honestly, it changed my life. Adrienne Rich, the way she writes feels like she is just getting right into your brain. It’s like she’s drawing on memories that you didn’t even know you had. She does it by streaming these images together like driftwood and a bottle of whiskey on a stack of paper. Suddenly, you find yourself immersed in this world. I love how that writer does that, so I wanted to write a song that does the same thing.
I wanted to string together a bunch of images and create a scene of this moment to draw people into it. It’s so specific to me and my experience with this person that it’s about who introduced me to this writer. It also feels universal in the sentiment, yearning, and nostalgia. It comes down to the question, “How is that person doing?” [laughs] You know that person so well in that short time. Maybe you spent one night together or went on a few dates that felt special to you. Then you look back and think, “I wonder how you’ve been?” It was about reflecting on that experience and passionate moment and all its details! Everything from the sunlight dancing on the walls the next morning to the coffee brewing on the stove. It’s about that, and it’s about Adrienne Rich. So, it felt like an enjoyable departure from my past stuff. It wasn’t “And I want to get back together…” or “and screw you!” [laughs] It was about honoring that moment!
“Lavender” is another impressive track. What is the story behind this one?
“Lavender” started as a banjo song. I wrote it for my best friend after she came out. It’s a song honoring her transition and celebrating her and celebrating the trans and queer communities. It honors the hardships of coming out and how difficult it can be for many people. I feel fortunate that when I came out as queer, I was met with a lot of love. My parents, friends, and family were super accepting, but many people have a much harder go of it. I wanted to write a song about that for people who didn’t necessarily have those songs growing up. As I said, the song began as a banjo song, but when we went into the studio to record it, it was becoming a little too sing-songy. It was banjo and guitar and felt like a campfire song! [laughs] That’s my comfort zone because I love campfire songs. Charlie said, “Okay, what if we made it a rock song?” I thought about it and was like, “Yeah, that’s what we have to do!” It’s an anthem! It’s powerful and big!
So, we dimmed the lights and lit some candles in the studio. It was around 10 PM, and we had just started jamming. Our drummer was drumming, Charlie played bass and piano, and I played acoustic guitar. We changed the chords around a little bit, and the song completely transformed! It feels more like the songs I like to listen to from Big Thief, Phoebe Bridgers, Soccer Mommy, or Skullcrusher. We did the song in one day, and it came together well. It’s probably my favorite song on the entire album, so I’m excited to share it with everybody!
What special moments come to mind from these incredible recording sessions?
Ashlawn Recording Company, where we recorded with Charlie, is one of the most beautiful places I have ever been in my life! It’s so stunning! It’s a farm on these rolling hills with horses grazing outside! We recorded in March when there was condensation rising off the grass. It was misty somedays, beautiful and sunny but still had this cool chilliness. It felt very cozy. It was initially a farm before becoming Charlie’s Mom’s coffee shop, Ashlawn Coffee Company. Then they moved locations, so he turned the coffee shop into a recording studio. It felt so cozy, and we huddled up there every day, drinking coffee that his Mom gave us! That was so nice of her! [laughs] It felt so safe and loving.
To be honest, I’ve always felt a little afraid to record. I say that because I don’t really know the lingo. I just write the songs, most of which are in an open tuning. Charlie made me feel so comfortable, and the atmosphere was terrific. It was like a bunch of pals mucking around and making some music. It couldn’t have been more laid back! That experience gave me more confidence as a recording artist. As I mentioned, I took some production classes in the past and wanted to do the album on my own. I kind of quickly realized that production wasn’t my thing. I recorded some parts and did the homework for the class, but it never felt quite right to me. I love making the music, but I don’t love having to plug in and constantly think about where it goes into the computer and how the interface works. Then, if I mess up on an engineering thing, I end up having to redo the whole thing. That was a bit of a bummer because I was hoping that I might continue to do audio engineering and production for other people. I quickly realized that wasn’t what I wanted to do.
Going into the studio and having someone experienced and who has worked on so many records care for me gave me a lot of confidence. It was like, “Okay, I might not know how to do those technical things, but I know enough of the vocabulary to articulate what I want.” Someone who has that type of experience can translate that pretty easily. The recording process is not as scary as I thought it would be! It’s not this intense process with all these people huddling over you and plugging things in. It can just be some friends making music and sound amazing even in a low-key setting! That felt special.
