Blog

Power your life with the Volvo EX90 – Automotive World

Don’t have an account? Subscribe
Home › News Releases › Power your life with the Volvo EX90
Many of us try to care for the environment by recycling the materials we can, cooking in a way that leads to less food waste or driving an electric car
Many of us try to care for the environment by recycling the materials we can, cooking in a way that leads to less food waste or driving an electric car. When it comes to making your energy usage more sustainable, however, it can be hard to know how to increase the share of renewable sources in the electricity that you use.
Because while society is increasing its electrification, with cars playing a key part of the green transition, an increased demand for electricity can lead to a significant strain on the grid.
We believe that with bi-directional charging, electric cars can have the potential to contribute to an easing of this strain while plugged in – together with many other electric cars forming a virtual powerplant. It can also help power your own home energy needs and, when unplugged, become a battery on wheels powering your life on the go – for your cookout, power tools or music system.
The upcoming, fully electric Volvo EX90, which will be revealed on November 9, will be the first Volvo car to be hardware-ready for bi-directional charging capabilities. Initially becoming available in selected markets, bi-directional charging has the potential to help you make your energy utilisation cheaper, more efficient and sustainable. Paired with smart-charging capabilities coming to the Volvo Cars smartphone app, the Volvo EX90 will allow you to charge your car when demand from the grid and prices are low – usually meaning there are more renewable sources in the energy mix – and save that stored energy to be used later.
Once available, bi-directional charging in the Volvo EX90 could enable you to power your home, as well as other electric devices.
“With the Volvo EX90 you can power your life,” says Head of Electrification Ecosystem Olivier Loedel. “You could use its battery in many ways, from topping up your electric bike when you’re out and about, to hooking up an outdoor cooking appliance for your weekend camping trip. It could even power your house during the expensive peak hours of the day.”
Along with being able to charge appliances and other devices, your car will ultimately have the capability to lend a helping hand and give some of its charge to other compatible Volvos. On the flip side, if you’re about to run out of juice, don’t worry. You can accept the same help from other Volvo cars as well.
Where available, the entire charging process will be automatic and managed entirely by the smart charging functionality in the Volvo Cars app. The underlying algorithm also makes sure that you charge and discharge the battery in a limited way, reducing the risk of avoidable battery degradation.
Depending on rules specific to each energy market, bi-directional charging could also allow customers to support the grid in different ways. This could include taking in more energy during times when there’s a surplus of renewable energy, or selling energy back during peak usage hours when there is more demand. If most cars have this functionality in the future, then the grid could be balanced more often. That could increase the overall sustainability of the grid by reducing potential energy waste from renewable sources at times when production outperforms demand.
Imagine this scenario: You come home from work with plenty of energy left in the battery, which has earlier been charged with cheaper and cleaner electricity. During the evening, your car can be plugged in and discharge energy when electricity prices are higher. Since energy is generally cheaper when climate-neutral sources are contributing more to the power supply, this energy transaction can save money on your energy bill and give back cleaner energy to the grid at the same time.
“We believe in a future where our customers can support the grid using this technology, enabling a more efficient and sustainable use of electricity in everyday life,” says Olivier Loedel.
We plan to offer the hardware you need to start using bi-directional charging features, including an advanced wall box and home energy management system. Other accessories such as adapter plugs for appliances and cables for charging other cars will also be available.
The small print
Future technology and features are described, and capabilities may vary. Features may not be available in all markets and will not be standard in all markets or for all models.
The bi-directional charging offer will initially be launched in selected markets. We are currently investigating which use cases we will be able to offer in different markets.
We will equip the Volvo EX90 with the necessary hardware to support the grid, and we are currently assessing in which markets it would be possible to offer this to our customers.
SOURCE: Volvo Cars
Let us help you understand the future of mobility
October 6, 2022
October 6, 2022
October 6, 2022
November 7, 2022
Our Future Mobility Europe online event brings together more than 1,000 stakeholders to discuss the business models, technologies and trends shaping the future of mobility.
December 5, 2022
Our Future Mobility North America online event brings together more than 1,000 stakeholders to discuss the business models, technologies and trends shaping the future of mobility.
Welcome back , to continue browsing the site, please click here

source

Eloro Resources Intersects 198.00 g Ag eq/t (67.79 g Ag/t, 1.44% Zn and 1.04% Pb) over 134.47m in Silver-Rich Area of High-Grade Feeder Zone in Santa Barbara Target Area at the Iska Iska Silver-Tin Polymetallic Project, Potosi Department, Bolivia – GlobeNewswire

| Source: Eloro Resources Ltd. Eloro Resources Ltd.
Toronto, Ontario, CANADA
TORONTO, Oct. 05, 2022 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — Eloro Resources Ltd. (TSX-V: ELO; OTCQX: ELRRF; FSE: P2QM) (“Eloro”, or the “Company”) is pleased to announce assay results from two (2) additional diamond drill holes from its on-going drilling program at the Iska Iska silver-tin polymetallic project in the Potosi Department, southern Bolivia. One drill hole, DSB-31, tested the potential south-southeastern extension of the high-grade feeder zone at Santa Barbara while the second hole, DSB-33, tested the southwest limit of the zone in the vicinity of the Central Breccia, as shown in Figure 1.
In its September 20, 2022 press release, the Company reported that new downhole geophysical data has significantly extended the strike length of the high-grade feeder zone at Santa Barbara a further 250m along strike to the south-southeast from existing drilling. The 3D inverse magnetic model which correlates very strongly with the conductive zone suggests that the high-grade feeder zone may extend across the entire caldera for as much as a further 1 km along strike for a total potential strike length of at least 2 km. As previously reported, the definition drill program has been modified to sectionally drill this potential extension with the intention of defining a major open-pittable deposit in the valley of the caldera. As a result, the estimated completion date for the maiden National Instrument 43-101 mineral resource has been pushed back to the end of Q1 2023.
Overall, the Company has completed 77,182m in 119 drill holes to-date at Iska Iska, including four holes in progress, as shown in Figure 1. Tables 1 and 2 list significant assay results for the drill holes reported. Prices used for calculating Ag equivalent grades are as outlined in Eloro’s July 21, 2022 press release. Table 3 summarizes drill holes with assays pending. Highlights for the drilling are as follows:
Santa Barbara High Grade Feeder Zone Extension Definition Drilling
Hole DSB-31 was drilled to test the potential south-southeastern extension of the Santa Barbara High Grade Feeder Zone shown in Figure 1. This hole was collared approximately 200m south-southeast of the underground drill bay in the Santa Barbara adit and was drilled at an azimuth of 2250 with a dip of -600. This hole intersected several extensive high grade silver zones:
The high-grade silver zone intersected in hole DSB-31 appears to be in the same structural-mineralized corridor as the silver-rich zone in the Santa Barbara adit. As previously reported (see press release dated April 13, 2021), channel sampling along the adit returned 441.98 g Ag eq/t (164.96 g Ag/t, 0.23 g Au/t, 3.46% Pb and 0.46% Sn) over 165.89m. Adjusted to prices used in this current release, the overall Ag eq/t value is 493.61 g Ag eq/t.
Hole DSB-33 was drilled at an azimuth of 2250 with a dip of -600 to test the southwest limit of the high-grade feeder zone in the vicinity of the Central Breccia (Figure 1). This hole intersected 18 reportable intersections including a very high tin intersection grading 1.41% Sn over 21.25m from 354.98m to 376.23m. This included a 9.04m section from 356.56m to 365.60m that graded 3.08% Sn. A total of 26% of this 825.82m hole contained reportable intersections which collectively averaged 123.39 g Ag eq/t.
Tom Larsen, CEO of Eloro said: “Hole DSB-31 and Hole DSB-33 continue to confirm high grade values of metals, especially silver to the south-southeast and tin to the southwest of the ever-expanding Santa Barbara feeder system. The geophysical surveys have been remarkable as a tool in determining where these highly conductive areas of potential commercial mineralization are located.
On behalf of the Eloro shareholders, I congratulate Dr. Bill Pearson, P.Geo., Dr. Chris Hale, P.Geo. and Dr. Osvaldo Arce, P.Geo., in systematically defining the Santa Barbara feeder system through geophysics and follow up drilling. The added strike length along the collapsed caldera valley floor will further extend the likely open pit dimensions resulting in potentially stronger economics. These recently released holes at Iska Iska further demonstrate both high grade metal zonation and substantial tonnage potential.”
Dr. Bill Pearson, P.Geo. Eloro’s Executive Vice President, Exploration commented: “We are continuing our 100m-spaced sectional definition diamond drill program focusing on testing the south-southeastern extension of the high-grade feeder zone across the valley of the Iska Iska Caldera. Figure 1 shows holes in progress and planned. Our aim is to complete this program by November so that assay results can be received by early Q1 2023 to facilitate completion of the inaugural NI 43-101 mineral resource by the end of Q1 2023. We are also continuing to work closely with GeologicAI and our mineralogists in Blue Coast Research and Lisa Can Analytical Solutions to calibrate the AI in the scanning system to track the mineral and metal zoning more accurately. The drilling results reported herein, as well as previous results, along with on-site work by Dr. Osvaldo Arce, P.Geo. and his geological team, support the potential for outlining significant zones of high-grade silver and high-grade tin. The high-grade silver is typically shallower whereas the high-grade tin is generally deeper. The remarkable feeder zone at Iska Iska continues to be open along strike and down-dip especially to the south-southeast and it likely extends across a width of least 500m for potentially as much as 2km along strike.”
Figure 1 – Geological Plan Map showing Drilling in Santa Barbara Area with Holes referred to in this release highlighted: https://www.globenewswire.com/NewsRoom/AttachmentNg/3c88f4da-0f6f-4d43-8335-35382ad973fb
Table 1: Significant Results, Surface Diamond Drilling, Santa Barbara Resource Definition High Grade Feeder Zone Extension as at October 5, 2022.
Note: True width of the mineralization is not known at the present time, but based on the current understanding of the relationship between drill orientation/inclination and the mineralization within the breccia pipes and the host rocks such as sandstones and dacites, it is estimated that true width ranges between 70% and 90% of the down hole interval length but this will be confirmed by further drilling and geological modelling.
Chemical symbols: Ag= silver, Au = gold, Zn = zinc, Pb = lead, Cu = copper, Sn = tin, Bi = bismuth, Cd = cadmium and g Ag eq/t = grams silver equivalent per tonne. Quantities are given in percent (%) for Zn, Pb Cu, Sn, Bi and Cd and in grams per tonne (g/t) for Ag, Au and Ag eq.
Metal prices and conversion factors used for calculation of g Ag eq/t (grams Ag per grams x metal ratio) are as follows: (Prices updated as of July 21, 2022, to more accurately reflect current metal prices):
In calculating the intersections reported in this press release a sample cutoff of 30 g Ag eq/t was used with generally a maximum dilution of 3 continuous samples below cutoff included within a mineralized section unless more dilution is justified geologically.
The equivalent grade calculations are based on the stated metal prices and are provided for comparative purposes only, due to the polymetallic nature of the deposit. Metallurgical tests are in progress by Blue Coast Ltd. to establish levels of recovery for each element reported but currently the potential recovery for each element has not yet been established. While there is no assurance that all or any of the reported concentrations of metals will be recoverable, Bolivia has a long history of successfully mining and processing similar polymetallic deposits which is well documented in the landmark volume “Yacimientos Metaliferos de Bolivia” by Dr. Osvaldo R. Arce Burgoa, P.Geo.
Table 2: Significant Results, Surface Diamond Drilling, Santa Barbara Resource Definition High Grade Feeder Zone Extension as at October 5, 2022.
See Note Table 1.

Table 3: Summary of Diamond Drill Holes Completed with Assays Pending and Drill Holes in Progress at Iska Iska from October 5, 2022 press release.
S = Surface UG=Underground; collar coordinates in metres; azimuth and dip in degrees. Total drilling completed since the start of the program on September 20, 2020 is 77,182.47m in 119 drill holes (32 underground drill holes and 87 surface drill holes) including 4 holes in progress.
Qualified Person
Dr. Osvaldo Arce, P. Geo., General Manager of Eloro’s Bolivian subsidiary, Minera Tupiza S.R.L., and a Qualified Person in the context of NI 43-101, has reviewed and approved the technical content of this news release. Dr. Bill Pearson, P.Geo., Executive Vice President Exploration Eloro, and who has more than 45 years of worldwide mining exploration experience, including extensive work in South America, manages the overall technical program, working closely with Dr. Osvaldo Arce, P.Geo. Dr. Quinton Hennigh, P.Geo., Senior Technical Advisor to Eloro and Independent Technical Advisor, Mr. Charley Murahwi P. Geo., FAusIMM of Micon are regularly consulted on technical aspects of the project.
Eloro is utilizing both ALS and AHK for drill core analysis, both of whom are major international accredited laboratories. Drill samples sent to ALS are prepared in both ALS Bolivia Ltda’s preparation facility in Oruro, Bolivia and the preparation facility operated by AHK in Tupiza with pulps sent to the main ALS Global laboratory in Lima for analysis. More recently Eloro has had ALS send pulps to their laboratory at Galway in Ireland. Eloro employs an industry standard QA/QC program with standards, blanks and duplicates inserted into each batch of samples analyzed with selected check samples sent to a separate accredited laboratory.
Drill core samples sent to AHK Laboratories are prepared in a preparation facility installed and managed by AHK in Tupiza with pulps sent to the AHK laboratory in Lima, Peru. Au and Sn analysis on these samples is done by ALS Bolivia Ltda in Lima. Check samples between ALS and AHK are regularly done as a QA/QC check. AHK is following the same analytical protocols used as with ALS and with the same QA/QC protocols. Turnaround time continues to improve, as laboratories return to more normal staffing levels.
About Iska Iska
Iska Iska silver-tin polymetallic project is a road accessible, royalty-free property, wholly controlled by the Title Holder, Empresa Minera Villegas S.R.L. and is located 48 km north of Tupiza city, in the Sud Chichas Province of the Department of Potosi in southern Bolivia. Eloro has an option to earn a 99% interest in Iska Iska.
Iska Iska is a major silver-tin polymetallic porphyry-epithermal complex associated with a Miocene possibly collapsed/resurgent caldera, emplaced on Ordovician age rocks with major breccia pipes, dacitic domes and hydrothermal breccias. The caldera is 1.6km by 1.8km in dimension with a vertical extent of at least 1km. Mineralization age is similar to Cerro Rico de Potosí and other major deposits such as San Vicente, Chorolque, Tasna and Tatasi located in the same geological trend.
Eloro began underground diamond drilling from the Huayra Kasa underground workings at Iska Iska on September 13, 2020. On November 18, 2020, Eloro announced the discovery of a significant breccia pipe with extensive silver polymetallic mineralization just east of the Huayra Kasa underground workings and a high-grade gold-bismuth zone in the underground workings. On November 24, 2020, Eloro announced the discovery of the SBBP approximately 150m southwest of the Huayra Kasa underground workings.
Subsequently, on January 26, 2021, Eloro announced significant results from the first drilling at the SBBP including the discovery hole DHK-15 which returned 129.60 g Ag eq/t over 257.5m (29.53g Ag/t, 0.078g Au/t, 1.45%Zn, 0.59%Pb, 0.080%Cu, 0.056%Sn, 0.0022%In and 0.0064% Bi from 0.0m to 257.5m. Subsequent drilling has confirmed significant values of Ag-Sn polymetallic mineralization in the SBBP and the adjacent CBP. A substantive mineralized envelope which is open along strike and down-dip extends around both major breccia pipes. Continuous channel sampling of the Santa Barbara Adit located to the east of SBBP returned 442 g Ag eq/t (164.96 g Ag/t, 0.46%Sn, 3.46% Pb and 0.14% Cu) over 166m including 1,092 g Ag eq/t (446 g Ag/t, 9.03% Pb and 1.16% Sn) over 56.19m. The west end of the adit intersects the end of the SBBP.
Since the initial discovery hole, Eloro has released a number of significant drill results in the SBBP and the surrounding mineralized envelope which along with geophysical data has defined an extensive target zone. In its September 20, 2022 press release, the Company reported that new downhole geophysical data has significantly extended the strike length of the high-grade feeder zone at Santa Barbara a further 250m along strike to the south-southeast from existing drilling. The 3D inverse magnetic model which correlates very strongly with the conductive zone suggests that the high-grade feeder zone may extend across the entire caldera for as much as a further 1 km along strike for a total potential strike length of at least 2 km. As reported, the definition drill program has been modified to sectionally drill this potential extension with the intention of defining a major open-pittable deposit in the valley of the caldera. As a result, the estimated completion date for the maiden National Instrument 43-101 mineral resource has been pushed back to the end of Q1 2023.
About Eloro Resources Ltd.
Eloro is an exploration and mine development company with a portfolio of gold and base-metal properties in Bolivia, Peru and Quebec. Eloro has an option to acquire a 99% interest in the highly prospective Iska Iska Property, which can be classified as a polymetallic epithermal-porphyry complex, a significant mineral deposit type in the Potosi Department, in southern Bolivia. A recent NI 43-101 Technical Report on Iska Iska, which was completed by Micon International Limited, is available on Eloro’s website and under its filings on SEDAR. Iska Iska is a road-accessible, royalty-free property. Eloro also owns an 82% interest in the La Victoria Gold/Silver Project, located in the North-Central Mineral Belt of Peru some 50 km south of Barrick’s Lagunas Norte Gold Mine and Pan American Silver’s La Arena Gold Mine.
For further information please contact either Thomas G. Larsen, Chairman and CEO or Jorge Estepa, Vice-President at (416) 868-9168.
Information in this news release may contain forward-looking information. Statements containing forward-looking information express, as at the date of this news release, the Company’s plans, estimates, forecasts, projections, expectations, or beliefs as to future events or results and are believed to be reasonable based on information currently available to the Company. There can be no assurance that forward-looking statements will prove to be accurate. Actual results and future events could differ materially from those anticipated in such statements. Readers should not place undue reliance on forward-looking information.
Neither the TSXV nor its Regulation Services Provider (as that term is defined in the policies of the TSXV) accepts responsibility for the adequacy or accuracy of this release.

