SYLVIE DOUGLIS, BYLINE: This is PLANET MONEY from NPR.
(SOUNDBITE OF COIN SPINNING)
STACEY VANEK SMITH, HOST:
Hello, and welcome to PLANET MONEY Summer School – the supply for your intellectual demand. I am Stacey Vanek Smith. So far this season, we have learned about inflation, the jobs market, the business cycle – all things macroeconomic. But today, we are going super macro. We are macroing (ph) out because, today, we’re looking not just at a country’s whole economy, but how a country’s whole economy interacts with other countries’ whole economies. I’m talking, of course, about trade.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
VANEK SMITH: Trade is a very powerful economic force. It has shaped our jobs, our lives, what we see on our store shelves in countless ways. Trade has created this economic web that binds us all together. Everybody on the planet – it links our fates. So here to parse this tangled web with us are two of my very favorite economists in the world – Soumaya Keynes and Chad Bown. Hey, guys.
CHAD BOWN: Hi, Stacey.
SOUMAYA KEYNES: Hi, Stacey.
VANEK SMITH: Soumaya, let’s start with you.
KEYNES: So I am an economist. Currently, I’m the Britain economics editor at The Economist, and so I spend my time thinking about trade, productivity, growth, which is a lot of nerdery (ph).
VANEK SMITH: And that brings us to Chad Bown, our other very special economist guest. Hello, Chad.
BOWN: So I’m a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington, D.C., which is a think tank. I’m a trade economist, and so I do, you know, trade economics all the time.
VANEK SMITH: So trade is, at its essence, a relationship between countries. And, in general, what countries are looking for from this relationship is something called gains from trade, which is just, you know, extra wealth or some other kind of advantage that countries can get by trading with each other. So PLANET MONEY did a very deep dive into this issue about a decade ago with the PLANET MONEY T-shirt Project. PLANET MONEY actually had T-shirts made, but, like, from scratch. It followed them from the cotton fields of Mississippi, where the cotton for the shirts was grown, to Bangladesh and Columbia, where the shirts were sewn, then back in shipping containers to the U.S., where they were sold. And it used this project to explore globalization and trade and to take a look at why so much of what we buy is made overseas. And one of the big reasons for this boils down to absolute advantage. Soumaya, Chad, would one of you mind defining absolute advantage?
KEYNES: So absolute advantage is when you’re just better at doing something than in another country. Supposing you make T-shirts – maybe you’ve just got lower costs. You’re just more efficient at producing T-shirts than another country. So that’s absolute advantage.
VANEK SMITH: When it comes to making T-shirts, the U.S. just is really never going to have an absolute advantage because people here get paid too much. Our wages are too high. Other countries can make basically the same exact T-shirt we could make here, but for a lot less money. They have a huge cost advantage over us. So PLANET MONEY followed its T-shirts to the places that had these advantages, and it partnered with the company Jockey to make the shirts. There were two kinds of shirts that were made. There was the men’s shirt, which was gray with kind of a round collar. And there was the women’s shirt, which was pink and more tailored and had a V-neck. Make of this what you will. But right after the break, we will travel to the place where the women’s T-shirt was made – Columbia. Stick around after the break. It’s a great story.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, DANETTE M DUFILHO AND SKINNY WILLIAMS’ “WERNER’S TANGENT”)
VANEK SMITH: We are back with our story from the PLANET MONEY T-shirt Project. In this piece, we followed the women’s T-shirt to a factory in Colombia, where it was sewn. Marianne McCune reported the story back in 2013. Here’s Marianne.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)
MARIANNE MCCUNE: The women’s T-shirt is made from exceptionally soft cotton knit fabric. It’s a deep V-neck, tailored down the sides. And when PLANET MONEY’s fans finally pull it on, the single mom who stitched on the neck has this message.
LINA MARIA TASCON: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: “Hi, ladies,” she says with a twinkle.
TASCON: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: “I hope you wear this shirt with a lot of pleasure because we put a lot of sweat into it. And we also put in a lot of love, of course.”
TASCON: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: Lina Maria Tascon works in Colombia’s fashion capital, Medellin, where she and the women she sews with are probably some of the fastest in the world. That’s just one reason why Jockey, the company that helped us make our shirts, chose Colombia for this batch. Jockeys’ director of manufacturing, Bill Frazier, came with us on a two-day tour of all the factories that made our T-shirts.
