TOPEKA, Kan. (WIBW) – Day 6 of the Dana Chandler double-murder retrial on Friday featured testimony from a Federal Bureau of Investigation special agent; the brother of Chandler’s murdered ex-husband, who was killed in 2002; and late in the afternoon, Chandler’s son, Dustin Sisco, who is now an adult.
Friday’s session started at 9:04 a.m. at the Shawnee County Courthouse. It was continuing at 3:15 p.m.
Chandler, now 62, was arrested in 2011 and charged with the July 7, 2002, murders of her ex-husband Mike Sisco, 47, and his fiancé Karen Harkness, 53, at a home at 2231 S.W. Westport Square in west Topeka.
Testimony indicated Harkness had been shot five times and Sisco seven times while they were in bed in the basement of the residence, located just southeast of S.W. 21st and Wanamaker.
Though she has maintained her innocence, Chandler was convicted in 2012.
However, in 2018, the Kansas Supreme Court overturned the conviction, citing misconduct by former prosecutor Jacqie Spradling, who has since been disbarred.
Chandler, who previously was in the Topeka Correctional Facility after her 2012 conviction, has been in the Shawnee County Jail since May 18, 2018.
The state’s prosecutor is Charles Kitt, chief of staff for the Shawnee County District Attorney’s Office.
Chandler is being represented by lead defense attorney Tom Bath, of Leawood. Tricia Bath and Mark Hartman also are serving as a defense lawyers for Chandler.
The first witness on Friday was Patrick McLaughlin, who was a Topeka police officer in 2002.
McLaughlin, who is now employed by the Shawnee County District Attorney’s office, said he assisted with a canvas of the neighborhood near the 2200 block of S.W. Westport Square on July 8 and 9, 2002, in the days after the double-homicide of Harkness and Sisco.
He said a woman in the neighborhood reported hearing a car running outside her house around 2:30 a.m. Sunday, July 7, 2002, followed by what sounded like a gunshot around 3 a.m.
McLaughlin said as part of the investigation, he later spent “five or six days” examining surveillance video covering 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sunday, July 7, 2002, from an entry and exit point of Rocky Mountain National Park, looking for a black 1997 Mitsubishi Eclipse, the same make and model of Chandler’s car.
He said he wasn’t able to locate a car of that type on the video footage, which he said was “not of great quality.”
The second witness on Friday morning was Kim Warrender, who formerly worked with Harkness between around 1999 and 2001 at the Capitol Plaza Hotel in Topeka.
Warrender said Harkness showed up to work one morning upset over phone calls she said had come from Chandler.
Warrender said Harkness “had been up all night” and was “very afraid” after Chandler’s phone calls.
Warrender said Harkness was “questioning” whether she should stay in her relationship with Sisco “because she was afraid and receiving lots of phone calls.”
Friday’s third witness was Dena Soden, who also worked with Harkness at the Capitol Plaza Hotel.
Soden also testified that Harkness had become “afraid” after phone calls from Chandler.
Soden said Harkness reported Chandler making “harassing” phone calls.
Both Warrender and Soden said they became friends with Harkness after meeting her through their work at the Capitol Plaza Hotel and socialized outside of work, frequently playing golf together.
They added that Harkness left her job at the Capitol Plaza around 2002 to work for Visit Topeka, which was the city’s convention and visitors bureau.
The morning’s fourth witness was Federal Bureau of Investigation Special Agent Ryan J. Williams, who said he was asked in 2018 by the Shawnee County District Attorney’s Office to analyze phone records in the Harkness-Sisco double-homicide case.
Williams said he examined calling patterns for numbers associated with Chandler over an approximate six-month period from December 2001 to June 2002, noting 707 calls were made over 194 days to numbers belonging to Harkness and Sisco.
From Williams’ report, Kitt highlighted 18 calls made in 21 minutes on June 3, 2002, as an example of “rapid calling” to numbers associated with Sisco and Chandler.
Williams also provided details on how towers are used to help track phone calls.
Under questioning from defense lawyer Tom Bath, Williams said he hadn’t seen phone records from 1999, 2000 and much of 2001, when Harkness told friends Warrender and Soden she and Sisco had received multiple calls from Chandler.
It also wasn’t known how many, if any, of the “rapid calls” had been answered, Williams said upon questioning from Tom Bath.
Upon further questioning, Tom Bath asked Williams to break down how many of the 700-plus calls went to Mike Sisco’s phones and how many went to Harkness’ residence.
Putting all of the calls together, Bath said, was similar to putting “soybeans and wheat” together as a single amount, but not specifying how much of each crop was included in the final total.
In responding to Tom Bath, Williams said only around 20 of the 700-plus calls from Chandler went to Harkness’ residence. That amounted to only about 3.5 percent of the calls during the six-month period from December 2001 to 2002. The rest of the 700-plus calls went to either Mike Sisco’s home phone or cellphone.
Three phone numbers were the focus of questioning from Bath to Williams. Two of the numbers belonged to Mike Sisco — a home number and a cellphone number — while the third number was to Harkness’ home.
