Fall Review: A Proudly Dumb and Panic Attack-Inducing Roller-Coaster Ride
Thirteen Lives Review: A Redundant Dramatization of an Incredible Rescue
Interview: Patton Oswalt on I Love My Dad and Cinema As Memory
El Gran Movimiento Review: An Exhilarating and Revelatory City Symphony
Emily the Criminal Review: A Volcanic Aubrey Plaza Anchors a Routine Crime Drama
Calvin Harris Funk Wav Bounces Vol. 2 Review: A Colorful but Nebulous Playlist
Madonna’s “Vogue”: Through the Years
Panda Bear & Sonic Boom Reset Review: A Misguided Gesture Toward the Past
Beyoncé Renaissance Review: A Disco-Trap Journey Where Past and Future Collide
King Princess Hold On Baby Review: Pre-Programmed Pop-Rock Transcendence
Cult of the Lamb Review: A Misbegotten Roguelike with Shades of Animal Crossing
South of the Circle Review: An Interactive Love Story with an Emotional Wallop
Stray Review: A Frivolous Cat Simulator Where the Cat Is Almost Beside the Point
Mothmen 1966 Review: A Pixel Pulp Novel That Packs a Punch, but Not a Knockout One
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge Review: A Cowabunga Beat ‘Em Up
Interview: Christina Ricci on Wednesday, Yellowjackets, and Coming Full Circle
The 12 Best True-Crime Docuseries on Netflix
Paper Girls Review: A Period Time Travel Yarn That Feels Lost in Time
Surface Review: A Psychological Thriller About Identity That Struggles to Find Itself
Uncoupled Review: A Gay Dramedy That Feels Too Betwixt and Between
Interview: Christina Ricci on Wednesday, Yellowjackets, and Coming Full Circle
Interview: Patton Oswalt on I Love My Dad and Cinema As Memory
Madonna’s “Vogue”: Through the Years
The 12 Best True-Crime Docuseries on Netflix
Interview: Clio Barnard on the Workshopping Process That Brought Ali & Ava to Life
Pink’s “Irrelevant” Takes on Twitter Trolls, Hypocrites, and Women’s Rights
With “Break My Soul,” Beyoncé Attempts a House Renaissance
Lady Gaga’s “Hold My Hand,” from Top Gun: Maverick, Struggles to Take Flight
Cannes 2022 Lineup: James Gray, Claire Denis, and More Compete for Palme d’Or
Marcel the Shell with Shoes On Trailer: A Shell Game on the Big Screen
4K UHD Review: Michael Mann’s Heat Gets Ultimate Collector’s Edition
Review: Frank Borzage’s Little Man, What Now? on Kino Lorber Blu-ray
Review: Gordon Parks’s Blaxploitation Classic Shaft on Criterion 4K UHD
Review: Anthony Mann’s Raw Deal on ClassicFlix Special Edition Blu-ray
Blu-ray Review: George Armitage’s Miami Blues on the MVD Rewind Collection
Summer of Discontent: Shakespeare in the Park’s Richard III and the Armory’s Hamlet
2022 Tony Awards: Predicting the Likely Winners, from A Strange Loop to Six
Interview: Paula Vogel on Revisiting Her Pulitzer-Winning How I Learned to Drive
Review: All Wishes Granted at New York City Center’s Revival of Into the Woods
A Strange Loop Review: A Big, Black, and Queer-Ass Revitalization of the Musical
Review: K-Ming Chang’s Gods of Want Is Driven by New and Strange Hungers
Review: Jon Lewis’s Road Trip to Nowhere: Hollywood Encounters the Counterculture
Review: Fred Goodman’s Rock on Film: The Movies That Rocked the Big Screen
Notes on Hong Sang-soo, Philosopher and Piss-Taker: Dennis Lim’s Tale of Cinema
Interview: Don Winslow on City on Fire and Channeling Greek Tragedy
Madonna’s “Vogue”: Through the Years
The 12 Best True-Crime Docuseries on Netflix
The 25 Best Original Series on Netflix Right Now
All 29 Marvel Cinematic Universe Movies Ranked, from Worst to Best
The Best TV Shows of 2022 … So Far
The film never seems to fully buy into its horror trappings and ends up treating its characters as avatars for multiple grievances.
By
on
Writer-director Mariama Diallo’s Master is a supernatural horror film that’s also a compendium of observations on racist institutional norms in higher ed. It certainly scores some points on the soft targets of liberal academia, but it never manages to turn its often trenchant social critique into a compelling, or even coherent, narrative.
