Update your browser to view this website correctly. Update my browser now × Home›Recording›Music Production The Fix the Mix Job Fair, a networking event for women and non-binary music industry pros, will take place this weekend in New York. By Mix Staff
New York, NY (August 8, 2022)—We Are Moving the Needle, a nonprofit organization that aims to close the gender gap in the technical fields of the recording industry, has announced the first Fix the Mix Job Fair, a networking event designed to create opportunities and connections for women and non-binary music industry professionals. The Fix the Mix Job Fair will take place during the She Knows Tech Summit in New York on August 11-14, 2022 at Power Station at Berklee NYC. We Are Moving the Needle launched Fix the Mix with Jaxsta earlier this year with the mission to streamline the search process for finding and connecting with women and non-binary music industry professionals. Under-represented participants can network with representatives from studios, labels, tech companies, educational institutions, and more. According to a statement, there will be opportunities to connect, ask questions and submit resumes and discographies for open positions. There will also be plug-n-play rooms for participants to share their music on-site with record label A&R executives, booking agents and managers. The She Knows Tech Summit features We Are Moving the Needle soundBoard members: Grammy-nominated artist-producer Carolyn Malachi, Grammy-winning engineer Shani Gandhi, Grammy-nominated producer LaNell Grant, Grammy-nominated engineer, songwriter and producer Suzy Shinn and Emily Lazar, founder of We Are Moving the Needle/the first woman to win a Grammy for Best Engineered Album, and many others. The She Knows Tech Summit boasts more than 15 sessions and more than 30 women and gender-expansive audio professionals. In-person participants will have a chance to explore and learn in one of the most awarded and decorated studios in the world, right in the heart of New York City: Power Station at Berklee NYC. Supported by audio brands like Ableton, Spitfire Audio, iZotope, Apogee, Kilohearts, Antares, and Sweetwater Sound, the She Knows Tech Summit offers dynamic programming focused on music production, sound design, immersive audio, live performance & DJing. This event is exclusively for She Knows Tech Pass holders. Registration is open at: summit.sheknows.tech Tags ⋅fix the mix ⋅ job fair ⋅ power station at Berkleenyc ⋅ she knows tech ⋅ We Are Moving The Needle Mix Staff
Thank you for visiting nature.com. You are using a browser version with limited support for CSS. To obtain the best experience, we recommend you use a more up to date browser (or turn off compatibility mode in Internet Explorer). In the meantime, to ensure continued support, we are displaying the site without styles and JavaScript. Advertisement Nature Communicationsvolume 13, Article number: 4801 (2022) Cite this article Metrics details Understanding how parents’ cognitive and non-cognitive skills influence offspring education is essential for educational, family and economic policy. We use genetics (GWAS-by-subtraction) to assess a latent, broad non-cognitive skills dimension. To index parental effects controlling for genetic transmission, we estimate indirect parental genetic effects of polygenic scores on childhood and adulthood educational outcomes, using siblings (N = 47,459), adoptees (N = 6407), and parent-offspring trios (N = 2534) in three UK and Dutch cohorts. We find that parental cognitive and non-cognitive skills affect offspring education through their environment: on average across cohorts and designs, indirect genetic effects explain 36–40% of population polygenic score associations. However, indirect genetic effects are lower for achievement in the Dutch cohort, and for the adoption design. We identify potential causes of higher sibling- and trio-based estimates: prenatal indirect genetic effects, population stratification, and assortative mating. Our phenotype-agnostic, genetically sensitive approach has established overall environmental effects of parents’ skills, facilitating future mechanistic work. Parents and children tend to have similar educational outcomes1. Since education is highly predictive of social mobility and health across the lifespan2,3, understanding the mechanisms underlying the intergenerational transmission of education could inform efforts to alleviate inequalities. Many studies have investigated how much certain parental characteristics influence offspring education, but relatively few have considered non-cognitive skills. The term ‘non-cognitive’ describes skills that differ from what has traditionally been education’s primary focus: academic and cognitive performance. The umbrella of non-cognitive skills encompasses a wide range of competencies, including academic motivation, perseverance, mindsets, learning strategies, and social skills4,5. Cognitive skills like executive functioning, working memory, and verbal IQ are more precisely integral to cognitive functioning, but both cognitive and non-cognitive skills are critical for educational success4. Research in developmental psychology6, economics7, and sociology8 has suggested that parents socially influence their children’s non-cognitive skills including emotion regulation, social capacities, attitudes and motivations9,10. Given that non-cognitive skills (particularly self-control and emotion regulation11,12) support education, it follows that parents’ non-cognitive skills may also affect children’s educational outcomes. Prior research has detected small associations between measured parental non-cognitive skills and offspring educational outcomes. In one study, mothers’ locus of control was the only significant non-cognitive predictor of offspring college attendance (β = 0.02, p < 0.05; β = ~0.01 for maternal self-concept and self-esteem, both non-significant)13. Mothers’ cognitive skills, measured by the U.S. Armed Forces Qualifying Test, were a stronger predictor (β = 0.06, p < 0.01). Another study found that fathers’ non-cognitive skills were associated with sons’ standardised test scores at age 16 (β = 0.09)14. Here, non-cognitive skills were measured by a single composite of extraversion, neuroticism, persistence, and perseverance from a standardised Swedish military-oriented psychological evaluation. Additionally, parents’ attitudes towards education and social skills have been found to account for 8% of the socioeconomic gap in children’s achievement15. The contributions of specific measured parental traits that were included were also not stated. Two key limitations weaken this base of evidence on the effects of parents’ skills on offspring education: challenges with phenotypic assessments of parents’ non-cognitive skills, and genetic confounding. First, regarding assessment, whereas cognitive skills can be directly measured by tests of domain-specific or general cognitive performance, non-cognitive skills are more challenging to capture16,17. There is little agreement on what non-cognitive skills to measure. Some researchers focus on personality, whereas others include self-control, self-esteem, motivation, and interests. Importantly, studies identifying partial effects of specific parental cognitive and non-cognitive skills are less informative about the overall influences of these domains. Measurement error could also mean that effects of parents’ non-cognitive skills have been underestimated. Genetic methods offer an alternative approach to defining parents’ non-cognitive skills. Both cognitive and typically-studied non-cognitive skills are substantially genetically influenced, with twin study heritability estimates of 40–70%18,19. A new method—‘GWAS-by-subtraction’—makes it possible to assess a broad latent genetic non-cognitive construct, by ‘subtracting’ cognitive ability-related genetic variation from educational attainment genetic variation20. This follows an influential definition of non-cognitive skills from economics21 as all traits positively contributing to educational and professional success that are not cognitive skills. This non-cognitive genetic construct—which could otherwise be conceptualized as ‘not-cognitive’—is associated with higher socioeconomic attainment, more open and conscientious personality, and some psychiatric disorders (e.g., higher risk for schizophrenia, lower risk for attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder). In the present study, we use this GWAS-by-subtraction measure of non-cognitive skills to capture the overall effect of all non-cognitive parent phenotypes on offspring education. This phenotype-agnostic approach is somewhat loose: it could include parental phenotypes not traditionally classed as ‘non-cognitive’ or ‘skills’. However, it provides a useful first step towards characterizing pathways from specific parental skills to offspring educational outcomes. After establishing overall effects, complementary research designs using measured parental non-cognitive skills can subsequently be used to identify specific mediating mechanisms. A second challenge is to distinguish social (i.e., environmental) from genetic transmission. None of the associations between parental skills and offspring education cited above were estimated using genetically sensitive designs. This is problematic, because from just parent-offspring correlations one cannot conclude that parents’ skills shape offspring education, for instance by providing resources, experiences, and support. Ignoring any shared genetic influences on parents’ skills and child educational outcomes confounds estimation of the effects of parental phenotypes on offspring outcome22. To establish the extent that parents’ (non-)cognitive skills influence child educational outcomes socially, it is vital to control for inherited genetic effects. Genetic study designs can isolate environmental effects of parental skills on offspring education, controlling for genetic transmission. Several designs estimate a genetic effect of the child’s genotype on the child phenotype (direct genetic effect), and an environmentally mediated effect of the parental genotype on the child’s phenotype (parental indirect genetic effect). For example, non-transmitted genetic variants affect offspring phenotypes indirectly via the environment shaped by parental phenotypes23,24. Polygenic scores (individual-level indices of trait-specific genetic endowment; PGS) for educational attainment based on parents’ non-transmitted variants, are associated with offspring attainment25,26,27. Complementary evidence of indirect effects of parents’ education-linked genetics on offspring education has also accumulated from sibling and adoption PGS designs25,26,28,29. To obtain estimates of indirect genetic effects using sibling data, within-sibling genetic associations (first developed to estimate direct genetic effects independent of population biases30,31) are compared to population-based associations. To obtain estimates of indirect genetic effects using adoption data, genetic associations estimated for adoptees and non-adopted individuals are compared29. Notably, variance decomposition as well as PGS methods can be applied to disentangle direct and indirect genetic effects, but the former requires much larger sample sizes32,33,34,35. It is not known whether parental indirect genetic effects on offspring education occur through cognitive or non-cognitive pathways (or both), because studies have not parsed out the contributions of sub-components of the educational attainment PGS. Here, we directly compare estimates of parental indirect genetic effects obtained from different designs. Estimation of genetic associations may involve numerous biases36,37,38. Sibling, adoption, and non-transmitted allele designs have different assumptions and subtle differences in biases and components affecting the estimated indirect genetic effect. As shown by our data simulations indirect genetic effect estimates from the adoption design may be less biased by population stratification and assortative mating than the sibling and non-transmitted allele designs (see Supplementary Note 6 and our GitHub repository39). However, estimates obtained from the adoption design do not capture prenatal parental environmental effects on child education and may be less generalisable to the population. The sibling design may estimate parental indirect genetic effects with more bias from sibling genetic effects. Triangulation across designs and sensitivity analyses can help detect possible biases and quantify parental indirect genetic effects and other environmental effects37,40. In the current study (pre-registration: https://osf.io/mk938/), we use a novel approach to estimate the social effects of parents’ cognitive and non-cognitive skills on offspring education. We deploy GWAS-by-subtraction to estimate individuals’ genetic endowments (PGS) for cognitive and non-cognitive skills, and test how much these operate environmentally via parental influences on offspring educational outcomes. We provide a comparison of parental indirect genetic effects in three cohorts of genotyped families in two countries (UK Biobank, UK Twins Early Development Study, Netherlands Twin Register). Each cohort includes multiple achievement outcome measures (i.e., standardised test results and teacher-reported grades in childhood and adolescence) and attainment (i.e., years of completed education reported in adulthood). We triangulate across three complementary study designs for estimating parental indirect genetic effects and assess the presence of components and biases. We identified the genetic components of cognitive and non-cognitive skills using Genomic SEM, following Demange et al.20, in samples that excluded participants used for polygenic score analyses. Educational attainment and cognitive performance meta-analytic summary statistics (see Methods) were regressed on two independent latent variables, Cog and NonCog (see Supplementary Fig. 1). These two latent factors were then regressed on 1,071,804 HapMap3 SNPs in a genome wide association (GWA) design. The LD score regression-based SNP heritabilities of Cog and NonCog were 0.184 (SE = 0.007) and 0.054 (SE = 0.002), respectively. More information on the GWAS is presented in Supplementary Data 1. SNP associations with the Cog and NonCog latent variables provided the weights to create individual-level polygenic scores in 3 cohorts with family data and educational achievement and/or attainment outcomes. Sample sizes for individuals with polygenic score and educational outcome data were: 39,500 UK Biobank siblings, 6409 UK Biobank adoptees, up to 4796 DZ twins in the Twins Early Development Study (TEDS), up to 3163 twins and siblings in the Netherlands Twin Register (NTR), and up to 2534 NTR individuals with both parents genotyped. Full phenotypic descriptive statistics are available in Supplementary Data 2. To estimate direct offspring-led and indirect parent-led effects of PGS for cognitive and non-cognitive skills on educational outcomes, we considered three family-based genomic designs. The designs are illustrated in Fig. 1. All models jointly included Cog and NonCog PGS. Note that population effects are equivalent to PGS effects estimated in standard population analyses that do not use within-family data. In contrast, within-family designs exploit the principles of Mendelian segregation or the natural experiment of adoption to separate direct and indirect/social components of the overall population PGS effect. Importantly, a direct genetic effect is only direct in the sense that it does not originate from another individual’s genotype. Direct effects are also not ‘purely’ genetic, but lead to educational outcomes via intermediate pathways, and are expressed in the context of environments. Square = observed variable, circle = unobserved/latent variable; β = estimated effect of polygenic score (PGS) on outcome; the population effect of a PGS captures both direct and indirect genetic effects; direct genetic effects (controlling for indirect genetic effects) are represented with solid arrows. Icons made by Freepik from www.flaticon.com. First, the sibling design estimates indirect genetic effects by comparing population-level and within-family (i.e., within-sibling or within-DZ twin) PGS associations (Eq. (1))28. The direct effect of a polygenic score is estimated based on genetic differences between siblings, which are due to random segregations of parental genetic material, independent of shared family effects (including parental indirect genetic effects). Specifically, the direct effect is estimated using a variable representing individuals’ polygenic scores minus the average polygenic score for their family: the within-family beta (βWithin in Eq. (1)). The population effect of a polygenic score is estimated in a separate model, simply regressing the outcome variable on polygenic score differences between individuals from different families (Eq. (2)). The indirect genetic effect is obtained by subtracting the within-family PGS effect estimate from the population effect estimate. Note: EA is the educational outcome, PGS is the polygenic score (for Cog PGSCog and NonCog PGSNonCog). (overline{{{{{{{{rm{PGS}}}}}}}}}) refers to the average polygenic score in the family j. i refers to the individual sibling. α0 refers to the intercept, Z are covariates for the individual i: sex, age, sex*age, the first 10 principal components, and genotyping platform. See Supplementary Note 5 for a comparison of different versions of this sibling design, using data simulations. Second, indirect genetic effects can be estimated by comparing polygenic score associations estimated in a sample of adoptees against those estimated for individuals who were reared by their biological parents29. Therefore, we estimate the regression model shown in Eq. (2) separately for adoptees and for non-adopted individuals. The population effect is estimated as the polygenic score effect on phenotypic variation among non-adopted individuals (i.e., a combination of direct and indirect genetic mechanisms). The direct genetic effect is the effect of the polygenic score among adoptees. Adoptees do not share genes by descent with their adoptive parents, so we expect their polygenic scores to be uncorrelated with the genotypes of their adoptive parents. Therefore, the polygenic score effect in adoptees cannot be inflated by environmentally mediated parental indirect genetic effects. In this design, the indirect genetic effect is estimated by subtracting this direct PGS effect from the population effect estimated in the non-adopted group. When taking the difference, it is important that the groups are similar in terms of all observed and unobserved confounders, an untestable assumption that is unlikely to always hold. We found small differences between adoptees and non-adopted individuals in the UK Biobank in their demographic and early-life characteristics. Cohen’s d values were d < 0.15 for Cog and NonCog PGS and educational attainment, and d = 0.31 for birth weight. The pattern of geographical clustering of adopted and non-adopted participants across the UK was highly similar (see Supplementary Data 11, Supplementary Note 3, and Supplementary Fig. 2). Third, indirect genetic effects can be estimated, and disentangled from direct genetic effects, using information on parental genetic variation that was not transmitted to offspring25,26 (Eq. (3)). The population effect is estimated from a polygenic score based on transmitted variants (βT). Transmitted genetic variants are present in an offspring and in at least one of their parents, and so may influence offspring education via both direct and indirect mechanisms. The parental indirect genetic effect is estimated as the effect of a polygenic score based on parental variants that were not transmitted to offspring (βNT). Non-transmitted variants can only take effect on offspring education through the environment. The direct genetic effect is estimated by partialling out the effect of the non-transmitted polygenic score from that of the transmitted polygenic score (βT − βNT). Maternal and paternal scores are averaged to create overall parental non-transmitted polygenic scores. We did not distinguish between maternal and paternal PGS, due to the replicated evidence that mothers’ and fathers’ PGS for educational attainment have equal effects on offspring education41,42, and to enable closer comparison with the adoption and sibling designs, which yield estimates of the overall parental genetic effect. Notably, regressing offspring phenotype on offspring PGS and parental PGS would allow equivalent estimation of the parental indirect genetic effect without haplotype estimation43. We investigated environmental effects of parents’ non-cognitive and cognitive skills on offspring education by estimating parental indirect genetic effects of NonCog and Cog PGS. Figure 2a shows that, for both NonCog and Cog PGS, indirect genetic effects of parents on offspring education were present (meta-analytic indirect βNonCog = 0.08, SE = 0.03; indirect βCog = 0.10, SE = 0.01), in addition to direct genetic effects (direct βNonCog = 0.14, SE = 0.03; direct βCog = 0.15, SE = 0.02). Averaged across all designs, outcomes and cohorts, indirect environmentally mediated effects explained 36% of the population effect of the NonCog PGS, and 40% of the population effect of the Cog PGS. However, results varied depending on the methods used and outcomes investigated. Results per cohort, outcome and design, as well as population genetic effects and the ratio of indirect to population effects are reported in Supplementary Data 3 and Supplementary Figs. 3, 4 and 5. Meta-analytic results are reported in Supplementary Data 4. Z-tests results comparing direct and indirect effects are reported in Supplementary Data 5. a Meta-analytic results. Meta-analysed estimates of direct and indirect genetic effects of NonCog and Cog PGS on educational outcomes (N = 68,919). Indirect genetic effects work through the environment that parents provide for their children. Beta coefficients were obtained from meta-analysis of effects across cohorts, designs and outcome phenotypes; bars = 95% CIs. b Sibling design by cohort. Estimates of direct and indirect effects of NonCog and Cog PGS by cohort (for age 12 and adult outcomes), using the sibling design only. NTR is a Dutch cohort (N = 1631 and N = 3163 respectively), TEDS (N = 2862) and UKB (N = 16,624) are UK cohorts; bars = 95% CIs. c Educational attainment by design. Estimates of direct and indirect effect of NonCog and Cog PGS by analytic design (for adult educational attainment outcomes only). Samples sizes: N = 42,663 (results meta-analysed across UKB and NTR); N = 6407 adoptees and 6500 non-adopted individuals (UKB); N = 2534 trios in NTR; bars = 95%CIs. Figure 2b shows estimates of direct and indirect genetic effects of NonCog and Cog PGS for different cohorts and educational outcomes, holding the design constant (i.e., the sibling design, which was available for all cohorts and outcomes). Estimates were highly consistent across cohorts except for age 12 achievement in Dutch versus UK cohorts: indirect genetic effects were negligible and represented a small fraction of the population effect in NTR (3% and 23% for NonCog and Cog, respectively), whereas they accounted for 56% and 48% of the population effects of NonCog and Cog PGS in TEDS. For adult educational attainment, estimates of direct and indirect effects were more similar for the Dutch (NTR: indirect βNonCog = 0.11, SE = 0.03; indirect βCog = 0.06, SE = 0.03) and UK (UKB: indirect βNonCog = 0.12, SE = 0.01; indirect βCog = 0.12, SE = 0.01) cohorts. See Supplementary Data 3 for full results. Figure 2c shows estimates of direct and indirect genetic effects of NonCog and Cog PGS for different designs, holding the phenotype constant (i.e., educational attainment, which was available for all three methods). While estimates obtained with sibling and non-transmitted PGS methods indicate equal indirect effect sizes (indirect βs for educational attainment ranged between 0.11 and 0.12; see Supplementary Data 3 and 4), the adoption design yielded low to null indirect genetic effects for both NonCog and Cog PGS (indirect βNonCog = 0.02, SE = 0.02; indirect βCog = 0.08, SE = 0.02). Figure 3 summarises how the three designs estimate parental indirect genetic effects in the presence of different contributors, thus highlighting possible explanations for lower adoption-based estimates. This information is based on simulations (see Supplementary Notes4 and 6, Supplementary Fig. 9, and our GitHub repository39). We consider prenatal and postnatal parental indirect genetic effects as components of the total parental indirect genetic effect, and other simulated contributors as biases. First, unlike the sibling and non-transmitted allele designs, the adoption design does not capture indirect genetic effects occurring in the prenatal period. Second, the adoption design estimates indirect genetic effects with less bias from population stratification. Third, the adoption design estimates indirect genetic effects with less bias from assortative mating than the sibling design, and, most likely, than the non-transmitted alleles design. How the bias in the adoption design estimates compares to the non-transmitted design depends on the precision of the polygenic score, see Supplementary Note 6. Any excess indirect genetic effect estimated in the sibling/non-transmitted allele designs compared to the adoption design therefore indicates the overall impact of prenatal indirect genetic effects, population stratification, and assortative mating. Sibling indirect genetic effects are an important potential influence to consider, but cannot explain the empirical results because they only do not affect indirect effect estimates from adoption and non-transmitted designs differently (they mainly inflate sibling-based estimates). Components include parental prenatal and postnatal indirect genetic effects. Biases include sibling indirect genetic effects, assortative mating, and population stratification. Boxplots of 100 replicates based on a simulated sample of 20,000 families. The center line represents the median, the box limits are the 1st and 3rd quartile, and the whiskers reach the maximum value within 1.5 times the interquartile range. Outlying values are not represented. For clarity, the red line benchmarks the true simulated postnatal parental indirect effect, although we note that prenatal parental genetic effects are a component rather than a bias of the parental indirect genetic effect. With the adoption design, the indirect genetic effect of the NonCog PGS on educational attainment in UK Biobank is 83% lower than with the sibling design, while it is only 33% lower for Cog. This suggests that estimates for NonCog are affected more strongly than Cog by population stratification, assortative mating and/or prenatal indirect genetic effects. Although triangulating designs suggested that prenatal indirect genetic effects, population stratification, and assortative mating may contribute to the higher estimated parental indirect genetic effects from non-transmitted alleles/sibling designs relative to the adoption design, this approach cannot disentangle the relative importance of these individual biases. To this end, we conducted additional sensitivity analyses to assess the magnitudes of these biases (not pre-registered). First, we analysed the GWAS summary data on which the polygenic scores were based, using LD score regression to detect population stratification. The LD score regression ratio statistics of uncorrected educational attainment and cognitive performance GWAS were 0.11 (SE = 0.01) and 0.06 (SE = 0.01), respectively (Supplementary Data 1). These non-null estimates indicated that a small but significant portion of the GWAS signal was potentially attributable to residual population stratification. As cognitive performance seems less prone to population stratification than EA, it is possible our estimates of direct and indirect genetic effects of NonCog were more biased by population stratification than Cog. Second, we detected slight evidence of assortative mating, which appeared stronger in the UK than Dutch cohorts. In NTR, parental PGS correlations are non-significant (NonCog r = 0.03, Cog r = 0.02). Sibling PGS intraclass correlations ranged between 0.49 and 0.52 in NTR, and between 0.53 and 0.56 in TEDS and UK Biobank. This supports the presence of assortative mating on NonCog and Cog PGS potentially biasing our estimates of indirect genetic effects in UK cohorts, but less in our Dutch cohort. See Supplementary Data 6 for full correlations. Third, our sensitivity analyses did not support the presence of indirect effects of siblings’ NonCog and Cog PGS on individuals’ educational outcomes. Our first approach leveraged sibling polygenic scores, the rationale being that in the presence of a sibling effect, a sibling’s PGS will influence a child’s outcome beyond child and parent PGS. In NTR, siblings’ NonCog or Cog PGS had non-significant effects (Supplementary Data 7). In a second approach, the difference in PGS effects on EA between monozygotic (MZ) and dizygotic (DZ) individuals was tested. Since MZ twins are more genetically similar than DZ twins, their PGS should capture more of the indirect genetic effect of their twin. In NTR and TEDS, PGS effects were not significantly different between MZs and DZs (Supplementary Data 8 and Supplementary Fig. 6). Finally, in UKB, we tested PGS effects on EA given the number of siblings individuals reported having. If more siblings lead to a stronger sibling effect, this will be captured as an increased effect of an individual’s own PGS on the outcome in the presence of more genetically related siblings. As a negative control, we conducted the same analysis in adoptees. Since adoptees are unrelated to their siblings, their PGS do not capture sibling effects at any family size. NonCog PGS effects weakly increased with number of siblings, but this pattern was also present in adoptees, suggesting confounding by unobserved characteristics of families with numerous children (Supplementary Data 9 and Supplementary Fig. 7). We used genetic methods to study environmental effects of parents’ skills on child education. We found evidence that characteristics tagged by NonCog and Cog polygenic scores (PGS) are both involved in how parents provide environments conducive to offspring education. Indeed, indirect genetic mechanisms explained 36% of the population effect of the NonCog PGS, and 40% of the population effect of the Cog PGS (population βNonCog = 0.22, SE = 0.01; population βCog = 0.25, SE = 0.01). This result was consistent across countries, generations, outcomes, and analytic designs, with two notable exceptions. First, estimated parental indirect genetic effects were null for childhood achievement in our Dutch cohort (NTR), but not for comparable outcomes in our UK cohort (TEDS). Second, parental indirect genetic effects estimated with the adoption design were lower than for the sibling and non-transmitted allele designs, particularly for the NonCog PGS. Given our evidence from data simulations that the adoption-based estimates of indirect genetic effects do not account for prenatal effects and may be more robust to population stratification and assortative mating, these factors may contribute substantially to estimates from the other two designs, especially for the NonCog PGS. This was supported by results from sensitivity analyses. This study demonstrates the utility of genetic methods for assessing elusive phenomena: non-cognitive skills, and genuine environmental influences from parents, unconfounded by offspring-led effects of inherited genes. Compared to analysing a set of measured parental non-cognitive skills, our GWAS-by-subtraction approach captures a wider array of traits linked genetically to attainment, and therefore broadly quantifies the overall salience of parents’ non-cognitive skills. Our evidence that parents’ non-cognitive and cognitive skills are both important for children’s education complements the growing literature that has considered effects of specific measured skills within both of these domains13,14. These studies found that effects of parents’ non-cognitive skills on offspring education were less than half the size of the effects of parents’ cognitive skills. In contrast, we found that indirect genetic effects of NonCog PGS were almost as large as for Cog skills. This discrepancy might stem in part from our comprehensive definition of non-cognitive skills, as we do not rely on possibly unreliable and incomplete phenotypic measures. Importantly, the parental indirect genetic effects we have identified may capture proximal forms of ‘nurture’ (e.g., a parent directly training their child’s cognitive skills, or cultivating their child’s learning habits through participation and support) and/or more distal environmental effects (e.g., a parent’s openness to experience leading them to move to an area with good schools). The environmental effects of parents’ non-cognitive and cognitive skills are likely to be larger than we estimate, because our approach only captures effects of parent skills tagged by current GWAS. Polygenic scores index a subset of the common genetic component of parent skills, which is in turn a fraction of the total genetic component (missing heritability44,45), and cannot account for the non-heritable component of parent skills. The lower importance of parental indirect genetic effects for child achievement in the Netherlands compared to the UK indicates that our UK achievement outcomes more strongly capture variation in family background. This difference could result from the design of these achievement measures: Dutch test results are standardized based on a representative population, but UK teacher reports might still be affected by student social background. Societal differences between the two countries might offer another explanation, as indirect genetic effects might be seen as indicator of social inequality (similarly to shared-environment variance in twin studies46). For adult attainment, results were more similar across UK and Dutch cohorts, corresponding with recent evidence for consistent shared-environment influence on educational attainment across social models47. This consistency also suggests that the difference in childhood is not due to a cohort or population difference. The higher indirect genetic effects in adult attainment in the Netherlands might reflect an increase in environmental variance following tracking taking place in secondary schools27. Indeed, socioeconomic disparities in achievement seem to increase more between ages 10 and 15 in the Netherlands than in the UK48 and children whose parents have a higher education are more likely to enrol in a higher educational track independently of