What did you learn about yourself by bringing this album to life?
I realized that I could be more of a leader in my music than I thought I could be. This speaks to the recording process and the band as well. After I had recorded the album, my goal was to make a band when I got to New York and start playing shows. I had never played with a full band before. Making this album was the first time I recorded or played with a band. I went into it very nervous and had all of these little hangups in my head. I feel like I’ve always been a singer/songwriter, so with my first album, I struggled a lot with keeping time with the click and stuff like that. So, we didn’t use a click, and I was speeding up a lot in the recordings and had to do it a bunch of times. I was just figuring it out, and I got very frustrated with myself.
I was at home in Maine for 15 months. I took those 15 months to be really intentional about writing the songs and learning more about the business side of things. The result is that I feel much more confident as an artist and recording artist. When I got to New York, I found a guitarist, drummer, and bassist. All of these people have become my best friends. They are all incredibly cool and talented. I remember our first band practice. We all get in, and they say, “Okay, so what do we do?” I was like, “I don’t know. What do you think we should do?” [laughs] They were like, “well, you’re the band leader!” [laughs] I said, “You’re right! I do have opinions! Here’s what we’re going to do!” [laughs] I gained a lot of confidence from that. I realized I had all the skills to do this.
I think many women in music feel this way that we are trained to second guess ourselves. I learned it’s okay to say, “Here’s what I want from this.” I now have more confidence in my decision-making regarding how the songs sound, the arrangements, and how they are recorded. I’m also not afraid to say no sometimes if something isn’t going to work for me. That doesn’t make me a jerk; it makes me a musician, a leader, and an artist. That’s okay to do! So, that’s something I’ve learned over the past year of making this album.
What does this album mean to you personally?
It’s a significant album to me. It explores my queerness a lot more and different expressions of queerness. Looking at the album, it feels like a collection of short stories or vignettes to me and the way I wanted to write it. These stories explore different moments in my life, expressions of queerness, femininity, and sexuality. There is a story about my best friend, and there is the story about Adrienne. There is a story about one of my more difficult breakups, moving to New York and reclaiming myself and my agency. It’s a love song to myself, and it’s the song that closes out the album.
The songs on this album focus on myself, the people I love in my life, and the queer community, all from different lenses and perspectives. Each song is really about somebody meaningful in my life. I spent a lot of time on the lyrics to truly capture what I wanted to capture in each piece. None of the songs feel like a throwaway or as if one of them is just there as filler. Each is a different expression of my identity, and it feels so meaningful to put that out into the world!
How do you view your evolution as a songwriter? Are there clear milestones for you?
Yeah! As I mentioned, these songs were all written over the pandemic, except for one I wrote right before graduating. That is the last track on the album. It’s funny because that one feels more like the songs on my first album. It’s a little more simple. It’s in 3/4, which I love. That song is about myself, whereas the other songs are about somebody else, as I mentioned. “In The Rearview” was very much me looking at myself. I’m asking, “Okay, this happened to me, but what does that say about my growth? Where does that leave me? Where do I want to go from this?” I think that inward turn was beneficial and a massive shift in my transition as a songwriter. I went from reacting to things happening to me to going more inward and reflecting on that feeling. That led me to reflect on other incidents and impactful moments in my life. So, that was a huge turning point.