source

Best Drum VST plugins for music producers in 2022 – We Rave You

 
 
The relation between the kick, bass, and drums is the most critical aspect of music production. In order to have a professional-sounding mix, you need to have a solid foundation carrying the whole track. Out there, are many great resources offering drums samples but the best ones are still coming from real drums. Below, you’ll find 8 of the best drum VST plugins, mostly recorded and sampled from real drum parts.
 
 
1. Toontrack Superior Drummer 3
Superior Drummer 3 can be seen as a whole software on its own. This massive library holds on to 230 GB of drum samples including 350+ drum sounds, categorized into 7 kits, 25 snares, 16 kicks, and 25 effects. All of these sounds are pre-processed and engineered by George Massenburg. Be the drummer yourself by playing around with your mouse and be the producer while arranging all of the different sounds.
 
2. Native Instruments Battery 4
NI’s Battery has been one of the most used digital drum machines for years. Its layout lets you load up to a total of 48 different samples at which you can change the length, starting point, tune, key, and movement of each sample. Furthermore, you can add different main effects to every sound including a volume envelope, pitch envelope, velocity, filter, compressor, and sends. You’ll also be able to add additional effects, modulation, an extended editor, and control the master output.
 
3. XLN Addictive Drums 2
Get your hands on professional-sounding drums, high-class effects, and live performances straight away while using this drum plugin. All of the drums are recorded in professional studios all around the world. Expect a massive range of drum kits, beats, and single drums compiled into 1 single vst plugin. Control the kick, snare, overhead, hihat, and room of your drums in order to mix your performance into your own track.
 
4. Native Instruments Studio Drummer
Studio Drummer brings more than sampled drums to the table. Select the right instruments for your kit and control the room mix, tune, attack, decay, and hold. Head over to the included grooves tab to access over 3300 authentic grooves and mix all of the instruments individually in the mixer tab. Over 3500 different drum samples are included, suitable for a broad range of different genres.
 
5. Heavyocity Damage
You’re at the right place if you’re seeking dramatic & industrial drum samples. Damage holds on to 30 GB of hard-hitting drums, particularly suitable for orchestral music and Trap. Get your hands on 200+ percussion samples and 500+ single shots, and heavy explosive FX. Heavyocity’s Damage can go from subtle organic to complete devastation. Use this plugin to add bite and color to the sound design of your next production.
 
6. Native Instruments DrumLab
Drum Lab is specialized in improving workflow for maximal output through its layout. Every instrument has its own space, in which you can control the mix (electronic/acoustic), tune, sub, room, filter, offset, trash, attack, hold, decay, and add a range of additional effects. Furthermore, you can choose a suitable groove and change its pattern, tightness, grid, swing, velocity, and tempo (:2, normal, x2).
 
7. Spitfire Hans Zimmer Drums
This ultimate orchestral percussion library is curated by non-other than the Oscar award-winning producer Hans Zimmer. Expect an impact of instruments ranging from softly to deafening loud. This plugin holds on to a range of instruments such as Taiko ensembles, Paper djun, Bombo ensembles, Surdo ensembles, Low booms, Gong drums, Timpani, Tamtam, Buckets, and so much more.
 
8. Spitfire originals drumline
Drumline’s samples are recorded in the Newman Stage, 20th Century Fox by Russell Emanuel. Included within are different ensembles, snare hits, tenor drum hits, bass drum hits, cymbals, rolls, swells, hairpins, 9 different presets, 5 controls, and multiple effects. This 1.5GB-sized library is packed with drums suitable for creating tension in your tracks or to use as a layer on top of your original drum section.
 
Next article: Toontrack Superior Drummer 3: Giant Drum Production Studio
Image Credits: Native Instruments
 
– DJ/Producer from the Netherlands. – Graduated from the Conservatory in Amsterdam. – Currently working as the technical writer at We Rave You
[email protected]

GET THE MAGAZINE!

We Rave You Ltd. All Rights Reserved © 2022

source

Mixing with MIDI vs. Audio: What's The Difference?

Tier Mobility-owned Spin lays off about 10% of workforce, exits two markets – TechCrunch

Spin, which was acquired by Tier Mobility earlier this year, has laid off about 10% of its staff — including a number of executives — and is exiting Canada and Seattle, TechCrunch has learned.
The micromobility company informed its workforce of more than 700 during a Friday all-hands meeting that lower-than-expected demand in the U.S. amid the waning pandemic, along with economic conditions such as rising inflation and a tightening VC funding environment, led to the decision.
About 78 people, the majority of whom are white-collar workers based in its San Francisco headquarters, have been laid off. The affected employees were notified prior to the meeting.
Staff was also told that it is exiting Kelowna, British Columbia, and Seattle, where it currently only operates e-bikes. Spin had operations in Edmonton, Red Deer and St. Albert, Canada, but never reactivated those cities after winter ended this year. Kelowna was its last remaining Canadian market.
Philip Reinckens, a Tier veteran who took the CEO spot in May, delivered the news to employees, according to sources who asked not to be named.
During the 20-minute meeting, Reinckens told workers that the company’s priorities are to preserve cash and achieve profitability. Notably, he said the entire micromobility industry was suffering from a perfect storm of events that included supply chain constraints, inflation, the war in Ukraine and a tight labor market. While the company has cut costs such as downsizing its San Francisco office and rolled out programs to encourage more ridership and raise its bottom line, the company still wasn’t able to capture the demand needed to make profit and loss figures work, he said, according to an audio recording of the event shared with TechCrunch.
Lucas Beard, Spin’s VP of growth and marketing, also confirmed the layoffs and the decision to leave Canada and Seattle.
“While it’s impossible for us to predict the future in such a new industry, what we can promise is that we’ll continue to be as transparent and thoughtful as possible as we continue to evaluate our financial performance and external market conditions,” Beard wrote in an email. He added that Spin is also centralizing some areas with parent company Tier.
The layoffs come about six months after Berlin-based micromobility operator Tier Mobility acquired Spin from automaker Ford. The acquisition marked Tier’s move into North America and came after an aggressive expansion in Europe that included buying e-scooter company Wind Mobility’s Italian subsidiary and bike-share startup Nextbike.
The Spin acquisition gave Tier a global footprint of more than 520 cities and communities in 21 countries. It also added to its costs and ultimately led Tier to restructure. In August, Tier laid off about 16% of its workforce, or 180 people, due to economic conditions and a tightening funding climate.
The VC firms once gladly forked over funds to shared micromobility startups even as costs piled up and questions loomed about whether shared scooters and e-bikes could ever be profitable enterprises.
In the past year, micromobility companies still reliant on external funding have found a less receptive VC community. Bird, Superpedestrian and Voi are a few that have laid off workers in 2022. The lack of demand in some markets — including ones that once were teeming with users before the COVID pandemic — has forced companies to restructure their businesses and seek ways to cut costs.
Micromobility is fun, but perhaps that’s all it’ll ever be

source

What are live direct marketing calls? – ICO

The UK’s independent authority set up to uphold information rights in the public interest, promoting openness by public bodies and data privacy for individuals.

Using live calls to speak to people about marketing messages is a very useful way to grow your business or gain support for your cause. However, many people find unsolicited live marketing calls intrusive or a nuisance.
It is important to know what the PECR rules are before you start your telephone marketing campaign so that you don’t breach PECR. Getting things wrong not only damages trust and confidence in you and your reputation, but in some cases the ICO can also fine you. See the section What happens if we do not comply with PECR when making live marketing calls? for further information.
This guidance supports and empowers you to use marketing by live calls to connect with your customers and supporters, while protecting people from unwanted intrusion and nuisance.
PECR do not use the terminology of ‘live’ calls. We commonly use the term ‘live’ call to distinguish this method of call from automated calls (ie those made by an automated dialling system that plays a recorded message). This is because these two methods of making direct marketing calls have different rules in PECR.
A live call is therefore a telephone call where a live person is speaking to the person they are calling.
Further reading
 
External link
PECR takes its definition of direct marketing from the Data Protection Act 2018 (DPA 2018). This is because any undefined term within PECR has the same meaning as in the UK data protection regime.
The DPA 2018 says that direct marketing means:
“the communication (by whatever means) of advertising or marketing material which is directed to particular individuals”
This definition is broad and covers all types of advertising, marketing or promotional material. It includes:
The definition covers any means of communication which includes marketing by live calls.
The definition doesn’t cover live calls made for administrative or customer service purposes. For example, calls to check that someone’s details are correct or to advise them of a problem with their account. These types of messages are often referred to as “service messages”. They don’t count as direct marketing if you use them purely for administrative purposes. This is because you aren’t advertising or marketing in these messages. However, if you include promotional content within your service call, then the call counts as direct marketing. For example, content aiming to get your customer to buy more products or increase their donations.
Likewise, live calls for genuine market research purposes don’t count as direct marketing. But if the call includes elements of promotional material or you collect details to send that person future marketing communications, then the call is direct marketing.
External link
External link
PECR covers any type of live marketing call. So it covers any live call that you make that is advertising, selling, promoting, fundraising or campaigning.
However, there are stricter rules on making some types of live marketing calls. See What are the rules on live direct marketing calls? for more information.
You don’t need to know the name of the person you are calling for PECR’s live marketing call rules to apply. This is because the rules aren’t limited to calls that involve using personal data.
The marketing rules in PECR protect “subscribers”. The subscriber is the customer who has a contract with the service provider – in other words, the person named on the bill for the telephone line or internet connection. There are two types of subscriber in PECR:
The PECR rules on live marketing calls apply to both types of subscriber. This means that businesses have the same protections as people.
External link
External link
 
Further reading
The UK’s independent authority set up to uphold information rights in the public interest, promoting openness by public bodies and data privacy for individuals.

source

Global Online Music Education Market to Reach $421.9 Million by 2027 – Astute Analytica – EIN News

Global Online Music Education Market to Reach $421.9 Million by 2027 – Astute Analytica  EIN News
source

Removery Turns 100th Studio Opening Into Fundraising For Florida – Valdosta Daily Times

Sunny skies. High 86F. Winds light and variable..
Clear skies. Low 51F. Winds light and variable.
Updated: October 6, 2022 @ 12:32 am

Laser tattoo removal company to support affected residents, and communities
FT. LAUDERDALE, Fla., Oct. 4, 2022 /PRNewswire/ — Removery is turning the celebration of its 100th location opening on Oct. 4 into a day of fundraising for Florida residents and communities affected by Hurricane Ian.
The milestone occasion will now be marked with five percent of sales on Oct. 4 going toward Volunteer Florida, the state’s lead agency for mobilizing volunteers and coordinating donations before, during and after disasters. Funds will aid Hurricane Ian relief efforts in honor of the 100th studio’s location at 721 N. Federal Highway in Ft. Lauderdale, FL.
“As our team members and clients from studios across Florida sought shelter, we knew we wanted to help them feel supported and safe,” said Tom Weber, CEO of Removery. “While we’re excited to open our 100th location as we continue to see demand for tattoo removal increase, our true success is in being able to use our international network of studios to do good and support our communities that need it most.”
Giving back is at Removery’s core with its INK-niative Program, which provides safe, effective and free tattoo removal on the hands, neck and face to those who were formerly incarcerated, gang members, survivors of human trafficking and those who wish to remove hate symbols or racist tattoos.
The clinically-driven world leader in tattoo removal services originally chose South Florida as the home of their milestone location to solidify their mission of helping people feel confident from the inside out.
“When you picture yourself on a beach near Miami, I think most people want to feel confident and strong in their own skin,” said Weber. “So it’s fitting that South Florida is the home of our 100th location, because Removery exists to help people feel their best, express their authentic selves, and normalize tattoo removal.”
Removery is the only tattoo removal brand with a Clinical Advisory Board that consists of leaders in the medical, dermatology, aesthetic, plastic surgery and laser industries. The Clinical Advisory Board created guidelines to ensure Removery’s laser technicians are highly trained and provide clients with a safe, effective and inclusive experience.
“Laser tattoo removal is helping your body break up and absorb tattoo ink over a span of months instead of the body’s natural process, which takes decades,” said Carmen Brodie, VP of Clinical Operations and Clinical Advisory Board member. “We studied what laser would provide our clients the safest and most efficient tattoo removal for a year and found that the picosecond laser was the obvious choice. Picosecond lasers break up tattoo ink into smaller particles than comparable lasers, making it easier for your body to erase unwanted ink.”
To date, Removery’s laser technicians have performed more than 600,000 laser tattoo removal treatments.
To participate in the fundraiser, schedule an in-person or virtual consultation for Oct. 4 or learn more at Removery.com.
Removery’s 100th Location
721 N. Federal Highway
Retail Bay #3
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33304
About Removery
Removery is the largest specialized provider of tattoo removal services in the world with more than 600,000 treatments completed and nearly 100 locations across the U.S., Australia and Canada. Its laser specialists are highly trained in Candela’s state-of-the-art PicoWay® lasers. Removery is clinically driven and the only tattoo removal brand with a Clinical Advisory Board that consists of leaders in the medical, dermatology, aesthetic, plastic surgery and laser industries. To learn more about Removery and tattoo removal, see before and after photos or schedule an in-person or virtual consultation, visit Removery.com.
Media Contact:
Jennifer Burkhardt, [email protected]
View original content to download multimedia: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/removery-turns-100th-studio-opening-into-fundraising-for-florida-301640857.html
SOURCE Removery
Copyright © 2022 PR Newswire Association LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Sorry, there are no recent results for popular commented articles.
Sign up now to get our FREE breaking news coverage delivered right to your inbox.
First Amendment: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

source

If you live in the 29403 zip code, Charleston needs your help – Live 5 News WCSC

CHARLESTON, S.C. (WCSC) – The city of Charleston is looking for feedback from people who live in the 29403 zip code on ways to improve their community.
The city’s Equitable Economic Mobility Initiative is designed to gain greater knowledge about what people in the city need as far as financial and economic resources.
Mindy Sturm, the director of the Mayor’s Office of Children, Youth and Families, says this is the first project with this level of engagement with residents. Sturm says she hopes her office can create more relationships with business owners, especially black-owned businesses.
She says the 29403 area lacks resident-level data, so now the city can learn more from a survey and focus groups.
“It’s great to always learn how residents want to get engaged,” Sturm said. “And so, hopefully, this will be an opportunity for us to gain knowledge about some ongoing methods that the city can utilize to really engage with residents so we have that two-way street of, you know, needs and people feeling as though there is a response to that need.”
Focus group times and locations for people that live in 29403:
Residents who live in 29403 can also take the digital survey by clicking this link.
Copyright 2022 WCSC. All rights reserved.