their achievement at age 1249, suggestive of greater parental effects on secondary and later education, which should be tested in further studies. We found that the design used to estimate indirect genetic effects matters, with the adoption design giving systematically lower estimates. Direct comparison of results across designs suggested that 33% (for Cog) and 83% (for NonCog) of the indirect genetic effects on adult educational attainment, estimated using the sibling design, are at least in part due to population stratification, assortative mating, and prenatal indirect genetic effects. The importance of population stratification for genetic associations with educational attainment was suggested by recent UK Biobank studies50,51. Our sensitivity analyses also indicated residual population stratification, which was more severe for the NonCog GWAS. There was some evidence of assortative mating, with sibling PGS correlations above expectation (>0.5) particularly in the UK cohorts. This country difference in assortment is supported by the lower estimated spouse PGS correlations in NTR (0.02 for Cog, 0.03 for NonCog) than for the EA PGS in the UK Biobank (0.06)52. There was no statistically significant difference in assortative mating between Cog and NonCog, suggesting that population stratification explains the particularly large design-based discrepancy between estimates of indirect genetic effects for NonCog (but possibly also differential bias in the Cog versus NonCog GWAS; see Limitations). Population stratification should be carefully considered in studies using NonCog PGS. Structural equation models, leveraging within-family polygenic scores and phenotypes, are being developed to parse the contributions of indirect and direct genetic effects to complex traits from assortative mating (both disequilibrium and equilibrium forms) and population stratification53,54. Another consideration for future research is that indirect genetic effects on education might span across more than a single generation, for example the influence of grandparents. Since cumulative indirect genetic effects are all removed when a child is adopted, their presence would contribute to the observed difference in indirect effect between the adoption and other designs. Regarding siblings, we did not find evidence that indirect effects of siblings’ NonCog and Cog PGS affect individual differences in educational outcomes, using three different approaches. This corresponds with null findings regarding indirect effects of siblings’ educational attainment genetics in the UK Biobank50,51. However, other UK Biobank studies have detected indirect effects of older siblings’ EA PGS on younger siblings’ educational attainment55, and parental compensation for sibling EA PGS differences56, suggesting that more subtle analyses are required to understand sibling effects. There is also some evidence for sibling effects on educational attainment in other populations, based on the EA PGS26 and on extended twin family data57. It is possible that our PGS analyses were not sufficiently powered to detect indirect genetic effects of siblings, since they were based on lower sample size than our main analyses. However, our results suggest that indirect genetic effects of siblings on education are small. Therefore, our methods provide good proxies for parental indirect genetic effects, with minimal inflation from sibling effects. Our data suggest that the adoption design may provide a useful lower-bound estimate of indirect genetic effects of parents. Given that there was no evidence for sibling effects of the Cog or NonCog PGS, our adoption-based estimates, which appear to be less biased by population stratification and assortative mating, should give a closer measure of (postnatal) parental indirect genetic effects in the absence of other issues. However, adoptees and non-adopted individuals differ in unobserved and observed ways, including birthweight (d = 0.3). These differences likely make adoption-based estimates of indirect genetic effects, which rely on a comparison of the two groups, less reliable. Moreover, three additional factors may make the adoption-based estimates of indirect genetic effects too conservative. First, adoption based indirect effect estimates exclude prenatal indirect genetic effects (and indirect genetic effects taking place between the birth and moment of adoption), which might influence educational outcomes58,59. While we are unable to test for prenatal indirect effects, these could be investigated in cohorts with pregnancy information, adjusting for postnatal indirect genetic effects. Second, adoptees may have been exposed to a narrower range of environments (e.g., family socioeconomic status) compared to non-adopted individuals60. This form of selection bias is likely to increase the genetic variance at the expense of the indirect genetic effect. Third, selective placement of children in adoptive families matching characteristics of their biological families, or adoption of children by close relatives61, could result in correlation between child and (adoptive) parent genotypes, leading to an underestimation of the indirect genetic effect. There is modest evidence for selective placement of adoptees based on education in the US62. We cannot control for selection and relatedness (e.g., by excluding individuals who were adopted by relatives and/or adopted relatively late in development), since there is no information on the adoptive parents in the UK Biobank resource. We acknowledge several limitations. First, while we suggest that an attribute of our study is the broad and phenotype-agnostic characterisation of non-cognitive skills, our GWAS-by-subtraction approach is unable to identify specific parental characteristics and is also still limited by measures of cognitive performance and educational attainment in the original GWAS. Some cognitive skills might not be reflected in the available Cognitive Performance GWAS, so the NonCog factor could capture genetic influences affecting cognition. However, previous analyses have shown that a NonCog PGS based on GWAS-by-subtraction predicts substantially less variation in cognition than the Cog PGS20. Additionally, our NonCog latent variable reflects the residual variance of adult educational attainment, and therefore is a measure of non-cognitive aspects of adult EA. Non-cognitive aspects of childhood achievement might differ somewhat, which might lead to an underestimation of indirect genetic effects of the NonCog PGS on these outcomes. Second, the generalisability of our results is limited. Highly educated individuals are over-represented in all cohorts. Participation bias also affects GWAS results63. Selection effects may be especially strong in the adoption design as adoptions may depend on (partially heritable) phenotypes of the biological parents, and many adoptive parents are also selected based on their (partially heritable) behavioural phenotypes. Additionally, only participants of European descent were included in the analysis. Third, replication efforts are needed. Special effort should be targeted to include diverse ancestry participants. While our overall estimates are well powered due to the aggregation of cohorts, some analyses rely on a single sample. As such, results from these analyses might reflect specifics of these samples and not design-specific biases and should be replicated. Fourth, although our within-family methods allowed us to evaluate biases in polygenic score effects within the target samples, the same biases are likely to influence the effect size estimates from the original population-based GWAS used to construct polygenic scores. This problem has been explored in relation to the sibling design in a recent preprint64, but remains to be investigated for non-transmitted PGS and adoption designs. Population GWAS effects could be differentially affected (i.e., stronger correlation between direct and indirect genetic effects) for NonCog versus Cog, which would make their respective PGS effects less comparable. Increasingly large within-family GWAS35,65 of Cog and EA will allow this to be resolved. Finally, while we conceptualize our NonCog PGS as a non-cognitive measure, it could also be considered a ‘not-cognitive PGS’, since it is a residual construct that results from removing heritable variance associated with cognitive skills from the heritable variance in educational attainment. In the future, it may be useful to develop a more precise non-cognitive skills GWAS, by creating the latent Cog and NonCog factors using additional measured phenotypes. To this end, large GWA meta-analyses should be completed not only for personality66 but for other classic non-cognitive skills such as motivation and self-control. Several additional future research directions emerge. First, given that we have quantified the overall environmental effects of parents on offspring education tagged by NonCog and Cog PGS, the next step is to identify specific mediating parent characteristics, whether proximal or distal. It will be informative to test not only typical non-cognitive skills measures such as parental locus of control (as suggested by13), but also ‘not-cognitive’ characteristics that do not appear in non-cognitive skill batteries yet are genetically correlated with the NonCog PGS and phenotypically correlated with offspring achievement. For instance, parental depression is a feasible partial mediator, given that Major Depressive Disorder is significantly genetically correlated with NonCog (rg = −0.19, p = 2.62E−14)20, and maternal depression is associated with offspring mathematics performance, possibly via offspring executive function67. Researchers could also examine mediating child characteristics on the pathway between their parents’ characteristics and their own educational outcomes. Children’s skills themselves might not be involved in these pathways. Indeed, educated parents do not appear to affect offspring education by fostering non-cognitive skill development11, and twin research shows no influence of shared environmental factors on individual differences in children’s measured non-cognitive skills such as grit and self-control68,69,70. A second future direction is to incorporate gender and socioeconomic status into research on indirect genetic effects on education. Twin data show that shared environmental contributions to educational attainment are larger for women than for men47. It is unknown whether this finding holds for indirect genetic effects and for childhood achievement. Another gender aspect to consider is differential maternal and paternal indirect genetic effects33. There is some evidence (although not genetically informed) that mother and father skills show unique associations with offspring education14. Indirect effects of parents’ genetic endowment for non-cognitive skills on child education might be mediated or moderated by parents’ income and cultural capital (including school-related skills and habits). While some evidence suggests that home learning environments may be more cognitively stimulating in families of higher socioeconomic71,72, there is also evidence suggesting that mothers who have lower reported incomes also report more frequent activities that facilitate cognitive stimulation73. In sum, this study provides evidence for environmental effects of parents’ non-cognitive and cognitive skills on offspring educational outcomes, indexed by indirect genetic effects of polygenic scores. Combining three cohorts and three designs for estimating indirect genetic effects allowed us to obtain robust findings. These results have significance for human health, as the role parents play in successful cognitive development and (mental) health development go hand in hand. Our research complies with all relevant ethical regulations. Project approval for the Twins Early Development Study (TEDS) was granted by King’s College London’s ethics committee for the Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience PNM/09/10–104. Ethical approval for the Netherlands Twin Register (NTR) was provided by the Central Ethics Committee on Research Involving Human Subjects of the VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, and Institutional Review Board certified by the U.S. Office of Human Research Protections (IRB number IRB-2991 under Federal-wide Assurance-3703; IRB/institute codes 94/105, 96/205, 99/068, 2003/182, 2010/359) and participants provided informed consent. The UK Biobank has received ethical approval from the National Health Service North West Centre for Research Ethics Committee (reference: 11/NW/0382). Informed consent was obtained from all human participants. The study methods were pre-registered on the Open Science Framework (https://osf.io/mk938/) on the 24/02/2020. Additional non-preregistered analyses are indicated as such below and should be considered exploratory. Additional deviations from the pre-registration are detailed in Supplementary Note 1. The UK Biobank is an epidemiological resource including British individuals aged 40 to 70 at recruitment74. Genome-wide genetic data came from the full release of the UK Biobank data, and were collected and processed according to the quality control pipeline75. We defined three subsamples of the UK Biobank to be used for polygenic score analyses: adopted participants, a control group of non-adopted participants, and siblings. Starting with UK Biobank participants with QC genotype data and educational attainment data (N = 451,229), we first identified 6407 unrelated adopted individuals who said yes to the question “Were you adopted as a child?” (Data-Field 1767). We restricted the sample to unrelated participants (kinship coefficient <1/(2^9/2))76. Second, our comparison sample (N = 6500) was drawn at random from non-adopted participants who were unrelated to each other and to the adopted participants. Third, we identified 39,500 full siblings, excluding adopted individuals. We defined full-siblings as participants with a kinship coefficient between 1/(2^(3/2)) and 1/(2^(5/2)) and a probability of zero IBS sharing >0.0012, as suggested by75 and76. After excluding the three sub-samples for polygenic score analyses and individuals related to these participants, we were left with 388,196 UK Biobank individuals with educational attainment (EA) data, and 202,815 individuals with cognitive performance (CP) data. We used these remaining individuals for the GWAS of EA and CP, and later meta-analysis with external GWASs77 (see ‘Statistical Analyses’ and Supplementary Note 2). The Twins Early Development Study (TEDS) is a multivariate, longitudinal study of >10,000 twin pairs representative of England and Wales, recruited 1994–199678. The demographic characteristics of TEDS participants and their families closely match those of families in the UK. Analyses were conducted on a sub-sample of dizygotic (DZ) twin pairs with genome-wide genotyping and phenotypic data on school achievement at age 12 (1431 DZ pairs) and age 16 (2398 pairs). The Netherlands Twin Register (NTR)79 is established by the Department of Biological Psychology at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam and recruits children and adults twins for longitudinal research. Data on health, personality, lifestyle and others, as well as genotyping data have been collected on participants and their families. We included in our analyses genotyped European-ancestry participants. We created a subsample of full-siblings. NTR contains information on numerous monozygotic multiples (twins or triplets). Because MZ multiples share the same genes, we randomly excluded all individuals but one per MZ multiple. Only siblings with complete genetic and outcome data were subsequently included in the analyses: 1631 siblings with CITO (achievement test taken during the last year of primary school) data (from 757 families) and 3163 siblings with EA data available (from 1309 families). We created a subsample with complete offspring, maternal and paternal genotypic data (i.e., trios). Among individuals with available parental genotypes, respectively 1526 (from 765 families) and 2534 (from 1337 families) had reported CITO and EA information. The sibling and trio subsets are not independent: for CITO, 823 participants are present in both subsets, 1374 for EA. Educational attainment and cognitive performance phenotypes were defined following Lee et al. 201877. From data-field 6238, educational attainment was defined according to ISCED categories and coded as the number of Years of Education. The response categories are: none of the above (no qualifications) = 7 years of education; Certificate of Secondary Education (CSEs) or equivalent = 10 years; O levels/GCSEs or equivalent = 10 years; A levels/AS levels or equivalent = 13 years; other professional qualification = 15 years; National Vocational Qualification (NVQ) or Higher National Diploma (HNC) or equivalent = 19 years; college or university degree = 20 years of education. For cognitive performance, we used the (standardized) mean of the standardized scores of the fluid intelligence measure (data-field 20016 for in-person and 20191 for an online assessment). Educational achievement at age 12 was assessed by teacher reports, aggregated across the three core subjects (Mathematics, English, and Science). Educational achievement at age 16 was assessed by self-reported results for standardized tests taken at the end of compulsory education in England, Wales and Northern Ireland: General Certificate of Secondary Education; GCSE). GCSE grades were coded from 4 (G; the minimum pass grade) to 11 (A∗; the highest possible grade). As with the age 12 measure, we analysed a variable representing mean score for the compulsory core subjects. Educational attainment was measured by self-report of the highest obtained degree80. This measure was re-coded as the number of years in education, following Okbay et al. 201681. Academic achievement is assessed in the Netherlands by a nation-wide standardized educational performance test (CITO) around the age of 12 during the last year of primary education. CITO is used to determine tracking placement in secondary school in the Netherlands, in combination with teacher advice. The total score ranges from 500 to 550, reflecting the child’s position relative to the other children taking the test this particular year. SNPs from HapMap3 CEU (1,345,801 SNPs) were filtered out of the imputed UK Biobank dataset. We then did a pre-PCA QC on unrelated individuals, and filtered out SNPs with MAF < 0.01 and missingness > 0.05, leaving 1,252,123 SNPs. After removing individuals with non-European ancestry, we repeated the SNP QC on unrelated Europeans (N = 312,927), excluding SNPs with MAF < 0.01, missingness > 0.05 and HWE p < 10−10, leaving 1,246,531 SNPs. The HWE p-value threshold of 10−10 was based on: http://www.nealelab.is/blog/2019/9/17/genotyped-snps-in-uk-biobank-failing-hardy-weinberg-equilibrium-test. We then created a dataset of 1,246,531 QC-ed SNPs for 456,064 UKB subjects of European ancestry. Principal components were derived from a subset of 131,426 genotyped SNPs, pruned for LD (r2 > 0.2) and long-range LD regions removed82. PCA was conducted on unrelated individuals using flashPCA v283. Two different genotyping platforms were used because genotyping was undertaken in two separate waves. AffymetrixGeneChip 6.0 SNP arrays were used to genotype 3665 individuals. Additionally, 8122 individuals (including 3607 DZ co-twin samples) were genotyped on Illumina HumanOmniExpressExome-8v1.2 arrays. After quality control, 635,269 SNPs remained for AffymetrixGeneChip 6.0 genotypes, and 559,772 SNPs for HumanOmniExpressExome genotypes. Genotypes from the two platforms were separately phased and imputed into the Haplotype Reference Consortium (release 1.1) through the Sanger Imputation Service before merging. Genotypes from a total of 10,346 samples (including 3320 DZ twin pairs and 7026 unrelated individuals) passed quality control, including 3057 individuals genotyped on Affymetrix and 7289 individuals genotyped on Illumina. The identity-by-descent (IBD) between individuals was <0.05 for 99.5% in the merged sample excluding the DZ co-twins (range = 0.00–0.12) and ranged between 0.36 and 0.62 for the DZ twin pairs (mean = 0.49). There were 7,363,646 genotyped or well-imputed SNPs (for full genotype processing and quality control details, see84). To ease high computational demands for the current study, we excluded SNPs with MAF < 1% and info <1. Following this, 619216 SNPs were included in polygenic score construction. Principal components were derived from a subset of 39,353 common (MAF > 5%), perfectly imputed (info = 1) autosomal SNPs, after stringent pruning to remove markers in linkage disequilibrium (r2 > 0.1) and excluding high linkage disequilibrium genomic regions to ensure that only genome-wide effects were detected. Genotyping was done on multiple platforms, following manufacturers protocols: Perlegen-Affymetrix, Affymetrix 6.0, Affymetrix Axiom, Illumina Human Quad Bead 660, Illumina Omni 1 M and Illumina GSA. For each genotype platform, samples were removed if DNA sex did not match the expected phenotype, if the PLINK heterozygosity F statistic was < −0.10 or >0.10, or if the genotyping call rate was <0.90. SNPs were excluded if the MAF < 1 × 10–6, if the Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium p-value was <1 × 10–6, and/or if the call rate was <0.95. The genotype data was then aligned with the 1000 Genomes reference panel using the HRC and 1000 Genomes checking tool, testing and filtering for SNPs with allele frequency differences larger than 0.20 as compared to the CEU population, palindromic SNPs and DNA strand issues. The data of the different platforms was then merged into a single dataset, and one platform was chosen for each individual. Based on the ~10.8 k SNPs that all platforms have in common, DNA identity-by-descent state was estimated for all individual pairs using the Plink 1.9 and King 2.1.6 programs. Samples were excluded if these estimates did not correspond to expected familial relationships. CEU population outliers, based on per platform 1000 Genomes PC projection with the Smartpca software v2.r904, were removed from the data. Then, per platform, the data was phased using Eagle v2.4.1 and then imputed to 1000 Genomes and Topmed using Minimac3-omp v2.10 following the Michigan imputation server protocols. Post-imputation, the resulting separate platform VCF files were merged with Bcftools 1.9 into a single file per chromosome for each reference, for SNPs present on all platforms. For the polygenic scoring and parental re-phasing, the imputed data were converted to best guess data and were filtered to include only ACGT SNPs, SNPs with MAF > 0.01, HWE p > 10–5 and a genotype call rate >0.98, and to exclude SNPs with more than 2 alleles. All mendelian errors were set to missing. The remaining SNPs represent the transmitted alleles dataset. 20 PCs were calculated with Smartpca using LD-pruned 1000 Genomes–imputed SNPs genotyped on at least one platform, having MAF > 0.05 and not present in the long-range LD regions. Using the—tucc option of the Plink 1.07 software pseudo-controls for each offspring were created, given the genotype data of their parents. This resulted in the non-transmitted alleles dataset, as these pseudo-controls correspond to the child’s non-transmitted alleles. To determine the parental origin of each allele, the transmitted and non-transmitted datasets were phased using the duoHMM option of the ShapeIT software. The phased datasets were then split based on parental origin, resulting in a paternal and maternal haploid dataset for the transmitted and non-transmitted alleles. All statistical tests are two-sided, unless otherwise stated. To generate NonCog summary statistics, we implemented a GWAS-by-subtraction using Genomic SEM following Demange et al. 2020 using summary statistics of EA and cognitive performance obtained in samples independent from our polygenic score samples. We ran a GWAS of Educational Attainment and Cognitive Performance in UK Biobank (polygenic score sample left-out). We meta-analysed them with the EA GWAS by Lee et al. excluding 23andMe, UK Biobank and NTR cohorts, and with the CP GWAS by Trampush et al. respectively (EA total N = 707,112 and CP N = 238,113) using Metal software release 2011-03-05. More information on these methods and intermediate GWAS are found in Supplementary Note 2 and Supplementary Data 1. Following Demange et al. 2020, we used EA and CP meta-analysed summary statistics with GenomicSEM to create two independent latent variables: Cog, representing the genetic variance shared between EA and CP, and NonCog representing the residual genetic variance of EA when regressing out CP (Supplementary Fig. 1). These two latent factors were regressed on each SNP: we obtained association for 1,071,804 SNPs (HapMap3 SNPs, as recommended when comparing PGS analyses across cohorts). We calculate the effective sample size of these GWAS to be 458,211 for NonCog and 223,819 for Cog. Polygenic scores of NonCog and Cog were computed with Plink software (version 1.9 for NTR, 2 for UKB and TEDS)85,86 based on weighted betas obtained using the LDpred v1.0.0 software using infinitesimal prior, a LD pruning window of 250 kb and 1000Genomes phase 3 CEU population as LD reference. Weighted betas were computed in a shared pipeline. In NTR, scores for non-transmitted and transmitted genotypes were obtained for fathers and mothers separately so we average them to obtain the mid-parent score. Each model included cognitive and non-cognitive polygenic scores simultaneously and controlled for: 10 ancestry principal components (PCs), sex and age, interaction between sex and age, and cohort-specific platform covariate (NTR: genotyping platform, UKB: array, TEDS: batch). Age was estimated by year of birth, age at recruitment or age at testing depending on the cohorts, see Supplementary Data 2. Correlations between NonCog and Cog PGS, as well as between and within-family PGS are reported Supplementary Data 10. Outcomes were standardized for each analysis group. Polygenic scores were standardised as follows prior to analysis. For the non-transmitted allele design, we summed the parental PGS and then scaled the non-transmitted and transmitted PGS separately, following Kong et al26. Note that the variances of the non-transmitted and transmitted PGS were not significantly different prior to scaling (Cog PGS: F = 1.0088, p = 0.71; NonCog PGS: F = 0.9920, p = 0.73). For the adoption design, we scaled the PGS in adopted and non-adopted groups separately. There were no significant differences in variances of adopted and non-adopted PGS prior to scaling (see Supplementary Data 11). For the sibling design, we scaled the PGS to have mean 0 SD 1 using the sibling group, and subsequently created the within-sibling PGS.” All regressions were linear models with lm() in R rather than mixed models as in previous analyses27,28 and our pre-registered methods. See Supplementary Note 1 for the justification based on simulated data. We obtained bootstrapped standard errors and bias-corrected confidence intervals (normal approximation) for the population, indirect and direct effects, as well as the ratios of indirect/direct and indirect/population effect. We ran ordinary non-parametric bootstraps using 10,000 replications with boot() in R. For the sibling design, where two independent regressions are used, we use the same bootstrap samples for both (both regressions were run within the same boot object). For the adoption design, the bootstrapped samples are drawn from the adopted and non-adopted samples separately. The bootstrap estimates were used to test for the difference between the direct and indirect effect in both Cog and NonCog and the difference between the ratio indirect/population for Cog and NonCog, using Z-tests. To estimate the overall indirect and direct effects of NonCog and Cog polygenic scores, we meta-analysed estimates across cohorts, designs and phenotypic outcomes. To compare results obtained across the three different designs, we meta-analysed effect sizes obtained from each design across cohorts, but holding the outcome constant (educational attainment). The adoption design was only applied to EA in UKB, hence no meta-analysis was necessary. Meta-analyses were conducted using the command rma.mv() in the R package metafor. Design was specified as a random intercept factor, except when results were meta-analysed within-design. Population stratification refers to the presence of systematic difference in allele frequencies across subpopulations, arising from ancestry difference due to non-random mating and genetic drift. This leads to confounding in genetic association studies. In a PGS analysis, bias due to population stratification can arise from both the GWAS used to create the scores and the target sample. We corrected for population stratification in the target sample by adjusting analyses for PCs (although this may not remove fine-scale stratification). For the GWAS summary statistics, the ratio statistics LDSC output is a standard measure of population stratification87. As a rule of thumb, an LDSC intercept higher than 1 (inflated) indicates presence of population stratification. Because we corrected the standard errors of the EA GWAS for inflation and GenomicSEM corrects for inflation as well, the ratio statistics of the Cog and NonCog GWAS are not a valid indication of population stratification (ratio < 0 following GC correction). We therefore use the ratio statistics of uncorrected EA and CP GWAS as proxies. Ratio and LDscore intercept was assessed with the ldsc software87. Assortative mating refers to the non-random mate choice, with a preference for spouses with similar phenotypes. If these preferred phenotypes have a genetic component, assortative mating leads to an increased genetic correlation between spouses, as well as between relatives52. Assortative mating can therefore be inferred from elevated correlations between polygenic scores in siblings (correlations would be 0.5 without assortative mating) and between parents (correlations would be 0 without assortative mating). We estimated sibling intraclass correlations of Cog and NonCog PGS in UKB, TEDS and NTR, and Pearson’s correlations of paternal and maternal Cog and NonCog PGS in NTR. Notably, these observed correlations cannot distinguish assortative mating from population stratification. We performed three additional analyses to investigate indirect genetic effects of siblings on educational outcomes. First, we ran a linear mixed model extending our main non-transmitted alleles design to include polygenic scores of siblings (Eq. (4)). To this end, we used data from NTR on DZ pairs and both of their parents. Sample sizes of genotyped ‘quads’ with offspring CITO or EA phenotypes were 657 and 788, respectively. Second, we can also assess the presence of sibling genetic effects using monozygotic and dizygotic twins. Because monozygotic twins have the same genotypes, the genetically mediated environment provided by the cotwin is more correlated to the twin genotype in MZ twins than in DZ twins. The sibling genetic effect is more strongly reflected in the polygenic score prediction of the educational outcome for MZ twins than for DZ twins. If the sibling genetic effect is negative, the polygenic score effect (betas) on the outcome in people that have an MZ twin will be lower than in people that have a DZ twin, it will be higher in those with an MZ twin then those with an DZ twin if the sibling genetic effect is positive. We therefore compare Betas from Eq. (2) in a subset of MZ twins and in a subset of DZ twins (one individual per pair) in both NTR (NMZ = 818 & NDZ = 865 for CITO and NMZ = 1600 & NDZ = 1369 for EA) and TEDS (NMZ = 546 & NDZ = 2709). Third, the presence of sibling genetic effects can be assessed using data on the number of siblings participants have. If an individual has more siblings, we expect their polygenic scores to be more correlated to sibling effects. As the number of siblings increases (if we assume linear increase) so does the degree to which a PGS captures sibling effects. If the sibling genetic effect is positive, the effect of the Cog and NonCog PGS on the educational outcome should increase with the number of siblings. However, family characteristics and environment might differ across families depending on the number of children. Therefore, changes in the effect of the PGS on our outcome with the number of siblings could be due to factors other than sibling genetic effects (for example, there is a known negative genetic association between number of children and EA88 which could result in confounding). By also looking at changes in the effect of the Cog and NonCog PGS on the educational outcome in adopted (unrelated) sibships, we break the correlation between PGS and any sibling effects. If there is a change in PGS effect on the educational outcome in adopted children dependent on the number of (non-biological) siblings, we can assume this effect to be caused by mechanisms other than a sibling effect. We finally contrast the change in PGS depending on family size in biological and adopted siblings to get an idea of the sibling effect minus any other confounding effects of family size. We use the total number of reported siblings (full siblings for non-adopted and adopted siblings for adopted individuals, data-fields: 1873, 1883, 3972 & 3982). Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article. For the original summary statistics of Cog and NonCog, including NTR and UKBiobank siblings data, see20. The summary statistics for Cog and NonCog generated for this study are available at: https://doi.org/10.34894/MMXYPL. For UK Biobank dataset access, see: https://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/using-the-resource/. Netherlands Twin Register data may be accessed, upon approval of the data access committee, email: [email protected]. Researchers can apply for access to TEDS data: https://www.teds.ac.uk/researchers/teds-data-access-policy. All scripts used to run the analyses (empirical and simulated) are available at our GitHub https://github.com/PerlineDemange/GeneticNurtureNonCog/, which can be cited as Demange P., et al. Estimating effects of parents’ cognitive and non-cognitive skills on offspring education using polygenic scores, GitHub, https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6581326, 2022. All additional software used to perform the analyses are available online. The pre-registration of the study is available on OSF: https://osf.io/mk938/. Hertz, T. et al. The Inheritance of Educational Inequality: International Comparisons and Fifty-Year Trends. B. E. J. Econom. Anal. Policy7, 1–48 (2008). Deary, I. J. et al. Intergenerational social mobility and mid-life status attainment: Influences of childhood intelligence, childhood social factors, and education. Intelligence33, 455–472 (2005). Article Google Scholar Oreopoulos, P. & Salvanes, K. G. Priceless: the nonpecuniary benefits of schooling. J. Economic Perspect.25, 159–184 (2011). Article Google Scholar Domitrovich, C. E., Durlak, J. A., Staley, K. C. & Weissberg, R. P. Social-Emotional Competence: An Essential Factor for Promoting Positive Adjustment and Reducing Risk in School Children. Child Dev.88, 408–416 (2017). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Heckman, J., Stixrud, J. & Urzua, S. The effects of cognitive and noncognitive abilities on labor market outcomes and social behavior. (National Bureau of Economic Research, 2006). https://doi.org/10.3386/w12006 Leerkes, E. M., Bailes, L. G. & Augustine, M. E. The intergenerational transmission of emotion socialization. Dev. Psychol.56, 390–402 (2020). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Cunha, F. & Heckman, J. The technology of skill formation. Am. Economic Rev.97, 31–47 (2007). Article Google Scholar Guhin, J., McCrory Calarco, J. & Miller-Idriss, C. Whatever happened to socialization? Annu Rev Sociol47, 109–129 (2021). Grusec, J. E. & Davidov, M. In Handbook of parenting: volume 3: being and becoming a parent (ed. Bornstein, M. H.) 762–796 (Routledge, 2019). https://doi.org/10.4324/9780429433214-22 England-Mason, G. & Gonzalez, A. Intervening to shape children’s emotion regulation: A review of emotion socialization parenting programs for young children. Emotion20, 98–104 (2020). PubMedArticle Google Scholar McGue, M., Rustichini, A. & Iacono, W. G. Cognitive, noncognitive, and family background contributions to college attainment: A behavioral genetic perspective. J. Pers.85, 65–78 (2017). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Richardson, M., Abraham, C. & Bond, R. Psychological correlates of university students’ academic performance: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Psychol. Bull.138, 353–387 (2012). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Doren, C. & Grodsky, E. What Skills Can Buy: Transmission of advantage through cognitive and noncognitive skills. Socio. Educ.89, 321–342 (2016). Article Google Scholar Grönqvist, E., Öckert, B. & Vlachos, J. The intergenerational transmission of cognitive and noncognitive abilities. J. Hum. Resour.52, 887–918 (2017). Article Google Scholar Claire, E., Crawford, A. & Goodman, R. Joyce Explaining the socio-economic gradient in child outcomes: the inter-generational transmission of cognitive skills. Longit. Life Course Stud. 2, 77–93 (2011). Morris, T. T., Davey Smith, G., Van den Berg, G. & Davies, N. M. Investigating the phenotypic consistency and genetic architecture of noncognitive skills. BioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/470682 (2018) Leslie Morrison, Gutman. & Ingrid, Schoon. The impact of non-cognitive skills on outcomes for young people. (The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) and the UK Cabinet Office, 2013). Tucker-Drob, E. M., Briley, D. A., Engelhardt, L. E., Mann, F. D. & Harden, K. P. Genetically-mediated associations between measures of childhood character and academic achievement. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol.111, 790–815 (2016). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Kovas, Y. et al. Why children differ in motivation to learn: Insights from over 13,000 twins from 6 countries. Pers. Individ. Dif.80, 51–63 (2015). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Demange, P. A. et al. Investigating the genetic architecture of noncognitive skills using GWAS-by-subtraction. Nat. Genet.53, 35–44 (2021). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Heckman, J. J. & Rubinstein, Y. The Importance of Noncognitive Skills: Lessons from the GED Testing Program. Am. Economic Rev.91, 145–149 (2001). Article Google Scholar Hart, S. A., Little, C. & van Bergen, E. Nurture might be nature: cautionary tales and proposed solutions. NPJ Sci. Learn.6, 2 (2021). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Zhang, G. et al. Assessing the causal relationship of maternal height on birth size and gestational age at birth: A mendelian randomization analysis. PLoS Med.12, e1001865 (2015). PubMedPubMed CentralArticleCAS Google Scholar Lawlor, D. et al. Using Mendelian randomization to determine causal effects of maternal pregnancy (intrauterine) exposures on offspring outcomes: Sources of bias and methods for assessing them. [version 1; peer review: 4 approved]. Wellcome Open Res.2, 11 (2017). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Bates, T. C. et al. The Nature of Nurture: Using a Virtual-Parent Design to Test Parenting Effects on Children’s Educational Attainment in Genotyped Families. Twin Res Hum. Genet21, 73–83 (2018). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Kong, A. et al. The nature of nurture: Effects of parental genotypes. Science359, 424–428 (2018). ADSCASPubMedArticle Google Scholar de Zeeuw, E. L. et al. Intergenerational transmission of education and ADHD: effects of parental genotypes. Behav. Genet50, 221–232 (2020). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Selzam, S. et al. Comparing Within- and Between-Family Polygenic Score Prediction. Am. J. Hum. Genet.105, 351–363 (2019). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Cheesman, R. et al. Comparison of Adopted and Nonadopted Individuals Reveals Gene-Environment Interplay for Education in the UK Biobank. Psychol. Sci.31, 582–591 (2020). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Fulker, D. W., Cherny, S. S., Sham, P. C. & Hewitt, J. K. Combined linkage and association sib-pair analysis for quantitative traits. Am. J. Hum. Genet.64, 259–267 (1999). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Abecasis, G. R., Cardon, L. R. & Cookson, W. O. A general test of association for quantitative traits in nuclear families. Am. J. Hum. Genet.66, 279–292 (2000). CASPubMedArticle Google Scholar Eaves, L. J., Pourcain, B. S., Smith, G. D., York, T. P. & Evans, D. M. Resolving the effects of maternal and offspring genotype on dyadic outcomes in genome wide complex trait analysis (“M-GCTA”). Behav. Genet44, 445–455 (2014). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Eilertsen, E. M. et al. Direct and indirect effects of maternal, paternal, and offspring genotypes: Trio-GCTA. BioRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.05.15.097840 (2020) Warrington, N. M., Freathy, R. M., Neale, M. C. & Evans, D. M. Using structural equation modelling to jointly estimate maternal and fetal effects on birthweight in the UK Biobank. Int. J. Epidemiol.47, 1229–1241 (2018). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Warrington, N. M. et al. Maternal and fetal genetic effects on birth weight and their relevance to cardio-metabolic risk factors. Nat. Genet.51, 804–814 (2019). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Morris, T. T., Davies, N. M., Hemani, G. & Smith, G. D. Population phenomena inflate genetic associations of complex social traits. Sci. Adv.6, eaay0328 (2020). ADSCASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Davies, N. M. et al. Within family Mendelian randomization studies. Hum. Mol. Genet.28, R170–R179 (2019). CASPubMedArticle Google Scholar Brumpton, B. et al. Avoiding dynastic, assortative mating, and population stratification biases in Mendelian randomization through within-family analyses. Nat. Commun.11, 3519 (2020). ADSCASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Demange, P. & Cheesman, R. Estimating effects of parents’ cognitive and non-cognitive skills on offspring education using polygenic scores, GitHub. Zenodohttps://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.6581326 (2022). Lawlor, D. A., Tilling, K. & Davey Smith, G. Triangulation in aetiological epidemiology. Int. J. Epidemiol.45, 1866–1886 (2016). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Wang, B. et al. Genetic nurture effects on education: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2021.01.15.426782 (2021). Isungset, M. et al. Social and genetic effects on educational performance in early adolescence. (National Bureau of Economic Research, 2021). https://doi.org/10.3386/w28498 Tubbs, J. D., Porsch, R. M., Cherny, S. S. & Sham, P. C. The genes we inherit and those we don’t: maternal genetic nurture and child BMI trajectories. Behav. Genet50, 310–319 (2020). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Manolio, T. A. et al. Finding the missing heritability of complex diseases. Nature461, 747–753 (2009). ADSCASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Young, A. I. Solving the missing heritability problem. PLoS Genet.15, e1008222 (2019). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Kovas, Y. et al. Literacy and numeracy are more heritable than intelligence in primary school. Psychol. Sci.24, 2048–2056 (2013). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Silventoinen, K. et al. Genetic and environmental variation in educational attainment: an individual-based analysis of 28 twin cohorts. Sci. Rep.10, 12681 (2020). ADSCASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar OECD. Equity in education: breaking down barriers to social mobility. (OECD, 2018). https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264073234-en van Spijker, F., van der Houwen, K. & van Gaalen, R. Invloed ouderlijk opleidingsniveau reikt tot ver in het voortgezet onderwijs. Economisch-Statistische Berichten102, 234–237 (2017). Young, A. I. et al. Mendelian imputation of parental genotypes for genome-wide estimation of direct and indirect genetic effects. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2020.07.02.185199 (2020). Kong, A., Benonisdottir, S. & Young, A. I. Family Analysis with Mendelian Imputations. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2020.07.02.185181 (2020). Yengo, L. et al. Imprint of assortative mating on the human genome. Nat. Hum. Behav.2, 948–954 (2018). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Balbona, J. V., Kim, Y. & Keller, M. C. Estimation of parental effects using polygenic scores. Behav. Genet51, 264–278 (2021). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Kim, Y., Balbona, J. V. & Keller, M. C. Bias and Precision of Parameter Estimates from Models Using Polygenic Scores to Estimate Environmental and Genetic Parental Influences. Behav. Genet51, 279–288 (2021). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Howe, L., Evans, D., Hemani, G., Smith, G. D. & Davies, N. M. Evaluating indirect genetic effects of siblings using singletons. https://doi.org/10.31219/osf.io/j2rms (2021). Fletcher, J. M., Wu, Y., Zhao, Z. & Lu, Q. The production of within-family inequality: Insights and implications of integrating genetic data. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2020.06.06.137778 (2020). Lyngstad, T. H., Ystrøm, E. & Zambrana, I. M. An Anatomy of Intergenerational Transmission: Learning from the educational attainments of Norwegian twins and their parents. https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/fby2t (2017). Armstrong-Carter, E. et al. The earliest origins of genetic nurture: prenatal environment mediates the association between maternal genetics and child development. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/2usk8 (2019). Trejo, S. Exploring genetic influences on birth weight. https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/7j59q (2020). McGue, M. et al. The environments of adopted and non-adopted youth: evidence on range restriction from the Sibling Interaction and Behavior Study (SIBS). Behav. Genet37, 449–462 (2007). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Hwang, L.-D., Moen, G.-H. & Evans, D. M. Using adopted individuals to partition maternal genetic effects into prenatal and postnatal effects on offspring phenotypes. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2021.08.04.455178 (2021). Ho, H., Plomin, R. & DeFries, J. C. Selective placement in adoption. Soc. Biol.26, 1–6 (1979). CASPubMedArticle Google Scholar Pirastu, N. et al. Genetic analyses identify widespread sex-differential participation bias. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2020.03.22.001453 (2020). Fletcher, J., Wu, Y., Li, T. & Lu, Q. Interpreting polygenic score effects in sibling analysis. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2021.07.16.452740 (2021). Howe, L. J. et al. Within-sibship GWAS improve estimates of direct genetic effects. BioRxivhttps://doi.org/10.1101/2021.03.05.433935 (2021). Lo, M.-T. et al. Genome-wide analyses for personality traits identify six genomic loci and show correlations with psychiatric disorders. Nat. Genet.49, 152–156 (2017). CASPubMedArticle Google Scholar Pearson, R. M. et al. Maternal perinatal mental health and offspring academic achievement at age 16: the mediating role of childhood executive function. J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry57, 491–501 (2016). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Rimfeld, K., Kovas, Y., Dale, P. S. & Plomin, R. True grit and genetics: Predicting academic achievement from personality. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol.111, 780–789 (2016). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Willems, Y. E., Boesen, N., Li, J., Finkenauer, C. & Bartels, M. The heritability of self-control: A meta-analysis. Neurosci. Biobehav. Rev.100, 324–334 (2019). CASPubMedArticle Google Scholar Malanchini, M., Engelhardt, L. E., Grotzinger, A. D., Harden, K. P. & Tucker-Drob, E. M. “Same but different”: Associations between multiple aspects of self-regulation, cognition, and academic abilities. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol.117, 1164–1188 (2019). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Lareau, A. Unequal Childhoods. (University of California Press, 2011). van Bergen, E., van Zuijen, T., Bishop, D. & de Jong, P. F. Why are home literacy environment and children’s reading skills associated? what parental skills reveal. Read. Res Q52, 147–160 (2017). Article Google Scholar Cooper, K. Are Poor Parents Poor Parents? The Relationship between Poverty and Parenting among Mothers in the UK. Sociology 003803852093939 https://doi.org/10.1177/0038038520939397 (2020). Allen, N. E., Sudlow, C., Peakman, T. & Collins, R. UK Biobank. UK biobank data: come and get it. Sci. Transl. Med.6, 224ed4 (2014). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Bycroft, C. et al. The UK Biobank resource with deep phenotyping and genomic data. Nature562, 203–209 (2018). ADSCASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Manichaikul, A. et al. Robust relationship inference in genome-wide association studies. Bioinformatics26, 2867–2873 (2010). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Lee, J. J. et al. Gene discovery and polygenic prediction from a genome-wide association study of educational attainment in 1.1 million individuals. Nat. Genet.50, 1112–1121 (2018). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Rimfeld, K. et al. Twins Early Development Study: A Genetically Sensitive Investigation into Behavioral and Cognitive Development from Infancy to Emerging Adulthood. Twin Res Hum. Genet22, 508–513 (2019). PubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Ligthart, L. et al. The Netherlands Twin Register: Longitudinal Research Based on Twin and Twin-Family Designs. Twin Res Hum. Genet22, 623–636 (2019). PubMedArticle Google Scholar Abdellaoui, A. et al. Educational attainment influences levels of homozygosity through migration and assortative mating. PLoS One10, e0118935 (2015). PubMedPubMed CentralArticleCAS Google Scholar Okbay, A. et al. Genome-wide association study identifies 74 loci associated with educational attainment. Nature533, 539–542 (2016). ADSCASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Abdellaoui, A. et al. Population structure, migration, and diversifying selection in the Netherlands. Eur. J. Hum. Genet.21, 1277–1285 (2013). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Abraham, G., Qiu, Y. & Inouye, M. FlashPCA2: principal component analysis of Biobank-scale genotype datasets. Bioinformatics33, 2776–2778 (2017). CASPubMedArticle Google Scholar Selzam, S. et al. Evidence for gene-environment correlation in child feeding: Links between common genetic variation for BMI in children and parental feeding practices. PLoS Genet.14, e1007757 (2018). PubMedPubMed CentralArticleCAS Google Scholar Purcell, S. et al. PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage analyses. Am. J. Hum. Genet.81, 559–575 (2007). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Chang, C. C. et al. Second-generation PLINK: rising to the challenge of larger and richer datasets. Gigascience4, 7 (2015). PubMedPubMed CentralArticleCAS Google Scholar Bulik-Sullivan, B. et al. LD Score regression distinguishes confounding from polygenicity in genome-wide association studies. Nat. Genet.47, 291–295 (2015). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Barban, N. et al. Genome-wide analysis identifies 12 loci influencing human reproductive behavior. Nat. Genet.48, 1462–1472 (2016). CASPubMedPubMed CentralArticle Google Scholar Download references We thank Dr. Aysu Okbay, the SSGAC and COGENT consortiums for sharing their summary statistics for GWAS of educational attainment and cognitive performance excluding specific cohorts. P.A.D. is supported by the grant 531003014 from The Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development (ZonMW). R.C. and E.M.E. are supported by the Research Council of Norway (288083). A.A. is supported by the Foundation Volksbond Rotterdam and by ZonMw grant 849200011 from The Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development. K.R. is supported the Wellcome Trust (213514/Z/18/Z). D.I.B. is supported by the Royal Netherlands Academy of Science (KNAW) Professor Award (PAH/6635). E.v.B. is supported by ZonMW grant 531003014 and VENI grant 451-15-017. M.G.N. is supported by R01MH120219, ZonMW grants 849200011 and 531003014 from The Netherlands Organisation for Health Research and Development, a VENI grant awarded by NWO (VI.Veni.191 G.030) and is a Jacobs Foundation Research Fellow. This research has been conducted using the UK Biobank Resource under Application Number 40310. The Netherlands Twin Register is supported by NWO Groot (480-15-001/674): Netherlands Twin Register Repository: researching the interplay between genome and environment and the Avera Institute for Human Genetics, Sioux Falls, South Dakota (USA) for genotyping. We gratefully acknowledge the research program ‘Consortium on Individual Development (CID)’ which is funded through the Gravitation program of the Dutch Ministry of Education, Culture and Science and the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO: 0240-001-003). We gratefully acknowledge ‘Open Data Infrastructure for Social Science and Economic Innovations (ODISSEI) (NWO: NRGWI.obrug.2018.008)’. We gratefully acknowledge the ongoing contribution of the participants in the Twins Early Development Study (TEDS) and their families. TEDS is supported by a program grant from the UK Medical Research Council (MR/V012878/1 and previously MR/M021475/1), with additional support from the US National Institutes of Health (AG046938). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript. Department of Biological Psychology, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Perline A. Demange, Jouke Jan Hottenga, Eveline L. de Zeeuw, Dorret I. Boomsma, Elsje van Bergen & Michel G. Nivard Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute, Amsterdam University Medical Centers, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Perline A. Demange Research Institute LEARN!, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Perline A. Demange, Eveline L. de Zeeuw & Elsje van Bergen Department of Psychiatry, Amsterdam UMC, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands Abdel Abdellaoui PROMENTA Research Center, Department of Psychology, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway Espen Moen Eilertsen & Rosa Cheesman Centre for Fertility and Health, Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Oslo, Norway Espen Moen Eilertsen Department of Biological and Experimental Psychology, School of Biological and Chemical Sciences, Queen Mary University of London, London, UK Margherita Malanchini Social, Genetic & Developmental Psychiatry Centre, Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience, King’s College London, London, UK Margherita Malanchini, Kaili Rimfeld, Gerome Breen & Rosa Cheesman Graduate School of Education, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA Benjamin W. Domingue & Emma Armstrong-Carter Center for Population Health Sciences, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA Benjamin W. Domingue Center for Education Policy Analysis, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, USA Benjamin W. Domingue & Emma Armstrong-Carter Department of Psychology, Royal Holloway University of London, London, UK Kaili Rimfeld NIHR Maudsley Biomedical Research Centre, South London and Maudsley NHS Trust, London, UK Gerome Breen You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar You can also search for this author in PubMedGoogle Scholar R.C. & P.A.D. conceived and designed the study, with helpful contributions from M.G.N. P.A.D. & R.C. analysed the data, with help from J.J.H. to obtain polygenic score weights and A.A. to perform GWAS in UK Biobank. P.A.D., M.G.N., R.C., and E.M.E. performed the simulation study. R.C. & P.A.D. wrote the manuscript. J.J.H., A.A., E.M.E., M.M., B.W.D., E.A.C., E.L.d.Z., K.R., D.I.B., E.v.B., and G.B. contributed to the interpretation of data, provided feedback on manuscript drafts, and approved the final draft. Correspondence to Perline A. Demange or Rosa Cheesman. The authors declare no competing interests. Nature Communications thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available. Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons license, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons license and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/. Reprints and Permissions Demange, P.A., Hottenga, J.J., Abdellaoui, A. et al. Estimating effects of parents’ cognitive and non-cognitive skills on offspring education using polygenic scores. Nat Commun13, 4801 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-32003-x Download citation Received: Accepted: Published: DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-32003-x Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content: Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
With a diverse resume of credits that range from Mega Ran to Akon and Dizzee Rascal to Ronnie Spector and beyond, Matthew Weiss is a highly sought-after recording, mixing and mastering engineer. We spoke with Weiss to get a run down of his career, starting with his early days as an intern studying under Grammy-winning engineer Denise Barbarita, serving as an assistant to the producer Mark Marshall, and living and working in Los Angeles today. We also discuss the gear and the educational initiative that he has launched in an effort to build better engineers. Could you tell me how you first got into engineering? I don’t think I know that part of your story. I think it depends on where you draw the line, but I would say my first little spark of it was in middle school when we were putting on a play. They asked what I wanted to do—I looked at the soundboard and I was like, “I wanna do that.” Nice. Do you remember what kind of board it was? I remember that the plug around the outlet was chipped and I remember getting shocked. A lot of kids do the four track recorder thing or the two deck karaoke thing—did you record stuff at home when you were young? I didn’t start recording at home until I was in high school. I had Sony Acid Pro, I think I had an early version of Audacity, and then eventually I had Pro Tools. Was recording an extension of you making music? Yeah, when I got into high school, I was really into hip hop and I just wanted to make beats so bad. So I had a little Roland MC-303 groove machine that my stepfather bought me and I would make the beats on that. I would track them into Sony Acid and I would move them around and arrange them in Acid Pro. Eventually, it’s just a couple short steps to recording myself and recording other people. So I got the little Samson microphone, the Sam Ash brand condenser and the Mbox, and that’s how I got Pro Tools. And I think it came with Reason also. Yeah. I love Reason and to this day I still use it. Reason was a badass program. It was a little above my head when I first got it, but looking at it retrospectively, I don’t think I really knew what I had. When did you really start engineering? How did you make that leap into the work that you do now as a professional? It was sort of a gradient, but I would say because the people that I was making music with started to kind of move forward as I was getting into college. Once I got into college, the best paying job on campus was the sound tech, who was responsible for recording as well. If you could drive a commercial vehicle, then you could drive the van around with all the equipment, and then you got paid even more. I had all those qualifications and by the end of freshman year I was the sound tech. I was picking up all of the gigs, recording all of the concerts and everything like that. But when I left school, I thought maybe I should just be taking this seriously—I thought I had wanted to be a writer at first, and then I kind of switched into music composition. I then realized what I really wanna be doing is recording the other people who are composing the music and playing it, so I picked up an internship when I got out of school. Where’d you intern? My first internship was at Shooters, which was a post and transfer facility in downtown Philadelphia. After that, I started interning and assisting with an engineer named Denise Barbarita and a producer named Mark Marshall who were both in New York. During this time, were you learning just how to run the board or were you learning about compression and that sort of thing too? I kind of learned all of the signal processing stuff on my own, but I also picked up learning about running the board and mic techniques and things like that from Denise and Mark. Do you remember some of the gear that you were working on early on? Oh, yeah, there was an SSL G+ with an automation brain in it, as well as an API desk at a studio called Pyramid. There were all sorts of arrays of outboard gear, but most of the work that I was doing at that point was editing work—so I spent most of my time really with the grid and, you know, figuring out how to move things around. How did you learn to mix and how did you transition into working more as a mixing engineer? I’d sort of been mixing my own stuff all along. I was still assisting in New York at the time that I started at Bobby Eli’s studio and Studio E in Philadelphia, which gave me a lot more access to being in the studio. I didn’t have to go back and forth because I was living in Philly at the time so I was able to be there 7 days a week. Because I was the in-house engineer, I was doing almost all of the recording, but a good portion of the mixing as well. From 2007 to 2010 was when I was doing most of my mixing. What’s a typical day like for you as an engineer? Well, I’ll give you today as an example: yesterday during the afternoon, until last night, I was in the studio tracking and then I came home. I decided that I didn’t want to do any additional work because I was already getting home late enough—I just wanted to hang with my fiance. I woke up this morning at about 7, took care of my little doggies here, and I got to work on the final edits for a video tutorial that I’m putting together. Then, I switched over to one of the records we worked on yesterday. I started doing Melodyne passes to get the vocalist’s takes to really fit. Now that I’ve done the Melodyne pass, I’m already in the process of getting an actual mix going, but probably won’t finish it before I have to go to the studio. From there I’ll probably be at the studio recording until about seven or eight. Could you walk me through a mix? What are some of your usual best practices that you apply? It kind of depends on whether or not I’m the tracking engineer as well—if I am, it’s a really easy flow and segue into the mix, which kind of starts during the tracking process. I just take my tracking template and I make a couple little changes and it becomes my mix setup, then I take effects that I’ve already done, and continue the process because I’m picking up the ideas that we already left the studio with. It’s a very easy flow. If somebody is sending me a record, they’re either going to be sending me a session—in which case I have to go through and hope that the session layout makes sense. If it doesn’t make sense, then I start committing sounds that I like and get rid of bizarre routing. A lot of times, I’ll get multi-tracks in which case I pull it in, throw the fades up and get a basic level balance. I just sort of say to myself, “Okay, how far along are we? Does this feel like something that is halfway done, done 0% done? Do we need to go back to the production phase?” And then each one of those options kind of spawns a completely different workflow. I am curious, do you have some go-to pieces of gear that you’re using right now—stuff that you really enjoy working with? Yeah—I sold a fair amount of my outboard and pared it down to the stuff that I just really can’t live without. I’ve got a Lucas Pultech-style equalizer—I love that thing, it’s like a three band Pultech. It’s amazing. I’m sort of a reverb junkie—digital or analog—and I only have three, but once I have more disposable income, I’m just gonna be stacking up reverbs. Certain outboard reverbs just have a certain character—I’ve got my Micmix Master Room XL-305. I’ve got my Eventide Ultra-Harmonizer and I’ve got my Bricasti M7 reverb and I don’t think I could part with any of those. I’m pretty sure if I had to, I could part with every other piece of gear besides my mics and my converters and monitors obviously. I think signal processing-wise, I would be really miserable if for whatever reason I was without them. I have a DBX 160SL—ironically, they stay cheap on eBay and Reverb but I love that thing. I sold a bunch of compressors, but this is one of the ones I hung onto. It was probably one of the ones I paid the least for. I’ve also got my Universal Audio 1176 limiting amplifier. I don’t think I’ll ever part with that thing. It’s just a go-to sound. There’s a million 1176’s in the box and they sound great, but they don’t sound like this one. What are some of the go-to mics that you like using? It depends on the voice—I like the Peluso 22 251. That’s really good for people who have very strong forward, nasal type voices. It smooths them out and gives them a high end and everything that’s nice and glossy. The JZB V67 is a great microphone—it’s pretty much a really good all-purpose microphone. The other JZ (BH-2 cardioid) that I have is really nice too, it’s a black hole and it’s very different sounding than the V 67. It’s kind of more like a poor man’s Sony C-800G with a little exaggerated top end. I do have a Neumann U87—ironically, it’s probably the one I use the least, but I do like it for when I want something that’s gonna be really mid-range forward. I’ve got my Neumann M147, which is sort of like a poor man’s U47 with a really nice low end—it’s great on bass cab, kick drum or voices that are naturally bright and need a little bit of extra body. I kind of love all my microphones though—my Electro-Voice RE20. It’s not a particularly expensive mic, but it’s great… my Neumann KM 184s… it just depends on what I’m recording. I appreciate hearing you talk about that—how the sound of the person’s voice that you’re recording will affect your choice of a microphone. I usually advise people to use the opposite rule: if you have somebody, assess the person’s voice first. Start by listening to the human. if they’re particularly bright with a lot of sibilance, you’re gonna wanna use a darker microphone. So an RE20 or an M147, avoiding the brighter microphones. If you have somebody who has a darker voice, then it’s the opposite, you know? The JZ Black Hole, the Neumann U87, maybe something that will pull the voice forward a little bit. Tell me about Weiss Advice? Weiss Advice is a continuation of the educational series that I’ve been doing on YouTube for a long time. I decided to start my own channel and the basic idea is to make it more subscription-oriented than download-oriented. Although I am selling download products at this point, it’s so that people can log into a Discord and get to interact with me and with other people and share what they’re working on and get advice in real time, as well as tune into webinars and get as much interaction as possible. I think that interactivity is really the future of online education. Are you walking people through how to record or how to mix a record? Explain the nuts and bolts of it. There’s a number of different things. There’s archived tutorials that you get access to—demonstrations of things like how to record vocals—that’s the one that I just finished editing this morning actually—the basics for recording acoustic guitar, here’s how to use compression, how to use reverb, et cetera. Those are always there as resources and references. Then there are biweekly webinars that are topical, based highly on what people in the Discord are asking for—then there are coachings, which I do charge an additional fee for: a one-on-one hourly session where we exchange the multi-tracks for whatever someone is working on, and we fire up Zoom and I let them hear my end. I record the session and show them whatever it is that they specifically are looking for, or just do a general coaching where I kind of figure out where they’re at and see how I can make them better at being themselves. I want people to recognize that the subjectivity and the gray areas of music production are the areas that we actually want to have fun in and live in and experiment with because there isn’t really right or wrong. Last question. If you could give a piece of advice or a way to go about things for a younger person who’s trying to get to where you are or do what you do. What would you say? Typically, my advice for most stages of people’s careers is to say yes to everything that you can. If you absolutely can’t say yes to something, then you say no—but find every reason to say yes to every project, to every person, as much as you possibly can. Eventually, what happens is you start saying no to things, because you’ve said yes to other things which have presented themselves as a higher priority. Your purchases help youth music programs get the gear they need to make music. Your purchases also help protect forests, including trees traditionally used to make instruments.