BILL FRAZIER: I think you’re going to be amazed of the thought that really goes into making underwear. I think you’re going to be overwhelmed by it.
MCCUNE: Yup. Here, eight women are stitching together the fronts, backs, necks and sleeves of our smooth, pink cotton.
ISABEL RIOS: This is your T-shirt.
MCCUNE: Isabel Rios, a manager here, picked up a little, white strip that will line the back of the T-shirt’s neck.
It says, PLANET MONEY, PLANET MONEY, PLANET MONEY.
RIOS: What is PLANET MONEY?
MCCUNE: PLANET MONEY is the name of our show.
RIOS: Ah, OK, the show in the radio.
MCCUNE: Yes.
RIOS: OK, OK.
MCCUNE: If you’re a sewing machine operator, this is the kind of place you want to work. Crystal pays for health insurance, there’s a subsidized restaurant on campus, ceiling fans keep things cool, overtime is paid, but it’s optional, not required, and at least once a shift, music blares over a loudspeaker to make everyone stand and stretch for a few minutes.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: Of course, this is still a minimum wage job, about $13 a day. And it’s still tough, repetitive manual labor. While we peered over her shoulder, Lina Maria Tascon, the single mom who said she put sweat and love into these shirts, she was madly stitching on one slender neck after another.
FRAZIER: I don’t think people really think that sewing operators are skilled.
MCCUNE: Bill Frazier, Jockeys’ director of manufacturing.
FRAZIER: But they’re highly skilled with their hand movements, and that’s where they gain their efficiency.
MCCUNE: He says he’s been in so many factories, he can measure that efficiency just by listening to the length of the silence between seams.
The workers in one factory, can they be twice as fast as the workers in another factory?
FRAZIER: Yes.
MCCUNE: You’ve seen that?
FRAZIER: Yes.
(SOUNDBITE OF SEWING MACHINE BUZZING)
MCCUNE: The day we visited, all eight women stayed from 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. in order to get the shirts done in time. It was good and dark by the time Noreli Morales got home to the barebones apartment she shares with her mom and 3-year-old daughter. Mariana crawled as fast as she could into her mom’s lap to snuggle.
MARIANA MORALES: (Speaking Spanish).
NORELI MORALES: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: Morales says, sure, she regrets not staying in school long enough to get a job that pays more for less taxing work. She started sewing because she and her family needed money. Now, she’s kind of stuck, hard to get a better job unless she goes to school, and with this schedule and a kid, there’s no time for that. But then you remember that there are people worse off than you. She says, I’m not as bad off as some people.
MARIANA: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: But there’s a flip side to Morales’s relative good fortune. Her job may be in jeopardy.
LUIS RESTREPO: There is a saying that is going to sound horrible, but our industry follows poverty.
MCCUNE: Our industry follows poverty. Luis Restrepo is Morales’ boss’ boss’ boss’ boss, or something like that. He’s the CEO of all the factories we visited here.
RESTREPO: Our industry is like on roller skates. First, it was Latin America. Then it moved to China. Now China is becoming more expensive. It will move to Bangladesh or move to Vietnam, and it goes like this.
MCCUNE: Rolling toward the lowest paid workers. What that means is that the better off Colombia gets, the less sense it makes for global apparel companies to manufacture here. With the Colombian peso extraordinarily strong against the dollar, the cost of labor here is many times what it costs in a place like Bangladesh. Colombia can no longer keep costs low enough. They have to offer something other than the lowest price, like speed or quality or innovative and higher-end products. If you can’t offer foreign companies something no one else can, making clothes for the global market will turn your hair gray because that breakup call, Restrepo says, where the client tells you he’s found a cheaper option, it can come at any moment.
RESTREPO: You have one phone call away. So that’s no good.
MCCUNE: Partly because of increased competition from Asia over the past decade, Restrepo says he’s had to cut his staff. He cut it by 10%. Sometimes at the factory, while Lina Maria Tascon’s hands are flying around the sewing machine, her head is far away. She’ll put in earbuds and listen to romantic salsa to drown out her worries – that increasingly nasty pain in her shoulder, the extra room she needs at home so her dad can move in, and here’s a really bad one – there’s this rumor making its way around the factory that after eight years of manufacturing here, Jockey is going to make that breakup call and pull out.