source

Billy Eichner says straight people 'just didn't show up for Bros' at the box office – Iowa Public Radio

Billy Eichner took to Twitter this weekend to share his thoughts on the disappointing reception his gay rom-com Bros received at the nation’s cinemas.
That’s just the world we live in, unfortunately. Even with glowing reviews, great Rotten Tomatoes scores, an A CinemaScore etc, straight people, especially in certain parts of the country, just didn’t show up for Bros. And that’s disappointing but it is what it is.
“Even with glowing reviews, great Rotten Tomatoes scores, an A CinemaScore etc,,” tweeted the film’s star, producer and co-writer, “straight people, especially in certain parts of the country, just didn’t show up for Bros. And that’s disappointing but it is what it is.”
Based on enthusiastic critical reaction at the Toronto International Film Festival, and robust social media attention, Universal Pictures had expected Bros – which is the first gay romantic comedy with a mostly LGBTQ cast to be given a wide release by a major studio — to open in the range of $8-10 million.
But playing in 3,350 locations this weekend, the film took in just $4.8 million, placing fourth at the box office after the horror film Smile, the second week of the thriller Don’t Worry Darling, and the third week of historical epic Woman King.
Although Bros was produced for a comparatively modest $22 million, Universal spent another $30 million on advertising and promotion, so the film will likely struggle to reach profitability.
Those who saw the comedy this weekend, made it clear they enjoyed it. Eichner tweeted of watching from “the back of a sold out theater playing BROS in LA. The audience howled with laughter start to finish, burst into applause at the end, and some were wiping away tears as they walked out.”
Indeed, with a 91% positive ranking from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, and 92% positive from audiences, Bros played well in big cities, with its best numbers coming from New York, Los Angeles and San Francisco. It did less well elsewhere though, especially in the South.
Eichner hinted at broader acceptance issues, tweeting that at one point a theater chain had “called Universal and said they were pulling the trailer because of the gay content. (Uni convinced them not to).”
“That’s just the world we live in, unfortunately,” the star continued, urging his followers to push past their disappointment and enjoy themselves.
“Everyone who ISN’T a homophobic weirdo should go see BROS tonight! You will have a blast! And it *is* special and uniquely powerful to see this particular story on a big screen, esp for queer folks who don’t get this opportunity often.”
Copyright 2022 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

source

Trump asks supreme court to intervene in Mar-a-Lago special master dispute – The Guardian US

Appellate court ruling prevented special master from examining 100 files seized from Mar-a-Lago with classification markings
Donald Trump on Tuesday asked the US supreme court to partially reverse an appellate court decision that prevented the special master, reviewing for privilege protections materials seized by the FBI from his Mar-a-Lago resort in August, from examining 100 documents with classification markings.
The motion to vacate the ruling by the US appeals court for the 11th circuit represents the former president’s final chance to reinsert the 100 documents into the special master review – and potentially exclude some from the investigation into whether he illegally retained national defense information
In the emergency request, Trump’s lawyers argued that the appellate court lacked jurisdiction to overrule the trial judge and decide that the justice department should regain access to the 100 documents and that the special master should be prohibited from examining them in the review.
The technical motion contended that although the 11th circuit was not wrong to allow the justice department to regain access to the 100 documents for its criminal investigation, it lacked jurisdiction to curtail the special master process.
The motion hinged on the doctrine of “pendent appellate jurisdiction”, which generally disfavors appeals for non-final, or interlocutory, decisions: it should not have intervened in the scope of the special master review since the trial judge’s order was procedural and not an injunction.
“That appointment order is simply not appealable on an interlocutory basis,” the filing said. “Nevertheless, the 11th circuit granted a stay of the special master order, effectively compromising the integrity of the well-established policy against piecemeal appellate review.”
In that sense, Trump’s motion was narrow, seeking only to have the special master be able review the 100 documents for potential privilege protections while leaving alone the 11th circuit decision to allow the justice department to use the materials for the criminal investigation.
Trump will face significant challenges even if the supreme court hears the case, even though the bench is dominated by six conservative justices – three of whom he appointed – who have previously shown deference to executive branch powers.
Just to meet the procedural criteria to vacate a lower court stay, legal experts said, Trump would have to show the supreme court that it needs to intervene because he is suffering irreparable harm – which his lawyers did not appear to address directly in the 37-page filing.
Lawyers for Trump also contended that the seized materials could be marked classified for national security purposes and simultaneously be personal documents – a position the justice department has previously said is impossible, with which the 11th circuit indicated it agreed.
The Trump motion was silent on whether Trump actually declassified any of the documents, as he has claimed publicly. It instead suggested the supreme court consider the case on the basis that Trump had the power to do so, and might have done so, without providing evidence.
The filing came two days into the new supreme court session, and after the justice department asked the 11th circuit to fast-track its own appeal against the appointment of a special master, arguing that the process was impeding the criminal investigation.
The justice department, aiming to capitalize on the decision Trump has now appealed, contended the special master should never have been appointed because the US district court judge, Aileen Cannon, misapplied a four-part test that allowed her to exercise jurisdiction.
In the ruling that stopped the 100 documents from being reviewed by the special master, the 11th circuit agreed with the justice department that Cannon was wrong on the first “Richey” test, regarding whether the government displayed “callous disregard” for Trump’s constitutional rights in seizing materials.
Cannon determined that Trump did not suffer callous disregard, and instead based her decision to grant a special master on the other tests. But the 11th circuit said Trump’s failure to satisfy the first callous-disregard standard alone was sufficient to dismiss his request.
“The absence of this ‘indispensa[ble]’ factor in the Richey analysis is reason enough to conclude that the district court abused its discretion in exercising equitable jurisdiction here,” ruled the three-judge panel on the 11th circuit that included two Trump appointees.
Though the appellate court was only narrowly deciding the question of whether the special master should examine the 100 documents in the review and whether the justice department could regain access to them, the government argued the reasoning suggested there should be no special master.

source

Testimony reveals disturbing details surrounding Cupcake McKinney's death – WLBT

BIRMINGHAM, Ala. (WBRC) – A jury was seated Monday in the first trial involving the death and disappearance of Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney. Patrick Stallworth will stand trial on two federal kidnapping charges. He also faces a state capital murder count.
Follow our coverage of the trial from start to finish in this story.
Day 3: Wednesday, October 5, 2022 – final update:
Some of the information in this update may be difficult to read or inappropriate for some audiences.
Wednesday was an emotionally challenging afternoon in court. The government called FBI Special Agent Stanley Ruffin, who recovered 3-year-old Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney’s body.
Ruffin was part of a large team assigned to search a landfill where trash was dumped from local apartments.
“Did you know it was a body right away?” asked Assistant United States Attorney and Criminal Chief Lloyd Peeples.
“I saw what I thought was a doll lying there,” Ruffin described. “For a moment everything slowed down, I closed my eyes and tried to make sure what I saw was real.”
Ruffin had trouble speaking as he recalled Cupcake’s body being put in a bag to be transported for an autopsy. At this point, she’d been missing for 10 days.
Due to the nature of the case and the burden of proof the government must meet, they had to show the jury very sensitive images of Cupcake in the landfill. Quickly, several jurors became emotional, wiping away tears. The court quickly timed the shots, holding them for no more than three seconds each, warning the jury in advance of a new picture so they were prepared.
As a seasoned 26-year veteran agent, Ruffin admitted he’d seen a lot of things, however, everyone involved in this recovery had to go through counseling.
“I was involved in 9/11 and thought it would be the worst thing I had experienced, but I had never experienced something like that with a child,” he stated.
Ruffin retired shortly after this assignment in Birmingham.
Dr. Daniel Dye, M.D., the forensic pathologist who performed Cupcake’s autopsy, testified next.
Dye explained the decomposition in this case posed a challenge to his work. He confirmed Cupcake had a contusion on her head, pointing toward the hairline area, with swelling on the side of the face that could be associated with blunt force trauma.
Dye ruled the cause of death in this case asphyxia, or suffocation, and agreed that injury could be associated with the head being pressed down against a hard object. This is consistent with a recorded statement Stallworth made to police, explaining his girlfriend Derick Brown killed Cupcake by putting her hand over the child’s nose and mouth until she couldn’t breathe.
The toxicology report also found methamphetamine and Trazadone in the child’s system, stating this also played a role in Cupcake’s death.
The government called Birmingham Police Sergeant Talana Brown, who was also involved in interviewing both Stallworth and Brown in the initial phases of the investigation.
The prosecution started by playing an interview with Stallworth’s co-defendant Derick Brown. In the interview, Brown insinuates Stallworth dumped Cupcake’s body in a dumpster. Talana Brown testified she passed along that tip FBI.
During cross-examination, Talana Brown testified that Derick Brown lied to police early in the investigation. The defense worked to shift the focus away from earlier testimony, which questioned whether Stallworth was forthcoming with authorities.
Defense attorney Derrick Collins showed the jury a video recording of one of Derick Brown’s interviews with police.
“I’ll lie on him if y’all want me to,” Brown told police, referencing Stallworth. “I’m not going to jail for anybody… what do y’all want me to say?”
FBI Cellular Analyst Blake Downing was called as the last witness of the day. Downing was tasked with tracking Stallworth’s cell phone during the investigation. He testified about the technology used to determine Stallworth’s location through the phone signal.
The government and the defense are expected to rest on Thursday. The jury could begin deliberations Friday morning.
Day 3: Wednesday, October 5, 2022 – 12 p.m. update:
Some of the information in this update may be difficult to read or inappropriate for some audiences.
On Wednesday morning, prosecutors began to peel back the layers of the investigation into Kamille “Cupcake” McKinney’s disappearance and death, and how Patrick Stallworth and Derick Brown were developed as suspects in the case.
The first witness of the day: Birmingham Police Detective Jonathan Ross, who oversaw the investigation and massive search effort.
The prosecution spent more than an hour playing video and audio recordings from Stallworth’s interviews with police.
The jury first saw a portion of Stallworth’s initial recorded interview with police on Oct. 13, 2019. During that meeting, Stallworth said he was at Tom Brown Village, which correlated with the same day and time of Cupcake’s disappearance. Stallworth stated he walked around the area and saw children playing with a mouse, consistent with the video the jury saw on Tuesday, which showed a man approaching two toddlers at Tom Brown Village.
The second recording took jurors back to the interview room at BPD the day Cupcake’s body was recovered. Stallworth requested to speak to Ross.
Jurors attentively read the transcript off the screen as the lengthy audio recording played from that interview. During this meeting, Stallworth told police Brown brought a baby home and killed her.
Stallworth told officers he woke up and saw a baby on the couch next to Brown and didn’t know how the child made it to his house.
“I told her you need to go, you need to get this baby out of here,” Stallworth told police. “I said, this ain’t your baby.”
Stallworth said he went back to sleep and when he woke up the baby was gone.
“I asked her where it was, and she said she took it back,” Stallworth stated. “She kept trying to talk about the baby and how she wanted to keep the baby.”
He revealed to police that Brown wanted him to “do some things to the child,” referencing inappropriately touching the toddler.
An investigator asked Stallworth whether forensic examiners would find his DNA during Cupcake’s autopsy.
“She killed her,” sobbed Stallworth. “I tried to keep her from choking that baby.”
Police asked them to show how she choked the baby and he held up his hand over his nose and mouth, according to the recording.
Assistant United States Attorney Blake Milner paused the recording asked Ross clarify the general crux of their conversation.
“He watched Derick Brown put his hands over her nose and mouth and kill Cupcake, and then took out the trash?” Milner questioned.
Ross responded, “That’s correct.”
Defense attorney Derrick Collins cross-examined Ross, asking the detective to confirm the statements Stallworth made to police that were true. Ross agreed Stallworth told the truth about being in Tom Brown Village and stopping at various service stations.
The court recessed at noon, testimony will resume at 1 p.m.
While the witnesses haven’t moved as quickly as expected, the government still believes it will rest Thursday.
Day 2: Tuesday, October 4, 2022 – final update:
Prosecutors spent the remainder of the day two calling witnesses and introducing evidence that would put Patrick Stallworth at Tom Brown Village around the time Cupcake went missing.
The government used surveillance video to reconstruct a timeline of Stallworth’s day which started around noon. An initial video shows Stallworth purchasing candy at a service station, other video later that afternoon showed what appears to be the Toyota Sequoia registered to Stallworth’s co-defendant Derick Brown stop and speak to some girls walking near Hayes K-8 school.
A 14-year-old girl who attended athletic practice at Hayes testified that she and her friend were stopped by a man and woman in the Toyota as they walked home. Her testimony revealed the man, who’s suspected to be Stallworth, asked her if she’d seen someone they were looking for, then asked her if she wanted any candy. The teen said that’s when her friend spoke up.
“She told me to run,” the student said. “We ran down the alley in the projects.”
When asked if she could pick that man out in the courtroom, there was strong hesitation. Stallworth looks noticeably different from his mugshot taken in 2019.
A grainy piece of video from a neighbor’s surveillance camera showed a man approach two toddler-aged children playing in a field. The FBI Agent Jonathan Spaeth testified the time of the video correlates with the timeframe Cupcake was reported missing.
Defense attorney Derrick Collins cross-examined the Spaeth asking whether he could prove that was Stallworth on the video.
“It’s consistent with a person like Stallworth,” Spaeth replied.
Collins pressed Spaeth, questioning whether he could prove that was Cupcake.
“This was right near Cupcake’s house [where she was that night], this toddler is wearing shorts, I know she was wearing shorts.” Other evidence, including statements Stallworth made to police pointed to him being at Tom Brown Village that evening. According to video from one of his interviews with Birmingham Police, he and Brown were in Tom Brown Village searching for the father of Brown’s children.
The final video showed the Toyota Sequoia pull up to another service station after the time Cupcake was reported missing. Brown is seen exiting the passenger door and walking inside the business, which is consistent with testimony that Stallworth was driving that night.
FBI Agent Kyle King testified that he was part of the group that served a search warrant at Stallworth’s apartment on October 18, 2019, days after the disappearance. At this time, search efforts to locate Cupcake were still underway. The prosecution filed through pictures of the apartment as the FBI found it, showing a picture of a mattress with a plastic cover with a noticeable a red stain. The cover appeared to be consistent with the plastic material that often covers new mattresses.
Today the jury was able to see that plastic cover in person. Two FBI agents opened the evidence packaging and unfolded it in front of the jury. During opening statements, the prosecution said an expert witness would testify that both defendants DNA and Cupcake’s DNA were found on a plastic mattress cover inside Stallworth’s apartment.
The government called nearly a dozen witnesses Tuesday. They’re expected to have at least one more day full day of testimony before resting their case. The trial resumes Wednesday morning.
Day 2: Tuesday, October 4, 2022 – 12 p.m. update:
The government took jurors to the home where Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney was kidnapped to begin day two of the trial.
Shenita Long lived in Tom Brown Village in Avondale where McKinney and her family visited on Oct. 12, 2019.
Long testified McKinney and her daughter Ava were best friends. When McKinney and her family arrived, Long said Ava and McKinney ran to play at a birthday party outside her apartment.
When it was time for McKinney and her family to leave, Long said McKinney’s older brother ran inside and said he couldn’t find her.
Long said her daughter looked startled.
“I asked Ava – where was Cupcake,” Long testified. “She said ‘Cupcake got in the car with that man, he took her to get candy at the store.’”
The defense worked to keep this testimony off the record, arguing the validity of a statement made by a child, which was overruled.
Long recounted everyone feverishly began searching for McKinney, going door to door while others searched local service stations.
“People started searching and we found her shoes in the backyard, that’s when we knew she was really missing,” Long recalled.
Less than an hour later, Long called 911 to report McKinney’s disappearance.
Body camera video from the responding officer showed Long, McKinney’s mother, April Thomas, and several children outside searching for McKinney. The children gave the officer a vehicle description: a blue Toyota with a brown bumper. Evidence showed the vehicle registered to Derick Brown, Stallworth’s girlfriend and co-defendant, was a blue Toyota Sequoia with gold trim.
The government also called the FBI Case Agent Eric Salvador, who recounted the initial days of the investigation and how the agency developed its case.
Assistant United States Attorney Lloyd Peeples used Salvador’s testimony to introduce various surveillance videos he collected during the investigation. The videos reconstructed Stallworth and Brown’s movements throughout the day McKinney was kidnapped. One of the videos shows Stallworth purchasing candy around noon at a service station, which parallels to testimony McKinney was lured away with candy. Another video showed the defendants stopping at a service station in the blue Toyota SUV later that day. Brown was seen exiting the passenger door and walked inside the store. The court recessed for lunch after noon; testimony will resume after 1 p.m.
Day 1: Monday, October 3, 2022 – 8 p.m. update:
A sixteen person jury was seated in Patrick Stallworth’s federal kidnapping trial Monday. It took attorneys roughly five hours to strike a jury in the high-profile case. The jury composition: thirteen women and three men. Stallworth elected not to move the trial to a different division which would pull jurors from outside Jefferson County.
Attorneys spent only an hour with the jury late Monday outlining what they can expect to see during the trial.
During opening statements, Assistant United States Attorney Lloyd Peeples, Criminal Division Chief, promised jurors the government would present evidence that linked Stallworth with McKinney’s disappearance and death.
“I will warn you that some of this evidence will not be easy to see or hear, but in order to bring justice we are going to ask that you do exactly that,” Peeples explained.
The evidence previewed by the government included phone records, DNA evidence from Stallworth’s apartment, DNA evidence from McKinney’s autopsy and recordings from Stallworth’s five meetings with law enforcement.
Peeples alleged Stallworth’s statements to law enforcement shifted over the course of the investigation.
“Shortly after Kamille’s body was recovered, the defendant admits to knowing things that only Cupcake’s kidnapper would know,” stated Peeples.
Peeples pointed to new evidence, a text message Stallworth sent from the Jefferson County Jail.
“A text message sent ten days after Kamille’s body was found, a message that said, “I’m sorry I did this. It was an accident, that poor baby’s family”,” Peeples quoted to the jury.
Defense Attorney Derrick Collins quickly told the jury there’s only one fact established in this case right.
“The only fact is that Mr. Stallworth is an innocent man,” Collins explained to the jury.
Collins said Stallworth wasn’t involved in the crime and went as far to say the government doesn’t have the evidence to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.
“I can tell you who did it,” Collins said of McKinney’s kidnapping. “She’s the author behind all of this – Derick Brown.”
Brown is Stallworth’s co-defendant and girlfriend. Collins shifted the blame to Brown, stating she couldn’t handle losing custody of her children, which prompted McKinney’s kidnapping.
“Evidence will show my client didn’t know [Brown] kidnapped Cupcake,” Collins told the jury.
The government called McKinney’s mother, April Thomas, as their first witness.
Thomas described October 12, 2019 to the jury; the day of McKinney’s disappearance and the last time she saw her daughter alive. Thomas and her children were visiting a family member’s house in Tom Brown Village where Cupcake often played with her cousins. As the sun began to set, Thomas asked her son to go tell Cupcake it’s time to go home.
“He was panicked, he came in and said he couldn’t find her,” Thomas recalled. “I looked and couldn’t find her – all I found were her shoes. I was sick to my stomach.”
Thomas was the first and final witness of the day. The government expects to call upwards of twenty witnesses over the course of the trial. Testimony resumes Tuesday morning.
“All that was left behind were here shoes, for her mother to find… Her body was found mixed in with trash, discarded, and left for more then ten days.” – Prosecutor Lloyd Peeples

