The cast of Berkshire Theatre Group’s production of “Songs for a New World” includes Michael Worldly, front, and rear from left, Mia Munn, Nathe Rowbotham and Alexandria J Henderson. The show runs at the Unicorn Theatre in Stockbridge, Mass., through Aug, 20.
STOCKBRIDGE, Mass. — More than 25 years have gone by since Jason Robert Brown’s off-Broadway debut announced the arrival of a major new composing talent for musical theater with his “Songs for a New World,” a cycle of 18 songs that occupies the late-summer slot for Berkshire Theatre Group’s Unicorn Theatre in an engaging, well-sung production suffused with yearning and ambition.
Brown writes what have been called ideal audition songs, offering the performer the opportunity, over a few minutes, to tell a complete story, develop a character and show off vocal range. At least one from “Songs for a New World,” titled “Stars and the Moon,” has become a cabaret and concert standard for its folk-rock melody and reflections on the folly of youthful dreams of riches and fame.
But a collection of standalone songs with only the most tenuous of obvious thematic connections requires different expectations from an audience, namely that they won’t get a narrative and will have to ponder to discern why the songs are presented together and in this particular order. Brown has said the through-line of the show is characters being at a decision point, of “having to make a choice, or take a stand, or turn around and go back.”
On the stage at BTG’s small Unicorn Theatre, director/choreographer Gerry McIntyre, who choreographed the company’s 2020 production of “Godspell” that was the nation’s first Equity-approved production during the pandemic, moves his young cast of four well to maintain audience interest. Performers start the show from platforms high above either side of the stage, returning later for effect. Sometimes they’re behind upstage screens (the abstract set is by Randall Parsons); at others, they descend steps to come to stage level, where music director Dante Harrell, who also sings and conducts the two-person backstage band, is at the center at a piano; and sometimes they’ll sit on simple boxes. But, regardless, the action flows as the songs progress.
The cast, identified in the program only as “Company Member” and a number, sing solo, as duets and in ensemble numbers. Among the highlights are the group songs “The New World,” “The River Won’t Flow,” “Steam Train” and the show-closing “Hear My Song”; Mia Munn vamping it up as an exasperated Mrs. Claus in the Kurt Weill parody “Surabaya-Santa”; Alexandria J. Henderson’s exquisite rendition of “Christmas Lullaby,” in which a woman discovers she’s pregnant; and almost everything sung by Michael Wordly, who has a broad vocal range and perfectly control of his impressive falsetto. Rounding out the cast, Nathe Rowbotham sings well on “Stars and the Moon” and in ensemble numbers but at times struggles when notes fall between their chest voice and upper register.
The best way to think of “Sings for a New World” is as a theatrically staged concert full of good music that portends what Brown would go on to write. He’s also known for “Parade” (on Broaday in 1998-99) and the stage-musical version of “The Bridge of Madison County,” which started life at the Williamstown Theatre Festival in summer 2013, moving to Broadway the following year and winning Tony Awards for Brown for best original score and best orchestrations.
When “Songs for a New World” premiered, Brown himself was center stage at the piano, and he was all of 25 years old. The bold if sometimes ill-defined ambitions of a young artist must’ve been evident during the run, the desire to create, to fulfill, to achieve, well, something. In that way, it reminds me of a more nebulous version of “Tick, Tick … Boom!,” which Jonathan Larson wrote before creating “Rent.” In their own ways, they’re products as well as portraits of a young artist on the rise.
“Songs for a New World”
When: 2 p.m. Sunday
Where: Unicorn Theatre, Berkshire Theatre Group, 6 East St., Stockbridge, Mass.
Running time: 80 minutes with no intermission
Continues: 7 p.m. Tuesday through Saturday; matinees, 2 p.m. Wednesday, Saturday and Sunday; though Aug. 20
Tickets: $75
Info: 413-997-4444 and berkshiretheatregroup.org
Note: Masks required upon entering theater
Steve Barnes has worked at the Times Union since 1996, served as arts editor for six years, and since 2005 has been a senior writer. He generally covers restaurants, food and the arts, and is the Times Union’s restaurant columnist and theater critic. Steve was also a journalism instructor at the University at Albany for 12 years. You can reach him at [email protected] or 518-454-5489.