Two other numbers that frequently had been called were determined to belong to Hailey Sisco and her boyfriend at the time, Chris Seal.
Under terms of a 1997 divorce settlement, testimony showed that Mike Sisco retained custody of the two children he had with Chandler — Hailey and Dustin Sisco.
As part of the divorce settlement, it was disclosed in testimony that Chandler had visitation rights on weekends and the right to call her children on a daily basis.
Bath also brought into question the use of an AT&T calling card on June 4 that registered to a 785 area-code number, which corresponds to Topeka, the same day records showed Chandler’s cellphone was being used in the Denver area.
Bath noted a calling card could be used by multiple people, noting in this case it could have been used by Hailey Sisco.
Bath also asked Williams about cellphone companies’ retention of call records.
Questions during Fridays proceedings also addressed details on cell-site towers.
Information from cell-site towers can help show when and where calls were placed or which calls were routed.
Williams said routing for cellphone calls occurs for one of four reasons: the cellphone Is turned off; the cellphone is outside the cellphone company’s service area; the call goes to voicemail; or the call is taking place in another cellphone company service area.
Bath also asked Williams if records could show if a phone is turned “on or off.”
Williams said he wasn’t aware of cellphone companies being able to track whether a phone was turned on or “powered off.”
Bath also confirmed with Williams on several dates in the spring of 2002 when Chandler’s Sprint cellphone had no service for more than 24 hours.
Those times were in addition to the dates in June and July of 2022 when evidence indicated Chandler’s cellphone also had no service for more than 24 hours.
Timothy Sisco, the younger brother of Mike Sisco, took the witness stand mid-afternoon on Friday.
In his testimony, while questioned by Kitt, Timothy Sisco recalled an incident at a youth soccer game in Olathe in where Hailey Sisco, Mike Sisco’s daughter, was playing.
Timothy Sisco said he was at the match with his brother when Chandler also came to the game and began to scream at Sisco on the sideline.
“She was yelling that Mike is a rapist, ‘He raped me,’” Timothy Sisco said. “That was the main thing that I heard. I don’t recall all the other things that were being spewed out. It was very, very traumatic.”
Timothy Sisco also testified Mike Sisco told him about an incident in which he came home in 2002 to find Chandler inside his house in the 2500 block of S.E. Alexander, in the Tecumseh area east of Topeka.
According to Timothy Sisco’s testimony, Mike Cisco said Chandler told him, “I have a solution to our problem.” She said, ‘I’ll move in and we’ll be a happy family again.”
Timothy Sisco said Mike Sisco replied to Chandler, “Are you crazy?” before telling her he was going to marry Harkness.
In her questioning of Timothy Sisco, Tricia Bath noted there had been prior talk of daughter Hailey moving to Denver to live with Chandler.
Tricia Bath also produced an audio recording in which Chandler and Mike Sisco had a discussion at a parent-teacher conference for their son, Dustin.
In the recording of the conversation, Chandler asked Mike Sisco if they could go together to the parent-teacher conference, but he resisted the idea.
Under questioning from Tricia Bath, Timothy Sisco said that following Mike Sisco’s death, he and his brother-in-law, Mark Boots, went on July 10, 2002, to a Holliday Inn in Topeka, where Chandler was staying, to tell her they didn’t want her to attend Mike Sisco’s funeral.
Timothy Sisco said Chandler agreed to meet with her children Hailey and Dustin for an hour before the funeral, but then stayed for the service.
The day’s last witness took the stand around 3:50 p.m. Friday, when Dustin Sisco, the son of Mike Sisco and Chandler, was questioned by Kitt.
Dustin Sisco recalled his parents’ 1997 divorce, noting he was 10 and his sister was 12 at the time.
He testified he and his sister were enlisted by their mother to “spy” on their dad — Mike Sisco — following their divorce while they were on a weekend visitation with their mother when they lived in Lawrence.
“We were with her,” Dustin Sisco said. “We were in her car, me and Hailey, my sister. She told us to come along — we could be her helpers, look and spy on my dad at his house while we were with her.”
After he was questioned by Kitt, Chandler’s lawyers declined to keep Dustin Sisco on the witness stand, and he was dismissed.
Court was adjourned for the weekend around 4:35 p.m. Friday as Rios noted the next witness — who wasn’t named — was expected to give extensive testimony.
The trial is set to resume at 9 a.m. Monday, Aug. 15.
During the first six days of the retrial, former Topeka police officers; former neighbors of Harkness in the 2200 block of S.W. Westport Square; a former employee of the Sac ‘N Fox Casino, where Harkness and Sisco went the night before they were killed; a U.S. Forestry Department fire investigator; a former business acquaintance of Chandler from Denver; the lead Topeka police detective in the case; and a friend of Chandler’s from Arizona.
Twelve jurors and five alternates were sworn in for duty when the retrial began Friday, Aug. 5.
Two of the jurors were released earlier this week.
The trial is expected to last up to three weeks.
Copyright 2022 WIBW. All rights reserved.