23 August 2022 Mauritius Reporter Lucy Carter Share this article IQ-EQ has appointed Shaun Geils as global head of insurance.
Based in Mauritius, Geils will lead the insurance team while expanding the range of insurance solutions that the company offers.
Geils will help spearhead the expansion of the debt, capital markets and corporates segment and aim to attract further opportunities for both current and future clients.
Prior to his current role, Geils was managing director of shared services in Mauritius for IQ-EQ.
Geils has extensive experience in the captive insurance sector. Before IQ-EQ he served as captives account manager at HSBC and captive and ILS insurance management manager at Kane, before moving to IQ-EQ in 2015.
Speaking on his appointment, Geils says: “This is an exciting time for IQ-EQ, and I cannot wait to get started on extending our service offering for our existing clients and our new ones. I enjoy new challenges, and this new role will have the scope to achieve great things, supported by a fantastic team of experts.”
Edward Stevenson, group head of debt, capital markets and corporates at IQ-EQ, says: “Geils will train our global sales teams on key global insurance trends and regulations while building a high level of domain and insurance workflow knowledge for our client’s strategic priorities and needs.”
Master Teague III’s time with the Pittsburgh Steelers is complete. The former Ohio State running back was waived Thursday to make room for former Washington State running back Max Borghi. After signing with the team as an undrafted free agent Aug. 3, Teague’s time with the Steelers has been eventful. He made a highlight-reel play in a one-on-one drill against a Steelers defender, lowering a shoulder and trucked a defensive player, forcing him to the ground, while still remaining upright and in bounds. This week, Teague was carted off the field during practice with a low ankle sprain. Steelers coach Mike Tomlin said Teague’s status was “day-to-day.” Gene Smith talks Big Ten divisions:Two straight weeks of OSU vs. Michigan hype? Gene Smith has warmed to the idea What Big Ten media deal means for OSU:Here’s what the new Big Ten media rights deal means for Ohio State athletics Teague was previously signed by the Chicago Bears as an undrafted free agent shortly after the 2022 NFL draft, but was cut after the team’s three-day rookie camp. Entering the Buckeyes’ program as a four-star running back in the 2018 class, he amassed 1,764 rushing yards and 17 touchdowns, averaging 5.5 yards per carry. Teague was a second-team All-Big Ten selection in 2020 after being a member of the third team in 2019. In his first three seasons, Teague helped Ohio State to three Big Ten Championships and played in two College Football Playoffs.
For many aspiring rock bands, signing a record deal is a dream come true. For Big Brother & the Holding Company, it was more a matter of fiscal necessity. In September 1966, the San Francisco band – which included guitarists Sam Andrew and James Gurley, bassist Peter Albin, drummer Dave Getz and singer Janis Joplin - found themselves stranded in Chicago. Even though they were paid for some performances at Mother Blues, there wasn't enough money for plane tickets back to California. Bob Shad of the California-based independent record label Mainstream Records offered a solution: Sign a contract to make the money. Up until that point, Mainstream produced jazz albums. Big Brother & the Holding Company would be the label's first rock act. Looking back, it was a rushed decision, but, as Albin recalled to Relix in 1992, the band was eager to keep Joplin as their lead singer. "We thought that it might lock Janis into the group a little bit better," he said. "[But] it was definitely a mistake. It cost us a lot of money. We never got paid any of the revenues from that record." It had been only eight months since the band's debut performance together at the Trips Festival in January 1966. And Joplin still hadn't fully developed her big voice. "We weren't flattened by her, and she wasn't flattened by us," Andrew said in a later interview. "It was probably a pretty equal meeting. She was real intelligent, Janis was, and she always rose to the occasion. She sang the songs. It wasn't like this moment of revelation like you would like it to be. Like in a movie or something. It wasn't like, 'Oh, my God, now we have gone to heaven. We have got Janis Joplin.' I mean, she was good, but she had to learn how to do that. It took her about a year to really learn how to sing with an electric band." On the flip side, it was Joplin who brought some structure to the fledgling group. "We would put bacon in a hot plate on an amp and plug the hot plate into the amplifier and play the song until the bacon was cooked and then we would stop playing the song and eat the bacon. Now, Janis is not going to put up with that," Andrew recalled. "I think it was like a thought experiment or something … we had a lot of things going like that where we would play real loud and because of the strange sounds in that, it would shift into a different gear and kind of levitate and go somewhere else into intuition land. It was a lot of fun but you can't do that with a singer." That kind of experimentation also wasn't going to fly during recording."In the studio, you have headphones on," Andrew explained. "You are not playing with everyone. It is just a totally artificial thing. You have to learn how to work within that. … It is an entirely different thing and we were all intimidated by it." Plus, the band's two guitarists were coming from different points of view and had to learn how to interact with one another's playing styles. Andrew was more structurally inclined; Gurley was the opposite. "I just always learned by ear, so I had a more emotional approach to it because I didn’t have any technique there or technical-theoretical nonsense to get in the way of something," Gurley said in 1978. "It was a little hard at first because I didn’t understand the technical things that [Andrew] would be talking about, and he wouldn’t understand the emotional intensity place that I was coming from." Recording sessions started in Chicago, but after the results were unsatisfactory, the band made its way back to Los Angeles, where they finished recording the rest of the songs. In July 1967, the first single from the album, "Blind Man" with "All Is Loneliness" as the B-side, was released, but it earned little attention beyond the Bay Area. A month later, on Aug. 23, 1967, the band's self-titled debut album came out on Mainstream. But it was far from the acid-rock sound the band became known for. Much of Big Brother & the Holding Company even leans toward country rock. "They put this out and [we] just hated it," Andrew said. "It sounded really weak and folk rocky." Listen to Big Brother & the Holding Company's 'Blind Man' Clocking in at less than 24 minutes, the LP contained mostly original numbers contributed individually by each member ("Blindman" is the only track to be credited to all five of them). Joplin, for her part, didn't put much stock in her writing. "I'm not really a songwriter," she said in a 1968 interview. "When I write a tune, it's just about the way I feel. My songs sort of sound the same after awhile. … I can only write about the inside of Janis Joplin, that's the only thing I can write about." A handful of the album's songs were arranged by Joplin, including "Down on Me," "an old spiritual that we had originally gotten from listening to a John Lomax recording of slaves washing their clothes in a river in Mississippi in the early 1900s," Albin recalled. "She liked that sort of stuff, and she adapted the words to be her own and more contemporary." Watch Big Brother & the Holding Company Perform 'Down on Me' in 1968 A month before the album's release, the band appeared at the Monterey Pop Festival, where they performed several tracks that appeared on the LP and effectively cemented themselves as a popular live act. Joplin, in particular, had blown away the audience with her voice and stage presence. Without intending to, Joplin represented a different sort of American woman, the opposite of what she called "bleach-blonde cellophane chicks." It wasn't meant to be a political statement, but Joplin touched on what it was like to be a woman in a male-dominated industry. "Well, I know you must have heard it all," she sang in the self-penned "Women Is Losers." "And everywhere men always seem to end up on top." She was met with both applause and criticism in the women's-liberation movement, with some implying that Joplin was too liberated. "How can they attack me?" she asked The Village Voice in 1970. "I’m representing everything they said they want. You know what I mean? Well, I have an opinion about this. It’s sort of like: You are what you settle for. Do you know what I mean? You’re only as much as you settle for. If they settle for being somebody’s dishwasher that’s their own fucking problem. If you don’t settle for that and you keep fighting it, you know, you’ll end up anything you want to be." Listen to Big Brother & the Holding Company's 'Women Is Losers' Big Brother & the Holding Company peaked at No. 60 on the Billboard 200 in October and remained on the chart for 30 weeks. Columbia Records eventually took over the band's contract and rereleased the album — this time with the words "Featuring Janis Joplin" on the cover – in 1970. "We said, 'These tapes are no good,'" Gurley later recalled. "'We want to do them over again and do them right,' because they were just made overnight." The updated version included two new songs: Albin's "Coo Coo" and Joplin's "The Last Time." By then, the band had risen to national prominence, achieving the recognition they had always hoped for. "I felt like I was expressing them as much as me," Andrew said in 1978. "It wasn’t like relating to an audience – in other words, that those were the record buyers out there. It was more like, 'We’re all in this together and we’re really doing something that the world needs.'"
Young music fans today may consider the notion of the celebrity duet as a modern phenomenon unique to our times. It is not. Fact is, the notion of the cross-pollinating artist duet has been around for some time. Turn back the pages of music history, and you’ll find the concept started long ago. There are many fine and interesting pairings in soul and rock & roll throughout the 20th century — more than I could possibly list here — but let us not forget how Gram Parsons and Emmylou Harris made instinctive waves together for a brief spell in the 1970s, while Tom Petty paired up with Fleetwood Mac’s Stevie Nicks to great popularity in the 1980s, as did Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush, and you’ll also find hit 1990s duet albums from the likes of Elton John and Frank Sinatra. Much more recently, Lady Gaga and Tony Bennett have together put forth a few fine genre-mashup duet albums themselves. (See? I could go on and on.) As for jazz, you’ll find many a dynamic duo hooking up on record. One of these legendary musical meet-ups began in the 1940s, when a young Ella Fitzgerald was connected with the already iconic Louis Armstrong, who was then at a career middle ground himself. One of the major influences on jazz overall — as well as what became known as scat vocal stylings, which Fitzgerald later helped to further popularize — the combination of Satchmo and Ella proved irresistible to the public. However, it took a number of years until they could release a full album together. In 1956, jazz impresario Norman Granz formed a new label called Verve Records as a fresh vehicle for promoting his rising star, Ella Fitzgerald (whom he was by then managing). So strong was his belief in her, Granz’s determined vision indeed elevated her to megastar status. One of the first projects on that journey was reconnecting her with Louis Armstrong for a full album (in mono) which was called simply Ella And Louis (Verve MGV 4003). This release proved so successful that there was a sequel, October 1957’s Ella And Louis Again. The duo scaled an artistic peak with their brilliant April 1959 interpretation of George and Ira Gershwin’s legendary 1930s opera, Porgy and Bess. UMe, owners and caretakers of the Verve Records catalog, have again paired up with the good folks at Acoustic Sounds to deliver us a fine 1LP restoration of Ella And Louis, which lists for $38.98. As with all the Acoustic Sounds releases I’ve reviewed here on AP thus far, this new production is exemplary overall. The pressing is top-notch, manufactured on thick, dark black 180g vinyl that is quiet and well-centered. Overall, Ella’s warm, melted-buttery voice makes for a tasty contrast when poured over Pops’ more angular salty popcorn-crunch vocals. Add in Satch’s rich round trumpet playing, and you’ve got the formula for a sweet sonic taste sensation. The sound on this new pressing is a wee bit on the bright side as compared to my 1950s-era copy of Ella And Louis, but I do think it sounds pretty terrific as an end-to-end listen. It must have been a particular challenge mixing and mastering this album — both back in the day, as well as today — given these were two very different vocalists recording simultaneously side-by-side in the same room. Each brought distinct dynamic qualities unique to their voices. Plus, they were recording in the then-new Capitol Records studios in Hollywood, which may have brought its own unique idiosyncrasies. There could be any number of reasons for this brighter sound, and my first guess is it might be due to a limited amount of compression and EQ used in making the new release. The result is a more open and airy-sounding disc than the somewhat boxier sound of my original copy. I do note there is an occasional bit of sibilance distortion apparent. I noticed it mainly on Louis’ vocals at times, such as on “Under a Blanket of Blue” and “Tenderly.” But I can’t fault this release, as I went back and listened closely to my original and it is there as well, albeit a bit reined in (likely by more EQ or compression). So, one must come into this listening experience knowing that it is one of those “it is what it is” type situations. Pops’ vocals sound like they were recorded pretty hot, and in a quest to create a dynamic and intimate recording perhaps he was at times a bit too close to the microphone. Or, if the engineer perhaps “rode” the microphone input levels too high into to the red, the original recording might have oversaturated a bit. Again, I don’t know this for certain, of course, as I am just speculating here. Whatever it is, I am surmising the sound is part of the recording. (Sidenote: For those who are curious, no, I don’t own a copy of the 2011 Analog Productions 45rpm edition to compare this to, but I did spot-check the 24-bit/96kHz streaming versions on Tidal and Qobuz — and indeed, Armstrong’s husky delivery is quite sibilant at times there, while Ella’s croon remains soft and feathery.) The backing music provided by Oscar Peterson and his band of that period — Herb Ellis on guitar, Ray Brown on bass, and Buddy Rich on drums — is swinging, subtle, and supportive of the singers on this release. The music is full-bodied and rich, but definitely positioned in the background of the mix. If you close your eyes while listening to “Cheek to Cheek,” for example, it feels almost like the band is 5-10 feet behind the singers in the room.
If you are a deeper Ella And Louis fan, you may want to try to track down an original pressing, but I suspect you’re going to have a difficult time of it. I say this from experience, as I’ve been trying to find a clean — and affordable — copy myself for many years now. This was a popular album in its day, and — like many jazz, pop, and R&B albums of the time period — they were often played on average to sub-average equipment. Indeed, if you look at the mid-1950s editions up for sale on Discogs at the time of this posting, none are listed in better than VG-plus quality, with prices ranging upwards of $100. The cover art for this new Verve and Acoustic Sounds edition of Ella And Louis is dramatically improved. The original album was a single-pocket sleeve design, but the new version is a far more deluxe gatefold package with a beautiful, laminated finish and elegant-looking session photos inside. They even reproduced the early orange-and-yellow Verve Records label design that graced certain pressings from this time period. I happen to know that particular label design mostly from some of Oscar Peterson’s easy-listening albums, but I think the original intent of the label variant was to try to establish a brand differentiation between jazz and pop-leaning releases. (My old copy of Ella And Louis is on the black Verve label, thanks for asking.) Oh, you may be wondering why the album is in mono, and not in stereo. That’s a very easy question to answer. Stereo records did not become a consumer reality until around 1958. That doesn’t make this album any less of an enjoyable listening experience, however — because Ella And Louis generally sounds fabulous in mono! Once again, UMe, through its Verve Records and Acoustic Sounds series, has delivered a reissue that is arguably better than the original in most every way. If you are a fan of these two legendary artists, you probably need this one in your collection ASAP. (Mark Smotroff is an avid vinyl collector who has also worked in marketing communications for decades. He has reviewed music for AudiophileReview.com, among others, and you can see more of his impressive C.V. at LinkedIn.)
ELLA FITZGERALD AND LOUIS ARMSTRONG ELLA AND LOUIS 1LP 180g mono (Verve/Acoustic Sounds) Side A 1. Can’t We Be Friends 2. Isn’t This A Lovely Day 3. Moonlight In Vermont 4. They Can’t Take That Away From Me 5. Under A Blanket Of Blue 6. Tenderly Side B 1. A Foggy Day 2. Stars Fell On Alabama 3. Cheek To Cheek 4. The Nearness Of You 5. April In Paris
I want it and keep trying to get it at a lower price, but no one seems to want to budge on the price and judging from the Miles Davis and Clifford Brown Esoteric SACD box sets that I already own, I expect it to be fabulous; Its funny your review posted today Mark, as I just heard my copy today, after the first one had to go back due to surface imperfections along with a Speakers Corner Miles Davis pressing which by the way, whatever happened to Speakers Corner quality control? Just awful these days. In any event, I thought the sound was smooth and both singers well captured. I don’t think it is as good as the 45 rpm version of a few years ago. Much better.
Mark has some setup issues which overemphasize certain aspects. No idea what should sound bright here for example.
But compared to the AP 45RPM I’d say the latter is an 11 and this here a 9 in my rough scale, so finally Mark is not completely wrong, given the potential upwards, he hasn’t heard yet.
I can only listen to the original pressings I own. And they are 10/11 for sure. The Ella & Louis Again I would rate with 11/11, because Autumn in New York is one of the best ten songs of all time to me.
“Plus, they were recording in the then-new Capitol Records studios in Hollywood, which may have brought its own unique idiosyncrasies.”
I believe that all these ‘idiosyncrasies’ (whatever you are referring to) were more than ironed out through the series of incredibly high quality recordings that Sinatra , Cole and other artists made in these studios during the 4-5 years preceeding the Ella-Louis recordings in question.
Submitted by SpinMark3313 on Sun, 2022-08-21 16:07
…my wallet. So, three weeks ago, when the Blue Train post went up, I thought nope, don’t need it. Then I went to reach for my LP copy for a listen and reminder of what version I own. It wasn’t there. Puzzled, I looked around other parts of my collection to see if it was mis-filed. Nope. But I know I have it. I know the music. It’s been quite awhile since I’ve listened, but one of the great things about AP (and some others) is the flow of reminders of great recordings, sometimes long neglected in my herd. Finally found it. On CD. OK – so I committed the shekels to the new Blue Train LP release. Now, Ella and Pops. Got it! Went to reach for the LP. There’s Porgy and Bess, but where’s E&L? I KNOW I HAVE IT. Yeah, same brain fart. It’s (well parts of it) on a Verve reissue of Ella & Louis highlights including tunes from “Again.” Yeah, and again I shell out more shekels on the way home today. Local Rasputin had two AP copies. This increase of music reviews and reissue news is gonna hurt, but hurt so good.
Is it an AAA source ? Is it a Digital master transfer? Is it DSD and what bit form was it done in. Re Issues these days . As a consumer we have to ask ? I am sure Chad Isn’t getting ever tape .Davis himself said it they do not release real master tapes. I will get an SACD
I have been through several orange label copies of this title, and ALL exhibit sibilance on many tracks featuring LA. This issue is still present but diminished in intensity on Black label pressings. My conclusion is the problems are on the master tape. Verve first pressings feature an Orange Label for vocals and some “mainstream” titles, and the “trumpeter” logo for straight jazz titles. Many Verve titles were pressed “hot” and could be unplayable on the equipment of the time. Unfortunately Verve chose to recut problematic titles using compression and EQ. Bass below about 80hz and treble above about 10khz is missing. I am curious to know if Kevin Gray had access to the original tape or the later EQ modified tape.
I heard this album at a show once, played back on a pair or Rethm Bhaava speakers and, if I kept my eyes closed, it sounded like Louis was having his head squeezed right out of the speaker.
Some versions can have an overemphasize on his upper vocal range.
I think your description is apt for some pressings….or the master.