Prosecutors say Meth Amphetamine was found in Cupcake’s body
—
Day 1: Monday, October 3, 2022 – 8 a.m. preview:
One of the defendants accused in the disappearance and death of three-year old Kamille ‘Cupcake’ McKinney will stand trial this week on federal kidnapping counts.
Prosecutors allege Patrick Stallworth and Derick Brown used candy to lure McKinney away from a birthday party in Tom Brown Village in October 2019. Following an extensive city-wide search, McKinney’s body was recovered in a dumpster a week later. Forensic evidence indicated McKinney likely fought for her life; testimony revealed Stallworth’s DNA was found under McKinney’s fingernails. During a state court hearing, investigators also testified DNA evidence from McKinney, Stallworth and Brown was found on a plastic bed cover in the couple’s apartment. Both face federal kidnapping charges and capital murder.
A jury is expected to be seated in Stallworth’s federal kidnapping trial on Monday October 3. In previous hearings, Chief Judge Scott Coogler anticipated opening statements would begin Monday afternoon with jury deliberations slated for later in the week. It’s unclear how many witnesses will be called. Stallworth elected not to move the trial to Tuscaloosa, which summons potential jurors from Tuscaloosa and Walker Counties. The Department of Justice elected not to seek the death penalty in this case.
Leading up to trial, both Stallworth and Brown’s defense argued to suppress statements they independently made to police in the initial phases of the investigation. Stallworth’s motion was denied, a ruling hasn’t been entered in Brown’s case. Brown’s kidnapping trial is scheduled for November in Tuscaloosa, Brown’s change of venue request was granted earlier this year. After the federal cases are adjudicated, both are scheduled to stand trial on state capital murder counts. If found guilty, they could face the death penalty.
Get news alerts in the Apple App Store and Google Play Store or subscribe to our email newsletter here.
Copyright 2022 WBRC. All rights reserved.

source

Collaboration is key for Highnote and Beatmaker launches – Music Ally





The digital marketing guide: expert insight, case studies, fresh approaches, and overlooked opportunities.
The latest and best jobs in the global music industry
Brief, deep analysis of essential music business stuff: every week, in about 20 mins.
Essential international guides, packed with data, interviews, strategies, and local insight.
Twice-monthly reports on the newest platforms – to help you find a competitive edge.
Music Ally Ltd., Holborn Studios,
49-50 Eagle Wharf Rd, London, N1 7ED,
United Kingdom
Music Ally is a Registered Learning Provider 10029483

source

Security forces audio recordings allowed as evidence in trial involving Colin Duffy – The Irish News

Recordings from covert listening devices have been allowed as evidence in a long-running terror trial in Belfast.
However a portion of voice recognition evidence which attributes the recordings to three suspects has been excluded in the trial, which has been running for almost a decade.
Colin Duffy, of Forest Glade in Lurgan, Henry Fitzsimons of Dunmore Mews, Belfast, and Alex McCrory of Sliabh Dubh View in Belfast, are charged with directing terrorism and membership of an illegal organisation, namely the IRA.
Fitzsimons and McCrory are also charged with attempting to murder police officers in a gun attack on the Crumlin Road in north Belfast on December 5, 2013, and with possessing two firearms and ammunition used in the attack.
They have denied the charges.
The trio were granted bail in 2016 after spending more than two years on remand.
 
 
The key evidence being used by the prosecution is a quantity of audio which was recorded by the security forces from listening devices planted at various points in Demesne Park in Lurgan, Co Armagh.
The devices picked up a conversation which the prosecution contends was an incriminating discussion between the three defendants.
The prosecution argues the recordings show Fitzsimons and McCrory were “intimately involved” in the Crumlin Road gun attack and that they knew of it, approved it and, in effect, signed off on it before it took place.
 
 
However, the authenticity of this audio, voice recognition evidence and CCTV evidence has been challenged during the case, which is being heard in a Diplock non-jury trial.
Today, Mr Justice O’Hara gave his ruling on a voir dire application brought by the defence.
He said the vast majority of evidence in the case has been called, and it is his task to rule whether any evidence should be excluded on the basis of fairness.
Mr Justice O’Hara said scrutiny has “revealed inconsistencies in the prosecution evidence”.
He went on to say he has “misgivings about the way in which the prosecution evidence was given”, particularly by a number of security forces witnesses, who he said “appeared to have been trained to be vague and unforthcoming in certain respects”.
“But having said that, in light of all of the evidence, the authenticity of the recordings cannot reasonably or sensibly be doubted,” he said, pointing to expert evidence that manipulation of the recordings “would be unachievable”.
Mr Justice O’Hara also ruled that evidence attributing voice recordings to the three suspects is not admissible, but allowed CCTV evidence.
Another hearing is to be held before October 14 to review the future running of the case.
Get the day’s headlines delivered directly to your inbox

source

Features | A Quietus Interview | The Goyt Method: An Interview With The Orielles – The Quietus

As they prepare to release their ambitious third album Tableau, The Orielles speak to Fergal Kinney about how Greater Manchester’s underground culture, putting faith in a first-time producer, and cooking each other’s tea inspired a major creative leap forward
Photos by Neelam Vela
The Goyt Valley is a blustery, tree-lined moorland around the river Goyt, located just outside Buxton on the border between Cheshire and Derbyshire. Textile mills, long emptied, give way to the wide-open valley which is reputed to be haunted by the ghost of a woman whose husband drowned in the river. She passes out the centuries wailing for her lover’s unlikely return. The Goyt Valley also lends its name to what The Orielles term The Goyt Method. The process would unlock and become central to the creation of Tableau, the band’s third album and first double record.
“We were at a studio in Goyt Mill,” remembers drummer Sidonie Hand-Halford, sat outside an East London pub. “We were doing some remixing, and we realised that having all of these stems, it was like having access to all of these paints. A huge colour palette. You could do that with anything, we realised, and the outcome could be millions of variations.” What, they wondered, if they were to apply that process not just to a remix but to their own work? In-between albums at the time, the band knew that this lightbulb moment would dictate where things would go next.
“We discovered how many avenues were open to us,” agrees vocalist Esmé Hand-Halford, “by taking an acoustic sound, and throwing it through a load of electronic plugins, and really effective randomisation methods, we could make it sound really different to the original source.” The album became governed by the band’s internal shorthand – to Goyt it.
The Orielles formed in the West Yorkshire market town of Halifax over a decade ago when they were in their teens, and gained a foothold as part of the indie and DIY scene around Manchester and Salford, where the band all live today. In 2017, they signed to Heavenly Recordings. Their second single for the label, the slippery nine-minute prog track ‘Sugar Tastes Like Salt’, would be early evidence of a band with far more exploratory impulses than they may have been given credit (the track was also subject to a terrific, dubbed out remix by Andrew Weatherall.) Where 2018’s Silver Dollar Moment was an assured debut of lo-fi indie pop, 2020’s superior Disco Volador would convincingly fuse the spectral pop of Stereolab and Broadcast with the tight avant-funk of A Certain Ratio (whose Jez Kerr was an important early mentor to the group.) When lockdown hit, the band even directed and scored their own art film, La Vita Olistica. None of this, though, would particularly anticipate the sounds heard across Tableau. Though seldom in thrall to influences or especially referential, the double album at points evokes Burial, Sonic Youth, FKA Twigs, Yo La Tengo, free jazz and the last two Radiohead records.
What happened? “In the past,” explains Esmé, “we’d resigned ourselves to the idea that it wasn’t possible to make something that sounds like it’s from the present or the future.” All in their early to mid twenties, for the first time the band found themselves all listening to far more contemporary music than sounds from the past. “Revisiting our processes means that what we were discussing was exactly the present and the future, we found our own view of what stuff should sound like now.”
The vibrant new music culture around Greater Manchester helped too. “All Night Flights in Stockport is such a well curated shop,” enthuses Sidonie, “also, things like going to White Hotel nights together, enjoying the music so much that the following day, you’re seeking out what they’re playing and chatting about it, all very nerdy.”
“It was how we were listening to music too,” says Henry Carlyle-Wade, the band’s guitarist. The oblique, downer sounds that have so far typified electronic music in the early 21st century became part of The Orielles’ language. “A lot of modern stuff is dark and introspective. It came from electronic DJs, people who do all of their work in the computer, we’re very interested in what they can do.”
The band knew that their new methodology could create something that, for the first time in their careers, would look the present moment firmly in the eye. How to get there? First, record as much as possible in adherence to The Goyt Method. Second, there would be no demoing of material (two album cycles had led the band to be suspicious of albums that ended up as “posh demos”). Third, the band would self-produce in collaboration with friend and relatively unknown North West producer Joel Anthony Patchett (who engineered on the first two Orielles records.) “Because we’ve got our communications and angle, he’s one of the only people that’s musically connecting with us,” explains Esmé. Though the record is Patchett’s first production credit, the band speak of him as an equal collaborator on the record and central to its scope and ambition.