TASCON: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: People on her team are really stressed about it, she says.
TASCON: (Speaking Spanish).
MCCUNE: That rumor that Jockey was leaving at the end of the year, we heard it elsewhere, too. So when I got back to the U.S. and had Jockey on the phone, it was the first thing I wanted to know. There’s this rumor going around that Jockey’s pulling out of Colombia by the end of the year. Is that right?
MARION SMITH: I see as close to being right as February. But yes.
MCCUNE: The gossip on the factory floor, it was true. Marion Smith, Jockey’s sourcing guru, he was the one who decided to put a stop to orders from Crystal.
SMITH: The reason I was taking a deep sigh is because it was very painful for me. We both like each other a lot. They’ve got great principles. They have great capabilities.
MCCUNE: The thing is, Smith told us, Colombia was a great place to source from when he started out.
SMITH: But since then, wages continue to go up. Costs continue to go up. The difference between everyone else in the sourcing mix in the world is becoming bigger and bigger and bigger, and it’s because the economy of Colombia is growing.
MCCUNE: Smith says, when Jockey leaves Colombia next year – moves that production to four or five other countries – the company will be spending a lot less per T-shirt.
FRAZIER: As a percent, 20% to 30%.
MCCUNE: Twenty to 30% less?
FRAZIER: Yes.
MCCUNE: Imagine you’re buying thousands and thousands of T-shirts, and you can pay, say, $2 a piece instead of three? That’s a big deal. In order to be less dependent on the Jockeys of the world, Crystal’s CEO says he’s been turning the company’s focus away from manufacturing for foreign companies toward producing its own successful clothing brands.
RESTREPO: We decided that we want to control our own destiny.
MCCUNE: They’ve already opened 160 of their own stores across Latin America, and they have plans for more. So while he’s had to cut factory jobs, he says he’s adding retail jobs, and that mirrors the path of Colombia’s economy. Factory jobs are on the decline, but the service sector is growing. If Lina Maria Tascon does lose her job, it will be hard to find a place in that new economy. She dropped out of school at 13 and had a son. Sewing is what she knows. But that son? He’s now in college studying graphic design. Maybe by the time he graduates, there will be more jobs for designers at the factory.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, DANETTE M DUFILHO AND SKINNY WILLIAMS’ “SORRY I KEPT YOU”)
VANEK SMITH: All right. Hello, class. We are back with our intrepid trade experts, Chad Bown and Soumaya Keynes. Do you have any initial reactions to this leg of our T-shirt’s journey? I’m wondering kind of what is jumping around in your mind right now?
KEYNES: I think what’s jumping around in my mind is that international competition in T-shirts is really fierce, right? You can have advantages, and they can disappear relatively quickly. But in this case, I think that could be a good thing. There are winners and losers as trade flows change. If you’re working in that particular factory and, essentially, you are outcompeted by one elsewhere, then it may be tricky for you individually to find a better job. But the fact that wages are growing overall suggests that other good things are happening in the economy, right? The services sector is expanding. We’ve got a burgeoning graphic design sector. That’s all exciting and just points to this idea that, OK, maybe in the medium term, Colombia will be making fewer T-shirts, but maybe they’ll be doing more of other things that might be associated with high wages, high living standards – general thumbs up for that.
BOWN: But at the same time, because the Colombian economy seems to be doing so well and wages are going up, they need to be offering more benefits to their workers to stay working at the factory. So they have to offer, you know, health care, which is great. They have to offer a subsidized restaurant to give their workers cheaper foods – so all of these extra benefits.
VANEK SMITH: Stretching breaks – the stretching breaks.
BOWN: The stretching breaks, where the music comes on. And all those things are great, but they add to costs. And so at the same time, they were finding it difficult to then compete with a place like Bangladesh, where the companies aren’t having to offer workers those same kind of benefits to get them to be able to make the T-shirts.
KEYNES: Colombia doesn’t have an absolute advantage in making T-shirts anymore because its wages have grown.
BOWN: The line that stuck out to me was when they said, our industry follows poverty, which I think is right, but is also incomplete. And the sentence really should go on from there and say, but our industry also helps lift people out of poverty because all the places where the industry has been – whether it is Colombia or China or Vietnam – those are countries that are much better off today than they were before the industry came and helped to employ people and the wage gains accrued.