“Canyon Moon,” the song I mentioned producing by myself, was also a big turning point. That was the first time I had ever recorded on my own. It’s kind of a stomp and clap song. Recently, I badly sprained my ankle on a run and couldn’t walk at all. I had already done all these stomps and claps, but my music professor at Berklee suggested that I do more. He said, “This sounds great, but I think we need it a little more fleshed out. I think you should do a couple more layers on top of that.” I was taking notes and said, “Yes, of course!” I’m on crutches at this point! I put them down and started stomping my good foot and clapping on my own in my childhood bedroom! It sounded great in the end! That is also thanks to Hill Kourkoutis, who is fantastic! She’s the first woman to win Best Recording Engineer at the Juno Awards. She rocks, and she’s so incredibly talented! We worked remotely, so she used all of these stems I was making and worked with me on it. I recorded all the earlier stems on my own. I did the banjo and the guitar, which was so empowering. I was listening to what I was doing and layering on top of that, which I had never done before. We used all of those original stems in the final recording even though we remixed it a little bit. That one feels very special to me, and it isn’t one I can perform live, which is cool. Usually, all the songs are guitar-based, and I can perform almost all of them with a band. However, with that song, you’d need at least three different people stomping and clapping like you were in a church. It’s really cool, and it feels very different. So, those are some of the bigger shifts in my songwriting and my attitude toward myself as a creative person.
Where do you find yourself looking for inspiration these days?
A lot of my ideas stem from reading. A lot of them happen when I’m reading poetry or a book. I have a collection of D.H. Lawrence short stories on my desk, my journal, and my coffee! [laughs] I often have ideas that spring from reading a phrase or a word that will stick with me for some reason. I will write them down, and I’ll just do a free association in my journal and write all of these different images that attach to that. I think I’m a pretty visual songwriter, so I think of a scene, a place, a person, a feeling, and a time. I write all of that down.
As I mentioned, “Adrienne” is from an Adrienne Rich poem. Another song on the album comes from a Frank O’Hara poem. When the song was written, I had been reading a lot of his work. I am just so in love with great poetry! I read all the time, and I’m constantly updating my Goodreads! [laughs] That’s often how it begins. I start writing about it, start free association, and then begin writing a poem. Then, I get my guitar and start fiddling around in open tuning to see which chords best evoke that feeling. I fiddle and futz around until I start singing the words. Eventually, everything comes into place! That’s how the songs on this more recent album went, as they are very visually based. All of them are in open tunings, so it’s got a huge, dreamy, ethereal sound.
I also have all of these musical heroes that I still look up to all the time. They are people like Phoebe Bridgers, Adrienne Lanker, and Soccer Mommy. I also listen to a lot of 70s folk like Joni Mitchell. I just went to see Phoebe Bridgers and MUNA live! I have gone to a lot of shows, but this was spectacular. The visuals were crazy! She’s done so much to get to where she is now. She is an incredible artist, songwriter, and producer, and she also puts on a show! That is such a dream to get to a point where you can have a full band with violins, crazy drums, and huge sound! Going to that was inspiring! I hope to see a lot more live music in the coming months. I also saw Norah Jones recently, and she rocks! I’m obsessed with her. She was the first artist I ever saw live when I was eight. All these years later, she is still killing it! I also love going to my friend’s gigs because I have so many pals in the city doing amazing stuff! People like Partygirl, Reliant Tom, and Camp Bedford Rescue Squad. There are so many bands doing incredible things right now. I feel like they will all blow up any minute. So, I’m trying to go to all the shows, be in the front row, singing and dancing along! That always feels so inspiring to me!
What do the next few months look like for you as we move closer to the album’s release date?
It has been such an overwhelming whirlwind of a year! One morning someone told me I was on NPR. I looked it up and found myself in an NPR article, which was very surprising. I also randomly ended up on Jimmy Fallon a couple of months ago! [laughs] That was a life-changing experience. So, all of these things are happening! I have no idea where all this momentum will take me, but I hope it amounts to some fun stuff!
I finished recording this album in March of 2021, so it’s already been a year of doing promotional stuff. I’ve also been doing more shows in New York. We had a Mercury Lounge show scheduled, but I had to cancel it when I got Covid. That was a big bummer, but I hope to return there soon. I also hope to return to Rockwood Music Hall, Pianos, and the other iconic New York City stages! I also hope to maybe go on tour. I’m kind of looking into that. Nothing’s official, but I think it would be fun to go back up to Burlington or maybe Maine, where I’m from, in support of the album. Maybe do a little Northeast thing following the album, so stay tuned on that!
Most importantly, I hope the album connects with people! Since I’ve been sitting on this album for a while, I’ve written many songs since then. I’m hoping to start recording those soon, so there may be more music coming after the album. I’m excited to be signed to Better Company Records. They absolutely rock, and I can only imagine the awesome stuff that will come from that collaboration!