“Imagine trying to achieve what we did with someone who we met for the first time on the first day in the studio?” says Henry, shaking his head, “it would be nearly impossible. We didn’t want someone who would think we were pissing around for hours. How can you explore the possibilities if someone thinks they know better? We don’t know, and that’s the best part of it.”
Esmé points to The Beatles’ Get Back as an example of good studio practices. “It wasn’t a reference point while we were writing, but they write it all on the spot together. That’s really what music should be. It isn’t making demos for a record label, who then throw a few grand at it. The time spent in the studio should be the time spent experimenting.”
“We decided not to overwrite anything either,” furthers Henry, “not really any structural things, and just see what would happen when we played these songs as they were being recorded. Because we had unfinished songs it forced us into a corner of being completely creative. We felt free. Maybe other people might have felt pressure but that wasn’t the case for us.”
Having convinced their record label, the band and Patchett devised two residential studio stays in Eastbourne and the Midlands town of Alcester. The decision to work in a residential stay was as much culinary as it was sonic. “Cooking together helps break down the barriers,” enthuses Esmé. “Showing people new ideas musically is easier if you’re also cooking them a breakfast or if they’re going to cook you a tea. On a rookie level, if you’ve got the same things in your gut, the outcome is going to be more in sync.” It also afforded the band the opportunity to work at their own schedule. “You get the ick sometimes if you work for too long,” explains Henry, “and we got the ick. From a sonic and spiritual perspective, too, we needed the high ceilings. It puts us in a better place to be able to explore that emotional palette.”
For the band, the high point of the sessions was Patchett bringing in the Northern Session Collective, the innovative string section led by Lancashire violinist Isabella Baker. In line with the album’s rigid commitment to chance, the band did not want to hear the scores that Patchett had written until the recording itself.
“We’d just planned to have strings on these four or five songs,” explains Sidonie, “but at the last minute we had an hour or so left. We had the song ‘Improvisation 001’, in which we all improvise, and it was a one take thing for us. We asked them to do the same, just improvise. We said we weren’t going to judge, just listen to it and react. And they did.”
Improvisation and chance would become central to Tableau, and The Orielles cultivated processes beyond simply jamming. They embraced automatic lyric writing, use of Brian Eno and Peter Schmidt’s Oblique Strategies cards, and Sidonie developing an interest in US jazz trumpeter Wadada Leo Smith’s concept of graphic scoring of music – the abstract, conceptual notation method that utilises the interplay of shapes and colour.
“I like the element of randomness, working within the bounds of what you’re given,” explains Henry, “we came to remix the album recently, and we had all these stems, all the songs, all these endless, endless possibilities. We put everything into online Wheel Of Fortune style spinners, so it was completely random, and the machine decided we’d take a drum track from here, a synth track from there.”
“It harkens back to early ideas of cybernetics in the 1960s, that computer technology could decide the elements,” ,” says Sidonie, “Look at the DALL-E AI art simulator. Just handing it to a robot to decide how we use it.”
For The Orielles, part of what has enabled them to develop their current work is what happens if you don’t become a hype band. “We discuss trends a lot, between the three of us, whether it’s fashion or film or music,” explains Henry, “British music moves so fast, these cycles and trends and trying to predict the future. It means you can see stuff for what it is, which is a trend no more than Crocs being back in right now. If you can identify substance, then you can reject everything that you just see through.” The three-piece would discuss their favourite acts – Sonic Youth, The Pastels, Yo La Tengo – and observe how those acts had found longevity.

Esmé introduced the group to the concept of the Lindy Effect, the idea that the longer a non-perishable item or idea has been around, the longer it’s likely to persist into the future. Introduced in a 1964 New Republican article by the writer Albert Goldman, the concept initially referred to Lindy’s Delicatessen on Broadway, where comedians would gather and talk shop, and the concept developed when discussing the impermanence of comedians who would oversaturate themselves early on in their career. Mathematicians like Nassim Taleb and Benoit Mandelbrot would take the idea from an anecdotal one to a mathematical formulation.
“There’s certain Lindy approaches to music,” Esmé argues, “it’s rejecting the idea of being a hype band. It might be really enjoyable for a year, but what about its lifespan?” It helped, too, that the band were at a formative age when they encountered the fevered egos of the hype artist in clubs and festival backstage areas across the UK. “You speak to those bands now, without naming any names,” says Sidonie, “and there’s something not even creative about them, they hate it now.”
For the future, the band are simply looking forward to taking Tableau out to two live shows – at Manchester’s Stoller Hall and Hackney’s EartH – where they will perform the record in full with the Northern Session Collective. When I speak to the band, they are in the thick of rehearsals for these shows. “You fall back in love with certain songs and out of love with others, the cycle does keep changing,” explains Esmé, “and then going forward next year, we’ve got certain songs that we’ve not played out as much and we’re definitely going to focus on, other ones will be put back for a bit. We’re constantly reinventing how our live sound is.”
“We’ve always loved the live sound being a completely different entity to the album anyway,” says Sidonie, “who is to say we can’t Goyt the whole thing for a live set?”
The Orielles’ Tableau is released on October 7 via Heavenly Recordings
Share this article: Post to Facebook Post to Twitter add to del.icio.us Digg it Stumble It! Post to Reddit
If you love what we do, you can help tQ to continue bringing you the best in cultural criticism and new music by joining one of our subscription tiers. As well as the unparalleled joy of keeping the publication alive, you’ll receive benefits including exclusive editorial, podcasts, and specially-commissioned music by some of our favourite artists. To find out more, click here.
Support tQ’s work by becoming a subscriber and enjoy the benefits of bonus essays, podcasts and exclusively-commissioned new music. To find out more, click here.
As a wholly independent publication, we rely entirely on our ad bookings to keep The Quietus going. Please whitelist our site in order to continue to access The Quietus.

source

Intraspecies characterization of bacteria via evolutionary modeling of protein domains | Scientific Reports – Nature.com

Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports volume 12, Article number: 16595 (2022)
Metrics details
The ability to detect and characterize bacteria within a biological sample is crucial for the monitoring of infections and epidemics, as well as for the study of human health and its relationship with commensal microorganisms. To this aim, a commonly used technique is the 16S rRNA gene targeted sequencing. PCR-amplified 16S sequences derived from the sample of interest are usually clustered into the so-called Operational Taxonomic Units (OTUs) based on pairwise similarities. Then, representative OTU sequences are compared with reference (human-made) databases to derive their phylogeny and taxonomic classification. Here, we propose a new reference-free approach to define the phylogenetic distance between bacteria based on protein domains, which are the evolving units of proteins. We extract the protein domain profiles of 3368 bacterial genomes and we use an ecological approach to model their Relative Species Abundance distribution. Based on the model parameters, we then derive a new measurement of phylogenetic distance. Finally, we show that such model-based distance is capable of detecting differences between bacteria in cases in which the 16S rRNA-based method fails, providing a possibly complementary approach , which is particularly promising for the analysis of bacterial populations measured by shotgun sequencing.
The accurate identification and classification of bacteria is essential for epidemiological surveillance, as well as for the study and understanding of specific ecosystems such as the human microbiome. Bacterial classification, however, is a complex problem, especially at the intraspecies level. Commonly used methods include the reconstruction of phylogenetic trees based on the comparison of specific molecular sequences (e.g. 16S rRNA gene) with reference databases, which contain annotated sequences of previously classified bacteria . This allows to generate the so-called taxonomic classification of the sampled bacteria.
The basic unit of classification in taxonomy is usually the species level. While such resolution may be sufficient for other domains of life, the intraspecies level of bacteria includes high amounts of genomic and phenot ypic variation, through which strains of bacteria belonging to the same species manifest highly different behaviours1. For instance, different strains can infect different hosts2,3,4, or even more extremely, some bacterial species can have both pathogenic and non-pathogenic isolates1,5. The 16S rRNA gene is commonly used for bacterial classification since random mutations of the 16S rRNA gene sequence serve as a proxy of evolutionary time6. However, bacterial classification based on 16S rRNA gene has low phylogenetic power at the intraspecies level, where functional diversification of strains is faster than random mutations of the 16S rRNA gene6. Various alternative approaches to estimate the bacterial phylogeny have hence been proposed7,8,9. Such methods mainly start from specific bacterial molecular sequences and either compute a distance matrix or model the substitution process through which the molecular sequences have evolved. In both cases, the appropriate choice of the specific molecular sequences to be investigated is crucial. The chosen sequences have to satisfy two conditions for the phylogenetic reconstruction to be successful: orthologs of sequences have to be shared by the tested bacteria and they have to contain a vertical phylogenetic signal. Approaches that use a single molecular sequence, such as 16S rRNA, may work well at higher taxonomic levels, but they are usually too generic to differentiate species or strains. A popular method which overcomes this problem while still controlling the phylogenetic noise is multilocus sequence analysis (MLSA)10,11, which simultaneously uses sequences of seven housekeeping genes. However, phylogenetic signals are not equally distributed across the genome and, while some classes of genes are expected to perform better for phylogenetic inference than others12, the choice of the specific set of genes to be used is still a matter of debate.
Here, we develop a new measurement of evolutionary distance derived from the ecological modeling of the protein domains that populate the bacterial genome and we propose to exploit such distance to deepen the characterization of bacteria at the intraspecies level. Our method does not rely on the selection of a specific set of genes or molecular sequences, but is based on the ecological modelling of the whole set of protein domains within the bacterial genome. Protein domains are segments of proteins and are defined as substructures produced by any contiguous part of a polypeptide chain that can fold independently of the rest of the protein into a compact and stable structure13,14. Studies on the conformation, function and evolution of proteins suggest to consider the protein as a molecule composed of a set of independent protein domains, which constitute its organizational units, so as its evolutionary components. The evolution of living organisms, or rather, the proteome evolution, is caused by the occurrence of random modifications of the genetic code and these events affect each protein domain independently. Protein domain duplication, mutation, recombination, relocation and horizontal transfer are in fact the main mechanisms that allow the outbreak of proteins with new functionalities, thereby contributing to the emergence of complexity15,16,17. As a matter of fact, the relationship between protein domain evolution and phylogeny has already been investigated in previous works, with findings suggesting a connection between the two. On the one hand the phylogeny of hundreds of organisms (including more than 100 bacteria) has been reconstructed satisfactorily (i.e., in good agreement with the classical taxonomy) based on the presence or absence of protein domain superfamilies18, or based on specific patterns of protein domains19. On the other hand the evolutionary origin and history of protein domains has been reconstructed based on the taxonomic tree of organisms20.
Taking an ecological approach, we here focus on the dynamic processes that led to the current configuration of protein domains, assuming that this could highlight important aspects of the evolution of genomes, proteins, and organisms. The proposed phylogeny will then be based on the evolutionary model of protein domains, incorporating the parameters estimated from such model.
In the past, various models of evolution have been proposed for protein domains, each linked to a particular distribution of the protein domains frequencies. This distribution is what in ecology is called Relative Species Abundance distribution (RSA). It is a measure of the biodiversity of an ecosystem, in our case the set of protein domain families that populate the genome, and can be used to fit real data in order to verify the validity of the underlying ecological hypothesis. Among the proposed ecological models for protein domains, the birth-death-innovation one stands out. The RSA distribution predicted by this model is a Pareto distribution and it fits the RSA of a wide range of genome-associated quantities well, including protein domains21,22.
Here, we consider a generalization of the birth-death-innovation model21 in which both demographic and environmental noise are added to the model. Environmental stochasticity is due to environmental changes which act simultaneously on all individuals while demographic stochasticity reflects the reproduction differences among individuals within a population. A suitable generalized model was developed by S. Engen and R. Lande in 199623,24, who proposed that the RSA distribution could be a Poisson Log-Normal or a Negative Binomial, depending on the assumptions.
Following Engen and Lande’s derivation23,24, we make the neutral ecological equivalence assumption that the evolutionary dynamics is the same for all the protein domain families. In this way, we will not need to introduce protein domain family-specific indices for the evolutionary rates in the following equations25. As in Engen and Lande’s papers, we also assume that protein domain families enter the protein domain community (i.e. the genome) at times generated by an inhomogeneous Poisson process (see Supplementary Material or, for more details, Karlin and Taylor textbooks26,27) with rate (omega (t)) and that they evolve independently of each other. Denoting the present time as (t=0), speciations (i.e. arrivals of new protein domain families in the genome) up to now have then occurred at negative times, generated by (omega (t)). Let the distribution of the abundance X(t) at time (t=0) of a protein domain family entering the genome at time (-t < 0) be f(x; t) and let p(t) be the probability that it has not gone extinct. Then, Engen and Lande showed that the abundances x of the protein domain families in the community are generated by an inhomogeneous Poisson process with rate
Now, we let the process for each protein domain family be a diffusion process (see Supplementary Material) which is a solution of the stochastic growth equation
where x still indicates the number of individuals within a protein domain family (i.e., its abundance), r is the constant growth rate ((r = b-d), where b is the birth rate and d is the death rate), g(x) is a density regulation function, (sigma ^2_r = sigma _e^2 + sigma _d^2/x) is the sum of the environmental ((sigma _e^2)) and demographic ((sigma _d^2/x)) stochasticities, and the process B(t) is a standard Brownian motion, so that (frac{dB(t)}{dt}) is the so-called white noise. It can be shown (see Supplementary Material) that the diffusion process which solves the stochastic differential Eq. (2) has infinitesimal mean (m(x) = [r+sigma ^2_d/(2x)+sigma ^2_e/2]x – xg(x)) which can be rewritten as (m(x)=[r-g(x)]x + (1/2)sigma ^2_d + (1/2)sigma ^2_ex). The noise term hence turns out to be composed by a multiplicative part (i.e., the environmental noise, which acts on the whole population of family domains), and an additive one (i.e., the demographic noise, which acts on individuals within the population and whose effect is thus stronger in smaller populations).
If protein domain families evolve independently from each other, then Engen and Lande showed that their abundances are generated by an inhomogeneous Poisson process with rate (lambda (x)) (see Supplementary Material). Specifically, depending on which assumptions are made on the model parameters, the predicted RSA distribution could be a Poisson Log-Normal, a Negative Binomial, or a Log-Series distribution.
Engen and Lande showed that if we consider the Gompertzian density regulation function23,28 (g(x)=gamma ln (x+epsilon )) , where (gamma) is a constant and (epsilon =sigma _d^2/sigma _e^2), then
where (omega _0) is the speciation parameter and (alpha = frac{2}{sigma _e^2}e^{frac{gamma }{sigma _e^2}left[ ln(1+epsilon ) -frac{r}{gamma } right] ^2}). When (epsilon ll x), (lambda (x)) can be approximated to a Log-Normal distribution
with parameters (mu = r/gamma) and (sigma ^2 = sigma ^2_{e}/2 gamma). This implies that the RSA distribution of protein domains would be a Poisson Log-Normal with parameters (mu) and (sigma ^2).
If instead, we consider a linear density regulation function24 (g(x)=eta x), where (eta) is a constant, then
where (omega _0) is the speciation parameter, (epsilon =sigma _d^2/sigma _e^2) and (a = frac{2 e^{2(1+epsilon )eta /sigma ^2_e}}{sigma ^2_e(1+epsilon )^{2(r+eta epsilon )/sigma ^2_e}}). When (epsilon ll x), (lambda (x)) is now a Gamma distribution with shape (alpha =2(r+eta epsilon )/sigma ^2_e) and rate (beta =2eta /sigma ^2_e), and the RSA distribution of protein domains is a Negative Binomial
with dispersion (alpha) and success rate ({q}=sigma ^2_e/(2eta + sigma ^2_e)).
Finally, if we consider the limit of Eq. (6) in which the dispersion parameter (alpha) tends to zero, the Negative Binomial density function [Eq. (6)] converges to a Log-Series
that hence represents a special case of Negative Binomial model when (2(r+eta epsilon )/sigma ^2_e rightarrow 0).
Here, we aim to model the evolution of protein domains within the genome using Engen and Lande’s theoretical framework. Specifically, modeling the protein domain RSA of thousands of bacterial genomes, we intend to provide a novel phylogenetic characterization of bacteria.
We hypothesize that new protein domain families are generated in the genome at times specified by an inhomogeneous Poisson process and that different families are mutually independent. Within the protein domain families, we assume that the evolutionary dynamics can be described by a stochastic birth-death process in which: (i) the growth rate r is constant; (ii) both environmental and demographic noise are included; iii) density regulation function is either linear or Gompertzian. The growth rate r can be interpreted as the rate by which a protein domain family gets a new copy inside the genome. This unifies two different events, the birth and death of protein domains which correspond to protein domain duplication and protein domain inactivation/deletion. Regarding the two noise terms ((sigma _d^2) and (sigma _e^2)), the demographic variance (sigma _d^2) captures small differences in duplication or survival between different individual domains which belong to the same protein domain family, while the environmental variance (sigma _e^2) represents larger scale disruptions of the proteome which act on all protein domains within the family simultaneously. Events such as horizontal gene transfer are an example of environmental stochasticity. The role of the density regulation, g(x), is to keep the abundance of protein domain family from diverging. This is usually a consequence of the limited availability of resources in the community, and it can be related to the limited size of the genome (and consequently of the proteome) in the contest of protein domains29.
The modeling of protein domain RSA within bacterial genomes will allow us to derive a novel measurement of phylogenetic distance. Specifically, we will show that the Poisson Log-Normal distribution [Eq. (4)] is the one that best fits the empirical RSA of bacterial protein domain families and we will derive our novel phylogenetic distance based on its two parameters (mu = r/gamma) and (sigma ^2 = sigma ^2_{e}/2 gamma), together with the protein domains density within the bacterial genome, as detailed in the “Materials and methods” section. In the following, we will show how such distance is related to the usual 16S rRNA gene-based and taxonomic classifications of bacteria and how it constitutes a promising measurement to investigate the bacterial phylogeny at the intraspecies level, where both 16S rRNA and taxonomic classification fail.
The protein domain RSA distributions of 3368 bacterial genomes were obtained as detailed in the “Materials and methods” section. Briefly, for each bacterial genome we retrieved all the identifiable protein domains. Then, we computed the RSA by counting the number of protein domains belonging to each protein domain family.
Three evolutionary hypotheses were tested by fitting the empirical RSAs with the Log-Series [Eq. (7)], the Negative Binomial (Eq. (6)) and the Poisson Log-Normal (Eq. (4)) distribution (Fig. 1a). According to the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC)30, in (99.97%) of bacteria the selected model was the Poisson Log-Normal (Fig. 1b). This model performed better than both the Log-Series and the Negative Binomial and described the data well, with an average (R^2) of 0.97 (minimum (R^2)=0.86). The selection of the Poisson Log-Normal model instead of the Negative Binomial or the Log-Series, implies that the protein domains evolution process is characterized by a Gompertzian density regulation function ((g(x)=gamma ln (x+epsilon ))) rather than a linear one ((g(x)=eta x)). This suggests an asymmetric process in which the proliferation rate for low abundant protein domains is faster than for the high abundant ones.
Fit of protein domains RSA. (a) Example of protein domains Preston plot fitted with three different distributions: the Poisson Log-Normal, the Negative Binomial and the Log-Series. Results refer to the bacterial genome (text {GCA}_000717515). The Negative Binomial and the Log-Series fit overlap. This implies that the dispersion parameter (alpha) of the Negative Binomial distribution (see Eq. (6)) is close to zero. The mean and the median of the dispersion parameter obtained for the 3368 bacterial genomes are ({2.67times 10^{-4}}) and ({2.62times 10^{-7}}), in agreement with the observed overlap. (b) Distribution of the difference between the AIC obtained with the Poisson Log-Normal model (PL) and the Log-Series (LS) or the Negative Binomial (NB) model, considering all the 3368 bacterial genomes.
The examination of the Poisson Log-Normal scale ((mu)) and location ((sigma ^2)) parameters (see Eq. (4) and Supplementary Material) estimated by the fitting procedure for each bacterial genome, allows us to reveal further features of the evolutionary process of protein domains.
First of all, Fig. 2 shows that (mu) has negative values in all bacterial genomes. Recalling that (mu =r/gamma), where r is the growth rate and (gamma) is the multiplicative constant of the Gompertzian function, which must be positive, this implies that the growth rate of protein domains, r, is also negative. Notice that the growth rate can be expressed as the difference between the birth and the death rate, (r=b-d). Hence, a negative r means that the death rate is greater than the birth rate ((d > b)). In the evolutionary model of protein domains, the birth rate b has the meaning of duplication rate, while the death rate d is the rate at which protein domains are deactivated. A negative r hence implies that protein domain deactivation, which is related to the accumulation of events which disrupt the coding sequence of protein domains, happens at a faster rate than the duplication of the whole protein domain sequence within the genome.
Distribution of species according to the model parameters. Scatter plot of Poisson Log-Normal parameters (mu) versus (sigma ^2) obtained fitting the protein domains RSAs. Only species represented by at least 10 different strains were included in the plot, for a total of 1173 bacterial genomes which belong to 48 different species. Different colors represent different species as indicated in the legend.
Furthermore, the plot of (mu) as a function of (sigma ^2) (Fig. 2) highlights the negative linear relationship between (mu) and (sigma ^2). Such relationship can also be deduced mathematically.
Starting from the expressions (mu =r/gamma) and (sigma ^2=sigma _e^2 / 2gamma), and after simple algebraic manipulation, we can in fact obtain that (mu = 2rsigma ^2 / sigma _e^2), which explains the negative linear relationship between the two parameters.
Besides the negative relationship, the plot of (mu) versus (sigma ^2) also highlights the presence of clusters of bacterial genomes with similar ecological features, which are pictured in the plot as roughly parallel stripes (Fig. 2). When we depict bacterial strains belonging to the same species using the same color, it emerges that the stripes are related to the bacterial taxonomy. This result motivates us to introduce a new approach to bacterial phylogeny based on the ecological modeling of protein domains and the consequent estimation of the parameters (mu) and (sigma ^2).
We propose to calculate the pairwise evolutionary distances between bacteria based on three parameters: the Poisson Log-Normal scale and location parameters discussed above ((mu) and (sigma)), and the density of protein domains in the bacterial genome. Such density describes to which extend the whole bacterial genome is populated with protein domains and it hence constitutes an additional feature of the protein domain ecological dynamics. As detailed in the Materials and Methods, the distance between bacteria is specifically computed as the 3D euclidean distance in the scaled space of (mu), (sigma), and protein domain density. In the following, we refer to such distance as ‘RSA distance’.
To evaluate the bacterial interrelationships derived from the RSA distances, we compared our results with both the bacterial taxonomic classification and the 16S rRNA gene-based phylogeny. Specifically, starting from the RSA distance matrix we computed a hierarchical clustering of bacteria and we compared the resulting clusters with those obtained from the 16S rRNA gene-based distance matrix. Both clustering results were then compared with the bacterial taxonomic classification.
Notice that the usage of both 16S rRNA phylogeny and bacterial taxonomic classification allows us to exploit the complementary information that these two approaches provide, despite their intrinsic connection. Namely, modern microbial taxonomy is mostly based on 16S rRNA gene6 and, on the other hand, the cutoffs commonly used in 16S rRNA phylogeny originated from phenotype-based taxonomy31. However, while taxonomy allows us to assign human interpretable names to bacteria, to associate such names with phenotypic properties, and to classify bacteria into a predefined hierarchy, 16S rRNA phylogeny provides a quantitative measurement of the evolutionary distance between bacteria that can be compared with the RSA distance without setting any pre-defined threshold. Moreover, the usage of 16S rRNA phylogeny allows us to investigate the bacterial relationships at the intraspecies level, for which the taxonomic classification is not available.
As detailed in the Materials and Methods, 16S rRNA distances were calculated based on the bacterial 16S rRNA gene reference sequences, following the standard procedure32. Taxonomic classification, instead, was retrieved from NCBI and included the following levels: phylum, class, order, family, genus and species. In order to obtain a comparable number of clusters from all three methods, we considered separately each taxonomic level and we cut the 16S rRNA and the RSA -based hierarchical trees so as to get a number of clusters equivalent to the number of taxa available at the selected taxonomic level.
At each taxonomic level, the Normalized Mutual Information (NMI) was used as a measurement of agreement between different clustering solutions33. Notice that, while the theoretical range of the NMI score is the interval (left[ 0,1right]), NMI is biased towards clustering solutions with more clusters and fewer data points34. Consequently, the baseline of NMI score in practise is not zero and relatively high NMI scores can be an artifact caused by the low ratio between number of bacteria and number of taxonomic groups. To make the comparison fair, we used simulations to calculate the baseline NMI for each taxonomic level (box plots of Fig. 3).
As expected by their intrinsic relationship, taxonomy and 16S rRNA phylogeny show high agreement (red dots in Fig. 3). RSA-based clusters, instead, show a certain deviation from both taxonomy (blue dots in Fig. 3) and phylogeny (green dots in Fig. 3). For both comparisons, however, the NMI scores are still evidently higher than the baseline, signifying that the RSA model captures phylogenetic signals to a certain degree. Comparing the obtained NMI scores with the baseline, we notice that the agreement between RSA-based clusters and both taxonomy and phylogeny increases at lower taxonomic levels, reaching the maximum at species level. Taking as ground truth the taxonomic classification, the total purity of the RSA-based clusters at species level is 0.65, signifying that 65% of bacteria are correctly classified.
Comparison between the three clustering results at different taxonomic levels. NMI scores (y-axis) are calculated as a measurement of agreement between clusters based on: RSA method and taxonomy (blue), 16S rRNA gene and taxonomy (red), RSA method and 16S rRNA gene (green). Different taxonomic levels are considered for the comparison: phylum, class, order, family, genus and species (x-axis). The box plots represent the baselines of NMI score and are based on simulations.
To assess the robustness and stability of the RSA-based phylogeny, with regard to the choice of protein domains, we randomly selected subsamples of protein domains in different proportions (from (10%) to 90% of all protein domains). The reconstructed phylogenetic trees were then compared with the phylogenetic tree obtained using all protein domains (see Materials and Methods for details), and the correlation between the trees was calculated (see Supplementary Fig. S6). As expected, with larger proportions of protein domains taken into account, the correlation between subsample-based phylogeny and base phylogeny increases. For larger subsampling proportions, the compared phylogenetic trees are in good agreement: for a subsample with 90% of protein domains, the mean cophenetic correlation is equal to 0.74, and the mean common-nodes-correlation is equal to 0.68. We notice that the common-nodes-correlation is more stable compared to the cophenetic correlation, as expected since cophenetic correlation is affected by the height of the phylogenetic trees. The results suggest that the overall structure of the phylogenies is stable even for smaller subsampling proportions, while subsampling height of the branches correlates with the full-data height only at larger subsampling proportions.
To evaluate the intraspecies composition obtained from the RSA-based clustering, we selected the subset of species for which at least 10 different strains were present in our data (48 species). Among them, we selected the species where hierarchical clustering showed a clear separation of clusters (including outliers) and for which published literature characterizing at least some of the strains was available (6 out of 48 species). For these 6 species, we again assessed the robustness and stability of RSA phylogenies, as detailed in the “Materials and methods” section. Our results suggest (see Supplementary Fig. S7) that the subsample-based phylogenies are in good agreement with the full-data phylogenies, especially for larger subsampling proportions. We notice the correlations is larger than in the case of phylogenetic trees for randomly selected 100 bacteria (Supplementary Fig. S6), especially for certain species (i.e., Xanthomonas citri). This could be attributed to the smaller size of the phylogenetic tree. However, the species with similar phylogenetic tree size still show differences in correlation (i.e., Xanthomonas citri and Francisella tularensis), suggesting that the RSA-based distance matrix between the strains of Xanthomonas citri carries stronger phylogenetic signal. Comparing 6 observed species with the randomly sampled subsets of 100 bacteria, we can analogously conclude that the RSA-captured phylogenetic signal is stronger within the species. In the following, we discuss the results obtained for the 6 selected bacterial species in more details.
(Previous page.) Hierarchical clustering of bacteria at the intraspecies level, comparing solutions obtained by RSA and 16S rRNA method. Each subplot shows a tanglegram with RSA-based dendrogram on the left and 16S rRNA-based dendrogram on the right. Lines connect the same bacteria from two dendrograms. The color/type of the line represents the feature of the bacterium it connects. (a) 22 strains of Xanthomonas citri belong to two different pathovars: A (orange) and (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) (purple). (b) 10 strains of Chlamydia pneumoniae are isolated from different tissues: conjuctival (yellow), respiratory (magenta) and vascular (violet). 9 strains represented with solid line are human (Homo sapiens) pathogens while the one strain represented by dashed line is koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) pathogen. (c) 14 strains of Vibrio cholerae are colored based on their karyotype. 11 strains have two circular chromosomes Chr1 ((sim 3) Mb) and Chr2 ((sim 1) Mb) (magenta). 2 strains have one (sim)4 Mb long circular chromosome (yellow). One strain has three chromosomes Chr1 ((sim)3 Mb), Chr2 ((sim)1 Mb) and Chr3 ((sim)1 Mb) (violet).
Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri (XCC) and Chlamydia pneumoniae (Cpn) are two species whose subspecies can infect different hosts. Here we show that the RSA-based method correctly discriminates such subspecies even when their divergence is not detected comparing the 16S rRNA gene sequences.
Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri (XCC) is a causal agent of citrus canker type A, a bacterial disease affecting different plants from the genus Citrus. While citrus canker A infects most citrus species, two of its variants, A* and (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}), have a much more limited host range with XCC pathotype (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) infecting only Key lime (C. aurantifolia) and alemow (C. macrophylla)2. Our data set includes 17 strains of XCC pathotype A and 5 strains of XCC pathotype (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}})2. RSA-based clustering of the 22 XCC strains identifies two separated clusters (Fig. 4a, left) which coincide with the two XCC pathotypes. Concurrently, clustering based on 16S rRNA gene fails to identify the two pathotypes of XCC (Fig. 4a, right). This suggests that even though pathotypes A and (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) have different hosts, their diversification is not reflected in the variability of the 16S rRNA gene. On the other hand, modeling the protein domain RSA of the two pathotypes succesfully captures the different functions of their proteomes.
Another important aspect of the citrus canker is the geographical spread of the disease. The 22 strains of XCC included in our data set have diverse geographical origin. While all (hbox {A}^{mathrm{W}}) strains were sampled from USA, strains of pathotype A originate from USA, Brazil and China. RSA clustering of 17 A-type strains colored by their sampling location shows a geographical pattern (Supplementary Fig. S2) similar to the one obtained by Patané et al.2 using a maximum likelihood tree based on 1785 concatenated unicopy genes, with the only exception of strain jx-6 ((text {GCA}_001028285)) coming from China.