VANEK SMITH: And this brings us to our second concept in trade – comparative advantage. So absolute advantage is, you know, who can make T-shirts the most efficiently for the least amount of money – things like that. But comparative advantage – Soumaya, Chad, would one of you mind jumping in to define comparative advantage in trade?
KEYNES: Comparative advantage is slightly more complicated. It might be the case that you would make these T-shirts super, super cheaply. But the question is, what else could you be doing with your resources, right? You’re a country. You could make T-shirts really well, but you can also make semiconductors or laptops really, really effectively. And actually, if you think about those two things, you might be relatively better at making the laptops than the T-shirts compared to a different country. And so if you’re relatively better at making the laptops, then fine. Shut down your T-shirt factory and make the laptops. The other country can make the T-shirts, even if it’s more expensive for them to do so, because they’re so terrible at making the laptops. And then you will specialize and trade, and those countries overall will be better off. Their options have expanded because everyone’s doing the best thing that, collectively, they’re best at doing.
VANEK SMITH: So in the case of Colombia and T-shirts, let’s say Colombia still has an absolute advantage when it comes to sewing some of the more complicated, intricate T-shirts with tailoring and V-necks – like the PLANET MONEY women’s shirt was. The factory Marianne visited, after all, has some of the fastest, most skilled sewers in the world and also a bunch of really fast machines that can crank out T-shirts in seconds for very little money. So they may be able to produce these high-quality shirts at the lowest cost, at least for now. They have an absolute advantage. But Colombia’s economy is clearly evolving. And so the factory that makes the T-shirts thinks, you know, we might be better off changing our business – becoming a clothing retailer, opening up stores, designing clothes, things that could ultimately be more profitable for us. And then, you know, they could get those clothes actually sewn, constructed in a country where, yeah, the workers might be a little less skilled, a little bit slower, but they will be able to make the clothes for a lot less money. And then the Colombian factory can import those clothes and sell them for a lower price, or at least get a higher profit margin. That is comparative advantage, right? I mean, comparative advantage is essentially a situation where everybody wins, right?
BOWN: I’m going to say that the countries both win from trade, but within countries, there are going to be both winners and losers tied to this idea of comparative advantage. So if there’s somebody in my country – the country as a whole isn’t going to be particularly good at making T-shirts. But there are people in my country that if we were just living in isolation, they would be the ones making the T-shirts for my country. Well, we open up the trade. Now all of a sudden, I can get cheaper T-shirts from somebody in a different country. The folks that are making T-shirts in my country, they’re going to be worse off. So trade will make my country as a whole better off. But if I happen to be making and I’m working in the industry that’s – that now has to compete with those imports, they’re not necessarily going to be made better off.
KEYNES: And in an ideal world, of course, you know, a government would see that and would try to redistribute and make sure that any losers from trade didn’t have such a bad time. In practice, sometimes that doesn’t happen.
VANEK SMITH: But also, as you pointed out, there are casualties with this evolution. And Lina Maria may be one of them, although her son could benefit.
BOWN: She is probably laid off, you know, as the industry moves out of Colombia. And she had a kid and needed more schooling. And so, you know, to transition into new and budding industries, that’s typically what we see. We need other social services provided by governments – retraining programs to provide skills so they can move on; child care, daycare, schooling, so that somebody else can help provide those skills to your children, so you can free up the time necessary to be able to learn the skills you need for that next job as well.
VANEK SMITH: In fact, we did see this with the garment industry in the U.S. All – almost all of those jobs moved overseas. And there were some retraining programs that were put in place, but they weren’t very effective. And whole communities were just decimated across the country because these industries left. But at the same time, those industries migrated to places where this business, these jobs, this money had a really transformative effect, and we’re going to look at some of those positive transformative effects right after the break.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, ET AL.’S “DON’T LOOK DOWN”)
VANEK SMITH: OK. Now we are going to hear a story that Caitlin Kenney and Zoe Chace reported back in 2013. It was part of PLANET MONEY’s T-shirt project. And Caitlin and Zoe traveled to Bangladesh, where the PLANET MONEY men’s T-shirt was being made. Here’s Caitlin.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED NPR BROADCAST)
CAITLIN KENNEY, BYLINE: Bangladesh has gone through some huge changes in the last 30 years. The clothing industry there has just exploded, and it’s changing the lives of the people who live there.
