Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) and Judicial Commission of Pakistan (JCP) Chairman Justice Umar Ata Bandial on Friday directed to make the audio recording of the JCP proceedings of July 28 available on the official website of the Supreme Court.
The version issued by the public relations officer of the Supreme Court on the instructions of the CJP had been disputed by two judges of the SC, namely Justice Qazi Faez Isa and Justice Sardar Tariq Masood.
A resulting controversy had therefore arisen in the print and electronic media. In these exceptional circumstances, the JCP chairman had been “pleased to relax the restriction under Rule 5(4) of the JCP Rules, 2010 and had directed for the audio recording of the JCP proceedings of 28.07.2022 to be made available on the official website of the SC”, according to a statement.
The audio recording from time slot 1:29:45 to 1:38:08 contained the statement by the attorney general of Pakistan that the matters under discussion should be deferred to frame the appropriate rules.
He did not assess or reject the merits of any of the high court judges proposed for appointment to the SC. As a result, five members of the JCP supported the deferment of the meeting, as reported in the press note of 28.07.2022.
It may be mentioned here that following Justice Qazi Faez Isa’s letter to the JCP, Justice Sardar Tariq Masood on Friday said that the press release issued by the public relations officer of the Supreme Court regarding the JCP meeting presented a “totally different version of events from what actually occurred”.
In a letter written to the JCP members, Justice Masood shared the events that transpired during the meeting held for the approval of the judges’ elevation to the apex court.
The judge said that when the meeting started, Justice Bandial described the credentials of his nominees. After that, he requested Justice (r) Sarmad Jalal Osmany, a member of the commission, to present his views. According to Justice Masood, members “endorsed four nominees and disapproved the nomination of Justice Naimatullah Phulpoto”.
“Thereafter, Justice Sajjad Ali Shah and Justice Ijazul Ahsan fully endorsed all the judges nominated by the Hon’ble chairman (CJP) for their appointment as judges of the Supreme Court,” said Justice Masood. After their approvals, it was Justice Masood’s turn, during which he discussed the seniority principle and also recommended that Justice Athar Minallah of the Islamabad High Court be considered.
“I did not approve three nominated judges of the High Court of Sindh and one judge of the Lahore High Court and requested to defer the nomination of the judge of the Peshawar High Court. The Hon’ble law minister, learned attorney general of Pakistan and Hon’ble member of Pakistan Bar Council/member of the commission agreed with my recommendations and disapproved three nominee judges of the High Court of Sindh and one of the Lahore High Court,” said Justice Masood.
The judge then shared, that when Justice Qazi Faez Isa expressed his agreement with him and was in the middle of giving his reasons for disapproval, it became clear that five members of the commission disapproved of the names of four nominees judges. Staff Report
Minute Mirror is providing news, investigative reports, articles and blogs at a faster speed, through its print and digital editions. Mr Ali Sajjad founded Minute Mirror as an independent newspaper with the belief that journalism must be fact-based, and readers needed efficient and reliable coverage of topics shaping the fast-changing world around us.
Sign up to be the first to hear about latest news & updates!
© Minutemirror | minutemirror.com.pk is a registered trademark. All rights reserved. Created by Clicktraces