For what concerns Chlamydia pneumoniae (Cpn), this is an obligate intercellular parasite which is widespread in human population and causes acute respiratory disease. Besides humans, different animal species can be infected with Chlamydia pneumoniae. Our data set includes 9 strains which infect humans (Homo sapiens) and 1 strain isolated from koala (Phascolarctos cinereus). RSA-based clustering clearly separates such isolate from the group of highly similar human isolates (Fig. 4b, left). This result is confirmed by 16S rRNA-based clustering (Fig. 4b, right) and is in agreeement with previous results in which the comparison of four human-derived isolates and the koala strain LPCoLN ((text {GCA}_000024145)) through whole-genome sequencing showed a much higher variation between human and koala-derived strains than within the human-derived strains35.
Another peculiarity of Chlamydia pneumoniae is tissue tropism. The human-derived strains of Chlamydia pneumoniae can in fact be divided into conjuctival, raspiratory and vascular based on their tissue of origin. Cpn tissue tropism was the focus of the study conducted by Weinmaier et al., where whole-genome sequences of multiple Cpn strains isolated from different human anatomical sites were compared and animal isolates were used as outgroup3. Weinmaier et al. found a good agreement between the anatomical origin of strains and the maximum likelihood phylogenetic tree based on all SNPs. However, they could not obtain a clear separation between anatomical subgroups of Cpn. Our results show that the RSA-based method partially succeeds in separating subspecies related to different tissues (Fig. 4b, left). The RSA-based dendrogram, in fact, shows a cluster of four respiratory bacteria. However, it does not separate the other subspecies by infection site, suggesting that tissue tropism is not entirely captured by our method.
In some cases, subspecies of the same species are characterized by global differences in the genome composition. This is, for example, the case of Vibrio cholerae and Buchnera aphidicola. Here, we show that the RSA-based model is able to capture such differences and to discriminate subspecies with known different genomic peculiarities.
Vibrio cholerae is the causative agent of cholera disease. Its genome is normally composed of two chromosomes: Chr1 ((sim 3) Mb) and Chr2 ((sim 1) Mb). However, some strains show a different karyotype. The two strains (1154text {-}74) ((text {GCA}_000969235)) and (10432text {-}62) ((text {GCA}_000969265)), for instance, underwent the process of chromosomal fusion and possess only one (sim 4) Mb long circular chromosome, which shows a high degree of synteny with the two chromosomes of the more common strains36. The strain (text {TSY}216) ((text {GCA}001045415)), on the other hand, besides having the original two chromosomes, also contains an additional (sim 1) Mb long replicon, which does not share any conserved region with Chr1 and Chr237. For these reasons, we expect the single- and two-chromosome strains to be phylogenetically closer to each other than to the three-chromosome strain, which contains the extra replicon. The 16S rRNA gene-based clustering, however, does not identify any clear separation between the three types of strains (Fig. 4c, right). As a matter of fact, all the 16S rRNA gene copies of all the Vibrio cholerae strains included in our data set are located on (sim 3) Mb long chromosome, which shows high synteny across all strains. It is therefore not surprising that the comparison of the 16S rRNA genes does not capture the global genomic differences that exist between the considered strains. On the other hand, the results obtained with the RSA-based clustering show a clear distinction of the strains with different genomic structure (Fig. 4c, left). The reason for the success of the RSA-based method lies in the theoretical definition of RSA-based distance. In fact, the RSA-based distance depends on the Poisson Log-Normal location parameter (sigma ^2), which increases with the genome length (Supplementary Fig. S1): by definition, (sigma ^2 = sigma _e^2 / 2gamma), and, while the environmental noise (sigma _e^2) can be reasonably considered independent of the genome length, the density regulation (gamma) is expected to be stronger for smaller genomes, which repesent a scarcer environment with less resources.
Buchnera aphidicola is a bacterial species in mutualistic endosymbiotic relationship with different aphids (members of superfamily Aphidoidea). As many endosymbionts, Buchnera aphidicola underwent the process of genome reduction as an adaptation to the host-associated lifestyle and has a genome with length (<1) Mb. One of the main processes which contributed to genome reduction is gene inactivation followed by progressive gene disintegration38. An intermediate step of this process is pseudogenization. For this reason, we expect the number of pseudogenes within a genome to be related to its evolutionary state and strains with similar numbers of pseudogenes to be phylogenetically similar. Among the 13 strains of Buchnera aphidicola available in our data set, we observe a high variability in the number of pseudogenes, with 12 strains having between 7 and 63, and one strain (JF98, (text {GCA}_000183305)) having 176 pseudogenes. Since the total number of genes (considering both protein coding genes and pseudogenes) is similar in all strains, this implies that JF98 has a smaller proteome compared to the others. Our results show that the divergence of strain JF98 from the others is evident from the RSA-based clustering (Supplementary Fig. S3-a, left), while it is not clear from the 16S rRNA-based one (Supplementary Fig. S3-a, right).
On the other hand, another outstanding property of the Buchnera aphidicola strains is their capability to infect different hosts. Focusing on this aspect, we notice that the RSA-based clustering only partially agrees with a grouping of the strains based on the infected host. The 16S rRNA-based method, instead, finds more coherent results (Supplementary Fig. S3-b), possibly due to the fact that endosymbionts and their hosts tend to co-evolve together once their endosymbiotic relationship starts4.
For several species in our data set, the RSA-based phylogenic tree indicates the presence of outlier strains (see Supplementary Fig. S8). For two of such species (Listeria monocytogenes and Francisella tularensis), in particular, we were able to find bibliographic information at the strain level which provides a biological explanation to our findings.
Listeria monocytogenes is a food-borne pathogenic bacterium which causes listeriosis in humans. From the 48 Listeria monocytogenes strains present in our data set, RSA-based clustering identifies a subgroup of two strains (Supplementary Fig. S4). These two strains, La111 ((text {GCA}_000382925)) and N53-1 ((text {GCA}_000382945)), seem to have very similar proteome composition which differs from that of the other strains. Holch et al. investigated strains La111 and N53-1 in their study on bacterial persistence in Listeria monocytogenes39. Based on whole-genome analysis, the authors found that these two strains, which were isolated 6 years apart from different Danish fish processors, are extremely similar and collectively different from the other analyzed strains, in agreement with our RSA-based results.
Francisella tularensis, instead, is an intracellular bacterium which is a causal agent of tularemia. Our data set includes 25 Francisella tularensis strains from different subspecies: tularensis, holarctica, mediasiatica and novicida. While neither RSA- nor 16S rRNA-based clustering accurately separate subspecies of Francisella tularensis, the RSA method identifies one outlier, strain TIGB03 ((text {GCA}_000248415)) (Supplementary Fig. S5). Unlike the other 24 virulent strains, strain TIGB03 is an attenuated tularensis strain. This strain was described by Modise et al. as an attenuated O-antigen mutant of the virulent strain TI0902 ((text {GCA}_000248435))5. Indeed, we notice that 16S rRNA genes of these two strains are identical (Supplementary Fig. S5) and thus 16S rRNA-based clustering is unable to detect the mutant strain. Comparing whole-genome sequences of strains TIGB03 and TI0902, Modise et al. found 31 nonsynonymous point mutations and a 75.9 kb long duplicated region in the mutant strain TIGB03. However, such long duplication does not make TIGB03 an outlier in terms of genome length (the genome length of TIGB03 is 1.97 Mb and that of the other 24 strains included in our study ranges from 1.86 to 2.05 Mb). This indicates that the presence of nonsynomymous mutations led to different proteome composition, which is recognized by our method.
The de novo clustering of phylogenetically similar metagenomes is a crucial step for the study of bacterial populations. To this aim, a typical approach is the pairwise comparison of 16S rRNA sequences derived from the biological sample of interest. After computing the pairwise distance matrix, clusters are defined based on a custom similarity threshold. Then, clusters are usually compared to databases of annotated sequences to derive the taxonomic classification, that is to associate human-made hierarchical labels (bacterial names) to the detected metagenomes. While taxonomic classification allows to recognize known bacteria and their phenotype, de novo clustering potentially allows to obtain a higher resolution of the bacterial population at the intraspecies level, unaffected by the possible bias of human-made classifications.
Here, we proposed to measure the phylogenetic distance between bacteria, based on their genomic evolving units: protein domains. Specifically, we exploited the ecological modeling of ecosystems proposed by Engen and Lande23 to describe the evolution of protein domains, considering them as ‘species’ that populate the genome. Based on such modeling, we derived a new phylogenetic distance that can be computed fitting the protein domains Relative Species Abundance distribution (RSA). We showed that clustering the bacterial genomes based on 16S rRNA or exploiting our model allows to capture different features in terms of both genome composition (e.g. presence of additional replicon, pseudogenes, duplicated regions, or nonsynomymous mutations) and bacterial phenotype (e.g. infected host). Our results hence open to the possibility of developing an algorithm in which both pieces of information are exploited to obtain an overall best inference of bacterial phylogeny. This will hopefully be part of future works.
The proposed approach is especially promising when samples are analysed by means of shotgun sequencing, rather than 16S rRNA sequencing40. Indeed, 16S rRNA sequencing is a powerful method to detect and compare metagenomes. However, it is limited by being based on the measurement of a single gene. On the other hand, information on the whole metagenome can be derived when using shotgun sequencing40. In terms of phylogeny, 16S rRNA sequencing detects only metagenomic divergences which directly affect the 16S rRNA gene, and its ability to discriminate metagenomes at the intraspecies level is therefore limited6. Our RSA-based method, on the other hand, provides a global measurement based on the whole proteome. As highlighted by our results, these two approaches are hence somehow complementary, being the RSA-based method more sensitive to evolutionary processes that affect the metagenome globally, possibly leaving the 16S rRNA gene unaffected, and the 16S rRNA-based method being instead more sensitive when such gene is involved, such as in the case of Buchnera aphidicola. Overall, our results show that the RSA-based approach is a promising method that could be exploited to study the metagenomic composition of samples, in particular when shotgun sequencing is performed and the whole metagenome could be reconstructed, though experimental validation would be required to definitely assess the efficacy of our approach.
The genome sequences of 3370 bacteria were downloaded from the NCBI database41. Draft genome sequences were discarded and only the higher quality fully circular genome sequences were retained. GeneBank files containing genome sequences and existing annotations were retrieved from the NCBI database and imported into the Semantic Annotation Platform for Prokaryotes42 using the EMBL/GBK to RDF SAPP module. De novo identification of genetic elements (gene calling) was performed using Prodigal (2.6)43 with codon table 11, which is recommanded when dealing with bacterial genomes. Dedicated SPARQL queries were built to extract all proteins and their sequences from the RDF triplestore used by SAPP to store the intermediate results. InterProScan44 was used to identify protein domains in the corresponding sequences. Due to the high number of distinct protein sequences to be analyzed, the SURFsara GRID infrastructure was used45 to concurrently analyze the sequences. Dedicated SPARQL queries were used to retrieve all the identified domains and assign them to the originating protein and bacterial genome. Finally, the matrix generating module from SAPP was used to generate a matrix containing the number of instances of the detected domain (domain abundance) for each of the studied genomes and for each of the identified protein domains. Overall 3370 bacterial genomes were analyzed and 13,934 distinct domains were identified.
Protein domains RSAs were fitted with the Maximum Likelihood Estimation method implemented in R “sads” package v.0.4.246. Data were modelled with a truncated Poisson Log-Normal, a truncated Log-Series and a truncated Negative Binomial distribution, so that to test and compare different ecological hypothesis. In all cases, truncation was performed to exclude the zero abundance class, that is not observable in empirical data. Two bacterial genomes which couldn’t be fitted due to extreme RSA distributions are (text {GCA}_000200735) and (text {GCA}_000831405). After removal of these bacteria, we proceeded with the analysis of the remaining 3368 bacterial genomes. Akaike Information Criterion (AIC)30 and R-squared were computed to assess the models performances and for model selection.
Fitting truncated Poisson Log-Normal distribution to protein domain RSA, we obtained estimates (mu) and (sigma) for 3368 bacteria. In addition to Poisson Log-Normal parameters, we calculated protein domain density for every bacteria as ratio between total number of protein domains present in the genome and the genome length. RSA distance between each pair of bacteria was calculated as 3D euclidean distance in the scaled space of (mu), (sigma) and protein domain density. Scaling was performed independently at each dimension subtracting the mean and dividing by standard deviation.
In order to calculate phylogenetic distances based on 16S rRNA gene, we used the silva database47 to retrieve the 16S rRNA reference sequences of the bacterial species for which protein domain data were available. For 48 bacteria, the 16S rRNA sequence was not present, so we considered only the remaining 3320 bacteria for the following analysis. Since the same bacterial genome can have multiple different copies of 16S rRNA gene, as 16S rRNA distance between a pair of bacteria we used the mean pairwise distance between all pairs of 16S rRNA sequences within two genomes48. The alignment of 16S rRNA sequences and calculation of distances was performed with mothur32 “pairwise.seqs” function with default parameters.
For each taxonomic level, we considered only bacteria for which the classification was known and which belonged to a taxonomic group with at least 10 members. As a result, we analysed 3270, 3148, 3032, 2714, 2139 and 161 bacteria at phylum, class, order, family, genus and species level, respectively. They belonged to 14, 20, 48, 63, 54 and 48 different taxonomic groups. Hierarchical clustering was performed on both RSA and 16S rRNA distance matrices. For RSA clustering we used Ward’s minimum variance method while for 16S rRNA we used average linkage method. The Ward’s method was used to minimize the total in-cluster variance49. Since this method is based on Euclidean distance, it couldn’t be applied to 16S rRNA distance matrix. To get clustering solutions for RSA and 16S rRNA, we cut the hierarchical tree fixing the number of clusters to the number of taxa at the selected taxonomic level. Finally, we used the NMI score as a measure of clustering agreement between the three approaches: RSA, 16S and predefined taxonomy. To calculate the baseline for the NMI score, we compared the taxonomy with clustering solutions based on simulations. For the fixed number of clusters and data points, each simulation assigned random cluster to each data point. Purity of a RSA cluster with respect to taxonomy is calculated as the ratio between the size of the cluster’s most abundant taxonomic group and the cluster size. The total purity of the RSA clustering solution is a weighted average of its clusters’ purities where weight is a cluster size.
To assess the robustness and stability of RSA-based phylogeny, regarding the choice of protein domains, we randomly selected subsamples of protein domains and we compared the obtained subsample-based results with the one obtained when all protein domains were used. Specifically, we subsampled protein domains in various proportions (ranging from 0.1 to 0.9), then we fitted the subsampled protein domain RSA distribution with Poisson LogNormal distribution and we used the estimated parameters to calculate the phylogeny of the examined bacteria, following the same methodology used when considering all protein domains. The obtained subsample-based phylogeny (i.e., dendrogram) was then compared to the full-data-based phylogeny calculating the correlation between dendrograms. Two different correlation measurements were used, cophenetic correlation and correlation based on common nodes (i.e., nodes that have the same list of leaves). For the calculations, the function “cor.dendlist” from the R “dendextend” package v.1.14.050 was used. For every subsampling proportion (0.1–0.9), 100 bacteria were randomly chosen from 3368 available bacteria and a random subsample of protein domains was taken from the remaining protein domains (which were present in at least one of the chosen bacteria). The correlation between two 100-leaf dendrograms (computed with all protein domains and with a chosen subsample of protein domains) was calculated. The procedure was repeated for 50 times, resulting in 50 correlation measurements for every subsampling proportion. Additionally, robustness and stability of phylogeny was assessed for 6 bacterial species (Xanthomonas citri, Vibrio cholerae, Francisella tularensis, Buchnera aphidicola, Listeria monocytogenes, Chlamydia pneumoniae). For every bacterial species and for different subsampling proportions (from 0.1 to 0.9), with 100 repeats, a subsample of protein domains was randomly selected and subsample-based phylogeny of the species was recontructed. Correlations between the full-data dendrogram and the 100 subsample-based dendrograms were calculated. Subsequently, the mean and standard deviation of correlation was obtained for every species and every subsampling proportion.
The datasets analysed during the current study are available in the NCBI repository41 (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/). The complete list of accession numbers (GenBank IDs) is provided in the Supplementary material.
Lan, R. & Reeves, P. R. Intraspecies variation in bacterial genomes: the need for a species genome concept. Trends Microbiol. 8, 396–401 (2000).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Patané, J. S. et al. Origin and diversification of xanthomonas citri subsp. citri pathotypes revealed by inclusive phylogenomic, dating, and biogeographic analyses. BMC Genomics20, 700 (2019).
Weinmaier, T. et al. Genomic factors related to tissue tropism in chlamydia pneumoniae infection. BMC Genomics 16, 268 (2015).
Article  Google Scholar 
Baumann, P. Biology of bacteriocyte-associated endosymbionts of plant sap-sucking insects. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 59, 155–189 (2005).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Modise, T. et al. Genomic comparison between a virulent type a1 strain of francisella tularensis and its attenuated o-antigen mutant (2012).
Janda, J. M. & Abbott, S. L. 16s rrna gene sequencing for bacterial identification in the diagnostic laboratory: pluses, perils, and pitfalls. J. Clin. Microbiol. 45, 2761–2764 (2007).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Felsenstein, J. Inferring phylogenies (Sinauer Associates is an imprint of Oxford University Press, 2004), 2 edn.
Zhu, Q. et al. Phylogenomics of 10,575 genomes reveals evolutionary proximity between domains bacteria and archaea. Nat. Commun. 10, 1–14 (2019).
Article  Google Scholar 
Ciccarelli, F. D. et al. Toward automatic reconstruction of a highly resolved tree of life. Science 311, 1283–1287 (2006).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Gevers, D. et al. Re-evaluating prokaryotic species. Nat. Rev. Microbiol. 3, 733 (2005).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Hanage, W. P., Fraser, C. & Spratt, B. G. Sequences, sequence clusters and bacterial species. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B Biol. Sci. 361, 1917–1927 (2006).
Article  Google Scholar 
Comas, I., Moya, A. & González-Candelas, F. Phylogenetic signal and functional categories in proteobacteria genomes. BMC Evol. Biol. 7, S7 (2007).
Article  Google Scholar 
Ponting, C. P. & Russell, R. R. The natural history of protein domains. Annu. Rev. Biophys. Biomol. Struct. 31, 45–71 (2002).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Alberts, B. et al.Molecular biology of the cell (Garland Science, Taylor a Francis Group, 2014), 6 edn.
Xie, X., Jin, J. & Mao, Y. Evolutionary versatility of eukaryotic protein domains revealed by their bigram networks. BMC Evol. Biol. 11, 242 (2011).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Chothia, C., Gough, J., Vogel, C. & Teichmann, S. A. Evolution of the protein repertoire. Science 300, 1701–1703 (2003).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Nasir, A., Kim, K. M. & Caetano-Anollés, G. Global patterns of protein domain gain and loss in superkingdoms. PLoS Comput. Biol. 10, e1003452 (2014).
Article  Google Scholar 
Yang, S., Doolittle, R. F. & Bourne, P. E. Phylogeny determined by protein domain content. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 102, 373–378 (2005).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Wang, M. & Caetano-Anollés, G. Global phylogeny determined by the combination of protein domains in proteomes. Mol. Biol. Evol. 23, 2444–2454 (2006).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Yang, S. & Bourne, P. E. The evolutionary history of protein domains viewed by species phylogeny. PLoS ONE 4, e8378 (2009).
Article  Google Scholar 
Karev, G. P., Wolf, Y. I., Rzhetsky, A. Y., Berezovskaya, F. S. & Koonin, E. V. Birth and death of protein domains: a simple model of evolution explains power law behavior. BMC Evol. Biol. 2, 1–26 (2002).
Article  Google Scholar 
Luscombe, N. M., Qian, J., Zhang, Z., Johnson, T. & Gerstein, M. The dominance of the population by a selected few: power-law behaviour applies to a wide variety of genomic properties. Genome Biol. 3, 1–7 (2002).
Article  Google Scholar 
Engen, S. & Lande, R. Population dynamic models generating the lognormal species abundance distribution. Math. Biosci. 132, 169–183 (1996).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Engen, S. & Lande, R. Population dynamic models generating species abundance distributions of the gamma type. J. Theor. Biol. 178, 325–331 (1996).
Article  Google Scholar 
Hubbell, S. P. The unified neutral theory of biodiversity and biogeography (Princeton University Press, 2011), 1 edn.
Karlin, S. & Taylor, H. M. A first course in stochastic processes (Academic Press, 1975), 2 edn.
Karlin, S. & Taylor, H. M. A second course in stochastic processes (Academic Press, 1981), 1 edn.
Gompertz, B. On the nature of the function expressive of the law of human mortality, and on a new mode of determining the value of life contingencies. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. 513–583 (1825).
Hidalgo, O. et al. Is there an upper limit to genome size. Trends Plant Sci. 22, 567–573 (2017).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Burnham, K. P., Anderson, D. R. & Huyvaert, K. P. AIC model selection and multimodel inference in behavioral ecology: some background, observations, and comparisons. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 65, 23–35 (2011).
Article  Google Scholar 
Cohan, F. M. What are bacterial species?. Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 56, 457–487 (2002).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Schloss, P. D. et al. Introducing mothur: open-source, platform-independent, community-supported software for describing and comparing microbial communities. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 75, 7537–7541 (2009).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Estévez, P. A., Tesmer, M., Perez, C. A. & Zurada, J. M. Normalized mutual information feature selection. IEEE Trans. Neural Netw. 20, 189–201 (2009).
Article  Google Scholar 
Romano, S., Bailey, J., Nguyen, V. & Verspoor, K. Standardized mutual information for clustering comparisons: one step further in adjustment for chance. In International Conference on Machine Learning, 1143–1151 (2014).
Myers, G. et al. Evidence that human chlamydia pneumoniae was zoonotically acquired. J. Bacteriol. 191, 7225–7233 (2009).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Xie, G. et al. Exception to the rule: genomic characterization of naturally occurring unusual vibrio cholerae strains with a single chromosome. Int. J. Genomics, 2017 (2017).
Okada, K. et al. Characterization of 3 megabase-sized circular replicons from vibrio cholerae. Emerg. Infect. Dis. 21, 1262 (2015).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Gómez-Valero, L., Latorre, A. & Silva, F. J. The evolutionary fate of nonfunctional DNA in the bacterial endosymbiont Buchnera aphidicola. Mol. Biol. Evol. 21, 2172–2181 (2004).
Article  Google Scholar 
Holch, A. et al. Genome sequencing identifies two nearly unchanged strains of persistent listeria monocytogenes isolated at two different fish processing plants sampled 6 years apart. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 79, 2944–2951 (2013).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Durazzi, F. et al. Comparison between 16s rRNA and shotgun sequencing data for the taxonomic characterization of the gut microbiota. Sci. Rep. 11, 1–10 (2021).
Article  Google Scholar 
Wheeler, D. L. et al. Database resources of the national center for biotechnology information. Nucleic Acids Res. 28, 10–14 (2000).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Koehorst, J. J. et al. Sapp: functional genome annotation and analysis through a semantic framework using fair principles. Bioinformatics 34, 1401–1403 (2018).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Hyatt, D. et al. Prodigal: prokaryotic gene recognition and translation initiation site identification. BMC Bioinform. 11, 119 (2010).
Article  Google Scholar 
Jones, P. et al. Interproscan 5: genome-scale protein function classification. Bioinformatics 30, 1236–1240 (2014).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Surf. https://www.surf.nl/en.
Prado, P. I., Miranda, D. M. & Chalom, A. Package sads. MASS (2018).
Quast, C. et al. The Silva ribosomal RNA gene database project: improved data processing and web-based tools. Nucleic Acids Res. 41, D590–D596 (2012).
Article  Google Scholar 
Větrovskỳ, T. & Baldrian, P. The variability of the 16s rRNA gene in bacterial genomes and its consequences for bacterial community analyses. PLoS ONE 8, e57923 (2013).
Article  Google Scholar 
Ward, J. H. Jr. Hierarchical grouping to optimize an objective function. J. Am. Stat. Assoc. 58, 236–244 (1963).
MathSciNet  Article  Google Scholar 
Galili, T. dendextend: an R package for visualizing, adjusting, and comparing trees of hierarchical clustering. Bioinformatics 31, 3718–20 (2015).
CAS  Article  Google Scholar 
Download references
This work was supported by the European Union’s H2020 research and innovation programme “VEO” Grant no. 874735, and by the H2020-MSCA-ITN “IMforFuture” Grant no. 721815.
Department of Physics and Astronomy ‘Augusto Righi’, University of Bologna, 40127, Bologna, Italy
Iva Budimir, Daniele Dall’Olio, Alessandra Merlotti & Daniel Remondini
Department of Experimental, Diagnostic and Specialty Medicine, University of Bologna, 40138, Bologna, Italy
Enrico Giampieri, Martina Tarozzi, Nico Curti, Gastone Castellani & Claudia Sala
Laboratory of Systems and Synthetic Biology, Wageningen University and Research, 6708 WE, Wageningen, The Netherlands
Edoardo Saccenti & Maria Suarez-Diez
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
You can also search for this author in PubMed Google Scholar
C.S., G.C., and D.R. conceived the analysis. E.S. and M.S.D conducted the bioinformatic analysis. I.B, C.S, E.G, and D.D. conducted the statistical analysis and modeling. E.G. and N.C. optimized the code. I.B., C.S., M.T., A.M. and N.C. processed the results and performed the bibliographic analysis. All authors reviewed the manuscript.
Correspondence to Gastone Castellani.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
Reprints and Permissions
Budimir, I., Giampieri, E., Saccenti, E. et al. Intraspecies characterization of bacteria via evolutionary modeling of protein domains. Sci Rep 12, 16595 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21036-3
Download citation
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-21036-3
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative
By submitting a comment you agree to abide by our Terms and Community Guidelines. If you find something abusive or that does not comply with our terms or guidelines please flag it as inappropriate.
Advertisement
Scientific Reports (Sci Rep) ISSN 2045-2322 (online)
© 2022 Springer Nature Limited
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.

