equine news, research, and information
Researchers have taken an important first step towards designing and assessing an accident analysis framework for horse-related activities.
Meredith Chapman, Kate Fenner and Matthew Thomas said horse-related activities can be dangerous, with riders citing hyperactive horse behavior as a major cause of injury. Other related risks include the horses’ size and weight, speed capabilities, unpredictability, or reactive behaviors.
The trio, writing in the journal Safety, noted that equestrianism is classified as a high-risk industry in Australia, along with mining, aviation, construction, and rail.
“Most high-risk industries have regulatory frameworks, implement work safety management systems, report incidents and complete accident analysis to mitigate risks,” they said.
“In Australia, equestrian work and non-work environments have few such regulations or processes and appear to lack insight into the value of exploring lessons that might be learned, from analyzing incidents, accidents and fatalities.”
Equestrian pursuits rarely use accident analysis, they said.
Chapman and Thomas, with Central Queensland University, and Fenner, with the University of Queensland, said accident analysis frameworks such as the Human Factors Analysis and Classification System (HFACS) are widely used in high-risk industries to determine risk-reduction strategies.
The study team set out to develop and test an equestrian-specific accident analysis framework that includes elements of human error, horse risk factors, and environmental factors.
Equestrianism, they said, has a triad of human, horse and environmental factors that can contribute to accidents. Horse-related activities, therefore, require an accident framework that can interpret all three factors, as well as evaluate their contributions, their relationships, and any other relevant influences. It also takes into account work and non-work environments.
“All human and horse errors, behaviors, responses, and acts, are equally important when determining equestrianism accident causation,” they said.
“Furthermore, by identifying risk-mitigation actions humans can adopt to reduce some unpredictable horse behaviors, an industry-specific accident analysis framework is likely to promote proactive management of human-horse interactions.”
In the first stage of their research, the study set about adapting the basic HFACS accident framework for use in the equestrian context. Following initial development, its validity was assessed against a set of horse-related accident scenarios, which resulted in some changes. This led to a new category specifically related to the horse.
Following additional testing, further refinements were made to what they called the Human Factors Analysis and Classification System-Equestrianism (HFACS-Eq) framework.
In the next phase, 10 simulated accident scenarios were assessed under the framework by the three authors, acting individually. The results showed that the HFACS-Eq framework achieved moderately reliable to reliable percentage agreement in terms of coding elements of accidents. Agreement was greater than 68% across all scenarios at the category and nano-code level, except for one scenario.
“This study is the first step towards an equestrian industry-specific, accident analysis framework to improve industry safety,” they said.
Elimination of possible bias and validation with real incident data are required before the wider application of the framework can be recommended, the authors said.
Discussing their work, they said that equestrianism is somewhat unfamiliar with high-risk safety and risk-mitigation systems and processes.
“Therefore, during the initial trial of HFACS-Eq, it was necessary to create equestrian-specific descriptive analysis language, terminology, and definitions.”
On further review, it was highlighted that the classification coding required frequent adaptation and simplification. The study’s results show the importance of having a clear, concise industry-specific framework, they said.
“This reinforces the importance of industry-specific fit-for-purpose applications.”
Ongoing reviews and modifications of such frameworks are likely to improve users’ knowledge and support new learnings from accident analysis and ultimately risk reduction through improved practices and safety management, especially in equestrianism.
Analysis of the 10 accident scenarios identified the horse as a 60% contributor to incident causation during human-horse interactions, they said.
“This would indicate that human acts or omissions, supervision, organisational factors, and the environment contributed 40%.” This finding, they said, may have been overlooked and its significance for equestrianism missed if the original HFACS had been used for the study.
They said further work using a larger sample of accidents may be beneficial.
While the HFACS-Eq framework emphasised the horse as a contributing factor in most accident scenarios, it was accompanied by a strong association with supervisory skills or capability and the physical environment.
Categories linked to the level of supervision and planning for safer human-horse interactions frequently arose as accident factors.
This supports the use of a systematic, integrated framework for accident analysis to extract “organisational deficits” that may contribute to horse-related accidents.
“The HFACS-Eq framework is likely to assist future investigators to locate active system failures that lead to an accident, highlighting areas to target training, support, and improvements to mitigate future accidents in equestrianism.”
They described their work as the first step towards designing and assessing an accident analysis framework for equestrianism.
“This study highlights the importance of organizational and procedural failures, segregating the horse as a contributing factor as well as the environment in which the human acts or makes decisions informing risk.
“Further research is needed using the HFACS-Eq framework to evaluate real incident data and eliminate possible bias before the wider application of the framework can be recommended to improve safety in equestrianism.”
Chapman, M.; Fenner, K.; Thomas, M.J.W. Development of a Humans Factors Approach to Equine-Related Human Accident Analysis, and Preliminarily Evaluation with Simulated Incidents. Safety 2022, 8, 72. https://doi.org/10.3390/safety8040072
The study, published under a Creative Commons License, can be read here.
Latest research and information from the horse world.
Your email address will not be published.
Affiliate disclaimer
WEB SITES
Aurora Pure Crabbets
Vollrath Hanoverians
NZ Farriers Assn.
NZ Hanoverian Soc.
Bryant Farrier Ltd
The Pole Man
Naturally Equine
Advertising Options
Affiliate disclaimer
We have detected that you are using browser extensions to block ads. Please support us by disabling your ad blocker, which helps keep this site free to view. You can then continue to the page you are seeking.