Your story can inspire so many people. So what’s the best lesson we can learn from your journey so far?
If there is any advice I would give to up-and-coming singer/songwriters, it’s to keep at it! Keep pushing forward, keep performing and keep trying new things. Keep making music, and don’t be afraid to challenge yourself. I’m not a rock star or a pop star. I’m just a gal making music, and it feels great. I love music and performing, but I’ve got a long way to go before I can make this a full-time career, and that’s okay! I’m still keeping my head down and working hard to make music that connects with other people but also feels genuine to me. That’s the biggest lesson, I would say. For anyone trying to get their foot in the door, don’t value your worth based on streams or press. What matters is that you are making music that is authentic. If you are making music that feels genuine to you, it will connect with people eventually. It may not happen overnight, but it will happen! Also, keep making connections because you never know where that may lead. You may go to a show and meet someone; years later, you are on tour with a superstar. You never know where those connections might take you!
Follow the continuing adventures of Gemma Laurence via social media:
Facebook | Twitter | Website | Instagram | Bandcamp | SoundCloud | YouTube
Jason Price founded the mighty Icon Vs. Icon more than a decade ago. Along the way, he’s assembled an amazing group of like-minded individuals to spread the word on some of the most unique people and projects on the pop culture landscape.
Transfer news LIVE: Morgan Gibbs-White set for Forest as Cristiano Ronaldo wanted by surprise club – The Independent
Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in
Arsenal, Manchester United and Chelsea are among those chasing deals with just two weeks left of the summer transfer window
Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile
In the latest summer transfer news, Manchester United are closing in on the signing of Real Madrid midfielder Casemiro while Chelsea continue to hold talks with Barcelona over a deal for Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang. The Independent understands Casemiro will sign a four-year deal with the option of a further year at Old Trafford, with the clubs set to agree a €60m fee plus potential add-ons for the five-time Champions League winner.
Casemiro trained with Real Madrid this morning but his manager Carlo Ancelotti has confirmed that the Brazil international will leave the club. “He wants to try a new challenge, a new opportunity,” Ancelotti said. “He wants to leave.”
Meanwhile, Chelsea continue their busy summer of transfer business and remain interested in Frenkie de Jong, Wesley Fofana and Anthony Gordon as well as a move for striker Aubameyang, who is said to be keen on a return to the Premier League. In other news, Nottingham Forest have signed the 22-year-old midfielder Morgan Gibbs-White from Wolves for an initial £25m that could rise to over £42m.
Elsewhere, Cristiano Ronaldo has been offered a way out of Manchester United by Sporting Lisbon while United are one of a number of clubs interested in signing Chelsea forward Christian Pulisic on loan. Follow all the latest news, rumours and done deals below.
Carlo Ancelotti has confirmed Casemiro wants to leave Real Madrid to join Manchester United.
The 30-year-old is set to sign a four-year deal at Old Trafford as new boss Erik ten Hag finally secures the defensive midfield reinforcement he has been desperate for all summer.
United have agreed a fee in the region of €60m with Real Madrid, plus an additional €10m in add-ons.
Ten Hag said he “cannot tell anything” when asked about the Brazil international in United’s press conference on Friday, but Madrid boss Ancelotti was more forthcoming when speaking to the media in Spain.
The 30-year-old Brazilian international midfielder is set to sign a four-year deal at Old Trafford
Nottingham Forest have confirmed the signing of Morgan Gibbs-White from Wolves for an undisclosed fee, reported to be an initial £25million which could rise to over £40m with add-ons.
Midfielder Gibbs-White, 22, becomes Forest’s 16th summer signing as head coach Steve Cooper continues to revamp his squad following Premier League promotion.
Former Swansea boss Cooper and Gibbs-White are reunited as the latter spent the first half of the 2020/21 season on loan at the Liberty Stadium.
The pair also worked together during Cooper’s spell in charge of England Under-17s, who won the U17 World Cup in 2017.
The midfielder becomes Forest’s 16th summer signing
Newcastle United boss Eddie Howe has issued a hands-off message to Real Madrid over star midfielder Bruno Guimaraes.