source

Disco Elysium Studio Accused Of Ousting Creators, Dev Says It's 'Bad News' For Sequel – Kotaku

Some of the core developers behind beloved 2019 indie RPG Disco Elysium, including the author of the novel it’s based on, are no longer working at the studio that created it. The news was revealed in a blog post written by an editor on the game, Martin Luiga, who claims studio leadership at ZA/UM forced out the lead designers at the end of 2021 and has kept it secret ever since. According to two sources familiar with the situation, the studio hasn’t been transparent about what exactly happened with staff either.
ZA/UM started out as a collective of artists in Estonia before later turning into a studio of the same name to develop one of its members’ books into a Dungeons & Dragons-inspired examination of political economy and self loathing. ZA/UM the studio is based out of the UK, and in 2019 released Disco Elysium, which became a critical and financial success, racking up multiple game of the year awards.
“I, Martin Luiga, a founding member and Secretary of the ZA/UM cultural association, as well as the assembler of most of the core team, am hereby dissolving the ZA/UM cultural association (not to be confused with the ZA/UM company, on which subject I would note that neither Kurvitz, Hindpere nor Rostov are working there since the end of last year and their leaving the company was involuntary,” the former ZA/UM developer wrote in an October 1 Medium post. “Which would seem like bad news for the loving fans that are waiting for the Disco sequel.”
Read More: A Year Later, I Still Can’t Stop Thinking About Disco Elysium
Robert Kurvitz was the lead designer on whose novel the game was based. Aleksander Rostov was the lead artist whose impressionistic oil paintings defined the aesthetic of the game. And Helen Hindpere was one of the main writers on the game’s exceptional script, who accepted the prize for best new indie game of the year from presenter Reggie Fils-Aime at the 2019 Game Awards. Rostov confirmed the departures in a tweet attributed to all three members.
Spooky and scary
Something video games have over their film counterparts when it comes to horror is the player’s agency. Sure, watching the slasher claim their next victim can get a jumpscare out of you, but you know what’s scarier? Knowing you had the power to stop it. Watching someone slowly open a door and enter a dark room is unnerving, but having to do it yourself will send shivers down your spine and paralyze you with fear.
According to two sources familiar with the situation, the studio’s internal announcement of Kurvitz’s departure late last year also contained a threat of possible legal action against him. Any split would have been made messier by Kurvitz and Rostov being shareholders in the studio, the sources said. It’s also clear ZA/UM has gone out of its way to try and keep the situation quiet. Kotaku reached out for an interview with Kurvitz in February. The studio declined on his behalf, but provided no indication the developer had already left the company.
While it’s not clear exactly why Kurvitz, Rostov, and Hindpere are no longer working at ZA/UM, Luiga’s post and subsequent comments and tweets insinuate that the core team was pushed out by the business side of the studio. “The money people come from a background which says you gotta grab when you can even when it in fact does not make much economic sense,” he tweeted.
In response to one commenter claiming “the suits have killed disco,” Luiga posted a picture of the game’s executive producers, Tõnis Haavel and Kaur Kender. Haavel was previously convicted of investment fraud in Estonia, while Kender was the one who initially persuaded Kurvitz to write the book that would later inspire Disco Elysium. “Once we got Kaur on board, everything really started flowing because Kaur has this superpower that’s very important in capitalism,” Kurvitz told Gamesradar in 2020. “He understands money.” Earlier this year, Amazon inked a deal with DJ2 Entertainment, the production company currently planning film adaptations of Disco Elysium and a bunch of other games.
While ZA/UM hasn’t officially announced a sequel to Disco Elysium, Kurvitz had previously spoken about wanting to do what Baldur’s Gate 2 did for Baldur’s Gate 1, heavily implying that one was in the works. Job listings spotted earlier this year included one for an environmental artist that mentioned expanded worlds and “sci-fi,” as well as one for a sales monitizations specialist.
The studio hasn’t yet commented directly on the latest allegations either. “Like any video game, the development of Disco Elysium was and still is a collective effort, with every team member’s contribution essential and valued as part of a greater whole,” a spokesperson for ZA/UM told Kotaku in a statement. “At this time, we have no further comment to make other than the ZA/UM creative team’s focus remains on the development of our next project, and we are excited to share more news on this with you all soon.”
Luiga, Kurvitz, Rostov, and Hindpere did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
     

source

Loretta Lynn's 'Van Lear Rose': a gift from a songwriting master – Tennessean

source

'Moonrise' Anime Series: Coming to Netflix in 2024 and What We Know So Far – What's on Netflix

‘Moonrise’ Anime Series: Coming to Netflix in 2024 and What We Know So Far  What’s on Netflix
source

Titus Andronicus: The Will to Live Album Review – Pitchfork

Titus Andronicus: The Will to Live Album Review  Pitchfork
source

‹ Previous Next ›