ZOE CHACE, BYLINE: We bring you the story of those changes as experienced by two sisters who made our shirt – Shumi and Minu.
KENNEY: Shumi and Minu work here at Deluxe Fashions Ltd. in Chittagong, Bangladesh. It’s this big, bright room. There are hundreds of women in here – some men, too – sitting at sewing machines. Shumi, the younger of the two sisters, her job was to sew the sleeve.
CHACE: The older sister, Minu, she worked on all parts of the T-shirt.
MINU: Side seam, silhouettes…
KENNEY: Side seam?
MINU: Silhouettes, (inaudible)…
CHACE: The side seams – she attached the front and the back of the T-shirt together.
KENNEY: These sisters sit at these sewing machines six days a week, about 10 hours a day. They make 6,000 taka a month. That’s about $80 U.S., and that’s in the middle of the pay scale here in Bangladesh. The minimum wage in Bangladesh right now is just $39 a month.
CHACE: And that is the lowest in the world for this type of work.
KENNEY: But right now, $80 each a month buys these sisters a small room a short bus ride away from the factory.
CHACE: So Minu is the older one. She is in her mid-20s. She is cynical. She’s kind of a fast talker. She likes to chew tobacco wrapped in betel leaf. It’s starting to stain her lips a little bit red. And she has this 7-year-old daughter who lives back in the village with her grandparents.
KENNEY: Shumi, the younger sister, is 19. And where Minu is reserved, Shumi is bubbly. Where Minu’s serious, Shumi is always smiling. She loves her makeup. She spends a lot of time doing her hair. And it’s really hard for her to get through any story without laughing.
SHUMI: (Non-English language spoken).
KENNEY: Today at work, she says she and her friends were throwing clothes at each other, and it was so funny.
SHUMI: (Non-English language spoken).
KENNEY: Shumi and Minu look out for each other in the city. They pool their money to split the rent and bills. They share the household chores. And they share this tiny room with Minu’s husband.
CHACE: Minu’s husband works, but he’s a day laborer. And his income, when it happens, is not reliable. It’s basically up to her and Shumi to cover the rent and the food. Tonight, it’s Minu’s turn to make dinner.
MINU: (Non-English language spoken).
CHACE: Ooh, there’s a bunch of vegetables bubbling up.
KENNEY: Yeah.
CHACE: And what is this?
MINU: (Non-English language spoken).
CHACE: It’s vegetable curry, tonight’s dinner, tomorrow’s breakfast and lunch – one dish, three meals in a row for both of them. To cook, they share these two little gas burners outside their room with their neighbors.
KENNEY: This is the world behind our T-shirts, behind lots of our clothes – a tiny, concrete room shared by three people, a life that, by Western standards, looks pretty wretched. But 4 million people in Bangladesh are essentially making the same choice that Shumi and Minu made – to move to the cities, to work long hours for very little money, to work in the garment industry.
The village where they grew up is about 2 hours away. To get here, the sisters take a bus to a motorized rickshaw.
(SOUNDBITE OF HORN HONKING)
KENNEY: And then, they walk through the rice paddies home. When we get there, lunch is cooking.
(SOUNDBITE OF FLINT STRIKING)
KENNEY: In the village where Shumi and Minu grew up, their mom cooks in the back room. And the difference between her life and her daughters’ lives is very clear. No gas burners here, it’s a fire pit made from mud. There are holes underneath to stick branches into, and the room fills with smoke when she cooks.
ABDUL JABBAR: (Non-English language spoken).
KENNEY: You’re father of Shumi and Minu.
Their father’s name is Abdul Jabbar (ph), and he used to be the only one in the family making any money. And he didn’t make enough. The consequences were horrible.
JABBAR: (Non-English language spoken).
KENNEY: Three of his daughters died before they were 7. They were eating dirt. They got sick. And he couldn’t afford to take them to the doctor.
JABBAR: (Through interpreter) I still remember them at times and feel bad because it’s my daughters, my kids. It feels emptiness in our family.
KENNEY: What Shumi remembers about this time is that there wasn’t enough to eat.