The Esoteric SACD release of this album is spectacular. I figure if Mo Fi can release all that digital material, it should be OK to mention this Esoteric release. It is sublimely good. The bummer is, I think it only comes as part of this set: https://www.discogs.com/release/16504995-Various-Verve-6-Great-Jazz I want it and keep trying to get it at a lower price, but no one seems to want to budge on the price and judging from the Miles Davis and Clifford Brown Esoteric SACD box sets that I already own, I expect it to be fabulous; Its funny your review posted today Mark, as I just heard my copy today, after the first one had to go back due to surface imperfections along with a Speakers Corner Miles Davis pressing which by the way, whatever happened to Speakers Corner quality control? Just awful these days. In any event, I thought the sound was smooth and both singers well captured. I don’t think it is as good as the 45 rpm version of a few years ago. Much better. Analogplanet, an edit choice is sorely needed (see above). This is what happens when I type during happy hour. The horror! This album is an undiluted joy from start to finish and one of mankind’s greatest achievements. If you care at all about music (I realize many audiophiles do not) you should own a copy of Ella and Louis. A very fine weekend to you all. The very slight sibilance on those tracks in my opinion is the typical Satchmo occasional mic sibilance, not from the record. Brightness I don’t hear at all on this release. I have the AP 45RPM and it’s a hell lot of better sounding, more open, 3D, focused etc. I own several early originals. This is an all valve all analog recording and the sound on them is a straight 11. Mark has some setup issues which overemphasize certain aspects. No idea what should sound bright here for example. But compared to the AP 45RPM I’d say the latter is an 11 and this here a 9 in my rough scale, so finally Mark is not completely wrong, given the potential upwards, he hasn’t heard yet. An 8 for this one is too low, I agree. I can only listen to the original pressings I own. And they are 10/11 for sure. The Ella & Louis Again I would rate with 11/11, because Autumn in New York is one of the best ten songs of all time to me. “Plus, they were recording in the then-new Capitol Records studios in Hollywood, which may have brought its own unique idiosyncrasies.” I believe that all these ‘idiosyncrasies’ (whatever you are referring to) were more than ironed out through the series of incredibly high quality recordings that Sinatra , Cole and other artists made in these studios during the 4-5 years preceeding the Ella-Louis recordings in question. …my wallet. So, three weeks ago, when the Blue Train post went up, I thought nope, don’t need it. Then I went to reach for my LP copy for a listen and reminder of what version I own. It wasn’t there. Puzzled, I looked around other parts of my collection to see if it was mis-filed. Nope. But I know I have it. I know the music. It’s been quite awhile since I’ve listened, but one of the great things about AP (and some others) is the flow of reminders of great recordings, sometimes long neglected in my herd. Finally found it. On CD. OK – so I committed the shekels to the new Blue Train LP release. Now, Ella and Pops. Got it! Went to reach for the LP. There’s Porgy and Bess, but where’s E&L? I KNOW I HAVE IT. Yeah, same brain fart. It’s (well parts of it) on a Verve reissue of Ella & Louis highlights including tunes from “Again.” Yeah, and again I shell out more shekels on the way home today. Local Rasputin had two AP copies. This increase of music reviews and reissue news is gonna hurt, but hurt so good. Is it an AAA source ? Is it a Digital master transfer? Is it DSD and what bit form was it done in. Re Issues these days . As a consumer we have to ask ? I am sure Chad Isn’t getting ever tape .Davis himself said it they do not release real master tapes. I will get an SACD all the wrong answers to yourself already, so it seems that’s what you need. I have been through several orange label copies of this title, and ALL exhibit sibilance on many tracks featuring LA. This issue is still present but diminished in intensity on Black label pressings. My conclusion is the problems are on the master tape. Verve first pressings feature an Orange Label for vocals and some “mainstream” titles, and the “trumpeter” logo for straight jazz titles. Many Verve titles were pressed “hot” and could be unplayable on the equipment of the time. Unfortunately Verve chose to recut problematic titles using compression and EQ. Bass below about 80hz and treble above about 10khz is missing. I am curious to know if Kevin Gray had access to the original tape or the later EQ modified tape. I heard this album at a show once, played back on a pair or Rethm Bhaava speakers and, if I kept my eyes closed, it sounded like Louis was having his head squeezed right out of the speaker. Some versions can have an overemphasize on his upper vocal range. I think your description is apt for some pressings….or the master.
by Despite the XFL hosting their showcases all summer long and sending draft invites out to players, it has been confirmed that teams will be holding their workouts for players in the coming weeks.
House of Athlete Hosting XFL Las Vegas For Private Player Workouts
It was confirmed by Defensive Back Jordan Canady today on Twitter that on Monday, August 29th, 2022, from 12 pm – 5 pm EST and Tuesday, August 30th, 2022 – 7 am to 3 pm House of Athlete will be holding a private player workout for the Las Vegas XFL team. It is unknown at this time who will be there representing XFL Las Vegas; it could be Head Coach Rod Woodson or some of his coaching staff.
As the day went on, we heard about more players being part of this private workout, and the names confirmed through Player Agency Team 1ST Choice Sports that the following players have been verified.
Current Players Confirmed for Workouts
XFLAnalyst confirmed other players including QB Tyquell Fields, TE Phil Brown II, WE Elisha Peat, DL Tyran Dixon, WR Keyon Thomas, WE Caleb Eagans, DL Tyrone Kelly, DB Adam Sparks, RB Kentavious Thomas, WR Cam White, WR Josh Wilkes, DB Josh Johnson, WR AJ Greene, DB Jordan Burney, DB Kareem Gaulden, and DB Byron Edwards.
QB Tyquell Fields, TE Phil Brown III, WR Elisha Peat, DL Tyran Dixon, WR Keyon Thomas, WR Caleb Eagens, and DL Tyrone Kelly are working out with #XFL Las Vegas, according to their agency @1stchoice_
Is Orlando also holding a workout as well? 1st Choice Sports confirmed that their clients DB CJ Anthony and LB Taylor Powell are trying out for a private player workout with the Orlando XFL team during a currently unknown date or location for this tryout. It is not confirmed at this point, but it appears that teams will be holding their tryouts as time goes on, these could be by private invites by the coaching staff of each XFL team, or the league itself remains to be seen. Currently, none of these players are drafted or associated with the teams themselves, and from what I can tell, only Cam White was part of the Texas Showcase and got an invite to the draft pool, whereas the others were not part of any of them.
Are teams going to start signing players before the draft?
Is this another way teams can sign players directly before the draft? Or will these private workouts be part of the opportunity to be invited into the draft this way with possible prior commitments or just not enough space during the summer showcases held across the country?
House of Athlete State-Of-The-Art Facility and Program Possibly leading to an XFL partnership?
According to its website, House of Athlete is a “State-Of-The-Art facility in a class of its own.” They offer athletes the best training, coaching, products, and recovery care at any level while maintaining a strong emphasis on mental fitness and wellness. Their facility provides pro-grade fitness, performance, wellness, and amenities while focusing on Mental Health and Fitness. A key point I noticed about House of Athlete is that they specialize in an NFL Combine Training program that currently only accepts 24 athletes at the HOA performance training location in Weston, FL, which assists young men transitioning into the NFL Draft process. They claim to be the experts in making the transition a successful one. For anyone not aware of the connection between HOA and Football, it is that HOA was founded by its current CEO, former Denver Broncos NFL Wide Reciever Brandon Marshall, who invested in a $10 million investment, that has worked out very well.
Researching House of Athlete, I also noticed that they are building a 24,000 SQFT two-level flagship with luxury member amenities, including locker rooms, hot & cold plunge, steam room, sauna, IV lounge, and physical therapy spaces. A 7,800 SQFT training floor with 40-yard turf and a private training studio in Dallas, TX, appears to be about 18 miles from XFL’s HQ in Arlington at Choctaw Stadium. Could we possibly see a partnership between the league and HOA if there isn’t one already going on based on these private player workouts and the new location opening in Dallas soon? You can find all the information and the excellent team over at HOA that handles the NFL Combine/Draft classes at this link here HOA NFL Combine. Stay tuned to XFLNewsHub.com for any developing information relating to the XFL having their teams holding their private player workouts as we get closer and closer to the XFL 2023 season kick-off in less than six months.
Your email address will not be published.Required fields are marked *
Danielle Smith says recordings posted to social media this weekend in which someone claiming to be from her campaign berates a Calgarian are "fake." Twitter user Cassandra Raugust posted audio of the phone calls to her account on Sunday evening. In one, a woman identifying herself as "Dale from the Danielle Smith campaign" thanks her for her recent donation and invites her to a "donor appreciation dinner" on Monday. In response, Raugust can be heard saying she would never vote for Smith. "I have asked (that) my name be removed from your call list and I certainly didn’t donate. I didn’t give you my phone number and I would really like these calls to stop." The woman then responds by saying she can give Raugust the number for complaints, if she’d like. Raugust interrupts to say she already has the number and has been "harassed" when using it. "I think I’d prefer if you’d just take my name off your list," Raugust says. "We’ll call you again, thanks so much. Hope you’re in a better mood. No communists are allowed," the woman replied. ok Twitter – here’s round 2 of @ABDanielleSmith campaign calling me – this is just one minute ago – please help me understand WTF is going on #ableg@CarrieTait@LeelaAheer@MichelletypoQpic.twitter.com/AejiEjj3RB Raugust shared the audio to Twitter at 8:55 p.m. Later, at 9:01 p.m., she shared audio of what she says is a voicemail left on her account. Ok Twitter – here is the voicemail left by @ABDanielleSmith campaign callers #ableg this was 3 minutes ago @LeelaAheer@MichelletypoQ welcome to your local evening harassment pic.twitter.com/raAwg7qBLa In the message, the caller, who again identifies themself as "Dale from the Danielle Smith campaign," says they will remove Raugust’s phone number from their list "And actually, as it turns out, communists are not allowed at the event tomorrow night so please don’t come as nobody will want to see you there," she says. "They also don’t want no vaccine. "Hope you have a wonderful evening and please don’t ruin the lives of any other people." CTV News has reached out to Raugust for an interview, but have yet to receive a response. Danielle Smith responded to the leaked audio on Monday, saying the caller did not work for her campaign. "This is clearly a malicious prank from someone trying to pretend to be on our campaign," said Smith. "This is fake. Our call centre uses a publicly accessible campaign number, not a private number. It’s a good idea to refrain from jumping to conclusions as dirty tactics seem to be common these days." .@ABDanielleSmith on phone calls alleged to have come from her campaign: “This is clearly a malicious prank from someone trying to pretend to be on our campaign. This is fake. Our call centre uses a publicly accessible campaign number, not a private number. (1/2) She adds that her staff are assessing next steps and will meet tomorrow on whether they will file a complaint with Elections Alberta or not. The complaint number provided by "Dale" actually belongs to a restaurant called Osteria De Medici in Calgary’s Kensington area, which has denied any involvement in the calls. The owner tells CTV News he has received many calls from people wanting to complain, and wants the calls to stop. CTV News has reached out to the UCP for comment, but have not yet received a response. Mount Royal University political science professor Duane Bratt says when he initially heard the calls, he thought they sounded legitimate. "I’m looking at this and I’m thinking there’s only a handful of possibilities: either the Smith team did this, (or) maybe one of the other UCP campaigns did that to try to embarrass the Smith campaign," said Bratt. "Maybe the NDP or a like-minded group did this to embarrass the Smith campaign, or this is just a lone wolf, pranking a person." However, Bratt believes if this was a competitor of Smith’s making the calls, they would have been more elaborate. "If I was doing disinformation against Smith, I would have gone a lot further than what the call did," said Bratt. "If I really wanted to attack them, I would have made it racial, I would have made it more vulgar. I would have gone much deeper than what was there, if I was trying to really embarrass the Smith team." Regarding this voicemail prank. Clearly it is someone pretending to be on our campaign. It is fake. Our call centre uses a public number & was also not in operation during those call times. Probably a good idea to refrain from jumping to conclusions from dirty tactics. #abpoli Elections Alberta communications officer Megan Narsing says she can’t confirm whether complaints have been made to Elections Alberta. "Elections Alberta is unable to comment about allegations that we may or may not have received or investigations that we may or may not be conducting," she said. "This is in accordance with the disclosure provisions in the Election Act." Narsing says any findings from an investigation would be made public. "We publish findings and decisions on the Chief Electoral Officer’s website when any investigation is concluded if an administrative penalty is imposed, a letter of reprimand is issued, or a request is received to publish from a person or organization who is the subject of the investigation," she said. The UCP will elect a new leader to replace Jason Kenney on Oct. 6. It has been six months since Russia launched its current attacks on Ukraine, sparking death, destruction, and condemnation from the international community. While the impacts of the invasion are most severely felt in Ukraine, the war has had global political implications, including here in Canada. CTVNews.ca looks at six key moments for Canada over the last six months.
A 24-year-old woman from Kenya whose drowning death was captured on a livestream video is being remembered as a “superhero” who helped Ontario long-term care homes through the pandemic.
A Saskatoon woman who was arrested in Oregon for allegedly using false identification to cross the border with her seven-year-old son is to be returned to Canada.
Residents of Kyiv woke up to air raid sirens as Ukraine observed its Independence Day on Wednesday, which also marked exactly six months since the start of Russia's military invasion.
The Kremlin's justification for invading Ukraine "is a lie," a Russian paratrooper who previously publicly condemned his country's war in Ukraine has told CNN.
Years of long hours, understaffed companies and burned-out employees have all led to the latest TikTok trend: quiet quitting.
She's been described as a 'virtuoso,' and at age 12, Lucy Lin is also the youngest player ever to qualify for the CP Women's Open.
The photograph of Sir Winston Churchill taken from Ottawa’s Chateau Laurier hotel was stolen about eight months ago and replaced with a copy, hotel officials said Tuesday.
Ukraine's ambassador to Canada will today mark Ukraine's Independence Day with the launch of an immersive exhibition in Toronto created during the most violent phases of the war with Russia.
Children's cold and fever medication has become increasingly hard to find at pharmacies across the country.
An Edmonton family changed forever on Aug. 14. 'Saying we are devastated would be an understatement. They just lived for their families and we really – none of us know what to do without them.'
The RCMP have confirmed they are investigating after Leela Aheer, one of the candidates in the UCP leadership race, reported that some of her social media accounts had been compromised.
A newly married couple who stopped in Vancouver on the way to their honeymoon had everything but the clothes on their backs stolen in Stanley Park.
The family of a doctor and mother of three who was brutally killed in India 19 years ago is calling on Ottawa to take action to help with the investigation.
For the first time in a decade, Canada has a chief nursing officer – and that has B.C. nursing groups eying a bigger role for the provincial equivalent.
RCMP Commissioner Brenda Lucki is to appear on the witness stand for a second day at the inquiry into the 2020 Nova Scotia mass shooting.
Nova Scotia has confirmed its first case of monkeypox. The provincial government said Tuesday that the case involves a Nova Scotia resident, but the person contracted monkeypox while travelling outside the province.
Lisa LaFlamme’s dismissal from her role as chief anchor of CTV National News continues to spark conversations — and fierce backlash — on social media more than a week after the news broke.
A Victoria man has been sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 14 years in a mistaken-identity murder case. Anthony Dheensaw, 38, was sentenced Tuesday morning in B.C. Supreme Court for the killing of Angela Dalman, 40, a beloved friend and mother.
A Vancouver Island man is getting ready to fly to Italy to take part in an international archery competition next month. Billy Sanderson is a barebow archer, a title that refers to the type of bow he uses. "There's no sights, no aiming devices on our bows," he said Tuesday.
A woman who was convicted of critically injuring a young girl at a crosswalk in Saanich, B.C., in 2017 has been granted full parole after spending less than one year in jail. The court heard from witnesses that she was speeding, texting and crossing into the oncoming lane to pass other vehicles before the crash occurred.
More than 250 people have been killed in land and water collisions so far this year, the Ontario Provincial Police says.
A 24-year-old woman from Kenya whose drowning death was captured on a livestream video is being remembered as a “superhero” who helped Ontario long-term care homes through the pandemic.
Along Toronto's waterfront, debris including tampons, condoms, and wet wipes could be seen floating in Lake Ontario following Monday’s heavy rainfall – a scene environmental groups say should raise concern over the city's sewage and storm water system.
Quebec Premier Francois Legault says the fall provincial election campaign will begin Sunday. He made the announcement in a video uploaded to social media. The Quebec election is scheduled for Oct. 3.
Quebec health officials expect to give a COVID-19 update Wednesday as the province continues to battle the seventh wave of the pandemic.
The Quebec Liberals have chosen lawyer Brigitte Garceau as their candidate in Montreal riding Robert-Baldwin.
The photograph of Sir Winston Churchill taken from Ottawa’s Chateau Laurier hotel was stolen about eight months ago and replaced with a copy, hotel officials said Tuesday.
An Ottawa farmer says he is feeling forgotten by the government three months after a massive storm destroyed his property.
Most millennials in Ottawa who don’t own a home believe they will one day while one-third think they never will, according to a new survey.
A Woolwich Township councillor is facing criticism for homophobic comments he made during a council meeting on Monday.
A Guelph man known for his friendly face and welcoming wave has died.
Ontario Provincial Police say one person is dead after a small plane crashed in Perth County Tuesday morning.
A Saskatoon woman who was arrested in Oregon for allegedly using false identification to cross the border with her seven-year-old son is to be returned to Canada.
Saskatchewan is projecting a $1.04 billion surplus for 2022-23, with a large bump from non-renewable resource revenues projected.
The University of Saskatchewan will not be mandating masks on campus this fall.
The owners of a northern Ontario farm are frantically searching for a three-week-old quarter horse colt that was stolen over the weekend saying it can't live much longer without its mother's milk.
Years of long hours, understaffed companies and burned-out employees have all led to the latest TikTok trend: quiet quitting.
It has been six months since Russia launched its current attacks on Ukraine, sparking death, destruction, and condemnation from the international community. While the impacts of the invasion are most severely felt in Ukraine, the war has had global political implications, including here in Canada. CTVNews.ca looks at six key moments for Canada over the last six months.
The Winnipeg Police Service has released the name of a woman recently found dead in an apartment on Jarvis Avenue on Monday.
The family of a Second World War veteran and Manitoba farmer has donated 318 acres of land near Brandon, Man. to celebrate his memory and aid in conservation efforts.
Residents in the Point Douglas area are on edge after a string of violence, from multiple assaults to a homicide investigation.
The Government of Saskatchewan amended its provincial trespassing act ahead of its ongoing dispute with the federal government.
The Saskatchewan Roughriders Football Club released its 2021-22 annual report Tuesday and is sitting at a loss of $4.5 million dollars due to the last two years of pandemic disruptions.
Saskatchewan is projecting a $1.04 billion surplus for 2022-23, with a large bump from non-renewable resource revenues projected.
Real Estate / Paradise Palms in Biltmore submarket sells for $36.5M Newmark announced the $36.5 million sale of Paradise Palms, a 130-unit, value-add multifamily community situated in the prime Biltmore/Uptown submarket of Phoenix, Arizona. Newmark Senior Managing DirectorsChris Canter and Brett Polachekand Executive Managing Director Brad Goff represented the seller, Ogden Capital Partners LLC, in the sale to an undisclosed buyer. Constructed in 1959, the Paradise Palms is garden-style community was designed by a famous architect, Ralph Haver. It offers large, spacious floor plans and features a mix of studio, one-, two- and three-bedroom units. Community amenities include on-site maintenance and property management, two resort-style pools, pet play area, storage space, grills and a picnic area. READ ALSO: Here’s what AZRE Forum experts say to watch in commercial real estate “Paradise Palms is a unique and spectacular multifamily asset in a Class A Uptown/Biltmore location,” said Canter. “This is the perfect asset for the buyer to capture the robust Phoenix rent growth with a more modern interior and exterior renovation. The previous owners purchased this asset in 2014 and have benefitted from the development and investment that has taken place along 7th and 16th Street.” Following a record 2021, investor demand for multifamily remained robust during the first quarter of 2022 with $63.0 billion in U.S. sales volume, according to Real Capital Analytics data analyzed by Newmark Research. In addition to this volume signifying the largest first quarter on record, year-over-year volume accelerated 65.4%. Trailing twelve-month volume increased to $374.3 billion. Phoenix ranked sixth among major metros in terms of sales volume over the 12 months ending in the first quarter, with $17.5 billion in volume. Located at 1517 E. Colter Street in Phoenix, Paradise Palms is situated just off the Piestewa Freeway, a convenient seven-minute drive to the I-10 freeway and a 10-minute drive to Sky Harbor International Airport. The location is proximate to over 200,000 high-paying jobs and multiple award-winning restaurants and entertainment options. GET OUR FREE SUBSCRIBE Copyright 2022 AZ Big Media. All Rights Reserved.
MHA suspends former top excise officials for ‘serious lapses’ MHA suspends then Excise Commissioner Arava Gopi Krishna&Dy Commissioner Anand Tiwari,days after Delhi Lt Gov VK Saxena approved suspension&initiation of disciplinary proceedings for “serious lapses” against 11 officers of Excise dept in connection withDelhi Excise Policy2021-22 pic.twitter.com/srtLLas7Ri AAP claims to have audio recording of BJP’s offer to Sisodia The AAP has the audio recording of the BJP’s “offer” to Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia that all cases against him will be dropped if he switched sides, sources in the Arvind Kejriwal-led party said on Monday. The Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) will make the audio recording public “when the time comes”, they added. (PTI) AIIMS paramedical students withdraw agitation after demands met Delhi | AIIMS paramedical students have withdrawn their agitation and resumed normal work with immediate effect after their demands have been approved. The students had made demands pertaining to hostel accommodation and other issues. Delhi logs 625 new Covid-19 infections, 7 deaths in last 24 hours Delhi reports 625 fresh #COVID19 cases, 1114 recoveries and 7 deaths in the last 24 hours.
Active cases 4645 pic.twitter.com/UHlg57UvIZ Delhi Jal Board calls for FIRs against corrupt water meter readers Delhi Jal Board vice chairman Saurabh Bhardwaj on Monday asked officials to file police complaints against water meter readers and private companies indulging in corrupt practices, according to a statement. During a meeting with officials, Bhardwaj also directed them to resolve issues related to water meter readings and “erroneous” water bills in a time-bound manner, the DJB statement said. (PTI) Muggy weather in Delhi as temperatures remain above average Muggy weather conditions prevailed in Delhi on Monday with the maximum temperature settling at 36.1 degrees Celsius, two notches above the season’s average. The minimum temperature was recorded at 27.6 degrees Celsius, a notch above the season’s average. Humidity levels oscillated between 88 and 56 per cent. (PTI) Bharat Jodo Yatra like ‘tapasya’ to me: Rahul Gandhi Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Monday told a group of civil society representatives at the Constitution Club in New Delhi thatthe party’s upcoming ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ is like a “tapasya” for him and that he is ready for the “long battle” to unite the country. The Congress had announced last week it will launch on September 7 the ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ — being billed by the party as the longest yatra mounted in this country over the last century. MSP committee forms four sub-groups to discuss key issues as farmers protest The committee on Minimum Support Price (MSP) formed four sub-groups on mandated topics, including making “MSP more effective and transparent” in its first meeting on Monday but Samyukta Kisan Morcha (SKM) remained absent. The committee, headed by former agriculture secretary Sanjay Agrawal, discussed ways to “promote zero budget based farming”, to “change” crop patterns keeping in mind the changing needs of the country, and to make MSP more “effective and transparent”. The panel has 26 members including the chairman, while three membership slots are kept aside for representatives of SKM. (PTI) AAP govt refutes to Delhi Chief Secretary’s excise policy report AAP government sources on Monday issued a point-by-point rebuttal to the Delhi chief secretary’s report flagging “violation of rules and procedural lapses” in the implementation of the Excise Policy 2021-22, amid a CBI probe into the matter. The CBI probe was recommended by Lieutenant Governor V K Saxena last month based on the Delhi chief secretary’s report that had listed various instances of “violations of rules and procedural lapses” and “undue favour” to licensees in the implementation of the policy from November 2021. The CBI has filed an FIR against 13 persons and two companies, including Deputy Chief Minister and Excise Minister Manish Sisodia, in the matter. The policy was withdrawn by the government after Saxena recommended a CBI probe into it. (PTI) ABVP claims JNU guards assaulted them during protest Over a dozen students were injured on Monday allegedly after security guards at JNU roughed them up for protesting on campus, ABVP claimed. The students were staging a protest on the campus alleging that they have not received their fellowship in over a year, a member from the RSS-backed student group said. “Over a dozen suffered injuries after Cyclops attacked them on the order of administration,” ABVP activist Ambuj said. Cyclops is the firm tasked with managing security on the Jawaharlal Nehru University campus. I’m a soldier of Kejriwal, have learnt honesty from him: Sisodia Two days back some uninvited guests came to my residence. People were good but those who sent them had done that uninvited. I’m not scared, I’m a soldier of Arvind Kejriwal. I’ve learnt the politics of working & honesty from him: Delhi Dy CM Manish Sisodia in Himmatnagar, Gujarat pic.twitter.com/HCQHKwrisw Police constable, guard assaulted by inebriated men at Delhi hospital A Delhi Police constable and security guard at a Delhi government-run hospital here were allegedly assaulted by two men in an inebriated state, officials said on Monday. The incident took place at the Lal Bahadur Shastri hospital in Kalyanpuri on the intervening night of Sunday and Monday, they said, adding hospital property was also damaged by the miscreants. Rahul Gandhi leaves Constitution Club after ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ meet Congress leader Rahul Gandhi on Monday interacted with civil society organisations andprominent personalities for the ‘Bharat Jodo Yatra’ to begin on 7th September. Congress MP Rahul Gandhi leaves from the Constitution Club of India in Delhi https://t.co/lqY8E2ETO4pic.twitter.com/Zl00UJD7YE Operation Lotus has failed in Delhi: Kejriwal दिल्ली में ऑपरेशन लोटस फेल https://t.co/y8XBCSPS0d Manish Sisodia responds to BJP ‘offer’ to make him CM candidate मुझे CM कैंडिडेट बनाने के ऑफर पर BJP को मेरा संदेश-@ArvindKejriwal जी मेरे राजनैतिक गुरु है, उनसे कभी ग़द्दारी नहीं करूँगा। मैं CM बनने नहीं आया, मेरा सपना है- देश के हर बच्चे को अच्छी शिक्षा मिले, तभी तो भारत न 1 देश बनेगा। पूरे देश में ये काम केवल केजरीवाल जी कर सकते हैं Sisodia deserves a Bharat Ratna for education reforms: Kejriwal Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Monday said his deputy Manish Sisodia should be given the Bharat Ratna for improving standard of education in Delhi schools, but is being hounded by the Central government due to political motives.