Set at the fictional Ancaster College, a New England liberal arts school that’s so exclusive that even Franklin D. Roosevelt reputedly couldn’t get in, the film juxtaposes the stories of two Black women at opposite ends of their academic careers. Jasmine Moore (Zoe Renee) is a naïve freshman assigned to a dorm room that campus lore holds to be haunted by the ghost of Margaret Millett, an alleged witch burned at the stake centuries ago. Meanwhile, Gail Bishop (Regina Hall), a well-respected professor who’s just been named as the college’s first Black master, is struggling to maintain her sense of identity while assisting a university rooted in racist exclusion to burnish its image as an inclusive place of learning.
In their own ways, these two women are forced to decide whether the price of gaining access to traditionally white corridors of power is even worth the trouble. Master ponders whether it’s possible for Black women to convince the gatekeepers of a racist institution to let them in without losing a piece of themselves. It’s a valid and inherently dramatic question, one that’s intimately connected to the specifics of the individual characters, but the film continually buries it under a pile of arbitrary scares, easy satire, and plot threads that lead nowhere.
Diallo attempts to shoehorn social commentary on so many hot-button campus issues—from sexual assault to Rachel Dolezal-style hucksterism to faux-woke diversity PR—that she leaves for herself little time to develop Jasmine and Gail as people. The film defines them largely in contradistinction to one of the few other Black faculty members at Ancaster: Liv Beckman (Amber Gray), a light-skinned English professor who gives Jasmine an F for failing to embrace a critical race reading of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter while buttering up Gail to convince a nearly all-white panel to grant her tenure. Gail and Jasmine, Master suggests, are dogged, hard workers, while Liv wields race cynically and opportunistically.
Beyond their relative work ethics, though, Jasmine and Gail largely remain ciphers. There are moments when Diallo’s film seems as if it’s going to deepen these characters, as in a scene in which Jasmine drafts an email to her parents lying that everything at school is just peachy. But these strands are oddly dropped almost as soon as they’re raised.
As her difficulties fitting in at Ancaster grow, Jasmine becomes increasingly haunted by nightmares of Margaret Millet’s ghost, which becomes a heavy-handed metaphor for the college’s racism as well as Jasmine’s propensity to run from her identity rather than embrace it. But Jasmine’s background, her motivation, and her desires are all far too vaguely drawn for this metaphorical demon to have much impact. It doesn’t help that Diallo’s handling of the film’s horror elements is a clunky mix of generic scares, conspicuous Shining-style slow zooms, and over-the-top lighting that inexplicably makes a normal dorm room hallway look like the boiler room from Wes Craven’s A Nightmare on Elm Street.
As a Black-made horror film with an eye toward a social critique of white liberalism, Master naturally invites comparison to Get Out. But if Jordan Peele’s film was able to get away with some relatively thin and caricatured characters, that’s thanks to the air-tight construction of its central metaphor, as well as its full-on commitment to the gonzo reality of its premise. By contrast, Master is a frustratingly diffuse work, one that never seems to fully buy into its own horror trappings and ends up treating its characters as mere avatars of Diallo’s grievances. However righteous the film’s targeting of injustice in white-dominated institutions like academia may be, it’s simply not enough, by itself, to sustain a work of fiction.
Cast: Regina Hall, Zoe Renee, Amber Gray, Talia Ryder, Talia Balsam, Ella Hunt, Noa Fisher, Kara Young, Bruce Altman, Jennifer Dundas, Joel de la Fuente, Molly Bernard Director: Mariama Diallo Screenwriter: Mariama Diallo Distributor: Amazon Studios Running Time: 91 min Rating: NR Year: 2022
Fresh Review: Mimi Cave’s Bloody Rom-Com Bites Off More Than It Can Chew
Brighton 4th Review: A Bittersweet Drama About the Imperative of Sacrifice
4K UHD Review: Josh and Benny Safdie’s Uncut Gems on the Criterion Collection
Review: Gina Prince-Bythewood’s Love & Basketball on Criterion Blu-ray
Review: The Underground Railroad Is an Unsparing Depiction of Collective Trauma
Enter to Win Blu-rays of Doctor Strange 2, Dona Flor and Her Two Husbands, & More
Our Preview Section Is Your Most Complete Guide for All the Films Coming Your Way Soon
Madonna’s “Vogue”: Through the Years
Prey Review: Dan Trachtenberg’s Predator Prequel Is Starved for Kineticism
4K UHD Review: Michael Mann’s Heat Gets Ultimate Collector’s Edition
Panda Bear & Sonic Boom Reset Review: A Misguided Gesture Toward the Past
Emily the Criminal Review: A Volcanic Aubrey Plaza Anchors a Routine Crime Drama
Interview: Patton Oswalt on I Love My Dad and Cinema As Memory
Review: Frank Borzage’s Little Man, What Now? on Kino Lorber Blu-ray
South of the Circle Review: An Interactive Love Story with an Emotional Wallop
Copyright © 2001 – 2022 Slant Magazine