If I ask you to close your eyes and picture what it was like when you were growing up, you know, what do you see? What do you feel?
SHUMI: (Non-English language spoken).
KENNEY: I’m sorry. I didn’t mean to make you cry.
CHACE: Now, things have really changed in this family. Shumi and Minu send money back to the village, and you can see how that’s changed things right here in the kitchen. The stove is the same as what they had growing up, but what’s inside the pot is different.
What is it?
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Non-English language spoken).
CHACE: (Non-English language spoken).
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #3: It’s chicken.
CHACE: Back before the sisters made money, this family rarely ate meat. Now, the sisters’ holiday bonuses pay for all the chicken and fish they want.
KENNEY: The money they send home keeps their younger brother in school. It keeps Minu’s daughter in school.
CHACE: For millions of young women like Shumi and Minu, making T-shirts, like the PLANET MONEY T-shirt, have transformed their lives.
KENNEY: But there’s this other thing that happens when millions of young women start to earn their own money. There’s a cultural shift, and that’s happening here in Bangladesh. You can see this shift just in the couple years difference between Shumi and Minu.
CHACE: For Minu, the older sister, she’s had very few choices of her own to make. When Minu became a teenager, her father began to worry about getting her married.
JABBAR: (Through interpreter) In Bangladesh, it’s a burden to have girls not get my married. I have to spend money on their fooding (ph), lodging, so it becomes a big burden. So if they marry, she will go to another boy’s house.
CHACE: Marrying Minu off meant she became her husband’s burden, not her father’s. And Minu’s family thought the man they chose for their daughter had money. He paid for the wedding. That was a big relief. But Minu’s parents were wrong. The man they chose didn’t have much money. And that’s why Minu went to work in the garment factories. Minu is unhappy in her marriage. Minu’s husband is pretty jealous.
KENNEY: Minu had no choice. She had to marry a man chosen by her parents. But by the time her younger sister Shumi was marrying age, the rules were changing in Bangladesh. The fact that Shumi’s young and unmarried means she gets to be selfish. Minu has to send all her money home for her daughter’s school. Shumi sends some money back to her parents, but she also has her own bank account. And she’s saving for something special, something that shows what a different world she’s living in compared to the one her sister grew up in.
SHUMI: (Through interpreter) I just save the money if I need it for my marriage, and then, I use the money for my marriage.
KENNEY: For your marriage.
SHUMI: (Through interpreter) Yes.
KENNEY: So I got to ask, do you have a groom in mind?
(LAUGHTER)
KENNEY: Yes?
SHUMI: (Through interpreter) Yes.
KENNEY: What’s his name?
Shumi is blushing and laughing, and she won’t tell me his name. Back in the village, her father would never let her talk to a boy who wasn’t a relative. But here in the city, she and her boyfriend take rickshaw rides together. He buys her jewelry. They hold hands. He tells her he loves her. Shumi has the paycheck. Shumi gets to make the choice. Her father isn’t in charge anymore.
CHACE: For Minu, these battles have already been lost. But here in the city, in this small room that she shares with Shumi, there are some things that make Minu happy. I ask Minu, what’s your favorite thing in this room?
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR: (Non-English language spoken).
CHACE: It’s the tiny TV in the corner.
MINU: (Through interpreter) Too good still now because I bought this TV with my salary, and when I was free, I just watching TV, and I feel too good…
CHACE: I feel too good when I watch it, she says.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, DANETTE M DUFILHO AND SKINNY WILLIAMS’S “WERNER’S TANGENT”)
CHACE: This is the world behind our T-shirt – two sisters, tiny room, watching TV they bought with their own money.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, DANETTE M DUFILHO AND SKINNY WILLIAMS’S “WERNER’S TANGENT”)
VANEK SMITH: That was Zoe Chace and Caitlin Kenney back in 2013. And I’m here in 2022 with our two economist guides, Chad Bown and Soumaya Keynes. So guys, I feel like this is a pretty extraordinary portrait of the very positive sides of trade and gains from trade, and just what an amazing and far-reaching impact these gains had in the lives of these two women. What are your thoughts?
KEYNES: You know, trade isn’t the miracle cure, right? It’s not like, having this T-shirt production in Bangladesh, Shumi has been completely lifted out of poverty, right? It’s still – you know, she’s a lot poorer than an average worker in, say, the U.S. But relative to what she might have been doing otherwise, she’s got more freedom.