Read more Kejriwal a ‘big liar’, his ministers ‘bigger liars’: Anurag Thakur Union minister Anurag Thakur on Monday called Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal a “big liar” and his ministers “bigger liars”, reacting to AAP leader Manish Sisodia’s claim that he was offered the CM’s post by the BJP if he broke the Aam Aadmi Party. Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Sisodia has claimed that he was approached by theBJPwith the offer to close all cases against him if he joined their party and broke the AAP. He is among 15 people and entities named in an FIR registered by the Central Bureau of Investigation in connection with alleged irregularities in the implementation of the Delhi excise policy. Farmers from various organisations gather as they participate in a protest against the central government policies, in New Delhi Credit: AFP Photo A farmer leader addresses other farmers during a protest against unemployment and other issues organized by Samyukt Kisan Morcha (SKM), at Jantar Mantar in New Delhi Credit: IANS Photo Delhi BJP holds protest outside Kejriwal’s residence: Delhi BJP president Adesh Gupta said Kejriwal should expel Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia from his Cabinet as he is “accused number one” in the case registered by the CBI. “Kejriwal is the kingpin of the whole scam in which liquor mafia was allowed to loot at the expense of state exchequer,” he alleged. Gupta said Delhi BJP workers will go door-to-door across the city to tell the people about the “corruption and excise scam” committed by the Kejriwal government. A probe is underway by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) into the alleged irregularities in the Delhi government’s Excise Policy 2021-22. Manish Sisodia may be arrested, who knows I may also be arrested; all this is being done for Gujarat elections: Arvind Kejriwal
Telangana Chief Minister K. Chandrasekhar Rao’s daughter and state legislator K. Kavitha on Monday announced that she will file defamation suit against two BJP leaders for their allegation that she was involved in the multi-crore liquor policy scam in Del Kavitha, a member of Telangana Legislative Council, said the defamation suit will be filed against BJP MP Parvesh Varma and former MLA Manjinder Singh Sirsa. The former MP will also move court seeking an injunction order against those making the allegations. This came a day after the two BJP leaders alleged that she played a crucial role in a liquor policy scam involving Delhi Deputy Chief Minister Manish Sisodia. BJP’s national spokesperson Gaurav Bhatia said that Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and his DyCM Manish Sisodia have no answer to the questions raised by the BJP on the irregularities in the excise policy. “That’s why, he is speaking nonsense,” Bhati
I gave a clear political answer to them, saying Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal is my political guru and I have learnt politics from him: Sisodia I have not come into politics to be CM or PM,” Sisodia said. AAP national convener Kejriwal and his deputy Sisodia on Monday arrived on a two-day visit to Gujarat, where the Assembly elections are due this year-end. During the visit, the two AAP leaders hold discussions on employment and education with youth ahead of the state. Their visit comes amid a row over alleged irregularities in Delhi’s excise policy and the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) registering an FIR against Sisodia. This is Kejriwal’s fourth visit to Gujarat this month. From Swaraj, it has now become ‘sharab’ (liquor) raj. If Sisodia is accused no 1 in the case, the kingpin is Arvind Kejriwal: Anurah Thakur slams AAP leaders Information and Broadcasting Minister Anurag Thakur told reporters in Shimla that the Arvind Kejriwal model has now been decoded and it is now “Mohalla clinic to Mohalla liquor vends”. “From Swaraj, it has now become ‘sharab’ (liquor) raj. If Sisodia is accused no 1 in the case, the kingpin is Arvind Kejriwal.” AAP leader Arvind Kejriwal breaking records in corruption, alleges BJP’s Gaurav Bhatia on Delhi excise policy Many discrepancies in what was recommended by panel on Delhi excise policy and what AAP govt implemented, alleges BJP’s Gaurav Bhatia BJP hits back at AAP and Sisodia after the latter’s claims. BJP spokesperson says “Whoever Kejriwal certifies as non-corrupt, certainly ends up behind bars”
AAP slams BJP, says those accused, are suddenly clean after joining BJP’s washing machine
वो बड़े नाम जिन्हें BJP ने सबसे बड़ा Corrupt कहा, CBI-ED की Raid कराई
फ़िर जो BJP Join करके Washing Machine में धुल गए, BJP के लिए अचानक निर्दोष हो गए:
—Shuvendu Adhikari —Himanta Biswa Sarma —Mukul Roy —Narayan Rane —Anil Sharma —Pema Khandu —Baijayant Panda
BJP workers protest against Aam Aadmi Party outside Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal's residence pic.twitter.com/2hnHwn3DlT Delhi Police detain farmers protesting against unemployment at Ghazipur on the Delhi-UP border Delhi Police detain farmers protesting at Ghazipur on the Delhi-UP border. Farmers are protesting today against unemployment. pic.twitter.com/wUV8arTPfa Sisodia claims BJP asked him to join party in exchange for dropping all cases In a major development, Delhi Deputy CM Manish Sisodia on Monday alleged that the BJP invited him to join its party, promising to “close all CBI, ED cases”. “I won’t bow down before conspirators and corrupt people. All cases against me are false,” Sisodia said in a tweet.
Delhi | Traffic piles up near the Ghazipur border as police put up checkpoints at the border, ahead of call by farmers for protest at Jantar Mantar today pic.twitter.com/dYJaiK9mQb Traffic movement is slow at the Noida-Delhi Chilla border as security is heightened at the border entry point to Delhi, amid a call for protest by farmers over the issue of unemployment at Jantar Mantar
Traffic movement is slow at the Noida-Delhi Chilla border as security is heightened at the border entry point to Delhi, amid a call for protest by farmers over the issue of unemployment at Jantar Mantar pic.twitter.com/SHyq6J9aMT Security tightened at Delhi’s Singhu border
Security tightened at Delhi's Singhu border ahead of the call by farmers to protest at Jantar Mantar today pic.twitter.com/uc3tADeS98 Security increased at Ghazipur border on the Delhi-Meerut expressway
Delhi | Security increased at Ghazipur border on the Delhi-Meerut expressway ahead of the call given by farmers to protest at Jantar Mantar today pic.twitter.com/mSSMGvfiD5 Farmers begin arriving at Jantar Mantar to stage a protest against unemployment, amid heavy police and security presence Police have heightened security at the three border entry points to Delhi at Ghazipur, Singhu and Tikri Delhi | Farmers begin arriving at Jantar Mantar to stage a protest against unemployment, amid heavy police and security presence
Police have heightened security at the three border entry points to Delhi at Ghazipur, Singhu and Tikri pic.twitter.com/cjzH2xGccE Traffic movement may be affected in many parts of Delhi as the police have put up barricades at border points Ppolice asked motorists to avoid Tolstoy Marg, Sansad Marg, Janpath Road, Ashoka Road, Outer Circle Connaught Place, Baba Kharak Singh Marg and Pandit Pant Marg due to farmers’ mahapanchayat. Security was beefed up on Monday at Delhi borders, including Singhu and Ghazipur, ahead of the ‘mahapanchayat’ called by farmers’ body at Jantar Mantar Police said all vehicles entering the capital are being checked and police personnel are on the ‘alert mode’. Traffic movement may be affected in many parts of Delhi as the police have put up barricades at border points, they said. In a tweet, the police asked motorists to avoid Tolstoy Marg, Sansad Marg, Janpath Road, Ashoka Road, Outer Circle Connaught Place, Baba Kharak Singh Marg and Pandit Pant Marg due to farmers’ mahapanchayat. The Samyukta Kisan Morcha and other farmers’ groups are organising the congregation and they will pass through outer district, which includes Ghazipur border in Ghaziabad, officials said. “In this connection, adequate deployment of local police and outside force has been made in outer district at Tikri border, major intersections, along railway tracks and metro stations to avoid any untoward incident,” a police official said. Excise Policy scam: Sisodia says CBI issues Look Out Circular against him, agency says nothing ‘as of now’ The war of attrition between the AAP and BJP intensified on Sunday with Manish Sisodia claiming that the CBI has issued a Look Out Notice against him even as Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal and the Deputy Chief Minister are all set to visit poll-bound Gujarat. Read more CBI initiates inquiry into purchase of DTC buses by Delhi govt The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has initiated a preliminary inquiry over allegations of corruption in procurement of 1,000 low-floor buses by the Delhi government. (IANS) New space telescope shows Jupiter’s auroras, tiny moons Road accidents caused by potholes killed 5,600 in 3 yrs India’s first space observatory to open in Uttarakhand Police arrest ‘Robin Hood’ thief in Delhi Cholera tragedy in Maha village highlights power debts LGBTQ Singaporeans welcome sex law repeal National Karnataka Bengaluru Sports Business Multimedia Opinion Entertainment Sisodia claims BJP asked him to join party Lathi charge on streets of Patna Why India is silent on Salman Rushdie DH photo galleries DH Picks Latest stories Trending news Download DH APP Services Our group sites Download DH APP We use cookies to understand how you use our site and to improve user experience. This includes personalising content and advertising. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, revised Privacy Policy. We use cookies.
Sure, the digital era is great and all, but there’s still a lot to be said for the sound of physical media and good ‘ol over-the-air radio. If you’re one of those people who can’t let go of your CDs and love tuning in the FM or AM band, the Bose Wave Music System IV is just what you’ve been searching for. QVC has dropped the price of this set, which includes a Bluetooth receiver, from $499 to just $330. That’s the lowest price we’ve found on the web. Trust us, this baby’s gonna fly off the shelves. Old-school meets new-school in this cult-favorite Bluetooth-enabled CD player and music system. Don’t want to pay all in one go? Opt for five installments of just $65.99instead. Plus, if you’re a first-time QVC shopper, you can grab an extra $15 off your purchase with code OFFER. The Bose Wave Music System IV — which comes in Espresso Black and Platinum Silver — delivers epic sound and comes equipped with a plug-in PAWW Bluetooth receiver, so you can wirelessly sync your smartphone or laptop to it (there’s also an auxiliary port if you want to plug in another device instead) — it’s a great marriage of old-school and tech-enabled. The design is elegant, minimal and slim, so this powerhouse can fit just about anywhere you want it, and the sound is epic. Enjoy waking up to the sound of music or the day’s headlines on the radio? You can program the system’s timer to sync up to your preferences too. There’s no shortage of amazing features in this powerful little sound system. It has a slot-loading CD player for all those beloved albums you’ve been neglecting, a headphone jack, and Waveguard speaker technology that amplifies everything beautifully, from your favorite podcasts to your workout playlists. Bose reviewers praise the longevity of this sound system and its superior sound quality. See below to learn why shoppers are obsessed with the Bose Wave Music System IV. “There is no question that the sound is fantastic,” wrote a five-star Bose reviewer. “Perfect system for the home,” wrote another shopper. “The sound is simply stunning and fills the entire room. The radio reception is superb and the ability to play Internet radio via TuneIn brings this product firmly in 2020s!” “I wanted a newer Bose, with a CD player, for another room, so the System IV was a natural choice…” shared a longtime Bose fan. “The AM/FM stereo radio and CD player perform flawlessly and the sound quality is equal to or better than a top-drawer stereo system with large bookshelf speakers I have owned before. All in an attractive, compact package.” The Bose Wave Music System IV produces “astounding sound,” added another happy customer. “Played about a dozen CDs of mine with even better results,” continued the fan. “The music just got better!” Catch this QVC sale while you can: The $169 off deal only lasts through the weekend. Old-school meets new-school in this cult-favorite Bluetooth enabled CD player and music system. The reviews quoted above reflect the most recent versions at the time of publication. Follow us on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest for nonstop inspiration delivered fresh to your feed, every day. Want daily pop culture news delivered to your inbox? Sign up here for Yahoo Entertainment & Life’s newsletter. The space agency’s release of noise from 200m light years away has been compared to everything from Pink Floyd to Björk. Here’s what a professional reviewer made of it Notable business headlines include eBay acquiring TCGplayer, Sony’s PlayStation being sued in the UK for allegedly overcharging consumers in their online store, and HBO’s Game of Thrones prequel ‘House of the Dragon’ debuting to nearly 10 million viewers. City of Durham MP Mary Foy, who hosted meeting with Keir Starmer at her office, says press also doorstepped staff’s families LONDON (Reuters) -Britain will need to continue to manage water resources carefully over the coming months following the driest summer for 50 years and should begin planning now for potential water shortfalls in 2023, the National Drought Group said on Tuesday. The group, made up of government officials, water companies, and environmental groups, said there was enough water for all essential household and business needs. Ten of the Environment Agency's 14 areas in England are now in drought status. School known as the “Socialist Eton” will join United Learning academy trust despite high-profile protest by parents The winner of the battle for the Conservative Party crown – widely expected to be Liz Truss – will be unveiled in a 12.30pm ceremony in two weeks, the party's co-chairman has announced. In a letter to Tory MPs and peers headed "Leadership Announcement: Arrangements", Andrew Stephenson urged them to apply early for tickets for the event on Monday 5 September. "I am pleased to confirm that the result will be announced at 12.30pm on Monday 5 September 2022 in a central Westminster venue, with attendees required to be seated by 12.15pm," Mr Stephenson wrote. Donald Trump has asked for a ‘special master’ to review the documents taken by FBI from his Mar-a-Lago home Rishi Sunak warned that millions of households face ‘destitution’ without further support this winter. Fire crews were deployed to battle a wildfire that broke out in the province of Sevilla, near the town of Guillena, Spain, on Tuesday, August 23, fire services said.The Forest Fire Extinction Service of Andalucia, known as INFOCA, said 35 forest firefighters and one fire engine had been deployed to tackle the blaze. INFOCA said the fire has originated in an area known as “Cucadero”.Aerial footage released by INFOCA shows smoke rising, while another clip shows firefighters battling the wildfire. Credit: INFOCA via Storyful A person on average income in the UK is already struggling to make ends meet. Anything that tips the balance against them now literally leaves them beyond their limits Former Prime Minister Najib Razak is seeking to remove Malaysia’s top judge from his final appeal in a graft case linked to the massive looting of the 1MDB state fund MI5 and MI6 have been accused of supplying information that led to the abduction and alleged torture of a British citizen who has been held in an Indian jail for almost five years. Police said they were ‘working as quickly as we can to remove the protesters from the service stations’. Singer Tom Parker has been posthumously shortlisted for a National Television Award following his death from a brain tumour at the age of 33. Parker, who died at a hospice near his home in southeast London on 30 March, is shortlisted for the authored documentary NTA alongside TV presenter Kate Garraway for her programme Caring For Derek, sharing insights into her husband Derek Draper's struggle with the long-term effects of coronavirus. Katie Price's What Harvey Did Next, Julia Bradbury's Breast Cancer And Me, and Paddy and Christine McGuinness's Our Family And Autism are also in the running for the award. Facebook users have been reporting issues with their service this morning as their homepage has not been showing regular posts. The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge have chosen a school for their children to attend once they make their move to Windsor. The Cambridges will live in Adelaide Cottage – just 10-minutes from Windsor Castle, the Queen’s main residence. Prince George, Princess Charlotte and Prince Louis will join the private Lambrook School in Berkshire from September. . A run of three games in as few as nine days has angered the rugby league players’ union, with its head, Garreth Carvell, highlighting that clubs are struggling to put out full squads Twenty minutes of stimulation on four consecutive days can improve two different types of memory in those aged 65 and older, researchers found. Jared Kushner dodges questions on Mar-a-Lago raid in Fox interview.mp4 The trio had been due to stand trial at the city’s crown court.
Oscar Höglund, CEO and Co-founder of Epidemic Sound “I envision someday getting an ice cream with my granddaughter. And she says, ‘So your generation basically invented the Internet. What was your contribution?” –Oscar Höglund, Epidemic Sound Co-founder The moment you walk into the Epidemic Sounds studio, you know it’s a special place. Like a music studio, it hums with creativity; but there’s something unique about it. Maybe it’s the feeling of a large group of creatives working together. Maybe it’s just the attitude that pervades the place, clearly displayed in lights that spell out, “Bad music kills good video.” It’s an apt way to sum up the role of Epidemic Sound, an innovative Swedish-based music platform driven by one exciting vision: to soundtrack the Internet. It is this vision which has made Epidemic Sound a tech unicorn and one of the original trailblazers of the passion economy. Epidemic Sound serves as a marketplace connecting stories with the music that can bring them to life. According to co-founder Oscar Höglund, driving their work is the belief that “music and stories are tied together in exactly the same way as flavor is tied to food”. Music is the language of emotions. It brings up memories and moments in our lives as nothing else can. And it’s precisely this power that Epidemic Sound harnesses for the use of content creators. Oscar continues to explain that Epidemic Sound exists in that sweet spot where the passion of creativity and the pragmatism of business intersect. This is the intersection in which musicians and other creatives can earn a living by doing what they love. Epidemic Sound solves the two major problems of the music industry: the logistical difficulty of adding music to stories, and the obstacles that musicians face in securing their fair share of royalties. These problems date back to the year 2008 when Epidemic Sound was in its infancy, linear television was the main channel for creators, and an Internet suite had to be plugged into your computer. The platform has disrupted the industry by purchasing the rights for music content, and then sharing it with a huge pool of distributors, content creators, and potential fans. Musicians are then allocated a share of the payout. Creators on Epicdemic Sound supply their tracks to a catalogue on the marketplace In contrast to the historic infrastructure of the music industry, Epidemic Sound has the ability to acquire a huge catalog of music to share with end users. They can also connect musicians with billions of storytellers. The compensation for musicians is obviously another important aspect of this industry disruption. A subset of music gets picked up by fans, and Epidemic Sound splits the royalties evenly 50/50 with music creators. They pay an upfront fee of USD 1,200-6,000 per track when acquiring the rights to a track, and their creators earn over $50,000 on average per year with top earners making more than $200,000 annually. Additionally, there is a bonus pool that is distributed proportionally among creators based on the popularity among users. In 2022, the bonus is set at $2 million but will grow as the business grows. This model is unique in an industry which traditionally split royalties in a multitude of directions, awarding a share of the profit to every individual who participated in the music’s creation and production. Leaving music creators with only a small fragment of royalties for themselves. But with this new model, all that is changing. Gustaf Lundberg Toresson: I guess you could say that Epidemic Sound has been around since the Dark Ages of the Passion Economy, the very beginning. But even before that, how did you get started? Oscar Höglund: Well, I often joke that I’m probably the least musical person at the office. You could say that I play the guitar in self-defense. I think that’s important, because we all have different skill sets. We’re good at different things. You need to be good at the trade before you dive in; it’s almost a prerequisite. One thing I learned by working as a management consultant is that it’s incredibly powerful to have a pool of different people with different skills and backgrounds. If you bring something unique to the table, it really makes you feel good, it gives your brain a shot of endorphins. My work with an American management firm was pivotal, because I got a look at the level of ambition out there. I learned what the world expects in order to succeed on a global scale. But I also saw the challenges. We were all pretty much the same. I saw the value of a culture of ferocious learning which was important. But I was looking for progress and evolution, and consultancy seemed like more of the same. I took a lot of the learning with me, and did some soul-searching. I met with tons of people in different industries, and eventually ran into a punk rocker from the north of Sweden. We were quite different. He was running a TV production company, so I joined him. I took a huge salary cut, but I stumbled upon something I really loved: the passion economy. I was the only person in the room who was good with numbers, while everyone around me was ten times more creative than I was. I stumbled onto the world of storytelling, and just fell in love with it. We did a lot of shows which were incredibly popular, and suddenly I was working in a context that mattered, stitching together stories. All of these experiences helped me along the way. Lundberg Toresson: After helping the punk rocker, what did you do next? Höglund: In the early days, there was a term that people used back then: “multimedia.” So when people asked me what I did, I would say, “I’m responsible for multimedia.” And that pretty much meant everything that wasn’t linear TV media. It really didn’t exist back then, and it was my role to kind of figure out the future of storytelling. That started out small, but I immediately fell in love with it. There’s something alluring about it. At the heart of the passion economy is the understanding of financial structures, which mixes with the other side of the equation: cultural ambiguity and success, the idea of fandom. All bets are off; things go viral and then everything changes. Everything inverts. That was very appealing to me. When we started Epidemic Sound, back in 2008, the Internet was very text-centric. And we stumbled upon problems that needed to be solved. There were five co-founders, all from different backgrounds, but we all gravitated to storytelling. We knew the importance of adding music to content, but the whole system was broken. It was horrendous. The historic infrastructure just wasn’t working. We’ve solved this problem by taking an opposing view to the current system, putting together a catalog that works for end users. An Epidemic Sound music studio Lundberg Toresson: Let’s say I was a passionate music creator with a guitar or turntables, but without the connections and not being well-known. Would I have been able to live on that income in 2009? Höglund: The short answer is no. In 2008 or 2009, the industry wasn’t set up to support a large base of music creators. The world was more binary back then. Your song was a hit or it wasn’t. There were also massive shifts taking place, like the rise of streaming services, playlists becoming more important, and the demise of physical albums. Around this time, you had many music creators who weren’t being paid upfront, were being promised royalties, and albums were less relevant. This situation was difficult to navigate. When we entered the scene, no one was paying upfront. Music creators often didn’t have colleagues and worked in isolation. That’s something we set out to address. The way we did it was wildly provocative at the time because of the understanding back that creators should hold on to their rights for dear life. To many creators, your rights represented a precursor for the success you wanted. We analyzed that and came up with different logic. We think music creators have two fundamental desires. One, you want to spread your music to as many people as possible. You want to create things so people enjoy them, and distribution is important to that goal. Second, you want to be able to support yourself. If your songs achieve commercial success, you should be rewarded. “It’s a game changer with the freedom and being able to live on my passion” – Dajana, musician and … [+] one of the creators on the Epidemic Sound platform Lundberg Toresson: Many people probably haven’t heard of ES. But let’s say that if you’re a Youtuber, you might use Epidemic Sound in every video? Höglund: Yes. We soundtrack over 1.5 billion streams daily on Youtube. Lundberg Toresson: On top of that you add other medias, e.g. Tiktok? Höglund: Tiktok, Facebook, television broadcasts, physical locations etc. We’re very serious about trying to soundtrack the entire world. The first job is to soundtrack the Internet, because that’s the “unlock.” That’s the big problem to solve, because building a cultural infrastructure and reimagining the business model for storytellers and creators. Getting all of that right is important. We can’t rely on historic cultural infrastructure because it was built for a different time. The Internet offers a more decentralized way to interact and distribute content, so we’ve had to re-engineer everything. We’re twelve years in! We’re an overnight success that has taken a decade to build. Lundberg Toresson: I’ve heard it said that if you want to work in music tech, move to Stockholm. It’s been compared to the Silicon Valley of the music tech industry. What is your personal feeling about that? Höglund: I think it’s accurate. We have a lot of music history in Sweden; it’s as if we have superpowers in a few specific areas. There’s a huge sense of camaraderie there, and a sense that people want to pay it forward. You can share knowledge online, get help, get recommendations. The companies that succeed quickly become very large, and they want to help others. I’ve been helped many times simply by calling people who have done this ahead of me. We all hire from and recommend to one another. Being a Swede definitely opens doors. All the data points and signals point to the fact that if you’re a Swede, you will do well. The Epidemic Sound platform Lundberg Toresson: So if I’m a creator, how much money can I make? Höglund: Once you get to scale, something incredible happens. For example, if you soundtrack 70% of YouTubers, in addition to Facebook, TikTok, and other platforms, you leave a huge footprint. It spreads, and we can see the download metrics. If you’re a creator, you’d send us a few samples. Of course, we do get tens of thousands of tracks, and the tolerance for variance with music is very low. With photos, all you have to do is swipe right or swipe left, but music has to be much more precise. If you’re talented, we give you a commission up front to write a track. Then a subset of viewers will find it and say, “That’s amazing.” So you get multiple revenue streams, and potentially could make thousands, tens of thousands, or hundreds of thousands. Lundberg Toresson: In 2021, you raised $450 million at a $1.4 billion valuation and reached unicorn status. What are you going to use that money for? Höglund: To sum it up in one word – friction. We’re dedicated to soundtracking the entire world, and starting off with the Internet gives us a very clear target. There’s a lot of friction involved: technical friction, commercial friction, payment friction, language friction, and cultural friction. We’ve done an excellent job of tracking the Western hemisphere. But now it’s about reducing friction across all these disciplines. We’ll have to use our entire toolbox to get there. There are new product questions, content questions, distribution questions, leverage questions, etc. We raised a lot of money, but we’ve forged relationships we trust with people who know the space, positioned to help us, challenge our thinking, and support us as necessary. The money will help us scale and address these friction questions, but our partners also help us see the bigger picture. Lundberg Toresson: So what’s next? Höglund: Our vision is to soundtrack the Internet, and it’s huge. Right now, we’re only serving about one-third of the world’s population. Everything has been launched in English, but only one-third of the world’s population speaks English. We just launched in Spain, and we’re upping our roster every quarter. We know we have to keep doing what got us here, but we also have to do more. We’re driving the passion economy, and that’s the canvas of a really interesting ecosystem. The conversation has been edited and condensed for clarity. For updates and more stories, visit @gltore