The 24-year-old Brazil international has made a stunning impact in the Premier League since his £35million January arrival at St James’ Park from Lyon, but has been linked with a move to the Spanish capital in recent days should Casemiro head for Manchester United.
Asked if he could contemplate allowing Guimaraes to leave, Magpies head coach Howe said: “No, absolutely not.
“We’re trying to build a squad here that we feel can take the club to be successful over the next few years, and we want to build that squad and enhance the group, not take away our best players.”
The £35million January signing has been linked with Real Madrid
Tottenham midfielder Tanguy Ndombele has joined Napoli on loan for the rest of the season, with an option to make the move permanent.
Frenchman Ndombele joined Spurs from Lyon during the summer of 2019, going on to make a total of 91 appearances and scoring 10 goals.
After finding first-team chances limited under Antonio Conte, Ndombele, 25, spent the second half of last season back in Ligue 1 with Lyon.
A club statement from the Serie A side read: “Napoli announces that it has acquired the sporting performances of Tanguy Ndombele from Tottenham Hotspur on a temporary basis with the right of redemption (a permanent transfer).”
After finding first-team chances limited, Ndombele, 25, spent the second half of last season back in Ligue 1 with former club Lyon
Aston Villa boss Steven Gerrard expects Diego Carlos to play a “big chunk” of the season after suffering a ruptured Achilles tendon.
Summer signing Carlos has had successful surgery on the injury he sustained on his second competitive Villa appearance against Everton last weekend.
The Brazilian, a reported £26million recruit from Sevilla, is set to be missing for several months, but Gerrard insists the 29-year-old will still play a significant role this season.
“It’s certainly a blow to lose a player of his importance,” Gerrard said ahead of Saturday’s Premier League trip to Crystal Palace.
Less than two weeks remain of the transfer window and Gerrard says he is mulling over whether defensive additions are needed in light of Carlos’ injury.
Gerrard said: “We’re having talks behind the scenes to decide what we do. I don’t think there’s an urgent need (to make a signing).”
The summer recruit from Sevilla was injured on his second competitive appearance for the club
Chelsea have completed the £12million signing of Cesare Casadei from Inter Milan.
The Blues have added the highly-rated 19-year-old midfielder to their ranks, continuing the new owners’ drive to recruit the game’s brightest young stars.
New chiefs Todd Boehly and Behdad Eghbali have also turned to academy boss Neil Bath for part of their long-term transfer strategy.
The Blues have now added Casadei to other young star signings Carney Chukwuemeka, Gabriel Slonina, Omari Hutchinson, Zak Sturge and Tyler Dibling.
Chelsea’s new owners are determined to plan for the long haul as well as boosting the senior squad strong amid a transformative summer.
Chelsea view Italy youth international Casadei as a player of high promise
Mikel Arteta is “very confident” that England forward Bukayo Saka will sign a new deal at Arsenal sooner rather than later.
The 20-year-old has two years remaining on his current contract at the Emirates Stadium and continues to be a vital part of Arteta’s side.
Saka finished as Arsenal’s top goal-scorer last season as he rose above the racist abuse he suffered after missing the deciding penalty in England’s Euro 2020 final defeat to Italy.
Having joined the academy aged seven, Saka made his first-team debut under head coach Unai Emery in 2019 but has flourished under Arteta.
Asked about a new deal for Saka, the Spaniard replied: “I am very confident that we as a club and Bukayo, his family, his agent, everybody, we are very much aligned in what we want to achieve. And now it is about putting it on a piece of paper.”
Arteta said Saka and the club were ‘very much aligned’ in their ambitions
Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola does not expect his side to do any more business in the transfer window.
City made Sergio Gomez their fifth summer arrival earlier this week, with the Anderlecht left-back following Julian Alvarez, Erling Haaland, Kalvin Phillips and Stefan Ortega to the Etihad Stadium.
But Guardiola has been told that is it with less than two weeks left in the transfer window.
Asked if their business was done, he said: “Apparently yes. But if someone moves or there is a problem we don’t expect maybe it happens, but apparently it is done.”