VANEK SMITH: It’s interesting to me in the story, too, how many things are affected by the poverty in the story, including, you know, marriages and life and death and just how much difference this one job makes. To see that transformation is very powerful. You know, she’s like, the TV – it’s almost too good. Like, they have a little extra. They have a TV.
BOWN: And to the point on choices, they have additional money that they can send home, which it sounds like their family is able to use to keep their younger – youngest brother in school longer than he might be able to stay before he has to get a job. And the more education that you get, probably the better, higher quality job you’re going to be able to get.
VANEK SMITH: OK, well, this has gone really fast, and I can’t believe it, but we are almost to the end of class, and it is time to go over concepts and vocabulary. We’ve got absolute advantage. That is a country’s ability to produce a good or service most efficiently, like a higher quality or for the very least amount of money. There’s also comparative advantage. That is a little more complicated. It’s a country’s ability to make a good or service most efficiently – for the lowest cost or at the highest quality – while taking into account the best or most efficient use of all of that country’s resources. And all of this, of course, is meant to achieve – final vocab word – gains from trade. That is money or other advantages that come when countries trade with each other.
Now, before I let you go, there is something that I’ve been really curious about for kind of a long time. Soumaya, I’ve known you for years, and I’ve never asked you about this, but I have to ask you because our summer school season – it all started with John Maynard Keynes, the economist who is basically the father of macroeconomics. I’ve never asked you this, but are you Soumaya Keynes like John Maynard?
KEYNES: I am indeed, yes.
VANEK SMITH: What?
KEYNES: Yeah, yeah. He’s my great-great-uncle. He died in 1946. So I’m not going to lie – the bond between the two of us is a weak one. It’s tempting to see me as the vessel of him, and it would be very unhealthy for everyone.
VANEK SMITH: You know, Einstein’s relatives are probably like, space-time continuum – like, I don’t believe in it. Or, you know, maybe they’re into mysticism or time travel or something.
KEYNES: Yeah. I mean, I think Einstein’s relatives are probably clever enough not to go into physics. So…
VANEK SMITH: (Laughter).
KEYNES: …I fell down on that one. But, you know, it’s too late now.
VANEK SMITH: Well, Soumaya, I, for one, am very glad that you went into economics, and I happen to know that I’m not alone. But before I let you guys go, I did want to ask if either of you guys have a song for our PLANET MONEY Econ Songs of the Summer playlist – anything inspired by trade or any of the topics we discussed.
BOWN: So I thought about this question in a different way, which is, if we didn’t have international trade, what music would I not have access to as an American, right?
VANEK SMITH: Oh, I love that. Yes.
BOWN: And so having teenage daughters at the moment, I wouldn’t be familiar with K-pop, for example.
VANEK SMITH: Right, BTS.
BOWN: Let alone – BTS, just at the White House.
VANEK SMITH: Is there a K-pop song that you especially love?
BOWN: Well, we’ve been listening to a lot of BLACKPINK lately.
(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, “HOW YOU LIKE THAT”)
BLACKPINK: (Singing) How – how you like that?
VANEK SMITH: Soumaya, Chad, this has been such a joy to see your faces and to talk trade again. Thank you.
BOWN: Thanks for having us.
KEYNES: Thanks so much for having us.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, DANETTE M DUFILHO AND SKINNY WILLIAMS’ “STINKBUG STARDUST AND THE TREMORS THAT WE KNOW OF”)
VANEK SMITH: PLANET MONEY Summer School is produced by Audrey Dilling, with help on this episode from Emma Peaslee and Greg Morton. It is edited by Alex Goldmark. Engineering on this episode by Gilly Moon. Our project manager is Devin Mellor. I’m Stacey Vanek Smith. PLANET MONEY is a production of NPR. Thanks for listening.
(SOUNDBITE OF AARON KELLEY, DANETTE M DUFILHO AND SKINNY WILLIAMS’ “STINKBUG STARDUST AND THE TREMORS THAT WE KNOW OF”)
Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at www.npr.org for further information.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.
Sponsor Message
Become an NPR sponsor
Sep 04, 2022 by The Beat Maker - 0 Comments