by NPR’s Washington Desk Rep. Jerry Nadler speaks at a candidate forum for New York’s 12th Congressional District on Aug. 10. Frank Franklin II/AP hide caption Rep. Jerry Nadler speaks at a candidate forum for New York’s 12th Congressional District on Aug. 10. In a battle of Manhattan, Rep. Jerry Nadler has beaten fellow Democratic Rep. Carolyn Maloney in a closely watched primary, according to a race call by The Associated Press. The two incumbents, who both chair powerful committees for the House Democratic caucus, were placed in the same district after redistricting. (Nadler has represented the Upper West Side for years, with Maloney representing the Upper East Side.) Nadler and Maloney were both first elected in 1992, and have largely voted the same over the years, with some key exceptions. Maloney had outraised her opponents, but Nadler received some key endorsements, including from Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. Another candidate, Suraj Patel, a former Obama aide, finished third. Nadler is expected to take the House seat, since the district leans so heavily Democratic. His opponent in November is Republican Michael Zumbluskas. by Elena Moore Maxwell Frost speaks during a March For Our Lives Florida drive-in rally and aid event at Tinker Field in Orlando on March 26, 2021. Orlando Sentinel/TNS hide caption Maxwell Frost speaks during a March For Our Lives Florida drive-in rally and aid event at Tinker Field in Orlando on March 26, 2021. Progressive activist Maxwell Frost, one of the first members of Generation Z to run for Congress, has won his Democratic primary, according to a race call by The Associated Press. Frost’s win nearly secures his path to Congress since the Orlando-based seat is considered a solidly Democratic district. Frost will face off against Republican Calvin Wimbish in November. “Today’s election is proof that Central Florida’s working families want representation that has the courage to ask for more,” Frost said in a statement. “I share this victory with the nurses, forklift drivers, teachers, caregivers, social workers, farmers, union organizers, cashiers, and other members of this vibrant community who supported this campaign.” At 25 years old, Frost just qualifies for the age requirement to serve in the U.S. House. The 2022 midterms mark the first election where members of Generation Z can run for congressional office. The Pew Research Center considers anyone born between 1997 and 2012 to be Gen Z. Frost campaigned on key progressive issues, including Medicare for All, a Green New Deal, student debt cancelation and an end to gun violence. He first became involved in political organizing in 2012 while in high school following the mass shooting in Newtown, Conn. He’s also spoken publicly about surviving a separate incident of gun violence. “Our generation has been born into a lot of trauma and a lot of civil unrest around people being frustrated with things. And I think because of that, our generation naturally thinks about things in a bit of a different way,” Frost told NPR. The former March for Our Lives national organizing director and ACLU activist beat out a crowded field of nine other competitors, including state Sen. Randolph Bracy and former Florida Reps. Corrine Brown and Alan Grayson. Frost also topped his competitors in fundraising while racking up key national endorsements from progressive leaders, including Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders and Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren. In an interview with NPR, Frost acknowledged that age plays a symbolic role in his campaign. “Yes we march, yes we engage in mutual aid, yes we engage on social media, and now we’re running for office because we believe that we are prepared to be in the rooms and to be the voice for our communities and we can do that and young people should be allowed,” he said. by Lynn Hatter Charlie Crist speaks to a crowd in St. Petersburg, Fla. after winning the Democratic nomination for governor in Florida on Tuesday, Aug. 23, 2022. Crist, a member of congress, will face Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis in November. Daylina Miller/WUSF hide caption Charlie Crist speaks to a crowd in St. Petersburg, Fla. after winning the Democratic nomination for governor in Florida on Tuesday, Aug. 23, 2022. Crist, a member of congress, will face Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis in November. TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Democrat and longtime politician Charlie Crist has won the primary for governor in Florida and will face Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis in November, according to a race call by The Associated Press. Crist served as Florida’s Republican governor more than a decade ago and is now a Democrat in the U.S. House of Representatives. The primary for governor has highlighted a split within the Democratic Party in the state. Crist’s challenger, Florida Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried, hammered him over his record as governor and for switching his stance on issues like abortion and criminal justice. As Crist claimed victory Tuesday night, he thanked Fried for a spirited campaign, but it was clear his sights were firmly set on DeSantis: “The stakes could not be any higher for this election. Our fundamental freedoms are literally on the ballot, my friends. A woman’s right to choose – on the ballot. Democracy – on the ballot. Your rights as minorities are on this ballot.” He called DeSantis a “bully” and “dangerous” and made sure to solidify his stance as a candidate who supports abortion rights. “On day one of my administration, I will sign an executive order protecting a women’s right to choose.” Crist outraised Fried and has run as a moderate by casting himself as the person most likely to beat DeSantis in November. He has tried to court unaffiliated voters and disaffected Republicans and has earned endorsements from top Democratic-leaning groups like the state’s teachers’ union. When it comes to winning elections, Crist has a mixed record. He left the Republican party in 2010 to run as an independent against Marco Rubio for the U.S. Senate. He made another run for governor as a Democrat in 2014 but lost by about a percentage point to Republican Rick Scott — now a U.S. senator. Now that the dust has settled on the Democratic primary, Crist will face DeSantis in November. The powerful governor is rumored to be considering a presidential run in 2024. He’s raised his national profile and has more than $100 million in the bank. DeSantis has become known for his battles over education, including how teachers talk to students about race, history and LGBTQ people. He’s pushed new laws that restrict how conversations around those subjects take place in public school classrooms and even businesses. If he’s to win in November, Crist will have to sway some of the nearly 4 million unaffiliated Florida voters. Registered Republicans now outnumber registered Democrats in the state, but statewide races have often been close. DeSantis, himself, won by about a single percentage point in 2018. WUSF’s Steve Newborn contributed to this story. Oklahoma holds runoff elections Tuesday following June primaries, led by the contest to replace retiring Republican Sen. Jim Inhofe. See results for other states holding elections on Tuesday: Florida and New York. by Elena Moore Florida state Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried and Rep. Charlie Crist lead the Democratic primary to try to defeat Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis. Joe Raedle/Getty Images; Octavio Jones/Getty Images hide caption Florida state Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried and Rep. Charlie Crist lead the Democratic primary to try to defeat Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis. The final primary day of August has some key election contests in Florida, New York and Oklahoma. Florida and New York had their congressional maps scrambled by redistricting, boosting the number of notable races Tuesday. But the biggest matchup in Florida is at the top of the ticket, where Democrats will pick a nominee to try to defeat Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis, a potential presidential contender in 2024. (Rep. Val Demings will also aim to lock up the Democratic nomination to take on GOP Sen. Marco Rubio.) In New York, voters are finally casting ballots in congressional races, months after the state’s top court scrapped the legislature’s map, ruling it unfairly benefited Democrats. The newly drawn map led to intraparty battles, mostly within solidly blue districts, as incumbent House members had to run in new districts, compete against colleagues or face a handful of challengers. New York also has two special congressional elections. And in the Republican stronghold of Oklahoma, runoff primary elections take place to fill a U.S. Senate term, and in the state’s 2nd District. Florida’s Democratic gubernatorial primary will likely come down to who voters believe has the best chance of defeating DeSantis in November. Rep. Charlie Crist is running against state Agriculture Commissioner Nikki Fried, the only statewide elected Democrat. Crist lost his last gubernatorial bid in 2014. But he was elected to serve as governor in 2006 as a Republican. Many state Democratic lawmakers, including some of the party’s more progressive members, have expressed support for Crist. He also has endorsements from the Sierra Club and several labor unions, including the statewide teachers union. Fried has received endorsements from a handful of Democratic state representatives and the Florida College Democrats. Crist has also raised more money than Fried. Most polls have shown Crist leading Fried — and DeSantis leading both in hypothetical matchups. – FL-07: Eight Republicans are campaigning for a chance to fill outgoing Democratic Rep. Stephanie Murphy’s seat, which contains parts of the Orlando suburbs and now skews Republican following redistricting. Leading among the GOP candidates are state Rep. Anthony Sabatini and controversial businessman Cory Mills — both of whom promote Donald Trump’s lie that the 2020 election was stolen. – FL-10: Progressive activist Maxwell Alejandro Frost leads among a slew of Democrats in fundraising and national endorsements in the race to fill the solidly Democratic, Orlando-based seat left open by Demings’ run for Senate. If elected, Frost, 25, would be the first member of Generation Z to serve in Congress. The Democratic field also includes state Sen. Randolph Bracy and former Rep. Alan Grayson. – FL-13: Florida’s latest round of redistricting has also turned Crist’s once-toss-up Democratic district, containing Clearwater and parts of St. Petersburg, into a competitive Republican playing field. Leading among Republican candidates is Air Force veteran Anna Paulina Luna, who’s been endorsed by Trump. The winner of the GOP primary will go on to face former Obama official Eric Lynn in November. Rep. Carolyn Maloney greets a voter while campaigning on the Upper East Side neighborhood of Manhattan on Aug. 16. Maloney is running against attorney Suraj Patel and Rep. Jerry Nadler in New York’s 12th District Democratic primary. Mary Altaffer/AP hide caption Redistricting has forced two high-ranking Democrats into a bitter fight over a single, Manhattan-based seat. Carolyn Maloney and Jerrold Nadler are both from New York City and were both first elected in 1992. They have largely voted the same, with a handful of key exceptions. Now, Maloney is making a pitch based on her work on women’s rights — arguing that she is the best candidate to fight for reproductive health care in a post-Roe world. Nadler highlights his votes opposing the Iraq War and the Patriot Act, as well as his leading role in the Trump impeachment hearings. They’re challenged by a third candidate, Suraj Patel, a former Obama aide who came within 4 percentage points of beating Maloney in 2020. Maloney has outraised her opponents, but Nadler has received some key endorsements, including from Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. Tuesday’s winner is expected to take the House seat, since the district leans so heavily Democratic. But no matter the outcome, Democrats will lose at least one of their senior leaders in Congress. As Nadler takes on Maloney, a newly redrawn 10th District is open for the first time in nearly a decade. Daniel Goldman, the former legal counsel to House Democrats who spearheaded Trump’s impeachment in 2019, is a leading candidate in the race, as are U.S. Rep. Mondaire Jones and state Assemblywoman Yuh-Line Niou. Assemblywoman Yuh-Line Niou, left, and Rep. Mondaire Jones stand together during an Aug. 15 news conference to speak out against Dan Goldman’s candidacy in the Democratic primary for New York’s 10th District. Mary Altaffer/AP hide caption Out of a crowded field of about a dozen candidates, Goldman leads in recent polling, followed by Niou, Jones and Councilwoman Carlina Rivera — all three of whom are self-described progressives. Goldman, a descendant of the family that owns Levi Strauss & Co., has been criticized for largely self-financing his campaign and vastly outspending his opponents. Jones — a freshman congressman currently representing District 17, located in the suburbs outside New York City — has been endorsed by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and the Congressional Progressive Caucus. But other progressive figures, such as fellow New York Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, have stayed out of the fray. – NY-19: In New York’s Hudson Valley, two county executives, Democrat Pat Ryan and Republican Marc Molinaro, are locked in a close race to serve out the remaining four months of former Rep. Antonio Delgado’s term. The Democrat Delgado resigned in May to serve as lieutenant governor. The district is considered a toss-up by the Cook Political Report, and Ryan and Molinaro are ideologically divided along party lines, notably splitting on the issue of abortion, making the race a key contest to watch as November inches closer. (A twist: Molinaro is running for a full term in the 19th District under the new congressional map, while Ryan is also running for a full term, but in the 18th District.) – NY-23: Republican Joe Sempolinski will face off against Democrat Max Della Pia for the remaining months of former Rep. Tom Reed’s term. But Sempoliski, a former aide to Reed, is not running in the primary for a full term, despite the district being solidly Republican and the term only lasting until January. Instead, Della Pia, who is running in the primary unopposed, will go up against either state GOP Chair Nick Langworthy or controversial businessman Carl Paladino. Despite a first-place finish in June, Oklahoma U.S. Rep. Markwayne Mullin failed to get over 50% of the Senate GOP primary vote, forcing a runoff against former state House Speaker T.W. Shannon. Alex Brandon/AP hide caption In Oklahoma, voters are one step closer to knowing who will finish the term of retiring Republican Sen. Jim Inhofe. And in a deep red state like Oklahoma, winning the GOP contest effectively seals the deal. Despite a first-place finish back in June, Rep. Markwayne Mullin failed to get over 50% of the primary vote, forcing a runoff against former state House Speaker T.W. Shannon. Mullin has the endorsement of Trump and has out-fundraised Shannon. The winner of the runoff will face Democrat Kendra Horn in November. Both Mullin and Shannon have the potential to become the first Indigenous person to serve in the Senate since 2005. The contest to succeed Mullin in the 2nd Congressional District, which encompasses the eastern portion of the state, is also in a runoff on the GOP side. Both former state Sen. Josh Brecheen and state Rep. Avery Frix tout their support for Trump — though the former president has not issued an endorsement. Frix marginally leads against Brecheen, according to recent polling, but 42% of Republican respondents polled remain undecided. The winner goes against Democrat Naomi Andrews. With reporting from WFSU’s Valerie Crowder in Florida and Zach Hirsch in New York. In Florida, Democrats have picked their nominees to take on Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis and GOP Sen. Marco Rubio. Several congressional seats are also open. See results for other states holding elections on Tuesday: New York and Oklahoma. After a redistricting scramble, New York on Tuesday holds primary elections for U.S. House seats, including a battle of longtime Democrats in the 12th District, in New York City. There’s also a notable special election in the 19th District. See results for other states holding elections on Tuesday: Florida and Oklahoma. by The Associated Press U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, an Alaska Republican, flashes a thumbs up to a passing motorist while waving signs Tuesday in Anchorage. Mark Thiessen/AP hide caption U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, an Alaska Republican, flashes a thumbs up to a passing motorist while waving signs Tuesday in Anchorage. JUNEAU, Alaska — Alaska Republican U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski advanced from her primary along with Kelly Tshibaka, her GOP rival endorsed by former President Donald Trump, while another Trump-backed candidate, Republican Sarah Palin, was among the candidates bound for the November general election in the race for Alaska’s only House seat. Murkowski had expressed confidence that she would advance and earlier in the day told reporters that “what matters is winning in November.” Tshibaka called the results “the first step in breaking the Murkowski monarchy’s grip on Alaska.” Tshibaka also said she was thankful “for the strong and unwavering support President Trump has shown Alaska.” A Murkowski has held the Senate seat since 1981. Before Lisa Murkowski, who has been in the Senate since late 2002, it was her father, Frank Murkowski. Under a voter-approved elections process being used for the first time in Alaska elections this year, party primaries have been scrapped and ranked choice voting is being used in general elections. The top four vote-getters in a primary race, regardless of party affiliation, are to advance to the general election. The other two places in the Senate race were too early to call. Murkowski voted to convict Trump in his second impeachment trial after the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection. Trump was acquitted. But he has had strong words for Murkowski, calling her “the worst” during a rally last month in Anchorage. Murkowski said that if Tshibaka derives her sole strength from Trump’s endorsement, “what does that really say about her as a candidate with what she has to offer Alaska? Is it just that she will be a rubber stamp for Donald Trump? I don’t think that all Alaskans are really seeking that. Not the ones that I’m talking to.” Kevin Durling, a co-chair of Tshibaka’s campaign, said Trump’s endorsement of Tshibaka was an added bonus for him. He said Tshibaka’s commitment to business and family and her values were important to him. He expressed frustration with Murkowski for the impeachment vote and for her support of the nomination of Interior Secretary Deb Haaland. In the House primary, Democrat Mary Peltola, Palin and Republican Nick Begich advanced to the November election. It was too early to call the fourth spot. The winner of the November race will be elected to a two-year term. Peltola, Begich and Palin were also competing in a special election to serve the remainder of the late-Rep. Don Young ‘s term, which ends early next year. Young died in March. The special election was voters’ first shot at ranked voting in a statewide race. The winner of the special election may not be known until at least Aug. 31. If successful, Peltola would be the first Alaska Native woman elected to the House. There also were several write-in candidates in the special election, including Republican Tara Sweeney, who was also competing in the House primary. Sweeney was an assistant secretary for Indian Affairs in the U.S. Interior Department during the Trump administration. The special election was on one side of the ballot; the other side contained primary races for U.S. Senate, U.S. House, governor and lieutenant governor and legislative seats. Palin, in a statement Tuesday evening, called this “the first test case of the crazy, convoluted, undesirable ranked-choice voting system.” Sarah Palin, a Republican seeking the sole U.S. House seat in Alaska, speaks during a forum on May 12 in Anchorage. Mark Thiessen/AP hide caption Sarah Palin, a Republican seeking the sole U.S. House seat in Alaska, speaks during a forum on May 12 in Anchorage. Supporters of ranked voting have said it encourages positive campaigning but the House race has at times taken on harsh tones. Begich, a businessman from a family of prominent Democrats, has come out hard against Palin, seeking to cast her as someone chasing fame and as a quitter; Palin resigned during her term as governor in 2009. In one Begich ad, the narrator says Alaska has faced “years of disasters,” including fires and COVID-19. “Sarah Palin is one disaster we can actually avoid,” the narrator says. A narrator in one of Palin’s ads refers to Begich as “negative Nick” and says Palin wants to serve in Congress “to carry Don Young’s torch.” Peltola, a former lawmaker who most recently worked at a commission whose goal is to rebuild salmon resources on the Kuskokwim River, has cast herself as a consensus builder. She said one thing that would help her be a good representative is that she is “not a millionaire. I am just like every other regular Alaskan, and I understand the economic struggles that Alaskans face first-hand. My priorities are the priorities of everyday Alaskans.” In a statement early Wednesday, she said while the results of the special election won’t be known for some time, “we are moving forward into the general election. We are going to build on this momentum and build a coalition of Alaskans that can win in November.” In the race for Alaska governor, Republican Gov. Mike Dunleavy advanced, as did former Gov. Bill Walker, an independent, and Democrat Les Gara. It was too early to call the fourth spot. Dunleavy and his running mate, Nancy Dahlstrom, in a statement said this “is only the start of the race. We’ll dig into all the numbers as they come in over the next few days to find out where we need to shore up our campaign, and we’re looking forward to reaching every Alaskan and earning their vote between now and November.” Walker is running with Heidi Drygas and Gara with Jessica Cook. by Ayana Archie Republican House candidate Harriet Hageman speaks to supporters on Tuesday in Cheyenne, Wyo., after defeating Rep. Liz Cheney in the Republican primary. Mead Gruver/AP hide caption Incumbent Wyoming Republican U.S. Rep. Liz Cheney was defeated Tuesday after she broke from her party to criticize former President Donald Trump following the Jan. 6 insurrection. She lost the race for Wyoming’s at-large congressional district to Harriet Hageman, an attorney who supported Cheney in her race for the House in 2016. While there is not extensive official information on Hageman, this is what we know: Hageman, a Wyoming native, received both her undergraduate degree and law degree from the University of Wyoming. She began her career as a law clerk for federal appeals Judge James Barrett, and went on to practice law privately in Wyoming, Colorado and Nebraska, according to Iowa State University. Her specialty as an attorney was natural resources and water litigation. She also represented the federal government in many private property cases and eventually opened her own firm, according to Wyoming Public Media. Hageman, whose father Jim Hageman was a Wyoming state representative for more than 20 years, first joined the political sphere when she unsuccessfully ran for governor in 2018. Hageman said in a statement that she decided to run against Cheney in the House because Cheney “betrayed Wyoming, betrayed the country and she betrayed me.” Cheney was ostracized by senior members of the Republican Party for voting to impeach Trump and later criticizing him for his handling of the Jan. 6 Capitol riot. Roughly 70% of Wyoming voted for Trump and Cheney’s repudiation of him became the red line for so many GOP voters who enthusiastically backed her not long ago. Trump eventually officially endorsed Hageman, a former Republican National Committee member for the state of Wyoming. by Deirdre Walsh Rep. Liz Cheney, R-Wyo., appears at an Election Day gathering in Jackson, Wyo., to concede defeat in a GOP primary to Harriet Hageman, who was backed by former President Trump. Cheney vows that she will carry on her work to make sure Trump doesn’t return to the presidency. Jae C. Hong/AP hide caption Rep. Liz Cheney, R-Wyo., appears at an Election Day gathering in Jackson, Wyo., to concede defeat in a GOP primary to Harriet Hageman, who was backed by former President Trump. Cheney vows that she will carry on her work to make sure Trump doesn’t return to the presidency. Wyoming Republican Rep. Liz Cheney is laying out her future political plans, including a possible run against Donald Trump in 2024, after conceding defeat in the primary election for her House seat. Her loss on Tuesday followed unyielding criticism since the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol of the former president and his efforts to subvert the 2020 election. “This primary election is over, but now the real work begins,” Cheney said in her concession speech Tuesday night, noting that she had called opponent Harriet Hageman to congratulate her. Cheney acknowledged in a Wednesday interview on NBC’s Today she was “thinking” about running for president in 2024. For her 2022 House race, Cheney raised $14 million, a record for any primary in Wyoming’s history, and she spent about half of it. The vast majority of donations came from out of state, and she has built up a network she could tap into in the future. Cheney plans to transform her campaign operation into a political action committee called The Great Task, according to a filing with the Federal Election Commission. “In coming weeks, Liz will be launching an organization to educate the American people about the ongoing threat to our Republic, and to mobilize a unified effort to oppose any Donald Trump campaign for president,” said Cheney spokesman Jeremy Adler, as first reported by Politico. In the interview on Wednesday, she called Trump a “grave threat” and said, “I think that defeating him is going to require a broad and united front of Democrats, Republicans and independents, and that’s what I intend to be part of.” Cheney didn’t say whether she would run as a Republican or an independent, but said the GOP is “in very bad shape” and said it “could take several election cycles” to return it to its principles. But she said it was important for the country that the Republican Party return to its roots, instead of being focused on Trump. It was an expected outcome for Cheney, who went from party star and heir to a conservative dynasty to a political outcast — marked by the moment she chose to break with the former president following his role in fomenting a mob to attack the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6. Cheney addressed supporters on Tuesday night in Jackson Hole, near her home, repeating her vow to do whatever she can to stop Trump from returning to the White House and warning against candidates for other offices willing to ignore the will of voters. “Our nation is barreling once again toward crisis, lawlessness and violence,” Cheney said. “No American should support election deniers for any position of genuine responsibility.” Hageman argued that Cheney was out of step with the state. “By our vote today, Wyoming has put the elites on notice: We are no longer going to tolerate representatives who don’t represent us,” Hageman said in her victory speech. Hageman, an attorney endorsed by Trump who once was a Cheney supporter, took a vast lead over the incumbent. In a state that gave Donald Trump his biggest victory in 2020, Hageman is on a glide path to win the seat outright against Democratic opponent Lynnette GreyBull in November. When Liz Cheney chose to run for reelection to her House seat in 2020 instead of making a bid for an open Senate seat, some Republicans speculated she was charting a path to become the first female Republican speaker of the House. Cheney’s allies assert she could have easily won reelection if she had done what the vast majority of her GOP colleagues in Congress have done — stood in lock step with Trump. Instead, Cheney made the race entirely about her decision to stand up to the former president. Roughly 70% of Wyoming voted for Trump and Cheney’s repudiation of him became the red line for so many GOP voters who enthusiastically backed her not long ago. Her final campaign ad zeroed in on her argument that Trump’s lie about the 2020 election being stolen is “insidious” and damaging to democracy. Mary Martin, chair of the Teton County Republican Party in Wyoming, supported Cheney in the past, but says Cheney’s interaction with voters changed following her sharp break with the former president. “I have heard personally from folks who were really staunch supporters of Liz Cheney, and contributed lots of money to her in the past, that she’s insulted them,” Martin said, adding that her rhetoric labeling her constituents, “Just her personal approach to this has alienated and turned people off. She is not the only person in Wyoming that supports the Constitution.” Republican strategist Alice Stewart says Trump’s influence was the ultimate factor in this race. “Without a doubt, again, when we’re talking about a primary, the base is king, and right now, the base of the Republican Party supports Donald Trump,” she said. Martin says the race became personal for many: “In Wyoming, trust and loyalty are very high traits. And she has betrayed trust and she’s betrayed loyalty. And she has taken a stance that is perceived by some to be arrogant and not acceptable. And that I mean, it comes down to just, in my opinion, January 6th.” Hageman proudly touted Trump’s support. He traveled to Casper in May hold a rally for her and labelled Cheney a “RINO” — Republican In Name Only. While Hageman criss-crossed the state, Cheney held mostly small private campaign events and her aides say security concerns forced a more limited public schedule. Cheney has had a U.S. Capitol Police detail for more than a year due to a steady stream of threats. Cheney was one of just 10 House Republicans who voted to impeach Trump after the attack on the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. With her loss, only two in that group — David Valadao of California and Dan Newhouse of Washington State — will remain on the ballot in November. Three others lost primaries and four chose to retire. Cheney’s public statements hinted for some time she’s focused on the long game. In June, she delivered a blunt broadside at fellow House GOP members still loyal to Trump at the primetime kick off of the public hearings of the House panel probing Jan, 6. “Tonight, I say this to my Republican colleagues who are defending the indefensible: There will come a day when Donald Trump is gone, but your dishonor will remain,” Cheney said. The panel is still interviewing witnesses and planning more public hearings this fall. It plans to release a report by the end of the year, and Cheney’s position as vice chair gives her a national platform for several more months. Even before the primary vote, Cheney was showing some signs of positioning for a possible 2024 presidential campaign. It’s unclear if she would remain a Republican, or consider an independent bid. In June, she traveled to the Ronald Reagan Library — a stop for GOP presidential hopefuls — and made a speech many viewed as the blueprint for a national campaign. It was a mix of her regular denunciations of Trump, mixed with her political biography. It outlined conservative principles similar to those espoused by her father, former Vice President Dick Cheney: limited government, lower taxes and a strong national defense. Cheney also made gender a part of her critique about the current leaders in power. She emphasized that many of the key witnesses in the Jan. 6 probe were young women like Cassidy Hutchinson, a former aide to White House chief of staff Mark Meadows, whose dramatic testimony marked a major moment in the investigation. She told the audience at the library, “These days, for the most part, men are running the world, and it is really not going all that well.” Stewart believes, even after she no longer has a seat in Congress, there is a place for Cheney in the GOP. She thinks she could be part of an effort to expand the message beyond the Trump base. “If she continues to get out there and engage in GOP circles and functions, and continue to remind people about her voting record as a Republican, and about her support for freedom and policies that unite the Republican Party as opposed to grievances that divide us, there’s a path for her to stay very relevant in the Republican Party,” Stewart said. Martin agreed that Cheney’s Wyoming primary, and her role in the party going forward, would be one that people would talk about for a while: “I know that she’s going to go down in history, but I think we are going to have to wait a while to see what the story is of what is said about Liz Cheney in history.” by Domenico Montanaro Republican Rep. Liz Cheney of Wyoming speaks at a hearing held by the House Jan. 6 committee. Cheney, who serves as vice chair of the committee, is facing a likely defeat in Tuesday’s GOP primary in Wyoming. Saul Loeb/AFP via Getty Images hide caption Republican Rep. Liz Cheney of Wyoming speaks at a hearing held by the House Jan. 6 committee. Cheney, who serves as vice chair of the committee, is facing a likely defeat in Tuesday’s GOP primary in Wyoming. Liz Cheney has cut a national profile, crossing former President Donald Trump because of his conduct on Jan. 6. The Wyoming Republican is one of two Republicans on the House Jan. 6 committee, of which she is the vice chair — and her voice has been one of the clearest laying blame for the insurrection on Trump. But on Tuesday, Cheney faces voters back home in Wyoming who will determine her fate and whether they want to send her back to Congress. And she looks to be in significant trouble. Cheney’s broadsides against Trump put her job in serious jeopardy, having drawn his ire and prompting him to endorse primary challenger Harriet Hageman. Polls show Cheney down by 20 points or more as her approval among Republicans in the state has nosedived. In an effort to adjust for that, Cheney has been trying to appeal to Democrats, encouraging them to cross over and vote for her, even invoking the late Democratic President John F. Kennedy in a fundraising email. That seems like a good idea on its face, but it’s likely ill-fated. There simply aren’t enough Democrats in Wyoming, the state that voted by a wider margin for Trump in the 2020 presidential election than any other state in the country. It’s been odd to see Cheney, the daughter of former Vice President Dick Cheney, lauded as something of a folk hero among Democrats. The numbers bear that out: In the latest NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll, Cheney had a 60% favorability rating with Democrats. But among Republicans, her favorability sank to just 13%. Looking at other surveys, it’s a similar story. A Quinnipiac poll, for example, showed her approval with Republicans at 17%. In Wyoming, a survey found Cheney’s disapproval in Wyoming at 72%. That’s bad news for a candidate trying to win a competitive primary. Let’s look at the numbers. Broadly, even if every Democrat, every member of the Constitution Party, libertarian and every other otherwise unaffiliated registered voter in the state broke for Cheney, she’d still be more than 200,000 votes short in a state of just under 300,000 registered voters. To put an even finer point on it, if Cheney wins every Wyoming voter who is not a Republican, she’d still lose by almost 50 points (73%-27%) if she won no Republican votes. Cheney will obviously win some Republicans’ votes, but that’s quite the steep hill to start from. It all points to a possibly rough night for Cheney, and if she does lose, just two of the 10 House Republicans who voted for Trump’s impeachment as a result of his conduct on Jan. 6 will have won their primaries. One of those, California’s David Valadao, is one of the most endangered Republicans in the country, because he’s in a district President Biden won in 2020 by double digits. That means when the next Congress begins, it’s possible just one Republican Trump impeacher, Washington’s Dan Newhouse, will likely still be in office. Two states hold primaries Tuesday: Alaska and Wyoming. In Wyoming, U.S. Rep. Liz Cheney was ousted in a Republican primary by Harriet Hagemen, who had the endorsement of former President Donald Trump. by Liz Ruskin, Alaska Public Media U.S. House candidate former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin greets the crowd during a rally held by former President Donald Trump on July 9 in Anchorage. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images hide caption U.S. House candidate former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin greets the crowd during a rally held by former President Donald Trump on July 9 in Anchorage. Alaskans go to the polls Tuesday to decide, among other things, whether to send former governor and Republican vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin to Congress. The right-wing Republican is among three candidates in a special election for Alaska’s sole U.S. House seat. Palin is up against Republican Nick Begich III and Democrat Mary Peltola in the first test of Alaska’s new ranked-choice voting system. The winner will serve until the end of the year, finishing the term of GOP Rep. Don Young. He died in March after serving 49 years. Begich is a wealthy tech entrepreneur. He was co-chair of Young’s 2020 campaign but turned on the incumbent the next year and ran to Young’s right. He comes from a family of prominent Democrats and is named for his grandfather, the congressman who held the seat before Young. With two conservatives splitting the vote, Peltola, a salmon advocate and former state legislator from western Alaska, is likely to gain the most first-choice ballots. But the winner of the special election won’t be known until the end of August, after all the mailed ballots arrive. That’s when the Alaska Division of Elections will tabulate the rankings. The third-place finisher will be eliminated and the ballots that went to the candidate will be reallocated according to the voters’ second choices. Palin has called it the “screwiest system” that “makes no sense to most voters.” A slim majority of Alaska voters adopted the new method in 2020. It pairs a nonpartisan primary with ranked choice voting in the general. To win the special general, one of the conservatives would have to get enough second-choice votes from the other to overcome Peltola’s likely lead in the first round of counting. The two Republicans have been attacking each other for weeks while leaving Peltola alone. Palin recently called the Democrat a “sweetheart,” even as she attacks Begich for supporting Democrats in past races. Begich has called Palin a “quitter,” tapping into the disappointment many Alaska Republicans felt when she resigned as governor in 2009in the wake of her unsuccessful campaign as John McCain’s vice presidential running mate in 2008. “We picked her to do a job, and she didn’t bother to finish it. Because she wanted to go out there and get rich and famous,” a Begich ad says. While they need second-choice votes, Begich and Palin have a more immediate concern. “Game No. 1 has to be that you don’t come in third,” said Art Hackney, a Republican consultant working for Begich. “Because if you come in third, you are, you know, moot to the whole thing, and it becomes your second-choice votes that are the things that matter.” To complicate this election day for voters, it is also the day of the regular primary. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, a moderate Republican who supports abortion rights, is on the ballot for reelection with 18 challengers. Among them is attorney and evangelical pastor Kelly Tshibaka. She, like Palin, has the endorsement of former President Donald Trump. The Alaska Republican Party would like to punish Murkowski for voting to convict Trump at his second impeachment trial, but the new system eliminates the partisan primary. The top four vote-getters will advance to the November ballot. Murkowski and Tshibaka are both sure to make the cut, along with Democrat Pat Chesbro, a retired educator. Also at stake this election season: Who will serve the next full term in the U.S. House. Begich, Palin and Peltola are all in that race, too. Two states hold primaries Tuesday: Alaska and Wyoming. In Alaska, there are notable races for governor, U.S. Senate and the state’s single U.S. House district. There are actually two simultaneous elections for the House. Three candidates are competing in a ranked-choice special election to fill the late Rep. Don Young’s seat until the end of the year. If no candidate has at least 50% of the vote on the first round, the candidate with the least number of votes will be eliminated and those votes will be redistributed to the second-choice candidate on the ballots. Those same candidates are among nearly two dozen competing in a primary for the full U.S. House term beginning in 2023. The top four candidates in that race will advance to a ranked-choice general election in November. by Ron Elving Former President Donald Trump campaigns May 28 in Casper, Wyo., for Harriet Hageman, who is challenging Rep. Liz Cheney in the state’s Republican primary. Chet Strange/Getty Images hide caption Former President Donald Trump campaigns May 28 in Casper, Wyo., for Harriet Hageman, who is challenging Rep. Liz Cheney in the state’s Republican primary. This Tuesday brings another round of important primaries for Congress and statewide office and the likelihood that big-name candidates will go down to defeat. But the news next week will not focus on those household-familiar names or what their losses mean for their states. It will focus on what those outcomes may mean for Donald Trump. That is all the more remarkable considering that these could be the last bids for seats in Congress for two of the best-known women in American politics — Republican icons Liz Cheney of Wyoming and Sarah Palin of Alaska. Cheney is vice chair of the committee investigating the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol and has often been the sharp point of the spear for that probe. Until she voted to impeach Trump in January 2021, she was on track to someday be the first Republican woman to be speaker of the House. She may also be a candidate for president in 2024. Cheney is, of course, also the daughter of former Vice President Richard B. Cheney, who served two terms in the White House (2001-2009) and was often described as the most powerful No. 2 executive in U.S. history. The former vice president has released an ad and a video in which he appears in a cowboy hat and growls out his support for his daughter and dismisses Trump’s claims about the 2020 election. The tag line is: “Only a coward would lie to his own supporters.” Palin was the first woman since Geraldine Ferraro in 1984 to be on the national ticket of either of the two major parties, chosen for the vice-presidential slot by GOP nominee John McCain in 2008. She delivered one of the most memorable speeches in recent history at the party’s St. Paul convention that summer and headlined packed rallies that autumn that in many ways anticipated Trump’s own. Before that she was the governor of Alaska and since then she has been a TV reality star, though far less successful in that career than Trump. She has also been a Fox News contributor prior to her current campaign and a contestant on “The Masked Singer.” She is running now for the seat held for 49 years by the late Rep. Don Young, the longest serving Republican member of Congress in history. If she wins the special election Tuesday, she will complete his term, and a primary vote on the same ballot would nominate her for a full term starting in 2023. Just over a year ago, the prospect of Cheney and Palin both serving in the same chamber of Congress at once would have been enough to draw media attention of all kinds at all levels of sophistication. With first names that easily fit in headlines and last names sure to be click-bait, the two could have driven traffic for years. That would have been especially true had one or the other or both run for president in 2024 or thereafter. And even if neither did, either would be an automatic mention for vice president in 2024 or thereafter. It is still possible, but developments in both their states and nationally have made it increasingly unlikely that either will be on the House floor next year. In another time — say one cycle ago — Cheney would be breezing to another GOP nod for the seat she first won in 2016 and has held since. In November she would expect to win with more than two-thirds of the vote, as she has three times. But this time, she is expected to lose badly to state legislator Harriet Hageman, who has been leading in the polls – including a University of Wyoming poll published Aug. 12 showing Hageman ahead 30 points. Trump endorsed Hageman the day she announced way back in September 2021, a swift move that helped to freeze out other Republican rivals who might have divided the anti-Cheney vote. “We love President Trump here,” Hageman says, thanking him for also coming to the state for her. Trump has made good on his vow to oppose the 10 House Republicans who voted to impeach him in January 2021 (two have survived their primaries, three have lost and four others did not seek re-election). Hageman was a strong supporter of the presidential aspirations of Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas in 2016, at the time dismissing Trump as “racist and xenophobic.” She now says she was the victim of lies about Trump told by Democrats and Liz Cheney at that time, but now regards him “as the greatest president of my lifetime.” In interviews, Cheney has strongly suggested she has already accepted the verdict of the Wyoming voters but is not ready to end her career. After completing her current term, observers have suggested, she could be the anti-Trump campaigner in a 2024 field of pro-Trump Republicans – quite possibly including Trump himself. While no data exist to suggest Cheney could still win on Tuesday, her candidacy has prompted an unprecedented outpouring of support from outside the state and from longtime adversaries as well. Led by former Gov. Mike Sullivan, many Wyoming Democrats are expected to switch their party registration (as state law permits on primary day) so as to vote for Cheney. But it’s highly unlikely there would be enough of these to make the difference. There may have been some erosion of Trump support in Wyoming, where he got 70% of the vote twice. But that slippage probably ended when the FBI searched his home at Mar-a-Lago on Aug. 8. Republicans in Wyoming, as elsewhere, closed ranks behind the former president this past week and denounced the search as politically motivated. After that FBI search, the blood is up in Trump states. But even this latest rallying around Trump might not be enough to save Palin. She has his endorsement, and he dialed in for one of her rallies as recently as the day his home was searched. What’s stopping Palin is not her relationship with the former president, it’s a voting system. Alaska has an open primary that lists all candidates together regardless of party. In the first round of the vote there this spring, there were 48 candidates on the ballot. Palin, no surprise, came in first with 27% of the total. She has often complained that she “got the most votes” and should not be subjected to a second round of voter assessment. But under Alaska’s system, Palin must face a second round of voting that includes the top four finishers from the first round. One of the top four in the June vote has dropped out, but Palin is still battling two second-round rivals on Tuesday, including another Republican. He is Nick Begich III, the grandson of the last person to hold this seat before Young. His grandfather was a Democrat who was lost in a plane crash in the Alaska wilderness in 1972; his uncle Mark, also a Democrat, was a one-term U.S. senator. The third candidate this Tuesday is Mary Peltola, a former state legislator who is a daughter of a Yup’ik Eskimo. A Democrat who has emerged as a factor in her own right, she could even win a plurality of first-place votes on Tuesday. But that would not be the end of the story, because a first-place plurality is not enough. Alaska has just installed a new ranked-choice system, like the one used in Maine and New York City and elsewhere. It allows each voter to vote for more than one candidate, ranking them by order of preference. If no one gets over 50% on first count, the two with the most first-place votes proceed to an “instant runoff” — a tally of their respective second-place votes. If a candidate has enough of an advantage in the second tally it can overcome a deficit in the first. Because third-place votes at this point may be the kiss of death, the contest becomes less a popularity contest than an unpopularity contest. The candidate liked best by some but liked least by too many others is not going to win. One of the arguments for the ranked-choice system has been that it encourages candidates to be more congenial and supposedly discourages negative campaigning. But Begich’s ads have been tough on Palin. One says “she left Alaska to be a celebrity.” A voice in another says “vote smart, not Sarah.” It was widely noted that she missed a candidate debate this summer for a fundraiser in Minnesota. And while she was a charismatic force in the 2008 presidential campaign, she has not faced any voters since quitting midway through her one term as governor in 2009. Some Republicans have still not forgotten how she won that term, challenging an incumbent Republican. A recent poll by Alaska Survey Research showed her to be viewed unfavorably by 60% of Alaskans, far more than either Begich or Peltola. Surveys have shown voters in other places have found the system reasonably easy to use and like the chance to make more than one choice. Trump, for his part, has weighed in calling the system “crap.” He might be even less enamored of it if it frustrates Palin on Tuesday. She was among the first famous Republicans to support him in his presidential quest, and he was pleased to return the favor. But he will likely console himself by thinking about Wyoming. Voting concludes Tuesday in Hawaii’s primary elections, including notable races for governor, U.S. Senate and a House congressional district. Polls close at 1 a.m. ET Sunday. Hawaii conducts its elections largely by mail. by Shawn Johnson Tim Michels, Wisconsin Republican candidate for governor, right, speaks as former President Donald Trump listens at a rally Friday, Aug. 5, 2022, in Waukesha, Wisc. Morry Gash/AP hide caption Tim Michels, Wisconsin Republican candidate for governor, right, speaks as former President Donald Trump listens at a rally Friday, Aug. 5, 2022, in Waukesha, Wisc. About a day after the FBI raided former President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home and resort, his pick for Wisconsin governor has won the Republican primary, according to a race call by The Associated Press. Late in the campaign, Trump endorsed construction executive and self-described political newcomer Tim Michels who spent millions of his own dollars on a TV ad blitz, painting himself as a businessman and “outsider” who wants to turn government upside down. Michels may not earn his living in politics, but he’s not a political newcomer. He first ran for office in 1998, losing a Republican primary for state Senate to now-U.S. Rep. Scott Fitzgerald. In 2004, Michels ran for U.S. Senate, winning a GOP primary but losing the general election to former Democratic U.S. Sen. Russ Feingold. After the backing of the former president in this race, Michels shot up in the polls and ran a competitive campaign against Rebecca Kleefisch, who was lieutenant governor under former Republican Gov. Scott Walker for eight years. Kleefisch was also supported by former Vice President Mike Pence. Michels hasn’t gone as far as Trump when it comes to the way he describes the 2020 presidential election, but he has cast doubt on President Biden’s victory in Wisconsin, which was affirmed by a statewide canvas, a partial recount and multiple state and federal court decisions. When asked at a recent debate whether he’d sign legislation that would “decertify” Biden’s 2020 victory in Wisconsin, Michels kept his options open. In 2018, Democratic Gov. Tony Evers won the election for governor by a sliver and the race in 2022 between Michels and Evers could be just as close. The governor has incumbency and a decent approval rating on his side. Evers is regularly at odds with Republicans in the state and has set veto records. In many ways, his veto is the only thing standing in between the large GOP majorities in the legislature and measures like making it easier to carry concealed guns and election law changes that would likely become law under Michels. To many in Wisconsin, Michels policy agenda is a mystery. While he’s laid out some of what he’d prioritize if elected, big questions remain about how he would govern. But the spotlight of the campaign has prompted Michels to take stands on some issues. In early July, his campaign didn’t respond when asked by the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel whether he would ban emergency contraceptives, known as Plan B. By mid-month, he told reporters he would not. “I am against abortion,” Michels said. “I am not against contraception.” Michels’ stump speech lists three priorities as governor. He tells voters he’s for “election integrity,” referencing a package of changes that includes eliminating the Wisconsin Elections Commission. He said he also wants to reduce crime and reform education. by Bob Kinzel Thursday, Jan. 7, 2021, Republican Gov. Phil Scott wears a mask as he takes the Oath of Office on the steps of the Vermont Statehouse in Montpelier, Vt., beginning his third two-year term. Vermont is one of two states that holds elections for governor every two years. Wilson Ring/AP hide caption Thursday, Jan. 7, 2021, Republican Gov. Phil Scott wears a mask as he takes the Oath of Office on the steps of the Vermont Statehouse in Montpelier, Vt., beginning his third two-year term. Vermont is one of two states that holds elections for governor every two years. Tuesday, there are primaries for governor in Connecticut, Minnesota, Wisconsin and Vermont. Three of those states hold elections for governor every four years. That’s the norm. But Republican Gov. Phil Scott, in Vermont, is running for his fourth term after first being elected in 2016. There are several reasons why Vermont and New Hampshire are the last two states to keep a two-year term. There’s a sense with some voters that they want the opportunity to review how a governor is doing every two years. Some believe there’s a benefit to having a governor address current issues and defend their priorities in a statewide campaign every two years. If something bad takes place — let’s say, a scandal of some sort or an unexpected development that becomes a dominant issue for the state — then voters have a chance to give the incumbent either a vote of confidence or vote them out of office. It’s worth noting that unlike some states, Vermont does not have a recall process to remove a governor from office, so the two-year term serves as a method of accountability. It also requires a constitutional amendment to change to a four-year term, and that’s a very long, difficult process. The two-year term has been on the minds of lawmakers for more than 100 years. Vermont actually went to a two-year term in 1870, but then in 1880 there was an effort to switch back — but it failed. Since 1880, there have been nearly 20 efforts to amend the Vermont constitution to expand the governor’s term to four years. All attempts have been unsuccessful. by Shawn Johnson From left, Rebecca Kleefisch, Tim Michels and Timothy Ramthun (not pictured) participate in a televised debate for the GOP nomination for Wisconsin governor on July 24 in Milwaukee. Morry Gash/AP hide caption From left, Rebecca Kleefisch, Tim Michels and Timothy Ramthun (not pictured) participate in a televised debate for the GOP nomination for Wisconsin governor on July 24 in Milwaukee. MADISON, Wis. – Tuesday, former President Donald Trump’s influence over GOP swing state voters will again be tested. This time in Wisconsin where the former president has endorsed candidates that pit him squarely against the establishment of the Republican Party. In the primary for Wisconsin governor, Trump endorsed construction executive Tim Michels over Rebecca Kleefisch, who was lieutenant governor under former Republican Gov. Scott Walker for eight years. Walker has campaigned aggressively for Kleefisch, who is also supported by former Vice President Mike Pence. Trump’s endorsement of Michels in early June upended the race for governor, giving his campaign a jolt roughly a month after he entered the race. Michels spent millions of dollars of his own money on a TV ad blitz, painting himself as a businessman and “outsider” who wants to turn government upside down, echoing messages used by Trump in his 2016 run for the presidency. Trump also backed Republican Adam Steen in his primary campaign against Robin Vos, the powerful speaker of the Wisconsin Assembly who angered Trump because of his refusal to try to overturn President Joe Biden’s 2020 victory in the state, a move election law experts say is legally impossible. Trump victories in both races could help him lay claim to the Wisconsin GOP ahead of his assumed presidential campaign in 2024. But Anthony Chergosky, a political scientist with the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse, says both of Trump’s candidates could very plausibly lose. “I wonder if Donald Trump fully understands what he’s getting into,” Chergosky says. Michels hasn’t gone as far as Trump when it comes to the way he describes the 2020 presidential election, but he has cast doubt on Biden’s victory in Wisconsin, which was affirmed by a statewide canvas, a partial recount and multiple state and federal court decisions. When asked at a recent debate whether he’d sign legislation that would “decertify” Biden’s 2020 victory in Wisconsin, Michels kept his options open. “Everything’ll be on the table,” Michels said. “I’ll make the right decision.” Kleefisch, who has said the 2020 election was “rigged,” has nevertheless been the only GOP candidate for governor in Wisconsin who has rejected the idea that the outcome of the race could be overturned. “It’s not constitutionally possible,” Kleefisch said at the same debate. “There is no path to decertifying an election that has already happened.” Other factors reportedly weighed into Trump’s endorsement decision. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported that Trump was angered by a picture Kleefisch posted on Twitter of her teenage daughter going to homecoming with the son of a state Supreme Court justice who ruled against Trump in multiple election lawsuits nearly two years ago. Trump’s push to overturn the election has certainly been front-and-center in his decision to endorse Steen, a political unknown until recently, over Vos, the legislature’s most powerful Republican who has set the GOP agenda in Wisconsin for more than a decade. “Adam Steen is running to defeat your RINO speaker of the house, Robin Vos,” Trump said at a Friday rally in Waukesha, Wis., referring to the acronym for “Republican In Name Only.” Chergosky says the races are broadly reflective of the battle for power within the GOP, both in Wisconsin and nationally. “You’ve got sort of the early 2010s version of the Republican Party on one side, and you’ve got the Donald Trump version of the Republican Party on the other side.” The primary also showcases a geographic divide, Chergosky says, in the GOP between the suburbs — where Kleefisch draws her strongest support — and rural areas that have been key to the Trump coalition. Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers awaits to address the virtual Democratic National Convention at the Wisconsin Center on Aug. 19, 2020, in Milwaukee, Wis. Evers is running for reelection in 2022. Melina Mara/Getty Images hide caption Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers awaits to address the virtual Democratic National Convention at the Wisconsin Center on Aug. 19, 2020, in Milwaukee, Wis. Evers is running for reelection in 2022. The winner will face Democratic Gov. Tony Evers in November in a race that public polling and recent Wisconsin history suggest will be close. Evers defeated Walker by a little more than a percentage point in 2018 and has spent the bulk of the past four years at odds with Republicans who have large majorities in the state legislature, vetoing more bills in a single session than any governor in Wisconsin history. When Trump visited Wisconsin last week, Evers’ campaign issued a statement that attacked both Michels and Kleefisch, yet another sign that the race could go either way. “Every candidate in the Republican primary is too extreme for our state, and would sign into law dangerous bills that would undermine our democracy,” said Evers campaign spokesman Sam Roecker. “Gov. Evers is focused on doing the right thing for our state and bringing people together to solve real problems.” Four states hold primaries Tuesday: Connecticut, Minnesota, Wisconsin and Vermont. In Vermont, there are competitive primaries for U.S. Senate and the state’s lone U.S. House district, as Rep. Peter Welch is giving up his House seat to run for the Senate seat left open by the retirement of Patrick Leahy. Four states hold primaries Tuesday: Connecticut, Minnesota, Wisconsin and Vermont. Wisconsin holds top billing, with a competitive Republican governor’s primary there highlighting the races. Polls in Wisconsin close at 8 p.m. CT, 9 p.m. ET. Note: Though they remain on the Senate Democratic ballot, notable candidates Sarah Godlewski, Alex Lasry and Tom Nelson have dropped out in recent days. Four states hold primaries Tuesday: Connecticut, Minnesota, Wisconsin and Vermont. Polls in Minnesota — which has a special congressional election, along with competitive primaries for several contests — close at 8 p.m. CT, 9 p.m. ET. Note: Voters in Minnesota’s 1st Congressional District will cast ballots in both a special election, to fill the remainder of the late Rep. Jim Hagedorn’s term, and in a primary for the seat. Here’s more from Minnesota Public Radio. Sponsor Message Become an NPR sponsor
Your guide to a better future Fans of 16-bit RPGs will Love A Love this Nintendo Switch remake. Sean Keane Senior Writer Sean knows far too much about Marvel, DC and Star Wars, and pours this knowledge into recaps and explainers on CNET. He also works on breaking tech, culture and every other kind of news. Retro video games that never got released outside Japan have a unique air of mystery about them, beyond the oft-cited Mother 3, Policenauts and Sweet Home. Given the language barrier and console region-locking, there’s a sense that Japanese players there got to experience all kinds of lost gems we don’t even know exist. Live A Live, which is getting a Nintendo Switch remake on Friday, is one such gem. Originally released for the Super Famicom — the Japanese Super NES — in 1994, it was made by names that would go on to be some of the industry’s most illustrious. Developed by Final Fantasy-maker Square, Live A Live was the directorial debut for Takashi Tokita, who worked on Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy 7. It features musical compositions from Yoko Shimomura, who also crafted killer soundtracks for Street Fighter 2, Kingdom Hearts and Final Fantasy 15. So it’s a game with incredible pedigree from the same era as Chrono Trigger and Final Fantasy 6, two Super NES games RPG fans swoon over endlessly, and it only ever came out in Japan. If ever a game fit the “lost gem” criteria, Live A Live is it. The Near Future is solid starting chapter but has a few too many quirky elements. The Switch remake spruces up the visuals, giving the game a striking HD-2D look similar to Octopath Traveler and Triangle Strategy, and adds voice acting on top of the traditional text boxes. Visually striking and aurally delightful, it feels designed to mirror how classic 16-bit games exist in our nostalgia-filtered memories. However expertly it gives life to the retro gaming aesthetic you fondly remember, Live A Live is a little different to the usual sprawling RPG where you play a single long story. Instead, you’re presented with seven scenarios set in different points of history that can be played in any order: Prehistory, Imperial China, Twilight of Edo Japan, The Wild West, Present Day, The Near Future and Far Future. The battle mechanics, leveling and equipment systems are consistent across all eras, but each has distinct gameplay and thematic elements. Each one lasts roughly two and a half to four hours, and you’re often presented with choices that’ll affect the narrative’s outcome, adding an element of replayability. Live A Live is overwhelming at first. I jumped into The Near Future initially, mostly because it was the first one highlighted on the menu. The game wastes little time jumping into Final Fantasy 7 levels of melodrama, opening with your character finding his police officer dad shot. You also have psychic powers, have a badass biker buddy and live in an orphanage full of quirky kids. And there’s an oddball scientist with a giant robot. Basically, it flings a lot of extremely anime elements at you in a short amount of time and feels like a mess. The Wild West scenario is awesome and made me want to play more RPGs set in this era. Thankfully, the other eras mostly offer simpler narratives (or maybe I just got into the game’s vibe). The Wild West scenario, which puts you in the boots of a mysterious outlaw on the run from a mouthy bounty hunter, is a standout. It’s focused, fun and oozes atmosphere, but I blasted through it in just over two hours and was left wanting more. Much of Live A Live’s fun lies in jumping into each era and seeing what awaits you, so I won’t go into too much detail about the others or the narrative elements that subtly link them together. Each tells a story that’s satisfying in isolation, offers unique gameplay elements and introduces memorable characters, but subtle hints that the eras are somehow linked will compel you to explore the next. There’s some trial-and-error when it comes to making major choices, but the game reminds you to save often to offset this. Live A Live’s eccentricities are balanced by the straightforward, fun turn-based combat system in which your party and the enemies move around a 7×7 grid, with a nice variety of physical and magical attacks that hit certain parts of the battlefield after their charge times elapse. It got me thinking in tactical way that brought back faded memories of Chrono Trigger’s fights. Most non-boss battles are straightforward and allow you to settle into the game’s mechanics, but several of the final bosses took multiple attempts to defeat, forcing me to come up with distinct strategies to overcome their most devastating attacks. Each was super satisfying to overcome, and their designs were often delightfully grotesque. Don’t let the enhanced visuals fool you; this is still unmistakably an RPG from the mid-’90s. Environments are magnificently designed but can feel a bit empty and tiresome to explore — I was bored with the Twilight of Edo Japan’s maze-like castle by the time I finished the chapter. The soundtrack is full of bangers, as you’d expect from Shimomura, and lodged themselves firmly in my brain for hours after each session. Unfortunately, most of the samples are short and become repetitive if you linger in an area or battle (though their brevity likely helps the melodies lodge themselves in your brain). The cast is charming, but many of the characters are straightforward tropes, and the mostly solid voice acting isn’t enough to overcome some weak scripting. Every single character is beautiful to look at though, positively popping off the screen and offering a pixelated hand to invite you on this old-school adventure. And it’s an adventure that RPG fans willing to put up with some dated mechanics should definitely take — a sizable free demo lets you transfer your progress to the full game if you’re uncertain. The love that went into remaking Live A Live while preserving the core experience is evident in every minute, right down the occasional tedium of ’90s gaming. It’d be incredible to see more classics — like Chrono Trigger, Final Fantasy 6 or Suikoden — remastered in this manner.