City made Sergio Gomez their fifth summer arrival earlier this week, with the Anderlecht left-back following Julian Alvarez, Erling Haaland, Kalvin Phillips and Stefan Ortega to the Etihad
Graham Potter said Moises Caicedo is loved at Brighton and Hove Albion and a “delight to work with” as he dismissed transfer speculation surrounding the midfielder.
Ecuador international Caicedo has shone since making his Albion debut in April, prompting links with Premier League rivals Manchester United and Liverpool.
The 20-year-old has played just 10 top-flight games in his fledgling career, losing only once, and Seagulls head coach Potter is excited by his potential.
Ecuador international Caicedo has shone since making his Albion debut in April, prompting links with Premier League rivals Manchester United and Liverpool
Frank Lampard has said he wants Anthony Gordon to stay at Everton and improve them rather than move to Chelsea – but admitted he could not guarantee the winger will still be at Goodison Park when the transfer window closes, Richard Jolly writes.
Everton rejected an offer, thought to be of up to £45 million, for the 21-year-old this week – but while Lampard believes Gordon has a huge value and is worth more than some players who have gone for high fees, he insisted that was not a negotiating ploy to get Chelsea to raise their bid.
Gordon is set to feature for Everton agaisnt Nottingham Forest despite transfer interest from Chelsea
Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism
By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists
{{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}
By clicking ‘Create my account’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.
Already have an account? sign in
By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.
Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism
By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists
{{#verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}} {{^verifyErrors}} {{message}} {{/verifyErrors}}
By clicking ‘Create my account’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.
Already have an account? sign in
By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
Getty Images
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in
Log in
New to The Independent?
Or if you would prefer:
Want an ad-free experience?
Hi {{indy.fullName}}
Sarah Sherman review – Saturday Night Live star’s queasy comedy hour – The Guardian
Gilded Balloon, Edinburgh
Sherman’s show, pitched between anti-comedy, performance art and body horror, leaves no doubt why she’s also known as Sarah Squirm
Delightfully weird, says the pre-publicity. I’m not sure that covers it. Sarah Sherman – Long Island native, featured player on Saturday Night Live – delivers to the fringe one of those late-night, is-this-really-happening? shows that feel like a fever dream. There’s a lot of laughter, much of it Sherman’s own. But what I’m watching, while it’s bewildering, queasy, manic and wearing a clown suit, is almost never uncomplicatedly funny.
If the experience was, for this viewer, as often alienating as enjoyable, it’s clear there’s something interesting going on: something pitched into uncharted space between anti-comedy, performance art and body horror. You could call it “queering the narrative of comedy by not being funny and just being scary”, as Sherman does, tongue firmly in cheek. There’s certainly nothing straight about the show, which feels substantially made up on the hoof, as the 29-year-old keens at reviewers to give her five stars, squawks about “Saint Arthur’s Seat” in a bad cockney accent and weighs up the relative virtues of haggis and her “pussy”.
There are one or two recognisably comic set-pieces: a riff sending up her home town’s civic pride, in a thick Noo Yawk accent; another on the labyrinthine ways her well-networked dad will find you a job. There’s a guided meditation set-piece, the joke of which – as conventional as Sherman gets – is that her narration is profoundly unsoothing, and sexually unsettling.
In the US, Sherman occasionally performs under the nom de guerre Sarah Squirm, and the second half here does exactly what it says on that tin. A series of DIY video animations illustrate a guess-what-you’re-looking-at quiz, in which the answers range from haemorrhoid blood, “pimple pop cream cheese” and turd emerging from an anus. Heartily though I sympathise with the politics of Sherman’s pushback against the prettifying of the female body, I averted my eyes from much of this stuff, not laughing but blanching.
But hey, it’s a strong flavour, and the image-making, when not completely gross, is often vividly strange – as when Sherman-on-screen makes Gaudi-esque sandcastles with her vagina. Not for the faint-hearted, but worth a look for those interested in far-out comedy.
At the Gilded Balloon, Edinburgh, until 21 August. Then at Soho theatre, London, 22-25 August.
All our Edinburgh festival reviews.











